There is increasing pressure to develop virtual reality surgical simulation that can be used in surgical training. However, little is known of the attitudes of the surgical community towards such simulation, and which aspects of simulation are most important. A postal survey on attitudes to surgical simulation was sent to all New Zealand orthopaedic surgeons and advanced trainees. This comprised 44 questions in ten sections, using either a visual analogue scale (0 to 10) or free text box replies. Results were analysed for two sub-groups; surgeons qualified before 1990 and those qualified in or after 1990 or still in training. Of 208 possible responses, 142 were received, a response rate of 68%. Only 4 respondents had tried a surgical based simulator. Earlier qualified surgeons were more likely to agree that simulation was an effective way to practice surgical procedures, median score 7.7 versus 5.6 (p=0.03). Both groups thought the most important task for simulation was practicing angulation/spatial orientation (median score 8.4/10), while a realistic view of the operation was the most important requirement (median score 9/10). Both groups were unconvinced that simulation would impact on their practice in the next five years, with this statement being scored lower by later qualified surgeons, median score 2.4 versus 4.1 (p=0.04). Orthopaedic surgeons in New Zealand are supportive of surgical simulation but do not expect simulation to have an impact in the near future. Intriguingly, later qualified surgeons and trainees are more sceptical than their earlier qualified colleagues.
IB-II 913 Patellar clunk 3.5% 0.3% Dislocation 0% 0.3% Fracture 0% 0.3% Loosening 0% 0% Clinical results at follow-up (phase-2) did not show any significant difference between the two matched groups in terms of Knee and Function scores (p=0.7). Patellar score showed a higher rate of excellent and good results in the 913 group (88% vs 81%: p=.043). Anterior knee pain was only mild and activity related in 26% of the IB-II and 14% of the 913 (p=.025). In a multivariate regression analysis, radiographic patellar tilt, subluxation, and height, did not correlate with clinical outcomes, whilst bone-implant contact showed a trend towards a higher incidence of pain, particularly when associated with asymmetric patellar resection.
Bone autograft contains living cells that participate in the healing process. Fragmentation and heat production during cutting will kill cells. We have investigated how excessive graft fragmentation and heating can be avoided. Two prototype cutters were fabricated. Each had a single cutting edge at the front end of a 12 mm diameter collection barrel. The principal difference between the cutters was the rake angle (at the cutting edge): 23° on cutter #1 and 45° on cutter #2. Thrust load, feed-rate, and torque were measured using an instrumented drill press. A total of 58 tests on specimens of fresh bovine cancellous bone (distal femur, ex-abattoir) and medium density polyurethane foam (Sawbones, WA. USA) (density 252 kg/m3) were conducted: twenty-four at 100 rpm and thirty-four at 200 rpm. Small flake-like fragmented bone chips were encountered at low thrust loads. As thrust load was increased the chips became thicker. The average cutting energy for bone was 43.7 Nm (s.d. 48.2 Nm) for cutter 1 and 37 Nm (s.d. 27 Nm) for cutter 2. The average cutting energy for the foam was 13.9 Nm (s.d. 6.0 Nm) for cutter 1 and 8.1 Nm (s.d. 3.0 Nm) for cutter 2. Polyurethane results showed a similar trend. A higher rake angle on a bone graft tool is associated with a lower cutting energy. In turn, a lower cutting energy will generate a lower temperature in the graft, a result that is beneficial for cell survival. Graft tool design can also influence bone chip size. These experimental results are being used for the development of cell-friendly tooling.
