Abstract
Cannulated screw fixation is currently the treatment of choice for slipped capital femoral epiphyses (SCFE). A SCFE module of the Bonedoc simulator was created in order to test the ability of advanced trainees to place the screw in the correct position, and the practicality of using the simulator within the orthopaedic surgery training curriculum.
Bonedoc (University of Auckland) is a virtual reality simulator of image guided orthopaedic operations1. This simulator runs in Internet Explorer (Microsoft, USA) using the Octaga (Octaga, Norway) plugin. The total download is around 4 MB. The SCFE module was created from a CT scan of a Grade 2 acute on chronic SCFE. DICOM images were imported into 3DView (www.rmrsystems.co.uk) and a mesh created. The generic femur from the DHS module was morphed within the CAD package Blender (Blender.org) to conform to this reconstructed SCFE mesh.
Forty two advanced trainees operated on the same virtual SCFE during a training weekend. The trainees had 25 minutes to become familiar with the simulator and complete the operative case. The trainees performed all tasks relevant to the operation. At the operation’s conclusion the trainees self-assessed their performance. Subsequently the simulator provided surgically relevant objective feedback on aspects such as exact position of the screw, misplaced attempts and the number of x-rays. The results were analysed using SAS (SAS Institute, USA) in subgroups based on year on the scheme, as well as correlated within each operation.
There was no difference in the accuracy with which the virtual slipped capital femoral epiphysis was pinned by trainees in different years in the training programme. However, 26 of the 39 of the virtual screws were placed in the superior direction. There was no correlation between number of X-ray images taken and final accuracy of screw placement. The number of misplaced drill holes was correlated both with number of X-ray images taken (p< 0.01) and operative time (p< 0.01) but not with final accuracy of the screw. An increase in misplaced attempts was correlated with angulation errors in the anterior plane (p< 0.01). There was no correlation between the trainees’ self assessment and any of the measured variables.
The Bonedoc simulator provides a means to test trainees on technical aspects of a surgical procedure. It provides objective results, which can mimic real world outcomes. In addition, the ability to test all trainees on the same virtual operative case allows standardisation of assessment. All trainees completed the task to a similar level of accuracy, which may reflect the overall skill level in advanced trainees within the New Zealand. However, many trainees placed the screw in the superior portion of the femoral head, which is thought to increase the risk of avascular necrosis2. Further work is required to evaluate how accurately performance on the simulator predicts performance in the operating theatre
Correspondence should be addressed to Associate Professor N. Susan Stott at Orthopaedic Department, Starship Children’s Hospital, Private Bag 92024, Auckland, New Zealand
References:
1 Blyth P et al. Injury (in Press); Google Scholar
2 Riley PM et al. JBJS1990; 721500–9 Google Scholar
