Dual Mobility (DM) Total Hip Replacements (THRs), are becoming widely used but function in-vivo is not fully understood. The aim of this study was to compare the incidence of impingement of a modular dual mobility with that of a standard cup. A geometrical model of one subject's bony anatomy \[1\] was developed, a THR was implanted with the cup at a range of inclination and anteversion positions (Corail® stem, Pinnacle® cup (DePuy Synthes)). Two DM variants and one STD acetabular cup were modelled. Joint motions were taken from kinematic data of activities of daily living associated with dislocation \[2\] and walking. The occurrence of impingement was assessed for each component combination, orientation and activity. Implant-implant impingement can occur between the femoral neck and the metal or PE liner (DM or STD constructs respectively) or neck-PE mobile liner (DM only). The results comprise a colour coded matrix which sums the number of impingement events for each cup position and activity and for each implant variant. Neck-PE mobile liner impingement, occurred for both DM sizes, for all activities, and most cup placement positions indicating that the PE mobile liner is likely to move at the start of all activities including walking. For all constructs no placement positions avoided neck-metal (DM) or neck-PE liner (STD) impingementevents in all activities. The least number of events occurred at higher inclination and anteversion component positions. In addition to implant-implant impingement, some instances of bone-bone and implant-bone impingement were also observed. Consistent with DM philosophy, neck-PE mobile liner impingement and liner motion occurred for all activities including walking. Neck-liner impingement frequency was comparable between both DM sizes (metal liner) and a standard cup (PE liner).
The aim of this study was to develop an in vitro GAG-depleted patella model and assess the biomechanical effects following treatment with a SAP:CS self-assembling hydrogel. Porcine patellae (4–6 month old) were harvested and subject to 0.1% (w/v) sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) washes to remove GAGs from the cartilage. Patellae were GAG depleted and then treated by injection with SAP (∼ 6 mM) and CS (10 mg) in Ringer's solution through a 30G needle. Native, GAG depleted and SAP:CS treated patellae were tested through static indentation testing, using 15g load, 5mm indenter over 1hr period. The degree of deformation of each group was assessed and compared (Mann-Whitney, p<0.05). Native, GAG depleted, sham (saline only) and SAP:CS treated paired patellae and femurs were additionally characterized tribologically through sequential wear testing when undergoing a walking gait profile (n=6 per group). The cartilage surfaces were assessed and compared (Mann-Whitney, p<0.05) using the ICRS scoring system, surface damage was illustrated through the application of Indian ink.Abstract
Objectives
Methods
Dual Mobility (DM) Total Hip Replacements (THRs) were introduced to reduce dislocation risk, which is the most common cause of early revision. The in-vivo mechanics of these implants is not well understood, despite their increased use in both elective and trauma settings. Therefore, the aim of this study was to comprehensively assess retrieved DM polyethylene liners for signs of damage using visual inspection and semi-quantitative geometric assessment techniques. Retrieved DM liners (n=20) were visually inspected for the presence of seven established modes of polyethylene damage. If embedded debris was identified on the external surface, its material composition was characterised using energy-dispersive x-ray analysis (EDX). Additionally, each liner was geometrically assessed for signs of wear/deformation using a validated methodology. Visual inspection of the liners revealed that scratching and pitting were the most common damage modes on either surface. Burnishing was observed on 50% and 15% of the internal and external surfaces, respectively. In addition, embedded debris was identified on 25% of the internal and 65% of the external surfaces. EDX analysis of the debris identified several materials including iron, titanium, cobalt-chrome, and tantalum. Geometric analysis demonstrated highly variable damage patterns across the liners. The results of this study provide insight into the in-vivo mechanics of DM bearings. For example, the results suggest that the internal bearing (i.e., between the head and liner) acts as the primary articulation site for DM-THRs as evidenced by a higher incidence of burnishing and larger, more concentrated regions of penetration across the liners’ internal surfaces. Furthermore, circumferential, and crescent-shaped damage patterns were identified on the articulating surfaces of the liners thus providing evidence that these components can rotate within the acetabular shell with varying degrees of mobility. The mechanics of DM bearings are complex and may be influenced by several factors (e.g., soft tissue fibrosis, patient activities) and thus further investigation is warranted. Finally, the results of this study suggest that DM liners may be susceptible to ex-vivo surface damage and thus caution is advised when handling and/or assessing these types of components.
