Advertisement for orthosearch.org.uk
Results 1 - 20 of 33
Results per page:
Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 105-B, Issue SUPP_2 | Pages 32 - 32
10 Feb 2023
Jadav B
Full Access

3D printing techniques have attracted a lot of curiosity in various surgical specialties and the applications of the 3D technology have been explored in many ways including fracture models for education, customized jigs, custom implants, prosthetics etc. Often the 3D printing technology remains underutilized in potential areas due to costs and technological expertise being the perceived barriers. We have applied 3D printing technology for acetabular fracture surgeries with in-house, surgeon made models of mirrored contralateral unaffected acetabulum based on the patients’ trauma CT Scans in 9 patients. The CT Scans are processed to the print with all free-ware modeling software and relatively inexpensive printer by the surgeon and the resulting model is used as a ‘reduced fracture template’ for pre-contouring the standard pelvic reconstruction plates. This allows use of the standard surgical implants, saves time on intra-operative plate contouring, and also aids in reduction to an extent. We share through this presentation the workflow of the freeware softwares to use in order to use this surgical planning and implant preparation that may remove the perceived barriers of cost and technology from surgeons that wish to explore using 3D printing technology for acetabular fracture management and may extend applications to other regions


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 105-B, Issue SUPP_2 | Pages 109 - 109
10 Feb 2023
Sun J Tan SE Sevao J
Full Access

Anatomically specific fixation devices have become mainstream, yet there are anatomical regions and clinical conditions where no pre-contoured plates are available, such as for glenohumeral arthrodesis. In a case series of 4 glenohumeral arthrodesis patients, a consultant orthopaedic surgeon at GCUH implemented 3D printing technology to create reconstructions of each patient's shoulder girdle to pre-contour arthrodesis plates. Our aim was to quantify the cost-benefit & intra-operative time savings of this technique in glenohumeral arthrodesis. We hypothesized that the use of 3D printing for creating patient specific implants through pre-operative contouring of plates will lead to intra-operative time and cost savings by minimising time spent bending plates during surgery. This study analysed 4 patients who underwent shoulder arthrodesis by a single consultant orthopaedic surgeon at GCUH between 2017-2021. A CT-based life-size model of each patient's shoulder girdle was 3D printed using freely available computer software programs: 3D Slicer, Blender, Mesh Mixer & Cura. Once the patient's 3D model was created, plate benders were used to contour the plate pre-op, which was then sterilised prior to surgery. Arthrodesis was performed according to AO principles of fixation. The time spent pre-bending the plate using the 3D model was calculated to analyse the intra-op time and cost-saving benefits. For the 4 cases, the plate pre-bending times were 45, 40, 45 & 20 minutes (average 38.8 mins). The intra-op correction time to make small adjustments to the plate was 2 min/ case. 3 plates needed minor (3 degree) adjustment to fine-tune scapula spine contouring. 1 plate needed a 5 degree correction to fine-tune hand position. On average, the pre-bending of the plate saved approximately 38.8 mins intra-op/ case. These shorter anaesthetic and operating times equate to approximately $2586 saving/ case, given an estimate of $4000/hour of theatre costs. We conclude that pre-bending plates around 3D-printed life-size models of an individual's shoulder girdle prior to surgery results in approximately 38.8 mins time saving intra-op when used in shoulder arthrodesis. This is a viable and effective technique that will ultimately result in significant operative time and financial savings


Purpose. The purpose was to compare the accuracy of the method using 3D printing model with the method using picture archiving and communication system (PACS) images in high tibial osteotomy (HTO). Materials and methods. This study analyzed 40 patients with varus deformity and medial osteoarthritis. From 2012 to 2016, patients underwent HTO using either 3D printing model (20 knees) or method based on a PACS image (20 knees). After obtaining the correction angle for the target point (62.5% point of the mediolateral tibial plateau width), in the 3D printing method, the wedge-shaped 3D-printed model was designed with the measured angle and osteotomy section and was produced by the 3D printer. The PACS method used preoperative radiographs to shift the weight bearing axis. The accuracy of the HTO and the proportion of acceptable range (62.5 ± 5%) at each method was compared using the full-length lower limb radiographs at the sixth postoperative week. The pre and postoperative posterior tibial slope angle was also compared at each method. Results. The weight bearing line on the tibial plateau was corrected from a preoperative 21.1 ± 11.8% to a postoperative 61.6 ± 3.4% in the 3D group and from 19.5 ± 12.3% to 61.4 ± 8.0% in the PACS group. The patients in an acceptable range were more in 3D printing group (80%) than in PACS group (60%) (p=0.028). The mean of absolute difference with the target point was less in 3D printing groups (2.4 ± 2.5) than PACS group (6.2 ± 5.1) (p=0.006). The posterior tibial slope was not significantly different in 3D printing group (8.6° to 8.9°, p=0.073), whereas different in PACS group (9.9° to 10.5°, p=0.042). Conclusions. In HTO, correction based on the 3D printing method was more accurate than correction using the PACS method


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 103-B, Issue SUPP_1 | Pages 36 - 36
1 Feb 2021
Spece H Kurtz S Yu T Marcolongo M Law A
Full Access

