Abstract

High tibial osteotomy (HTO) is a well-recognised procedure to address medial compartment osteoarthritis (OA). There remains dispute on the impact of pre-operative patient factors on patient related outcome measures (PROMS).

Does BMI and age affect > 2 year and > 5 year oxford knee scores (OKS) and Knee injury and osteoarthritis outcome scores (KOOS).

A retrospective review of a prospectively collected database was performed. Timeframe was 26/6/2014 and 25/8/2022. BMI and age were recorded. OKS and KOOS were collected at > 2 years and > 5 years.

There were 81 procedures included, of these 50 had OKS and KOOS scores at > 2 years and 35 at > 5 years. Median BMI was 28.5kg/m², range was 18.6–40.8kg/m². Spearman's rank for >2 year OKS was p(df)=−0.210 p=0.157, > 5 year OKS p(df)=−0.215 p=0.230. For > 2 year and > 5 year KOOS subscales there were no statistically significant associations on Spearman's rank.

For age, median age was 52.5, range 26–71 years old. OKS at >2 year p(df)=0.068 p=0.664, OKS >5 years p(df)=0.065 p= 0.709. For >2 year and > 5 year KOOS subscales there were no statistically significant associations on Spearman's rank.

There were no adverse outcome in patients up-to the age of 71. There were no statistically significant Spearman's rank correlations between PROMS and OKS/KOOS scores. This supports recent KOG consensus statement highlighting physiological age importance vs chronological age. Of note there were more negative associations in the BMI group compared with age.

Abstract

Unicompartment knee replacement (UKR) has been an effective treatment of isolated medial compartment osteoarthritis (OA). There has been several studies which suggest that patellofemoral (PFJ) wear may not be a relative contraindication for UKR with no statistical difference in failure rates. There is currently conflicting evidence on the role of BMI.

We will review if BMI and PFJ wear impacts on the post operative functional scores following UKR.

A retrospective review of a prospectively collected database was performed. Data was collected between 26/6/2014 and 25/8/2022. 159 UKR procedures were identified. BMI and PFJ cartilage wear were collected. Oxford knee scores (OKS) were collected at > 2 years. PFJ wear was split into International Cartilage Research Society (ICRS) grades I&II and III&IV.

159 UKR procedures were identified, of these 115 had 2 year follow up. There were 77 who had OKS recorded at 2 years. For PFJ wear there was no statistical difference in the median OKS at 2 years 45 vs 43.5 (p=0.408). Assessing the BMI the median was 29kg/m², range 20–43kg/m². Spearman's rank was performed to assess the correlation between BMI and >2 year OKS, this demonstrated a moderately negative correlation p(df)=−0.339 (CI 95% −0.538, −0.104) p=0.004.

There is no statistically significant difference in >2 year OKS following UKR regardless of PFJ wear. There is a moderately negative correlation between BMI and >2 year OKS which was significant p=0.004. Therefore BMI is a more important consideration when counselling patients for UKR.

Introduction

Patellofemoral pain and instability can be quantified by using the tibial tuberosity to trochlea groove (TT-TG) distance with more than or equal to 20mm considered pathological requiring surgical correction. Aim of this study is to determine if knee joint rotation angle is predictive of a pathological TT-TG.

Oxford hip and knee scores are being used by many heath care commissioners to determine whether individual patients are eligible for joint replacement surgery. Oxford scores were not designed for use in deciding whether patients are suitable for surgery and they are not validated as a triage tool. The aim of this study was to assess what effect these predetermined threshold Oxford Scores would have on a contemporary patient cohort.

An analysis was undertaken of 4254 pre-operative Oxford scores in patients who had already undergone either hip resurfacing, a total hip, total knee or unicompartmental knee replacement surgery at our institution between 2008 and 2011. We assessed how these scores would affect the decision making pathway determining which patients would be eligible for joint replacement surgery. We also evaluated the effects this would have on patients undergoing surgery in terms of gender, sex, age and type of arthroplasty.

22.4% hip resurfacings, 10.0% of total hip replacements, 7.5% total knee replacements and 11.0% unicompartmental knee replacements would have been declined on the Oxford Scores system. The selection criteria as set by the health care commissioners was found to be ageist as there was a bias against older patients obtaining surgery. There was a bias against different forms of arthroplasty, particularly those patients suitable for resurfacing or unicompartmental knee replacement. It was also sexist as it selectively excluded male patients from surgery.

Rather than using pre-operative Oxford scores to discern which patients are eligible for surgery, evaluation of patient factors which are reported to adversely affect the outcome of hip and knee replacement surgery, may offer a better solution to improving quality of care. Oxford scores are undertaken to benchmark a providers performance and not to decide on an individual's suitability for surgery.