Autologous osteochondral grafting has demonstrated positive outcomes for treating articular cartilage defects by replacing the damaged region with a cylindrical graft consisting of bone with a layer of cartilage, taken from a non-loadbearing region of the knee. Despite positive clinical use, factors that cause graft subsidence or poor integration are relatively unknown. The aim of this study was to develop finite element (FE) models of osteochondral grafts within a tibiofemoral joint and to investigate parameters affecting osteochondral graft stability. Initial experimental tests on cadaveric femurs were performed to calibrate the bone properties and graft-bone frictional forces for use in corresponding FE models, generated from µCT scan data. The effects of cartilage defects and osteochondral graft repair were measured by examining contact pressure changes using in vitro tests on a single cadaveric human tibiofemoral joint. Six defects were created in the femoral condyles which were subsequently treated with osteochondral autografts or metal pins. Matching µCT scan-based FE models were created, and the contact patches were compared. Sensitivity to graft bone properties was investigated. The bone material properties and graft-bone frictional forces were successfully calibrated from the initial tests with good resulting levels of agreement (CCC=0.87). The tibiofemoral joint experiment provided a range of cases to model. These cases were well captured experimentally and represented accurately in the FE models. Graft properties relative to host bone had large effects on immediate graft stability despite limited changes to resultant cartilage contact pressure. Model confidence was built through extensive validation and sensitivity testing, and demonstrated that specimen-specific properties were required to accurately represent graft behaviour. The results indicate that graft bone properties affect the immediate stability, which is important for the selection of allografts and design of future synthetic grafts. Supported by the EPSRC-EP/P001076.Acknowledgements
Non-optimal clinical alignment of components in total hip replacements (THRs) may lead to edge loading of the acetabular cup liner. This has the potential to cause changes to the liner rim not accounted for in standard wear models. A greater understanding of the material behaviours could be beneficial to design and surgical guidance for THR devices. The aim of this research was to combine finite element (FE) modelling and experimental simulation with microstructural assessment to examine material behaviour changes during edge loading. A dynamic deformable FE model, matching the experimental conditions, was created to simulate the stress strain environment within liners. Five liners were tested for 4Mc (million cycles) of standard loading (ISO14242:1) followed by 3Mc of edge loading with dynamic separation (ISO14242:4) in a hip simulator. Microstructural measurements by Raman spectroscopy were taken at unloaded and highly loaded rim locations informed by FE results. Gravimetric and geometric measurements were taken every 1Mc cycles. Under edge loading, peak Mises stress and plastic deformation occur below the surface of the rim during heel strike. After 7Mc, microstructural analysis determined edge loaded regions had an increased crystalline mass fraction compared to unloaded regions (p<0.05). Gravimetric wear rates of 12.5mm3/Mc and 22.3mm3/Mc were measured for standard and edge loading respectively. A liner penetration of 0.37mm was measured after 7Mc. Edge loading led to an increase in gravimetric wear rate indicating a different wear mechanism is occurring. FE and Raman results suggest that changes to material behaviour at the rim could be possible. These methods will now be used to assess more liners and over a larger number of cycles. They have potential to explore the impact of edge loading on different surgical and patient variables.
Variations in component positioning of total hip replacements can lead to edge loading of the liner, and potentially affect device longevity. These effects are evaluated using ISO 14242:4 edge loading test results in a dynamic system. Mediolateral translation of one of the components during testing is caused by a compressed spring, and therefore the kinematics will depend on the spring stiffness and damping coefficient, and the mass of the translating component and fixture. This study aims to describe the sensitivity of the liner plastic strain to these variables, to better understand how tests using different simulator designs might produce different amounts of liner rim deformation. A dynamic explicit deformable finite element model with 36mm Pinnacle metal-on-polyethylene bearing geometry (DePuy Synthes, Leeds, UK) was used with material properties for conventional UHMWPE. Setup was 65° clinical inclination, 4mm mismatch, 70N swing phase load, and 100N/mm spring. Fixture mass was varied from 0.5-5kg, spring damping coefficient was varied from 0-2Ns/mm. They were changed independently, and in combination. Maximum separation values were relatively insensitive to changes in the mass, damping coefficient, or both. The sensitivity of peak plastic strain, to this range of inputs, was similar to changing the swing phase load from 70N to approximately 150N – 200N. Increasing the fixture mass and/or damping coefficient increased the peak plastic strain, with values from 0.15-0.19. Liner plastic deformation was sensitive to the spring damping and fixture mass, which may explain some of the differences in fatigue and deformation results in UHMWPE liners tested on different machines or with modified fixtures. These values should be described when reporting the results of ISO14242:4 testing. Acknowledgements Funded by EPSRC grant EP/N02480X/1; CAD supplied by DePuy Synthes.
Dual mobility (DM) total hip replacements (THRs) were introduced to reduce dislocation risk, which is the most common cause of early revision. Although DM THRs have shown good overall survivorship and low dislocation rates, the mechanisms which describe how these bearings function in-vivo are not fully understood. Therefore, the study aim was to comprehensively assess retrieved DM polyethylene liners for signs of damage using visual inspection and semi-quantitative geometric assessment methods. Retrieved DM liners (n=18) were visually inspected for the presence of surface damage, whereby the internal and external surfaces were independently assigned a score of one (present) or zero (not present) for seven damage modes. The severity of damage was not assessed. The material composition of embedded debris was characterised using energy-dispersive x-ray analysis (EDX). Additionally, each liner was geometrically assessed for signs of wear/deformation [1]. Scratching and pitting were the most common damage modes on either surface. Additionally, burnishing was observed on 50% of the internal surfaces and embedded debris was identified on 67% of the external surfaces. EDX analysis of the debris identified several materials including titanium, cobalt-chrome, iron, and tantalum. Geometric analysis demonstrated highly variable damage patterns across the liners. The incidence of burnishing was three times greater for the internal surfaces, suggesting that this acts as the primary articulation site. The external surfaces sustained more observable damage as evidenced by a higher incidence of embedded debris, abrasion, delamination, and deformation. In conjunction with the highly variable damage patterns observed, these results suggest that DM kinematics are complex and may be influenced by several factors (e.g., soft tissue fibrosis, patient activities) and thus further investigation is warranted.
