header advert
Results 21 - 40 of 40
Results per page:
Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 94-B, Issue SUPP_XVIII | Pages 55 - 55
1 May 2012
Mellon SJ Kwon Y Simpson DJ Murray DW Gill HS
Full Access

Introduction

Metal-on-metal (MoM) hip resurfacing arthroplasty is a popular choice for young and active patients. However, there are concerns recently regarding soft tissue masses or pseudotumours. The appearance of these complications is thought to be related blood metal ion levels. The level of metal ions in blood is thought to be the result of MoM wear. In the present study the contribution of acetabulum orientation to stress distribution was investigated.

Methods

Four subjects with MoM resurfacings and with known blood metal ion levels underwent motion analysis followed by CT scans. The positions of the acetabular (cup) and femoral components were determined the CT data relative to local coordinate systems in the pelvis (PCS) and the femur (FCS). Transformations, calculated from the motion analysis data, between the PCS and FCS gave the position of the cup relative to the femoral component for each frame of captured motion data.

Hip reaction forces were taken from published data1. The intersection of hip reaction force with each subject's cup and the increase in inclination required to move the force to the edge of the cup was calculated for 2% intervals during the stance phase of gait. Finite element models representing each subject's cup and femoral components were created and contact stresses were determined for the native cup inclination angle. For each model, the effect of increasing the inclination of the cup, by up to 10°, in 1° increments, was determined.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 94-B, Issue SUPP_XVIII | Pages 59 - 59
1 May 2012
Simpson DJ Kendrick B Thomas G Gill H O'Connor J Murray DW
Full Access

Introduction

The results of the original mobile bearing Oxford unicompartmental knee replacement (UKR) in the lateral compartment have been disappointing because of high dislocation rates (11%). This original implant used a flat bearing articulation on the tibial tray. To address the issue of dislocation a new implant (domed tibia with biconcave bearing to increase entrapment) was introduced with a modified surgical technique. The aim of this study was to compare the risk of dislocation between a domed and flat lateral UKR.

Methods

Separate geometric computer models of an Oxford mobile bearing lateral UKR were generated for the two types of articulation between the tibial component and the meniscal bearing: Flat-on-flat (flat) and Concave-on-convex (domed). Each type of mobile bearing was used to investigate three distinct dislocation modes observed clinically: lateral to medial dislocation, with the bearing resting on the tray wall (L-M-Wall); medial to lateral dislocation, out of the joint space (M-L); anterior to posterior dislocation, out of the joint space (A-P).

A size C tray and a medium femoral component and bearing were used in all models. The femoral component, tibial tray and bearing were first aligned in a neutral position. For each dislocation the tibial tray was restrained in all degrees of freedom. The femoral component was restrained from moving in the anterior-posterior directions and in the medial-lateral directions. The femoral component was also restrained from rotating about the anterior-posterior, medial-lateral and superior-inferior directions. This meant that the femoral component was only able to move in the superior-inferior direction. Different bearing sizes were inserted into the model and the effect that moving the femoral component medially and laterally had on the amount of distraction required to cause bearing dislocation was investigated.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 94-B, Issue SUPP_XVIII | Pages 80 - 80
1 May 2012
Thomas GER Simpson DJ Gill HS Glyn-Jones S Beard DJ Murray DW EPOS study group
Full Access

Femoral stem varus has been associated with poorer results. We report the incidence of varus/valgus malalignment of the Exeter polished, double taper design in a multicentre prospective study. The surgical outcomes at a minimum of five year and complication rates are also reported.

A multicentre prospective study of 987 total hip replacements was undertaken to investigate whether there is an association between surgical outcome and femoral stem malalignment. The primary outcome measure was the change in the Oxford hip score (OHS) at five years. Secondary outcomes included the rate of dislocation and revision.

The incidence of varus and valgus malignment were 7.1% and 2.6% respectively. There was no significant difference in OHS between neutral and malaligned femoral stems at 5 years (neutral, mean = 40.2; varus, mean 39.3, p = 0.465; valgus, mean = 40.9, p = 0.605). There was no significant difference in dislocation rate between the groups (p = 0.66). There was also no significant difference in revision rate (p = 0.34).

