Abstract
We evaluated the clinical, radiographic, and functional outcome of uncemented total hip arthroplasty (THA) following vascularized fibular grafting for avascular necrosis (AVN) of the femoral head. A group of twenty-two patients who had been converted from a vascularized fibular graft to THA was compared to a similar group of twenty-two patients who had received a THA with no prior graft. The graft group was found to have worse outcomes than the control group as measured by SF-36, and WOMAC scores, as well as a hip score.
These results show that vascularized fibular grafting complicates future THA.
The Purpose of this study was to evaluate the clinical, radiographic, and functional outcome of uncemented total hip arthroplasty (THA) following vascularized fibular grafting for avascular necrosis (AVN) of the femoral head. These results indicate that functional and clinical outcome following post-graft THA is worse than outcome following THA performed as a primary intervention.
Judicious use of the vascularized fibular graft procedure is critical in order to minimize the number of graft failures and avoid the negative outcomes associated with THA after failed vascularized fibular grafting.
Twenty-six hips in twenty-two patients who had a THA following a failed vascularized fibular graft were compared to a group of twenty-three hips in twenty-two age and sex-matched patients who had received a THA with no prior graft (combined mean age: 39.0 yrs). Primary outcome measures included the SF-36 (patient-based general health assessment – total score and physical sub-component) and WOMAC (patient-based arthritis specific score) scores at matched follow up times (mean: 6.2years, range: two to fourteen years). An objective hip score was also used, as were several radiographic variables. The post-graft group had lower SF-36 final scores (p< 0.006), lower SF-36: physical function scores (p< 0.001), and lower WOMAC scores (p< 0.045) than the control group. Post-graft THA was complicated by longer operative time (p< 0.025) and greater subsidence of the femoral prosthesis (p< 0.004) compared to controls. Additionally, the post-graft group had worse hip score values (p< 0.05) than controls.
Vascularized fibular grafting is a commonly used procedure to cure or delay progression of AVN in the hip. Currently this procedure is used for young (< 40 years) patients with hip AVN who are in an early, pre-collapse stage of the disease. Although the efficacy of vascularized fibular grafting has been proven, up to 29% of grafts fail at five years and need to be converted to THA (Urbaniak et al., 1995). This study shows that THA after failed vascularized fibular grafting has a worse outcome than THA as a primary intervention. Therefore judicious use of the graft procedure is critical in order to minimize the number of graft failures and avoid the negative outcomes associated with it.
Correspondence should be addressed to Cynthia Vezina, Communications Manager, COA, 4150-360 Ste. Catherine St. West, Westmount, QC H3Z 2Y5, Canada