Introduction. The ability to create patient-specific implants (PSI) at the point-of-care has become a desire for clinicians wanting to provide affordable and customized treatment. While some hospitals have already adopted extrusion-based 3D printing (fused filament fabrication; FFF) for creating non-implantable instruments, recent innovations have allowed for the printing of high-temperature implantable polymers including polyetheretherketone (PEEK). With interest in FFF PEEK implants growing, it is important to identify methods for printing favorable implant characteristics such as porosity for osseointegration. In this study, we assess the effect of porous geometry on the cell response and mechanical properties for FFF-printed porous PEEK. We also demonstrate the ability to design and print customized porous implants, specifically for a sheep tibial segmental defect model, based on CT images and using the geometry of triply periodic minimal surfaces (TPMS). Methods. Three porous constructs – a rectilinear pattern and gyroid/diamond TPMSs – were designed to mimic trabecular bone morphology and manufactured via PEEK FFF. TPMSs were designed by altering their respective equation approximations to achieve desired porous characteristics, and the meshes were solidified and shaped using a CAD workflow. Printed samples were mCT scanned to determine the resulting pore size and porosity, then seeded with pre-osteoblast cells for 7 and 14 days. Cell proliferation and alkaline phosphatase activity (ALP) were evaluated, and the samples were imaged via SEM. The structures were tested in compression, and stiffness and yield strength values were determined from resulting stress-strain plots. Roughness was determined using optical profilometry. Finally, our process of porous structure design/creation was modified to establish a proof-of-concept workflow for creating PSIs using geometry established from segmented sheep tibia CT images. Results. ALP activity measurements of the porous PEEK samples at 7 and 14 days were significantly greater than for solid controls (p < 0.001 for all three designs, 14 days). No difference between the porous geometries was found. SEM imaging revealed cells with flat, elongated morphology attached to the surface of the PEEK and into the pore openings, with filopodia and lamellipodia extensions apparent. mCT imaging showed average pore size to be 545 ± 43 µm (porosity 70%), 708 ± 64 µm (porosity 68%), and 596 ± 94 µm (porosity 69%) for the rectilinear, gyroid, and diamond structures, respectively. The average error between the theoretical and actual values was −16.3 µm (pore size) and −3.3 % (porosity). Compression testing revealed elastic moduli ranging from 210 to 268 MPa for the porous samples. Yield strengths were 6.6 ± 1.2 MPa for lattice, 14.8 ± 0.7 MPa for gyroid, and 17.1 ± 0.6 for diamond. Average roughness ranged from 0.8 to 3 µm. Finally, we demonstrated the ability to design and print a fully porous implant with the geometry of a sheep tibia segment. Assessments of implant geometrical accuracy and mechanical performance are ongoing. Discussion. We created porous PEEK with TPMS geometries via FFF and demonstrated a positive cellular response and mechanical characteristics similar to trabecular bone. Our work offers an innovative approach for advancing point-of-care 3D printing and PSI creation


Introduction. The ability to manufacture implants at the point-of-care has become a desire for clinicians wanting to provide efficient patient-specific treatment. While some hospitals have adopted extrusion-based 3D printing (fused filament fabrication; FFF) for creating non-implantable instruments with low-temperature plastics, recent innovations have allowed for the printing of high-temperature polymers such as polyetheretherketone (PEEK). Due to its low modulus of elasticity, high yield strength, and radiolucency, PEEK is an attractive biomaterial for implantable devices. Though concerns exist regarding PEEK for orthopaedic implants due to its bioinertness, the creation of porous networks has shown promising results for bone ingrowth. In this study, we endeavor to manufacture porous PEEK constructs via clinically-used FFF. We assess the effect of porous geometry on cell response and hypothesize that porous PEEK will exhibit greater preosteoblast viability and activity compared to solid PEEK. The work represents an innovative approach to advancing point-of-care 3D printing, cementless fixation for total joint arthroplasty, and additional applications typically reserved for porous metal. Methods. Three porous constructs – a rectilinear pattern and two triply period minimal surface (TPMSs) - were designed to mimic the morphology of trabecular bone. The structures, along with solid PEEK samples for use as a control, were manufactured via FFF using PEEK. The samples were mCT scanned to determine the resulting pore size and porosity. The PEEK constructs were then seeded with pre-osteoblast cells for 7 and 14 days. Cell proliferation and alkaline phosphatase activity (ALP) were evaluated at each time point, and the samples were imaged via SEM. Results. mCT imaging showed the pores in the PEEK constructs to be open and interconnected. The average pore size was 535 ± 92 µm for the rectilinear, 484 ± 237 µm for the diamond, and 669 ± 216 µm for the gyroid. Porosity was 71% for the rectilinear, 76% for the diamond, and 68% for the gyroid. The average error between the theoretical and actual values was −37.3 µm for pore size and −2.3 % for porosity. Normalized ALP activity of the three porous PEEK samples at 7 days were found to be significantly greater than the solid sample (p < 0.05 rectilinear, p < 0.005 gyroid, p < 0.001 diamond). At 14 days, the same relationships were observed (p < 0.001 for all three designs). No difference between the three geometries was found. SEM imaging revealed cells with flat, elongated morphology attached to the surface of the PEEK. The 14-day samples appeared to have proliferated well and spread along the PEEK pores. Extensions of filopodia and lamellipodia were observed along with large blankets of cells covering the PEEK surface. Discussion. We demonstrated the ability of FFF printed porous PEEK surfaces to promote cellular processes necessary for bone-implant fixation. While all porous structures showed promising results, more investigation into their material characteristics and osteogenic potential are necessary to determine which geometry may be suitable for orthopaedic use. Our work offers an innovative approach to advancing point-of-care 3D printing, cementless implant fixation, and additional applications typically reserved for porous metal


