Navigation was used to achieve a balanced
INTRODUCTION:. A discrepancy exists between biomechanical and clinical outcome studies when comparing cruciate-retaining (CR) versus posterior stabilized (PS) component designs. The purpose of this study is to re-evaluate experimental model results using half-body specimens with intact extensor mechanisms and navigation to evaluate PS and CR component gaps though an entire range of motion. METHODS:. A custom-designed knee testing apparatus was used for secure anchoring of the lower half of cadaver pelvic, allowing full range of knee motion and the application of traction throughout that range. Eight sequential testing regimens: were conducted with knee intact, with CR TKA in place, with PS TKA with quadriceps tendon in place, with PS TKA with sectioned quadriceps tendon in place, with and without traction at each stage. At each stage, a navigated knee system with dedicated software was used to record component gapping through a full range of motion from 0° to 120°. The amount of traction used was 22N. Each knee (n = 10) was taken through 6 full ranges of motion at every stage. At each stage, corroboration of navigation findings was attempted using a modified gap balancer to take static gap measurements at 0° and 90° with 12 in. lbs of torque was applied. RESULTS:. The difference in component gapping between CR and PS knees resulted in a range from −0.85 mm to 0.62 mm. The range of component gapping was from −0.67 mm to 0.70 mm with both constructs under 22N traction load. There was no significant difference between loaded and unloaded component gaps, and there were no statistically significant differences in component gapping between CR and PS knees throughout a full range of motion. Static
The study is to evaluate mid-term follow-up clinical results and navigation prediction of the first 106 TKAs, which was performed based on the soft tissue balancing technique using the OrthoPilot navigation system (B.Braun Aesculap, Tuttlingen, Germany). All the 106 cases were diagnosed as osteoarthritis with varus deformity. After anatomical and kinematic registration, the mechanical axis was restored to neutral (±2°) at full extension with step by step meticulous medial soft tissue release and osteophyte removal. Proximal tibial bone cutting was performed under real-time navigation system control. Flexion and extension gaps were measured at full extension and at 90° of flexion using a tensioning device (V-STAT tensor, Zimmer) and a special torque wrench set at 50lb/inch before femoral bone cutting. The flexion and extension gap was evaluated and it’s difference was classified into 3 kinds; balanced, tight flexion gap and tight extension gap. Sixty-one (57.5%) knees were classified as having a ‘balanced gap’ (meaning that flexion and extension gaps were within 2 mm), 20 (18.9%) knees as having a ‘tight flexion gap’ (an extension gap at least 3mm more that the corresponding flexion gap), and 25 (23.6%) knees as having a ‘tight extension gap’ (a flexion gap at least 3mm more that the corresponding extension gap). Depending extension/flexion, and medial/lateral gap difference, the level of distal femoral cut and the rotation of femoral component was determined. Following the final bone cuts and completion of soft tissue release, assessment of the flexion and extension gap was repeated. Balanced flexion and extension gap (difference between flexion and extension gap ≤ 3mm) was confirmed in 99 cases (94%). A mobile bearing prosthesis (e motion FP, B.Braun Aesculap) was used. One patient (bilateral TKAs) died of unrelated causes at postoperative 2 year. One knee was revised due to infection. One hundred three cases were followed up at least more than 4 years, 53 months in average. Overall survival rate is 97%. Average preoperative HHS scores and range of motion (ROM) were 65.4 points (range, 33~82) and 126.8 degrees (80~140). At the last follow-up, HHS score and ROM were 95.0 points (78~100) and 131.4 degrees (110~140). Statistically significant improvement in HHS score and ROM were observed (p<
0.05). The mean mechanical axis was 179.44±1.83° (175~184°) with 8 cases of outliers (more than ±3° of optimum). There was no radiolucency, osteolysis, subsidence, or loosening at the last follow-up. In conclusion, navigation is an excellent predictor for achieving balanced soft tissue &
