To determine the biomechanical effect of increasing scaphoid malunion and scaphoid non-union on carpal kinematics during dynamic wrist motion using an active wrist motion simulator. Seven cadaveric upper extremities underwent active wrist flexion and extension in a custom motion wrist simulator with scaphoid kinematics being captured with respect to the distal radius. A three-stage protocol of progressive simulated malunion severity was performed (intact, 10° malunion, 20° malunion) with data analyzed from 45° wrist flexion to 45° wrist extension. Scaphoid malunions were modelled by creating successive volar wedge osteotomies and fixating the resultant scaphoid fragments with 0.062 Kirshner wires. At the completion of malunion motion trials, a scaphoid non-union trial was carried out by removing surgical fixation to observe motion differences from the malunion trials. Motion of the scaphoid, lunate, capitate, and trapezium-trapezoid was recorded and analyzed using active optical trackers. Increasing scaphoid malunion severity did not significantly affect scaphoid or trapezium-trapezoid motion (p>0.05); however, it did significantly alter lunate motion (p<0.001). Increasing malunion severity resulted in progressive lunate extension across wrist motion (Intact – Mal 10: mean dif. = 7.1° ± 1.6, p<0.05; Intact – Mal 20: mean dif. = 10.2° ± 2.0, p<0.05;) although this change was not as great as the difference seen during non-union trials (native – non-union: mean dif. = 13.8° ± 3.7, p<0.05). In this in-vitro model, increasing scaphoid malunion severity was associated with progressive extension of the lunate in all wrist positions. The clinical significance of this motion change is yet to be elucidated, but this model serves as a basis for understanding the kinematic consequences of scaphoid malunion deformities.
This study examined the regional variations of cortical and cancellous bone density present in superiorly eroded glenoids. It is hypothesized that eroded regions will contain denser bone in response to localized stress. The shift in natural joint articulation may also cause bone resorption in areas opposite the erosion site. Clinical CT scans were obtained for 32 shoulders (10m/22f, mean age 72.9yrs, 56–88yrs) classified as having E2-type glenoid erosion. The glenoid was divided into four measurement regions - anterior, inferior, posterior, and superior - as well as five depth regions. Depth regions were segmented in two-millimeter increments from zero to 10 millimeters, beginning at the center of the glenoid surface. A repeated-measures multiple analysis of variance (RM-MANOVA) was performed using SPSS statistical software to look for differences and interactions between mean densities in each depth, quadrant, and between genders. A second RM-MANOVA was performed to examine effects of gender and quadrant on cortical to cancellous bone volume ratios. Significance was set at p < 0 .05. Quadrant and depth variables showed significant multivariate main effects (p 0.147 respectively). Quadrant, depth, and their interaction showed significant univariate main effects for cortical bone (p≤0.001) and cancellous bone (p < 0 .001). The lowest bone density was found to be in the inferior quadrant for cancellous bone (307±50 HU, p < 0 .001). The superior quadrant contained the highest mean density for cortical bone (895±97 HU), however it was only significantly different than in the posterior quadrant (865±97 HU, p=0.022). As for depth, it was found that cortical bone is most dense at the glenoid surface (zero to two millimeters, 892±91 HU) when compared to bone at two to eight millimeters in depth (p < 0 .02). Cancellous bone was also most dense at the surface (352±51 HU), but only compared to the eight to 10 millimeters depth (p=0.005). Cancellous bone density was found to decrease with increasing depth. For cortical-to-cancellous bone volume ratios, the inferior quadrant (0.37±0.28) had a significantly lower ratio than all other quadrants (p < 0 .001) The superoposterior region of the glenoid was found to have denser cancellous bone and a high ratio of cortical to cancellous bone, likely due to decreased formation of cancellous bone and increased formation of cortical bone, in response to localized stresses. The inferior quadrant was found to have the least dense cortical and cancellous bone, and the lowest volume of cortical bone relative to cancellous bone. Once again, this is likely due to reduction in microstrain responsible for bone adaptation via Wolff's law. The density values found in this study generally agree with the range of values found in previous studies of normal and arthritic glenoids. An important limitation of this study is the sizing of measurement regions. For a patient with a smaller glenoid, a depth measurement of two millimeters may represent a larger portion of the overall glenoid vault. Segments could be scaled for each patient based on a percentage of each individual's glenoid size.
Previous biomechanical studies of lateral collateral ligament (LCL) injuries and their surgical repair, reconstruction and rehabilitation have primarily relied on gravity effects with the arm in the varus position. The application of torsional moments to the forearm manually in the laboratory is not reproducible, hence studies to date likely do not represent forces encountered clinically. The aim of this investigation was to develop a new biomechanical testing model to quantify posterolateral stability of the elbow using an in vitro elbow motion simulator. Six cadaveric upper extremities were mounted in an elbow motion simulator in the varus position. A threaded screw was then inserted on the dorsal aspect of the proximal ulna and a weight hanger was used to suspend 400g, 600g, and 800g of weight from the screw head to allow torsional moments to be applied to the ulna. An LCL injured (LCLI) model was created by sectioning of the common extensor origin, and the LCL. Ulnohumeral rotation was recorded using an electromagnetic tracking system during simulated active and passive elbow flexion with the forearm pronated and supinated. A repeated measures analysis of variance was performed to compare elbow states (intact, LCLI, and LCLI with 400g, 600g, and 800g of weight). During active motion, there was a significant difference between different elbow states (P=.001 pronation, P=.0001 supination). Post hoc analysis showed that the addition of weights did not significantly increase the external rotation (ER) of the ulnohumeral articulation (10°±7°, P=.268 400g, 10.5°±7.1°, P=.156 600g, 11°±7.2°, P=.111 800g) compared to the LCLI state (8.4°±6.4°) with the forearm pronated. However, with the forearm supinated, the addition of 800g of weight significantly increased the ER (9.2°±5.9°, P=.038) compared to the LCLI state (5.9°±5.5°) and the addition of 400g and 600g of weights approached significance (8.2°±5.7°, P=.083 400g, 8.7°±5.9°, P=.054 600g). During passive motion, there was a significant difference between different elbow states (P=.0001 pronation, P=.0001 supination). Post hoc analysis showed that the addition of 600g and 800g but not 400g resulted in a significant increase in ER of the ulnohumeral articulation (9.3°±7.8°, P=.103 400g, 11.2°±6.2°, P=.004 600g, 12.7°±6.8°, P=.006 800g) compared to the LCLI state (3.7°±5.4°) with the forearm pronated. With the forearm supinated, the addition of 400g, 600g, and 800g significantly increased the ER (11.7°±6.7°, P=.031 400g, 13.5°±6.8°, P=.019 600g, 14.9°±6.9°, P=.024 800g) compared to the LCLI state (4.3°±6.6°). This investigation confirms a novel biomechanical testing model for studying PLRI. Moreover, it demonstrates that the application of even small amounts of torsional moment on the forearm with the arm in the varus position exacerbates the rotational instability seen with the LCL deficient elbow. The effect of torsional loading was significantly worse with the forearm supinated and during passive elbow motion. This new model allows for a more provocative testing of elbow stability after LCL repair or reconstruction. Furthermore, this model will allow for smaller sample sizes to be used while still demonstrating clinically significant differences. Future biomechanical studies evaluating LCL injuries and their repair and rehabilitation should consider using this testing protocol.
