Debate continues about the best treatment for patients over 65 years with non-displaced subcapital hip fractures: internal fixation (IF) or hemiarthroplasty (HA). Surgical aggression, mortality, complications and recovery of walking ability after 1year have been compared between both treatments. Match-paired comparison of 2 retrospective cohorts. 220 patients with IF vs 220 receiving a cemented bipolar HA. Matching by age (82.6±7.16 years (65–99)), sex (74.5% women), year of intervention (2013–2021) and ASA scale (24.2% ASA II, 55.8% III, 20.0% IV). Age (p=0.172), sex (p=0.912), year of intervention (p=0.638) and ASA scale (p=0.726) showed no differences. Surgical aggression smaller in IF: Surgical time (p< 0,00001), haemoglobin/haematocrit loss (p <0,00001), need for transfusion (p<0,00008), in-hospital stay (p<0,00001). Mortality: higher in-hospital for hemiarthroplasties (12 deaths (5.5%) vs 1 (0.5%) (p=0.004) (RR=12, 1.5–91.5)). But no significant differences in 1-month (13 hemiarthroplasties, 6%, vs 9 osteosynthesis, 4.1%) and 1-year mortality (33 hemiarthroplasties, 15%, vs 35, 16%). Medical complications: no differences in urinary/respiratory infections, heart failure, ictus, myocardial infarction, digestive bleeding, pressure sores or pulmonary embolus (p=0.055). Surgical complications: no significant differences. HA: 6 intraoperative (2,7%) and 5 postoperative periprosthetic fractures (2,3%), 5 infections (2,3%), 10 dislocations (4,5%), 3 neurovascular injuries. IF: 10 acute fixation failures (4,5%), 2 infections (0,9%), 9 non-unions (4,1%), 16 ischemic necrosis (7,3%). Functional results: no significant differences; 12 patients in each group (5,5%) never walked again (p=1), 110 HA (50%) and 100 IF (45.5%) suffered worsening of previous walking ability (p=0.575), 98 HA (44%) and 108 IF patients (49%) returned to pre-fracture walking ability (p=0.339). Fixation with cannulated screws may be a better option for non-displaced femoral neck fractures because recovery of walking ability and complications are similar, while surgical aggression and in-hospital mortality are lower.
To compare complications, survivorship and results in 2 groups of Furlong-HAP Active, one with ceramic-ceramic and the other with metal-XLPE friction pair Prospective, non-randomized, comparison of 2 series of JRI uncemented prosthesis, implanted with identical protocol by 1 surgeon in 1 hospital from 2006 to 2014. Friction pair was ceramic (Biolox Forte or Delta) in 35 patients of 53.7+/−10.6 years (25–69) (21 males, 60%), and CrCo-XLPE in 65 cases of 69.0+/−8.9 years (42–81) (36 males, 55%); there were significant differences in age (p<0.00001) but not in sex (p=0.6565). Head diameter: Ce-Ce with 19 of 28mm, 9 of 32 and 7 of 36mm; Me-PE with 63 of 28mm, 1 of 32 and 1 of 36. Follow-up averaged 10.5+/−3.1 years (1–15) in ceramic and 9.8+/−3.8 years (2–15) in XLPE group. Pearson, Fisher, Kolmogorov-Smirnov, Student, Mann-Whitney, calculated with the informatic tools Microsoft Excel 2007 and Complications in ceramic joints: 2 late infections (Fisher exact test=0.6101) (1 DAIR, 1 one-stage exchange); 1 dislocation (Fisher exact test=0.2549) (closed reduction); 1 Vancouver C fracture (ORIF) (Fisher exact test=0.6548). Complications in Me-XLPE joints: 2 late infections (Fisher=0.6101) (1 DAIR, 1 two-stage exchange); 7 dislocations (Fisher=0.2549) (2 early, open reduction) (5 late: 3 closed reduction, 1 cup revision, 1 constrained cup); 4 Vancouver B fractures (Fisher=0.6548) (2 intraoperative, cerclages; 2 late, exchange). Final follow-up: Harris Hip Score averaged 93.2+/−13.7 (23–100) in ceramic and 94.3+/−8.7 (65–100) in XLPE joints (p=0.64552). Wear: 0.06+/−0.38mm (0–1.5) in ceramic and 0.16+/−0.5mm (0–2) in Me-PE THAs (p=0.30302). Osteolysis in Charnley-De Lee zones: 8 zones (6 patients) (17%) in ceramic cups, 25 zones (15 patients) (23%) in XLPE cups (p=0.980127). Survivorship without any surgery or closed reduction after 15 years: 91.0% in ceramic joints, 83.8% in Me-XLPE joints. Survivorship without component exchange after 15 years: 93.9% in ceramic joints, 93.6% in Me-XLPE joints. At least after 10 years follow-up of Furlong-HAP Active, metal-XLPE and ceramic-ceramic joints present no significant differences in complications, clinical score, wear, acetabular osteolysis, or survivorship without component exchange. On the contrary, survivorship without any surgery or closed reduction is different because of the high rate of dislocation in 28mm metal-poly joints.
