Reverse total shoulder replacement is a viable surgical option for Cuff Tear Arthropathy. Short term results have been promising. Longer term follow-up has demonstrated a high rate of scapular notching. This is attributed to mechanical impingement between the humeral cup and scapular neck when the arm is fully adducted. The long term sequelae of scapular notching are unclear but there is concern that it may compromise fixation of the glenoid component and affect functional outcomes. Design modifications to address this problem include the newly available eccentric glenospheres and larger diameter glenospheres. These glenospheres are designed to offer greater ranges of motion and theoretically may reduce the risk of impingement and notching. The purpose of this biomechanical study is to demonstrate the difference in range of motions with each design of glenosphere. To our knowledge there is no published literature evaluating this design differences. The SMR (Lima Orthotec) reverse total shoulder prothesis was implanted into a synthetic bone model (Sawbones, Pacific Laboratories, Vashon, Washington). Four different types of glenospheres (Standard 36 mm, Eccentric 36 mm, Standard 44 mm, Eccentric 44 mm) were then implanted into the same model which was fixed on a measurement table. The precision coordinate measurement device (FARO-Arm, SO6/Rev22, FARO Technologies Inc., Lake Mary, Florida) was used to establish the centres of rotation and ranges of motion. To date, the collection of data has just been completed, but the data are yet to be analysed. In conclusion, this is a biomechanical study evaluating the ranges of motion and risk of notching, comparing different designs of glenospheres in Reverse Total Shoulder Joint Replacement.
Total elbow arthroplasty (TEA), as a primary procedure and open reduction and internal fixation (ORIF) have been used to treat complex intra-articular distal humeral fractures in elderly patients. The failure rate after ORIF is high and TEA has often been used as a salvage procedure. Although satisfactory results have been reported after TEA as a primary procedure, there are no publications reporting the results of TEA after failed internal fixation (FIF). In this study we compared the results of patients that had TEA after FIF with those that had had primary arthroplasty (PA). We reviewed the results of 9 consecutive patients who had FIF with 12 patients who had PA. All the operations were performed by one surgeon using the same technique and same prosthesis. Both groups of patients were similar with respect to ages, sex, co-morbidity and hand dominance. The mean follow-up for both groups of patients was 5 years. At final review, patients who had had FIF had a mean Mayo score of 68 and a range of flexion/extension of 90 degrees, there was 1 infection and 1 case of loosening. The PA group had a mean Mayo score of 88 and a range of flexion/extension of 96 degrees, there were no cases of infection or loosening. This study shows the results of TEA are satisfactory either as a PA or after FIF, however the results after PA are significantly better than after FIF.
Implant malposition remains one of the common causes of total knee replacement (TKR) failure and increased wear. Recent advances in computer technology have made available navigation systems for TKR and other orthopaedic procedures. The purpose of our study was:
to develop a method to assess the accuracy of an image-free TKR navigation system; to assess its accuracy in a leg with normal or near-normal mechanical axis; to assess its accuracy in a leg with abnormal mechanical axis. The system chosen was an image-free system based on electromagnetic technology, the MedTronic AxiEM TKR navigation system. To facilitate measurements, an artificial leg (phantom) was constructed from machined Plexiglas with simulated hip and knee joints. Additional joints located at the midshaft of the tibia and femur allowed deformation in the flexion/extension (y), varus/valgus (x) and rotational (z) planes. Using a highly accurate digital calliper unit (FaroARM Technologies, USA) to precisely measure co-ordinates with pre-machined points on the phantom, a software program was developed to convert these local co-ordinates into a determination of actual leg alignment. This technique was verified using repeated measurement with variable coordinates, giving accuracy to within 0.05 of a degree. Simulated procedures were then performed with both normal and abnormal leg mechanical axis. At specific points in the procedure, information was compared between the FaroARM digital measurements and the CAS system. Repeated serial measurements were undertaken. In the setting of normal alignment, accuracy to within one degree was demonstrated. In the setting of abnormal x, y and z plane alignment in both femur and tibia, accuracy to within two degrees was demonstrated. Several clinical studies have been performed to assess the precision of computer navigation in TKR. This study was designed to assess the accuracy of a clinically validated navigation system. The study demonstrates the high level of in-vitro accuracy of the MedTronic AxiEM navigation system in both normal and abnormal mechanical leg alignment settings.