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 98-B, Issue SUPP_1 | Pages 134 - 134
1 Jan 2016
Frame M
Full Access

Many orthopaedic procedures require implants to be trialled before definitive implantation. Where this is required, the trials are provided in a set with the instrumentation. The most common scenario this is seen in during elective joint replacements. In Scotland (2007) the Scottish Executive (. http://www.sehd.scot.nhs.uk/cmo/CMO(2006)13.pdf. ) recommended and implemented individually packed orthopaedic implants for all orthopaedic sets. The premise for this was to reduce the risk of CJD contamination and fatigue of implants due to constant reprocessing from corrosion. During many trauma procedures determining the correct length of plate or size of implant can be challenging. Trials of trauma implants is no longer common place. Many implants are stored in closed and sealed boxes, preventing the surgeon looking at the implant prior to opening and contaminating the device. As a result many implants are incorrectly opened and either need reprocessed or destroyed due to infection control policy, thus implicating a cost to the NHS. With even the simplest implants costing several hundreds of pounds, this cost is a very significant waste in resources that could be deployed else where. My project was to develop a method to produce in department accurate, cheap and disposable trials for implants often used in trauma, where the original manufacturer do not offer the option of a trial off the shelf. The process had to not involve contaminating or destroying the original implant in the production of a trial. Several implants which are commonly used within Glasgow Royal Infirmary and do not have trials were identified. These implants were then CT scanned within their sealed and sterile packaging without contamination. Digital 3D surface renders of the models were created using free open source software (OsiriX, MeshLab, NetFabb). These models were then processed in to a suitable format for 3D printing using laser sintering via a cloud 3D printing bureau (. Shapeways.com. ). The implants were produced in polyamide PA220 material or in 316L stainless steel. These materials could be serialized using gamma irradiation or ethylene oxide gas. The steel models were suitable for autoclaving in the local CSSU. The implants produced were accurate facsimiles of the original implant with dimensions within 0.7mm. The implants were cost effective, an example being a rim mesh was reproduced in polyamide PA220 plastic for £3.50 and in 316L stainless steel for £15. The models were produced within 10 days of scanning. The stainless steel trials were durable and suitable for reprocessing and resterilisation. The production of durable, low cost and functional implant trials all completed in department was successful. The cost of production of each implant is so low that it would be offset if just one incorrect implant was opened during a single procedure. With some of the implants tested, the trials would have paid for themselves 100 times. This is a simple and cost saving technique that would help reduce department funding and aid patient care


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 96-B, Issue SUPP_10 | Pages 2 - 2
1 Jul 2014
Hughes A Soden P Abdulkarim A McMahon C Hurson C
Full Access

Revision hip arthroplasty requires a comprehensive appreciation of abnormal bony anatomy. Advances in radiology and manufacturing technology have made three-dimensional representation of actual osseous anatomy obtainable. These models provide a visual and tactile reproduction of the bony abnormality in question. Life size three dimensional models were manufactured from CT scans of two patients. The first had multiple previous hip arthroplasties and bilateral hip infections. There was a pelvic discontinuity on the right and a severe postero-superior deficiency on the left. The second patient had a first stage revision for infection and recurrent dislocations. Specific metal reduction protocols were used to reduce artefact. The dicom images were imported into Mimics, medical imaging processing software. The models were manufactured using the rapid prototyping process, Selective Laser Sintering (SLS). The models allowed accurate templating using the actual prosthesis templates prior to surgery. Acetabular cup size, augment and buttress sizes, as well as cage dimensions were selected, adjusted and re-sterilised in advance. This reduced operative time, blood loss and improved surgical decision making. Screw trajectory simulation was also carried out on the models, thus reducing the chance of neurovascular injury. With 3D printing technology, complex pelvic deformities can be better evaluated and can be treated with improved precision. The life size models allow accurate surgical simulation, thus improving anatomical appreciation and pre-operative planning. The accuracy and cost-effectiveness of the technique were impressive and its use should prove invaluable as a tool to aid clinical practice


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 99-B, Issue SUPP_20 | Pages 55 - 55
1 Dec 2017
Andreß S Eck U Becker C Greiner A Rubenbauer B Linhart C Weidert S
Full Access

Achieving precise open reduction and fixation of acetabular fractures by using a plate osteosynthesis is a complex procedure. Increasing availability of affordable 3D printing devices and services now allow to actually print physical models of the patient's anatomy by segmenting the patient's CT image. The data processing and printing of the model however still take too much time and usually the resulting model is rigid and doesn't allow fracture reduction on the model itself. Our proposed solution automatically detects relevant structures such as the fracture gaps and cortical bone while eliminating irrelevant structures such as debris and cancellous bone. This is done by approximating a sphere to the exterior surface of a classic segmented STL model. Stepwise, these approximated vertices are projected deeper into any structure such as the acetabular socket or fractures, following a specific set of rules. The resulting surface model finally is adapted precisely to the primary segmented model. Creating an enhanced surface reconstruction model from the primary model took a median time of 42 sec. The whole workflow from DICOM to enhanced printable 3D file took a median time of 13:25 min. The median time and material needed for the prints without the process was 32:25:36 h and 241,04 g, with the process 09:41:33 h and 65,89 g, which is 70% faster. The price of material was very low with a median of 2,18€ per case. Moreover, fracture reduction becomes possible, allowing a dry-run of the procedure and allowing more precise plate placement. Pre-contouring of osteosynthesis plates by using these 3D printouts was done for eleven patients prior to surgery. These printouts were validated to be accurate by three experiences surgeons and compared to classic segmented models regarding printing time, material cost and reduction ability. The pre-contouring of the plates was safely achievable. Our results show that improving the operative treatment with the help of enhanced 3D printed fracture models seems feasible and needs comparably little time and cost, thus making it a technique that can easily integrated into the clinical workflow