We previously reported the long-term results of the cementless Duraloc-Profile total hip arthroplasty (THA) system in a 12- to 15-year follow-up study. In this paper, we provide an update on the clinical and radiological results of a previously reported cohort of patients at 23 to 26 years´ follow-up. Of the 99 original patients (111 hips), 73 patients (82 hips) with a mean age of 56.8 years (21 to 70) were available for clinical and radiological study at a minimum follow-up of 23 years. There were 40 female patients (44 hips) and 33 male patients (38 hips).Aims
Patients and Methods
We assessed the clinical and radiological outcome of a single uncemented total hip replacement (THR) after twenty years, analysing polyethylene wear and osteolysis. 82 hips implanted between 1992 and 1995 were prospectively evaluated. Mean follow-up was 20.6 years (18–23). A hemispherical porous-coated cup matched to a proximally hydroxyapatite-coated anatomic stem. A 28mm PE liner, sterilised by gamma irradiation in air, was used in all hips. Radiological position, eventual loosening and osteolysis were recorded over time. Penetration of the head into the liner was measured by the Roentgen Monographic Analysis (ROMAN) Tool at 6 weeks, 6 months, one year and yearly thereafter. Six cups were revised due to wear and four cups because of late dislocation. All stems showed osseointegration and all cups appeared radiographically well-fixed. Six unrevised hips showed osteolysis on the acetabular side and two hips on the proximal femur. Creep at one year was 0.30±0.23 mm. Mean total femoral head penetration was 1.23mm at ten years, 1.52mm at 15 years and 1.92mm at 23 years. Overall mean wear was 0.12±0.1 mm/year and 0.09±0.06 mm/year after the creep period. Mean wear was 0.08±0.06 mm/year in hips without osteolysis and 0.14±0.03 mm/year in hips revised or hips with osteolysis (p<0.001). Although continued durable fixation can be observed with porous-coated cups and proximally hydroxyapatite-coated anatomic stems, true wear continues to increase at a constant level over time. PE wear remains as the main reason for osteolysis and revision surgery in uncemented THR after twenty years.