This study provides evidence that the Exeter stem is extremely tolerant of varus and valgus malalignment, both in terms of outcome and complication rate.


Bone & Joint Research
Vol. 1, Issue 4 | Pages 42 - 49
1 Apr 2012
Kwon Y Mellon SJ Monk P Murray DW Gill HS

Objectives

Pseudotumours (abnormal peri-prosthetic soft-tissue reactions) following metal-on-metal hip resurfacing arthroplasty (MoMHRA) have been associated with elevated metal ion levels, suggesting that excessive wear may occur due to edge-loading of these MoM implants. This study aimed to quantify in vivo edge-loading in MoMHRA patients with and without pseudotumours during functional activities.

Methods

The duration and magnitude of edge-loading in vivo was quantified during functional activities by combining the dynamic hip joint segment contact force calculated from the three-dimensional (3D) motion analysis system with the 3D reconstruction of orientation of the acetabular component and each patient’s specific hip joint centre, based on CT scans.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 94-B, Issue SUPP_IX | Pages 26 - 26
1 Mar 2012
Gulati A Pandit H Gill HS Price AJ Dodd CAF Murray DW
Full Access

INTRODUCTION

Mobile bearing unicompartmental knee replacement (UKR) is an accepted treatment for patients with isolated medial unicompartmental knee osteoarthritis (OA) with a full thickness cartilage loss. The aim of this study was to determine if this recommendation was correct and if the procedure could be used for partial-thickness cartilage loss.

METHODS

1053 Oxford medial UKRs were studied prospectively. The knees were divided into two groups; partial-thickness cartilage loss (PTCL) group and the full thickness-cartilage loss (FTCL) group. The primary outcome measure was the total Oxford Knee Score (OKS, 0 to 48) at the time of final follow up. The groups were also compared for the change in OKS (?OKS) and the proportion of patients that were considered to have benefited substantially from surgery (?OKS >5).


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 92-B, Issue SUPP_III | Pages 411 - 411
1 Jul 2010
Kendrick BJL Simpson D Bottomley NJ Marks B Pandit H Beard D Gill HS Dodd CA Murray DW Price AJ
Full Access

Purpose: This study was designed to establish the poly-ethylene wear rates in the Oxford medial unicompert-mental knee replacement.

Introduction: The Oxford meniscal bearing knee was introduced as a design to reduce polyethylene wear. There has been one previous retrieval study of the Oxford UKA, which reported very low wear rates in some specimens, but abnormal patterns of wear in others, including impingement. There has been no further investigation of these abnormal wear patterns.

Methods: Forty-seven bearings were retrieved from patients who had received a medial Oxford UKA for anteromedial osteoarthritis of the knee, none of which had previously been studied. Mean time to revision was 8.4 years (SD 4.1) and 20 had been implanted for over 10 years. The macroscopic pattern of polyethylene wear and the linear penetration (dial gauge measurement) was recorded for each bearing.

Results: The mean linear penetration rate (LPR) was 0.07mm/year. The patterns of wear fell into 4 categories, each with a different LPR; 1) No abnormal macroscopic appearance, n=16 (LPR = 0.01mm/year), 2) Abnormal macroscopic wear with extra-articular impingement, n=16 (LPR = 0.05mm/year), 3) Abnormal macroscopic wear with intra-articular impingement, n=6 (LPR = 0.10mm/year), 4) Abnormal macroscopic wear with impingement and signs of incongruous articulation, n=9 (LPR = 0.14mm/year). The differences in LPR were statistically significant (p< 0.05).

Conclusion: The results show that very low polyethylene wear rates are possible if the device functions normally. However if the bearing displays abnormal function (extra-articular, intra-articular impingement or incongruous articulation) wear rates increase significantly.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 92-B, Issue SUPP_III | Pages 421 - 421
1 Jul 2010
Monk AP Simpson DJ Ostlere S Dodd CAF Doll H Price AJ Beard DJ Gill HS Murray DW Gibbons CLMH
Full Access

Introduction: Patellofemoral joint subluxation is associated with pain and dysfunction. The causes of patel-lofemoral subluxation are poorly understood and multi-factorial, arising from abnormalities of both bone and soft tissues. This study aims to identify which anatomical variables assessed on Magnetic Resonance (MR) images are most relevant to patellofemoral subluxation.