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 99-B, Issue SUPP_3 | Pages 88 - 88
1 Feb 2017
Dadia S Jaere M Sternheim A Eidelman M Brevadt MJ Gortzak Y Cobb J
Full Access

Background. Dislocation is a common complication after proximal and total femur prosthesis reconstruction for primary bone sarcoma patients. Expandable prosthesis in children puts an additional challenge due to the lengthening process. Hip stability is impaired due to multiple factors: Resection of the hip stabilizers as part of the sarcoma resection: forces acts on the hip during the lengthening; and mismatch of native growing acetabulum to the metal femoral head. Surgical solutions described in literature are various with reported low rates of success. Objective. Assess a novel 3D surgical planning technology by use of 3D models (computerized and physical), 3D planning, and Patient Specific Instruments (PSI) in supporting correction of young children suffering from hip instability after expandable prosthesis reconstruction following proximal femur resection. This innovative technology creates a new dimension of visualization and customization, and could improve understanding of this complex problem and facilitate the surgical decision making and procedure. Method. Two children, both patients with Ewing Sarcoma of the left proximal femur stage-IIB, ages 3/5 years at diagnosis, were treated with conventional chemotherapy followed by proximal femur resection. Both were reconstructed with expandable prosthesis (one at resection and other 4 years after resection). Hip migration developed gradually during lengthening process in the 24m follow up period. 3D software (Mimics, Materialise, Belgium) were used to make computerized 3D models of patients' pelvises. These were used to 3D print 1:1 physical models. Custom 3D planning software (MSk Lab, Imperial College London) allowed surgeons visualizing the anatomical status and assess of problem severity. Thereafter, osteotomies planes and the desired position of acetabular roof after reduction of hip joint were planned by the surgeons. These plans were used to generate 3D printed PSIs to guide the osteotomies during shelf and triple osteotomy surgeries. Accuracy of planning and PSIs were verified with fluoroscopy and post-op X-rays, by comparing cutting planes and post-op position of the acetabulum. Results. Surgeons reported excellent experience with the 3D models (computerized and physical). It helped them in the decision process with an improved understanding of the relationship between prosthesis head and acetabulum, a clear view of the osteophytes and bone formation surrounding the pseudoacetabulum, and osteophytes inside the native acetabulum. These osteophytes were not immediately visible on 2D CT imaging slices. Surgeons reported a good fit and PSIs' simplicity of use. The hip stability was satisfactory during surgery and in the immediate post-op period. X-ray showed a good and centered position of the hip and good levels of the osteotomies. Conclusions. 3D surgical planning and 3D printing was found to be very effective in assisting surgeons facing complex problems. In these particular cases neither CT nor MRI were able to visualize all bony formation and entrapment of prosthesis in the pseudoacetabulum. 3D visualisation can be very helpful for surgical treatment decisions, and by planning and executing surgery with the guidance of PSIs, surgeons can improve their surgical results. We believe that 3D technology and its advantages, can improve success rates of hip stability in this unique cohort of patients


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 100-B, Issue SUPP_10 | Pages 68 - 68
1 Jun 2018
Gehrke T
Full Access

The treatment of extensive bone loss and massive acetabular defects is a challenging procedure, especially in cases with concomitant pelvic discontinuity (PD). Pelvic discontinuity describes the separation of the ilium proximally from the ischio-pubic region distally. The appropriate treatment strategy is to restore a stable continuity between the ischium and the ilium to reconstruct the anatomical hip center. Several treatment options such as antiprotrusio cages, metal augments, reconstruction cages with screw fixation, structural allograft with plating, jumbo cups, oblong cups and custom-made triflange acetabular components have been described as possible treatment options. Cage and/or ring constructs or acetabular allograft are commonly used techniques with unsatisfactory results and high failure rates. More favorable results have been presented with custom triflange acetabular components (CTAC), although the results are still unsatisfactory. Three-dimensional printing technology (3DP) has already become part of the surgical practice. In this context, preliminary clinical and radiological results using a 3D-printed custom acetabular component in the management of extensive acetabular defects are presented. The overall complication rate was 33.3 %. In one out of 15 patients (6.6 %), implant-associated complication occurred revealing an overall implant-associated survival rate of 93.3%. The 3D-printed custom acetabular component suggests a promising future, although the manufacturing process has high costs and the complication rate is still high.


Background

It is technically challenging to restore hip rotation center exactly in total hip arthroplasty (THA) for patients with end-stage osteoarthritis secondary to developmental dysplasia of the hip (DDH) due to the complicated acetabular morphology changes. In this study, we developed a new method to restore hip rotation center exactly and rapidly in THA with the assistance of three dimensional (3-D) printing technology.

