The effect of cup geometry in uncemented Total Hip Arthroplasty has not been investigated. We reviewed the radiological and clinical results of 527 primary total hip arthroplasties. We assessed the bone ingrowth potential of two geometric variations of an uncemented cup and compared hydroxyappetite and porous coated shells. Patients undergoing primary hip arthroplasty between 1997 and 2004 were prospectively entered into an arthroplasty database. Patients were reviewed at 1,2,4,5,8 and 10 years post surgery. Three acetabular shell types were used. These included hemispherical cups with porous or hydroxyapatite coating, and cups with peripheral expansion with porous coating. Radiographs with minimum 1-year follow-up were examined in 542 cases, using digital templating software. Radiographs were assessed for signs of bone in-growth, lucent lines, migration and polyethylene wear. Survivorship analysis was performed using Kaplan-Meier analysis with 95% confidence intervals. Radiological findings and cup type were analysed using Fishers exact test. Radiological evidence of bone ingrowth was seen in 82% of hemispherical cups, compared with 59% of peripherally expanded cups, which was significant (p,0.05). Bone ingrowth was not affected by the presence of HA coating. The most common diagnoses were osteoarthritis (67%) and avascular necrosis (12%). The mean age was 56 years. Survivorship with revision or impending revision for aseptic loosening was 95.6% at 7 years (95%CI 1.0134-0.8987). The 3 revisions and 1 impending revision for loosening were in patients with avascular necrosis (3) or previous acetabular and femoral osteotomies for DDH (1), with a mean age of 44 years. Hemispherical shells have improved radiographic outcome in comparison with peripherally expanded components. At 7 years, clinical results are similar for both components.
This study compared the accuracy of reduction of intra-medullary nailed femoral shaft fractures, comparing conventional and computer navigation techniques. Twenty femoral shaft fractures were created in human cadavers, with segmental defects ranging from 9–53mm in length. All fractures were fixed with antegrade 9mm diameter femoral nails on a radiolucent operating table. Five fractures (control) were fixed with conventional techniques. Fifteen fractures (study) were fixed with computer navigation, using fluoroscopic images of the normal femur to correct for length and rotation. The surgeon was blinded to defect size. Two landmark protocols were used in the study group referencing the piriform fossa (n=10) or proximal shaft axis (n=5). Postoperative CT scans, blindly reported by a musculoskeletal radiologist, were used to compare femoral length and rotation with the normal leg. Results were analysed using the Wilcoxon two-sample test. The mean leg length discrepancy in the study group was 3.8mm (range 1–9), compared with 9.8mm(range 0–17) in the control group (p=0.076). The mean torsional deformity in the study group was 7.7 degrees (range 20–2) compared with 9 degrees (range 0–22) in the control group (p=0.86). Within the navigated study group, length discrepancy was similar in subgroups A (3.6mm) and B (4.2mm). Torsion appeared more accurate in group B (5.6 degrees) than group A (8.7 degrees), although not significantly. Computer navigation appears to improve leg length discrepancy following femoral nailing. Technique modification during the study improved rotational accuracy, and with further improvement, will make this technique applicable to femoral fracture fixation.
In perfroming hip resurfacing arthroplasty, concern has been expressed as to the proximity of the femoral neurovascular bundle during the anterior capsulotomy and the risk of damage during this maneuver. We therefore aimed to identify the proximity of the femoral nerve, artery and vein during an anterior capsulotomy done during a hip resurfacing procedure using the posterior approach. A standard posterior approach was performed in 5 fresh frozen cadavic limbs. An anterior incision was then used to measure the distance of the femoral neurovascular structures to the anterior capsule. Measurements from the most posterior aspect of the vessels and nerves to the most anterior aspect of the anterior capsule were taken prior to hip dislocation. The femoral head was then dislocated, and measurements were made with the hip in both flexion and extension. In a separate group of eleven patients that underwent routine MR imaging of the hip, measurements were taken to assess the proximity of the anterior joint capsule to the femoral neurovascular bundle, by a specialist musculoskeletal radiologist who had no prior knowledge of the results obtained during the cadaveric dissection All 5 cadaveric limbs were utilised. 3 were male and 2 were female. The average age was 72.4 years (range 56–84). The patients whom underwent routine MR imaging incorporated 6 males and 5 females with a mean age of 43.7 years (age range 18–64 years). There was no significant difference between the mean distances to the nerve (p=0.21), artery (p=0.21) or vein (p=0.65) between the MR and cadaveric groups. Prior to dislocation the femoral artery and vein were closest to the anterior capsule (mean distance of 21mm) and the femoral nerve was the furthest away (mean distance 25mm). Following dislocation there was a significant increase (25mm to 31mm) in mean distance to the femoral nerve when the superior capsule was cut with the hip in a flexed position (p=0.01) and to the femoral artery in flexion (increase mean distance from 21mm to 35mm) (p<
0.0001) and in extension(increase mean distance from 21mm to 31mm) (p=0.005). When the inferior capsule was cut, there was a significant increase (25mm to 31mm) in mean distance to the femoral nerve and femoral artery when the hip was dislocated and the capsule cut with the hip in flexion (increase mean distance from 21mm to 27mm) (p=0.019) and in extension(increase mean distance from 21mm to 28mm) (p=0.015). This study suggests that the neurovascular structures are relatively well protected during an anterior capsulotomy performed during hip resurfacing. The procedure may be safer if the capsulotomy is performed with the hip dislocated and the hip in a flexed position while cutting the antero-superior aspect and in an extended position while cutting the antero-inferior aspect.
The purpose of this study was to develop a cell-based VEGF gene therapy in order to accelerate fracture healing and investigate the effect of VEGF on bone repair in vivo. Twenty-one rabbits were studied. A ten millimeter segmental bone defect was created after twelve millimeter periosteal excision in the middle one third of each tibia and each tibia was plated. Primary cultured rabbit fibroblasts were transfected by use of SuperFect (Qiagen Inc) with pcDNA-VEGF. 5.0 X 106 cells in 1ml PBS were delivered via impregnated gelfoam into the fracture site. Experimental groups were:
Transfected fibroblasts with VEGF (n=7), Fibroblasts alone (n=7), and PBS only (n=7). The animals were sacrificed and fracture healing specimens collected at ten weeks post surgery Radiology: Fracture healing was defined as those with bone bridging of the fracture defect. After ten weeks, fourteen tibial fractures were healed in total including six in group one, four in group two and four in group three. The VEGF group had an earlier initial sufficient volume of bridging new bone formation. Histological evaluation demonstrated ossification across the entire defect in response to the VEGF gene therapy, whereas the defects were predominantly fibrotic and sparsely ossified in groups two and three. Numerous positively stained (CD31) vessels were shown in the VEGF group. MicroCT evaluation showed complete bridging for the VEGF group, but incomplete healing for groups two and three. Micro-CT evaluation of the new bone structural parameters showed that the amount of new bone (volume of bone (VolB) x bone mineral density (BMD)), bone volume fractions (BVF), bone volume/tissues (BV/TV), trabecular thickness (Tb.Th), number (Tb.N) and connectivity density (Euler number) were higher; while structure model index (SMI), bone surface/bone volume (BS/BV), and trabecular separations (Tb.Sp) were lower in the VEGF group than the other groups. P-Values <
0.05 indicated statistical significance (ANOVA, SPSS) in all parameters except for SMI (0.089) and VolBx-BMD (0.197). These results indicate that cell-based VEGF gene delivery has significant osteogenic and angiogenic effects and demonstrates the ability of cell based VEGF gene therapy to enhance healing of a critical sized defect in a long bone in rabbits.
