The National Institute for Health and Clinical
Excellence (NICE) has thus far relied on historical data and predominantly
industry-sponsored trials to provide evidence for venous thromboembolic
(VTE) prophylaxis in joint replacement patients. We argue that the
NICE guidelines may be reliant on assumptions that are in need of
revision. Following the publication of large scale, independent
observational studies showing little difference between low-molecular-weight
heparins and aspirin, and recent changes to the guidance provided
by other international bodies, should NICE reconsider their recommendations? Cite this article:
Femoroacetabular impingement (FAI) causes pain
and chondrolabral damage via mechanical overload during movement
of the hip. It is caused by many different types of pathoanatomy,
including the cam ‘bump’, decreased head–neck offset, acetabular
retroversion, global acetabular overcoverage, prominent anterior–inferior
iliac spine, slipped capital femoral epiphysis, and the sequelae
of childhood Perthes’ disease. Both evolutionary and developmental factors may cause FAI. Prevalence
studies show that anatomic variations that cause FAI are common
in the asymptomatic population. Young athletes may be predisposed
to FAI because of the stress on the physis during development. Other
factors, including the soft tissues, may also influence symptoms and
chondrolabral damage. FAI and the resultant chondrolabral pathology are often treated
arthroscopically. Although the results are favourable, morphologies
can be complex, patient expectations are high and the surgery is
challenging. The long-term outcomes of hip arthroscopy are still
forthcoming and it is unknown if treatment of FAI will prevent arthrosis.
Giant cell tumours (GCTs) of the small bones
of the hands and feet are rare. Small case series have been published but
there is no consensus about ideal treatment. We performed a systematic
review, initially screening 775 titles, and included 12 papers comprising
91 patients with GCT of the small bones of the hands and feet. The
rate of recurrence across these publications was found to be 72%
(18 of 25) in those treated with isolated curettage, 13% (2 of 15)
in those treated with curettage plus adjuvants, 15% (6 of 41) in
those treated by resection and 10% (1 of 10) in those treated by
amputation. We then retrospectively analysed 30 patients treated for GCT
of the small bones of the hands and feet between 1987 and 2010 in
five specialised centres. The primary treatment was curettage in
six, curettage with adjuvants (phenol or liquid nitrogen with or
without polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA)) in 18 and resection in six.
We evaluated the rate of complications and recurrence as well as
the factors that influenced their functional outcome. At a mean follow-up of 7.9 years (2 to 26) the rate of recurrence
was 50% (n = 3) in those patients treated with isolated curettage,
22% (n = 4) in those treated with curettage plus adjuvants and 17%
(n = 1) in those treated with resection (p = 0.404). The only complication
was pain in one patient, which resolved after surgical removal of remnants
of PMMA. We could not identify any individual factors associated
with a higher rate of complications or recurrence. The mean post-operative
Musculoskeletal Tumor Society scores were slightly higher after
intra-lesional treatment including isolated curettage and curettage
plus adjuvants (29 (20 to 30)) compared with resection (25 (15 to
30)) (p = 0.091). Repeated curettage with adjuvants eventually resulted
in the cure for all patients and is therefore a reasonable treatment
for both primary and recurrent GCT of the small bones of the hands
and feet. Cite this article:
The aim of this study was to review the role
of clinical trial networks in orthopaedic surgery. A total of two
electronic databases (MEDLINE and EMBASE) were searched from inception
to September 2013 with no language restrictions. Articles related
to randomised controlled trials (RCTs), research networks and orthopaedic
research, were identified and reviewed. The usefulness of trainee-led
research collaborations is reported and our knowledge of current
clinical trial infrastructure further supplements the review. Searching
yielded 818 titles and abstracts, of which 12 were suitable for
this review. Results are summarised and presented narratively under
the following headings: 1) identifying clinically relevant research