Methods

Seventeen patients (21 hips) with end-stage osteoarthritis secondary to DDH who underwent THA were included in this study. Simulated operations were performed on 3-D printed hip models for preoperative planning. The Harris fossa and acetabular notches were recognized and restored to locate acetabular center. The agreement on the size of acetabular cup and bone defect between simulated operations and actual operations were analyzed. Clinical and radiographic outcomes were recorded and evaluated.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 102-B, Issue SUPP_8 | Pages 65 - 65
1 Aug 2020
Ekhtiari S Shah A Levesque J Williams D Yan J Thornley P
Full Access

Three-dimensional (3D) printing has become more frequently used in surgical specialties in recent years. Orthopaedic surgery is particularly well-suited to 3D printing applications, and thus has seen a variety of uses for this technology. These uses include pre-operative planning, patient-specific instrumentation (PSI), and patient-specific implant production. As with any new technology, it is important to assess the clinical impact, if any, of three-dimensional printing. The purpose of this review was to answer the following questions: . What are the current clinical uses of 3D printing in orthopaedic surgery?. Does the use of 3D printing have an effect on peri-operative outcomes?. Four electronic databases (Embase, MEDLINE, PubMed, Web of Science) were searched for Articles discussing clinical applications of 3D printing in orthopaedics up to November 13, 2018. Titles, abstracts, and full texts were screened in duplicate and data was abstracted. Descriptive analysis was performed for all studies. A meta-analysis was performed among eligible studies to compare estimated blood loss (EBL), operative time, and fluoroscopy use between 3D printing cases and controls. Study quality was assessed using the Methodological Index for Non-Randomized Studies (MINORS) criteria for non-randomized studies and the Cochrane Risk of Bias Tool for randomized controlled trials (RCTs). This review was prospectively registered on PROSPERO (Registration ID: CRD42018099144). One-hundred and eight studies were included, published between 2012 and 2018. A total of 2328 patients were included in these studies, and 1558 patients were treated using 3D printing technology. The mean age of patients, where reported, was 47 years old (range 3 to 90). Three-dimensional printing was most commonly reported in trauma (N = 41) and oncology (N = 22). Pre-operative planning was the most common use of 3D printing (N = 63), followed by final implants (N = 32) and PSI (N = 22). Titanium was the most commonly used 3D printing material (16 studies, 27.1%). A wide range of costs were reported for 3D printing applications, ranging from “less than $10” to $20,000. The mean MINORS score for non-randomized studies was 8.3/16 for non-comparative studies (N = 78), and 17.7/24 for non-randomized comparative studies (N = 19). Among RCTs, the most commonly identified sources of bias were for performance and detection biases. Three-dimensional printing resulted in a statistically significant decrease in mean operative time (−15.6 mins, p < .00001), mean EBL (−35.9 mL, p<.00001), and mean fluoroscopy shots (−3.5 shots, p < .00001) in 3D printing patients compared to controls. The uses of 3D printing in orthopaedic surgery are growing rapidly, with its use being most common in trauma and oncology. Pre-operative planning is the most common use of 3D printing in orthopaedics. The use of 3D printing significantly reduces EBL, operative time, and fluoroscopy use compared to controls. Future research is needed to confirm and clarify the magnitude of these effects


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 103-B, Issue SUPP_1 | Pages 12 - 12
1 Feb 2021
Pianigiani S Verga R
Full Access

A common location for radius fracture is the proximal radial head. With the arm in neutral position, the fracture usually happens in the anterolateral quadrant (Lacheta et al., 2019). If traditional surgeries are not enough to induce bone stabilization and vascularization, or the fracture can be defined grade III or grade IV (Mason classification), a radial head prosthesis can be the optimal compromise between bone saving and recovering the “terrible triad”. A commercially available design of radial head prosthesis such as Antea (Adler Ortho, Milan, Italy) is characterized by flexibility in selecting the best matching size for patients and induced osteointegration thanks to the Ti-Por. ®. radial stem realized by 3D printing with laser technique (Figure 1). As demonstrated, Ti-Por. ®. push-out resistance increased 45% between 8 −12 weeks after implantation, hence confirming the ideal bone-osteointegration. Additional features of Antea are: bipolarity, modularity, TiN coating, radiolucency, hypoallergenic, 10° self-aligning. The osteointegration is of paramount importance for radius, in fact the literature is unfortunately reporting several clinical cases for which the fracture of the prosthesis happened after bone-resorption. Even if related to an uncommon activity, the combination of mechanical resistance provided by the prosthesis and the stabilization due to the osteointegration should cover also accidental movements. Based upon Lacheta et al. (2019), after axial compression-load until radii failure, all native specimens survived a compression-load of 500N, while the failure happened for a mean compression force of 2560N. The aim of this research study was to test the mechanical resistance of a radial head prosthesis obtained by 3D printing. In detail, a finite element analysis (FEA) was used to understand the mechanical resistance of the core of the prosthesis and the potential bone fracture induced in the radius with simulated bone- resorption (Figure 2a). The critical level was estimated at the height for which the thickness of the core is the minimum (Figure 2b). Considered boundary conditions:. - Full-length prosthesis plus radius out of the cement block equal to 60mm (Figure 2a);. - Bone inside the cement equal to 60mm (Figure 2b);. - Load inclined 10° epiphysiary component (Figure 2c);. - Radius with physiological or osteoporotic bone conditions;. - Load (concentrated in the sphere simulating full transmission from the articulation) of 500N or 1300N or 2560N. Figure 3 shows the results in terms of maximum stress on the core of the prosthesis and the risk of fracture (Schileo et al., 2008). According to the obtained results, the radial head prosthesis shows promising mechanical resistance despite of the simulated bone-resorption for all applied loads except for 2560N. The estimated mechanical limit for the material in use is 200MPa. The risk of fracture is in agreement with the experimental findings (Lacheta et al. (2019)), in fact bone starts to fail for the minimum reported failure load, but only for osteoporotic conditions. The presented FEA aimed at investigating the behavior of a femoral head prostheses made by 3D printing with simulated bone-resorption. The prosthesis shows to be a skilled solution even during accidental loads. For any figures or tables, please contact the authors directly


