Purpose: To analyse preliminary outcomes of a new synthetic ligament used for reconstructing coraco-clavicular ligament in acromio-clavicular joint disruption. Methods: Patients who underwent acromio-clavicular joint stabilisation using Nottingham Surgilig were followed up at average of 40 months (range 6–80 months) post operation. Apart from clinical and radiological assessment, the Constant-Murley scoring system and the Imatani scores were also used to measure outcome. Results: Twenty patients underwent this operation and data was available on 19 of them. These patients had their operation after an average of 18 months following injury, during which period they had conservative treatment, except in 2 cases where a Weaver Dunn operation was performed initially. The mean Constant score was 88 (s.d. 12). The mean Imatani score was 86 (s.d. 16). Most patients were satisfied with the operation (90%). There was one case of rupture through the central portion of the Surgilig, and following extensive laboratory analysis, the ligament has been modified since. One patient had a fracture of his coracoid while lifting heavy weights. In 4 patients there was clinical and radiological evidence of loosening of the screw but only 1 complained of this being a problem. Conclusion: This is an initial medium term outcome analysis of the Nottingham Surgilig. Our results are promising and justify further use and evaluation of this relatively new technique

Background. Nonsurgical treatment of Acromioclavicular joint dislocations is well established. Most patients treated conservatively do well, however, some of them develop persistent symptoms. We have used two different surgical reconstruction techniques for Chronic ACJ dislocation stabilization. The study evaluates the effectiveness of a braided polyester prosthetic ligament and modified Weaver-Dunn reconstruction methods. Methods. 55 patients (mean age 42) with Chronic Acromioclavicular joint dislocation were included in this study. They were treated either by a modified Weaver-Dunn method or a braided polyester prosthetic ligament. Patients were assessed using Oxford shoulder score preoperatively and a minimum of 12 months postoperatively. Results. 31 patients (mean age 40, M=24, F=7) were treated by Modified WD method and 24 patients (mean age 44, M=18, F=6) by Surgilig at a mean21 and 24 months post injury. The mode of injury, presentation of symptoms, grade of injury and mean time at surgery post injury was similar in both the groups. There was a significant improvement (p<0.05) in mean pre and postoperative Oxford Shoulder score in both the groups (WD Mean preop OSS=28, postop OSS= 42, Surgilig Mean preop OSS=26, postop OSS=45). The Surgilig group returned to work significantly earlier (Surgilig; mean 6 wks, WD mean 14 wks). There were 3 failures in the WD group and 1 in Surgilig. Superficial infection was seen in 3 patients requiring antibiotics only. Most of the patients from both groups were satisfied with their result except for 3 patients, one which developed complex regional pain syndrome and two developed secondary shoulder problems resulting in ongoing pain. Conclusions. Chronic ACJ dislocations can be successfully treated surgically by either Weaver-Dunn or Surgilig based on similar satisfaction scores amongst patients of both groups. In this study Surgilig had higher overall success rate, less incidence of failure and allowed earlier return to work

Chronic instability of the acromioclavicular joint is relatively common and normally occurs following a fall onto the point of the shoulder. Reconstruction of the joint (Weaver-Dunn procedure) is often required in service personnel, and numerous methods of fixation have been used, including vicryl tape, PDS loops and the use of a hook plate. Many of these operative methods require a second operation to remove the plates and/or screws, and are associated with a failure rate of up to 30%. The ‘Surgilig’ was designed as a method of revision for failed Weaver-Dunn procedures. However this study evaluates its use in the primary operation. We prospectively followed up the Modified Weaver Dunn procedures using surgilig. The post-operative x-rays were reviewed at six weeks, 3 months and then 6 months when the patients were discharged to assess the radiological success of the procedure. We have performed this procedure in 11 patients. Of the eight patients that have reached the six month postoperative time so far, at which they would be discharged from clinic follow-up, none have had radiological failure of the fixation. One patient even had weight-bearing x-rays taken at 6 weeks, with no detrimental effect. Even though a small study, the initial results for primary fixation of acromioclavicular joint disruption with surgilig are extremely encouraging. The study suggests that surgilig should continue to be used in its current role. As patient numbers increase, a follow-up study should be conducted to evaluate these preliminary findings

Osteolysis has been reported following ACJ reconstruction with a synthetic graft. We present the first study into its prevalence and pattern, and its effect on patient outcome. Patients who underwent treatment of an unstable ACJ injury using the Surgilig/LockDown implant were identified via our database. Patients were invited to attend a dedicated outpatient clinic for clinical examination, radiographic evaluation, and completion of outcome scoring. Patients who were unable to attend were contacted by telephone. 49 patients were identified. We assessed 21 clinically at a mean of 7 years post-procedure (range 3–11 years). All had radiographic evidence of distal clavicle and coracoid osteolysis. We did not observe progression of osteolysis from the final post-operative radiographs. A further 13 were contacted by phone. The mean Oxford Shoulder Score was 43 (range 31–48) and mean DASH score was 8.5 (range 3–71). The average Patient Global Impression of Change score was 6 (range 2–7). Six patients underwent removal of a prominent screw at a mean of 2 years after surgery; the pattern of osteolysis was no different in this group. All patients had comparable abduction, forward flexion and internal rotation to their uninjured shoulder. We did not observe any relationship between patient demographics, position of implant or etiology and the pattern of osteolysis. Osteolysis of the distal clavicle and/or coracoid is always seen following synthetic reconstruction of the ACJ using this implant, but is non-progressive. Range of shoulder movement is largely unaffected and patient outcomes remain high

In the UK we have many surgeon inventors – surgeons who innovate and create new ways of doing things, who invent operations, who design new instruments to facilitate surgery or design new implants for using in patients. However truly successful surgeon inventors are a rare breed and they need to develop additional knowledge and skills during their career in order to push forward their devices and innovations. This article reviews my own experiences as a surgeon inventor and the highs and lows over the whole of my surgical career.

The December 2015 Shoulder & Elbow Roundup360 looks at: