Advertisement for orthosearch.org.uk
Orthopaedic Proceedings Logo

Receive monthly Table of Contents alerts from Orthopaedic Proceedings

Comprehensive article alerts can be set up and managed through your account settings

View my account settings

Visit Orthopaedic Proceedings at:

Loading...

Loading...

Volume 95-B, Issue SUPP_8 February 2013 Combined Services Orthopaedic Society (CSOS) Annual Meeting

J.A.G. Singleton I.E. Gibb A.M.J. Bull J.C. Clasper

Recent advances in combat casualty care have enabled survival following battlefield injuries that would have been lethal in past conflicts. While some injuries remain beyond our current capability to treat, they have the potential to be future ‘unexpected’ survivors. The greatest threat to deployed coalition troops currently and for the foreseeable future is the improvised explosive device (IED) Therefore, the aim of this study was to conduct an analysis of causes of death and injury patterns in recent explosive blast fatalities in order to focus research and mitigation strategies, to further improve survival rates.

Since November 2007, UK Armed Forces personnel killed whilst deployed on combat operations undergo both a post mortem computed tomography (PMCT) scan and an autopsy. With the permission of the coroners, we analysed casualties with PMCTs between November 2007 and July 2010. Injury data were analysed by a pathology-forensic radiology-orthopaedic multidisciplinary team. Cause of death was attributed to the injuries with the highest AIS scores contributing to the NISS score. Injuries with an AIS < 4 were excluded. During the study period 227 PMCT scans were performed; 211 were suitable for inclusion, containing 145 fatalities due to explosive blast from IEDs. These formed the study group. 24 cases had such severe injuries (disruptions) that further study was inappropriate. Of the remaining 121, 79 were dismounted, and 42 were mounted (in vehicles).

Leading causes of death were head CNS injury (47.6%), followed by intra-cavity haemorrhage (21.7%) in the mounted group, and extremity haemorrhage (42.6%), junctional haemorrhage (22.2%) and head CNS injury (18.7%) in the dismounted group.

The severity of head trauma in both mounted and dismounted IED fatalites would indicate that prevention and mitigation of these injuries is likely to be the most effective strategy to decrease their resultant mortality. Two thirds of dismounted fatalities have haemorrhage implicated as a cause of death that may have been amenable to prehospital treatment strategies. One fifth of mounted fatalites have haemorrhagic trauma which currently could only be addressed surgically. Maintaining the drive to improve all haemostatic techniques for combat casualties from point of wounding to definitive surgical proximal control alongside development and application of novel haemostatics could yield a significant survival benefit.


J.A.G. Singleton I.E. Gibb A.M.J. Bull J.C. Clasper

The mechanism of traumatic amputation (TA) from explosive blast has traditionally been considered to be a combination of blast wave induced bone injury – primary blast - followed by limb avulsion from the blast wind – tertiary blast. This results in a transosseous TA, with through joint amputations considered to be extremely rare. Data from previous conflicts has also suggested that this injury is frequently associated with a non-survivable primary blast lung injury (PBLI), further linking the extremity injury to the primary blast wave. However, our current experience in the Middle East would suggest that both the mechanism of TA and the link with fatal primary blast exposure need to be reconsidered. The aim of this study was to analyse the injury profile of the current cohort of TA fatalities to further investigate the underlying blast injury mechanism and to allow hypotheses on injury mechanisms to be developed for further analysis.

With the permission of the coroners, 121 post-mortem CT (PMCT) scans of UK Armed Forces personnel who died following an IED blast were analysed. All orthopaedic injuries were identified, classified and the anatomical level of any associated soft tissue injury noted. PMCT evidence of PBLI was used as a marker of significant primary blast exposure.

75/121 (62%) sustained at least 1 TA, with 138 TAs seen in total. 31/138 (22%) were through joints, with through knee amputations most common (23/31, 74%). Only 7/31(23%) through joint amputations had an associated fracture proximal to and contiguous with the amputation site. The soft tissue injury profile of through joint and transosseous TAs were not significantly different (p=0.569). When fatality location was considered (i.e. mounted or dismounted), no overall relationship between PBLI and TA was evident. The two pathologies were not seen to consistently occur concurrently, as has been previously reported.

