Abstract
A number of densitometry studies have reported dramatic density losses in the acetabular region after uncemented Total Hip Arthroplasty (THA)1,2. However the mechanical implication of such loss is not yet known. This study aims to perform a mechanical analysis with patient specific Finite Element (FE) models to find out how the stress distribution affects the Bone Mineral Density (BMD) changes after uncemented THA.
An existing patient CT dataset collected for a densitometry study was used to generate patient-specific FE models with a previously validated FE mesh generation method3. Boundary and loading conditions included the hip joint force and the forces of 21 muscles attached to the pelvic bone at eight characteristic phases of a gait cycle 4. Tensile and compressive components of principal stresses were calculated after each simulation.
In general, both compressive and tensile principal stresses decreased after uncemented THA but the magnitude of decrease for tensile stresses was much greater than compressive stresses. The changes in tensile stresses were matched with BMD loss patterns. In particular, the densitometry study revealed that areas dorsal to the prosthesis lost more bone density than areas ventral to the prosthesis1. The stress distribution pattern showed that such areas experienced high tensile stress initially and then a dramatic decrease in their magnitude while their compressive stresses remained relatively unchanged. On the other hand, the regions where BMD was maintained - the areas superior to the cup - experienced high compressive stresses initially, which remained relatively high three years after the surgery.
Although it is a result from one patient, results suggest that changes to tensile and compressive stresses might influence BMD differently after uncemented THA. Our hypothesis is that regions with high tensile stress experience bone loss while BMD of the regions with high compressive stress are maintained. More patient datasets are being processed to test this hypothesis. Findings from this study can explain the phenomena of retroacetabular osteolysis, late migration and implant failure of press-fit cups observed in long-term clinical studies.
Correspondence should be addressed to David Haynes, PhD, Senior Lecturer, President ANZORS, at Discipline of Pathology, School of Medical Sciences, University of Adelaide, SA, 5005, Australia