Method: A retrospective analysis of MR studies of 60 patients with suspected patellofemoral subluxation was performed. All patients were graded for the severity/ magnitude of radiological subluxation using a dynamic MR scan (Grade 0 [nil] to Grade 3 [subluxed]. The patient scans were assessed using a range of anatomical variables, these included:

Patella alta,

Patella type (Wiberg classification),

Trochlea sulcus angles for bone and cartilage,

The shortest horizontal distance between the most distal part of the vastus medialis obliquis (VMO) muscle to the supra-medial aspect of the patella,

Trochlea and patella cartilage thickness (maximum depth),

The horizontal distance between the tibial tubercle and the midpoint of the femoral trochlea (TTD),

Patella Engagement – represented as the percentage of the patella height that is captured in the trochlea groove when the knee is in full extension,

A Discriminant Analysis test for multi-variant analysis was applied to establish the relationship between each bony/soft tissue anatomical variable and the severity/magnitude of patellofemoral subluxation.

Results: The distance of the VMO from the patella (p < 0.001), TTD (p < 0.001) and Patella Engagement (p < 0.001) showed highly significant relationships with patellofemoral subluxation.

Conclusions: The following three anatomical variables are associated with patellofemoral subluxation: the distance of the VMO muscle from the patella, TTD and Patella Engagement.

This is the first study to establish that patella engagement is related to PFJ subluxation showing that the lower the percentage engagement of the patella in the trochlea, the greater the severity/magnitude of patellofemoral subluxation. The finding provides greater insight into the aetiology and understanding of the mechanism of symptomatic PFJ subluxation.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 92-B, Issue SUPP_I | Pages 60 - 61
1 Mar 2010
McDonnell* SM Rout R Hollander AP Clark IM Murray DW Gill HS Hulley PA Price AJ
Full Access

Anteromedial Osteoarthritis of the Knee (AMOA) is a distinct phenotype of OA. Within this pattern of disease, the anterior third of the medial tibial plateau exhibits full thickness cartilage loss. The middle third has damaged partial thickness cartilage, and the posterior third has retained cartilage, which is seen on macroscopic visual assessment to be normal. This study investigates the molecular features of progressive severities of cartilage damage within this phenotype.

Ten medial tibial plateau specimens were collected from patients undergoing unicompartmental knee replacements. The cartilage within the area of macroscopic damage was divided into equal thirds: T1(most damaged), to T3 (least damaged). The area of macroscopically undamaged cartilage was taken as a 4th sample, N. The specimens were prepared for histological (Safranin-O) and immunohistochemical analysis (Type I and II Collagen, proliferation and apoptosis). Immunoassays were undertaken for Collagens I and II and GAG content. Real time PCR compared gene expression between areas T and N.

There was a decrease in OARSI grade across the four areas, with progressively less fibrillation between areas T1, T2 and T3. Area N had a grade of 0 (normal). The GAG immunoassay showed decreased levels with increasing severity of cartilage damage (p< 0.0001). Proliferation and apoptosis, as expected, were increased in the more damaged areas. There was no significant difference in the Collagen II content or gene expression between areas. The Collagen I immunohistochemistry showed increased staining within chondrocyte pericellular areas in the undamaged region (N) and immunoassays showed that the Collagen I content of this macroscopically and histologically normal cartilage, was significantly higher than the damaged areas (p< 0.0001). Furthermore, real time PCR showed a significant increase in Collagen I expression in the macroscopically normal areas compared to the damaged areas (p=0.04).

We conclude that in this phenotype the Collagen I increase, in areas of macroscopically and histologically normal cartilage, may represent very early changes of the cartilage matrix within the osteoarthritic disease process. This may be able to be used as an assay of early disease and as a therapeutic target for disease modification or treatment.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 91-B, Issue SUPP_III | Pages 411 - 412
1 Sep 2009
Chau R Gulati A Pandit HG Beard DJ Gill HS Dodd CAF Simpson DJ Murray DW
Full Access

Purpose: To evaluate the effects of underhanging/overhanging tibial components on clinical outcome following the Oxford unicompartmental knee arthroplasty (UKA), and to identify an acceptable sizing limit.

Method: One hundred and sixty-three knees which had undergone the Phase 3 medial Oxford UKA (Biomet, Swindon) were measured. Based on five-year post-operative radiographs, they were divided into groups with tibial component underhang (n=38), none or minimal overhang of less than three millimetres (n=121), and a group with overhang equal to or in excess of three millimetres (n=13). Clinical outcome was assessed by changes in the twelve-question Oxford Knee Score (ΔOKS) and pain score (ΔPS) component (questions 1,4,5,8,9) from pre-operative assessment to five years following surgery.

Results: At five years after surgery, ΔOKS was significantly worse in the overhang group compared to both the neutral and underhang groups (p=0.015, and p=0.028 respectively). ΔPS was also shown to be significantly worse between the overhang and the neutral group (p=0.026 respectively).

Conclusion: Appropriate sizing of the tibial component is essential to optimise load bearing in total knee arthroplasty. In UKA such sizing is critical due to halving of the bony support for the tibial component and the lack of room for a large stem. Excessive undersizing of the prosthesis may lead to subsidence and loosening, whilst excessive overhanging may cause local soft tissue irritation and pain.

This study demonstrates that medial overhang of less than three millimetres for the tibial component is acceptable in the Oxford UKA. Excessive overhang equal to this or more results in significantly worse ΔOKS and ΔPS. However, no difference in the five year ΔOKS and ΔPS was demonstrated between underhang and the other two groups in this study.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 91-B, Issue SUPP_III | Pages 412 - 412
1 Sep 2009
Gulati A Jenkins C Chau R Pandit HG Dodd CAF Price AJ Simpson DJ Beard DJ Gill HS Murray DW
Full Access

Purpose: Varus deformity after total knee replacement (TKR) is associated with poor outcome. This aim of this study was to determine whether the same is true for medial unicompartmental arthroplasty (UKA).

Methods: 158 patients implanted with the Oxford UKA, using a minimally invasive approach, were studied prospectively for five years. Leg alignment was measured with a long-arm goniometer referenced from Anterior Superior Iliac Spine, centre of patella and centre of ankle. Patients were grouped according to the American Knee Society Score (AKSS). Group A: > 0° varus (n=13, 8.2%); Group B: 0 to 4° valgus (n=39, 24.7%); Group C: 5–10° valgus (normal alignment, n=106, 67.12%). Comparisons were made between the three groups in terms of the absolute and the change in Oxford Knee Score (OKS) and AKSS over the five year period, and the presence of radiolucency.

Results: There was no significant difference in any outcome measure except for Objective-AKSS (p< 0.001). The means and standard deviations of the ΔOKS for the groups were:

24 ± 5,

22 ± 10, and

22 ± 9 and for Objective-AKSS were 84 ± 12, 82 ± 15 and 91 ± 11 respectively.

The frequency of five year radiolucency for the groups A, B, and C were 42%, 35%, and 45% respectively.

Conclusion: The aim of the Oxford UKA is to restore knee kinematics and thus knee alignment to the pre-disease state. Therefore, as demonstrated by this study, about 30% of patients have varus alignment. This study also demonstrates that post-operative varus alignment does not compromise the outcome. The only score which did show worse outcome was the Objective-AKSS. This is because 10 or 20 points are deducted for varus alignment, which is not appropriate following UKA. Therefore, AKSS in its present form is not a reliable tool for assessment of UKA.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 91-B, Issue SUPP_III | Pages 421 - 421
1 Sep 2009
Chau R Pandit HG Gulati A Gray H Beard DJ Gill HS Dodd CAF Price AJ Murray DW
Full Access

Purpose: To identify associative factors for radiolucency (RL) under the tibial component following the Oxford unicompartmental arthroplasty (UKA), and to evaluate its effect on clinical outcome scores.

