Objectives. To assess the effectiveness of a modified tibial tubercle osteotomy as a treatment for arthroscopically diagnosed chondromalacia patellae. Methods. A total of 47 consecutive patients (51 knees) with arthroscopically proven chondromalacia, who had failed conservative management, underwent a modified Fulkerson tibial tubercle osteotomy. The mean age was 34.4 years (19.6 to 52.2). Pre-operatively, none of the patients exhibited signs of patellar maltracking or instability in association with their anterior knee pain. The minimum follow-up for the study was five years (mean 72.6 months (62 to 118)), with only one patient lost to follow-up. Results. A total of 50 knees were reviewed. At final follow-up, the Kujala knee score improved from 39.2 (12 to 63) pre-operatively to 57.7 (16 to 89) post-operatively (p < 0.001). The visual analogue pain score improved from 7.8 (4 to 10) pre-operatively to 5.0 (0 to 10) post-operatively. Overall patient satisfaction with good or excellent results was 72%. Patients with the lowest pre-operative Kujala score benefitted the most. Older patients benefited less than younger ones. The outcome was independent of the grade of chondromalacia. Six patients required screw removal. There were no major complications. Conclusions. We conclude that this modification of the Fulkerson procedure is a safe and useful operation to treat anterior knee pain in well aligned patellofemoral joints due to chondromalacia patellae in adults, when conservative measures have failed

The aim of this study was to assess the outcome of patients who underwent ElmslieTrillat antero-medial tibial tubercle transfer for treatment of persistent symptomatic anterior knee pain due to chondromalacia patellae. We performed a prospective analysis of 23 patients who underwent Elmslie-Trillat antero-medial tibial tubercle transfers over a five year period for chronic anterior knee pain and an arthroscopic diagnosis of chondromalacia patellae. All patients who presented with anterior knee pain underwent an initial period of physiotherapy and all patients whose symptoms persisted following physiotherapy underwent arthroscopic assessment. Patients who continued to experience debilitating symptoms despite this initial treatment and who also had a diagnosis of chondromalacia patellae from arthroscopic assessment were listed for an Elmslie-Trillat tibial tubercle anteromedialisation. Patients who gave a history of instability or dislocation were excluded. The average age of patients undergoing surgery was 34 years (21–48 years) and the average time between arthroscopic diagnosis and surgery was 14 months. All patients who underwent surgery had pre and post operative KuJala patellofemoral scoring. The average pre-operative score was 54 (30–78) and post operative score 76 (46–100). The average post operative assessment was 25 months (6–62 months). Twenty one patients had improved post operative scores with one having a worse score and one score remaining unchanged following surgery. Nineteen patients felt that their symptoms had improved, three felt that there had been no change and one felt that they were worse after surgery. When asked if the improvement in symptoms had been worthwhile nineteen stated that they would undergo surgery again if in the same situation and four stated that they would not. The treatment of symptomatic chondromalacia patellae remains a challenge. Although a more selective approach to individuals with anterior knee pain is widely advocated in the literature this study demonstrates that good results can still be achieved in patients treated empirically with a tibial tubercle anteromedialisation

The October 2012 Knee Roundup. 360. looks at: autologous chondrocytes and chondromalacia patellae; drilling the femoral tunnel at ACL reconstruction; whether we repair the radially torn lateral meniscus; factors associated with patellofemoral pain; mechanoreceptors and the allografted ACL; whether high tibial osteotomy can delay the need for knee replacement; return to sport after ACL reconstruction; tissue-engineered cartilage; and the benefits of yoga

Background. Autologous chondrocyte implantation (ACI) and mosaicplasty (MP) are two methods of repair of symptomatic articular cartilage defects in the adult knee. This study represents the only long-term comparative clinical trial of the two methods. Methods. A prospective, randomised comparison of the two modalities involving 100 patients with symptomatic articular cartilage lesions was undertaken. Patients were followed for ten years. Pain and function were assessed using the modified Cincinnati score, Bentley Stanmore Functional rating system and visual analogue scores. ‘Failure’ was determined by pain, a poor outcome score and arthroscopic evidence of graft disintegration. Results. Patients had a mean age at index operation of 31. There was a long mean pre-op duration of symptoms of seven years and the defects had an average of 1.5 operations (excluding arthroscopy) to the articular cartilage lesion prior to the cartilage repair surgery. The aetiology of the articular cartilage defects was mainly trauma; some patients had osteochondritis dissecans or chondromalacia patellae. Five patients were lost to follow-up. A total of 23 out of 42 mosaicplasty patients failed, 10 out of 58 ACI patients failed (p<0.001). Most patients did well for the first two years when there was a steep failure of mosaicplasty patients, after which the failure rate was more constant. There was a low steady failure rate of ACI over the 10 years. Older patients treated by ACI did worse than younger patients; age was less of a prognostic indicator in MP. Patients irrespective of gender or aetiology of the defect fared better with ACI than MP. Conclusion. At ten years, patients who underwent cartilage repair using ACI fared significantly better than those who underwent mosaicplasty

