header advert
Results 21 - 35 of 35
Results per page:
Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 93-B, Issue SUPP_IV | Pages 430 - 430
1 Nov 2011
Argenson J Parratte S Flecher X Aubaniac J
Full Access

Unicompartmental knee arthroplasty (UKA) is a logic procedure when osteoarthritis or avascular necrosis is limitad to one femorotibial compartment. The indications for the procedure includes osteoarthrosis or osteonecrosis with full-thickness loss of articular cartilage limited to one of the tibiofemoral knee compartments. Physical examination should ensure full range of knee motion. Frontal and sagittal knee stability has to be tested. A particular attention should be given to the state of the anterior cruciate ligament. The status of the patellofemoral joint should be analysed by physical examination and patellofemoral view at 30, 60 and 90° of flexion. Preoperative anteroposterior varus and valgus stress radiographs should be done to confirm the complete loss of articular cartilage in the involved compartment, the full thickness cartilage in the opposite compartment and the possibility of full correction of the deformity to neutral.

The so-called minimally invasive surgery (MIS) procedure using a specific instrumentation is able to provide quicker recovery since the extensor mechanism disruption is eliminated. More importantly the radiological evaluation has shown that precise implantation of the components is possible with an MIS approach which is important for the long term results of the arthroplasty. The clinical results at ten years of follow-up of cemented metal-backed UKA performed through a conventional approach have shown results comparable to those obtained with total knee arthroplasty. The in vivo kinematic evaluation of patients implanted with UKA has shown that kinematics similar to the normal knee can be obtained, enhancing the importance of a functional anterior cruciate ligament.

Recent design improvements have increased the femorotibial area of contact to accommodate high flexion angles. Additionally our experience has demonstrated that modern UKA is a valid alternative for young and active patients with unicompartmental tibiofemoral noninflammatory disease, including both osteoarthritis and avascular necrosis. Compared to medial UKA lateral UKA represents in our experience only 5% of all UKA implantations.

However the long term results of lateral UKA compares at least equally with those reported for medial UKA.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 93-B, Issue SUPP_II | Pages 174 - 174
1 May 2011
Parratte S Sorenson M Dahm D Larson D O’Byrne M Pagnano M Stuart M Smith A Berry D
Full Access

Introduction: The International Knee Documentation Committee (IKDC) recommends use of the IKDC score to document subjective, objective and functional ACL outcome. To further improve knowledge concerning patient QOL after ACL reconstruction, an additional specific QOL questionnaire was developed. Using a combination of univariate and multivariate analysis the patient factors and surgical factors that influenced QOL 5- years after ACL reconstruction were determined.

Materials: 500 patients operated on for arthroscopic ACL reconstruction at our institution between 1997 and 2001 were prospectively enrolled. Patient psychosocial profile, sport expectations, knee exam, type of graft, associated lesion, type of anesthesia, complications, IKDC, KT 2000 at 6 moths, 1 year and 2 years were recorded. At five years, patients were asked to complete a 5-subscale validated QOL questionnaire for ACL deficiency. A multivariate analysis was performed to identify the factors influencing 5-year QOL.

Results: 203 patients completed the 5-years QOL questionnaire. Responders did not statistically differ from non responders. Patient subjective factors such as: patient expectations, pre-operative symptoms, work-school concerns, recreations concerns, social and psycho-social concerns were significantly (p< 0.05) and independently associated with the five-year QOL results. Objective factors such as meniscus tears and results of the KT 2000 (p< 0.05) were the two surgical factors correlated with 5-year QOL.

Discussion: In this large prospective study, most of the factors influencing the 5-year QOL results after ACL reconstruction were related to patient expectations, psycho-social, symptoms and work-sport concerns. The presence of a meniscus tear and greater KT 2000 laxity also contributed to poorer 5-year QOL results.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 93-B, Issue SUPP_II | Pages 216 - 216
1 May 2011
Parratte S Amphoux T Kolta S Gagey O Skalli W Bouler J Argenson J
Full Access

Introduction: The incidence of contralateral, second hip fractures after a first hip fracture is as high as 20% in the elderly. Femoroplasty using an injectable and resorbable bi-phosphonate loaded bone substitute to prevent controlateral hip fracture may represent a promising preventive therapy. We aimed to evaluate the biomechanical consequences of the femoroplasty using this bone substitute.