questions; 2) education and training; 3) conduct of multicentre
RCTs and 4) dissemination and adoption of trial results. This review
confirms growing international awareness of the important role research
networks play in supporting trials in orthopaedic surgery. Multidisciplinary
collaboration and adequate investment in trial infrastructure are crucial
for successful delivery of RCTs. Cite this article:
In the absence of patellar resurfacing, we have
previously shown that the use of electrocautery around the margin of
the patella improved the one-year clinical outcome of total knee
replacement (TKR). In this prospective randomised study we compared
the mean 3.7 year (1.1 to 4.2) clinical outcomes of 300 TKRs performed
with and without electrocautery of the patellar rim: this is an
update of a previous report. The overall prevalence of anterior knee
pain was 32% (95% confidence intervals [CI] 26 to 39), and 26% (95%
CI 18 to 35) in the intervention group compared with 38% (95% CI
29 to 48) in the control group (chi-squared test; p = 0.06). The
overall prevalence of anterior knee pain remained unchanged between
the one-year and 3.7 year follow-up (chi-squared test; p = 0.12). The
mean total Western Ontario McMasters Universities Osteoarthritis
Indices and the American Knee Society knee and function scores at
3.7 years’ follow-up were similar in the intervention and control
groups (repeated measures analysis of variance p = 0.43, p = 0.09
and p = 0.59, respectively). There were no complications. A total
of ten patients (intervention group three, control group seven)
required secondary patellar resurfacing after the first year. Our study suggests that the improved clinical outcome with electrocautery
denervation compared with no electrocautery is not maintained at
a mean of 3.7 years’ follow-up. Cite this article:
This study describes the epidemiology and outcome
of 637 proximal humeral fractures in 629 elderly (≥ 65 years old) patients.
Most were either minimally displaced (n = 278, 44%) or two-part
fractures (n = 250, 39%) that predominantly occurred in women (n
= 525, 82%) after a simple fall (n = 604, 95%), who lived independently
in their own home (n = 560, 88%), and one in ten sustained a concomitant
fracture (n = 76, 11.9%). The rate of mortality at one year was
10%, with the only independent predictor of survival being whether
the patient lived in their own home (p = 0.025). Many factors associated
with the patient’s social independence significantly influenced
the age and gender adjusted Constant score one year after the fracture.
More than a quarter of the patients had a poor functional outcome,
with those patients not living in their own home (p = 0.04), participating
in recreational activities (p = 0.01), able to perform their own
shopping (p <
0.001), or able to dress themselves (p = 0.02)
being at a significantly increased risk of a poor outcome, which
was independent of the severity of the fracture (p = 0.001). A poor functional outcome after a proximal humeral fracture is
not independently influenced by age in the elderly, and factors
associated with social independence are more predictive of outcome. Cite this article:
By and large, physicians and surgeons trust what they read, even if they take authors’ conclusions with a pinch of salt. There is a world of difference between being cautious about the implications of what you read and being defrauded by dishonest researchers. Fraud and scientific research are incompatible bedfellows and yet are an unhappy part of our research existence. All subspecialties are to blame and orthopaedics is no exception.
The October 2012 Foot &
Ankle Roundup360 looks at: ankle arthrodesis in young active patients; the Bologna-Oxford total ankle replacements; significant failure and revision rates for total ankle arthroplasty; surgical treatment of Achilles tendon rupture; selective plantar fascia release; whether removal of metalwork can resolve foot pain; allografting of osteochondral lesions; distracting from osteoarthritis; and ultrasound-guided minimally invasive surgery.
This study explores the relationship between
delay to surgical debridement and deep infection in a series of
364 consecutive patients with 459 open fractures treated at an academic
level one trauma hospital in North America. The mean delay to debridement for all fractures was 10.6 hours
(0.6 to 111.5). There were 46 deep infections (10%). There were
no infections among the 55 Gustilo-Anderson grade I open fractures.