Introduction: The indications for patellectomy have been considerably narrowed in recent years, but there remains a cohort of patients with previous patellectomies that remain symptomatic. In addition, these patients can develop osteoarthrosis or instability, and their treatment is challenging. We report our experience of the use of a novel implant to substitute for the absent native patella. Materials and Methods: Six patients were treated with the Augmentation Patella (Zimmer, Allendale, USA), which was sutured to the patellar tendon. All 6 patients had previously had a patellectomy for anterior knee pain syndrome or chondromalacia patellae, between 5 and 22 years previously. They all had an arthroscopy to document the extent of degenerative changes. Patients with trochlear changes only had the trochlea resurfaced (4 cases) and those with tibio-femoral changes as well had a total knee replacement (2 cases). Results: One patient reported excellent relief of pain, with no evidence of radiological loosening. Two patients continued to complain of pain despite the implant being solidly fixed. One patient developed wound complications secondary to difficult closure due to the bulk of the implant. In two patients, the implant loosened within 15 months necessitating further surgery to retrieve the Augmentation Patella. Discussion: The results of the Augmentation Patella in our series of patients with previous patellectomies have been disappointing. Previous studies, where this implant has been used with a remaining shell of patella, has yielded better results. This suggests that bony ingrowth is important for a successful outcome. We recommend that this device should only be implanted if bony contact is possible

Aims: Anterior knee pain is a common complaint of mixed aetiology, and in many cases no demonstrable cause is identified. For patients with persistant anterior knee pain, tibial tubercle transfer (TTT) can be a surgical option. The aim of this study is to assess the effectiveness of TTT for chronic anterior knee pain resistant to conservative treatment. Method: All patients with arthroscopically proven Chondromalacia patellae (CMP) without clinical evidence of patella instability, who have failed to respond to conservative treatment such as physiotherapy were included in the trial. They underwent TTT with a modified Fulkerson technique and then routine post-operative care with a cricket pad splint for 2–4 weeks. Pre and post-operative scores were obtained using a Kujala patello-femoral score, a visual analogue score for pain and a patient satisfaction score. The Outerbridge grading was used to score the severity of CMP at arthroscopy. Results: There were 50 TTT’s followed up (7 staged bilaterals) with a mean follow up of 32.4 months (5–88 months). There were significant improvement in the pre-operative and post-operative Kujala (p> 0.001) and visual analogue pain scores (p> 0.001). Of the 50 TTT’s 70% had an excellent or good result and 30% a fair or poor result. Moreover 76% claimed that they would have the same operation again for their condition. There was no significant correlation between Outerbridge grading and post-operative outcome. Complications include late anterior knee pain (10 cases), superficial wound infection (1 case), non-union of osteotomy (1 case) and tuberosity fracture (1 case). Conclusion: Anteromedial tibial tubercle transfer is a reliable and effective treatment for peristant anterior knee pain

Traditional dogma states that anterior knee pain in adolescence does not lead to patello-femoral arthritis. However analysis of 642 new knee referrals seen in one year showed that over 25% had anterior knee pain and that patients were of all ages. This lead to us questioning whether anterior knee pain or adolescent chondromalacia patellae is in fact a benign self limiting condition. Method: A postal questionnaire was sent to 150 patients who had undergone isolated patello femoral replacement (PFR) enquiring about patella problems earlier in life. The same questionnaire was sent to a matched group of patients who had undergone unicompartmental replacement; because of the selection policy of the unit, these would not have had changes of patellofemoral arthritis. Results: 118 patients who had undergone PFR retumed the form. 107 were female; the average age at surgery was 66 years. 26 (22%) reported adolescent anterior knee pain at an average age of 18. 112 forms were returned form the UKR group in which females predominated and who had an average age at surgery of 67 years. Only 7 (6%) reported adolescent anterior knee pain, at an average age of 19. 16 (14%) of the PFR group reported adolescent patella instability as opposed to 1 on the UKR group. Discussion: The finding that significantly more patients with isolated patello-femoral arthritis had suffered from adolescent anterior knee pain suggests a possible causal relationship. Further long-term studies are needed to determine whether adolescent anterior knee pain is benign, as traditionally believed, or whether certain subsets are precursors of patello-femoral arthritis