Periprosthetic bone density (BD) changes can be tracked using computed-tomography (CT) assisted osteodensitometry. Patient-specific computer-generated models allow for good visualisation of density changes in bone. We describe techniques for generating smooth and realistic finite element (FE) models that contain both BD and geometry from quantitative CT data using cubic Hermite elements. FE models were created for three patients who had a total hip replacement. CT-scans were performed at 10 days, one year, and 3 years after the operation and calibrated using a synthetic hydroxyapatite phantom. FE models of the proximal femur were automatically generated from the CT data. Each model had on average 300 tri-cubic Hermite elements. Models were least squares fitted to the entire dataset. BD data was also sampled and fitted using the same cubic interpolation functions. Density was displayed using a colour spectrum. Realistic patient-specific FE models were obtained. Density and changes in BD were easy to identify. The error in the geometric fitting (RMS distance between data points and the model surface) was generally less then 0.5 mm. The average error for the density fitting (RMS difference between each density data point and the interpolation function value at the same point) was 61.64 mg/ml or 3.08%. CT osteodensitometry’s potential use as a clinical tool for monitoring changes to BD can be significantly enhanced when used in conjunction with realistic patient-specific finite element (FE) models. Realistic models can be generated with an economic use of scan data, thus keeping radiation dosage down.
Pelvic osteolysis secondary to polyethylene wear is a major complication following THR. Identification of implant specific characteristics associated with osteolysis is essential. The purpose of this study is to compare incidence of CT scan identifiable osteolysis in 2 groups of young, active patients following THR; one with multi-holed acetabular shells with screws, one with cups without screw holes. Between 1990–1993, 77 patients (85 hips) underwent THR with a cementless titanium, multi-holed shell with screws, modular, compression molded polyethylene and an uncemented titanium femoral stem. Average follow-up: 9 years, average age at surgery: 51 years. Between 1984–1987, 163 patients (183 hips) underwent THR with a cementless cobalt-chrome, solid shell, modular, heat-pressed polyeth-ylene liner and uncemented cobalt-chrome femoral stem. Average follow-up: 16 years, average age at operation: 52 years. All polyethylene was irradiated in air. At most recent follow-up, CT scans with metal suppression software was obtained to evaluate incidence of pelvic osteolysis. Patients classified: Group 1-no osteolysis, Group 2-cavitary osteolysis, Group 3-segmental osteolysis. Patients with titanium, multi-holed shells had: Group 1-50.0%, Group 2-38.7%, and Group 3-11.3%. Patients with cobalt-chrome, solid shells had: Group 1-59.3%, Group 2-33.3% and Group 3-7.4%. Although the patients with solid cups had much longer follow-up, less secure capture mechanism, less congruency between polyethylene and shell, and heat-pressed polyethylene, the incidence and extent of pelvic osteolysis was less than in the patients with multi-holed shell with screws. The presence of 6.5 mm cancellous screws is a serious independent risk factor for pelvic osteolysis following THR.
The objective of this present study was to determine the in vivo kinematic patterns for subjects implanted with a patellofemoral arthroplasty (PFA). Twenty subjects, all having a PFA, were studied (<
2 years post-op) under fluoroscopic surveillance to determine patellofemoral contact positions, sagittal plane, and medial/lateral translation using a skyline view. The patellofemoral contact patterns for each subject having a PFA was highly variable, 11.9 mm of translation. The average amount of patella rotation during the full flexion cycle was 26.3 degrees, while one subject experienced 48.6 degrees. The average amount of medial/lateral translation was 3.8 mm (5 >
5 mm). Five subjects experienced grater than 5 mm of motion. This was the first study to ever determine the in vivo kinematics for subjects having a PFA and the in vivo medial/lateral translation patterns of the patellofemoral joint. Subjects in this study experienced high variability and some abnormal rotational patterns. Most of the subjects who underwent PFA in this study had a previous history of subluxed or dislocated patella which affects the normal patella tracking, especially regarding tilting and translation. This tracking may also be directly affected by patellofemoral conformity, a consequence of femoral implant design. Finally, after PFA the patello-tibial tilt angle is influenced by the anteroposterior positioning of the femoral component. The results of this very first in vivo kinematic study may play an important role, not only for design consideration of patellofemoral replacement but also for surgical technique in order to obtain optimal implant positioning.