Involving research users in setting priorities for research is essential to ensure research outcomes are patient-centred and to maximise research value and impact. The Musculoskeletal (MSK) Disorders Research Advisory Group Versus Arthritis led a research priority setting exercise across MSK disorders. The Child Health and Nutrition Research Initiative (CHRNI) method of setting research priorities with a range of stakeholders were utilised. The MSKD RAG identified, through consensus, four research Domains: Mechanisms of Disease; Diagnosis and Impact; Living Well with MSK disorders and Successful Translation. Following ethical approval, the research priority exercise involved four stages and two surveys, to: 1) gather research uncertainties; 2) consolidate these; 3) score uncertainties using agreed criteria of importance and impact on a score of 1–10; and 4) analyse scoring, for prioritisation.Background
Methods
Osteoarthritis (OA) is one of the lead causes of pain and disability in adults. Bone marrow lesions (BMLs) are one feature of subchondral bone involvement in OA. MRI images suggest changes in tissue content and properties in the affected regions however, it is not known if this alters the mechanical behavior of the bone, which could in turn affect OA progression. The aim of this study was to characterize the mechanical properties of BMLs, using a combined experimental and computational approach. Six human cadaveric patellae from donors aged 56–76 were used in this study; all exhibited BML regions under MRI. Bone plugs were taken from non-BML (n = 6) and BML (n = 7) regions within the patellae, with guidance from the MRI. The plugs were imaged at 82µm resolution using micro computed tomography (µCT) and tested under uniaxial compression. Finite element (FE) models were created for each plug from the µCT scans and morphological properties such as bone volume fraction (BV/TV) were also determined. The relationship between bone volume fraction and apparent modulus was investigated for both sample groups.Abstract
Introduction
Methods
Dual mobility (DM) total hip replacements (THRs) were introduced to reduce the risk of hip dislocation in at-risk patients. DM THRs have shown good overall survivorship and low rates of dislocation, however, the mechanisms which describe how these bearings function in-vivo are not fully understood. This is partly due to a lack of suitable characterisation methodologies which are appropriate for the novel geometry and function of DM polyethylene liners, whereby both surfaces are subject to articulation. This study aimed to develop a novel semi-quantitative geometric characterisation methodology to assess the wear/deformation of DM liners. Three-dimensional coordinate data of the internal and external surfaces of 14 in-vitro tested DM liners was collected using a Legex 322 coordinate measuring machine. Data was input into a custom Matlab script, whereby the unworn reference geometry was determined using a sphere fitting algorithm. The analysis method determined the geometric variance of each point from the reference surface and produced surface deviation heatmaps to visualise areas of wear/deformation. Repeatability of the method was also assessed.Abstract
OBJECTIVES
METHODS
The patella tendon (PT) is commonly used as a graft material for anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR). The function of the graft is to restore the mechanical behaviour of the knee joint. Therefore, it is essential that a robust methodology be developed for the mechanical testing of the PT, as well as for the tissue engineered grafts derived from this tissue. Our objectives were to (1) survey the literature, in order to define the state-of-the-art in mechanical testing of the PT, highlighting the most commonly used testing protocols, and (2) conduct validation studies using porcine PT to compare the mechanical measurements obtained using different methodological approaches. A PubMed search was performed using a boolean search term to identify publications consisting of PT tensile testing, and limited to records published in the past ten years (2010–2020). This returned a total of 143 publications. A meta-analysis was undertaken to quantify the frequency of commonly used protocol variations (pre-conditioning regime, strain rates, maximum strain, etc.). Validation studies were performed on porcine PT (n=4) using Instron tensile testing apparatus to examine the effect of preconditioning on low-strain (toe-region) mechanical properties.Abstract
Objectives
Methods
Develop a methodology to assess the long term mechanical behavior of intervertebral discs by utilizing novel sequential state testing. Bovine functional spinal units were sequentially mechanically tested in (1) native (n=8), (2) degenerated (n=4), and (3) treated states (n=4). At stage (2), artificial degeneration was created using rapid enzymatic degeneration, followed by a 24 hour hold period under static load at 42°C. At stage (3), nucleus augmentation treatments were injected with a hydrogel or a ‘sham’ (water, chondroitin sulfate) injection. The mechanical protocol employed applied a static load hold period followed by cyclic compressive loading between ∼350 and 750 N at 1 Hz. 1000 cycles were applied at each stage, and the final test on each specimen was extended up to 20000 cycles. To verify if test time can be reduced, functions were fitted using stiffness data up to 100, 1000, 2500, 5000, 10000 and 20000 cycles. Linear regression for the native specimens comparing the stiffness at various cycles to the stiffness at 20000 cycles was completed.Abstract
Objectives
Methods