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 105-B, Issue SUPP_2 | Pages 52 - 52
10 Feb 2023
Di Bella C
Full Access

3D printing and Bioprinting technologies are becoming increasingly popular in surgery to provide a solution for the regeneration of healthy tissues. The aim of our project is the regeneration of articular cartilage via bioprinting means, to manage isolated chondral defects. Chrondrogenic hydrogel (chondrogel: GelMa + TGF-b3 and BMP6) was prepared and sterilised in our lab following our standard protocols. Human adipose-derived mesenchymal stem cells were harvested from the infrapatellar fat pad of patients undergoing total knee joint replacements and incorporated in the hydrogel according to our published protocols. The chondrogenic properties of the chondrogel have been tested (histology, immunohistochemistry, PCR, immunofluorescence, gene analysis and 2. nd. harmonic generation microscopy) in vitro and in an ex-vivo model of human articular defect and compared with standard culture systems where the growth factors are added to the media at repeated intervals. The in-vitro analysis showed that the formation of hyaline cartilage pellet was comparable between the two strategies, with a similar metabolic activity of the cells. These results have been confirmed in the ex-vivo model: hyaline-like cartilage was observed within the chondral defect in both the chondrogel group and the control group after 28 days in culture. The use of bioprinting techniques in vivo requires the ability of stem cells to access growth factors directly in the environment they are in, as opposed to in vitro techniques where these factors are provided externally at recurrent intervals. This study showed the successful strategy of incorporating chondrogenic growth factors for the formation of hyaline-like cartilage in vitro and in an ex-vivo model of chondral loss. The incorporation of chondrogenic growth factors in a hydrogel is a possible strategy for articular cartilage regeneration


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 105-B, Issue SUPP_3 | Pages 93 - 93
23 Feb 2023
Thai T
Full Access

Conventional fracture courses utilise prefabricated sawbones that are not realistic or patient specific. The aim of this study is to determine the feasibility of creating 3D fracture models and utilising them in fracture courses to teach surgical technique. We selected an AO type 2R3C2 fracture that underwent open reduction internal fixation. De-identified CT scan images were converted to a stereolithography (STL) format. This was then processed using Computer Aided Design (CAD) to create a virtual 3D model. The model was 3D printed using a combination of standard thermoplastic polymer (STP) and a porous filler to create a realistic cortical and cancellous bone. A case-based sawbone workshop was organised for residents, unaccredited registrars, and orthopaedic trainees comparing the fracture model with a prefabricated T-split distal radius fracture. Pre-operative images aided discussion of fixation, and post-operative x-rays allowed comparison between the participants fixation. Participants were provided with identical reduction tools. We created a questionnaire for participants to rate their satisfaction and experience using a Likert scale. The 3D printed fracture model aided understanding and appreciation of the fracture pattern and key fragments amongst residents and unaccredited trainees. Real case-based models provided a superior learning experience and environment to aid teaching. The generic sawbone provided easier drilling and inserting of screws. Preliminary results show that the cost of 3D printing can be comparable to generic sawbones. It is feasible to create a fracture model with a real bone feel. Further research and development is required to determine the optimum material to use for a more realistic feel. The use of 3D printed fracture models is feasible and provides an alternative to generic sawbone fracture models in providing surgical training to residents


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 105-B, Issue SUPP_3 | Pages 98 - 98
23 Feb 2023
Woodfield T Shum J Tredinnick S Gadomski B Fernandez J McGilvray K Seim H Nelson B Puttlitz C Easley J Hooper G
Full Access

Introduction: The mechanobiology and response of bone formation to strain under physiological loading is well established, however investigation into exceedingly soft scaffolds relative to cancellous bone is limited. In this study we designed and 3D printed mechanically-optimised low-stiffness implants, targeting specific strain ranges inducing bone formation and assessed their biological performance in a pre-clinical in vivo load-bearing tibial tuberosity advancement (TTA) model. The TTA model provides an attractive pre-clinical framework to investigate implant osseointegration within an uneven loading environment due to the dominating patellar tendon force. A knee finite element model from ovine CT data was developed to determine physiological target strains from simulated TTA surgery. We 3D printed low-stiffness Ti wedge osteotomy implants with homogeneous stiffness of 0.8 GPa (Ti1), 0.6 GPa (Ti2) and a locally-optimised design with a 0.3 GPa cortex and soft 0.1 GPa core (Ti3), for implantation in a 12-week ovine tibial advancement osteotomy (9mm). We quantitatively assessed bone fusion, bone area, mineral apposition rate and bone formation rate. Optimised Ti3 implants exhibited evenly high strains throughout, despite uneven wedge osteotomy loading. We demonstrated that higher strains above 3.75%, led to greater bone formation. Histomorphometry showed uniform bone ingrowthin optimised Ti3 compared to homogeneous designs (Ti1 and Ti2), and greater bone-implant contact. The greatest bone formation scores were seen in Ti3, followed by Ti2 and Ti1. Results from our study indicate lower stiffness and higher strain ranges than normally achieved in Ti scaffolds stimulate early bone formation. By accounting for loading environments through rational design, implants can be optimised to improve uniform osseointegration. Design and 3D printing of exceedingly soft titanium orthopaedic implants enhance strain induced bone formation and have significant importance in future implant design for knee, hip arthroplasty and treatment of large load-bearing bone defects