The objective of the present study was to analyse kinematics of subjects having a UKA during stance phase of gait, where the ACL was intact at the time of the operative procedure. Femorotibial contact positions for nineteen subjects (15 medial UKA (MUA); 14 lateral UKA (LUA); HSS >
90, post-op >
3 yrs) were analysed using video fluoroscopy. During stance-phase of gait, on average, subjects having a medial UKA experienced 0.8 mm of anterior motion (7.7 to – 2.3 mm), while subjects having a lateral UKA experienced −0.4 mm (0.9 to – 2.1 mm) of posterior femoral rollback (PFR). Eight of 15 subjects having a medial UKA and two out of four lateral UKA experienced PFR. Eight of 15 subjects having a medial UKA experienced normal axial rotation (average = 0.9 degrees) and one out of four subjects having a lateral UKA experienced normal axial rotation (average = −6.0 degrees). High variability in the kinematic data for subjects experiencing an anterior slide and opposite axial rotation suggests that these subjects had an ACL that was not functioning properly and was unable to provide an anterior constraint force with the necessary magnitude to thrust the femur in the anterior direction at full extension. Progressive laxity of the ACL may occur over time, and at least in part, lead to premature polyethylene wear occasionally seen in UKA. Our results support the findings of other studies that the ACL plays a significant role in maintaining satisfactory knee kinematics, which may also, in part, contribute to UKA longevity.
The objective of this present study is to conduct a comparative analysis of the kinematic data derived for all subjects having a TKA who were analysed over the past eight years at our laboratory. Femorotibial contact positions for 705 subjects having either a fixed bearing PCR or PS TKA or mobile bearing TKA were analysed in three-dimensions using video fluoroscopy. During a deep knee bend, all PS TKA types subjects experienced a medial pivot motion, averaging −3.8 of lateral condyle posterior femoral rollback (PFR), respectively. Subjects having a fixed bearing PCR TKA experienced only −0.7 mm of lateral condyle PFR and an anterior slide of 1.6 mm for the medial condyle. Twenty-nine percent of the PCR TKA analysed had a lateral pivot and 71% experienced a medial pivot. Subjects having a mobile bearing TKA experienced −2.8 mm of lateral condyle PFR and 0.4 mm of medial condyle anterior slide. Fifty-one percent of the moble bearing implants experienced a medial pivot and 43% experienced a lateral pivot. During gait, PS and PCR fixed bearing TKA types experienced similar kinematic patterns. Subjects having a mobile bearing TKA experienced minimal motion, probably due to the mobile bearing TKA having greater sagittal conformity and had the lowest standard deviation. There was great variability in the data comparing various TKA designs. Subjects in this multicentre analysis predominantly experienced a medial pivot motion, although certain TKA designs did demonstrate a lateral pivot motion.
A procedure is presented which allows the efficient production of a patient specific computer model of the femur, for surgical planning. Similar models require long processing times and/or high performance computing. The method uses 24 key landmark points to customise a generic femur to patient data, using a desktop computer. By using non-linear elements a smooth, curved surface is obtained. A finite element mesh of a generic femur consisting of 384 elements was created using the analysis software CMISS (Bioengineering Institute, University of Auckland). A rectangular shaped host mesh was defined to enclose the generic femur. Datasets of 5 human femurs were obtained using a hand-held laser scanner on dry bones and the visible human dataset. Key landmark data points were selected on the generic femur along with corresponding target points on each data set. The host mesh was then deformed using a least squares algorithm, causing customisation of the generic femur to the patient specific model. Each customised model was compared with its entire dataset. The fitting process took less than 100 seconds on a 180 MHz 02 computer (SGI, CA, USA). The algorithm yielded an average root mean square (RMS) of 3.09mm with a standard deviation of 0.15mm. Operator time for positioning the projection points was less than 5 minutes. This paper presents a novel means for customisation of human femoral geometry with generation of patient specific models on a PC from scan data in under 10 minutes. Current work is focusing on stress analysis, surgical simulation and planning.
