Abstract
Debate continues about the best treatment for patients over 65 years with non-displaced subcapital hip fractures: internal fixation (IF) or hemiarthroplasty (HA). Surgical aggression, mortality, complications and recovery of walking ability after 1year have been compared between both treatments.
Match-paired comparison of 2 retrospective cohorts. 220 patients with IF vs 220 receiving a cemented bipolar HA. Matching by age (82.6±7.16 years (65–99)), sex (74.5% women), year of intervention (2013–2021) and ASA scale (24.2% ASA II, 55.8% III, 20.0% IV).
Age (p=0.172), sex (p=0.912), year of intervention (p=0.638) and ASA scale (p=0.726) showed no differences.
Surgical aggression smaller in IF: Surgical time (p< 0,00001), haemoglobin/haematocrit loss (p <0,00001), need for transfusion (p<0,00008), in-hospital stay (p<0,00001).
Mortality: higher in-hospital for hemiarthroplasties (12 deaths (5.5%) vs 1 (0.5%) (p=0.004) (RR=12, 1.5–91.5)). But no significant differences in 1-month (13 hemiarthroplasties, 6%, vs 9 osteosynthesis, 4.1%) and 1-year mortality (33 hemiarthroplasties, 15%, vs 35, 16%).
Medical complications: no differences in urinary/respiratory infections, heart failure, ictus, myocardial infarction, digestive bleeding, pressure sores or pulmonary embolus (p=0.055).
Surgical complications: no significant differences. HA: 6 intraoperative (2,7%) and 5 postoperative periprosthetic fractures (2,3%), 5 infections (2,3%), 10 dislocations (4,5%), 3 neurovascular injuries. IF: 10 acute fixation failures (4,5%), 2 infections (0,9%), 9 non-unions (4,1%), 16 ischemic necrosis (7,3%).
Functional results: no significant differences; 12 patients in each group (5,5%) never walked again (p=1), 110 HA (50%) and 100 IF (45.5%) suffered worsening of previous walking ability (p=0.575), 98 HA (44%) and 108 IF patients (49%) returned to pre-fracture walking ability (p=0.339).
Fixation with cannulated screws may be a better option for non-displaced femoral neck fractures because recovery of walking ability and complications are similar, while surgical aggression and in-hospital mortality are lower.