Joint hemiarthroplasty replaces one side of a synovial joint and is a viable alternative to total joint arthroplasty when one side of the joint remains healthy. Most hemiarthroplasty implants used in current clinical practice are made from stiff materials such as cobalt chrome or ceramic. The substitution of one side of a soft cartilage-on-cartilage articulation with a rigid implant often leads to damage of the opposing articular cartilage due to the resulting reductions in contact area and increases in cartilage stress. The improvement of post-operative hemiarthroplasty articular contact mechanics is of importance in advancing the performance and longevity of hemiarthroplasty. The purpose of the present study was to investigate the effect of hemiarthroplasty surface compliance on early in-vitro cartilage wear and joint contact mechanics. Cartilage wear tests were conducted using a six-station pin-on-plate apparatus. Pins were manufactured to have a hemispherical radius of curvature of 4.7 mm using either Bionate (DSM Biomedical) having varying compliances (80A [E=20MPa], 55D [E=35MPa], 75D [E=222MPa], n=6 for each), or ceramic (E=310GPa, n=5). Cartilage plugs were cored from fresh unfrozen bovine knee joints using a 20 mm hole saw and mounted in lubricant-containing chambers, with alpha calf serum diluted with phosphate buffer solution to a protein concentration of 17 g/L. The pins were loaded to 30N and given a stroke length of 10 mm for a total of 50,000 cycles at 1.2 Hz. Volumetric cartilage wear was assessed by comparing three-dimensional cartilage scans before and during wear testing. A two-way ANOVA was used for statistical analysis. To assess hemiarthroplasty joint contact mechanics, 3D finite element modelling (ABAQUS v6.12) was used to replicate the wear testing conditions. Cartilage was modeled using neo-Hookean hyper-elastic material properties. Contact area and peak contact stress were estimated. The more compliant Bionate 80A and 55D pins produced significantly less volumetric cartilage wear compared with the less compliant Bionate 75D and ceramic pins (p 0.05). In terms of joint contact mechanics, the more compliant materials (Bionate 80A and 55D) had significantly lower maximum contact stress levels compared to the less compliant Bionate 75D and ceramic pins (p < 0 .05). The results of this study show a relationship between hemiarthroplasty implant surface compliance and early in vitro cartilage wear, where the more compliant surfaces produced significantly lower amounts of cartilage wear. The results of the joint contact mechanics analysis showed that the more compliant hemiarthroplasty materials produced lower maximum cartilage contact stresses than the less compliant materials, likely related to the differences in wear observed. More compliant hemiarthroplasty surfaces may have the potential to improve post-operative cartilage contact mechanics by increasing the implant-cartilage contact area while reducing peak contact stress at the implant-cartilage interface, however, such materials must be resistant to surface fatigue and longer-term cartilage wear/damage must be assessed.
The role of anconeus in elbow stability has been a long-standing debate. Anatomical and electromyographic studies have suggested a potential role as a stabilizer. However, to our knowledge, no clinical or biomechanical studies have investigated its role in improving the stability of a lateral collateral ligament (LCL) deficient elbow. Seven cadaveric upper extremities were mounted in an elbow motion simulator in the varus position. An LCL injured model was created by sectioning of the common extensor origin, and the LCL. The anconeus tendon and its aponeurosis were sutured in a Krackow fashion and tensioned to 10N and 20N through a transosseous tunnel at its origin. Varus-valgus angles and ulnohumeral rotations were recorded using an electromagnetic tracking system during simulated active elbow flexion with the forearm pronated and supinated. During active motion, the injured model resulted in a significant increase in varus angulation (5.3°±2.9°, P=.0001 pronation, 3.5°±3.4°, P=.001 supination) and external rotation (ER) (8.6°±5.8°, P=.001 pronation, 7.1°±6.1°, P=.003 supination) of the ulnohumeral articulation compared to the control state (varus angle −2.8°±3.4° pronation, −3.3°±3.2° supination, ER angle 2.1°±5.6° pronation, 1.6°±5.8° supination). Tensioning of the anconeus significantly decreased the varus angulation (−1.2°±4.5°, P=.006 for 10N in pronation, −3.9°±4°, P=.0001 for 20N in pronation, −4.3°±4°, P=.0001 for 10N in supination, −5.3°±4.2°, P=.0001 for 20N in supination) and ER angle (2.6°±4.5°, P=.008 for 10N in pronation, 0.3°±5°, P=.0001 for 20N in pronation, 0.1°±5.3°, P=.0001 for 10N in supination, −0.8°±5.3°, P=.0001 for 20N in supination) of the injured elbow. Comparing anconeus tensioning to the control state, there was no significant difference in varus-valgus angulation except with anconeus tensioning to 20N with the forearm in supination which resulted in less varus angulation (P=1 for 10N in pronation, P=.267 for 20N in pronation, P=.604 for 10N in supination, P=.030 for 20N in supination). Although there were statistically significant differences in ulnohumeral rotation between anconeus tensioning and the control state (except with anconeus tensioning to 10N with the forearm in pronation which was not significantly different), anconeus tensioning resulted in decreased external rotation angle compared to the control state (P=1 for 10N in pronation, P=.020 for 20N in pronation, P=.033 for 10N in supination, P=.001 for 20N in supination). In the highly unstable varus elbow orientation, anconeus tensioning restores the in vitro stability of an LCL deficient elbow during simulated active motion with the forearm in both pronation and supination. Interestingly, there was a significant difference in varus-valgus angulation between 20N anconeus tensioning with the forearm supinated and the control state, with less varus angulation for the anconeus tensioning which suggests that loads less than 20N is sufficient to restore varus stability during active motion with the forearm supinated. Similarly, the significant difference observed in ulnohumeral rotation between anconeus tensioning and the control state suggests that lesser degrees of anconeus tensioning would be sufficient to restore the posterolateral instability of an LCL deficient elbow. These results may have several clinical implications such as a potential role for anconeus strengthening in managing symptomatic lateral elbow instability.
Superiorly eroded glenoids in cuff tear arthropathy represent a surgical challenge for reconstruction. The bone loss orientation and severity may influence glenoid component fixation. This computed-tomography study quantifies both the degree of erosion and orientation in superiorly eroded Favard E2 glenoids. We hypothesized that the erosion in E2 glenoids does not occur purely superiorly, rather, it is oriented in a predictable posterosuperior orientation with a largely semicircular line of erosion. Three-dimensional reconstructions of 40 shoulders with E2 glenoids (28 female, 12 male patients) at a mean age of 74 years (range, 56–88 years) were created from computed-tomography images. Point coordinates were extracted from each construct to analyze the morphologic structure. The anatomical location of the supra- and infraglenoid tubercle guided the creation of a superoinferior axis, against which the orientation angle of the erosion was measured. The direction and, thus, orientation of erosion was calculated as a vector. By placing ten point coordinates along the line of erosion and creating a circle of best fit, the radius of the circle was placed orthogonally against a chord that resulted by connecting the two outermost points along the line of erosion. To quantify the extent of curvature of the line of erosion between the paleo- and neoglenoid, the length of the radius of the circle of best fit was calculated. Individual values were compared against the mean of circle radii. The area of bony erosion (neoglenoid), was calculated as a percentage of the total glenoid area (neoglenoid + paleoglenoid). The severity of the erosion was categorized as mild (0% to 33%), moderate (34% to 66%), and severe erosion (>66%). The mean orientation angle between the vector of bony erosion and the superoinferior axis of the glenoid was 47° ± 17° (range, 14° – 74°) located in the posterosuperior quadrant of the glenoid, resulting in the average erosion being directed between the 10 and 11 o'clock position (right shoulder). In 63% of E2 cases, the line of erosion separating the paleo- and neoglenoids was more curved than the average of all bony erosions in the cohort. The mean surface area of the neoglenoid was 636 ± 247 mm2(range, 233 – 1,333 mm2) and of the paleoglenoid 311 ± 165 mm2(range, 123 – 820 mm2), revealing that, on average, the neoglenoids consume 67% of the total glenoid surface. The extent of erosion of the total cohort was subdivided into one mild (2%), 14 moderate (35%) and 25 severe (62%) cases. Using a clock-face for orientation, the average orientation of type E2 glenoid defects was directed between the 10 and 11 o'clock position in a right shoulder, corresponding to the posterosuperior glenoid quadrant. Surgeons managing patients with E2 type glenoids should be aware that a superiorly described glenoid erosion is oriented in the posterosuperior quadrant on the glenoid clock-face when viewed intra-operatively. Additionally, the line of erosion in 63% of E2 glenoids is substantially curved, having a significant effect on bone removal techniques when using commercially available augments for defect reconstruction.
Hinged elbow orthoses (HEO) are often used to allow protected motion of the unstable elbow. However, biomechanical studies have not shown HEO to improve the stability of a lateral collateral ligament (LCL) deficient elbow. This lack of effectiveness may be due to the straight hinge of current HEO designs which do not account for the native carrying angle of the elbow. The aim of this study was to determine the effectiveness of a custom-designed HEO with adjustable valgus angulation on stabilizing the LCL deficient elbow. Eight cadaveric upper extremities were mounted in an elbow motion simulator in the varus position. An LCL injured (LCLI) model was created by sectioning of the common extensor origin, and the LCL. The adjustable HEO was secured to the arm and its effect with 0°, 10°, and 20° (BR00, BR10, BR20) of valgus angulation was investigated. Varus-valgus angles and ulnohumeral rotations were recorded using an electromagnetic tracking system during simulated active elbow flexion with the forearm pronated and supinated. We examined 5 elbow states, intact, LCLI, BR00, BR10, BR20. There were significant differences in varus and ER angulation between different elbow states with the forearm both pronated and supinated (P=0 for all). The LCLI state with or without the brace resulted in significant increases in varus angulation and ER of the ulnohumeral articulation compared to the intact state (P 0.05). The difference between each of the brace angles and the LCLI state ranged from 1.1° to 2.4° for varus angulation and 0.5° to 1.6° for ER. Although there was a trend toward decreasing varus and external rotation angulation of the ulnohumeral articulation with the application of this adjustable HEO, none of the brace angles examined in this biomechanical investigation was able to fully restore the stability of the LCL deficient elbow. This lack of stabilizing effect may be due to the weight of the brace exerting unintentional varus and torsional forces on the unstable elbow. Previous investigations have shown that the varus arm position is highly unstable in the LCL deficient elbow. Our results demonstrate that application of an HEO with an adjustable carrying angle does not sufficiently stabilize the LCL deficient elbow in this highly unstable position and varus arm position should continue to be avoided in the rehabilitation programs of an LCL deficient elbow.