To analyze the evolution of “Tsukayama type IV” infections (unexpected positive intraoperative cultures in hip arthroplasty -THA- exchange because of supposedly mechanical failure) treated with an extended protocol of combined oral antibiotics. Prospective cohort: 14 patients, 66.9+/−10.9 years (40–85), 11 males (78.6%). Eleven suffered isolated cup exchange: 6/14 first cup-exchange, 4/14 second (one with a 1st Slooff impaction-grafting reconstruction and 2 with a 2nd Slooff reconstruction), 1/14 third cup-exchange. Two were operated of isolated stem exchange. One patient received a complete exchange. Cultures identified 10 epidermidis (5 methicillin-resistant -MR-), 4 aureus (3 MR), 1 Propionibacterium, 1 Enterococcus, 1 Escherichia, 1 Streptococcus, 1 Corynebacterium, and 1 Ruminococcus. Patients received 2 oral combined intracellular and biofilm-effective antibiotics for 6 months: ciprofloxacin (8 patients), rifampin (6), amoxicillin-clavulanic (3), levofloxacin (2), clindamycin (3), trimethoprim-sulfamethoxazole (2), fosfomicin (2). Follow-up: 4.5+/−4.3 years (1–14). Healing: absence of clinical, serological and radiographic signs of infection along all followup. Infection reappeared in 1/14 patients (7.1%) with pain, distance limitation and elevated ESR&CRP; patient rejected surgery and was treated with a 2nd cycle of oral antibiotics, disappearing symptoms and serological abnormality along the following 7 years. The other 13 cases maintained normal ESR&CRP along follow-up. At the end of follow-up, 4/14 hips remain asymptomatic and with no limitation of function, 11/14 present no pain, 10/14 walk over 1Km without support, 1/11 uses a cane, 1/14 two crutches, and 2/14 a walker. In conclusión, oral combined antibiotics may be a useful alternative therapy for Tsukayama type IV hip arthroplasty infections.
Combination of antibiotics with N-acetylcisteine and sub-MIC concentration of erythromycin was evaluated in two collection and 16 clinical strains of staphylococci isolated from PJI. The results were strain-dependent, so it evidences the necessity of perform individual studies of biofilm susceptibility. Staphylococci are the most common cause of prosthetic joint infections (PJI) (1), making the treatment of this disease difficult due to the increased resistance to antibiotics of biofilms. Combination between antibiotics and other compounds could be a good alternative. The aim of this study was to evaluate the effect of the combination of two compounds with nine antibiotics in biofilms formed by staphylococcal strains isolated from PJI.Summary Statement
Objectives
Prosthetic joint related-infections (PJRI) are severe complications in orthopaedic surgery. 35 staphylococcal strains INTRODUCTION
MATERIAL AND METHODS
Observational and retrospective comparison of incidence or prevalence of all risk factors described in the literature. These factors have been classified according to the period of risk in: epidemiologic; pre, intra and postoperative; and distant infections.
Pearson was used for comparison of qualitative variables and ANOVA for quantitative ones.
Preoperative conditions: previous surgery in the same knee (25% vs 9%), chronic therapy with glucocorticoids (19% vs 4%), immunosuppressive treatments (16% vs 3%), and non-rheumatoid inflammatory arthritis (13% vs 0%). Patients in this case-control did not present a significant difference in the prevalence of rheumatoid arthritis, diabetes, obesity (BMI>
30), chronic liver diseases, or alcohol addiction. Intraoperative facts: a prolonged surgical time (149 min vs 108 min) and intraoperative fractures. Differences were not found in the amount of bleeding or need for transfusion. Postoperative events: secretion of the wound longer than 10 days (48% vs 0%), wound haematoma (36% vs 6%), new surgery in the knee (30% vs 0%), and deep venous thrombosis in lower limbs (10% vs 1%). Distant infections (risk for haematogenous seeding): deep cutaneous (27% vs 3%), generalized sepsis (7% vs 0%), upper and lower urinary tract (27% vs 5%), pneumonias and bronchopneumonias (27% vs 5%), and diverse abdominal focus (17% vs 1%). On the contrary, significant differences were not found in the prevalence of severe oral or dental infections. Epidemiologic characteristics: significant differences were not found in gender or in the prevalence of any aetiology.
to control and minimize these risk factors when present when this is not possible not possible, to implement additional prophylactic measures.
Observational and retrospective comparison of incidence or prevalence of all risk factors described in the literature. These factors have been classified according to the period of risk in: epidemiologic; pre, intra and postoperative; and distant infections.
Pearson was used for comparison of qualitative variables and ANOVA for quantitative ones.