Osteoarthritis (OA) affects more than four million people in the UK alone. Bone marrow lesions (BMLs) are a common feature of subchondral bone pathology in OA. Both bone volume fraction and mineral density within the BML are abnormal. The aim of this study was to investigate the effect of a potential treatment (bone augmentation) for BMLs on the knee joint mechanics in cases with healthy and fully degenerated cartilage, using finite element (FE) models of the joint to study the effect of BML size. FE models of a human tibiofemoral joint were created based on models from the Open Knee project (simtk.org). Following initial mesh convergence studies, each model was manipulated in ScanIP (Synopsys-Simpleware, UK) to incorporate a BML 2mm below the surface of the tibial contact region. Models representing extreme cases (healthy cartilage, no cartilage; BML region as an empty cavity or filled with bone substitution material (200GPa)) were generated, each with different sizes of BML. Models were tested under a representative physiological load of 2kN.Abstract
Introduction
Methods
Impingement in total hip replacements (THRs), including bone-on-bone impingement, can lead to complications such as dislocation and loosening. The aim of this study was to investigate how the location of the anterior inferior iliac spine (AIIS) affected the range of motion before impingement. A cohort of 25 CT scans (50 hips) were assessed and nine hips were selected with a range of AIIS locations relative to the hip joint centre. The selected CT Scans were converted to solid models (ScanIP) and THR components (DePuy Synthes) were virtually implanted (Solidworks). Flexion angles of 100⁰, 110⁰, and 120⁰ were applied to the femur, each followed by internal rotation to the point of impingement. The lateral, superior and anterior extent of the AIIS from the Centre of Rotation (CoR) of the hip was measured and its effect on the range of motion was recorded.Abstract
Objectives
Methods
Osteochondral grafting (OCG) is one treatment strategy for osteoarthritis with good clinical results. Decellularised tissues provide a promising alternative to standard autografts or allografts. This study aimed to compare the stability of traditional OCG and decellularised scaffolds upon initial implantation. Host cubes (N=16) were extracted from porcine femoral condyles around an artificial defect hole. Grafts (N=11) were harvested from the trochlear groove; porcine decellularized osteochondral scaffold (N=5) were prepared. Each host was secured in fixtures and submerged in PBS at 37 ºC. Each graft or scaffold was press fit into one of the hosts, then pushed in for 5 mm, using an indenter (Instron3365) and pushed out in the opposite direction for 10 mm. Parameters analysed were the force required to initiate movement (Dislodging Force) and the maximum force (Max Force).Abstract
Objectives
Methods
The importance of cup position on the performance of total hip replacements (THR) has been demonstrated in Pelvic movement data for walking for 39 unilateral THR patients was acquired (Leeds Biomedical Research Centre). Patient's elected walking speed was used to group patients into high- and low-functioning (mean speed, 1.36(SD 0.09)ms−1 and 0.85(SD 0.08)ms−1 respectively). A computational algorithm (Python3.7) was developed to calculate cup version during gait cycle. Inputs were pelvic angles and initial cup orientation (assumed to be 45° inclination and 7° version, anterior pelvic plane was parallel to radiological frontal plane). Outputs were cup version angles during a gait cycle (101 measurements/cycle). Minimum, maximum and average cup version during gait cycle were measured for each patient. Two-sample t-test (p=0.05) was used to compare groups.Abstract
Objectives
Methods
Impingement of total hip replacements (THRs) can cause rim damage of polyethylene liners, and lead to dislocation and/or mechanical failure of liner locking mechanisms[1]. A geometric model of a THR in situ was previously developed to predict impingement for different component orientations and joint motions of activities[2]. However, the consequence of any predicted impingement is unknown. This study aimed to develop an in-vitromethod to investigate the effects of different impingement scenarios. A ProSim electro-mechanical single-station hip simulator (Simulation Solutions) was used, and the 32mm diameter metal-on-polyethylene THRs (DePuy Synthes) were assessed. The THR was mounted in an inverted orientation, and the input (motion and loading) applied simulated a patient stooping over to pick an object from the floor[3]. The impingement severity was varied by continuing motion past the point of impingement by 2.5° or 5°, and compressive load applied in the medial-lateral direction was varied from 100N to 200N. Each test condition was applied for 40,000 cycles (n=3). Rim penetration was assessed using a CMM and component separation was measured during the tests.Abstract
Objectives
Method
Ankle arthritis is estimated to affect approximately 72 million people worldwide. Treatment options include fusion and total ankle replacement (TAR). Clinical performance of TAR is not as successful as other joint replacement and failure is poorly understood. Finite element analysis offers a method to assess the strain in bone implanted with a TAR. Higher strain has been associated with microfracture and alters the bone-implant interface. The aim of this study was to explore the influence of implant fixation on strain within the tibia when implanted with a TAR through subject-specific models. Five cadaveric ankles were scanned using a Scanco Xtreme CT. The Tibia and Talus were segmented from each scan and virtually implanted with a Zenith TAR (Corin, UK) according to published surgical technique. Patient specific models were created and run at five different positions of the gait cycle corresponding to peak load and flexion values identified from literature. Bone material properties were derived from CT greyscale values and all parts were meshed with linear tetrahedral elements. The implant-bone interface was adjusted to fully-fixed or frictionless contact, representing different levels of fixation post-surgery. Strain distributions around the tibial bone fixation were measured.Abstract
