Bearing diameter and acetabular component orientation have been shown to be important variables effecting blood metal ion levels following hip resurfacing arthroplasty. So far no studies on bilateral hip resurfacings have taken into account these variables. We examined the serum ion results of patients under the care of two experienced hip resurfacing surgeons who carry out ion analysis as part of routine post operative care. Surgeon 1: Patients were implanted exclusively with a “third generation” resurfacing device. Surgeon 2: Patients were implanted with the same “third generation” device and also a low clearance “fourth generation” resurfacing device. Only ion results from patients who were 12 months post surgery were included. Bilateral patients were matched to unilateral patients according to the surgeon performing the operation; the resurfacing system implanted and cup inclination and anteversion angles. The ion data from each bilateral group was tested against the corresponding unilateral groups using the Mann Whitney U test for non parametric data. Significance was drawn at p<0.05. Surgeon 1: There were 310 patients with unilateral joints and 50 with bilateral joints. There were no significant differences with regard to time to follow up, activity levels, joint sizes or cup orientations. Serum chromium (Cr) and cobalt (Co) concentrations were significantly greater in the bilateral group (p<0.001). Median ion levels were greater in the bilateral group by a factor of >2 in the smallest joint sizes and <2 in the largest joints. Surgeon 2: There were 11 patients with bilateral third generation resurfacing joints and 50 with unilateral joints of the same design. The same relationship as described above was identified. There was a notable difference in the fourth generation implant group (n=13 bilateral, n=100 unilateral). Median ion levels for patients receiving bilateral joints of sizes <47mm were ten times greater than in the corresponding unilateral group. Bearing diameter and component design are critical factors in determining metal ion levels following bilateral hip resurfacings. Surgeons must consider the potential implications of gross increases in metal ion levels prior to performing bilateral hip resurfacings in smaller patients.
To investigate the value of tranexamic acid (TA) in reducing blood loss and blood transfusion after TKR and other clinical outcomes such as deep venous thrombosis (DVT), pulmonary embolism (PE), ischaemic heart diseases and mortality. A systematic review and meta-analysis of published randomised and quasi-randomised trials which used TA to reduce blood loss in knee arthroplasty was conducted. The data was evaluated using the generic evaluation tool designed by the Cochrane Bone, Joint and Muscle Trauma Group.Objectives
Methods
20-70% of patients need blood transfusion postoperatively. There remain safety concerns regarding allogenic blood transfusion. Tranexamic acid (TA) is a synthetic antifibrinolytic agent that has been successfully used to stop bleeding in other specialties. We applied TA topically prior to the wound closure to find out the effect on blood loss as well as need for subsequent blood transfusion. This method of administration is quick, easy, has less systemic side effect and provides a higher concentration at the bleeding site. A double blind randomised controlled trial of 154 patients who underwent unilateral primary cemented total knee replacement. Patients were randomised into tranexamic acid group (1g drug mixed with saline to make up 20mls) or placebo (20ml 0.9% saline). The administration technique and drain protocol was standardised for all patients. Drain output was measured at 24 hours, and both groups compared for need of Blood transfusion. Outcome measures - blood loss, transfusion, complications, Euroqol and Oxford Knee Score.PURPOSE OF STUDY
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Cup orientation in vivo was compared to explant analysis of 60 retrieved resurfacing components using a coordinate measuring machine.
This report documents the clinical and histological findings, the operative management and the explant analyses of patients with early aseptic failure of large metal-on-metal (MonM) bearing joints. Three hundred and fifty patients have been implanted with the ASR bearing surface (resurfacing or a modular THR) by a single surgeon at an independent centre since 2004. Six patients (all female) have been revised secondary to aseptic failure. All complained of severe groin pain exacerbated by straight leg raise and routine investigations were unable to establish a cause. Large amounts of sterile, highly viscous green fluid were aspirated from the hip joints in each case. Gross swelling of the pseudocapsule and a similar green fluid surrounding the implants were found at revision surgery. Histological examination of periprosthetic tissue samples showed changes consistent with ALVAL/metallosis, and analysis of the fluid revealed dense numbers of inflammatory cells. Symptoms in patients revised to ceramic-on-ceramic bearings improved post operatively. This was not the case with those reimplanted with MoM joints. Data from a subset of 76 patients (all unilateral resurfacings) showed that malaligned cups (anteverted >
20° +/− inclination angle >
45°) were associated with significantly higher whole blood metal ion levels than cups positioned within this range. All the patients with early aseptic failure had malaligned cups. Independent explant analysis revealed significant increases in the surface roughness values of the articular surfaces. Our results suggest that some patients develop a significant inflammatory reaction to metal implants. This may be due to high levels of metal debris around the implant as a result of accelerated wear. Poor component alignment was found in all our patients with early aseptic failure.