Materials and Methods: Twelve paired human cadaveric femora from donors with a mean age of 86 years (7 women and 6 men) were randomly assigned for femoroplasty and biomechanically tested for fracture load against their native contralateral control. Anterior–posterior and lateral radiographs and DXAscan’s were made before injection. Femoroplasty were performed under fluoroscopic guidance with an injectable and resorbable bi-phosphonate loaded bone substitute. All femurs were fractured by simulating a fall on the greater trochanter by an independent observer.

Results: Mean T-score of the tested femur were −3. Bone density was comparable for each pair of femur. All the observed fractures were Kyle II throchanteric fractures. Mean fracture load was 2786 Newton in the femoroplasty group (group F) versus 2116 Newton in the control group (group C) (p< 0.001). Fracture loads were always higher in the group F: mean 41.6% (mini: 1.2%/maxi:102.1%). Effect of femoroplasty was significantly superior for women and also correlated to initial bone density (p< 0.0001).

Discussion:According to our results, femoroplasty with an injectable and resorbable bi-phosphonate loaded bone substitute can provide significant biomechanical reinforcement of the proximal femur to prevent controlateral fracture.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 93-B, Issue SUPP_II | Pages 93 - 93
1 May 2011
Parratte S Argenson J Since M Pierre PB Pauly V Aubaniac J
Full Access

Introduction: Women have gender specific shape of the distal femur. To fit these gender characteristics, gender specific femoral implants were developed for total knee arthroplasty (TKA). We aimed to compare

objective and subjective functional improvement;

patient satisfaction and preference and

cost-utility ratio after gender specific TKA or standard component implanted on the same women.

Materials and Methods: 30 women (60 knees) operated on successively (6 months in between) for a bilateral TKA between March 2006 and March 2008 by the same surgeon were included in this prospective study. The same surgical protocol and the same post-operative management protocol were applied for both sides. Mean age was 67±3 and mean BMI 26±4 Kg/m2. At a minimum follow-up of one year, evaluation objective and subjective functional improvement, patient satisfaction and preference and cost-utility analysis were performed double blind.

Results: Knee Society knee score and Knee Osteoarthritis Outcome Score (KOOS) improvements were comparable in both groups. However, 75% of the women preferred their gender TKA (p< 0.001). 68% of the women described less crepitus or anterior knee bothering after gender TKA (p=0.003) and 64% had faster recovery with the gender implant (p< 0.001). The cost-utility analysis was favorable for the gender knee.

Discussion: No objective or subjective superiority in terms of functional improvement was shown with gender specific implants at this short-term follow-up. However significant differences in terms of patient satisfaction and preference and a favorable cost-utility analysis were observed. These results should now be confirmed at longer-follow-up. Despite comparative functional improvement, patient satisfaction and preference were higher for the side implanted with a gender specific TKA in this prospective comparative study.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 92-B, Issue SUPP_III | Pages 387 - 387
1 Jul 2010
Flecher X Pearce O Parratte S Grisoli D Helix M Aubaniac J Argenson J
Full Access

Introduction and Method: For 16 years, now, we have been using custom made femoral stems (titanium stem, HA coated) based on preoperative patient CT scans in young patients presenting with symptomatic osteoarthritis of the hip. The aim was to provide optimum initial fit-and-fill of the stem in the femoral medullary canal, conferring the best chance of secondary osteoin-tegration. This, with a goal of long term survivorship. The custom stem also enables dialling-in correction of the (often abnormal) femoral neck version (in young patients presenting with arthritis) to a more normalised 15 degrees of anteversion.

Results: We present the long term results (5–16 year, mean of 10 years), clinical, survivorship and radiological, of 312 primary total hip arthroplasties in 280 patients, all of whom were under the age of 50 years of age (mean age 40).

At 10 years we have a survivorship, if femoral aseptic loosening is used as an end point, of 97.6%. There was a deep infection rate of 1.2%, and a dislocation rate of 1.9%. There were no cases of thigh pain, and no intra-operative femoral neck/shaft fractures.