The purpose of this study was to assess the accuracy of clinical assessment compared to imageless computer navigation in determining the amount of fixed flexion during knee arthroplasty. In fourteen cadaver knees, a medial para-patella approach was performed and the navigation anatomy registration process performed. The knees were held in various degrees of flexion with two crossed pins. The degree of flexion was first recorded on the computer and then on lateral radiographs. The cadaver knees were draped as for a knee arthroplasty and nine examiners (three arthroplasty surgeons, three fellows, and three residents) were asked to clinically assess the amount of fixed flexion. Three examiners repeated the process one week later. The mean error from the radiograph in the navigation group was 2.18 degrees (95%CI 2.18+/−0.917) compared to 5.57 degrees (CI 5.57+/− 0.715) in the observer group. The navigation was more consistent with a range of error of only 5.5 degrees (standard deviation 1.59). The observers had a range of error of 18.5 degrees (S.D. = 4.06). When analysing the observers’ error with respect to flexion (+) and extension (−), they tended to under-estimate the amount of knee flexion (median error=−4) whereas the navigation was more evenly distributed (median error=0). The highest correlation was found between navigation and the radiograph r=0.96. The highest observer correlation with the radiograph was a consultant surgeon (r=0.91) and the worst was from a resident (r=0.74). The intra-class correlation coefficient was 0.88 for the three surgeons who repeated the measurements; their mean error was 3.5 degrees with a range of fifteen degrees. The use of computer navigation appears to be more accurate in assessing the degree of knee flexion, with a reduced range of error when compared to clinical assessment. It is therefore less likely to leave the patient with residual fixed flexion after knee arthroplasty.
The purpose of this study was to evaluate the effect of previous femoral osteotomy on the outcome of total hip replacement performed for degenerative arthritis secondary to developmental dysplasia of the hip. Eighty three primary total hip arthroplasties were performed in sixty-nine patients with osteoarthritis secondary to developmental hip dysplasia (DDH) with a minimum three year follow up. Twenty six hips had undergone previous femoral osteotomy (eleven hips, femoral osteotomy alone (FO); fifteen hips, combined femoral and pelvic osteotomy and fifty-seven hips, no previous surgery. The non operative patients with DDH served as an age and sex matched control group (control). Cementless arthroplasty was performed in seventy-eight hips. The mean duration from femoral osteotomy to primary THA was 22.9 years. The mean follow up was 7.6 years (FO) and 7.2 years (control). The overall revision rate was 15.4 % (FO) and 21.1 % in the Control group (p>
0.05). Twenty-one hips had one or more complications during or after surgery. The FO group had a higher femoral fracture rate (23.1%) compared to controls (10.5%) (p<
0.05). At latest mean follow-up (7.4 yrs (range, two to sixteen)), the mean Harris hip score was eighty-five (FO) and eighty-five (control group) (p>
0.05). The function and pain scores in the femoral osteotomy group were similar to the controls (p>
0.05). The requirement for bone grafting was similar and operative time significantly greater (FO) compared to controls. The frequency of radiolucent lines around the femoral component in the FO group (36%) was significantly higher than the control group (12.2%) (p<
0.05). Survival analysis was performed with the Kaplan-Meier method. At ten years, the survival of the acetabular component was 84.6%/73.6% and for the femoral component 92.2%/96% in the FO/control group. Patients with a prior femoral osteotomy have no significant difference in functional outcome, overall complication rate or revision rate compared to controls. However, there is a significant increase in femoral fracture and operative time. Previous femoral osteotomy does not compromise the functional outcome of subsequent total hip arthroplasty.
To assess the accuracy of plain digitised radiographic images for measurement of neck-shaft and stem-shaft angles in hip resurfacing arthroplasty. Fifteen patients having undergone hip resurfacing arthroplasty with the Birmingham Hip Resurfacing (BHR) were selected at random. Digital radiographs were analyzed by three observers. Each observer measured the femoral neck-shaft angles (NSA) of the pre-operative and stem-shaft angles (SSA) of the postoperative radiographs on two separate occasions spanning one week. The effect of femur position on SSA measured by digital radiographs was also analyzed. A BHR prosthesis was cemented into a third generation Sawbone composite femur. Radiographs were taken with the synthetic specimen positioned in varying angles of both flexion and external rotation in increments of 10° ranging from 0° to 90°. The mean intraobserver difference in measured angle was 3.13° (SD 2.37°, 95% CI +/−4.64°) for the NSA group and 1.49° (SD 2.28°, 95% CI +/−4.47°) for the SSA group. The intraclass correlation coefficient for the NSA group was 0.616 and for the SSA group was 0.855. Flexion of the synthetic femur of twenty degrees resulted in a five degree discrepancy in measured SSA and flexion of forty degrees resulted in a thirteen degree discrepancy. External rotation of the synthetic specimen of twenty and forty degrees resulted in a three and nine degree discrepancy in measured SSA, respectively. Patient malposition during radiographic imaging can contribute to erroneous NSA and SSA results. Significant intra- and inter-observer variation was noted in the measurement of neck shaft angle however, variation was less marked for measurement of stem shaft angle.
The purpose of this study was to evaluate functional outcome following supracondylar femur fractures using patient-based outcome measures. Patients having sustained supracondylar femur fractures between 1990 and 2004 were identified from the fracture databases of two level-one trauma centres. Three patient-based outcome measures, the Short Form-36 (SF-36) Version two, the Short Musculoskeletal Functional Scale (SMFA), and the Lower Extremity Functional Scale (LEFS) were used to evaluate functional outcome. Each patient’s medical record was also reviewed to obtain information regarding potential predictors of outcome, including age, gender, fracture type (AO classification), presence of comorbidities, smoking status, open vs. closed fracture, and occurrence of complications. Univariate and multivariate models were then used to identify significant predictors of outcome, as reflected in the SMFA bother and dysfunction scores. Sixty-one patients (thirty-five males and twenty-six females) with an average age (at time of injury) of 53 ± 18 years consented to participate. The average length of follow-up was 64 ± 34 months from the time of injury. Mean SF-36 V2 scores were lower than Canadian population norms indicating decreased function or greater pain, while mean SMFA scores were higher than published population norms indicating greater impairment and bother. The mean LEFS score was 40.78 ± 15.90 out of a maximum score of eighty. At the univariate level, the presence of complications was a significant predictor of both the SMFA bother (p=0.002) and dysfunction scores (p=0.015), while positive smoking status was a significant predictor of the bother score (p=0.002). Based on a multivariate linear regression model, the presence of complications (p=0.013) and positive smoking status (p=0.011) were both significant predictors of a higher SMFA bother score. In the multivariate model for SMFA dysfunction score, the presence of complications (p=0.014) and the presence of comorbidities (p=0.017) were significant predictors of a higher score. Comparing SF-36 and SMFA scores with published population norms, supracondylar femur fractures were associated with residual impact. Based on our analysis, smoking, the presence of medical comorbidities at the time of fracture, and the occurrence of complications following fracture repair were the main predictors of poorer patient outcomes following supracondylar femur fracture.
This study examines the biomechanical performance of five types of fixation techniques in a model of pathological fracture of the diaphyseal humerus. In forty synthetic humeri, a hemi cylindrical defect centered in the middle third of the diaphysis was created. A transverse fracture was created through the centre of each defect. The bones were randomly assigned to five groups. Group A was fixed with standard ten hole DCP plates centered over the defect with five screws inserted on either end. In group B, the screw holes were injected with bone cement and then the screws and plate were reapplied while the cement was still soft. The defect was also filled with cement. Group C was fixed by injecting the cement into the entire intramedullary canal. The fracture was then reduced and the screws and plate were applied once the cement had hardened. In group D, the specimens were fixed with locked antegrade IM nail with one proximal and one distal interlocking screw. Group E was same as D except that the defect was filled with cement. Each specimen was tested in external rotation to failure by fracture. There was no significant difference in torsional stiffness between groups B, C, and E (P>
0.16), whereas there were differences between all other groups using pairwise comparisons(p<
0.001). Groups B, C, and E were of highest stiffness followed by A and then D. Group C had the highest torque to failure, followed by groups A/B and then D/E. Total cumulative energy to failure for group C was statistically greater than each of B, D, and E (p<
0.005), but not different from A, though it approached significance (p=0.057). This study demonstrates that, in a model of a fracture through a hemicylindrical defect in the middiaphysis of the humerus, fixation with a broad ten-hole dynamic compression plate after filling the entire medullary canal with cement is associated with the highest torque to failure and energy to failure with torsional forces. This fixation technique may best accomplish the clinical goal of maximal initial stability.