Introduction
Methods
Impingement of total hip replacements (THRs) can cause rim damage of polyethylene liners, and lead to dislocation and/or mechanical failure of liner locking mechanisms[1]. Previous work has focussed on the influence of femoral neck profile on impingement without consideration of neck-shaft angle. This study assessed the occurrence of impingement with two different stem designs (Corail standard [135°] and coxa vara [125°]) under different activities with varying acetabular cup orientation (30° to 70° inclination; 0° to 50° anteversion) using a geometric modelling tool. The tool was created in a computer aided design software programme, and incorporated an individual's hemi-pelvis and femur geometry[3] with a THR (DePuy Synthes Pinnacle® shell and neutral liner; size 12 Corail® standard or coxa vara and 32mm head). Kinematic data of activities associated with dislocation[2], such as stooping to pick an object from the floor was applied and incidences of impingement were recorded. Predicted implant impingement was influenced by stem design. The coxa vara stem was predicted to cause implant impingement less frequently across the range of activities and cup orientations investigated, compared to the standard stem [Fig. 1]. The cup orientations predicted to cause impingement the least frequently were at lower inclination and anteversion angles, relative to the standard stem [Fig. 1]. The coxa vara stem included a collar, while the standard stem was collarless; additional analysis indicated that differences were due to neck angle and not the presence of a collar. This study demonstrated that stem neck-shaft angle is an important variable in prosthetic impingement in THR and surgeons should be aware of this when choosing implants. Future work will consider further implant design and bone geometry variables. This tool has the potential for use in optimising stem design and position and could assist with patient specific stem selection based on an individual's activity profile. For any figures or tables, please contact the authors directly.
Impingement of total hip arthroplasties (THAs) has been reported to cause rim damage of polyethylene liners, and in some instances has led to dislocation and/or mechanical failure of liner locking mechanisms in modular designs. Elevated rim liners are used to improve stability and reduce the risk of dislocation, however they restrict the possible range of motion of the joint, and retrieval studies have found impingement related damage on lipped liners. The aim of this study was to develop a tool for assessing the occurrence of impingement under different activities, and use it to evaluate the effects a lipped liner and position of the lip has on the impingement-free range of motion. A geometrical model incorporated a hemi-pelvis and femur geometries of one individual with a THA (DePuy Pinnacle® acetabular cup with neutral and lipped liners; size 12 Corail® stem with 32mm diameter head) was created in SOLIDWORKS (Dassault Systèmes). Joint motions were taken from kinematic data of activities of daily living that were associated with dislocation of THA, such as stooping to pick an object off the floor and rolling over. The femoral component was positioned to conform within the geometry of the femur, and the acetabular component was orientated in a clinically acceptable position (45° inclination and 20° anteversion). Variation in orientation of the apex of the lip was investigated by rotating about the acetabular axes from the superior (0°) in increments of 45° (0°−315°), and compared to a neutral liner.Introduction
MATERIALS & METHOD
There is great potential for the use of computational tools within the design and test cycle for joint replacement devices. The increasing need for stratified treatments that are more relevant to specific patients, and implant testing under more realistic, less idealised, conditions, will progressively increase the pre-clinical experimental testing work load. If the outcomes of experimental tests can be predicted using low cost computational tools, then these tools can be embedded early in the design cycle, e.g. benchmarking various design concepts, optimising component geometrical features and virtually predicting factors affecting the implant performance. Rapid, predictive tools could also allow population-stratified scenario testing at an early design stage, resulting in devices which are better suited to a patient-specific approach to treatment. The aim of the current study was to demonstrate the ability of a rapid computational analysis tool to predict the behaviour of a total hip replacement (THR) device, specifically the risk of edge loading due to separation under experimental conditions. A series of models of a 36mm BIOLOX® Delta THR bearing (DePuy Synthes, Leeds, UK) were generated to match an experimental simulator study which included a mediolateral spring to cause lateral head separation due to a simulated mediolateral component misalignment of 4mm. A static, rigid, frictionless model was implemented in Python (PyEL, runtime: ∼1m), and results were compared against 1) a critically damped dynamic, rigid, FE model (runtime: ∼10h), 2) a critically damped dynamic, rigid, FE model with friction (µ = 0.05) (runtime: ∼10h), and 3) kinematic experimental test data from a hip simulator (ProSim EM13) under matching settings (runtime: ∼6h). Outputs recorded were the variation of mediolateral separation and force with time.INTRODUCTION
METHODS