Among the grade II and III injuries, a statistically significant
increase in the rate of deep infection was found for each hour of
delay (OR = 1.033: 95% CI 1.01 to 1.057). This relationship shows
a linear increase of 3% per hour of delay. No distinct time cut-off
points were identified. Deep infection was also associated with
tibial fractures (OR = 2.44: 95% CI 1.26 to 4.73), a higher Gustilo-Anderson
grade (OR = 1.99: 95% CI 1.004 to 3.954), and contamination of the
fracture (OR = 3.12: 95% CI 1.36 to 7.36). These individual effects
are additive, which suggests that delayed debridement will have
a clinically significant detrimental effect on more severe open
fractures. Delayed treatment appeared safe for grade 1 open fractures. However,
when the negative prognostic factors of tibial site, high grade
of fracture and/or contamination are present we recommend more urgent
operative debridement. Cite this article:
Total knee replacement (TKR) is an operation
that can be performed with or without the use of a tourniquet. Meta-analyses
of the available Level-1 studies have demonstrated that the use
of a tourniquet leads to a significant reduction in blood loss.
The opponents for use of a tourniquet cite development of complications
such as skin bruising, neurovascular injury, and metabolic disturbance
as drawbacks. Although there may certainly be reason for concern
in arteriopathic patients, there is little evidence that routine
use of a tourniquet during TKR results in any of the above complications.
The use of a tourniquet, on the other hand, provides a bloodless
field that allows the surgeon to perform the procedure with expediency
and optimal visualisation. Blood conservation has gained great importance
in recent years due to increased understanding of the problems associated
with blood transfusion, such as increased surgical site infection
(due to immunomodulation effect), increased length of hospital stay
and increased cost. Based on the authors’ understanding of the available
evidence, the routine use of a tourniquet during TKR is justified
as good surgical practice. Cite this article:
Non-accidental injury (NAI) in children includes orthopaedic trauma throughout the skeleton. Fractures with soft-tissue injuries constitute the majority of manifestations of physical abuse in children. Fracture and injury patterns vary with age and development, and NAI is intrinsically related to the mobility of the child. No fracture in isolation is pathognomonic of NAI, but specific abuse-related injuries include multiple fractures, particularly at various stages of healing, metaphyseal corner and bucket-handle fractures and fractures of ribs. Isolated or multiple rib fractures, irrespective of location, have the highest specificity for NAI. Other fractures with a high specificity for abuse include those of the scapula, lateral end of the clavicle, vertebrae and complex skull fractures. Injuries caused by NAI constitute a relatively small proportion of childhood fractures. They may be associated with significant physical and psychological morbidity, with wide- ranging effects from deviations in normal developmental progression to death. Orthopaedic surgeons must systematically assess, recognise and act on the indicators for NAI in conjunction with the paediatric multidisciplinary team.
The August 2012 Shoulder &
Elbow Roundup360 looks at: platelet-rich fibrin matrix and the torn rotator cuff; ultrasound, trainees, and ducks out of water; the torn rotator cuff and conservative treatment; Bankart repair and subsequent degenerative change; proprioception after shoulder replacement; surgery for a terrible triad, with reasonable short-term results; and the WORC Index.
The technical advances in arthroscopic surgery
of the hip, including the improved ability to manage the capsule
and gain extensile exposure, have been paralleled by a growth in
the number of conditions that can be addressed. This expanding list
includes symptomatic labral tears, chondral lesions, injuries of
the ligamentum teres, femoroacetabular impingement (FAI), capsular
laxity and instability, and various extra-articular disorders, including snapping
hip syndromes. With a careful diagnostic evaluation and technical
execution of well-indicated procedures, arthroscopic surgery of
the hip can achieve successful clinical outcomes, with predictable
improvements in function and pre-injury levels of physical activity
for many patients. This paper reviews the current position in relation to the use
of arthroscopy in the treatment of disorders of the hip. Cite this article:
The February 2014 Hip &
Pelvis Roundup360 looks at: length of stay; cementless metaphyseal fixation; mortality trends in over 400,000 total hip replacements; antibiotics in hip fracture surgery; blood supply to the femoral head after dislocation; resurfacing and THR in metal-on-metal replacement; diabetes and hip replacement; bone remodelling over two decades following hip replacement; and whether bisphosphonates affect acetabular fixation.