A 5 year review into the workload and subsequent financial implications of pelvic and acetabular reconstruction at a regional tertiary referral centre. To ascertain the level and means of financial recompense for performing pelvic/acetabular reconstruction on patients from other healthcare trusts at a tertiary referral centre. The records of all 120 patients who underwent either pelvic or acetabular reconstruction between 1995–2000 were examined. Epidemiological data and information on all possible costs of their stay was accumulated (itemised finance department figures were used). The individual patient billing system of ECRs (Extra Contractual Referrals) was changed in 1998 and replaced by the OATs system (Out of Area Treatments) whereby an annual lump sum was received based on historic referral patterns. We investigated the financial effects that occurred. 60 out of 120 patients treated, were from other health-care trusts. From 1995–1998, 25 ECR patients were treated at an estimated cost of £480, 000. The trust received £280, 000, a net loss of £200, 000. From 1998–2000, 34 OATS patients were treated at an estimated cost of £650, 000, amounting to a net gain of £1. 15 million pounds. ‘Out of area’ referrals for pelvic and acetabular reconstruction have increased by 50 % in the last 2 years. However the new payment system i. e. OATS has resulted in the tertiary referral centre being generously rewarded, unlike prior to 1998 and the old ECR system. It is therefore recommended that annual review must be carried out to ensure that funding will meet the demand for specialist services in the future and prevent subsidisation of some centres by other trusts.
Conclusions:
Significant unloading of the osteoarthritic compartment could be observed by applying manually a valgus force to the knee. Significant unloading of the arthritic compartment of the knee was not observed by applying a brace (up to 10%). Measurement of pressures within the osteoarthritic knee is difficult and variable.
The work of Sloof, Ling and Gie has established allografting as a modern technique in revision total hip arthroplasty. The use of allograft enhances the local bone stock and provides a secure fixation for cemented components. Its association with the problem of heterotopic ossification has not been previously considered. The records and x-rays of 114 patients after revision hip surgery were reviewed. All had been operated upon by three Consultant Orthopaedic Surgeons using standard techniques. 35 patients had undergone revision with impaction allografting of both the femur and acetabulum, 29 had allografting of the femur only, 18 of the acetabulum alone and the final 32 patients (acting as controls) had cemented revision arthroplasty without impaction allografting. Fresh frozen allograft was used in all cases and prepared using a bone mill. No patient was given radiation or Indomethacin after their revision surgery, even if they had pre-existing heterotopic ossification. The immediate pre-operative x-rays and x-rays at least a year post-revision were assessed independently by a musculoskeletal radiologist. He was blinded to the type of revision procedure and graded the heterotopic ossification according to the Brooker Classification. Our results report the incidence of heterotopic ossification after revision hip arthroplasty with fresh frozen allograft when compared with cemented revision arthroplasty from our unit and other studies.
Shoulder movements from neutral into flexion, extension, abduction, adduction and external rotation are easily measured with a goniometer. In the neutral position, the glenohumeral ligaments, which act as the reins of the joint, limit movement and are symmetrically relaxed. The torso obstructs internal rotation with the arm adducted at the side and the full range of movement cannot be attained. The torso is cleared when the shoulder is abducted, usually to 90°. However, this degree of abduction places the shoulder within the painful arc of impingement and may influence the degree of internal rotation. Further, owing to shoulder joint stiffness, some patients may not be able to abduct the shoulder to 90°. Because of these problems, it has become internationally accepted to measure internal rotation in the near-neutral position by determining the vertebral level behind the back to which the thumb can reach. We assessed 200 symptomatic and asymptomatic shoulders to determine the correlation between the ‘hand behind back’ and angular measurements of internal rotation at 90° or 30° of abduction.