At present, orthopaedic surgeons utilize either CT, MRI or X-ray for imaging a joint. Unfortunately, CT and MRI are quite expensive, non weight-bearing and the orthopaedic surgeon does not receive revenue for these procedures. Although x-rays are cheaper, similar to CT scans, patients incur radiation. Also, all three of these imaging modalities are static. More recently, a new ultrasound technology has been developed that will allow a surgeon to image their patients in 3D. The objective of this study is to highlight the new opportunity for orthopaedic surgeons to use 3D ultrasound as alternative to CT, MRI and X-rays. The 3D reconstruction process utilizes statistical shape atlases in conjunction with the ultrasound RF data to build the patient anatomy in real-time. The ultrasound RF signals are acquired using a linear transducer. Raw RF data is then extracted across each scan line. The transducer is tracked using a 3D tracking system. The location and orientation for each scan line is calculated using the tracking data and known position of the tracker relative to the signal. For each scan line, a detection algorithm extracts the location on the signal of the bone boundary, if any exists. Throughout the scan process, a 3D point cloud is created for each detected bone signal. Using a statistical bone atlas for each anatomy, the patient specific surface is reconstruction by optimizing the geometry to match the point cloud. Missing regions are interpolated from the bone atlas. To validate reconstructed models output models are then compared to models generated from 3D imaging, including CT and MRI.Introduction
Methods
Altered distal radioulnar joint contact (DRUJ) mechanics are thought to cause degenerative changes in the joint following injury. Much of the current research examining DRUJ arthrokinematics focuses on the effect of joint malalignment and resultant degenerative changes. Little is known regarding native cartilage contact mechanics in the distal radioulnar joint. Moreover, current techniques used to measure joint contact rely on invasive procedures and are limited to statically loaded positions. The purpose of this study was to examine native distal radioulnar joint contact mechanics during simulated active and passive forearm rotation using a non-invasive imaging approach. Testing was performed using 8 fresh frozen cadaveric specimens (6 men: 2 women, mean age 62 years) with no CT evidence of osteoarthritis. The specimens were thawed and surgically prepared for biomechanical testing by isolating the tendons of relevant muscles involved in forearm rotation. The humerus was then rigidly secured to a wrist simulator allowing for simulated active and passive forearm rotation. Three-dimensional (3D) cartilage surface reconstructions of the distal radius and ulna were created using volumetric data acquired from computed tomography after joint disarticulation. Using optically tracked motion data and 3D surface reconstructions, the relative position of the cartilage models was rendered and used to measure DRUJ cartilage contact mechanics. The results of this study indicate that contact area was maximal in the DRUJ at 10 degrees of supination (p=0.002). There was more contact area in supination than pronation for both active (p=0.005) and passive (p=0.027) forearm rotation. There was no statistically significant difference in the size of the DRUJ contact patch when comparing analogous rotation angles for simulated active and passive forearm motion (p=0.55). The contact centroid moved 10.5±2.6 mm volar along the volar-dorsal axis during simulated active supination. Along the proximal-distal axis, the contact centroid moved 5.7±2.4 mm proximal during simulated active supination. Using the technique employed in this study, it was possible to non-invasively examine joint cartilage contact mechanics of the distal radioulnar joint while undergoing simulated, continuous active and passive forearm rotation. Overall, there were higher contact area values in supination compared with pronation, with a peak at 10 degrees of supination. The contact centroid moved volarly and proximally with supination. There was no difference in the measured cartilage contact area when comparing active and passive forearm rotation. This study gives new insight into the changes in contact patterns at the native distal radioulnar joint during simulated forearm rotation, and has implications for increasing our understanding of altered joint contact mechanics in the setting of deformity.
Distal radius fractures are the most common fracture of the upper extremity. Malunion of the distal radius is a common clinical problem after these injuries and frequently leads to pain, stiffness loss of strength and functional impairments. Currently, there is no consensus as to whether not the mal-aligned distal radius has an effect on carpal kinematics of the wrist. The purpose of this study was to examine the effect of dorsal angulation (DA) of the distal radius on midcarpal and radiocarpal joint kinematics, and their contributions to total wrist motion. A passive wrist motion simulator was used to test six fresh-frozen cadaveric upper extremities (age: 67 ± 17yrs). The specimens were amputated at mid humerus, leaving all wrist flexor and extensor tendons and ligamentous structures intact. Tone loads were applied to the wrist flexor and extensor tendons by pneumatic actuators via stainless steel cables. A previously developed distal radius implant was used to simulate native alignment and three DA deformity scenarios (DA 10 deg, 20 deg, and 30 deg). Specimens were rigidly mounted into the simulator with the elbow at 90 degrees of flexion, and guided through a full range of flexion and extension passive motion trials (∼5deg/sec). Carpal motion was captured using optical tracking; radiolunate and capitolunate joint motion was measured and evaluated. For the normally aligned radius, radiolunate joint motion predominated in flexion, contributing on average 65.4% (±3.4). While the capitolunate joint motion predominated in extension, contributing on 63.8% (±14.0). Increasing DA resulted in significant alterations in radiolunate and capitolunate joint kinematics (p<0.001). There was a reduction of contribution from the capitolunate joint to total wrist motion throughout flexion-extension, significant from 5 degrees of wrist extension to full extension (p = 0.024). Conversely, the radiolunate joint increased its contribution to motion with increasing DA; significant from 5 degrees of wrist extension to full extension as the radiolunate and capitolunate joint kinematics mirrored each other. A DA of 30 degrees resulted in an average radiolunate contribution of 72.6% ± 7.7, across the range of motion of 40 degrees of flexion to 25 degrees of extension. The results of our study for the radius in a normal anatomic alignment are consistent with prior investigators, showing the radiocarpal joint dominated flexion, and the midcarpal joint dominated extension; with an average 60/40 division in contributions for the radiocarpal in flexion and the midcarpal in extension, respectfully. As DA increased, the radiocarpal joint provided a larger contribution of motion throughout flexion and extension. This alteration in carpal kinematics with increased distal radius dorsal angulation may increase localised stresses and perhaps lead to accelerated joint wear and wrist pain in patients with malunited distal radial fractures.
Despite reverse total shoulder arthroplasty (RTSA) being primarily indicated for massive rotator cuff tears, it is often possible to repair portions of the infraspinatus and subscapularis of patients undergoing this procedure. However, there is disagreement regarding whether these tissues should be repaired, as their effects remain unclear. Therefore, we investigated the effects of rotator cuff repair and changes in humeral and glenosphere lateralisation (HLat & GLat) on deltoid and joint loading. Six shoulders were tested on an in-vitro muscle driven active motion simulator. Cuff tear arthropathy was simulated in each specimen, which was then implanted with a custom adjustable RTSA fitted with a six axis load sensor. We assessed the effects of 4 RTSA configurations (i.e. all combinations of 0&10mm of HLat & GLat) on deltoid force, joint load, and joint load angle during abduction with/out rotator cuff repair. Deltoid and joint loads recorded by the load cell are reported as a % of Body Weight (%BW). Repeated measures ANOVAs and pairwise comparisons were performed with p<0.05 indicating significance. Cuff repair interacted with HLat & GLat (p=0.005, Fig. 1) such that with no HLat, GLat increased deltoid force without cuff repair (8.1±2.1%BW, p=0.012) and this effect was significantly increased with cuff repair (12.8±3.2%BW, p=0.010). However, adding HLat mitigated this such that differences were not significant. HLat and GLat affected deltoid force regardless of cuff status (−2.5±0.7%BW, p=0.016 & +7.7±2.3%BW, p=0.016, respectively). Rotator cuff repair did significantly increase joint load (+11.9±2.1%BW, p=0.002), as did GLat (+13.3±1.5%BW, p<0.001). The increases in deltoid and joint load caused by rotator cuff repair confirm that it acts as an adductor following RTSA and increases deltoid work. Additionally, cuff repair's negative effects are exacerbated by GLat, which strengthens its adduction affect, while Hlat increases the deltoid's abduction effect thus mitigating the cuff's antagonistic effects. Cuff repair increases concavity compression within the joint; however, Hlat produces a similar effect by wrapping the deltoid around the greater tuberosity – which redirects its force – and does so without increasing the magnitude of muscle and joint loading. The long-term effects of increased joint loading due to rotator cuff repair are unknown, however, it can be postulated that it may increase implant wear, and the risk of deltoid fatigue. Therefore, RTSA implant designs which improve joint compression without increasing muscle and joint loading may be preferable to rotator cuff repair.