We aimed to establish if radiological parameters, dual energy x-ray absorbtiometry (DEXA) and quantitative CT (qCT) could predict the risk of sustaining a femoral neck fracture following hip resurfacing. Twenty-one unilateral fresh frozen femurs were used. Each femur had a plain AP radiograph, DEXA scan and quantitative CT scan. Femurs were then prepared for a Birmingham Hip Resurfacing femoral component with the stem shaft angle equal to the native neck shaft angle. The femoral component was then cemented onto the prepared femoral head. No notching of the femoral neck occurred in any specimens. A repeat radiograph was performed to confirm the stem shaft angle. The femurs were then potted in a position of single leg stance and tested in the axial direction to failure using an Instron mechanical tester. The load to failure was then analysed with the radiological, DEXA and qCT parameters using multiple regression. The strongest correlation with the load to failure values was the total mineral content of the femoral neck at the head/neck junction using qCT r= 0.74 (p<
0.001). This improved to r=0.76 (p<
0.001) when neck width was included in the analysis. The total bone mineral density measurement from the DEXA scan showed a correlation with the load to failure of r=0.69 (p<
0.001). Radiological parameters only moderately correlated with the load to failure values; neck width (r=0.55), head diameter (r= 0.49) and femoral off-set (r=0.3). This study suggests that a patient’s risk of femoral neck fracture following hip resurfacing is most strongly correlated with total mineral content at the head/neck junction and bone mineral density. This biomechanical data suggests that the risk of post-operative femoral neck fracture may be most accurately identified with a pre-operative quantitative CT scan through the head/neck junction combined with the femoral neck width.
To investigate differences between the Reamer Irrigator Aspirator and the AO reamer on fat embolism outcome using a porcine model. All animal procedures were approved and performed in accordance with the Animal Care Committee at St. Michael’s hospital. Following anesthetic administration, the animals were stabilised for thirty minutes. One third of the pig’s blood volume was withdrawn to simulate hemorrhagic shock. Each animal was kept in a state of hypovolemia for an hour before transfusion and resuscitation. Once the animal was stabilised surgical exposure of the distal femur was completed. A 12 mm Reamer Irrigator Aspirator or AO reamer was used depending on which group the animal was assigned to. Blood work was obtained at: baseline, immediately after induction of hypovolemia, one hour post hypovolemia, post stabilization, one minute, five minutes, 1.5 hours and three hours after reaming. The results were analyzed for activation of the coagulation system, platelet and neutrophil activation, and cytokine elevation. ANOVA was the primary tool used to assess statistical significance. There was no statistical difference between the two reamers with respect to PT, APTT, and fibrinogen. There was a statistical difference in D-dimer at 1.5 and three hours post-reaming, with the RIA showing a lower value. Neither reamer demonstrated any systemic platelet nor neutrophil activation. TNF-alpha spiked immediately post-reaming with the RIA group returning to baseline values and the AO group remaining elevated. There is a spike in IL-1B post reaming in the AO group, however this was not seen in the RIA group. No statistical difference was detected between the two reamers. All markers for platelet and neutrophil activation and the coagulation cascade were measured at the systemic level. Although there is no statistical difference between the RIA and AO reamer, it is possible that activated cells were removed from the systemic circulation and sequestered as thrombi in the pulmonary microvasculature. This hypothesis may be supported by a drop in platelet count and an increase in D-dimer, with the AO reamer suggesting greater thrombi formation. The trends in IL-1B and TNF-alpha seem to suggest that the RIA abrogates the post-reaming proinflammatory state.
We aimed to identify whether patients in lower socioeconomic groups had worse function prior to total knee arthroplasty and to establish whether these patients had worse post-operative outcome following total knee arthroplasty. Data was obtained from the Kinemax outcome study, this was a prospective observational study of 974 patients undergoing primary total knee arthroplasty for osteoarthritis. The study was undertaken in thirteen centers, four in the United States, six in the United Kingdom, two in Australia and one in Canada. Pre-operative data was collected within six weeks of surgery and patients were followed for two years post-operatively. Pre-operative details of the patient’s demographics, socioeconomic status (education and income), height, weight and co-morbid conditions were obtained. The WOMAC and SF-36 scores were also obtained. Multivariate regression was utilised to analyse the association between socioeconomic status and the patient’s pre-operative scores and post-operative outcome. During the analysis, we were able to control for variables that have previously been shown to effect pre-operative scores and post-operative outcome. Patients with a lower income had a significantly worse pre-operative WOMAC pain (p=0.021) and function score (p=0.039) than those with higher incomes. However, income did not have a significant impact on outcome except for WOMAC Pain at 12-months (p=0.014). At all the other post-operative assessment times, there was no correlation between income and WOMAC Pain and WOMAC Function. Level of education did not correlate with pre-operative scores or with outcome at any time during follow-up. This study demonstrates that across all four countries, patients with lower incomes appear to have a greater need for total knee arthroplasty. However, level of income and educational status did not appear to effect the final outcome following total knee arthroplasty. Patients with lower incomes appear able to compensate for their worse pre-operative score and obtain similar outcomes post-operatively.
Alignment of the femoral component during hip resurfacing has been implicated in the early failure of this device. Techniques to facilitate a more accurate placement of the femoral component may help prevent these early failures. We aim to establish whether the use of imageless computer navigation can improve the accuracy in alignment of the femoral component during hip resurfacing. 6 pairs of cadaveric limbs were randomized to the use of computer navigation or standard instrumentation. All hips had radiographs taken prior to the procedure to facilitate accurate templating. All femoral components were planned to be implanted with a stem shaft angle of 135 degrees. The initial guide wire was placed using either the standard jig with a pin placed in the lateral cortex or with the use of an imageless computer navigation system. The femoral head was then prepared in the same fashion for both groups. Following the procedure radiographs were taken to assess the alignment of the femoral component. The mean stem shaft angle in the computer navigation group was 133.3 degrees compared to 127.7 degrees in the standard instrumentation group (p=0.03). The standard instrumentation group had a range of error of 15 degrees with a standard deviation of 4.2 degrees. The computer navigated group had a range of error of only 8 degrees with a standard deviation of 2.9 degrees. Our results demonstrated that the use of standard alignment instrumentation consistently placed the femoral component in a more varus position when compared to the computer navigation group. The computer navigation was also more consistent in its placement of the femoral component when compared to standard instrumentation. We suggest that imageless computer navigation appears to improve the accuracy of alignment of the femoral component during hip resurfacing.
Ten out of 32 hips required revision; 9 acetabular components were revised because of aseptic loosening (3), osteolysis/excessive wear (4), instability (1) and infection (1) with a total revision rate of 28%. Eight patients needed acetabular revision alone, one femoral revision alone and one revision of both components. There was no significant difference in bone grafting, heterotopic bone formation, revision rate, operative time and blood loss between the two groups (p>
0.05).
We aimed to establish if radiological parameters, dual energy x-ray absorbtiometry (DEXA) and quantitative CT (qCT) could predict the risk of sustaining a femoral neck fracture following hip resurfacing. 21 unilateral fresh frozen femurs were used. Each femur had a plain AP radiograph, DEXA scan and quantitative CT scan. Femurs were then prepared for a Birmingham Hip Resurfacing femoral component with the stem shaft angle equal to the native neck shaft angle. The femoral component was then cemented onto the prepared femoral head. No notching of the femoral neck occurred in any specimens. A repeat radiograph was performed to confirm the stem shaft angle. The femurs were then potted in a position of single leg stance and tested in the axial direction to failure using an Instron mechanical tester. The load to failure was then analysed with the radiological, DEXA and qCT parameters using multiple regression. The strongest correlation with the load to failure values was the total mineral content of the femoral neck at the head/neck junction using qCT r= 0.74 (p<
0.001). This improved to r=0.76 (p<
0.001) when neck width was included in the analysis. The total bone mineral density measurement from the DEXA scan showed a correlation with the load to failure of r=0.69 (p<
0.001). Radiological parameters only moderately correlated with the load to failure values; neck width (r=0.55), head diameter (r= 0.49) and femoral off-set (r=0.3). This study suggests that a patient’s risk of femoral neck fracture following hip resurfacing is most strongly correlated with total mineral content at the head/neck junction and bone mineral density. This biomechanical data suggests that the risk of post-operative femoral neck fracture may be most accurately identified with a pre-operative quantitative CT scan through the head/neck junction combined with the femoral neck width.