We examined the risk of thrombotic and major
bleeding events in patients undergoing total hip and knee replacement
(THR and TKR) treated with thromboprophylaxis, using nationwide
population-based databases. We identified 83 756 primary procedures
performed between 1997 and 2011. The outcomes were symptomatic venous thromboembolism
(VTE), myocardial infarction (MI), stroke, death and major bleeding
requiring hospitalisation within 90 days of surgery. A total of 1114 (1.3%) and 483 (0.6%) patients experienced VTE
and bleeding, respectively. The annual risk of VTE varied between
0.9% and 1.6%, and of bleeding between 0.4% and 0.8%. The risk of
VTE and bleeding was unchanged over a 15-year period. A total of
0.7% of patients died within 90 days, with a decrease from 1% in
1997 to 0.6% in 2011 (p <
0.001). A high level of comorbidity
and general anaesthesia were strong risk factors for both VTE and
bleeding, with no difference between THR and TKR patients. The risk
of both MI and stroke was 0.5%, which remained unchanged during
the study period. In this cohort study of patients undergoing THR and TKR patients
in routine clinical practice, approximately 3% experienced VTE,
MI, stroke or bleeding. These risks did not decline during the 15-year
study period, but the risk of dying fell substantially. Cite this article:
We evaluated the quality of guidelines on thromboprophylaxis
in orthopaedic surgery by examining how they adhere to validated
methodological standards in their development. A structured review
was performed for guidelines that were published between January
2005 and April 2013 in medical journals or on the Internet. A pre-defined
computerised search was used in MEDLINE, Scopus and Google to identify
the guidelines. The AGREE II assessment tool was used to evaluate
the quality of the guidelines in the study. Seven international and national guidelines were identified.
The overall methodological quality of the individual guidelines
was good. ‘Scope and Purpose’ (median score 98% interquartile range
(IQR)) 86% to 98%) and ‘Clarity of Presentation’ (median score 90%,
IQR 90% to 95%) were the two domains that received the highest scores. ‘Applicability’
(median score 68%, IQR 45% to 75%) and ‘Editorial Independence’
(median score 71%, IQR 68% to 75%) had the lowest scores. These findings reveal that although the overall methodological
quality of guidelines on thromboprophylaxis in orthopaedic surgery
is good, domains within their development, such as ‘Applicability’
and ‘Editorial Independence’, need to be improved. Application of
the AGREE II instrument by the authors of guidelines may improve
the quality of future guidelines and provide increased focus on
aspects of methodology used in their development that are not robust. Cite this article: Bone Joint J 2014;96-B:19–23.
Since the introduction of the National Institute
for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) guidelines on thromboprophylaxis
and the use of extended thromboprophylaxis with new oral agents,
there have been reports of complications arising as a result of
their use. We have looked at the incidence of wound complications
after the introduction of dabigatran for thromboprophylaxis in our
unit. We investigated the rate of venous thromboembolism and wound
leakage in 1728 patients undergoing primary joint replacement, both
before and after the introduction of dabigatran, and following its
subsequent withdrawal from our unit. We found that the use of dabigatran led to a significant increase
in post-operative wound leakage (20% with dabigatran, 5% with a
multimodal regimen; p <
0.001), which also resulted in an increased
duration of hospital stay. The rate of thromboembolism in patients
receiving dabigatran was higher (1.3%) than in those receiving the multimodal
thromboprophylaxis regimen, including low molecular weight heparin
as an inpatient and the extended use of aspirin (0.3%, p = 0.047).
We have ceased the use of dabigatran for thromboprophylaxis in these
patients. Cite this article:
The June 2012 Spine Roundup360 looks at: back pain; spinal fusion for tuberculosis; anatomical course of the recurrent laryngeal nerve; groin pain with normal imaging; the herniated intervertebral disc; obesity’s effect on the spine; the medicolegal risks of cauda equina syndrome; and intravenous lidocaine use and failed back surgery syndrome.