Wrist motion is achieved primarily via rotation at the radiocarpal and midcarpal joints. The contribution of each carpal bone to total range of motion has been previously investigated, although there is no consensus regarding the influence of each structure to global wrist motion. The objective of this comprehensive in-vitro biomechanical study was to determine the kinematics of the capitate, scaphoid and lunate during unconstrained simulated wrist flexion-extension. In addition, this study examined the effect of motion direction (i.e. flexion or extension) on the kinematics and contribution of the carpal bones. Seven fresh frozen cadaveric upper limb specimens (age: 67±18 yrs) were amputated mid-humerus, and the wrist flexors/extensors were exposed and sutured at their musculotendinous junctions. Each specimen was mounted on a wrist motion simulator in neutral forearm rotation with the elbow at 90° flexion. Passive flexion and extension motion of the wrist was simulated by moving a K-wire, inserted into the third metacarpal, through the flexion/extension motion arc at a speed of ∼5 mm/sec under muscle tone loads of 10N. Carpal kinematics were captured using optical tracking of bone fixated markers. Kinematic data was analysed from ±35° flexion/extension. Scaphoid and lunate motion differed between wrist flexion and extension, but correlated linearly (R‸2=0.99,0.97) with capitate motion. In wrist extension, the scaphoid (p=0.03) and lunate (p=0.01) extended 83±19% & 37±18% respectively relative to the capitate. In wrist flexion, the scaphoid (p=1.0) and lunate (p=0.01) flexed 95±20% and 70±12% respectively relative to the capitate. The ratio of carpal rotation to global wrist rotation decreased as the wrist moved from flexion to extension. The lunate rotates on average 46±25% less than the capitate and 35±31% less than the scaphoid during global wrist motion (p=0.01). The scaphoid rotates on average 11±19% less than the capitate during wrist flexion and extension (p=0.07). There was no difference in the contribution of carpal bone motion to global wrist motion during flexion (p=0.26) or extension (p=0.78). The capitate, lunate and scaphoid move synergistically throughout planar motions of the wrist. Our study found that both the scaphoid and lunate contributed at a greater degree during wrist flexion compared to extension, suggesting that the radiocarpal joint plays a more critical role in wrist flexion. Our results agree with previous studies demonstrating that the scaphoid and lunate do not contribute equally to wrist motion and do not function as a single unit during planar wrist motion. The large magnitude of differential rotation observed between the scaphoid and lunate may be responsible for the high incidence of scapholunate ligament injuries relative to other intercarpal ligaments. An understanding of normal carpal kinematics may assist in developing more durable wrist arthroplasty designs.
Wrist motion is achieved primarily via rotation at the radiocarpal and midcarpal joints. The contribution of each carpal bone to total range of motion has been previously investigated, although there is no consensus regarding the influence of each structure to global wrist motion. The objective of this comprehensive in-vitro biomechanical study was to determine the kinematics of the capitate, scaphoid and lunate during unconstrained simulated wrist flexion-extension. In addition, this study examined the effect of motion direction (i.e. flexion or extension) on the kinematics and contribution of the carpal bones. Seven fresh frozen cadaveric upper limb specimens (age: 67±18 yrs) were amputated mid-humerus, and the wrist flexors/extensors were exposed and sutured at their musculotendinous junctions. Each specimen was mounted on a wrist motion simulator in neutral forearm rotation with the elbow at 90° flexion. Passive flexion and extension motion of the wrist was simulated by moving a K-wire, inserted into the third metacarpal, through the flexion/extension motion arc at a speed of ∼5 mm/sec under muscle tone loads of 10N. Carpal kinematics were captured using optical tracking of bone fixated markers. Kinematic data was analysed from ±35° flexion/extension. Scaphoid and lunate motion differed between wrist flexion and extension, but correlated linearly (R^2=0.99,0.97) with capitate motion. In wrist extension, the scaphoid (p=0.03) and lunate (p=0.01) extended 83±19% & 37±18% respectively relative to the capitate. In wrist flexion, the scaphoid (p=1.0) and lunate (p=0.01) flexed 95±20% and 70±12% respectively relative to the capitate. The ratio of carpal rotation to global wrist rotation decreased as the wrist moved from flexion to extension. The lunate rotates on average 46±25% less than the capitate and 35±31% less than the scaphoid during global wrist motion (p=0.01). The scaphoid rotates on average 11±19% less than the capitate during wrist flexion and extension (p=0.07). There was no difference in the contribution of carpal bone motion to global wrist motion during flexion (p=0.26) or extension (p=0.78). The capitate, lunate and scaphoid move synergistically throughout planar motions of the wrist. Our study found that both the scaphoid and lunate contributed at a greater degree during wrist flexion compared to extension, suggesting that the radiocarpal joint plays a more critical role in wrist flexion. Our results agree with previous studies demonstrating that the scaphoid and lunate do not contribute equally to wrist motion and do not function as a single unit during planar wrist motion. The large magnitude of differential rotation observed between the scaphoid and lunate may be responsible for the high incidence of scapholunate ligament injuries relative to other intercarpal ligaments. An understanding of normal carpal kinematics may assist in developing more durable wrist arthroplasty designs.
There are a variety of sizes currently available for reverse total shoulder arthroplasty (RTSA) implant systems. Common sizing options include a smaller 36 to 38 mm or a larger 40 to 42 mm glenosphere, and are typically selected based on surgeon preference or patient size. Previous studies have only evaluated the abduction and adduction range of motion within a single plane of elevation, providing a limited view of the joint's possible range of motion. The purpose of this study was to use computer modeling to evaluate the abduction and adduction range of motion across multiple planes of elevation for a range of glenosphere sizes. Computed tomography images of four cadaveric specimens (age: 54 ± 24 years) were used to obtain the osseous anatomy to be utilised in the model. Solid-body motion studies of the RTSA models were constructed with varying glenosphere diameters of 33, 36, 39, 42, and 45 mm in Solidworks (Dassault Systems, US). The implant components were scaled, while maintaining a consistent centre of rotation. Simulations encompassing the full range of abduction and adduction were conducted for the planes of elevation between −15˚ and 135˚ at 15˚ intervals, with the motion of the humerus being constrained in neutral internal-external rotation throughout all planes. Angles of elevation were obtained utilising the humeral long axis and the RTSA centre of rotation. Statistical analysis was performed using repeated measures ANOVA. Glenosphere diameter was found to significantly affect the adduction range of motion (p=0.043), in which the largest size provided approximately 17˚ more adduction range of motion than the smallest. However, abduction range of motion was not found to be significantly affected through the alteration of glenosphere size (p=0.449). The plane of elevation was not found to significantly affect abduction or abduction (p=0.585 & p=0.225, respectively). Increasing glenosphere diameter resulted in an increased adduction range of motion when averaged across the tested planes of elevation; however the observed influence on abduction was not significant. These are similar to the trends observed in the previous single plane of elevation studies. These findings illustrate the importance of implant sizing related to range of motion. Further studies are required to determine the influence of glenosphere size on internal and external range of motion.