Method: One hundred and sixty-one knees which had undergone primary Phase 3 medial Oxford UKA were included. Fluoroscopic radiography films were assessed at five years post-operatively for areas of tibial RL. The two groups of patients, with and without RL, were compared to

patients’ pre-operative demographics for age, weight, height, BMI,

intra-operative variables such as the operating surgeon (n=2), insert and component sizes,

post-operative varus/valgus deformity, and

clinical outcome, assessed by the change in Oxford knee (OKS) and Tegner (TS) scores, from before surgery to five-year post-operatively.

Results: 101 (62%) knees were found to have tibial RL. All RL were categorised as physiological or they were < 1mm thick, with sclerotic margins and non-progressive. No statistical difference was found between knees with RL and those without, in terms of pre-operative demographics, intra- or post-operative factors, and clinical outcome scores (p> 0.1 in all variables).

Discussion: Radiolucency (RL) under the tibial component is a common finding following the Oxford UKA. Many theories have been proposed to explain the cause of RL, such as poor cementing, osteonecrosis, micromotion, and thermal necrosis. However, the true aetiology and clinical significance remain unclear. We attempted to address this.

We found no significant relationship between physiological RL, pre-operative demographics, intra-operative variables and clinical outcome scores in this study. Tibial RL remains a common finding following the Oxford UKA yet we do not know why it occurs but in the medium term, clinical outcome is not influenced by RL. In particular, it is not a sign of loosening. Physiological RL can therefore be ignored even if associated with adverse symptoms following the Oxford UKA.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 91-B, Issue SUPP_III | Pages 415 - 415
1 Sep 2009
McDonnell SM Rout R Hollander AP Clark IM Simms T Davidson R Dickinson S Waters J Gill HS Murray DW Hulley PA Price AJ
Full Access

Aim: To investigate the molecular features of progressive severities of cartilage damage, within the phenotype of Anteromedial Osteoarthritis of the Knee (AMOA).

Methods: Ten medial tibial plateau specimens were collected from patients undergoing unicompartmental knee replacements.

The cartilage within the area of macroscopic damage was divided into equal thirds: T1(most damaged), to T3 (least damaged). The area of macroscopically undamaged cartilage was taken as a 4th sample, N. The specimens were prepared for histological (Safranin-O and H& E staining) and immunohistochemical analysis (Type I and II Collagen, proliferation and apoptosis).

Immunoassays were undertaken for Collagens I and II and GAG content. Real time PCR compared gene expression between areas T and N.

Results: There was a decrease in OARSI grade across the four areas, with progressively less fibrillation between areas T1, T2 and T3. Area N had an OARSI grade of 0 (normal).

The GAG immunoassay showed decreased levels with increasing severity of cartilage damage (ANOVA P< 0.0001).

There was no significant difference in the Collagen II content or gene expression between areas.

The Collagen I immunohistochemistry showed increased staining within chondrocyte pericellular areas in the undamaged region (N) and immunoassays showed that the Collagen I content of this macroscopically and histologically normal cartilage, was significantly higher than the damaged areas (ANOVA P< 0.0001). Furthermore, real time PCR showed that there was a significant difference in Collagen I expression between the damaged and macroscopically normal areas (p=0.04).

Conclusion: In AMOA there are distinct areas, demonstrating progressive cartilage loss. We conclude that in this phenotype the Collagen I increase, in areas of macroscopically and histologically normal cartilage, may represent very early changes of the cartilage matrix within the osteoarthritic disease process. This may be able to be used as an assay of early disease and as a therapeutic target for disease modification or treatment.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 91-B, Issue SUPP_III | Pages 409 - 409
1 Sep 2009
Murray DW
Full Access

There is little good evidence about the relative merits of different knee replacement designs as no adequately powered randomised controlled trials have been undertaken. To address this, a pragmatic multi-centre randomised trial involving 116 surgeons in 34 UK centres was begun in 1999. Within a partial factorial design 1715 patients were randomly allocated to patella resurfacing or not, 539 to mobile bearing or not and 409 to metal backing of the tibial component or not. Primary outcome measures are the Oxford Knee Score (OKS), SF-12, EQ-5D and need for further surgery.