Background

Unicompartmental knee arthroplasty provides a good alternative to total knee arthroplasty in patients with isolated medial compartment osteoarthritis. There has been variable reporting in the literature as to whether age and sex affect the survival of unicompartmental knee arthroplasty. The aim of this study was to determine whether age and sex were predictors of failure for the Oxford unicompartmental knee arthroplasty.

Background

A number of studies have reported on the early failure of the Oxford unicompartmental knee arthroplasty. However, less evidence is available regarding the outcome following revision of failed unicompartmental knee prostheses to total knee arthroplasty. The aims of this study were to determine the time to failure for the Oxford unicompartmental knee arthroplasty and to assess the short-term outcome following revision surgery.

Aims

The purpose of our study was three fold; firstly to assess the survival of closing wedge high tibial osteotomies (CWHTO), secondly to assess any clinical factors or radiological alignment which may affect survival and thirdly to assess the change in tibial inclination and patella height.

Aims

The primary aim of this study was to determine the long-term survival of OATS (Osteochondral Autograft Transfer System) (Arthrex, Florida, USA) grafting in our centre and evaluate the reasons for failure, the secondary aim was to ascertain if age, gender, BMI, site or size of OATS graft had any influence on outcome.

Background

Unicompartmental knee arthroplasty provides a good alternative to total knee arthroplasty in patients with isolated medial compartment osteoarthritis. There has been variable reporting in the literature as to whether age and sex affect the survival of unicompartmental knee arthroplasty.

Background

A number of studies have reported on the early failure of the Oxford unicompartmental knee arthroplasty. However, less evidence is available regarding the outcome following revision of failed unicompartmental knee prostheses to total knee arthroplasty.

We present a case control comparison between two methods of fixation for 1st metatarsophalangeal (MTPJ) fusion. From 2007–2008 sixty patients were treated with either 4.0mm ACE (De Puy) screws or a Hallu-fix (Integra LifeSciences) plate fixation. We found no difference between the two groups in regard to age, ASA grade, smoking status and non-steroidal antiinflammatory use but there was a statistically significant difference in union rates. In the Hallu-fix group, nine patients went on to develop a non-union whereas one patient developed a non-union in the ACE screw fixation group, p = 0.01. Whilst there may be perceived advantages with the Hallu-fix system in regard to the accuracy of reduction, from our results we caution against it’s use, and have found a better outcome with cheaper 4.0mm ACE screws.

Purpose: The Ponseti method of clubfoot treatment has revolutionised the management of this condition. Prior to the introduction of the Ponseti regime to the UK in the late 1990’s children were frequently treated by open surgical releases. The aim of our study is to compare the patient’s perspective of outcome following Ilizarov treatment against the long-term outcome generated by the formal scoring systems.

Method: We identified nine patients and 14 feet from the theatre logbooks, treated by the senior author (CB), with recurrent deformity of idiopathic clubfeet, using an ilizarov external fixator between 1994 and 1996. A variety of objective and subjective scoring systems were used to compare the results following Ilizarov treatment.

Results: International Clubfoot Study Group (ICFSG) scores on six patients gave two excellent feet, one good foot, four fair feet and one poor foot. Giving an excellent/ good rate of only 37.5% with a mean follow up of 13.5 years. The Reinker & Carpenter scoring system resulted in five feet graded as excellent, one as good and two were rated poor. Giving an excellent/good rate of 75%. Functional questioning was also undertaken, six of seven (85%) patients deemed their treatment a success and were glad to have undergone treatment with an ilizarov frame. All but one patient is in higher education pursuing a vocational career or are in full time employment.

Conclusion: Our results show that 85% of our patients who were treated with an Ilizarov frame for correction of a relapsed clubfoot were happy with their long term outcome. Thus the patient’s perspective of the long term results of Ilizarov treatment for relapsed club foot are very encouraging. These results do not appear to correlate well with the International Clubfoot Study Group scores.

Salter’s innominate osteotomy predisposes the hip to acetabular retroversion as it hinges upon the symphysis pubis. Retroversion is a recognised cause of osteoarthritis, hip pain and clinical signs of impingement, but there is uncertainty as to whether this over cover persists with growth and development.

We reviewed the long-term follow up of twenty patients that had undergone a Salter’s osteotomy between 1985 to 1993 at The Royal Orthopaedic Hospital Birmingham or New Cross Hospital Wolverhampton. Sixteen skeletally mature patients were available for review that had previously had the pelvic osteotomy performed at a mean five years of age with a contralateral normal hip. Salter’s osteotomy had been performed for developmental dysplasia of the hip in 13 patients and for Perthes’ disease in three patients. Follow up was performed at an average age of 20 years. Outcome was assessed using the Harris Hip Score and a clinical examination for signs of impingement and by a measurement of acetabular version, on well centered pelvic radiograph.