Discussion: The under 50’s with hip arthritis requiring total hip arthroplasty are a highly challenging group, they are young, active and tend to have distorted anatomy. Our results are superior to those previously published using either cemented or standard uncemented stems. Thus, justifying the increased initial financial outlay on the custom-made stem.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 92-B, Issue SUPP_II | Pages 359 - 359
1 May 2010
Parratte S Mahfouz M Booth R Argenson J
Full Access

Introduction: morphological analysis of the general shape of the bones and of their particular variations according to the patient age, gender and pathology is an important step to improve the orthopedic management. We aimed to performed a gender specific analysis of the bi and tridimensional anatomy of the distal femur in vitro and in vivo.

Materials and Methods: in vitro data were obtained from CT-scan performed on 92 dry men femurs and 52 dry women femurs. Using a manual contouring method and a segmentation method, tridimensional reconstructions were obtained and according to two different algorithms, the regions of discrepancies between men and women were determined. An automatic calculation of 59 defined measurements was then performed. In vivo data providing from 59 CT-scans of men femur and 73 CT-scan of women femurs were acquired. Standardized bidimensional measurements at the level of the trochlear cut were performed.

Results: in vivo, statistically significant differences were observed for the: medio-lateral distance (M-Ld women=7.4±0.4cm vs M-Ld men=8.4±0.5cm; p< 0.0001), anteroposterior distance (A-Pd women=5.9±0,4cm vs A-Pd men= 6.4±0.4cm; p< 0.0001) and for the ratio anterior-posterior distance/medio-lateral distance (p< 0.0001). The trochlear groove angle was comparable in the two groups. In vitro, the tridimensional shape of the distal femur was more trapezoidal in women than in men. Medio-lateral distances were also statistically greater in men than in women (p< 0.01), the ratio anterior-posterior distance/medio-lateral distance was also statistically greater in men than in women (p< 0.01) and the Q angle more open in women than in men (p< 0.01).

Discussion: Three types of differences between men and women were observed in this gender specific evaluation of the distal femur anatomy. First, for a same anteroposterior distance, the medio-lateral distance was smaller in women. Second, the global shape of the distal femur was more trapezoidal in women and third the Q angle was more open in women. This gender specific anatomy should be clinically considered when performing total knee arthroplasty in women and gender specific implants may be required.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 92-B, Issue SUPP_II | Pages 274 - 275
1 May 2010
Parratte S Flecher X Vesin O Brunet C Aubaniac J Argenson J
Full Access

Introduction: Due to the diversity of the prosthetic implants for hip arthroplasty, a better matching between the implant and the intra and extra-medullary characteristic of the patient anatomy is now possible. This adaptation however requires a perfect understanding of the tridimensional characteristics of the patient hip anatomy. Little data are available in the literature. We aimed to analyze the muscular and bony anatomy of the hip at the time of arthroplasty.

Material and Methods: data acquisition was performed according a standardized CT-scan in the same center for all patients within the standard workup before arthroplasty. Standardized measurements were obtained after automatic tridimensional bone reconstructions using dedicated software. 549 femurs in 469 patients including primitive coxarthrosis (COX), dysplasic development of the hip (DDH) and aseptic osteonecrosis (ONA) were analyzed. Mean age was 58 and 70% of the patients were women. Tridimensional reconstruction of the muscular anatomy of the hip was performed for 30 patients using manual contouring on dedicated software. Characteristics of the bony and muscular anatomy were then analyzed according to the etiology and correlations between bony and muscular anatomy were evaluated.

Results: Concerning the bone analysis, mean offset was 23.2 ±1.5mm in the DDH group, 40.5±1.2 mm in the COX group and 29.6± 0.9mm in the ONA group(p< 0.001). Neck-shaft angle was 132±25º in the DDH group, 130±0.5º in the COX group and 134±1º in the ONA group (p< 0.001). Mean anteversion was 33±3.5º in the DDH group, 25±3.8º in the COX group and 16±3.2º in the ONA group (p< 0.001). Concerning the muscular analysis, gluteus medius and minimus volumes were correlated with the body mass index and with the gender, but not with patient age (p: NS). Location of the muscular insertion of the gluteus medius and minimus on the greater trochanter were correlated with the femoral anteversion.