Epidemiologic characteristics: female gender, post-traumatic osteoarthritis (17% vs 3%). On the contrary, primary osteoarthritis is a “protective” factor. Preoperative conditions: previous surgery in the same hip (60% vs 6%), obesity (BMI>
30) (9% vs 1%), chronic therapy with glucocorticoids (13% vs 0%), immunosuppressive treatments, chronic liver diseases (20% vs 2%), alcohol addiction (13% vs 0%) and intravenous drug abuse. Patients in this case-control did not present a significant difference in the prevalence of diabetes (a recognised risk factor for spine and knee surgery) or rheumatoid arthritis. Intraoperative facts: a prolonged surgical time is the only significant risk factor (133 min vs 98 min), but differences were not found in the amount of bleeding, need for transfusion or intraoperative fractures. Postoperative events: secretion of the wound longer than 10 days (46% vs 8%), palpable deep haematoma (27% vs 1%), dislocation of the prosthesis (40% vs 6%), and need for new surgery in the hip (21% vs 1%). Distant infections (risk for haematogenous seeding): deep cutaneous (30% vs 8%), upper and lower urinary tract (36% vs 2%), pneumonias and bronchopneumonias (23% vs 5%), and diverse abdominal focus (14% vs 3%). On the contrary, significant differences were not found in the prevalence of severe oral or dental infections.
to control and minimize these risk factors when present when this is not possible not possible, to implement additional prophylactic measures.
Cultures were polymicrobial in 22 cases and by Gram-positive in 55 (80.9%). Highly-resistant organisms: methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus (36 patients) and ESBL-producing Enterobacteriaceae (2 patients). “Problematic-treatment”: Enterococcus (6 patients), Pseudomonas (3 patients), non-fermenting Gram-negative (2), moulds (1). Oral antibiotic selection: according to bacterial sensitivity, biofilm and intracellular effectiveness. Protocolized surgery: two-stage exchange. Average follow-up: 4.7+/−2.7 years (1–11). Healing of infection is diagnosed if absence of clinical, serological and radiological signs of infection during the whole follow-up. Orthopaedic outcome is evaluated by HHS for hips and by KSCRS for knees.
Healing of infection: 59/68 patients (86.8%), 32/37 hips (86.5%) and 27/31 knees (87.1%). Infection not healed: 7/68 cases (10.3%) (4/37 hips, 3/31 knees) (5 by highly-resistant and 1 by “problematic-treatment” bacteria). There are no differences between hips and knees (p=0.55).
Statistically significant differences are not found when comparing subgroups according to Gram stain (p=0.43), multiple vs single bacteria (p=0.47 infective, p=0.71 orthopaedic), highly-resistant bacteria (p=0.2 infective, p=0.1/0.5 orthopaedic), or “problematic-treatment” (p=0.68).
A strong statistical correlation appears between infective and orthopedic results after late arthroplasty infections. With the number of cases presented significant differences in infective or in orthopaedic results are not found when comparing single vs. polymicrobial, gram-negative vs. gram-positive, high vs. low antimicrobial resistance and “problematic-treatment” infections.
Patients undergoing programmed hip/knee arthroplasties frequently have abnormal preoperative urine analysis. Up to 4% of patients undergoing programmed hip/knee arthroplasties have preoperative asymptomatic UTI. Up to now no patient with an abnormal analysis/UTI has developed an arthroplasty infection.
(1) Women undergoing elective hip arthroplasty frequently have abnormal preoperative urine analysis. (2) Asymptomatic urinary infection is only detected in a small percentage of patients that undergo programmed hip arthroplasty. (3) No hip prosthesis infection has been seen during follow-up up to the current time.
We reviewed 111 hemispherical Duraloc series-500 acetabular components with a minimum follow-up of 12 years. The mean clinical and radiological follow-up was 13.4 years (12 to 15). A Profile hydroxyapatite-coated anatomical femoral component was used in each case. Six patients had a late dislocation, for whom the polyethylene liner was exchanged. Each acetabular component was well fixed and all femoral components showed signs of bone ingrowth. The mean rate of femoral head penetration was 0.10 mm/year (0.021 to 0.481). The probability of not developing femoral cortical hypertrophy and proximal osteopenia by 12 years was 80.2% (95% confidence interval, 72.7 to 87.6) and 77.5% (95% confidence interval, 69.7 to 85.2), respectively. Despite these good clinical results, further follow-up is needed to determine whether these prostheses will loosen with time.