INTRODUCTION. Mechanical alignment in TKA introduces significant anatomic modifications for many individuals, which may result in unequal medial-lateral or flexion-extension bone resections. The objective of this study was to calculate bone resection thicknesses and resulting gap sizes, simulating a measured resection mechanical alignment technique for TKA. METHODS. Measured resection mechanical alignment bone resections were simulated on 1000 consecutive lower limb CT-Scans from patients undergoing TKA. Bone resections were simulated to reproduce the following measured resection mechanical alignment surgical technique. The distal femoral and proximal tibial cuts were perpendicular to the mechanical axis, setting the resection depth at 8mm from the most distal femoral condyle and from the most proximal tibial plateau (Figure 1). If the resection of the contralateral side was <0mm, the resection level was increased such that the minimum resection was 0mm. An 8mm resection thickness was based on an implant size of 10mm (bone +2mm of cartilage). Femoral rotation was aligned with either the trans-epicondylar axis or with 3 degrees of external rotation to the posterior condyles. After simulation of the bone cuts, media-lateral gap difference and
Introduction. The objective of this study was to assess the effect of PCL resection on
Objective. In Total Knee Arthroplasty (TKA), it is important to adjust the difference of the
Background. Despite the success of total knee arthroplasty (TKA) restoration of normal function is often not achieved. Soft-tissue balance is a major factor leading to poor outcomes including malalignment, instability, excessive wear, and subluxation. Mechanical ligament balancers only measure the joint space in full extension and at 90° flexion. This study uses a novel electronic ligament balancer to measure the ligament balance in normal knees and in knees after TKA to determine the impact on passive and active kinematics. Methods. Fresh-frozen cadaver legs (N = 6) were obtained. A standard cruciate-retaining TKA was performed using measured resection approach and computer navigation (Stryker Navigation, Kalamazoo, MI). Ligament balance was measured using a novel electronic balancer (Fig 1, XO1, XpandOrtho, Inc, La Jolla, CA, USA). The XO1 balancer generates controlled femorotibial distraction of up to 120N. The balancer only requires a tibial cut and can be used before or after femoral cuts, or after trial implants have been mounted. The balancer monitors the distraction gap and the medial and lateral gaps in real time, and graphically displays gap measurements over the entire range of knee flexion. Gap measurements can be monitored during soft-tissue releases without removing the balancer. Knee kinematics were measured during active knee extension (Oxford knee rig) and during passive knee extension under varus and valgus external moment of 10Nm in a passive test rig. Sequence of testing and measurement:. Ligament balance was recorded with the XO1 balancer after the tibial cut, after measured resection of the femur, and after soft-tissue release and/or bone resection to balance flexion-extension and mediolateral gaps. Passive and active kinematics were measured in the normal knee before TKA, after measured resection TKA, and after soft-tissue release and/or bone resection to balance flexion-extension and mediolateral gaps. Results & Discussion. Overall the changes in knee balance affected passive kinematics more than active kinematics. Correcting a tight extension gap by resecting 4 mm from the distal femur had a significant effect on femoral rollback and tibial rotation and increased the varus-valgus laxity of the knee (Fig 2). Sequential release of the MCL increased active femoral rollback and tibial internal rotation primarily in flexion (Fig 3). Combinations of bone resections with ligament release had an additive effect. For example, MCL release combined with 2 mm resection of bone at the distal femoral cut increased total valgus laxity by 8° during passive testing. However, even after balancing the
There is ample data to confirm that Computer-assisted total knee replacement improves alignment of the limb when compared with the conventional technique. There is also published evidence that optimum alignment correlates with longevity of implants. CAS enables accurate component alignment of both femoral and tibial components. It enables accurate restoration of the posterior tibial slope which has important consequences for flexion range and stability of the component in flexion especially if mobile bearing implants are considered. CAS also aids in correctly orienting rotation of the femoral component; this has value in minimizing patellar maltracking. We will present our data showing accurate restoration of joint line and posterior femoral offset. As CAS ensures alignment, rotation, sizing and positioning of components, the surgeon is free to devote his efforts to ensuring soft-tissue balance and stability, since TKA is really a ‘soft-tissue’ operation. How CAS is of immense value in deformity correction and soft-tissue balancing will be illustrated with examples. It helps in better understanding and quantification of the effects of soft-tissue release on