This study evaluated the impact of smoking on the surgical outcome of rotator cuff repair controlling for age, gender, and size of tear. Two hundred and fifty patients were evaluated by a blind evaluator and by self report (SST and WORC questionnaires) at baseline and one year post-op. Types of cuff repair included arthroscopic, mini-open and open procedures. Smoking status was evaluated as a current smoker, quit, or never smoked. Smoking history was subsequently dichotomised into smoker and non-smoker. Generalised linear modeling was used to determine the impact of smoking on surgical outcome using age, gender, and tear size as covariates. The mean age of the population used was 56+/−11 years in which 70% were males and 30% females. Tear size was distributed amongst this population as small (0–1 cm {44.9%}), moderate (1–3cm {22.7%}), large (3–5cm {15.2%}) and massive (5+cm {17.2%}). All preliminary analyses indicated gender affected tear size and surgical outcomes, and was also associated with smoking status. Due to this confounding effect, males and females were separated for subsequent analysis. The SST questionnaire found smoking to have a significant negative effect on the 1-year l outcomes of males (8.5 vs. 6.1 p=0.025). A similar trend was seen with the WORC (p=0.07). No significant effects were seen for females, but the sample size was underpowered. Analysis of this population of rotator cuff repairs showed complex interrelationships may exist between gender, age, physical demands and smoking status. The existence of these confounding interrelationships may explain the mixed results seen in the literature concerning smoking and orthopedic procedures. This relatively large cohort established a negative impact of smoking on outcome, after controlling for covariates and confounders. Future research on mediators of cuff outcome should consider potential confounders. Conclusion: Smoking negatively effected surgical outcomes for males but was inconclusive for females. Sex behaved as a confounding variable that masked the smoking effects.
A number of densitometry studies have reported dramatic density losses in the acetabular region after uncemented Total Hip Arthroplasty (THA)1,2. However the mechanical implication of such loss is not yet known. This study aims to perform a mechanical analysis with patient specific Finite Element (FE) models to find out how the stress distribution affects the Bone Mineral Density (BMD) changes after uncemented THA. An existing patient CT dataset collected for a densitometry study was used to generate patient-specific FE models with a previously validated FE mesh generation method3. Boundary and loading conditions included the hip joint force and the forces of 21 muscles attached to the pelvic bone at eight characteristic phases of a gait cycle 4. Tensile and compressive components of principal stresses were calculated after each simulation. In general, both compressive and tensile principal stresses decreased after uncemented THA but the magnitude of decrease for tensile stresses was much greater than compressive stresses. The changes in tensile stresses were matched with BMD loss patterns. In particular, the densitometry study revealed that areas dorsal to the prosthesis lost more bone density than areas ventral to the prosthesis1. The stress distribution pattern showed that such areas experienced high tensile stress initially and then a dramatic decrease in their magnitude while their compressive stresses remained relatively unchanged. On the other hand, the regions where BMD was maintained - the areas superior to the cup - experienced high compressive stresses initially, which remained relatively high three years after the surgery. Although it is a result from one patient, results suggest that changes to tensile and compressive stresses might influence BMD differently after uncemented THA. Our hypothesis is that regions with high tensile stress experience bone loss while BMD of the regions with high compressive stress are maintained. More patient datasets are being processed to test this hypothesis. Findings from this study can explain the phenomena of retroacetabular osteolysis, late migration and implant failure of press-fit cups observed in long-term clinical studies.