A three dimensional femoral finite element model was constructed and molded with a femoral component constructed from the dimensions of a Birmingham Hip Resurfacing. The model was created with a superior femoral neck notch of increasing depths.
This study was undertaken to assess the contribution of pulmonary fat embolism to systemic platelet activation in a rabbit model of fat embolism. Fifteen NZW rabbits were randomly assigned into one of two groups: fat embolism and control. Fat embolism was induced via intramedullary canal pressurization with a 1–1.5 ml bone cement injection. Only the animals that underwent fat embolism displayed consistent platelet activation, as demonstrated by platelet degranulation and procoagulatory surface expression. These findings suggest that fat embolism plays a role in platelet activation and in the overall activation of hemostasis following trauma. The objective of this study was to use a recently developed rabbit model of fat embolism to assess the systemic hemostatic response to pulmonary fat embolism. Our findings demonstrate platelet activation following forced liberation of bone marrow contents into the circulation only in the FE group, as demonstrated by CD62P elevation (a marker of platelet degranulation) and annexin V elevation (a marker of procoagulatory surface expression). Platelet activation also coincided with significantly lower platelet counts in the FE group at two and four hours post embolism, suggesting platelet aggregation. These findings suggest that fat embolism plays a role in platelet activation and in the overall activation of hemostasis following trauma. Platelet count decreased significantly at two and four hours post knee manipulation only in the FE group. Annexin V expression increased significantly in the FE group at two and four hours post knee manipulation. Lastly, CD62P expression only increased significantly in the FE group at two hours post knee manipulation Fifteen New Zealand White male rabbits were randomly assigned into one of two groups: control and fat embolism (FE). In FE group (n=8), the intramedullary cavity was drilled, reamed and pressurized with a 1–1.5 ml bone cement injection. In the control group (n=7), a sham knee incision was made, exposing both femoral condyles, but was immediately closed without further manipulations. All animals were mechanically ventilated for an additional monitoring period of four hours post-surgical closure. For flow cytometric evaluation of platelet activation, blood samples were stained with fluorescence-conjugated antibodies against CD41 (FITC), CD62P (P-selectin) and annexin V (FITC). Platelet events were identified by their characteristic CD41 staining and size and were analyzed using a flow cytometer. All animals were mechanically ventilated for four hours post surgical closure. The implications of platelet activation following fat embolism are numerous, ranging from adherence and aggregation, to secretion of key components of both the coagulation and inflammatory cascades.
Bone transport/limb lengthening with circular external fixation has been associated with a prolonged period of time in the frame and a significant major complication rate following frame removal. We examined the results of bone transport in fifty-one limbs using the “monorail” technique and found a dramatically improved lengthening index (24.5 days/cm. – time in frame /cm. of length gained) and an absence of refracture or angulatory deformity following fixator removal. This technique is our treatment of choice for limb lengthening/bone transport. We sought to determine patient oriented outcome and complication rates following b one transport using an external fixator placed over an intramedullary nail (the “monorail” technique). Bone transport using the monorail technique is associated with a dramatically improved lengthening index and a lower major complication rate than traditional ring fixator methods. Patient satisfaction with the procedure was high. Our study confirms the significant advantages of the monorail technique for bone transport/limb lengthening. The time in the fixator is dramatically reduced, and complications associated with earlier techniques such as angulatory deformity or refracture were not seen. We identified forty-nine patients (fifty-one limbs) who had undergone bone transport using the monorail technique (external fixator placed over an intramedullary nail). There were thirty-five men and fourteen women with a mean age of thirty-five years (range 17–50). Pre-operative diagnoses included post traumatic length discrepancy/bone defect (forty-one), congenital short stature (six) and other (four). All patients had a unilateral fixator placed over an implanted intramedullary nail. Once length correction was achieved, the fixator was removed and the nail “locked”. The mean amount of lengthening was 5.5 cm. (range 2 – 18 cm.). The lengthening index was 24.5 days /cm. (duration of external fixation/cm. bone length gained), with a range from ten to fifty days /cm. There were nineteen complications (thirty-seven percent): nine premature consolidations, four infected pin sites, two hardware failures, two osteomyelitis, one DVT, one nonunion. There were no refractures, angulatory deformities or cases of intramedullary sepsis.
Clinicians ask patients “How are you now?” to ascertain treatment outcomes and to set a plan for subsequent care. However, sometimes patient views do not agree with those of the clinicians. This study compared patient and clinician views of outcome one to two years after an operatively managed extremity fracture and described any discordance. There were significant differences between groups, especially in areas such as pain and disruption of their personal and work lives. A discordance was observed between patient and physician views of recovery after fracture, likely associated with disruptions to personal life, unaccounted for in a clinician’s view of outcome. Clinicians ask patients “How are you now?” to ascertain treatment outcomes and to set a plan for subsequent care. However, sometimes patient views differ from those of clinicians’. The purpose of this study is to compare patient and clinician views of outcome one to two years after an extremity fracture and to describe any discordance. Cross-sectional survey of patients one to two years after an operatively managed upper or lower extremity fracture. Patients were recruited from two tertiary care centres and completed a mailback questionnaire that included measures of health (DASH, SMFA), self-rated recovery, burden of illness (Illness Intrusiveness, Loss of self), symptoms, and work status. These were linked with clinical records of radiologic and clinical recovery. Two hundred and fifty-five patients returned usable questionnaires. Mean age was forty-two years and 42% were female. Sixty-seven patients said that they were completely better (CB), one hundred and thirty-four almost better (AB) and fifty-four not completely better (NCB). Significant differences were found between groups. In four variables, NCB was distinct from AB/CB, while in all other variables, such as pain, disability and disruption of their personal and work lives, all three groups were unique (Duncan’s post hoc). However, of the patients who said they were not better, the radiologist and clinician reports stated that thirty (68%) and twenty-eight (64%) were healed, respectively. A discordance was observed between patient and physician views of recovery after fracture. It appeared associated with disruptions to personal life that may not be accounted for in a clinician’s view of outcome.