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 105-B, Issue SUPP_3 | Pages 85 - 85
23 Feb 2023
Flynn S Lemoine M Boland F O'Brien F O'Byrne J
Full Access

Restoration a joint's articular surface following degenerative or traumatic pathology to the osteochondral unit pose a significant challenge. Recent advances have shown the utility of collagen-based scaffolds in the regeneration of osteochondral tissue. To provide these collagen scaffolds with the appropriate superstructure novel techniques in 3D printing have been investigated. This study investigates the use of polyɛ-caprolactone (PCL) collagen scaffolds in a porcine cadaveric model to establish the stability of the biomaterial once implanted. This study was performed in a porcine cadaveric knee model. 8mm defects were created in the medial femoral trochlea and repaired with a PCL collagen scaffold. Scaffolds were secured by one of three designs; Press Fit (PF), Press Fit with Rings (PFR), Press Fit with Fibrin Glue (PFFG). Mobilisation was simulated by mounting the pig legs on a continuous passive motion (CPM) machine for either 50 or 500 cycles. Biomechanical tensile testing was performed to examine the force required to displace the scaffold. 18 legs were used (6 PF, 6 PFR, 6 PFFG). Fixation remained intact in 17 of the cohort (94%). None of the PF or PFFG scaffolds displaced after CPM cycling. Mean peak forces required to displace the scaffold were highest in the PFFG group (3.173 Newtons, Standard deviation = 1.392N). The lowest peak forces were observed in the PFR group (0.871N, SD = 0.412N), while mean peak force observed in the PF group was 2.436N (SD = 0.768). There was a significant difference between PFFG and PFR (p = 0.005). There was no statistical significance in the relationship between the other groups. PCL reinforcement of collagen scaffolds provide an innovative solution for improving stiffness of the construct, allowing easier handling for the surgeon. Increasing the stiffness of the scaffold also allows press fit solutions for reliable fixation. Press fit PCL collagen scaffolds with and without fibrin glue provide dependable stability. Tensile testing provides an objective analysis of scaffold fixation. Further investigation of PCL collagen scaffolds in a live animal model to establish quality of osteochondral tissue regeneration are required


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 94-B, Issue SUPP_XXXIV | Pages 20 - 20
1 Jul 2012
Frame M Huntley J
Full Access

3D printing an additive manufacturing technique, allowing for rapid prototyping in many industries. To date, medical applications have generally been within a research or industry environment, as the costs (expertise, software and equipment) have been prohibitive. We have established a means by which 3D printing of bones can be achieved quickly, cost-effectively and accurately from standard computer tomography (CT) digital imaging and communications in medicine (DICOM) data. CT DICOM data of a malunited forearm fracture were manipulated using open-source software (no cost) and a 3D model was produced by selective-laser-sintering. The entire process took 7 days (total cost £77). This process and the resultant model were then assessed for overall accuracy. This sequential methodology provides ready and economical access to a technology that is valuable for preoperative templating/rehearsal in complex 3D reconstructive cases


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 99-B, Issue SUPP_6 | Pages 5 - 5
1 Mar 2017
Siegler S Belvedere C Toy J Ensini A Leardini A
Full Access

Background. Total Ankle Replacement (TAR) has become a common surgical procedure for severe Osteoarthritis of the ankle. Unlike hip and knee, current TARs still suffer from high failure rates. A key reason could be their non-anatomical surface geometry design, which may produce unnatural motion and load-transfer characteristics. Current TARs have articular surfaces that are either cylindrical or truncated cone surfaces following the Inman truncated cone concept from more than 60 years ago [1]. Our recent study demonstrated, that the surfaces of the ankle can be approximated by a Saddle-shaped, Skewed, truncated Cone with its apex directed Laterally (SSCL) [2]. This is significantly different than the surface geometry used in current TAR systems. The goal of this study was to develop and test the reliability of an in vitro procedure to investigate the effect of different joint surface morphologies on the kinematics of the ankle and to use it to compare the effect of different joint surface morphologies on the 3D kinematics of the ankle complex. Methodology. The study was conducted on ten cadaver ankle specimens. Image processing software (Analyze Direct. TM. ) was used to obtain 3D renderings of the articulating bones. The 3D bone models were then introduced into engineering design software packages (, Geomagic. TM. and Inventor. TM. ) to produce a set of four custom-fit virtual articular surfaces for each specimen: 1. Exact replica of the natural surfaces; 2. cylindrical; 3. truncated cone with apex oriented medially according to Inman's postulate; and 4. SSCL. The virtual TAR implants were exported to a 3D printing software and 3D physical models of each implant was produced in PLA using 3D printing (Figure 1). The intact cadaver was tested first in a specially design loading and measuring system [3] in which external moments were applied across the ankle in the three planes of motion and the resulting motion was measured through a surgical navigation system (Figure 1). Each of the four customized implant sets were then surgically introduced one at a time and the test was repeated. From the results, the ankle, subtalar and complex kinematics could be compared to that of the intact natural joint. Results and Conclusions. 1. Replacing the natural ankle joint surfaces by artificial exact replicas do not significantly affect the kinematic characteristics thus establishing good reliability of the experimental technique. This high reliability is an important finding proving that the combined factors involved in the process, such as replacing the natural surfaces with artificial replicas and the overall surgical procedure, do not significantly affect the kinematic characteristics of the ankle joint; 2. The SSCL implant produces close to intact joint kinematics (Figure 3), 3. The SSCL produces closer to normal kinematics then TARs with either cylindrical surfaces or those representing a symmetric truncated cone with apex oriented medially (Figure 3). For any figures or tables, please contact authors directly (see Info & Metrics tab above).