At two years there was no evidence of differences in complications, clinical outcome, functional status or quality of life measures between randomised groups.

95% of the patient are now 5 year post-operation and have been sent questionnaires. 93% of these have been returned. By January 2008, all will be past 5 years and will have been sent questionnaires. When the complete 5 year data set is available it will be analysed. The 5 year data relating to the randomised groups will be presented.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 90-B, Issue SUPP_III | Pages 531 - 532
1 Aug 2008
Barker KL Newman MA Pandit H Murray DW
Full Access

Introduction: Metal-on-metal hip resurfacing arthroplasty (HRA) is currently recommended for younger, active patients with high expectations but information about outcomes is limited. Reports concentrate on wear, fracture rates and radiographic appearance, rather than function. Studies that report function do not describe rehabilitation protocols. This data is important to discussions about likely outcomes and restrictions prior to consent and to fully evaluate HRA.

Methods: Consecutive Conserve HRA operations were reviewed 1 year post-surgery. Function was assessed using 3 validated questionnaires; the OHS (Oxford Hip Score), HOOS (Hip Disability and Osteoarthritis Outcome Score) and UCLA Activity Scale. Complications, pain, ROM, muscle strength, single leg stand, walking and stair climbing ability were recorded.

Results: 125 HRA were reviewed (68 right, 57 left hips) in 120 patients (71 male, 49 female) of mean age 56 years. 86.7% recorded no complications, but 20% had pain at 3 months. The median OHS was 15, median UCLA 7 (active) and mean HOOS 82.78%. Operated hip flexors, extensors and abductors were weaker (p=0.000) and hip flexion ROM a mean 94.46 ± 12.71 (55–120) degrees. For 25% walking was limited, 7.6% needed a stick and 10% a stair rail. The OHS correlated with HOOS pain subscale (r=0.812, p=0.000), flexion ROM (r=0.426, p=0.000), hip extensor (r=0.359, p=0.000) and abductor (r=0.424, p=0.000) strength. Pain at 3 months correlated with the HOOS pain subscale (p=0.000, r= 0.503).

Discussion: Although outcomes were generally good with few complications, high levels of function and activity 25% had poor outcomes; with pain, restricted hip flexion, decreased strength, limited walking and functional problems, particularly putting on socks. Pain present at 3 months was associated with pain and worse function at 1 year. It is postulated this sub-optimal recovery may be related to current rehabilitation protocols adopted from THA and not tailored to HRA.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 88-B, Issue SUPP_II | Pages 258 - 258
1 May 2006
Langdown AJ Pandit H Price AJ Dodd CAF Murray DW Svärd UCG Gibbons CLMH
Full Access

Introduction: This study assesses the outcome of medial unicompartmental knee arthroplasty (UKA) using the Oxford prosthesis for end-stage focal spontaneous osteonecrosis of the knee (SONK, Ahlback grades III & IV).

Methods: A total of 29 knees (27 patients) with SONK were assessed using the Oxford Knee Score. Twenty-six had osteonecrosis of the medial femoral condyle; 3 had osteonecrosis of the medial tibial plateau. This group was compared to a similar group who had undergone Oxford Medial UKA for primary osteoarthritis. Patients were matched for age, sex and time since operation.

Results: Mean length of follow-up was 5.2 years (range 1–13 years). There were no implant failures in either group, but there was one death 9 months post-arthroplasty from unrelated causes in the group with osteonecrosis. The mean Oxford Knee Score in the group with osteonecrosis was 37.8 (± 7.6) and 40.0 (± 6.6) in the group with osteoarthritis. There was no significant difference between the two groups using Student’s t-test (p=0.31).

Interpretation: Use of the Oxford Medial UKA for focal spontaneous osteonecrosis of the knee is reliable in the short to medium term, and gives similar results to when used for patients with primary osteoarthritis.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 86-B, Issue SUPP_IV | Pages 439 - 439
1 Apr 2004
Rees JL Price AJ Beard DJ McLardy-Smith P Dodd CAF Murray DW
Full Access

Introduction: A new procedure has been recently adopted to implant the Oxford medial unicompartmental arthroplasty (UCA). All cases are now implanted through a short incision without dislocation of the patella. The aims of this study were to assess the one-year results using this new technique and to determine if the outcome is dependent on surgical experience.