Mal-positioning of the acetabular component in total hip replacement (THR) could lead to edge loading, accelerated component wear, impingement and dislocation [1,2]. In order to achieve a successful position for the acetabular component, the assessment of the acetabular orientation with reference to different coordinate systems is important [3]. The aims of the present study were to establish a pelvic coordinate system and a global body coordinate system, and to assess the acetabular orientations of natural hips with reference to the two coordinate systems. Three-dimensional (3D) computed tomographic (CT) images of 56 subjects (28 males and 28 females) lying supine were obtained from a public image archive (Cancer Image Archive, website: INTRODUCTION
METHODS
The performance of total hip replacement (THR) devices can be affected by the quality of the tissues surrounding the joint or the mismatch of the component centres during hip replacement surgery. Experimental studies have shown that these factors can cause the separation of the two components during walking cycle (dynamic separation) and the contact of the femoral head with the rim of the acetabular liner (edge loading), which can lead to increased wear and shortened implant lifespan1. There is a need for flexible pre-clinical testing tools which allow THR devices to be assessed under these adverse conditions. In this work, a novel dynamic finite element model was developed that is able to generate dynamic separation as it occurs during the gait cycle. In addition, the ability to interrogate contact mechanics and material strain under separation conditions provides a unique means of assessing the severity of edge loading. This study demonstrates these model capabilities for a range of simulated surgical translational mismatch values, for ceramic-on-polyethylene implants. The components of the THR were aligned and constrained as illustrated in Figure 1. CAD models of commercially available implant geometries were used (DePuy Synthes, Leeds, UK) modified for model simplicity by removing anti-rotation features. The polyethylene cup liner was given elastic-plastic behaviour. An axial load following the Paul cycle pattern (5 repetitive cycles) with maximum of 3KN and swing phase load of 0.3KN, was applied through the cup holder. The effect of translational mismatch was implemented by using a spring element connected to the cup unit on the lateral side. The spring was compressed by a fixed amount to replicate a degree of medial-lateral mismatch of the components. The instantaneous resultant force vector dictated the dynamic sliding behaviour of the cup against the head. In this study, translational medial-lateral mismatch values of 1, 2, 3 and 4mm were used and the medial-lateral dynamic separation, contact pressure maps and plastic strain were recorded.Introduction
Methodology
Prophylactic vertebroplasty treatment of ‘at-risk’ vertebrae may reduce fracture risk, however which areas weaken, thus providing surgical targets? Direct spatial 3D mapping of ReTm overcomes the constraints of 2D histology, and by application may provide insight into specific regional atrophy. Insidious bone loss with age makes the skeleton fracture-prone in the rapidly expanding elderly population. Diagnosis of osteoporosis is often made after irreversible damage has occurred. There are over 300,000 new fragility fractures annually in the UK, more than 120,000 of these being vertebral compression fractures (VCF). Some VCFs cause life-altering pain, requiring surgical intervention. Vertebroplasty is a minimally invasive procedure whereby bone cement is injected into the damaged vertebral body with the aim of stabilisation and pain alleviation. However, vertebroplasty can alter the biomechanics of the spine, apparently leaving adjacent vertebrae with an increased VCF risk. Prophylactic augmentation of intact, though ‘at-risk’, vertebrae may reduce the risk of adverse effects. The question therefore arises as to which areas of a non-fractured vertebral body, structurally weakened with age, and thus should be targeted. Frequent reports of an overlap in BMD (bone mineral density) between fracture and non-fracture subjects suggest the combination of bone quantity and its ‘quality’ (microarchitectural strength) may be a more reliable fracture predictor than BMD alone. Providing a reliable method of cancellous connectivity measurement (a highly significant bone strength factor) is challenging. Traditional histological methods for microarchitectural interconnection are limited as they usually indirectly extrapolate 3D structure from thin (8 µm) 2D undecalcified sections. To address this difficulty, Aaron et al (2000) developed a novel, thick (300 µm) slicing and superficial staining procedure, whereby unstained real (not stained planar artifactual) trabecular termini (ReTm) are identified directly within their 3D context. The aim of this study was to automate a method of identifying trabecular regions of weakness in vertebral bodies from ageing spines. Patients and methods. 27 Embalmed cadaveric vertebral bodies (T10-L3) from 5 women (93.2±8.6 years) and 3 men (90±4.4 years) were scanned by µCT (micro-computerised tomography; µCT80, Scanco Medical, Switzerland, 74 µm voxel size), before plastic-embedding, slicing (300µm thick), and surface-staining with the von Kossa (2% silver nitrate) stain. The ReTm were mapped using light microscopy, recording their coordinates using the integrated stage, mapping them within nine defined sectors to demonstrate any apparent loci of structural disconnectivity that may cause weakness disproportionate to the bone loss. A transparent 3D envelope corresponding to the cortex, was constructed using code developed in-house (Matlab 7.3, Mathworks, USA), and was modulated and validated by overlay of the previous µCT scan and the coordinate data.Summary Statement
Introduction