Introduction and aim: Several authors have suggested that hyaline repair tissue following autologous – chondrocyte implantation (ACI) gives better clinical results than either mixed hyaline and fibrocartilage or fibrocartilage alone. This data is based on the use of periosteum as a covering membrane in these previous studies. We have for some years been using a porcine collagen type 1/III membrane (ACI-C) instead of periosteum and have now the opportunity to analyze the clinical results when compared with the histology of the repaired defect. We have also analysed the influence on the result of age and sex of the patient, the etiology of the lesion, the duration of the knee symptoms, number of previous knee procedures, the site and size of defect and the preoperative functional scores. Method: Until 2004, 234 patients underwent autologous chondrocyte implantation at our centre. The patients were assessed clinically by their modified Cincinnati scores prospectively from 1 to 4 years from surgery. Also at arthroscopy (1 to 3 years following ACI-C) they underwent biopsy of the implant where possible and the neo-cartilage was graded as hyaline (H), mixed fibrohyaline (F.H), fibrocartilagenous (F.C) and fibrous (F). Results: The clinical results showed that older patients had poorer results (p< 0.001) and a high preoperative modified Cincinnati score predicted a good result (p< 0.001). Concerning the cause of the defect, the percentage of patients with excellent and good results were significantly low among those with previously failed ACIs and mosaicplaties (12.5%) compared with those following trauma, osteochondritis dessicans and chondromalacia patellae (67% to 77%). At 4 year follow-up, 75% of patients with hyaline neo-cartilage had excellent and good modified Cincinnati scores whereas those with mixed fibro-hyaline and fibro-cartilage had fewer excellent and good results (44.4% and 54.5% respectively). The other parameters such as gender, the site of defect, duration of knee symptoms and the number of previous procedures and the size of the defect did not significantly influence the outcome. In conclusion, patients most likely to benefit from autologous chondrocyte implantation using a collagen membrane (ACI – C) are younger patients with higher preoperative functional scores and those who develop hyaline neo-cartilage

Many methods have been described over the past 5 years for repair of articular cartilage defects. The best reported results have been from the use of autologous chondrocyte transplantation (ACT)(1) and mosaicplasty.(2) There have, however, been no prospective clinical trials of these two methods. In this trial 70 patients were prospectively randomized to receive either autologous chondrocyte transplantation (37) or mosaicplasty (33) in the knee. 37 patients were female and 33 male. The average age was 32 years (16 – 44). The indications for surgery were persistent pain and mechanical symptoms in the knee with an isolated defect of the articular cartilage. 38 (56%) were post-traumatic, 12 (16%) due to osteochondritis dissecans, 10 (14%) due to previous meniscectomy, and 10 (14%) due to chondromalacia patellae. The size of the defects ranged from 2cm2 to 12cm2 (mean 4.8cm2). There were 35 defects on the medial femoral condyle, 13 on the lateral femoral condyle, 17 on the patella and 5 on the trochlear. 31 patients were undergoing primary surgery and 39 secondary surgery. All were independently reviewed using the Visual Analogue Pain Score, the Cincinatti Pain Score and the Stanmore Score. Patients were arthroscoped at one year with MRI scan and biopsies where possible. Results: The visual analogue pain score improved overall from a mean of 5.4 (range 3.4 – 7.4) pre-operatively to 3.9 (1.8 – 5.1) at one year review. Similarly the Cincinatti pain score improved from 6.5 pre-operatively to 10.2 post-operatively and the Cincinatti function score improved from 46 to 62 at one year before sport commenced. Overall 71% (49) patients were excellent or good on the clinical scoring scales, 15% (11) were fair, and 14% (10) were poor. The 10 poor results were no different from the main group with regard to age, sex, pain level or site or size of lesion. However, 5 were secondary procedures, 2 had multiple lesions, and 3 had had previous ruptured anterior cruciate ligaments. Arthroscopy and biopsy of 21 lesions so far after one year has shown mature articular cartilage in 2, and immature cartilage in 19. In all cases there was bonding of the repair tissue to the underlying bone. This study is already clarifying the role of ACT and mosaicplasty in the management of cartilage defects in the knee and also the necessity for the use of periosteal covering membrane

Objectives

Matrix-assisted autologous chondrocyte transplantation (MACT) has been developed and applied in the clinical practice in the last decade to overcome most of the disadvantages of the first generation procedures. The purpose of this systematic review is to document and analyse the available literature on the results of MACT in the treatment of chondral and osteochondral lesions of the knee.