Method: The first 104 Oxford UCA’s (Phase 3) implanted by six surgeons under the care of two consultants were reviewed at one year. All operations were performed using the new technique. The average age at surgery was 68 years. All knees were scored pre-operatively and at review with the American Knee Society score. The cohort was divided into two groups; the first ten cases for each surgeon were included in a ‘learning’ group, whilst the remaining cases were included in an ‘experienced’ group.

Results: Overall the average ‘knee score’ improved from 37 points to 94 and the average ‘functional score’ from 50 points to 92. Average maximum flexion improved from 117° to 131°. The ‘knee score’ for the ‘learning’ group was 91 points. This was significantly less (p = 0.008) than the score of the ‘experienced’ group (96 points).

Conclusions: These results are significantly better than the best historical results of the Oxford (UCA), performed through an open approach with dislocation of the patella.

Despite impressive overall results at one year, lower knee scores were associated with a surgeons ‘learning curve’. After this ‘learning curve’, increased surgical experience led to further improvement with 90% achieving an excellent result, 8% a good, 2% a fair and 0% a poor result.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 85-B, Issue SUPP_I | Pages 55 - 55
1 Jan 2003
Rees JL Beard DJ Price AJ Gill HS Dodd CAF Murray DW
Full Access

Introduction: In conjunction with a bilateral randomised control trial comparing the clinical outcome of two total knee arthroplasties (TKA), we carried out an in-vivo fluoroscopic analysis of both knees in the trial. Knee A, is a new mobile bearing posterior cruciate retaining TKA and Knee B, an established fixed bearing posterior cruciate retaining TKA.

Method: In an ethically approved study, video fluoroscopy was taken of both knees of seven patients performing three exercises; extension against gravity, flexion against gravity and a step up exercise. Ten images at ten-degree intervals over the flexion range were frame grabbed and digitised. The relationship of patella tendon angle (PTA) to knee flexion angle (KFA) was assessed using a newly developed computer system. Five normal knees in fit volunteers were also fluoroscoped and assessed.

Results: A similar pattern of results was obtai ed for all three exercises. Knee A behaved in a linear, more consistent fashion than Knee B, which behaved non-linearly. Analysis of variance showed this difference was significant for all three exercises (p < 0.039).

Conclusions: This bilateral study provides a powerful way of assessing the kinematics of two different knee implants. Knee A behaves in a linear predictable fashion that is nearer normal than Knee B. These results will be used in conjunction with a clinical outcome study and an RSA study to provide a complete assessment of a new TKA.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 85-B, Issue SUPP_I | Pages 52 - 53
1 Jan 2003
Rees JL Price AJ Beard DJ Robinson BJ Dodd CAF Murray DW
Full Access

Introduction: The Oxford medial unicompartmental arthroplasty (UCA) is now routinely performed through a short incision without Dislocation of the patella. The aim of this study was to assess the one-year results of this new technique to determine whether it enhances the quality of outcome, as well as the speed of its achievement.

Method: The first 88 consecutive Oxford UCA’s (Phase 3) implanted into 75 patients by two consultant surgeons were scored pre-operatively and at review with the American Knee Society Score. The average age of the patients was 68.1 years; the male to female ratio was 0.9 to 1.

Results: At review, one patient (one knee) had died and one knee had been revised for infection. The other patients (86 knees) were examined at a mean of 1.3 years from surgery. The average ‘knee score’ improved from 37 points to 95 and the average ‘functional score’ from 51 points to 93. Average maximum flexion improved from 117° to 132°. The ‘knee score’ outcome categories at review were 87% excellent, 8% good, 2.5% fair and 2.5% poor.