When deciding on treatment for displaced mid-shaft clavicle fractures, patients often inquire if repair of (potential) nonunion results in outcome similar to acute fixation. We used objective muscle strength testing and patient-oriented outcome measures to examine this question. Late reconstruction of nonunion following displaced mid-shaft fractures of the clavicle results in restoration of objective muscle strength similar to that seen with immediate fixation. However, there was a significant loss in muscle endurance as well as a trend towards a decrease in outcome scores (DASH, Constant) following late reconstruction. This information is useful in surgical decision making and in counseling patients. Using objectively measured strength and patient-oriented health-status instruments, we sought to determine if delay in repair of displaced, mid-shaft clavicle fractures negatively affected shoulder strength or outcome. Late reconstruction of clavicle nonunion results in restoration of objective muscle strength similar to that seen with immediate fracture fixation, but there was a significant loss in muscle endurance as well as a trend towards a decrease in outcome scores (DASH, Constant). All patients had sustained completely displaced, closed, isolated mid-shaft clavicle fractures. Fifteen patients had immediate plate fixation (mean 0.6 months post-fracture) and fifteen had plate fixation for non-union (mean fifty-eight months post-fracture). Objective muscle strength testing on the BTE was done a mean of twenty-nine months post-fixation (normal contralateral limb as control). There were no significant differences between acute fixation and delayed reconstruction groups with regards to strength of shoulder flexion (acute = 92.4%, delayed = 89.4%, p=0.56), shoulder abduction (acute = 98.8%, delayed = 96.7, p=0.75), external rotation (acute = 98.4%, delayed = 91.9%, p=0.29), or internal rotation (acute = 96.3%, delayed = 97.4%, p=0.87). However, there was a trend for improved Constant scores (acute = 94.5, delayed = 90, p=0.09) and the DASH scores (acute = 3.4, delayed = 9.0, p=0.09) in the acute fixation group. We found a significant decrease in muscle endurance with regards to shoulder flexion (acute = 107.0%, delayed = 71.1%, p=0.007) and a trend towards weaker shoulder abduction (acute = 103.1%, delayed = 88.7 %). Funding: Mr. Potter was supported by a St. Michael’s Hospital Summer Student Scholarship
The purpose of this study was to determine the effect of positioning (lateral vs. supine) on pulmonary patho-physiology following pulmonary contusion and fat embolism in a canine model of polytrauma. Platelet and neutrophil activation were assessed using flow-cytometry. There were no significant differences between groups in CD62P and CD11/18 MCF (markers of platelet and neutrophil activation, respectively) following fat embolism. However, only animals in the lateral position displayed significant increases in both measures as compared to baseline values. Lateral positioning may exert an early effect on proinflammatory and coagulation activation, and may play a role in the development of acute lung injury. It has previously been suggested that acute lung injury can be influenced by patient positioning, be it lateral or supine. The purpose of this study was to determine the effect of positioning on pulmonary pathophysiology associated with concomitant pulmonary contusion and fat embolism in a canine model of polytrauma. Twelve dogs were randomly assigned to one of two surgical positioning groups, lateral and supine. The dogs were subjected to pulmonary contusion by application of force between 200–250 N/m2 for thirty seconds in three areas of one lung. Two hours later, fat embolism was induced via reaming of the ipsilateral femur and tibia and cemented nailing. Two hours later, the dogs were sacrificed. For flow-cytometric evaluation of platelet and neutrophil activation, venous blood samples were stained with fluorescence-conjugated antibodies against CD62P and CD11/18, respectively. There were no significant differences between the groups in CD62P and CD11/18 mean channel fluorescence (MCF) following pulmonary contusion and fat embolism. However, only animals in the lateral positioning group displayed significant increases in CD62P and CD11/18 MCF at two hours following fat embolism as compared to baseline values. Our findings suggest that lateral positioning, autoregulation and preferential blood flow to the contused non-dependent lung may render lung tissue more susceptible to congestion and lead to activation of both platelets and neutrophils. Lateral positioning may have an early effect on activation of the inflammatory and coagulation cascades and may be significant in the development of posttraumatic acute lung injury.
In a meta-analysis of fourteen trials (N=1901 patients) in patients with displaced hip fractures, we identified significant reductions in the risk of revision surgery with internal fixation compared to arthroplasty. A trend towards increased mortality with arthroplasty was identified. The purpose of this study was to determine the effect of arthroplasty (hemi-arthroplasty, bipolar arthroplasty and total hip arthroplasty) in comparison to internal fixation for displaced femoral neck fractures on rates of mortality and revision surgery Arthroplasty for displaced femoral neck fractures, in comparison to internal fixation, significantly reduces the risk of revision surgery at the cost of greater infection rates, blood loss and operative time, and a possible increase in early mortality. Over 220,000 fractures of hip occur per year in North America representing an annual seven billion dollar cost to the health care system. Current evidence suggests internal fixation may reduce mortality risk at the consequence of increased revision rates. A large trial is needed to resolve this issue. We searched computerized databases (MEDLINE, COCHRANE and SCISEARCH) for published clinical studies from 1969–2002 and identified additional studies through hand searches of major orthopaedic journals, bibliographies of major orthopaedic texts and personal files. We found a non-significant trend toward an increase in the relative risk of dying with arthroplasty when compared to internal fixation (relative risk=1.27, 95% confidence interval, 0.84–1.92, p = 0.25; homogeneity p= 0.45). Arthroplasty appeared to increase the risk of dying when compared to pin and plate, but not in comparison to internal fixation using screws (relative risk= 1.75 vs 0.86, respectively, p<
0.05). Fourteen trials provided data on revision surgery (n=1901 patients). The relative risk of revision surgery with arthroplasty was 0.23 (95% confidence interval, 0.13–0.42, p = 0.0003, homogeneity p = <
0.01).
Using patient-oriented outcome measures, we examined twenty-six patients following surgical repair of clavicular nonunion. Patient satisfaction was high, and there was only a minor degree of residual disability (mean DASH score 14.5, SF-36 scores within normal range). Time from injury to surgical repair did not influence results. Using modern, patient-oriented limb-specific outcome measures, we sought to determine the effect of time to repair on patient satisfaction following surgical fixation of nonunion of the clavicular shaft. As measured by the DASH and SF-36, patient satisfaction was high following clavicular nonunion repair with only minor degrees of residual disability. Time to repair did not have a significant effect on outcome. Previous reports of clavicular nonunion repair have concentrated on radiographic or surgeon-based criteria. Our study shows that successful clavicular nonunion repair effectively restores upper extremity function and general health status to near-normal levels. We identified twenty-six patients who had undergone open reduction, internal fixation of a nonunion of the clavicular shaft. There were sixteen men and ten women, with a mean age of forty-four years (range thirty to seventy-one years). The mean duration of nonunion was 1.9 years with a range from four months to thirty-one years. All patients underwent fixation with a plate, and 73% of patients also underwent iliac crest bone grafting. Two nonunions required revision surgery for healing: twenty-four healed after the index procedure. We assessed patient outcome using standard history and physical, radiographs, and the DASH and SF-36 outcome instruments. The mean DASH score (0 = perfect, 100 = complete disability, “normal” = 10) was 14.5 (range 0 to 58), indicating good restoration of upper extremity function with mild residual disability. SF-36 scores were within the normal range. There was no significant difference in DASH or SF-36 scores between those fixed “early” (<
six months) and those repaired “late” (>
six months), p=0.30, p=0.78, respectively. Using patient-oriented outcome measures, we examined twenty-six patients following surgical repair of clavicular nonunion. Patient satisfaction was high, and there was only a minor degree of residual disability (mean DASH score 14.5, SF-36 scores within normal range). Time from injury to surgical repair did not influence results.
We report preliminary results from the first, multicenter prospective study designed to define the incidence of symptomatic (Venous Thromboembolism) VTE in patients with isolated leg fractures distal to the knee. Eight hundred and twenty-six enrolled patients have completed three months of follow up. By three months, only seven patients had sustained a symptomatic VTE with no fatal PE. Symptomatic and fatal VTE were infrequent complications after isolated leg fractures distal to the knee without thromboprophylaxis. Routine thromboprophylaxis may not be warranted in isolated leg fractures distal to the knee. To report results from the first, multicenter prospective study designed to define the incidence of symptomatic Venous Thromboembolism (VTE) in patients with isolated leg fractures distal to the knee. Symptomatic and fatal VTE are infrequent complications after isolated leg fractures distal to the knee without thromboprophylaxis. Routine thromboprophylaxis may not be warranted in isolated leg fractures distal to the knee. From August 2002 to April 2004, one thousand eight hundred and eight consecutive patients with isolated leg fractures distal to the knee were screened for entry at five hospitals in Ontario. Patients with major trauma, active cancer and previous VTE were excluded. Thromboprophylaxis was not allowed. Patients were followed prospectively for three months, with telephone calls at fourteen days, six weeks and three months. Suspected DVT and PE were investigated in a standardized manner. Eight hundred and twenty-six enrolled patients have completed three months of follow up. The mean age was forty-five years (range sixteen to ninety-three) and 59.5% of this cohort was female. 99% of these fractures were unilateral and 97% were closed. Fractures included: fibula (38%), metatarsal (29%), phalanges (13%), calcaneus, talus or tarsal (10%), tibia (10%) and patella (7%). Only 11% of fractures were surgically treated. 88% of fractures received a cast or splint for a mean duration of 41+/− 20 days. Complete follow-up was available for 97.5% of this cohort. By three months only seven patients had sustained a symptomatic VTE (2 proximal DVT, 3 calf DVT, 2 PE) with no fatal PE-an incidence of 0.9% (95% CI 0.3 to 1.8%). Funding: This study was funded by a research grant from Pharmacia
The purpose of this study was to evaluate trabecular bone response, at fifty-two week follow-up, to four different synthetic graft materials (CaSO4 and CaSO4 – HA/TCP composites) as compared to autograft in a canine defect model. The group with the highest HA/ TCP proportion had the greatest amount of residual graft material and total mineralized material. Increasing the proportion of HA/TCP reduces the rate of dissolution, and appears to have little effect on bone formation at long term follow-up. This study further suggests that a range of composites could be created to match the spectrum of resorption rates demanded by clinical applications. The purpose of this study was to evaluate trabecular bone response to four synthetic graft materials (CaSO4 and CaSO4 – HA/TCP composites) as compared to autograft in a canine defect model, at long term follow-up. Both 85% CaSO4 – 15% HA/TCP and 65% CaSO4 – 15% HA/TCP showed bone formation similar to autograft. The group with the highest proportion of HA/TCP lasted longer than the other formulations. The results suggest that increased HA/TCP proportions reduce the rates of dissolution, without compromising bone formation in the current model. Results suggests that a range of composites could be created to match the spectrum of resorption rates demanded by clinical applications. In this REB-approved RCT, bilateral humeral and femoral cylindrical defects were filled with one of four types of pellets with varying proportions of CaSO4 – HA/TCP, autograft bone, or left unfilled. After sacrifice at six, twelve, twenty-six or fifty-two weeks, defect sites were evaluated histologically for tissue and inflammatory response, area fractions of residual graft material, and bone ingrowth in the defects. The area of the defect occupied by residual graft material in the group with the highest percentage of HA/TCP was greater than in other composite groups (p<
0.0001). This group contained the greatest amount of total mineralized material (graft material + bone) (p<
0.03. The extent of new bone formation increased from twelve to twenty-six weeks (p<
0.0001). Both 85% CaSO4 – 15% HA/TCP and 65% CaSO4 – 15% HA/TCP showed bone formation similar to autograft.