Shoulder arthroplasty, both primary (TSA) and reverse (RTSA), are common interventions for arthritis and cuff tear arthropathy. The effect of shoulder arthroplasty on shoulder motion is of particular interest in assessing the effectiveness of the procedure and the development and biomechanical testing of implants. A comparison of the arthroplasty shoulder to that of the non-operated contralateral shoulder provides insight into how well the reconstruction has restored natural shoulder motion. The purpose of this study was to ascertain the shoulder motion of patients who have undergone shoulder arthroplasty and to compare the motion of the reconstructed and contralateral natural sides. Eleven human subjects (70±9yrs) who had undergone total shoulder arthroplasty wore a custom instrumented shirt for the waking hours of one day. The 3D orientation of each humeral sensor was transformed with respect to the torso to allow for the calculation of humeral elevation and plane of elevation angles. Joint angles for each subject were then discretised, and the operative and contralateral normal (control) shoulders were then compared. The majority of both the arthroplasty and control shoulder elevation motions took place below 80° of elevation, totaling on average 1910±373 and 1887±312 motions per hour, respectively. Conversely, elevations greater than 80° were significantly less with occurrences totaling only 55±31 and 78±41 motions per hour for the arthroplasty and control shoulders, respectively (p<0.01). Both the arthroplasty and control shoulder were at elevations below 80° for 88±7% and 87±7% of the day, respectively. When the total motion of the arthroplasty and non-operative control shoulders were compared, no statistically significant difference was detected (p=0.8), although the non-operated side exhibited marginally more motion than the operated side, an effect which was larger at higher elevation angles (p=0.3). This study provides insight into the effects of shoulder arthroplasty on thoraco-humeral motion and compares it to the non-operative side. Interestingly, there were no significant differences measured between the arthroplasty and the control side, which may demonstrate the effectiveness of reconstruction on restoring natural shoulder motion. It is interesting to note that on average, each shoulder arthroplasty elevated above 80° approximately 55 times per hour, corresponding to just under 330,000 motions per year. Similarly, when elevations greater than 60° are extrapolated, the resulting yearly motions total approximately 1.5 million cycles (Mc), which suggests that the ‘duty cycle’ of the shoulder is similar to the hip, approximated to be between 1–2 Mc per year. Arthroplasty wear simulators should be calibrated to simulate these patterns of motion, and component design may be improved by understanding the kinematics of actual shoulder motion.
Fracture or resection of the radial head can cause unbalance and long-term functional complications in the elbow. Studies have shown that a radial head excision can change elbow kinematics and decrease elbow stability. The radial head is also important in both valgus and varus laxity and displacement. However, the effect of radial head on ulnohumeral joint load is not known. The objective of this experimental study was to compare the axial loading produced at the ulnohumeral joint during active flexion with and without a radial head resection. Ten cadaveric arms were used. Each specimen was prepared and secured in an elbow motion simulator. To simulate active flexion, the tendons of the biceps, brachialis, brachioradialis, and triceps were attached to servo motors. The elbow was moved through a full range of flexion. To quantify loads at the ulnohumeral joint, a load cell was implanted in the proximal ulna. Testing was conducted in the intact then radial head resected case, in supination in the horizontal, vertical, varus and valgus positions. When comparing the average loads during flexion, the axial ulnar load in the horizontal position was 89±29N in an intact state compared to 122±46N during radial head resection. In the vertical position, the intact state produced a 67±16N load while the resected state was 78±23N. In the varus and valgus positions, intact state resulted in loads of 57±26N and 18±3N, respectively. Conversely, with a radial head resection, varus and valus positions measured 56±23N and 54±23N loads, respectively. For both joint configurations, statistical differences were observed for all flexion angles in all arm positions during active flexion (p=0.0001). When comparing arm positions and flexion angle, statistical differences were measured between valgus, horizontal and vertical (p<0.005) except for varus position (p=0.64). Active flexion caused a variation in loads throughout flexion when comparing intact versus radial head resection. The most significant variation in ulnar loading occurred during valgus and horizontal flexion. The vertical and varus position showed little variation because the position of the arm is not affected by the loss of the radial head. However, in valgus position, the resected radial head creates a void in the joint space and, with gravity, causes greater compensatory ulnar loading. In the horizontal position, the forearm is not directly affected by gravitational pull and cannot adjust to counterbalance the resected radial head, therefore loads are localised in the ulnohumeral joint. These findings prove the importance of the radial head and that a radial head resection can overload the ulnohumeral side.
To evaluate the efficacy of using a novel button-suture construct in place of traditional screws to provide bone block fixation for the Latarjet procedure. Four paired cadaveric shoulders (n=8) were denuded, with the exception of the conjoint tendon on the coracoid, and were potted. A 15% anterior glenoid bone defect was simulated. Right and left specimens were randomised into two groups: double-screw versus quadruple-button Latarjet reconstruction techniques. A uniaxial mechanical actuator loaded the Latarjet reconstructed glenoid articular surface via a 47mm diameter metallic hemisphere. Cyclic loading between 50–200N was applied to the glenoid at a rate of 1Hz for 1000 cycles. Testing was repeated three times for conjoint tendon loads of 0N, 10N and 20N. The relative positions of three points on the inferior, central and superior edges of the coracoid bone fragment were optically tracked with respect to a glenoid coordinate system throughout testing. Screw and button constructs were compared on the basis of maximum relative displacement at these points (RINF, RCENT, RSUP). Statistical significance was assessed using a paired-samples t-test in SPSS. When conjoint tendon loading was not present the double screw and quadruple button constructs were not significantly (P>0.779) different (0N: RINF: 0.11 (0.05)mm vs. 0.12 (0.03)mm, RCENT: 0.12 (0.04)mm vs. 0.12 (0.03)mm, RSUP: 0.13 (0.04)mm vs. 0.12 (0.03)mm). Additionally, the double screw construct was not found to differ (P>0.062) from the quadruple button in terms of resultant coracoid displacement for all central and superior points, regardless of conjoint loading (10N: RCENT: 0.11 (0.03)mm vs. 0.19 (0.05)mm, RSUP: 0.11 (0.01)mm vs. 0.18 (0.04)mm; 20N: RCENT: 0.13 (0.01)mm vs. 0.30 (0.13)mm, RSUP: 0.13 (0.03)mm vs. 0.26 (0.14)mm). It was only for the inferior point with conjoint loading of 10N and 20N that the double screw construct began to produce significantly lower displacements than the quadruple button (10N: RINF: 0.11 (0.03)mm vs. 0.23 (0.05)mm, P=0.047; 20N: RINF: 0.12 (0.02)mm vs. 0.39 (0.15)mm, P=0.026). The results of the screw and button constructs when conjoint tendon loading was absent suggest that the button may be a suitable substitute to the screw when the coracoid is used as a bone block. Due to the small resultant displacements (max: screw = 0.19mm, button = 0.52mm), it is suggested that buttons may also act as a substitute to screws for Latarjet procedures, provided conjoint tendon overloading is minimised during the post-operative graft healing period. These in-vitro results support the in-vivo results of Boileau et al (2015) that demonstrated the suture-button technique to be an excellent alternative to screw fixation Latarjet, with graft healing in 91% of their subjects.
Optimal soft tissue tension maximises function following total knee arthroplasty. Excessive tension may lead to stiffness and or pain, while inadequate tension can lead to instability. Composite component thickness is a prime determinant of this soft tissue tension. The variable component thickness provided by polyethylene inserts generally allows for 2–3mm incremental change. This study analyzed the effect of 1-mm incremental changes in polyethylene thickness on soft tissue tension. Our hypothesis was that soft tissue tension would be markedly affected by increases in insert thickness. Computer assisted TKA was performed on eight cadaveric knee specimens (four pairs). The knees were passively moved through full flexion-extension range of motion, for each tibial construct thickness. Kinematics were recorded using the computer navigation software. Soft tissue tension was analyzed by measuring compartmental loads. A validated load cell instrumented tibial insert was used to measure medial and lateral compartmental loads independently. The effect of 1-mm increments in polyethylene thickness on compartmental loads was evaluated. An increase in compartmental loads was measured with increasing insert thickness. Loading in contralateral compartments showed differing behaviour, reflecting varying tension in the medial and lateral sides. Many generated loads showed a reduction after reaching a maximal level with further increase in insert thickness (seven of eight specimens), indicative of tissue failure, although there were no overt indications of failure during the procedure. With a 1-mm increase in insert thickness, six of eight specimens showed an increase in peak loads greater than 100N at some point in the testing procedure, although not always with the same shim thickness. Compartmental loads varied as a function of insert thickness. Most specimens showed signs of soft tissue “micro-failure”. The high sensitivity of compartmental loads to a 1-mm incremental increase is significant and has not been previously appreciated, especially intra-operatively. Currently available inserts with 2–3mm incremental sizes may make obtaining optimal soft tissue tension difficult. In addition to the current focus of obtaining accurate leg alignment, further computer-assisted techniques are required to address soft tissue tension.