- 34 patients, 31 female. average age 72.9 +/− 7.1 years (56–90) - Level of activity previous to fracture: 82.4% level III, 14.6% level II - Displaced (Garden III and IV) fracture of femoral neck excluding pathologic fractures - Hip hemiartrhoplasty with a JRI Furlong bipolar head (22.25 mm inner head), 30 patients with a Furlong HAP-coated uncemented stem and 4 patients with an auto-blocking-type Surgival cemented stem - Follow-up: minimum 2 years, average 2.9 years (2–5) - Clinical evaluation: Merle-DAubigne-Postel six-point scale for pain and for function - Radiological evaluation: measure of joint line width at superior-lateral quadrant (weight bearing area), perpendicular distance from prosthesis head to Kohler line - Statistical analysis: Kolmogorov-Smirnov, ANOVA, Bonferroni, Pearson, and Spearman tests
- Function: average score 4.7 +/− 1.1 after 1 year, 4.7 +/− 1.4 after 2 years, 4.8 +/− 1.3 after 3 years - Radiological joint line: disappeared in 13 patients (38.2%) after 1 year, in 14 (41.2%) after 2 years, in 54.5% of patients after 3 years. Average joint line width in the other patients: 0.9 mm (0.6–1.3) immediately after surgery, 0.6 mm (0.4–0.8) after 1 year, 0.5 mm (0.3–0.7) after 2 years, 0.5 mm (0.2–0.7) after 3 years (p<
0.05) - Distance from head to Kohler line: 5.7 +/− 3.8 mm (4.6–6.8) immediately after surgery, 4.6 +/− 3.7 mm (3.6–5.6) after 1 year, 4.3 +/− 2.9 mm (3.3–5.3) after 2 years, 4.0 +/− 3.3 mm (2.5–5.5) after 3 years (p<
0.05). There were 2 cases of acetabular protrusion.
33 patients were treated from 1996 to 2002: 8 THA, 5 hip hemiarthroplasties, 20 TKA. Bacteriology: 24 Staphylococci of which 16 were methycillin-resistant, 7 multi-resistant Gram-negative, 2 Cory-nebacteriae; 7 polymicrobian. Antibiotic therapy: two simultaneous oral antibiotics, selected according to bacterial sensitivity and intracel-lular effectiveness (rifampin, ofloxacin, ciprofloxacin, levofloxacin, trimethoprim-sulfamethoxazole, fosfomicin, linezolid, doxiciclin), were used on an outpatient basis (between 1st and 2nd surgery, and after 2nd surgery until serological normalization). Patients received intravenous antibiotics and were in-hospital only for one week after surgery. Surgery: two-stage exchange with 2nd stage delayed until clinical and serological normalization. Healing of infection: absence of clinical, serological and radiological evidence of infection along all follow-up. Prospective follow-up: 24-96 months.
Treatment failure: 1 patient (TKA) (3%). THA: 8/8 infections healed: 1 Girdlestone patient (1st stage of exchange) rejected reimplantation; 7 two-stage exchange (good/excellent objective and subjective result). Hip hemiarthroplasty: 5/5 infections healed: 3 Girdlestone (1st stage of exchange surgery, 2nd stage rejected because of hemiplegia or Alzheimer); 2 two-stage exchange (good/excellent objective and subjective result). TKA: 19/20 infections healed: 3 resection-arthroplasty (1st stage of exchange surgery, 2nd stage rejected because of Buerger, cirrhosis or Alzheimer); 17 two-stage exchange (15 good/excellent objective and subjective results, 1 patient needed a debridement 2 months after 2nd surgery because of prolonged aseptic drainage and healed uneventfully, 1 failure described).