EFFICACY OF THE PAVLIK HARNESS; THE SHEFFIELD EXPERIENCE OF 189 HIPS

Abstract

Introduction: This study examined the cohort of patients selectively screened over a 5 year period with ultrasonography according to our risk factors (positive Ortolani or Barlow manoeuvre, breech presentation, first degree affected relative and talipes equinovarus) for developmental hip dysplasia (DDH). The aims were to evaluate the success of those managed in a Pavlik harness and identify predictive factors for those that failed treatment.

Methods: 728 patients were selectively screened between 1999 and 2004. Of those, 128 patients (189 hips) were identified as having hip instability. Failure was defined as inability to achieve or maintain hip reduction in a Pavlik harness. A proforma was designed to document patients’ risk factors and ultrasound findings at time of initial dynamic ultrasound scan where the senior radiographer and treating consultant were present. Each hip was classified according to Graf type. Acetabular indices were recorded prior to discharge.

Results: All 128 patients with hip instability were managed in a Pavlik harness. This was abandoned for surgical treatment in 9 patients (10 hips) giving a failure rate of 5.3 %. All those successfully managed had an acetabular index of less than 30 degrees at follow up (6 – 48 months). 7 hips in the series were classified as Graf type IV, of these, 6 went on to fail management in a Pavlik harness. 67% of those that failed were also breech presentation compared to 22% of those managed successfully. There were no complications associated with management in a Pavlik harness.

Discussion: Our overall rate of selective screening is 14 per 1,000 with a subsequent treatment rate of 2.3 per 1,000, which is comparable with other centres. Our rate of failure for DDH in a Pavlik harness (5.3 %) is extremely encouraging. Graf type IV hips and breech presentation correlated with a high likelihood of treatment failure.