header advert
Orthopaedic Proceedings Logo

Receive monthly Table of Contents alerts from Orthopaedic Proceedings

Comprehensive article alerts can be set up and managed through your account settings

View my account settings

Visit Orthopaedic Proceedings at:

Loading...

Loading...

Full Access

THE CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE OF HIGH CUP ANGLES AND METAL ION LEVELS AFTER HIP RESURFACING



Abstract

Introduction: Potential problems resulting from metal-on-metal hip wear debris are well known. Previous studies have shown an association between high cup angles and raised metal ion levels, but a link to clinical outcome has yet to be established. We aim to show the relationship between high cup angles, raised metal ion levels and pain following hip resurfacing.

Methods: This analysis comprised the first 250 Depuy ASR hip resurfacings performed by a single surgeon (senior author) over a 3 yr period at an independent centre. Patients were followed up, examined and x-rayed at regular intervals. We measured Harris Hip Score (HHS) and pain. The acetabular cup inclination angles were measured from standardised pelvic radiographs. A subgroup of 80 patients had serum and whole blood chromium and cobalt measurements performed. This subgroup comprised patients with a similar sex split, age, activity level, follow-up and cup angle profile to the parent group.

Results: HHS improved from 51.6 pre-operatively to 94.6 post-operatively. Males had a significantly higher post-op HHS (97.1) compared with the females (91.0). 2.1% of male patients had pain compared with 8.7% of females. High cup angles were associated with pain in females. This relationship did not occur in males. In patients with cup angles of 48° and above there were no males with pain compared to 15.4% of females. Females under 48° had a HHS of 93.7 compared to 88.0 for those over 48°. When we analysed metal ion levels there was a similar relationship. Patients with cup angles of 48° and above had significantly higher serum and whole blood chromium and cobalt levels compared with lower cup angles. Three patients with cup angles over 50° developed ALVAL (aseptic lymphocyte dominated vasculitis associated lesion) based on histological findings. All were female.

Discussion: High cup angles are associated with increased pain and elevated metal ion levels. Women seem to be more intolerant of an higher cup angle than men. This may be a consequence of the smaller prostheses in females. Cups implanted lower than 48° had a better clinical outcome and less metal ion wear. Like other 4th generation designs, the ASR cup is not a complete hemisphere (unlike the BHR) and may be susceptible to edge loading at lower inclination angles than previously thought. We believe the current recommendation of 45° +/−5° is too high based on our findings. We recommend an inclination angle that does not exceed 48°.

Correspondence should be addressed to: EFORT Central Office, Technoparkstrasse 1, CH – 8005 Zürich, Switzerland. Email: office@efort.org