Metal ion concentrations following metal on metal hip resurfacing arthroplasty remain a concern. Variables associated with increased metal ion concentrations need to be established. This study provides metal ion data from a consecutive cohort of the first 76 patients implanted with a fourth generation hip resurfacing prosthesis. All patients agreed to post-operative blood metal ion sampling at a minimum of one year. Post-operative radiographic measurements of cup inclination and anteversion were obtained using the EBRA software. Mean whole blood chromium (Cr) and cobalt (Co) concentrations in patients receiving the smallest femoral implants (Ł51mm) were greater than in the patients implanted with the largest prostheses (ł53mm) by a factor of 3 and 9 respectively. Ion concentrations in the small femoral group were significantly related to acetabular inclination (R=0.439, P<
0.001 for Cr, R=0.372, P=0.004 for Co) and anteversion (R=0.330, P=0.010 for Cr, R=0.338, P=0.008 for Co). This relationship was not significant in the large implant group. Mean Cr and Co concentrations in patients with accurately orientated cups (inclination <
45°, anteversion <
20°) were 3.7μg/l and 1.8 μg/l respectively, compared to 9.1μg/l and 17.5μg/l in malaligned cups. A reduced surface contact area caused by cup malalignment may increase contact stresses, resulting in a high wear rate if fluid film lubrication is inadequate. Improved fluid film lubrication has previously been found in larger heads in vitro. Accurate acetabular component positioning is essential in order to reduce metal ion concentrations following hip resurfacing.
Since the era of total knee replacement (TKR) began in the late 1960s, total knee replacement has become one of the commonest operations in orthopaedic practice. TKR is frequently associated with transfusion of allogenic blood Benoni G 1995; Seppo T 1997. In our centre, 30 % of patients who had undergone TKR received allogenc blood transfusion perioperatively. Although, serological screening has reduced the risk for viral infection to a very low levelKlein HG 1995; Schreiber GB 1996, the public is still concerned about this potential serious complication. Allogenic blood transfusion can be also associated with other non infectious complications such as haemolysis, immunosuppression, transfusion-related acute lung injury and even death.Madjdpour C 2005 Therefore, further refinement of strategies to avoid exposure to allogeneic blood is needed. Amongst the technologies to minimise the need for blood transfusion is the use of the anti-fibrinolytic drugs aprotinin, tranexamic acid (TXA), and epsilon amino-caproic acid (EACA).New Reference
Five blinded orthopaedic registrars then used EBRA (Einzel-Bild-Roentgen-Analysis, University of Inns-bruck, Austria) software to determine the radiological anteversion from the AP films. Twenty-five ASR and twenty-five BHR images were analysed. At the same time each observer was asked to grade the cups as “1” (<
10°) “2” (10–20°) “3” (20–30°) or “4” (>
30°) depending on the appearances of the cup vertices.
Cups graded as “1” or “4” showed high sensitivity and specificity for the true grade as determined on the lateral radiographs.