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 105-B, Issue SUPP_10 | Pages 38 - 38
1 Jun 2023
Hrycaiczuk A Biddlestone J Rooney B Mahendra A Fairbairn N Jamal B
Full Access

Introduction. A significant burden of disease exists with respect to critical sized bone defects; outcomes are unpredictable and often poor. There is no absolute agreement on what constitutes a “critically-sized” bone defect however it is widely considered as one that would not heal spontaneously despite surgical stabilisation, thus requiring re-operation. The aetiology of such defects is varied. High-energy trauma with soft tissue loss and periosteal stripping, bone infection and tumour resection all require extensive debridement and the critical-sized defects generated require careful consideration and strategic management. Current management practice of these defects lacks consensus. Existing literature tells us that tibial defects 25mm or great have a poor natural history; however, there is no universally agreed management strategy and there remains a significant evidence gap. Drawing its origins from musculoskeletal oncology, the Capanna technique describes a hybrid mode of reconstruction. Mass allograft is combined with a vascularised fibula autograft, allowing the patient to benefit from the favourable characteristics of two popular reconstruction techniques. Allograft confers initial mechanical stability with autograft contributing osteogenic, inductive and conductive capacity to encourage union. Secondarily its inherent vascularity affords the construct the ability to withstand deleterious effects of stressors such as infection that may threaten union. The strengths of this hybrid construct we believe can be used within the context of critical-sized bone defects within tibial trauma to the same success as seen within tumour reconstruction. Methodology. Utilising the Capanna technique in trauma requires modification to the original procedure. In tumour surgery pre-operative cross-sectional imaging is a pre-requisite. This allows surgeons to assess margins, plan resections and order allograft to match the defect. In trauma this is not possible. We therefore propose a two-stage approach to address critical-sized tibial defects in open fractures. After initial debridement, external fixation and soft tissue management via a combined orthoplastics approach, CT imaging is performed to assess the defect geometry, with a polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA) spacer placed at index procedure to maintain soft tissue tension, alignment and deliver local antibiotics. Once comfortable that no further debridement is required and the risk of infection is appropriate then 3D printing technology can be used to mill custom jigs. Appropriate tibial allograft is ordered based on CT measurements. A pedicled fibula graft is raised through a lateral approach. The peroneal vessels are mobilised to the tibioperoneal trunk and passed medially into the bone void. The cadaveric bone is prepared using the custom jig on the back table and posterolateral troughs made to allow insertion of the fibula, permitting some hypertrophic expansion. A separate medial incision allows attachment of the custom jig to host tibia allowing for reciprocal cuts to match the allograft. The fibula is implanted into the allograft, ensuring nil tension on the pedicle and, after docking the graft, the hybrid construct is secured with multi-planar locking plates to provide rotational stability. The medial window allows plate placement safely away from the vascular pedicle. Results. We present a 50-year-old healthy male with a Gustilo & Anderson 3B proximal tibial fracture, open posteromedially with associated shear fragment, treated using the Capanna technique. Presenting following a fall climbing additional injuries included a closed ipsilateral calcaneal and medial malleolar fracture, both treated operatively. Our patient underwent reconstruction of his tibia with the above staged technique. Two debridements were carried out due to a 48-hour delay in presentation due to remote geographical location of recovery. Debridements were carried out in accordance with BOAST guidelines; a spanning knee external fixator applied and a small area of skin loss on the proximal medial calf reconstructed with a split thickness skin graft. A revision cement spacer was inserted into the metaphyseal defect measuring 84mm. At definitive surgery the external fixator was removed and graft fixation was extended to include the intra-articular fragments. No intra-operative complications were encountered during surgeries. The patient returned to theatre on day 13 with a medial sided haematoma. 20ml of haemoserous fluid was evacuated, a DAIR procedure performed and antibiotic-loaded bioceramics applied locally. Samples grew Staphylococcus aureus and antibiotic treatment was rationalised to Co-Trimoxazole 960mg BD and Rifampicin 450mg BD. The patient has completed a six-week course of Rifampicin and continues on suppressive Co-Trimoxazole monotherapy until planned metalwork removal. There is no evidence of ongoing active infection and radiological evidence of early union. The patient is independently walking four miles to the gym daily and we believe, thus far, despite accepted complications, we have demonstrated a relative early success. Conclusions. A variety of techniques exist for the management of critical-sized bone defects within the tibia. All of these come with a variety of drawbacks and limitations. Whilst acceptance of a limb length discrepancy is one option, intercalary defects of greater than 5 to 7cm typically require reconstruction. In patients in whom fine wire fixators and distraction osteogenesis are deemed inappropriate, or are unwilling to tolerate the frequent re-operations and potential donor site morbidity of the Masqualet technique, the Capanna technique offers a novel solution. Through using tibial allograft to address the size mismatch between vascularised fibula and tibia, the possible complication of fatigue fracture of an isolated fibula autograft is potentially avoidable in patients who have high functional demands. The Capanna technique has demonstrated satisfactory results within tumour reconstruction. Papers report that by combining the structural strength of allograft with the osteoconductive and osteoinductive properties of a vascularised autograft that limb salvage rates of greater than 80% and union rates of greater than 90% are achievable. If these results can indeed be replicated in the management of critical-sized bone defects in tibial trauma we potentially have a treatment strategy that can excel over the more widely practiced current techniques