Discussion: The results of our study demonstrated that bony and muscular anatomical characteristics were correlated with the etiology of the degenerative joint disease, with the patient body mass index and gender. Surgeons should be aware of these characteristics to improve the patient anatomy reconstruction during the arthroplasty.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 92-B, Issue SUPP_II | Pages 326 - 326
1 May 2010
Parratte S Sah A Aubaniac J Scott R Agenson J
Full Access

Introduction: The data reporting clinical and radiological outcomes after modern unicompartmental knee arthroplasty (UKA) for spontaneous avascular osteonecrosis are limited. We hypothesized that UKA for spontaneous osteonecrosis may be as reliable and durable as it is for osteoarthritis.

Materials and Methods: We retrospectively reviewed 40 cemented UKA operated for spontaneous osteonecrosis of the knee in two different centers between 1989 and 2004. Twenty-six patients were women and 14 men, mean patient age was 67 years (range, 45 to 84) and mean body mass index was 27.4 Kg/m2 (range, 18 to 44). Clinical and radiological evaluations were performed by an independent observer in each center according to the same protocol at a minimum follow-up of 3 years (mean 8 years; range, 3–17.5 years).

Results: The mean Knee Society Knee score improved from 60 preoperatively to 95 post-operatively. The mean Knee Society Function score improved from 50 preoperatively to 89 post-operatively. Restoration of an appropriate lower-limb mechanical axis was achieved for 36 knees (90%). Two knees were revised for aseptic loosening. The Kaplan–Meier survivorship was 95% at 12 years.

Discusssion and conclusion: Our data suggest UKA is a reasonable solution for restoring clinical function and radiological lower-limb alignment for spontaneous osteonecrosis of the knee, with a durable survivorship.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 92-B, Issue SUPP_II | Pages 297 - 297
1 May 2010
Flecher X Parratte S Aubaniac J Argenson J
Full Access

A clinical and radiographic study was conducted on 97 total hip arthroplasties (79 patients) performed for congenital hip dislocation using three-dimensional custom cementless stem. The mean age was 48 years (17 to 72). The mean follow up was 123 months (83 to 182).

According to Crowe, there were 37 class 1, 28 class 2, 13 class 3 and 19 class 4. The average lengthening was 25 mm (5 to 58 mm), the mean femoral anteversion 38.6° (2° to 86°) and the correction in the prosthetic neck −23.6° (71° to 13°). The average Harris hip score improved from 58 to 93 points. Six hips (6.2%) required a revision. The survival rate was 97.7% ± 0.3% at 13 years.

Custom cementless stem allows anatomical reconstruction and good functional results in a young and active population with disturbed anatomy, while avoiding a femoral osteotomy.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 91-B, Issue SUPP_II | Pages 227 - 228
1 May 2009
Bicknell R Boileau P Chuinard C Jacquot N Parratte S Trojani C
Full Access

The purpose of this study was to review the results of biceps tenodesis and biceps reinsertion in the treatment of type II SLAP lesions.

We conducted a retrospective cohort study of a continuous series of patients. Only isolated type II SLAP lesions were included: twenty-five cases from January 2000 to April 2004. Exclusion criteria included associated instability, rotator cuff rupture and previous shoulder surgery. Ten patients (ten men) with an average age of thirty-seven years (range, 19–57) had a reinsertion of the long head of the biceps tendon (LHB) to the labrum with two suture anchors. Fifteen patients (nine men and six women) with an average age of fifty-two years (range, 28–64) underwent biceps tenodesis in the bicipital groove. All patients were reviewed by an independent examiner.

In the reattachment group, the average follow-up was thirty-five months (range, 24–69); three patients underwent subsequent biceps tenodesis for persistent pain, three others were disappointed because of an inability to return to their previous level of sport, and the remaining four were very satisfied. The average Constant score improved from sixty-five to eighty-three points. In the tenodesis group, the average follow-up was thirty-four months (range, 24–68). No patient required revision surgery. Subjectively, one patient was disappointed (atypical residual pain), two were satisfied and twelve were very satisfied. All patients returned to their previous level of sports, and the average Constant score improved from fifty-nine to eighty-nine points.