The accepted mechanism for traumatic amputation following explosive blast does not adequately explain the significant number of through joint TAs presented here. The previously reported link between TA and PBLI in fatalities was not supported by this analysis of modern combat blast fatalities. Lack of an associated fracture with the majority of through joint TAs in conjunction with a lesser contribution of primary blast may implicate flail and periarticular soft tissue failure as a potential injury mechanism. Analysis of through joint TA incidence and associated injuries in survivors is now indicated. Case studies within the fatality dataset may facilitate generation of injury mechanism hypotheses. To further investigate the injury mechanism, work is required to understand osseous, ligamentous and other soft tissue behaviour and failure at high strain rates. This should allow characterisation and modeling of these injuries and inform mitigation strategies.


A. Roberts J.M. Quayle P. Krishnasamy J. Houghton

CECS is an exercised induced condition that causes pain, typically in the lower limbs, and is relieved by rest. It is often seen in military personnel significantly restricting their duties. Conservative treatment is rarely successful and patients often require surgical decompression by fasciotomy or fasciectomy.

All IMP (intramuscular pressure) tests (n=286) carried out between December 2007 and October 2010 on patients with suspected CECS in the anterior compartment of the lower leg were reviewed. The treatment and outcomes of those referred for surgery were analysed. Pre- and post-surgery military medical grading for leg function was extracted from the medical records system. Independent t-tests compared differences between patients that had surgery or did not. The Wilcoxon signed-rank test compared grades before and after surgery.

According to the diagnostic criterion, 80% of patients undergoing IMP testing had CECS. Of these, 179 (68%) patients underwent surgery, 17 (9%) of these were for recurrent symptoms. Almost all decompressions were bilateral (95%). The majority of operations (121) were fasciectomies of the anterior compartment only and were performed by 2 surgeons. The remaining operations (58) were performed by 6 surgeons and were fasciotomies of both anterior and lateral compartments. The mean time from testing to surgery was 24 (median 11) weeks. There were 23 (13%) complications other than recurrence including 16 wound infections, 6 seromas and 1 haematoma. Pre- and post-surgery grading was available for 67% of patients. These patients had significantly better leg function after surgery (Z=−3.67, p<0.001). Of these, 47% improved, 38% showed no improvement and 15% had a poorer outcome had. Those who had a fasciectomy were significantly more likely to improve than those who had a fasciotomy (p=0.023, rho=−1.96).

Our results demonstrate that patients generally improve lower limb function following surgical decompression. However, 53% showed no improvement or deteriorated in their medical grading. In addition, there is a high diagnosis rate for CECS following IMP measurement. This may reflect the poor validity of the diagnostic criterion or this could be due to good clinical selection for testing. Furthermore, fasciectomy shows a greater correlation with improved outcome than fasciotomy. There is a need to develop more accurate diagnostic criteria and to evaluate the benefits of standardising surgical technique.


ACM Keenan ACM Wood N Beattie RM Boyle FC Doogan C Court-Brown

The collective orthopaedic literature appears to highlight the Jones fracture of the fifth metatarsal, as being slow to heal, and having a high incidence of non-union. There remains a lot of confusion, throughout the orthopaedic literature, about the exact nature of this fracture.

The authors present the largest case series currently published of 117 patients who sustained a Jones fracture, demonstrating patient outcomes with different modalities of care.

All Medical notes from the Emergency Department are recorded on a database.

A computer program was use to search the Emergency department database of the Edinburgh Royal infirmary notes data base for the terms 5th metatarsal combined with a coding for referral to fracture clinic over a 6 years period from 2004–2010. The researchers went through the X-ray archive, identified and classified all 5th metatarsal fractures.

There were 117 patients in our series, refracture rate 7/117 6%. Average time to discharge 13 weeks (4–24). 18% of patients took longer than 18 weeks for their fracture to clinically heal. 34% were clinically healed at less than six weeks, with only 7% radiologically healed at six weeks. There was no significant difference in outcome between cast, moonboot, tubigrip or hard shoe in terms of outcome.

A large proportion of Jones fractures have delayed healing, patients who are clinically asymptomatic may not have radiological healing. Currently in our practice there is no uniform management of Jones fractures. We discuss the difference in healing rates for different management techniques.