INTRODUCTION. The results of modified gap balancing and measured resection technique have been still controversial. We compared PS-type TKAs for osteoarthritis performed using the modified gap technique and the measured resection to determine if either technique provides superior clinical results. METHODS. The modified gap technique was used in 85 knees, and the measured technique using preoperative CT was used in 70 knees. To compare intra-operative soft tissue balance, bone gap and component gap were measured using original two paddle tensor (20,30,40lb) at 0 degree extension and 90 degrees flexion. To assess the post-operative patella congruency and soft tissue balance, we measured patella tilt, condylar twist angle (CTA) and condylar lift-off angle (LOA) in radiographs. Finally, we evaluated postoperative clinical result (1–5 years) KOOS. Statistical analysis was used by StatView. RESULTS. (1). Component gaps in flexion at measured techniques were bigger than at gap techniques. Lateral
Bicruciate ligament retaining total knee arthroplasty preserves all of the ligaments of the knee while still addressing the ligament balance and the
INTRODUCION. Appropriate soft tissue balance is an important factor for postoperative function and long survival of total knee arthroplasty(TKA). Soft tissue balance is affected by ligament release, osteophyte removal, order of soft tissue release, cutting angle of tibial surface and rotational alignment of femoral components. The purpose of this study is to know the characteristics of soft tissue balance in ACL deficient osteoarthritis(OA) knee and warning points during procedures for TKA. METHODS. We evaluated 139 knees, underwent TKA (NexGen LPS-Flex, fixed surface, Zimmer) by one surgeon (S.A.) for OA. All procedures were performed through a medial parapatellar approach. There were 49 ACL deficient knees. A balanced gap technique was used in 26 ACL deficient knees, and anatomical measured technique based on pre-operative CT was used in 23 ACL deficient knees. To compare
Instability remains a common reason for revision after primary TKA. Careful preoperative examination is necessary to determine the exact direction of and reason for the instability. Radiographs and CT can be useful to evaluate component alignment and rotation. Obviously, ruling out concurrent infection should be a part of the routine preoperative workup. PCL insufficiency can be treated by conversion to a more “dished” insert if available, and all other component issues are acceptable. If dished inserts are not available, then revision to a posterior stabilised component can be effective. Flexion instability can occur with PCL substituting designs, and may require revision as well. Up-sizing, and posteriorising the femoral component (often requiring posterior augmentation) to tighten the flexion gap can be an effective strategy. With collateral ligament problems, so called CCK or “constrained” implants can be effective. While ligament advancement or augmentation techniques have been described, few surgeons are familiar with these techniques, and most “back up” such reconstructions with constrained implants. With more severe collateral ligament deficiencies, multi-directional instabilities, or massive
In primary TKA, non- or semi-constrained TKA implants might have their limitations in the absence of collateral ligaments, severe deformity, large osseous defects and gross flexion-extension instability. Although most primary TKA indications can be solved with modular, non-hinged implants, an adequate balancing might require a relevant soft tissue release. This consequently adds complexity and operative time with less predictable results in the elderly patient. The current literature reporting on short- to mid-term results of rotating hinged implants in primary osteoarthritis shows some quite diverse results and consequently different interpretations of this implant type in primary knee arthroplasty. Although some authors were able to show good and excellent clinical results in 91% of patients and consequent survival rates of a rotating hinge implant after 15 years up to 96% in primary indications, others found high complication rates of up to 25% of all operated patients, which remains unclear for us and is inconsistent with our clinical results in primary and revision TKA in over 30 years of experience with the ENDO-Model rotating hinge implant. Our potential indications in the elderly for a rotating or pure hinged implant in primary TKA include: Complete MCL instability; Severe varus or valgus deformity (>20 degrees) with necessary relevant soft tissue release; Relevant bone loss including insertions of collaterals; Gross