This study examined the effect of wrist fracture deformities on the work and kinematics of forearm rotation in vitro. An osteotomy was performed on eight fresh frozen upper extremities just proximal to the distal radioulnar joint and a three-degree of freedom modular implant designed to simulate distal radius fracture deformities was secured in place. This allowed for accurate adjustment of dorsal angulation, dorsal displacement, and radial shortening. The study was divided into two parts, the first phase examining the effects of distal radius deformity and the second sectioned the TFCC and repeated the testing, reviewing the effects of a progressive soft tissue injury in conjunction with distal radius deformity. The magnitude of muscle activity required to achieve the motion, namely the work of rotation, was affected by the degree of simulated malunion and whether the TFCC was intact or sectioned. Increasing dorsal angulation caused a significant reduction in forearm pronation and supination. Once the TFCC ligaments were sectioned, the range of motion was restored to the pre-injured state for both pronation and supination. Dorsal displacement decreased the forearm range of motion significant at 10mm from native (p=0.02) and 5mm (p=0.03) for intact pronation. Radial shortening of 5mm or less had no effect on forearm rotation. However, 7.5mm of radial shortening could not be achieved in any of the specimens until the TFCC was divided. Our results reveal that a significant loss of forearm rotation can be expected if a radius fracture exceeds thirty degrees dorsal angulation or 10mm of dorsal displacement. Radial shortening greater than 7.5mm could only be achieved concomitant with a TFCC rupture. This and further study in this area, should assist clinicians in developing treatment strategies for their patients with fractures and deformities of the distal radius.
We compared the initial strength of two techniques for repair of rotator cuff tears. Eight paired cadaveric shoulders with a standardized supraspinatus defect were studied. A transosseous suture and anchor repair was conducted on each side. Specimens were tested under cyclic loading, while fixation was monitored with an optical tracking technique. Mode of failure, number of cycles and load to failure were measured for 50% (5 mm) and 100% (10 mm) loss of repair. Anchors provide improved repair strength at 50% repair loss, in comparison to sutures (p<
0.05). Strength was unaffected by bone mineral density, age and gender. The purpose of this study was to compare the initial strength of two rotator cuff repair techniques. Repair strength with anchors was superior to sutures. Strength was unaffected by bone quality. Anchors, enabling a quicker, less invasive arthroscopic repair, offer improved fixation over sutures, which are more time consuming and invasive. Eight paired shoulders with a standardized supra-spinatus defect were randomized to anchor or suture repair, and subjected to cyclic loading. Repair migration was measured using a digital camera. Failure mode, cycles and load were measured for 50% and 100% loss of repair. Results were correlated with bone mineral density, age and gender. The anchors failed at the anchor-tendon interface, whereas the sutures failed through the sutures. Mean values for 50% loss of repair were 205.6 ± 87.5 cycles and 43.8 ± 14.8 N for the sutures, and 1192.5 ± 251.7 cycles and 156.3 ± 19.9 N for the anchors (p<
0.05). The corresponding values for 100% loss of repair were 2457.5 ± 378.6 cycles and 293.8 ± 27.4 N for the sutures, and 2291.9 ± 332.9 cycles and 262.5 ± 28.0 N for the anchors (p>
0.05). These results did not correlate with bone quality. This study has demonstrated that anchors provide improved repair strength, in comparison to sutures. This may be due to the relative less deformability of the anchors. Repair strength did not correlate with bone quality. This may be attributed to each repair failing primarily through the repair construct or at the anchor-tendon interface, and not through bone.
A load cell, capable of measuring medial and lateral loads independently, was used to evaluate current methods of ligamentous balancing in total knee arthroplasty. Ten cadaveric knees were randomized with the surgeons blinded or unblinded to the load cell’s output. Before ligament resection, there were differences between medial and lateral forces (p<
0.05). Balance improved in both groups following ligamentous releases. There was a trend for superior balance (medial-lateral compressive force) with load cell feedback provided: 30°(11.1 vs. 44.4N), 60°(7.1 vs. 36.9N), and 90°(3.0 vs. 8.7N). Further in-vivo studies with this device may improve load transfer and the longevity of TKA. The purpose of this study was to employ a tibial load cell to assess current methods of ligamentous balance during total knee arthroplasty, and to determine whether the load cell can improve load distribution between the medial and lateral compartments. Current methods achieve imperfect load balance, however this may be improved with the assistance of an intra-operative load cell. Intra-operative assessment and quantification of load balance with a load cell may improve the longevity of TKA. TKA was performed on five pairs of cadaveric knees which were randomly assigned into one of two groups based upon whether the surgeons were blinded or unblinded to the load cell’s output. A validated tibial load cell, capable of measuring medial and lateral loads independently, was inserted. Compartment forces were recorded at discrete flexion angles prior to ligamentous balancing and again after soft tissue balancing with final components cemented into position. Initially, there were significant differences between the loads in the medial and lateral compartments (p<
0.05). With soft tissue release, there was improved balance. There was a trend for superior balance (medial minus lateral compressive force) in the unblinded group at 30°: 11.1N unblinded vs. 44.4N blinded, 60°: 7.1 vs. 36.9N, and 90°: 3.0 vs. 8.7N. Failure to achieve ligamentous balance results in instability and unequal load distribution. Current balancing techniques are not perfect, but appear to be improved with the use of the load cell. Further in-vitro and in-vivo studies are needed to improve the load distribution following TKA.
Quantitative measurements of load transfer through the distal radioulnar joint (DRUJ) are limited. An instrumented ulnar head prosthesis was developed to measure bending and torsion moments about the three anatomic axes of the ulna. This device has shown repeatable loading data following insertion in a cadaveric specimen during active forearm rotation trials conducted in an To develop a system to quantify A load-measuring system was developed that was easily surgically inserted, and produced repeatable loading data. The instrumented implant developed in this study will contribute to the optimization of surgical procedures and implant design parameters related to distal ulnar arthroplasty. Four pairs of strain gauges were applied to the stem of an ulnar head prosthesis to measure bending and torsion moments about the three anatomic axes of the ulna. Three ulnar heads were machined with varying eccentricities (axisymmetric, 1.5 mm offset and 3.0 mm offset). The implant was inserted in one unpreserved cadaveric upper extremity and active forearm rotation induced using a computer controlled joint simulator. Repeatability (assessed using the maximum standard deviation over 5 trials of pronation and supination) was less than 9% of the output range for all loads. Bending and torsion moments between −0.4 and 0.5 Nm, correlating to joint loads between 0 and 50 N, were measured. The measured loads followed a consistent pattern with forearm position. Higher loads were noted for the eccentric implant heads compared to the axisymmetric head, especially at the extreme ranges of rotation. Clinical interpretation of these findings is difficult since the optimal loading scenario for distal ulnar implant longevity remains unknown. Please contact author for diagrams and graphs.
To determine the relationship between forearm muscle activity and joint reaction force (JRF) in the distal radioulnar joint (DRUJ). The DRUJ reaction force is linearly related to the muscle activity of the PT and biceps, but not necessarily to the activity of the supinator and PQ. This work has implications for biomechanical modelling, implant design, fixation and rehabilitation protocols following DRUJ arthroplasty. JRFs were found to increase linearly with muscle load for all muscles simulated (biceps, pronator teres (PT), pronator quadratus (PQ), supinator) in all forearm positions tested (supination, neutral and pronation) (correlation coefficient r>
0.85, p<
0.01) with two exceptions; simulation of the PQ in the neutral position (r=−0.65, p=0.2), and the supinator in the pronated position (r=0.72, p=0.2). Biceps simulation generated larger JRF magnitudes in all positions compared to other muscles (p<
0.001), and the PQ generated larger JRF magnitudes compared to the supinator (p=0.05). Ulnar head arthroplasty was performed with a replacement ulnar head implant instrumented with strain gauges to allow measurement of the DRUJ reaction force. An upper extremity joint simulator applied muscle loads in seven fresh frozen cadaveric upper extremities through computer-controlled pneumatic actuators. Load was varied in 10N increments from 10-80N (biceps and PT) and from 10-50N (PQ and supinator). A hand clamp was used to restrain the forearm in varying positions. The results illustrate that broad insertion and non-linear muscles may not be linearly correlated to joint reaction force in the DRUJ. Please contact author for diagrams and graphs.