TA Wood A Getgood N Smith T Spalding P Thompson

We reviewed all patients that suffered a deep infection following anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) repair kept between January 2007 and April 2011 at our teaching hospital NHS trust, and the two local private hospitals.

18 patients were identified. All patients underwent at least 2 arthroscopic washouts, with limited synovectomy if required. Targeted antibiotics were commenced according to the culture results, and following microbiological advice. These patients were reviewed at a minimum of 1 year following eradication of infection (range 12–46 months). There were 7 surgeons performing the ACL reconstructions.

The primary outcome measure was graft failure requiring revision. Our secondary outcome measures were a history of ongoing instability, KT 1000™ measurement, Tegner and Lysholm outcome scores. There were 18 patients identified as having suffered infection after ACL infection (mean age 24.3 years, range 15–38 years). Average C Reactive Protein (CRP) was 217 on admission (range 59–397). The most common organism isolated was coagulase negative staphylococcus in 47.3% of cases. There were 3 graft failures within the infection group. Of the remaining 15 patients there were no episodes of ongoing instability and mean pivot shift grade was 1.1, mean KT 1000™ side-to- side difference was +1.8mm. There was a reported drop on the Tegner activity score of 1.75 (range 0–6) and mean Lysholm score was 89 (range 56–100).

The failure rate is slightly higher than that reported in the literature. Patient reported outcome measures in the patients are broadly consistent. We recommend an aggressive approach to the treatment of deep infection following ACL reconstruction, in order to achieve a satisfactory outcome.


J. Granville-Chapman S.Z. Nawaz A. Trompeter K.J.H. Newman D.S. Elliott

Intramedullary nailing of tibial fractures is commonplace and freehand techniques are increasingly popular. The standard freehand method has the knee of the injured leg flexed over a radio-lucent bolster. This requires the imaging C-arm to swing from antero-posterior to lateral position several times. Furthermore, guide wire placement; reaming and nail insertion are all performed well above most surgeons' shoulder height. If instead the leg is hung over the edge of the table, the assistant must crouch and hold the leg until the nail is passed beyond the fracture.

We describe a method of nailing which is easier both for the surgeons and the (often inexperienced) radiographer and present a series of 87 consecutive cases managed with this technique.


D. Griffiths L. Young N. Obi S. Nikolaou G. Tytherleigh-Strong L. Van Rensburg

The current standard for treatment of humeral shaft fractures is in a functional humeral brace. Aims: To further assess the union rate for this mode of treatment and to delineate and any fracture type less likely to go on to union.

Retrospective radiographic and clinical review of 199 consecutive acute adult humeral shaft fractures. 43 operated on acutely (including all open fractures). Remaining 156 fractures treated in a humeral brace. Non union was determined as delayed fracture fixation or no evidence of union at 1 year. Union rate 82.9% with 88.5% follow-up. 16 of the 24 non unions were proximal third (all but one spiral/oblique): 71.4% union rate. Middle third fractures 87.3% and distal third shaft fractures 88.9 % union rate. Union rate of fractures with 3+ parts inclusive of all regions of the shaft was 95.6%.

The union rate in this study is not as high as has previously been reported for functional brace treatment. A lower threshold for intervention in proximal third spiral/oblique humeral shaft fractures may be indicated. Fracture site comminution is a very good prognostic indicator.


H.C. Guthrie K.R. Martin C. Taylor A. Spear J.C. Clasper S.A. Watts

A 7-day randomised controlled pre-clinical trial utilising an existing extremity war wound model compared the efficacy of saline soaked gauze to commercially available dressings. The Flexor Carpi Ulnaris of anaesthetised rabbits was exposed to high-energy trauma using a computer-controlled jig and inoculated with 106Staphylococcus aureus 3 hours prior to application of dressing. Quantitative microbiological assessment demonstrated reduced bacterial counts in INADINE (Iodine) and ACTICOAT (Nanocrystalline Silver) groups and an increase in ACTIVON TULLE (Manuka Honey) group (2-way ANOVA p<0.05).

Clinical observations were made throughout the study. Haematology and plasma cytokines were analysed at intervals. Post-mortem histopathology included subjective semi-quantitative assessment of pathology severity using light microscopy to grade muscle injury and lymph node activation. Tissue samples were also examined using scanning electron microscopy (SEM).