In our independent centre, in the period from January 2003 to august 2008, over 1100 36mm MoM THRs have been implanted as well as 155 Birmingham Hip Resurfacing procedures, 402 ASR resurfacings and 75 THRs using ASR XL heads on SROM stems. During this period we have experienced a number of failures with patients complaining of worsening groin pain at varying lengths of time post operatively. Aspiration of the hip joints yielded a large sterile effusion on each occasion. At revision, there were copious amounts of green grey fluid with varying degrees of necrosis. There were 11 failures of this nature in patients with ASR implants (10 females) and 2 in the 36 MoM THR group (one male one female). Tissue specimens from revision surgery showed varying degrees of ‘ALVAL’ as well as consistently high numbers of histiocytes. Metal debris was also a common finding. A fuller examination of our ASR cohort as a whole has shown that smaller components placed with inclinations >
45° and anteversions <
10 or >
20° are associated with increased metal ion levels. The 11 ASR failed joints were all sub optimally positioned (by the above definition), small components. Explant analysis using a coordinate measuring machine and out of roundness device confirmed greater than expected wear of each component. The lower number of failures in the 36mm MoM group, as well as the equal sex incidence, suggests that the majority of these failures are due to the instigation of an immune reaction by large amounts of wear debris rather than adverse reactions to well functioning joints. It is likely that small malpositioned ASRs function in mixed to boundary lubrication, and this, combined with the larger radius of these joints compared to the 36mm MoM joints, results in more rapid wear.
Optimal cup orientation for metal-on-metal hip resurfacing has yet to be established. Guidance is based on hip replacement data and in vitro studies. We sought to determine the influence of component size and positioning on early clinical outcome. This study comprises a consecutive series of 200 hip resurfacings. All had Harris Hip Scores (HHS) at one-year review. Acetabular inclination angles were measured on pre-operative radiographs, and cup inclination/anteversion angles on 3-month post-operative films using EBRA. Restoration of anatomy was defined as placement of the cup within +/−5 degrees of pre-operative inclination. The difference between pre-operative acetabular and post-operative cup inclination was termed cup-angle difference (CAD). HHS inversely correlated with CAD (P=0.023) and anteversion (P=0.003), and directly correlated with femoral head size (P<
0.001). In patients with restoration of inclination anatomy mean HHS at one year was significantly higher at 98.7 compared with cups placed outside the normal anatomy restoration limits (93.8, P=0.003). Patients with anteversion >
20 degrees had a significantly lower HHS (P=0.010) compared with cups anteverted <
20 degrees. 96% of patients with HHS <
90 had malaligned cups (inclination over 45 degrees, anteversion over 20 degrees). Restoring pre-operative cup inclination, anteverting the cup <
20 degrees and using large femoral heads improves early clinical outcome following MonM hip resurfacing. We recommend accurate pre-operative planning and meticulous attention to intra-operative cup positioning with these results in mind.
Resurfacing metal-on-metal hip arthroplasty is currently showing promising clinical results. However there are concerns related to such implants, including the elevated levels of metal ions typically seen in patients. Valuable data can be obtained from explanted prostheses but due to their recent introduction few retrieval studies on resurfacing hip prostheses have been published. Five ASR hip resurfacing prostheses were revised due to pain. From two patients, head and cup were available for independent explant analysis. In the other three cases only femoral components were available. All were removed from female patients and all were revised to ceramic-on-ceramic hip prostheses. Post-operative radiographic measurements of cup inclination and ante-version were obtained using the EBRA software. The surface roughness values of the articulating surfaces of the explants were measured using a non-contacting profilometer. A co-ordinate measuring machine was used to measure the diameter of the head and the cup and thus the diametral clearance. The same measurements were then taken from a new unused ASR prosthesis and compared. Using elastohydrodynamic theory the minimum effective film thickness of the implant was calculated. In turn this allowed the lubrication regime to be determined. The average roughness values of the head and the cup of one implant were found to be 0.135microns and 0.058microns respectively, with a diametral clearance of 110microns. These results indicated that, at the time of removal, the prosthesis would have operated in the boundary lubrication regime. Other explants showed evidence of localised contact between the head and the rim of the acetabular cup, and these showed articulating surfaces with typical roughness values of between 0.025microns and 0.050microns. The new ASR had head and cup surface roughness values of 0.010microns and 0.012microns respectively and a diametral clearance of 87microns, implying that a new implant would operate under fluid film lubrication. All cups five were implanted with inclination angles over 45 degrees and anteversion over 25 degrees. These results suggest that components with high inclination and anteversion angles display greater than expected wear and may operate in boundary rather than fluid film lubrication which may eventually lead to early failure.