The annulus fibrosus (AF) of the intervertebral disc (IVD) has a unique, complex structure. If engineered tissues for the IVD are to be successfully developed, it is essential that the constituent level mechanics of the tissues in their natural form are fully understood (Nerurkar, J. Biomech. 2010). Published finite element (FE) models of the IVD do not represent lamellae behaviour and are validated using bulk mechanics of the intervertebral joint. This study aims to develop models of the IVD that include representation of the lamellae structure of the AF and the behaviour of this tissue within the disc. Three FE models of a vertebra-disc-vertebra section were developed considering the following scenarios of the AF: Homogenous AF. Concentric rings representing AF's lamellae structure with frictionless contact between rings. Concentric rings with ‘interface’ elements representing the interlamellar space; properties were derived through calibration of a separate model of an AF tissue sample with histological studies of the AF (Gregory, J. Biomechs. 2009). Displacements, stiffness and disc bulge were compared with the literature. The properties derived for the interface elements were stiffer than those for the AF tissue. this is in agreement with in vitro studies that have examined the mechanisms by which the lamellae fail prior to the interlamellar interaction (Veres, Spine, 2010). The macro-scale performance of the disc was sensitive to how the interlamellar interactions were modelled. Disc stiffness reduced by 7.1% between the homogenous and frictionless models. Use of the interface model improved the agreement with the in vitro performance of the disc: 5.8% error was recorded for disc stiffness and 2.1% error for disc bulge. The mechanics of the lamellae within the AF changed significantly between the frictionless and interface models. The relative displacement of adjacent lamellae was reduced by 15% between the frictionless and interface models. This study shows that the representation of the lamina structure of the AF affects the mechanics of the whole disc. Discrepancies in the modelling of interlamellar mechanics could have a significant effect on the interpretation of several important aspects of the biomechanics of the IVD.METHODS
RESULTS & CONCLUSIONS
Periprosthetic femoral fractures can occur as a complication of total hip arthroplasty and are often challenging to treat as the mechanical scenario is influenced by the presence of the metal prosthesis within the bone. This research focuses on finding the optimum fixation for transverse, Vancouver type B1 periprosthetic fractures, stabilised using locking plates and secured using screws. The aim of this study was to experimentally validate a computer model of a human femur, develop that model to represent a periprosthetic femoral fracture fixation and show how the model could be used to indicate differences between plating techniques. In the first development stage, both a laboratory model and a finite element model were developed to evaluate the mechanical behaviour of an intact composite femur under axial loading. Axial strains were recorded along the medial length of the femur in both cases and compared to provide validation for the computational model predications. The computational intact femur model was then modified to include a cemented total hip replacement, and further adapted to include a periprosthetic fracture stabilised using a locking plate, with unicortical screws above, and bicortical screws below the transverse fracture. For the intact femur case, the experimental and computational strain patterns correlated well with an average difference of 16%. Following the inclusion of the stem, there was a reduction in the strain in the region of the prosthesis reducing by an average of 45%. There was also a large increase in bulk stiffness with the introduction of the prosthesis. When the fracture and plate fixation were included, there was little difference in the proximal strain where the stem dominated, and the strains in the distal region were found to be highly sensitive to the distribution of the screws. The results of this study indicate that screw configuration is an important factor in periprosthetic fracture fixation. A laboratory model of the periprosthetic facture case is now under development to further validate the computational models and the two approaches will then be used to determine optimum fixation methods for a range of clinical scenarios.
In selected patients in-cement revision of the total hip arthroplasty components is an attractive option. Recommended roughening of the primary mantle surface remains controversial. Aim of the study was to investigate the influence of the cement surface roughening on the strength of bilaminar cement interface. Flat, laboratory model of bilaminar cement interface was used. Prior to its creation, modeled primary mantle surface was machined to the roughness of either smooth surface observed after removal of a highly polished stem (Ra=200nm) or that following roughening (Ra=5μm). Two viscosities of interfering fluids (water and bone marrow) were also used. 6 variants (smooth or rough, both stained with water, bone marrow or with no fluid) with 7 repeats were exposed to single shear to failure. No significant difference in resistance to shear was observed between the groups with dry smooth (16.82MPa) and rough surfaces (16.96MPa), and those stained with large volume of low viscosity fluid. In the presence of water, roughening did not significantly influence the interface (smooth – 17.04MPa and rough – 16.25MPa respectively). In the smooth variant with large volume of viscous fluid, ultimate stress value dropped to 5.53MPa, and 9.87MPa in the roughened group with the same amount of viscous fluid (p<
0.05). Extra roughening may offer some benefit when performing in-cement revision in the presence of large volume of viscous fluid only though in-cement revision would not be then recommended. In the presence of low viscosity fluids (blood, irrigation fluid) benefit of roughening is dubious.