Implant malposition is one of the most common causes of failure in resurfacing arthroplasty of the hip (RAH). Recent advances in computer technology have made available navigation systems for RAH and other orthopaedic procedures. The purpose of our study was:
to develop a method to assess the accuracy of an image-free RAH navigation system; to assess its accuracy in a leg with normal anatomy and with deformity of the proximal femur. We used the Ci-CAS RAH navigation system (DePuy - BrainLab). To facilitate measurements, an artificial leg (phantom) was constructed from machined aluminium with simulated hip and knee joints. The hip and knee articulating surfaces were synthetic bone material (Sawbones – Pacific Laboratories). An additional joint located at the trochanteric region allowed deformation in varus/valgus and ante/retroversion of the head/neck segment. Using a highly accurate digital calliper unit (FaroARM Technologies, USA) to precisely measure co-ordinates with pre-machined points on the phantom, a software program was developed to convert these local co-ordinates into a determination of actual anatomy and leg alignment. This technique was verified using repeated measurement with variable co-ordinates, giving accuracy to within 0.05 of a degree. Simulated procedures were performed with both normal and abnormal anatomy of the proximal femur. At specific points in the procedure, information was compared between the FaroARM digital measurements and the Ci-CAS system. Repeated serial measurements were undertaken. In the setting of normal alignment, accuracy to within 0.5 degrees was demonstrated. In the setting of abnormal alignment (varus/valgus and ante/retroversion) of the proximal femur, accuracy to within 2 degrees was demonstrated. To our knowledge, this is the first study to assess accuracy of a RAH navigation system. The study demonstrates a satisfactory level of accuracy for the Ci-CAS in both normal and abnormal anatomical settings. Currently, no international standard or methodology exists against which these results can be compared. In the near future, introduction of new navigation technologies will make crucial the development of international standards for pre-clinical validation of computer-assisted navigation systems. The present study is a first attempt to address this issue.
Cannulated screw fixation is currently the treatment of choice for slipped capital femoral epiphyses (SCFE). A SCFE module of the Bonedoc simulator was created in order to test the ability of advanced trainees to place the screw in the correct position, and the practicality of using the simulator within the orthopaedic surgery training curriculum. Bonedoc (University of Auckland) is a virtual reality simulator of image guided orthopaedic operations Forty two advanced trainees operated on the same virtual SCFE during a training weekend. The trainees had 25 minutes to become familiar with the simulator and complete the operative case. The trainees performed all tasks relevant to the operation. At the operation’s conclusion the trainees self-assessed their performance. Subsequently the simulator provided surgically relevant objective feedback on aspects such as exact position of the screw, misplaced attempts and the number of x-rays. The results were analysed using SAS (SAS Institute, USA) in subgroups based on year on the scheme, as well as correlated within each operation. There was no difference in the accuracy with which the virtual slipped capital femoral epiphysis was pinned by trainees in different years in the training programme. However, 26 of the 39 of the virtual screws were placed in the superior direction. There was no correlation between number of X-ray images taken and final accuracy of screw placement. The number of misplaced drill holes was correlated both with number of X-ray images taken (p<
0.01) and operative time (p<
0.01) but not with final accuracy of the screw. An increase in misplaced attempts was correlated with angulation errors in the anterior plane (p<
0.01). There was no correlation between the trainees’ self assessment and any of the measured variables. The Bonedoc simulator provides a means to test trainees on technical aspects of a surgical procedure. It provides objective results, which can mimic real world outcomes. In addition, the ability to test all trainees on the same virtual operative case allows standardisation of assessment. All trainees completed the task to a similar level of accuracy, which may reflect the overall skill level in advanced trainees within the New Zealand. However, many trainees placed the screw in the superior portion of the femoral head, which is thought to increase the risk of avascular necrosis
Cerebral palsy (CP) results from an injury to the immature brain; and it leads to progressive musculoskeletal (MS) impairment in most affected patients. Orthopaedic surgery involving muscle-tendon lengthening is a method for managing short muscles in CP patients. Knowledge of muscle length prior to surgery is beneficial to surgical success. However, using common assessment methods like 3D gait analysis or physical examination, accurate pre-surgery estimation of muscle lengths during walking is difficult. Computer models of the lower limbs, which provide more insight into muscle functioning during walking, have become increasingly important within the research field of CP. MS models are commonly driven by joint kinematics from clinical gait analysis. The most often used MS model in CP related research is based on the geometry of an adult human man with muscles modelled as line segments. This approach might be reasonable for small muscles with well-defined paths; however, for long muscles with multiple attachment points and curved paths, a more realistic 3D muscle model is required. The aim of this study is the development of a clinical assessment tool for CP patients by incorporating kinematic data from gait analysis into a 3D finite-element MS model of the lower limbs. Ethical approval has been obtained to develop subject-specific MS models of 12 children with CP and 12 control children (age 8 – 12 years) based on magnetic resonance images. Kinematic data from 3D gait analysis is used as input data to transform the bony structures. Soft-tissue muscle deformation is modelled according to a variant of free-form deformation called the Host-Mesh Fitting Technique. So far, MS models of the lower limbs of three control children and of one child with CP were developed. The resulting muscle length changes during walking agree reasonably well with published data. The proposed modelling approach together with the library of 24 MS models will enable us to develop a powerful tool to investigate gait of children with CP.