There were no bacteraemias, abscesses, purulent discharge or evidence of contralateral axillary lymph node activation. There were no significant differences in animal behaviour, weight change, maximum body temperature or white blood cell count elevation nor in pathology severity in muscle or lymph nodes (Kruskal-Wallis). There was no evidence of bacterial penetration or biofilm formation on SEM. Interleukin-4 and Tumour Necrosis Factor α levels were significantly higher in the ACTIVON TULLE group (1-way ANOVA p<0.05).

This time-limited study demonstrated a statistically significant reduction in Staphylococcus aureus counts in wounds dressed with INADINE and ACTICOAT and an increase in wounds dressed with ACTIVON TULLE. There was no evidence that any of these dressings cause harm but nor have we established any definite clinical advantage associated with the use of the dressings tested in this study.


P. M. Guyver J. M. Taylor I. T. Sharpe N. J. Talbot A. C. Redfern D. A. T. Silver

Achilles tendinopathy is characterised by chronic degeneration of the Achilles tendon, usually secondary to injury or overuse. Extracorporeal shockwave treatment (ESWT) is of potential benefit in refractory cases where conservative management with analgesia, physiotherapy and corticosteroid injection have been unsuccessful.

Patients with refractory Achilles tendinopathy enrolled between October 2010 and October 2011 received three sessions of ESWT over three weeks. Patients completed visual analogue scale (VAS) scores for pain at rest and on activity and the Victorian Institute of Sport Assessment-Achilles (VISA-A) questionnaire pre-treatment. These outcome measures and a six-point Likert satisfaction scale were reassessed at six and 16 weeks post treatment.

51 patients completed follow up. Mean age was 56 (34–80) years and mean length of symptoms 34 (4–252) months. Significant improvement (p<0.05) in VAS scores (rest and activity) and VISA-A scores was observed between baseline and 16 weeks. Mean Likert score was 3 (somewhat improved) at 16 weeks. Patients suffering Achilles tendinopathy for longer than 25 months had significantly less improvement than those affected for a shorter period.

This study suggests that ESWT improves subjective and objective outcomes in patients with refractory Achilles tendinopathy.


P.M. Guyver A. Jaques A.M.F. Goubran C.D. Smith T.D. Bunker

Introduction

Massive rotator cuff tears in the patient who is too young for a reverse shoulder replacement are a challenging situation. A technique using a ‘Grammont osteotomy’ of the acromion has been developed to allow a comprehensive approach, the so called “Full Monty”.

Aim

To document the functional outcome of patients undergoing an acromial osteotomy for the repair of massive tears of the supraspinatus.


E Spurrier O Payton P Hallam

The Global Conservative Anatomic Prosthesis (Global CAP) is an uncemented press fit humeral resurfacing implant developed by DePuy. We report a single surgeon series of Global CAP prostheses implanted in Norwich.

103 procedures were carried out between 2006 and 2011, in 93 patients. Mean age was 72 years (range 43 to 90). Patients were followed up for a mean 8 months (range 0 to 56). Pre-operative Oxford shoulder scores were recorded in a preadmission clinic and an Oxford score questionnaire was sent to patients post-operatively in December 2011. The mean score preoperatively was 19, rising to 28 postoperatively.

Two patients developed rotator cuff tears and have been revised to reverse polarity arthroplasty. One is pending revision for a cuff tear.

This prosthesis shows promise at this early stage for compensated glenohumeral arthritis when a bone preserving procedure is desirable.


P. Hindle E. Davidson L. Biant

It is widely accepted by orthopaedic surgeons that antibiotics should be withheld until aspiration has been performed to increase the odds of identifying an organism in septic arthritis. Patients often present to other specialties that may not be as familiar with these principles.

Twenty-five of forty-nine patients with septic arthritis of the native or prosthetic knee had received antibiotics prior to review by the orthopaedic service. Patients were significantly less likely to demonstrate an organism on initial microscopy (entire cohort p=0.001, native knees p=0.006, prosthetic knees p=0.033) or on subsequent culture (entire cohort p=0.001, native knees p=0.017, prosthetic knees p=0.012) of their aspirate if they had received antibiotics. The sensitivity of microscopy dropped from 0.58 to 0.12 when patients had received antibiotics (native knees 0.46 to 0, prosthetic knees 0.72 to 0.27). The sensitivity of the culture dropped from 0.79 to 0.28 when the patient had received antibiotics (native knees 0.69 to 0.21, prosthetic knees 0.91 to 0.36).

