Abstract
Background
Flexion-extension gap balancing is recognized as an essential part of total knee arthroplasty (TKA). The gap is often evaluated using spacer blocks, laminar spreader, or tensor device. The evaluation of gap balancing with the patella in the reduced position is more physiological and reproducible than with patellofemoral (PF) joint everted. However, in the knee with a reduced PF joint, it is difficult to comprehend the anteroposterior position of the tibia to the femur. So, we developed a new tensor to lift up the tibia ahead and fix the anteroposterior position of the tibia to the femur with the PF joint reduced [Fig.1].
Purpose
To investigate how accurate the extension and flexion gaps would be measured by comparing our new tensor with the conventional tensor which could not fix the position of the tibia to the femur.
Methods
This study includes 60 knees in 48 patients underwent TKA using the Posterior Stabilized (PS) Prosthesis (Striker), for varus osteoarthritis. The mean age of patients was 78.2 (62 to 88) at the time of surgery. All knees were exposed using a standard medial parapatellar approach. The posterior cruciate ligament was sacrificed at the beginning of the procedure. A balanced gap technique was used for the femoral and tibial bone cuts. After the completion of bony resection, osteophyte removal, and soft-tissue balancing by the release of the medial collateral ligament (MCL), the offset knee balancer which consisted of an upper seesaw plate and a lower platform plate, and allowed the PF joint reduction during the measurement was inserted into the knee to balance on the knee flexion angles of 0 deg and 90 deg at 30 pounds. We prepared two plate types, one plate which was flat and conventionally-known plate, the other plate to which the claw hook was attached at the end. The tension device provides two measurements: the central gap length (mm) between femur and tibia which was cut, and as the ligament balance, the angle (°) between the seesaw plate and the platform plate with positive values representing varus imbalance. The joint gap measurement was performed at full extention or 90°of flexion using the both tensors. We calculated difference between the two extreme values of the values measured 3 times repeatedly using each tensor, and defined the difference as error span.
Results
In the joint gap at full extention, the error span on the value measured with the claw hook type was 0.9±0.8mm, significantly small compared with the conventional type, 2.8±1.4mm [Fig.2]. On the other hand, the joint gap at 90°of flexion and the ligament balance at full extention and 90°of flexion were not significantly different between the claw hook type and the conventional type [Fig.3].
Conclusion
The tensor of claw hook type have proved to be useful in the joint gap measurement especially at full extention than the conventional type by preventing the tibia from falling posterior to the femur by gravity.