Acetabular version was evaluated by the relationship between anterior and posterior walls of both the normal and Salter acetabulum, using radiographic templates as described by Hefti. Mean acetabular version averaged 16.9 degrees (95% CI 7.6 to 26.1) of anteversion on the Salter side and 17.6 degrees (95% CI 10.4 to 24.8) anteversion on the contralateral normal hip. There was no statistical difference between the version on operated and normal hips, paired t test (p = 0.83). Harris Hip Score averaged 85, indicating a good outcome at long-term follow up. Two patients (12%) demonstrated retroversion, however neither of these had signs of impingement on clinical examination.

After a Salter innominate osteotomy in childhood, we believe there is remodelling of acetabular version by skeletal maturity.

We present a review of 195 patients attending hip ultrasound clinic from June 2005–2006 to assess for hip dysplasia. 51 dysplastic hips were identified and if appropriate were treated with a Pavlik harness. Follow up was continued until ultrasound was normal. However three cases (7%) were found to be dysplastic on further follow up. Whilst this study does not prove the existence of ‘late’ dysplasia occurring in hips that were normal at birth, it does show that hips treated to normality in the first six months of life can develop recurrent dysplasia. It suggests that weaning from Pavlik harness maybe appropriate and highlights the need for long term follow up for dysplastic hips with pelvic x-ray at 5 months.

Purpose of study: To report the use of a forearm fascial strip to repair the annular ligament and treat late diagnosed or irreducible Monteggia fracture.

Methods: Through Boyd’s approach nineteen patients with Monteggia fractures were treated with a technique to reconstruct the annular ligament using forearm fascia, retaining its proximal attachment to the ulna. The radial head was dislocated and the fascial strip wound around the neck of the radius. After reducing the radial head, forearm rotation was checked. The strip was sutured to the residual annular ligament on the proximal ulna after correction of any ulna deformity. In late diagnosis, the ulna deformity was managed with ulna lengthening of approximately 0.5 cm and stabilization with a 4- or 5- hole semi-tubular AO plate. The stability of the radial head was then assessed using intra-operative fluoroscopy.

Results: Stability of the radial head was achieved in all cases. According to the Anderson classification, the final outcome was excellent in ten cases satisfactory in eight cases and unsatisfactory in one late diagnosed patient with an associated radioulnar synostosis secondary to a compartment syndrome. There were no failures. Two radiocapitellar K-wires broke while in plaster in the initial period, so the use of a K wire was subsequently abandoned.

Conclusions: We have found this technique to be reliable for stabilizing the proximal radioulnar joint. The length of the incision is less than that required for the Bell Tawse (triceps tendon) technique and permits a tourniquet on the upper arm. Poorer results were achieved with delay in diagnosis beyond 6 months.

Patients must be warned of potential reduction of forearm rotation.

Introduction: The aim of our study was to assess any difference in outcome between non-surgical and surgical treatment of displaced calcaneal fractures.

Materials and Methods: We studied 40 patients between 2000 to 2005 with displaced calcaneal fractures. Patients with significant co-morbidities were excluded. Two groups of 14 patients, surgery vs. no surgery were compared for age, sex, length of follow-up, fracture type by Essex-Lopresti classification and SF-36 outcome score. The non-surgical group underwent treatment with rest, ice, compression, elevation and the surgical group underwent fixation with an AO calcaneal plate through an extended lateral approach.

Results: There was no statistically significant difference between the surgical and conservatively treated groups for age, sex, time since injury and fracture type according to Essex-Lopresti but a highly statistically significant difference in SF-36 outcomes between the two groups favouring surgically treated calcaneal fractures.

Summary: Displaced fractures of the calcaneum are a significant injury affecting patients general health. In the literature controversy exists as to whether operative or non-operative treatment is better for this type of fracture.

Conclusion: Although the numbers are small, our study favours operative intervention, if possible, for this controversial fracture.

Meticulous haemostasis not only improves the operative field facilitating spinal surgery, but also diminishes chances of post-operative neurological complications from a compressive haematoma. Since being introduced in the 1940’s, implantable haemostats have proven a useful adjunct in achieving haemostasis with relatively few complications. However, their use in spaces bounded by bony architecture can lead to compressive effects on neurological structures.

We present three cases of post-operative cauda equina syndrome – two cases following surgery for lumbar disc herniation and one case following surgery for lumbar canal stenosis. In each case, implantable haemostats were utilised to control haemorrhage for complications during the surgery. All three patients underwent urgent exploration, which revealed cauda equina compression from clot organised around the haemostat. Neurological recovery was variable.

We recommend careful attention to intra-operative haemostasis. Although haemostats can assist in achieving haemostasis, we caution against leaving them in situ.