Patients treated with empirical antibiotics are less likely to demonstrate an organism on microscopy and culture of their initial aspirate. There is a significantly high false negative rate associated with knee aspiration, particularly with prior administration of antibiotics.


N.M. Walker W. Eardley T. Bonner J. Clasper

In a recent publication, 4.6% of 6450 Coalition deaths over ten years were reported to be due to junctional bleeding. The authors suggested that some of these deaths could have been avoided with a junctional hemorrhage control device.

Prospectively collected data on all injuries sustained in Afghanistan by UK military personnel over a 2 year period were reviewed. All fatalities with significant pelvic injuries were identified and analysed, and the cause of death established.

Significant upper thigh, groin or pelvic injuries were recorded in 124 casualties, of which 92 died. Pelvic injury was the cause of death in 42; only 1 casualty was identified where death was at least in part due to a vascular injury below the inguinal ligament, not controlled by a tourniquet, representing <1% of all deaths. Twenty one deaths were due to vascular injury between the aortic bifurcation and the inguinal ligament, of which 4 survived to a medical facility.

Some potentially survivable deaths due to exsanguination may be amenable to more proximal vascular control. We cannot substantiate previous conclusions that this can be achieved through use of a groin junctional tourniquet. There may be a role for more proximal vascular control of pelvic bleeding.


T.J. Bonner J. Singleton S.D. Masouros I. Gibb J.M. Kendrew J.C. Clasper

Counter-insurgency warfare in recent military operations has been epitomised by the use of Improvised Explosive Devices (IED) against coalition troops. Emerging patterns of skeletal fractures, limb amputations and organ injuries, which are caused by these weapons have been described over recent years. This paper describes a retrospective case series of knee dislocations caused by IEDs in recent conflict.

Data was obtained about military personnel from 2006 to 2011, who had sustained a knee dislocation while serving in Afghanistan from a prospectively gathered database, the Joint Theatre Trauma Registry (JTTR), maintained by the Academic Department of Military Emergency Medicine, Royal Centre for Defence Medicine. The diagnosis of knee dislocation and its associated skeletal injuries was assessed by review of all relevant plain radiographs, computed tomography scans and magnetic resonance images. The mechanism of injury, incidence of vascular injuries and other skeletal injuries was recorded.

During the study period, 23 casualties sustained a knee dislocation caused by an IED. Four casualties had an associated popliteal vascular injury. Eleven injuries were caused in enclosed spaces, and 10 injuries caused by IEDs out in the open. Anterior dislocations were common in the group caused in enclosed spaces. 19/20 patients had at least one other skeletal fracture.

Knee dislocations represent an uncommon but important diagnosis in modern warfare. Urgent and careful assessment for any associated vascular injuries or other skeletal injuries may help ensure timely treatment and promote future recovery. Mitigation against knee dislocation may be possible in the enclosed environment because of the predictable pattern of injury.


A. Ramasamy S. Masouros N. Newell T.J. Bonner ATH West AM Hill JC Clasper AMJ Bull

Current military conflicts are characterised by the use of the Improvised Explosive Device (IED). Improvements in personal protection, medical care and evacuation logistics have resulted in increasing numbers of casualties surviving with complex musculoskeletal injuries, often leading to life-long disability. Thus, there exists an urgent requirement to investigate the mechanism of extremity injury caused by these devices in order to develop mitigation strategies. In addition, the wounds of war are no longer restricted to the battlefield; similar injuries can be witnessed in civilian centres following a terrorist attack.

Key to mitigating such injuries is the ability to deconstruct the complexities of an explosive event into a controlled, laboratory-based environment. In this study, an anti-vehicle underbelly injury simulator, capable of recreating in the laboratory the impulse from an anti-vehicle (AV) explosion, is presented and characterised. Tests were then conducted to assess the simulator's ability to interact with human cadaveric legs. Two mounting conditions were assessed, simulating a typical seated and standing vehicle passenger using instrumented cadaveric lower limbs.