The strength of the intact and four reconstruction techniques (figure-eight, docking, single strand utilizing interference screws, and a single strand) of the medial collateral ligament (MCL) of the elbow were compared. Twenty cadaveric specimens were tested with a cyclic valgus loading protocol. The peak loads to failure of the MCL reconstructions were inferior compared to the intact ligament (p<
0.05). The docking and single strand reconstruction utilizing an endobutton for ulnar fixation were equivalent and had greater initial strength than the interference screws or figure-eight technique. It is suggested that improved interference screws are required for this repair. The purpose of this study was to compare the initial strength of the intact medial collateral ligament (MCL) of the elbow and four reconstruction techniques. The docking and endobutton reconstructions showed equivalent peak load to failure. Improved interference screws are required before they are employed clinically. The average peak load to failure or 5mm of joint gapping was 142.5±39.4N for the intact, 53.0±9.5N for the docking, 52.5±10.4N for the endobutton, 41.0±16.0N for the interference screw, and 33.3±7.1N for the figure-eight reconstructions. The peak load to failure was higher for the intact specimens compared to any of the reconstructions (p<
0.001). The docking reconstruction showed higher peak loads than the figure-eight or interference screw reconstruction, and the endobutton reconstruction showed higher peak loads than the figure-eight reconstruction (p<
0.004). There was no difference in peak loads between the docking and endobutton reconstructions (p>
0.05). Twenty (ten pairs) unpreserved cadaveric upper extremities were mounted in a custom jig with the elbow at 90°, and a valgus force was applied 12cm from the elbow joint. The specimens were loaded starting at 20N with the load increased in increments of 10N (200 cycles at each load), until either complete ligament failure or a 5mm increase in the distance between the attachment sites of the MCL. The results support that a single strand or multistrand ligament reconstruction can be equivalent with respect to maximal peak loads and cyclic loading. There are concerns with regard to the use of interference screw fixation in the clinical situation.
Passive and active elbow flexion was performed in eight cadaveric arms to determine the effect of Type 1 coronoid fractures and suture repair on kinematics. Testing was performed in ligamentously intact and MCL deficient elbows; with radial head arthroplasty (RHA); with an intact coronoid, following a Type 1 fracture, and with suture repair of the coronoid. There was an alteration in elbow kinematics and stability following Type 1 coronoid fractures that was not corrected with coronoid repair. Suture fixation of the coronoid is probably unnecessary if the lateral ligaments are repaired and the radial head is repaired or replaced. To determine the effect of fixation of Type 1 coronoid fractures on elbow stability and kinematics in ligamentously intact and medial collateral ligament (MCL) deficient elbows with radial head arthroplasty (RHA). Type 1 coronoid fractures cause changes in elbow kinematics and stability that are not corrected with suture repair. Suture fixation of Type 1 coronoid fractures is probably unnecessary if the lateral ligaments are repaired and the radial head is repaired or replaced. With intact ligaments, there was an increase in valgus angulation following a Type 1 coronoid fracture (p<
0.05) that was not corrected with fixation. With MCL deficiency, there was no change in valgus angulation for all coronoid states. For both ligament states, there was an increase maximum varus-valgus laxity after a Type 1 coronoid fracture with forearm pronation (p=0.03) that was not corrected with fixation (p=0.4). Kinematic data was collected from eight cadaveric arms during passive and simulated active elbow motion. The protocol was performed in stable and MCL deficient elbows with RHA. Testing occurred with the coronoid intact, following Type 1 coronoid fracture, and with suture repair of the fracture. Valgus angulation and maximum varus-valgus laxity were measured. With intact ligaments, Type 1 coronoid fractures cause an alteration in elbow kinematics and laxity that is not corrected with suture fixation. With MCL disruption, Type 1 coronoid fractures have no effect on elbow kinematics and a small effect on laxity that is not corrected with coronoid repair. Funding: Research and Institutional Support received from Wright Medical Technologies. Please contact author for graphs and/or diagrams.
Twenty fresh-frozen clavicles were fractured and randomized to one of four fixation techniques. Three plates were used: the LCP (locking compression plate), LCDCP (low contact dynamic compression plate) and Recon (pelvic reconstruction plate). One intramedullary device was used (the Rockwood Clavicle Pin). The constructs were tested for stiffness in bending and torque modes and ultimate strength in bending. The three plates were significantly stiffer then the Pin. Of the three plates, the Recon was significantly less stiff and weaker in ultimate strength then the LCP and LCDCP plates. This study was conducted to compare and evaluate different fixation techniques for clavicle fractures. Plate fixation with LCP (locking compression plate), LCDCP (low contact dynamic compression plate) and Recon (reconstruction plate) is stiffer then Pin fixation. The Recon plate was weaker and less stiff then the other two plates. Fractures of the clavicle are common and account for approximately 5–10% of all fractures and represent 35–45% of shoulder girdle fractures. Open reduction, internal fixation is becoming a standard for more clavicle fractures with the recognition of the limitations of non-operative management. There is a great disparity in biomechanical literature on clavicle fixation. The average bending stiffness compared to the intact clavicles for each construct was: Recon=104%, LCDCP=124%, LCP=122%, and Pin=69%. The average torque stiffness for each construct was: Recon=83%, LCDCP=91%, LCP=99%, and Pin=46%. The three plate constructs provided significantly more rigid fixation in both bending and torque testing then the clavicle pin (p<
0.05). Ultimate bending strength for each construct was: Recon=8.5 Nm, LCDCP=21.3 Nm, LCP=21.8 Nm, and Pin=15.8 Nm. The Recon plate was significantly weaker the three other constructs (p<
0.05). Twenty fresh frozen cadaver clavicles were randomized to one of the four fixation groups. An Instron materials testing machine was used to compare the fixation constructs. Each clavicle was tested for its bending and torque stiffness. Following construct stiffness testing, all samples were brought to their ultimate failure strength with a superior bending load. This study has shown that plate fixation of clavicle fractures yields stiffer constructs then pin fixation. However, plate fixation requires extensive dissection and stripping of the periclavicular soft tissue and may result in prominent hardware. In fracture situations with significant comminution, the LCP and LCDCP offer significantly greater fracture fixation then the reconstruction plate.
This study investigated the effect of the articulation position on joint load transfer in total elbow arthroplasty. To quantify loading, an adjustable humeral component, instrumented with a load cell, was developed to measure ulnohumeral loads in-vitro. Computer guidance was implemented to accurately place the linked articulation into eight cadaveric elbows. Axial compression and bending about the flexion axis produced the greatest loads during simulated active elbow flexion. An anteriorly malpositioned flexion-extension axis resulted in increased joint loads during flexion. Translational positional errors were more influential than rotational position on articular loading. To quantify the relationship between total elbow arthroplasty position and elbow joint loading. Eight cadaveric upper extremities were tested using a motion-controlled testing device, which simulated muscle activity. Computer guidance was employed to accurately position a linked implant consisting of a custom-designed adjustable humeral component and commercial ulnar component. The testing apparatus was instrumented with a six-degree-of-freedom load cell to measure axial and bending loads. Seven implant positions were tested including anterior-posterior translation (−5.0, −2.5, 0.0, 2.5, 5.0 mm) and internal-external rotation (−5, 0, 5°) during supinated and pronated flexion. The resultant joint force decreased for all prosthetic hinge positions as elbow flexion increased (p<
0.001). Anterior hinge positions produced greater ulnohumeral loads (p<
0.001) and moments (p<
0.001) than posterior hinge positions during simulated elbow flexion. The greatest bending moment occurred about the flexion axis which reached maximum magnitudes during mid-flexion. Implant hinge malrotation did not have a significant effect on axial (p=0.07) or bending (p=0.6) forces experienced at the joint. The distance between the flexion (hinge) axis and the muscular line-of-action of flexors is reduced with anterior hinge placement, likely increasing the force necessary to produce flexion. An anteriorly malpositioned flexion-extension axis resulted in an increase in joint loading during flexion and should be avoided during elbow arthroplasty. This is the first reported study to measure the effect of elbow prosthesis positioning on joint loading. The knowledge gained about joint loads should improve future prosthetic designs and treatment options. Funding: Canadian Institute for Health Research. Please contact author for graphs and/or diagrams.
This in-vitro study was conducted to determine the effect of rotator cuff tears on joint kinematics. A shoulder simulator produced unconstrained active abduction of the humerus. Three sequential 1cm lesions were created, the first two in the supraspinatus tendon and the third in the subscapularis tendon. The plane of abduction moved posteriorly and became more abnormal throughout abduction as the size of the tear increased. It is concluded that in order to generate the same motions achieved by the intact joint other muscle groups must be employed, inevitably resulting in altered joint loading. This in-vitro study was conducted to determine the effect of simulated progressive tears of the rotator cuff on active glenohumeral joint kinematics. Five cadaveric shoulders were tested using a shoulder simulator designed to produce unconstrained active motion of the humerus. Forces were applied to simulate loading of the supraspinatus, subscapularis, infraspinatus/teres minor, anterior, middle, and posterior deltoid muscles based upon variable ratios of electromyographic data and average physiological cross-sectional area of the muscles. Three sequential 1cm lesions were created, the first two in the supraspinatus tendon and the third in the subscapularis tendon. Simulated active glenohumeral abduction was performed following the creation of each lesion. Five successive tests were performed to quantify repeatability. The plane of abduction moved posteriorly and became more abnormal throughout abduction as the size of the lesion increased (p=0.01) (Figure 1). In order to generate the same motions achieved with an intact rotator cuff other muscle groups must be employed, inevitably resulting in altered joint loading. A better understanding of the effects that rotator cuff tears have on the kinematics of the glenohumeral joint may result in the development of innovative rehabilitation strategies to compensate for this change in muscle balance and improve the clinical outcomes. Please contact author for diagram and/or graph.