The goal of this study was to determine which of two techniques for the treatment of peri-prosthetic femoral shaft fractures has the greatest torsional integrity. The study designed was a laboratory study, using 13 matched pairs of embalmed femurs. The femurs were implanted with a cemented total hip prosthesis, with a transverse osteotomy distal to the stem. These fractures were fixed either with a metal plate with three proximal unicortical screws and three distal bicortical screws or with three proximal cables and three distal bicortical screws. The fracture fixation was tested to failure in torsion. The pattern of failure and torsional limits were recorded. There was no significant difference to failure level between the two constructs. Failure with the proximal unicortical screws was usually catastrophic versus non-catastrophic with proximal cables. The femurs were significantly more likely to fracture in internal rotation. Treatment with proximal cables has the same load to failure in torsion but significantly less complications than with unicortical screws, in agreement with the literature. The findings of the construct being weaker in internal rotation, appears to be a new finding and an area of possible new research.
The purpose of this study was to establish a model to predict the future need for total hip and knee replacement surgery over the next ten years. Analysis based on queuing theory and Ontario data (Ontario Joint Replacement Registry) considered such factors as changing demographics, specific wait time objectives and changing indicators to predict the future need for THR and TKR up to 2015. 26 725 Ontarians were waiting for THR and TKR surgery on any given day in 2004–05. Each month, the number of new decisions for surgery exceeded the actual number of surgeries by over 20%, adding another five hundred patients to the wait list. We predict that the population >
fifty-five years of age will increase by 3.4% annually and that the willingness of patients to consider TJR surgery will increase by 8.7%/year To reduce wait times and establish a steady state of waiting (less than 6 months wait), more than 50 000 surgeries per year must be provided within five years and 70 000 total joint replacements per year by 2014–15 as compared to the 31 448 performed annually at this time. Providing this volume of surgeries means that the number of surgeons will have to double within five to seven years. The results of this queuing theory analysis predict a substantial need for markedly increased THR and TKR volumes and orthopaedic manpower over the next decade.