Conclusions: Historical comparison of these results with the best results of the Oxford UCA, performed through an open approach with dislocation of the patella, suggest that the minimally invasive approach, in addition to faster recovery, improves the quality of outcome at one year.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 85-B, Issue SUPP_I | Pages 62 - 62
1 Jan 2003
Glyn-Jones S Gill HS McLardy-Smith P Murray DW
Full Access

This early study examines the influence of a wider shoulder on the 1 year migration of a cemented, polished, tapered stem, using RSA.

Polished, tapered stems (PTS) have excellent 10 year survival rates. RSA studies have demonstrated that these devices subside about 1 mm / year. Small amounts of subsidence are beneficial in stabilising a stem. Stem rotation (measured as posterior head migration) within the cement mantle is probably a more important mechanism of failure than subsidence. Stems with a wider proximal portion are thought to better resist rotation. The CPS (Endoplus, UK) is such a device; here we compare its’ stability with that of the Exeter.

20 patients received the CPS-plus stem and underwent RSA examinations at 3, 6 and 12 months postoperatively. The Exeter 1 year migration data was used as a comparison. Both groups underwent a Hardinge approach with CMW3G cement.

Both stems subsided about 1mm. The CPS showed less medio-lateral and A-P movement of the proximal stem than the Exeter over 1 year, as shown below:

The CPS internally rotates less than the Exeter, as demonstrated by the smaller amount of posterior head migration. It has a lateral flare of the shoulder; making its cross-section wider than the Exeter’s, this probably accounts for its’ greater resistance to rotation. The CPS also undergoes less medio-lateral proximal stem migration. Its’ lateral shoulder flare is probably responsible for this axial subsidence, as it prevents the shoulder from moving laterally whilst subsiding over the calcar.

A PTS with a broad proximal section is more stable, this may confer an increased survival advantage.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 84-B, Issue SUPP_II | Pages 156 - 157
1 Jul 2002
Beard DJ Murray DW Rees JL Price AJ Hambly PR Dodd CAF
Full Access

A pilot study was performed to assess the feasibility of discharging patients undergoing unicompartmental knee replacement (UKR) within a day of surgery; both clinical and administrative issues were examined.

Logistics and responsibilities were organised prior to the study. Representatives of anaesthetics, pain team, orthopaedics, admissions, bed management, nursing, theatres, physiotherapy, radiology and outpatients were involved. Patients with medial compartment osteoarthritis undergoing unicompartmental knee replacement who passed strict exclusion criteria were recruited. Factors included; unsuitable home situation (no phone, excessive stairs, no support person), low tolerance to NSAIDS, and not living within a 25 mile radius of the hospital. To date seven NHS patients (mean age 60 years) have been recruited. All patients underwent preoperative assessment and counselling. The mean preoperative Oxford Knee Score was 24/48, the mean Knee Society Score (KSS) was 43/100 and average pain score was 14/50 indicating all patients had significant dysfunction and pain before operation. Average knee flexion was 111° and the average flexion deformity was 5°.

Each patient had a medial UKR using the minimally invasive approach and then underwent the accelerated recovery program. The program included pain control, accelerated rehabilitation, dedicated instructions and self assessment. Post operative pain was controlled by an intra-operative infiltration of local anaesthetic around the knee and large doses of NSAIDs. All patients were mobilised on the day of surgery and all except one who was delayed for administrative reasons) were discharged the following day. Patients were discharged in an extension splint and provided with post operative instructions including an emergency back up telephone number. A designated clinician made regular contact with the patient at home to assess progress. Patients were then assessed in clinic at 6 days, 13 days, and 6 weeks after surgery.

Patients average pain scores at 7 days and 14 days were 2/10 and 2.2/10 respectively. At 6 week follow up the average knee flexion was 124° and average flexion deformity was 1°. All patients were walking independently and painfree. No complications were encountered except one patient required further manipulation for limited knee flexion.

The new pain control protocol permits early mobilisation and discharge for patients undergoing UKR. Potential benefits include increased patient comfort, functional rehabilitation, avoidance of hospital induced infection and substantial cost benefits to the NHS. The pilot study demonstrates that, provided adequate communication is maintained between involved personnel, the program is both practical and safe. It now is planned to implement the accelerated recovery program for UKR as routine.