During hip revision removal of old cement mantle is a major problem. In cases of satisfactory bond between cement mantle and the underlying bone, cementing the revision stem into the old mantle is regarded as a highly attractive option. The aim was the analysis of the shearing strength of the interface between two layers of poly-methylmethacrylate cement in the presence of fluid. A laboratory, two-dimensional model of the interface was used. Effect of different viscosity fluids and volumes on its strength was checked. 6 variants (control monoblock, dry surface, surface stained with small or large volume of water or highly viscous fluid) containing 7 repeats were exposed to a single shearing stress to failure. Large volume of viscous fluid prevented bonding completely in two cases and significantly weakened the other samples showing mean failure stress of 5.53 MPa. This was significantly lower compared with control monoblock (19.8MPa), dry surface variant (16.9MPa) and the stain with small amount high viscosity fluid (16.01MPa). Interestingly, presence of a large volume of low viscosity fluid did not significantly reduce resistance to shear stress (17.05MPa). In all but large volume of viscous fluid variants, the failure occurred away from the interface between two cement layers. Large amount of viscous fluid weakened significantly this interface. If such a viscous fluid could be eliminated by copious water irrigation it is likely that strength of the cement-cement bond will be maintained. Our observations suggest that cement-in-cement technique seems to be biomechanically acceptable
The mechanical performance of the cement-in-cement interface in revision surgery has not been fully investigated. The quantitative effect posed by interstitial fluids and roughening of the primary mantle remains unclear. We have analysed the strength of the bilaminar cement-bone interface after exposure of the surface of the primary mantle to roughening and fluid interference. The end surfaces of cylindrical blocks of cement were machined smooth (Ra = 200 nm) or rough (Ra = 5 μm) and exposed to either different volumes of water and carboxymethylcellulose (a bone-marrow equivalent) or left dry. Secondary blocks were cast against the modelled surface. Monoblocks of cement were used as a control group. The porosity of the samples was investigated using micro-CT. Samples were exposed to a single shearing force to failure. The mean failure load of the monoblock control was 5.63 kN (95% confidence interval (CI) 5.17 to 6.08) with an estimated shear strength of 36 MPa. When small volumes of any fluid or large volumes were used, the respective values fell between 4.66 kN and 4.84 kN with no significant difference irrespective of roughening (p >
0.05). Large volumes of carboxymethylcellulose significantly weakened the interface. Roughening in this group significantly increased the strength with failure loads of 2.80 kN (95% CI 2.37 to 3.21) compared with 0.86 kN (95% CI 0.43 to 1.27) in the smooth variant. Roughening of the primary mantle may not therefore be as crucial as has been previously thought in clinically relevant circumstances.
6 variants (control monoblock, dry surface, surface stained with small or large volume of water or highly viscous fluid) containing 7 repeats were exposed to a single shearing stress to failure at the speed of 1mm/min (Autograph AGS, Shimadzu, Japan). Results were analyzed using 1-way ANOVA with post-hoc analysis (equal N HSD) and power calculations.
Similar relations were observed when strain at failure and toughness were analyzed.
Percutaneous vertebroplasty (PVP) is an emerging interventional technique for treatment of vertebral compression fractures. Bone cement is introduced to mechanically augment fracture and pain relief is almost immediate. Recent clinical and biomechanical studies have outlined the phenomenon of fractures occurring in adjacent vertebrae following PVP [ Most biomechanical studies adopt a single vertebral body as a model for PVP analysis. With this approach it is not possible to determine the effect of load distribution on adjacent structures. Where multi-segment vertebrae have been used there is little documentation of the fracture characteristics produced or their repeatability. The purpose of this study was to develop a 3-vertebra model for the biomechanical analysis of PVP. The particular focus was on developing a robust technique for generating repeatable level of fracture severity from specimen to specimen. An alignment device was developed to fit into standard materials testing machine, which allowed constant axial compression without causing lateral bending or flexion-extension of the specimen’s ends. Porcine 3-segment specimens (T8-L2) were mechanically compressed to failure at a rate of 5mm/min applied vertically at a distance of 35% to the anterior edge of the specimen’s anterior-posterior length. During the test load-displacement data was displayed in real time on a PC. In order to generate uniform fractures, a protocol was devised in which the specimens were compressed for a further 6mm after initial yield point. After the initial fracture the segments were augmented with 3ml of PMMA cement injected through each pedicle and then recompressed. The fracture characteristics generated under these conditions were analysed using quantitative microcomputer tomogragy (μCT). μCT images showed that fractures were generated in the central vertebra, with some propagation towards adjacent vertebra. The results support the use of a 3-segment specimen as a better representation for PVP analysis. The method will enables the load shift and fracture progression on either side of the augmented vertebra to be observed, thereby providing a more complete picture of load-bearing kinetics. Secondly, the middle, augmented motion segment remains unconstrained by platens and cement impressions; hence its anatomical boundary conditions are less compromised. Although longer segments have been shown to be more anatomically appropriate, it is difficult to apply physiologic levels of load without causing the specimen to buckle. We were able to minimise buckling effect by incorporating an alignment device to position the specimen without constraint. Given the preceding observations, the concepts of 3-segment specimen in PVP biomechanical tests provides a suitable compromise in choosing an appropriate clinical setting for in-vitro testing of biological spine specimens.