Long term clinical follow-up of total hip arthroplasty (THA) has identified problems associated with cyst formation. Such cysts are formed as a result of expansile osteolysis, which starts on a small area of the skeleton and spreads into the bone away from the surface of the prosthesis. Since large areas of the prosthesis are still in immediate contact with the skeleton the prosthesis is not loose and the patients are usually without pain. However this form of osteolysis may destroy large areas of the skeleton before it is detected and result in a sudden fracture due to a weakened skeleton. While there are some short term prospective trials that have shown changes in bone density in the periacetabular region, one needs a biomechanical model to understand factors that influence bone remodeling leading to cyst formation. This study aims to develop a mathematical model for studying the mechanical effects of bone cysts in the acetabulum of THA patients. 2D finite element (FE) models of patients with known restroacetabular cystic disease were generated using coronal CT images from the central region of the acetabulum. The boundary between bone and soft tissue was segmented and an FE model generated. Mesh convergence tests were performed to identify a suitable level of mesh refinement. Three material zones representing– cortical bone (E=17GPa), cancellous bone (E=1GPa) and a titanium cup (E=120GPa) – were included in the model. A series of simulations were run to investigate how cysts affect stress distribution as well as the mechanical consequence of medial wall deficiency. The presence of a cyst did not alter the pattern of stress distribution in the lateral and medial wall. But the strain energy function increased significantly at the inferior margin of the cyst within its cancellous bone. This may encourage bone formation at the cyst margin and help to explain the sclerotic walls seen in some cysts. Models with absent medial walls showed that both compressive and tensile stresses lowered in the cortical wall and the strain energy function reduced almost to zero. This suggests that a medial wall defect has a high risk of progression. The current 2D model cannot incorporate complex acetabular geometry or complex forces acting on the hip. Therefore the current model will be further developed into a 3D FE model of the whole pelvis that also represents the pelvic ring structure more adequately. Physiologically meaningful boundary conditions as well as patient specific geometry and material properties will be used to investigate mechanical effects of bone cysts realistically.
Lateralisation of the tuberosity tibia causes distal malalignment of the extensor mechanism of the knee and can lead to lateral tracking patella (LTP), resulting in anterior knee pain, or objective patellar instability (OPI), resulting in recurrent luxations. For a precise preoperative diagnosis the tuberositas tibia (TT) trochlear groove (TG) distance was measured on a CT scan. A distance of more than 15 mm was considered to be pathological. In a prospective study, the clinical results of a subtle, CT-guided medial tuberosity transfer for LTP and OPI were evaluated. 30 Consecutive patients with LTP and 30 patients with OPI and an increased TT TG were included. Outcomes were documented at 3, 12 and 24 months follow-up using the Lysholm scale, the Kujala score, and a visual analogue pain score. Postoperatively all but one patient reported good improvement in stability (no persistent subluxations or luxations). All patients had a marked improvement in pain and functional scores at follow up. Complications seem to be related to the peroperative technique. CT-guided TT transfer appears to be satisfactory and safe method for treating patients with an increased TT TG leading to either LTP or OPI.
This article has been retracted, an editorial will follow.
In recent years, some attempts have been made to develop a method that generates finite element (FE) models of the femur and pelvis using CT. However, due to the complex bone geometry, most of these methods require an excessive amount of CT radiation dosage. Here we describe a method for generating accurate patient-specific FE models of the total hip using a small number of CT scans in order to reduce radiation exposure. A previously reported method for autogenerating patient-specific FE models of the femur was extended to include the pelvis. CT osteodensitometry was performed on 3 patients who had hip replacement surgery and patient-specific FE models of the total hip were generated. The pelvis was generated with a new technique that incorporated a mesh morphing method called ‘host mesh fitting’. It used an existing generic mesh and then morphed it to reflect the patient specific geometry. This can be used to morph the whole pelvis, but our patient dataset was limited to the acetabulum. An algorithm was developed that automated all the procedures involved in the fitting process. Average error between the fitted mesh and patient specific data sets for the femur was less than 1mm. The error for the pelvis was about 2.5mm. This was when a total 18 CT scans with 10mm gap were used – 12 of the femur, and 6 of the pelvis. There was no element distortion and a smooth element surface was achieved. Previously, we reported a new method for automatically generating a FE model of the femur with as few CT scans as possible. Here we describe a technique that customizes a generic pelvis mesh to patient-specific data sets. Thus we have developed a novel hybrid technique which can generate an accurate FE model of the total hip using significantly less CT scans. An automated method of generating FE models for the total hip with reduced CT radiation exposure will be a valuable clinical tool for surgeons.