This study was conducted to determine the effect of passive and active muscle loading on humeral head translation during glenohumeral abduction. A shoulder simulator produced unconstrained active glenohumeral abduction using several sets of loading ratios. Significantly greater translations occurred in passive motion as compared to active motion between 30 and 70 degrees of elevation in three dimensions and in the anterosuperior plane. No difference was found between the active motions. Also, translations of the humeral head decreased with active simulation of abduction emphasizing the importance of the rotator cuff muscles in creating and maintaining the ball-and-socket kinematics of the shoulder. This in-vitro study was conducted to determine the effect of passive and active loading on humeral head translation during glenohumeral abduction. Five cadaveric shoulders were tested using a shoulder simulator designed to produce unconstrained abduction of the humerus. Forces were applied to simulate loading of the supraspinatus, subscapularis, infraspinatus/teres minor, anterior, middle, and posterior deltoid muscles using four different sets of loading ratios. These were based on:
equal loads to all cables (Constant-Constant); average physiological cross-sectional areas (pCSAs) of the muscles (pCSA); constant (Constant EMG), and variable (Variable EMG) values of the product of electromyographic data and pCSAs. In three dimensions, significantly greater translations occurred in passive motion as compared to active motion between 30 and 70 degrees of elevation (p<
0.001). No difference was found between the active motions. Similar results were observed in the two-dimensional resultant translations in the anterosuperior plane of the scapula, with more translation occurring during passive motion (3.6 ± 1.1mm) than active (2.1 ± 1.0mm) (p=0.002), and no significant differences between the active loading methods (Figure 1). The majority of translation tended to occur in the superior-inferior direction for all loading ratios employed. It was clearly shown that the translations of the humeral head decreased with active simulation of abduction. These findings are in agreement with other in-vivo and in-vitro investigations. This emphasizes the importance of the rotator cuff muscles in creating and maintaining the ball-and-socket kinematics of the shoulder.
The influence of the supinator and pronator quadratus (PQ) muscles on distal radioulnar joint stability were evaluated using a joint simulator capable of producing forearm rotation, before and after ulnar head excision. Multiple pronation trials were conducted with incremental loading of the PQ relative to the pronator teres; supination trials were similarly conducted with the supinator and biceps. Incremental supinator muscle loading did not alter forearm kinematics. Increased PQ loading did not affect intact kinematics, but did alter joint motion following ulnar head excision. PQ activation will likely aggravate forearm instability following ulnar head excision; suggesting rehabilitation should incorporate immobilization in supination. The purpose of this study was to study the effect of pronator quadratus (PQ) and supinator loads on forearm kinematics in both an intact distal radioulnar joint (DRUJ) and following ulnar head excision. The PQ muscle appears to aggravate instability of the DRUJ following ulnar head excision, while incremental loading of the supinator muscle had no effect. Patients with DRUJ instability and/or who have undergone surgical removal of the ulnar head should be rehabilitated in supination to limit the influence of the PQ muscle. Eight cadaveric upper extremities were tested in a custom joint simulator employing motion and load-controlled tendon loading to produce forearm rotation. Pronation was achieved via loading of the pronator teres and PQ muscles. Repeated trials were conducted in which the ratio of the PQ load was increased incrementally relative to the pronator teres load. Supination trials were similarly conducted using the biceps and supinator muscles. Testing was conducted in the intact forearm and following ulnar head excision. An electromagnetic tracking device was used to record motion of the radius and ulna. Kinematic data was analyzed with a planar analysis that measured dorsal palmar displacements and diastasis of the DRUJ. Greater diastasis and dorsal translation of the radius relative to the ulna were noted under increased PQ loading following ulnar head excision (p<
0.05). Increased supinator load had no effect on kinematics before or after ulnar head excision. This effect is likely due to the location of the two muscles. The effect of PQ muscle loading was only noted in neutral to full pronation. These results suggest that rehabilitation of the forearm following ulnar head excision should be conducted with the forearm in supination to minimize joint instability.
Three 3mm transverse slices were sectioned from the distal cancellous region of seven fresh-frozen cadaveric humerii. Each slice was marked with a 3x3mm grid, and subjected to compressive testing using a flat cylindrical indenter (1.6mm diameter). Indentation modulus and strength were calculated for each site, and pooled into nine anatomically-defined regions. The most distal slice had higher moduli values (p<
0.05), and the posterior capitellar region had lower moduli values (p<
0.05). There were no slice or regional differences in strength. This suggests that surgical procedures requiring cancellous fixation utilize the most distal aspect of the humerus while avoiding the posterior capitellum. To quantify the indentation strength and modulus of distal humeral cancellous bone, and identify any regional variations. Cancellous bone modulus in the distal humerus decreases from distal to proximal. The posterior capitellum has a lower modulus than the other regions of the distal humerus. The influence of slice depth emphasizes the importance of minimizing the amount of bone removed during prosthetic replacement. Regional variations in modulus suggest that the posterior capitellum should be avoided during fixation of implants or placement of screws. Three 3mm transverse cancellous bone slices obtained from the distal end of each of seven fresh-frozen cadaveric specimens were subjected to compressive testing using a materials testing machine with a 1.6mm flat cylindrical indenter. Testing was performed in a 3x3mm grid. The indentation modulus and local strength were calculated for each test site, and then averaged into nine regions defined by the capitellum, medial and lateral trochlea, and anterior, central and posterior sections for each slice. Mean modulus was found to be 309.8±242.0 MPa (range: 2.9–1041.7 MPa). Yield strength averaged 4.4±2.5 MPa (range: 0.6–16.3 MPa). The highest modulus was found in the distal-most slice (p<
0.05). The lowest modulus region was the posterior capitellum (p<
0.05). There were no differences in strength between slices or across the nine regions. A comparison with proximal tibial cancellous bone properties suggests the distal humerus may carry loads approaching 30% of those at the knee, assuming that bone adapts to stress magnitudes. Funding: Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council; University of Western Ontario
Single-strand medial collateral elbow ligament (MCL) reconstruction strength was evaluated using double docking (DD) and interference screw (IS) methods with either palmaris longus (PL) or Graft Jacket_ (GJ) as the reconstruction material. Thirteen upper-extremities were mounted in 90° valgus orientations, and subjected to increasing cyclic valgus loading until failure. DD reconstructions outperformed IS reconstructions (P<
0.05), while PL and GJ performed comparably (P>
0.05). The initial Graft Jacket strength makes it a potential alternative to palmaris longus tendons; Laboratory evaluation of graft strength during healing is required. For its simplicity and strength, the DD technique should be considered, clinically. Single-strand medial collateral elbow ligament (MCL) reconstruction strength was evaluated using double docking (DD) and interference screw (IS) methods with either palmaris longus (PL) or Graft Jacket_ (GJ) as the reconstruction material. Thirteen, fresh-frozen upper-extremities (66 ±5 years) were cleaned of all soft tissues except the medial and lateral collateral ligaments, flexed to 90° and mounted in a rigid, valgus testing system. DD or IS reconstructions were performed using either PL or GJ. A cyclic (0.5Hz) load was applied 12cm distal to the medial epicondyle. After 500 cycles, the load was increased by 10N until catastrophic failure or a length increase of 10mm. The mean maximum load for the DD with GJ was 65 ±12N; for the IS with GJ: 45 ±5N; for the DD with PL: 59 ±11N; and for the IS with PL: 56 ±14N. The mean maximum number of cycles endured by the DD with GJ was 1292 ±562; for the IS with GJ: 356 ±292; for the DD with PL: 1104 ±479; and for the IS with PL: 924 ±690. For both the maximum load and number of cycles, the DD outperformed the IS (P<
0.05) and the GJ and PL performed comparably (P>
0.05). Single-strand reconstructions using the double dock method outperform the interference screw technique. For its simplicity and strength, the DD technique should be considered, clinically. The initial Graft Jacket strength makes it a potential alternative to palmaris longus tendons; laboratory evaluation of graft strength during healing is required. Funding: This study was partially funded by Wright Medical Technology (Arlington, TN) and the Canadian Institute for Health Research. Please contact author for graphs and/or diagrams.