We evaluated the clinical, radiographic, and functional outcome of uncemented total hip arthroplasty (THA) following vascularized fibular grafting for avascular necrosis (AVN) of the femoral head. A group of twenty-two patients who had been converted from a vascularized fibular graft to THA was compared to a similar group of twenty-two patients who had received a THA with no prior graft. The graft group was found to have worse outcomes than the control group as measured by SF-36, and WOMAC scores, as well as a hip score. These results show that vascularized fibular grafting complicates future THA. The Purpose of this study was to evaluate the clinical, radiographic, and functional outcome of uncemented total hip arthroplasty (THA) following vascularized fibular grafting for avascular necrosis (AVN) of the femoral head. These results indicate that functional and clinical outcome following post-graft THA is worse than outcome following THA performed as a primary intervention. Judicious use of the vascularized fibular graft procedure is critical in order to minimize the number of graft failures and avoid the negative outcomes associated with THA after failed vascularized fibular grafting. Twenty-six hips in twenty-two patients who had a THA following a failed vascularized fibular graft were compared to a group of twenty-three hips in twenty-two age and sex-matched patients who had received a THA with no prior graft (combined mean age: 39.0 yrs). Primary outcome measures included the SF-36 (patient-based general health assessment – total score and physical sub-component) and WOMAC (patient-based arthritis specific score) scores at matched follow up times (mean: 6.2years, range: two to fourteen years). An objective hip score was also used, as were several radiographic variables. The post-graft group had lower SF-36 final scores (p<
0.006), lower SF-36: physical function scores (p<
0.001), and lower WOMAC scores (p<
0.045) than the control group. Post-graft THA was complicated by longer operative time (p<
0.025) and greater subsidence of the femoral prosthesis (p<
0.004) compared to controls. Additionally, the post-graft group had worse hip score values (p<
0.05) than controls. Vascularized fibular grafting is a commonly used procedure to cure or delay progression of AVN in the hip. Currently this procedure is used for young (<
40 years) patients with hip AVN who are in an early, pre-collapse stage of the disease. Although the efficacy of vascularized fibular grafting has been proven, up to 29% of grafts fail at five years and need to be converted to THA (Urbaniak
5207 patients treated for a calcaneous fracture in Ontario between 1993–1999 were identified from population datasets and were reviewed to evaluate regional practice variation and complication rates for operatively and non-operatively managed calcaneous fractures. There was considerable geographic variation in treatment. Individuals in some parts of Ontario were almost eight times more likely to receive operative treatment than others. The majority of calcaneous fractures in Ontario are treated non-operatively, however the large observed practice variation suggests that there is disagreement among treating clinicians. Primary subtalar fusion has a high risk of post-operative infection and should therefore be considered very cautiously. The purpose of this study was to evaluate regional practice variation and complication rates for operatively and non-operatively managed calcaneous fractures. The majority of calcaneous fractures in Ontario are treated non-operatively, however the large observed practice variation suggests that there is disagreement among treating clinicians. Primary subtalar fusion has a high risk of post-operative infection and should therefore be considered very cautiously. Given the observed regional variation in management of calcaneous fractures more work needs to be done to address this issue. 5207 fractures of the calcaneous in Ontario between 1993–1999were identified from population datasets. Regional variations in treatment and complication rates were computed. Multiple linear regression was used to identify factors associated with complications. There was considerable geographic variation in treatment. Individuals in some parts of Ontario were almost eight times more likely to receive operative treatment than others. General surgeons or general practitioners definitively treated 30% of patients (almost all closed). Overall rate of complications was low, however there was a 13.4 percent infection rate following immediate subtalar fusion. Infection was 5.3% following ORIF and 0.6% following closed treatment. Infection risk was increased in multiple trauma patients and those with open fractures. Subsequent subtalar fusion rates (within the study period) were higher in multiple trauma patients, but were not associated with treatment (open or closed). Amputation was 22.5 times more likely following open calcaneous fractures but the overall amputation rate was only 0.17%. No relationship between surgeon experience and the rate of complications following operative treatment was identified.
Fifty-five patients undergoing isolated acetabular revisions in fifty-seven hips were available for review. In thirty-three of fifty-seven hips there was no significant acetabular deficiency; of the remaining twenty-four hips twenty underwent allograft reconstruction and four autogenous bone grafting. Mean follow-up was four years with a range of three to seven years; there have been no femoral loosening, and three further surgical procedures for hip instability. All acetabular components at last review were soundly fixed with the exception of one patient who underwent excision arthroplasty at twelve months for deep infection. The purpose of this study was to review the functional outcome and the fate of the femoral stem and revised acetabular component following isolated ace-tabular revision. Findings of the current study demonstrate that isolated acetabular revision does not compromise the final functional nor radiographic outcome in acetabular revision in appropriately selected patients; the fate of the femoral component is not adversely influenced by this procedure. There is no need to remove the femoral component at the time of acetabular revision if the femoral component is well fixed and stable by pre- and intra-operative assessment. Prospectively entered data on fifty-seven hips (fifty-five patients) who have undergone isolated acetabular revision without femoral revision was available for review. All patients were assessed pre-operatively and post-operatively on an annual basis by means of physical examination, x-ray, SF-36 and WOMAC questionnaires. In thirty-three of fifty-seven hips there was no significant acetabular deficiency; of the remaining twenty-four hips, one had a segmental defect, thirteen had a cavitary defect and ten had a combined segmental and cavitary defect. Osteolysis existed in the proximal femur of two hips. Bone grafting in twenty-four hips consisted of morselized allograft in nine; combined structural and morselized allograft used in eleven and autogenous bone used in four acetabular defects. Autogenous bone grafting was done in two femoral osteolytic lesions. Mean follow-up was four years with a range of three to seven years. The mean duration of arthroplasty prior to revision was fourteen years (range four to twenty-three years). There were no nerve palsies, vascular injuries or intra-operative fractures in this patient group. All ace-tabular components at latest review were soundly fixed with the exception of one patient who underwent excision arthroplasty at twelve months for deep infection. Twenty-one of the twenty-four hips with bone grafting demonstrated positive radiographic signs of incorporation; the remaining threehips have a stable interface but no evidence of bone ingrowth. Three of the fifty-seven hips presented with hip dislocations after revision arthroplasty; two were managed by closed reduction; the third by open reduction and soft tissue repair.