In recent years, some attempts have been made to develop a method that generates finite element (FE) models of the femur and pelvis using CT. However, due to the complex bone geometry, most of these methods require an excessive amount of CT radiation dosage. Here we describe a method for generating accurate patient-specific FE models of the total hip using a small number of CT scans in order to reduce radiation exposure. A previously reported method for autogenerating patient-specific FE models of the femur was extended to include the pelvis. CT osteodensitometry was performed on 3 patients who had hip replacement surgery and patient-specific FE models of the total hip were generated. The pelvis was generated with a new technique that incorporated a mesh morphing method called ‘host mesh fitting’. It used an existing generic mesh and then morphed it to reflect the patient specific geometry. This can be used to morph the whole pelvis, but our patient dataset was limited to the acetabulum. An algorithm was developed that automated all the procedures involved in the fitting process. Average error between the fitted mesh and patient specific data sets for the femur was less than 1mm. The error for the pelvis was about 2.5mm. This was when a total 18 CT scans with 10mm gap were used – 12 of the femur, and 6 of the pelvis. There was no element distortion and a smooth element surface was achieved. Previously, we reported a new method for automatically generating a FE model of the femur with as few CT scans as possible. Here we describe a technique that customizes a generic pelvis mesh to patient-specific data sets. Thus we have developed a novel hybrid technique which can generate an accurate FE model of the total hip using significantly less CT scans.
The correct positioning of implant components in total knee replacement (TKR) is important for a successful long-term outcome. In order to address the problems inherent with conventional alignment methods, several computer-assisted navigation systems (CAS) have been developed. Despite numerous reports of clinical outcomes and system reliability, there is a lack of studies independently evaluating the precision and accuracy of such systems. We report on the design and development of a method and device to evaluate the accuracy of such a computer-assisted navigation system in two situations; 1) Normal or near-normal lower limb mechanical axis, and 2)Simulated femoral and/or tibial extra-articular deformity in either varus/valgus (x), internal/external rotation (y) or flexion/extension (z) planes. The system assessed was the Ci Knee-CAS navigation system (BrainLab/De Puy). This image-free system requires the registration of specific anatomical points to identify the mechanical axis of the lower limb and therefore provide information on resection level and alignment. In order to precisely measure and accurately reproduce these points we constructed a phantom device along anatomical guidelines, with lockable joints located at the mid-shaft of both femur and tibia. We then identified geometric CAS data; 1) Tibial resection height, and 2) Tibial resection plane, and using specially written software compared this against validated co-ordinate measurements independently obtained by a FaroArm co-ordinate measurement system (FARO Technologies, USA). This enabled data from the navigation system to be directly compared against highly accurate reference measurements. Accuracy of the system was then assessed with both normal mechanical alignment of the lower limbs and simulated extra-articular deformity.
An abnormal lateral position of the tibial tuberosity causes distal malalignment of the extensor mechanism of the knee and can lead to lateral tracking of the patella causing anterior knee pain or objective patellar instability, characterised by recurrent dislocation. Computer tomography is used for a precise pre-operative assessment of the tibial tubercle-trochlear groove distance. A distance of more than 15 mm is considered to be pathological and an indication for surgery in symptomatic patients. In a prospective study we performed a subtle transfer of the tibial tuberosity according to the information gained from the pre-operative CT scan. This method was applied to two groups of patients, those with painful lateral tracking of the patella, and those with objective patellar instability. We evaluated the clinical results in 30 patients in each group. The outcome was documented at 3, 12 and 24 months using the Lysholm scale, the Kujala score, and a visual analogue pain score. Post-operatively, all but one patient in the instability group who had a patellar dislocation requiring further surgery reported good improvement with no further subluxation or dislocation. All patients in both groups had a marked improvement in pain and functional score. Two patients sustained a tibial fracture six and seven weeks after surgery. One patient suffered a per-operative fracture of the tibial tubercle which later required further fixation. If carefully performed, this type of transfer of the tibial tubercle appears to be a satisfactory technique for the treatment of patients with an increased tibial tubercle-trochlear groove distance and who present with symptoms related to lateral maltracking of the patella.