Purpose. The tibia first technique in unicompartmental knee arthroplasty (UKA) may have the advantage that surgeons can obtain a balanced
In primary TKA, non- or semi-constraint TKA implants might have their limitations in the absence of collateral ligaments, severe deformity, large osseous defects and gross flexion - extension instability. Although most primary TKA indications can be solved with modular, non-hinged implants, an adequate balancing might require a relevant soft tissue release. This consequently adds complexity and operative time with less predictable results in the elderly patient. The current literature reporting on short to mid-term results of rotating hinged implants in primary osteoarthritis shows some quite diverse results and consequently different interpretations of this implant type in primary knee arthroplasty. Although some authors were able to show good and excellent clinical results in 91% of patients and consequent survival rates of a rotating hinge implant after 15 years up to 96% in primary indications, others found high complication rates of up to 25% of all operated patients, which remains unclear for us and is inconsistent with our clinical results in primary and revision TKA in over 30 years of experience with the Endo-Model rotating hinge implant. Our potential indications in the elderly for a rotating- or pure-hinged implant in primary TKA include: Complete MCL instability, Severe varus or valgus deformity (>20 degrees) with necessary relevant soft tissue release, Relevant bone loss including insertions of collaterals, Gross
The preoperative prediction of gap balance after robotic total knee arthroplasty (TKA) is difficult. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the effectiveness of a new method of achieving balanced
Background.
Introduction. Achieving proper ligament tension in knee flexion within cruciate retaining (CR) total knee arthroplasty (TKA) has long been associated with clinical success. The distal femoral joint line (DFJL) is routinely used as a variable to assist in achieving proper
Mechanical alignment (MA) techniques for total knee arthroplasty (TKA) may introduce significant anatomic modifications, as it is known that few patients have neutral femoral, tibial or overall lower limb mechanical axes. A total of 1000 knee CT-Scans were analyzed from a database of patients undergoing TKA. MA tibial and femoral bone resections were simulated. Femoral rotation was aligned with either the trans-epicondylar axis (TEA) or with 3° of external rotation to the posterior condyles (PC). Medial-lateral (DML) and
Introduction. Cruciate Retaining (CR) and Posterior Stabilizing (PS) are two common types of total knee arthroplasty (TKA) surgeries. The CR approach preserves the posterior cruciate ligament (PCL) while the PS approach sacrifices it. Implant size selection during a TKA surgery is primarily driven by the patient's bone size, but could also be affected by surgery types due to the influence of the PCL. The objective of this study was to investigate the effect of TKA surgery type on implant size selection, based on the clinical database of a well-established commercial implant system. Methods. A clinical database operated by Exactech, Inc. (Gainesville, FL, USA) was utilized for this study. The database contains TKA patient information of Optetrak® implant recipients from over 30 physicians in the US, UK, and Colombia since 1995. Patient height was used as a control factor for comparison of surgery types, and categorized by every 10 cm (e.g., the “170 cm” category contains patients from 170 to 179 cm). Taking primary TKA only and body heights from 130 cm to 199 cm, a total of 2,677 cases were examined. No statistical difference exists on patients' gender, body weight, or BMI within every height category between the CR and PS groups. The femoral implant size and tibial insert thickness were compared between the two groups. Results. The implant size generally increases with patient height for both CR and PS groups, except for those under 140 cm (Figure 1). For all height categories, the CR patients received consistently smaller implants than the PS patients (p<0.05). On average, a CR TKA was about 0.67 size smaller than a PS TKA (p<0.001). A 0.67 size corresponds to about 2.7 mm in femoral component's AP dimension. Tibial insert thickness does not vary substantially by patient size (Figure 2). The difference between CR and PS groups was also less significant. On average, the CR group's tibial insert was about 0.5 mm thinner than that of the PS group (10.4 mm vs. 10.9 mm). Discussion.