Little is known about the psychological morbidity associated with orthopaedic trauma. Our study aimed to determine the extent of psychological symptoms and whether patient psychological symptoms were predictive of outcomes following orthopaedic trauma. Overall, trauma patients experienced higher intensity of psychological symptoms than population norms. Psychological symptoms, patient age, and ongoing litigation predicted functional outcomes. Patients may benefit from early interventions by social workers and psychologists to process their psychological states post injury. Little is known about the psychological morbidity associated with orthopaedic trauma. Our study aimed to determine the extent of psychological symptoms and whether patient psychological symptoms were predictive of outcomes following orthopaedic trauma. All patients attending ten orthopaedic fracture clinics at three University-affiliated Hospitals were approached for study eligibility. All consenting patients would be requested to complete a baseline assessment form, a 90-item symptom checklist-90R (SCL-90R), and the Short-Form–36. The SCL-90R constitutes nine dimensions (Somatization, Obsessive-compulsive, Interpersonal sensitivity, Depression, Anxiety, Hostility, Phobic anxiety, Paranoid ideation, Psychoticism) and three global indices (Global severity index, Positive symptom distress index, positive symptom total). We conducted regression analyses to determine predictors of quality of life among study patients. Of two hundred and fifteen patients, 59% were male at a mean age of 44.5 years. Over half of patients had lower extremity fractures. Trauma patients experienced greater psychological symptoms than population norms. Overall, trauma patients experienced higher intensity of psychological symptoms than population norms. Patient functional outcomes were predicted by patient age, ongoing litigation, and Positive Symptom Distress. This model predicted 21% of the variance in patient function. Patient somatization was an important psychological symptom resulting in increasing intensity of symptoms. Smoking, alcohol, open fracture, surgeons’ perception of technical outcome, level of education, and time since injury were not predictive in this model. Psychological symptoms, patient age, and ongoing litigation predicted functional outcomes. Patients may benefit from early interventions by social workers and psychologists to process their psychological states post injury. Funding: This study was funded in part by research grants from AO North America and Regional Medical Associates, McMaster University. Dr. Bhandari was funded, in part, by a 2004 Detweiler Fellowship, Royal Colleges of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada. Dr. Busse is funded by a Canadian Institutes of Health Research Fellowship Award.
This study investigated the effect presence, method, and timing of fixation of femoral shaft fractures have on the morbidity and mortality of patients with pulmonary contusion. In the multiply-injured patient with femoral shaft fractures, early (<
24 hours) fracture stabilization with closed, reamed, statically-locked intramedullary nailing has been shown to decrease morbidity and mortality. Controversy exists as to whether such treatment compromises the outcome in patients that have significant co-existing pulmonary injury. This study is the first to specifically investigate the sub-group of patients that have pulmonary contusion. A retrospective review of patients presenting to a Level One trauma center from 1990 to 2002 with pulmonary contusion identified three hundred and twenty-two cases. Patient characteristics of age, sex, GCS, ISS, AIS, presence of femoral shaft fracture, method and timing of treatment of femoral shaft fracture, and presence of other pulmonary injuries were recorded, as were the outcomes of pulmonary complications (acute lung injury (ALI), ARDS, fat embolism syndrome, pulmonary embolism, and pneumonia), days on ventilatory support, days in the intensive care unit and ward, and death. There were no significant differences in the patient characteristics between groups with and without femoral shaft fracture. Except for an increased likelihood of the femoral shaft fracture group having ALI (RR 1.11), there were no significant differences in outcomes between the femur fracture/non-femur fracture groups. As well, there were no significant differences in outcomes between the groups that had fracture fixation before or after twenty-four hours or had the fracture fixed with or without intramedullary nailing. The presence, method, and timing of treatment of femoral shaft fractures do not increase the morbidity or mortality of trauma patients that have pulmonary contusion.
The purpose of this study was to investigate patient-based functional outcome and objectively measure strength following plate fixation of fractures of both bones of the forearm. Twenty-five subjects were clinically and radiographically reviewed. Strength of elbow flexion, extension, supination, pronation, wrist flex-ion, extension and grip were significantly reduced in the injured arm. (p<
0.01, range 62%–84% of normal). Mean (+/− SE) DASH score was 19.5 +/− 4.0 and eighty-eight percent (22/25) scored good to excellent on the Gartland-Werley scale (mean 4.04 +/− 0.91). No statistical difference in mean maximal radial bow (MRB) or location of MRB between injured and non-injured arm was found. The purpose of this study was to investigate functional outcome and objectively measure strength following plate fixation of fractures of both bones of the forearm (BBOF). Anatomic reduction was associated with good to excellent functional outcome. However strength of the elbow, forearm, wrist and grip were significantly reduced in the injured arm. Despite good to excellent functional outcome following this injury, significant reduction in strength of the upper extremity should be expected, and thus is an area for potential improvement in post-operative care. Twenty-five subjects (M/F 19/6, mean age 47.6 (range 20–71)) treated with plate fixation for fractures of BBOF were clinically and radiographically reviewed. Mean duration of follow-up was 5.7 years (range 2–13.4 y). Post-operative protocol included short-term immobilization followed by active-assisted ROM and strengthening starting between four and six weeks. Isometric muscle strength was objectively measured with the Baltimore Therapeutic Equipment work simulator (model WS-20). Strength of elbow flexion (72% of non-injured arm, p<
0.0001), elbow extension (84%, p=0.0004), forearm supination (75%, p=0.005), forearm pronation (69%, p<
0.0001), wrist flexion (81%, p=0.009), wrist extension (62%, p<
0.0001) and grip (70%, p<
0.0001) were all significantly reduced in the injured arm. Mean (+/− SE) DASH and Gartland-Werley scores were 19.5 +/− 4.0 (range 0–61) and 4.04 +/− 0.91 (range 0–15) respectively. Eighty-eight percent (22/25) scored good to excellent on the Gartland-Werley scale. No statistical difference in mean maximal radial bow (MRB) between injured and non-injured arm was found (mean +/− SE, 1.42 +/− 0.07 vs 1.58 +/− 0.05 respectively) or in location of MRB (61% vs 59%).
This study was undertaken to assess the contribution of fat embolism (FE) to the development of acute lung injury in the presence of resuscitated hemorrhagic shock. Twenty-seven NZW rabbits were randomly assigned into four groups: resuscitated hemorrhagic shock and FE (HR/FE), resuscitated hemorrhagic shock, FE, and control. FE was induced via intramedullary femoral canal pressurization using a 1–1.5 ml bone cement injection. Only HR/FE animals displayed significant proinflammatory cytokine release as compared to controls. These findings suggest that the combination of resuscitated shock with FE initiates an inflammatory response, which may lead to the development of fat embolism syndrome. The objective of this study was to assess the contribution of fat embolism caused by intramedullary femoral canal pressurization to the development of acute lung injury in the presence of resuscitated hemorrhagic shock. Only the animals that underwent resuscitated shock and fat embolism displayed amplified BALF proinflammatory cytokine expression. These findings suggest that the combination of resuscitated shock with fat embolism initiates an inflammatory response, which may play a role in the development of fat embolism syndrome. Only HR/FE BALF IL-8 and MCP-1 levels were significantly higher than controls (0.72 ng/ml vs. 0.26ng/ ml, p=0.03; 18.3 ng/ml vs. 2.0 ng/ml, p=0.01, respectively). Twenty-seven NZW rabbits were randomly assigned into four groups: resuscitated hemorrhagic shock + fat embolism (HR/FE), resuscitated hemorrhagic shock (HR), fat embolism (FE), and control. Shock was induced via carotid bleeding for one-hour prior to resuscitation. For FE induction, the intramedullary cavity was drilled, reamed and pressurized with a 1–1.5 ml bone cement injection. Four hours later, postmortem bronchoalveolar lavage was performed through the right mainstem bronchus. Analyses of bronchoalveolar lavage fluid (BALF) of interleukin-8 (IL-8) and monocyte chemoattractant protein-1 (MCP-1) were carried out in triplicate and blinded fashion using the ELISA technique. Our findings suggest that FE by itself does not initiate inflammatory lung injury, as there were no apparent differences between the control and FE cytokine levels. Only the HR/FE animals revealed elevated levels of pro-inflammatory cytokines in BALF. These findings are in agreement with our previous results, which displayed neutrophil activation only in the HR/FE group.