This experimental device, will now allow us (a) to gain comprehensive understanding of the load-transfer mechanisms through the lower limb, (b) to characterise the dissipating capacity of mitigation technologies, and (c) to assess the biofidelity of surrogates.


A. Ramasamy A.M. Hill R. Phillip I. Gibb A.M.J. Bull J.C. Clasper

The defining weapon of the conflicts in Iraq and Afghanistan has been the Improvised Explosive Device (IEDs). When detonated under a vehicle, they result in significant axial loading to the lower limbs, resulting in devastating injuries. Due to the absence of clinical blast data, automotive injury data using the Abbreviated Injury Score (AIS) has been extrapolated to define current NATO injury thresholds for Anti-vehicle (AV) mine tests. We hypothesized that AIS, being a marker of fatality rather than disability would be a worse predictor of poor clinical outcome compared to the lower limb specific Foot and Ankle Severity Score (FASS).

Using a prospectively collected trauma database, we identified UK Service Personnel sustaining lower leg injuries from under-vehicle explosions from Jan 2006–Dec 2008. A full review of all medical documentation was performed to determine patient demographics and the severity of lower leg injury, as assessed by AIS and FASS. Clinical endpoints were defined as (i) need for amputation or (ii) poor clinical outcome. Statistical models were developed in order to explore the relationship between the scoring systems and clinical endpoints.

63 UK casualties (89 limbs) were identified with a lower limb injury following under-vehicle explosion. The mean age of the casualty was 26.0 yrs. At 33.6 months follow-up, 29.1% (26/89) required an amputation and a further 74.6% (41/89) having a poor clinical outcome (amputation or ongoing clinical problems). Only 9(14%) casualties were deemed medically fit to return to full military duty. ROC analysis revealed that both AIS=2 and FASS=4 could predict the risk of amputation, with FASS = 4 demonstrating greater specificity (43% vs 20%) and greater positive predictive value (72% vs 32%). In predicting poor clinical outcome, FASS was significantly superior to AIS (p<0.01). Probit analysis revealed that a relationship could not be developed between AIS and the probability of a poor clinical outcome (p=0.25).

Foot and ankle injuries following AV mine blast are associated with significant morbidity. Our study clearly demonstrates that AIS is not a predictor of long-term clinical outcome and that FASS would be a better quantitative measure of lower limb injury severity. There is a requirement to reassess the current injury criteria used to evaluate the potential of mitigation technologies to help reduce long-term disability in military personnel. Our study highlights the critical importance of utilising contemporary battlefield injury data in order to ensure that the evaluation of mitigation measures is appropriate to the injury profile and their long-term effects.


J. Quayle R. Pennington P. Rosell

Traumatic injuries to the sternoclavicular joint (SCJ) are uncommon representing only 3% of all injuries to the shoulder girdle. Acutely, the majority are managed non-operatively with physiotherapy rehabilitation. However, if there is evidence of neurovascular compromise emergency reduction is indicated. There is no consensus on treatment of SCJ dislocations and subluxations that remain symptomatic after conservative treatment. Multiple surgical techniques have been described to alleviate this problem. These include resection of the medial end of the clavicle and various stabilization techniques using Kirschner wires, muscle tendon (subclavius, sternocleidomastoid, semi-tendinosus and palmaris longus) and synthetic materials (Dacron). However, all techniques have reported problems in terms of pain, decreased range of movement and a relatively high complication rate.

We report a new technique using a LARS® ligament (Ligament Augmentation and Reconstruction System) with good early post-operative results. 5 symptomatic SCJ dislocations were repaired over a 3 year period. The operations were conducted by the same surgeon and at the same unit. The patients were on average 20 years old (17–22). Mean follow up time was 21 months (9–41). Functional assessment was made using the DASH (Disabilities of the Arm, Shoulder and Hand) and the OSS (Oxford Shoulder Score) outcome measures. An improvement between pre- and post-operative scoring was observed in both DASH median 51.7 (24.2–75.0) v 13.7 (8.3–20.8) (p=0.024) and OSS 20.6 (15–32) v 41.8 (39–47) (p<0.001). One patient had a pneumothorax intra-operatively but this resolved with conservative treatment. There were no long term complications experienced during follow up.