The purpose of this study was to determine the effect of positioning (lateral vs. supine) on pulmonary pathophysiology following pulmonary contusion and fat embolism in a canine model of polytrauma. Platelet and neutrophil activation were assessed using flow-cytometry. There were no significant differences between groups in CD62P and CD11/18 MCF (markers of platelet and neutrophil activation, respectively) following fat embolism. However, only animals in the lateral position displayed significant increases in both measures as compared to baseline values. Lateral positioning may exert an early effect on proinflammatory and coagulation activation, and may play a role in the development of acute lung injury. It has previously been suggested that acute lung injury can be influenced by patient positioning, be it lateral or supine. The purpose of this study was to determine the effect of positioning on pulmonary pathophysiology associated with concomitant pulmonary contusion and fat embolism in a canine model of polytrauma. Twelve dogs were randomly assigned to one of two surgical positioning groups, lateral and supine. The dogs were subjected to pulmonary contusion by application of force between 200–250 N/m2 for thirty seconds in three areas of one lung. Two hours later, fat embolism was induced via reaming of the ipsilateral femur and tibia and cemented nailing. Two hours later, the dogs were sacrificed. For flow-cytometric evaluation of platelet and neutrophil activation, venous blood samples were stained with fluorescence-conjugated antibodies against CD62P and CD11/18, respectively. There were no significant differences between the groups in CD62P and CD11/18 mean channel fluorescence (MCF) following pulmonary contusion and fat embolism. However, only animals in the lateral positioning group displayed significant increases in CD62P and CD11/18 MCF at two hours following fat embolism as compared to baseline values. Our findings suggest that lateral positioning, autoregulation and preferential blood flow to the contused non-dependent lung may render lung tissue more susceptible to congestion and lead to activation of both platelets and neutrophils. Lateral positioning may have an early effect on activation of the inflammatory and coagulation cascades and may be significant in the development of posttraumatic acute lung injury.
Fracture of the femoral head usually results from high-energy trauma, particularly motor vehicle accidents. These fractures are often associated with poor functional outcomes. SF-36 and MFA scores were obtained for twenty-five femoral head fractures. The mean SF-36 scores was 57.2 (22.6 to 82) and the mean MFA score was 37.6 (10–72). As expected the scores were negatively correlated (−0.587, p=0.005). The presence of an ipsilateral posterior acetabluar wall fracture negatively affected functional outcome. Fragment excision was associated with a higher functional outcome when compared to internal fixation. Posterior surgical approach resulted in higher scores than patients who underwent an anterior procedure. Fracture of the femoral head is a rare but severe injury. The purpose of this study is to determine the functional outcome of and prognostic factors associated with femoral head fractures. Acetabular wall fracture, surgical approach, and method of surgical treatment are prognostic factors of functional outcome as measured by the SF-36 and the MFA. There is currently no consensus on the management of femoral head fractures and treatment practices have evolved on the basis of a limited series of studies. Functional outcome following femoral head fracture has been evaluated using Epstein’s criteria in several studies, however, only one study has been conducted using a validated outcome measure. Twenty-five femoral head fractures in twenty-four patients were identified from the trauma and orthopaedic databases of two major trauma centres. The patient with bilateral femoral head fractures was not included in the analysis. After obtaining informed consent, the patients’ medical records were reviewed. Functional outcome was assessed using two validated, patient-based outcome measures, the Short Form (SF)-36 and the Musculoskeletal Functional Assessment instrument (MFA). The average age of the patients was 36.8 (std. dev. 11.1) and the mean length of follow-up was 41.4 months (minimum twelve months). Three factors were identified using non-parametric analysis that significantly affected the functional outcome scores:
The presence of an ipsilateral posterior acetabluar wall fracture negatively affected functional outcome (p=0.08). Fragment excision resulted in significantly higher scores when compared with the patients treated by internal fixation (p=0.067). A posterior surgical approach resulted in a better functional outcome than the anterior approach (p=0.013).
This study was undertaken to assess the contribution of pulmonary fat embolism caused by intramedullary femoral canal pressurization to the development of acute lung injury in the presence of resuscitated hemorrhagic shock. Twenty-seven NZW rabbits were randomly assigned into one of four groups: resuscitated hemorrhagic shock and fat embolism, resuscitated hemorrhagic shock, fat embolism, and control. Fat embolism was induced via intramedullary cavity with a 1–1.5 ml bone cement injection. Only the animals that underwent resuscitated shock and fat embolism displayed amplified neutrophil activation and alveolar infiltration. These findings suggest that the combination of resuscitated shock with fat embolism initiates an inflammatory response, which may play a role in the development of fat embolism syndrome. The objective of this study was to assess the contribution of pulmonary fat embolism caused by intramedullary femoral canal pressurization to the development of acute lung injury in the presence of resuscitated hemorrhagic shock. Only the animals that underwent resuscitated shock and fat embolism displayed amplified neutrophil activation and alveolar infiltration. These findings suggest that the combination of resuscitated shock with fat embolism initiates an inflammatory response, which may play a role in the development of fat embolism syndrome. CD11b mean channel florescence was only significantly elevated in the HR/FE group at two and four hours post knee manipulation. Moreover, greater infiltration of alveoli by leukocytes was only significantly higher in the HR/FE group as compared to controls. Twenty-seven NZW rabbits were randomly assigned into one of four groups: resuscitated hemorrhagic shock + fat embolism (HR/FE), resuscitated hemorrhagic shock (HR), fat embolism (FE), and control. Hypovolemic shock was induced via carotid bleeding for one-hour prior to resuscitation. For fat embolism induction, the intramedullary cavity was drilled, reamed and pressurized with a 1–1.5 ml bone cement injection. For evaluation of neutrophil activation, blood was stained with antibodies against CD45 and CD11b and analyzed with a flow cytometer. Animals were mechanically ventilated for four hours post surgical closure. Postmortem thoracotomy was performed, and three stratified random blocks of each lung were processed for histological examination. Our findings suggest that FE by itself does not cause lung injury, as there were no apparent differences between the control and FE animals. Only the HR/FE animals revealed a higher number of infiltrating neutrophils into alveolar spaces and greater neutrophil activation.
The purpose of this study was to evaluate trabecular bone response to four different synthetic graft materials (CaSO4 and CaSO4 – HA/TCP composites) as compared to autograft in a canine defect model. The group with the highest HA/TCP proportion (and the lowest CaSO4 proportion) had the greatest amount of residual graft material and total mineralized material (p<
0.05). Increasing the proportion of HA/TCP reduces the rate of dissolution, and appears to have little effect on bone formation. This study suggests that a range of composites could be created to match the spectrum of resorption rates demanded by clinical applications. Calcium sulfates and phosphates have become popular clinically for use as bone graft substitutes, however, their in-vivo performance has not been well characterized. The purpose of this study was to evaluate trabecular bone response to four synthetic graft materials (CaSO4 and CaSO4 – HA/TCP composites) as compared to autograft in a canine defect model. Both 100% CaSO4 and the 3 CaSO4– HA/TCP formulations showed good bone formation. The group with the highest proportion of HA/TCP lasted longer than the other formulations, suggesting increased HA/TCP proportions reduce the rates of dissolution, without compromising bone formation in the current model. Results suggests that a range of composites could be created to match the spectrum of resorption rates demanded by clinical applications. In this REB-approved RCT, bilateral humeral and femoral cylindrical defects were filled with one of four types of pellets with varying proportions of CaSO4 – HA/TCP, autograft bone, or left unfilled. After sacrifice at six or twelve weeks, defect sites were evaluated histologically for tissue and inflammatory response, area fractions of residual graft material, and bone ingrowth in the defects. The area of the defect occupied by residual graft material in the group with the highest percentage of HA/TCP was greater than in other composite groups (p<
0.0006). At twelve weeks, this group contained more total mineralized material (graft material + bone) (p<
0.005). The extent of new bone formation was not different among the composite groups at either time-point, but all showed more bone formation than the empty defect.