The results of labral reattachment were disappointing in comparison to biceps tenodesis. Thus, arthroscopic biceps tenodesis can be considered as an effective alternative to reattachment in the treatment of isolated type II SLAP lesions. By moving the origin of the biceps to an extra-articular position, we eliminated the traction on the superior labrum and the source of pain; furthermore, range of motion and strength are unaltered allowing for a return to a pre-surgical level of activity.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 90-B, Issue SUPP_II | Pages 242 - 242
1 Jul 2008
PARRATTE S ARGENSON J FLECHER X AUBANIAC J
Full Access

Purpose of the study: Malposition of the acetabular implant of a total hip arthroplasty can provoke dislocation, limited joint movement, and early wear. The purpose of this prospective randomized study was to assess the efficacy of a image-free navigation system to achieve correct acetabular position for total hip arthroplasty.

Material and methods: The navigation software for the acetabular component used intraoperative anatomic acquisition. The prospective randomized study included two groups of 20 patients. In the first group, the acetabular implant was inserted using the computer-assisted system and in the second using the conventional method. The same operator performed all procedures via an anterolateral approach and using the same non-cemented hemispheric cup. The postoperative assessment was performed by an independent investigator who noted the cup inclination on the standard ap view and cup anteversion on the computed tomography; then using a dedicated system for 3D reconstruction, the same values were determined one month after surgery.

Results: Each group included ten men and ten women, mean age 63 years and mean body mass index 24. For the computed-assisted group, mean additional operative time for navigation was 13 minutes (range 8–20 min). The intraopeartive concordance with the surgeons subjective impression was excellent for 12 patients and good for 8. Mean intraoperative values were for the computer-assisted group were: for operative mode: inclination 30° (25–46°), anteversion 14° (0–25°), radiographic mode: inclination 35° (25–47°), anteversion 13° (0–26°), anatomic mode: inclination 36°, anteversion 19° (0–27°). There was no significant difference between the intraoperative and postoperative values for the computer-assisted group. There was no significant difference between the average values between the computer-assisted and conventional groups but the standard deviation was smaller in the computer-assisted group.

Discussion and conclusion: The image-free navigation system enables reliable positioning of the prosthetic cup for total hip arthroplasty and increases the precision of acetabular implantation without increasing significantly operative time. This first step must be integrated into the computerized preoperative planning for total hip arthroplasty. The next step will be to use the navigation system for implanting the femoral component.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 90-B, Issue SUPP_II | Pages 258 - 258
1 Jul 2008
PARRATTE S JACQUOT N PELEGRI C TROJANI C BOILEAU P
Full Access

Purpose of the study: Arthroscopic reinsertion of SLAP lesions is the most commonly used approach. Tenodesis of the long biceps could be proposed as an alternative to reinsertion. The purpose of our study was to report the results of tenodesis and reinsertions for the treatment of type II SLAP lesions.

Material and methods: This was a consecutive monocentric comparative series analyzed retrospectively. Isolated type II SLAP lesions treated arthroscopically were retained for study: 25 cases treated from January 2000 to May 2004. Exclusion criteria were: associated instability, associated cuff tears, history of surgery. The long biceps tendon was reinserted on the glenoid tubercle using two threads mounted on resorbable anchors in ten patients (all men), mean age 27.5 years (range 19–57 years). Tenodesis of the long biceps in the gutter was performed in fifteen patients (six women and nine men), mean age 52.2 years (range 28–64 years). All patients were reviewed by an independent observer.

Results: In the reinsertion group, mean follow-up was 35 months (range 12–57 months). Three patients had revision tenodesis due to persistent pain and three others were disappointed because they were unable to resume their former sport. Four others were very satisfied. The mean Constant score improved from 65 to 83 points. Force was 16 kg in flexion and 5 kg in supination. In the tenodesis group, mean follow-up was 34 months (range 12–56 months). There were no revision procedures in this group. Subjectively, one patient was disappointed (atypical pain), two were satisfied and 12 very satisfied. The mean Constant score improved from 59 to 89 points. Force was 14.5 kg in flexion and 4.8 kg in supination.

Discussion: This series showed that results obtained with reinsertions can be disappointing: three revisions and three disappointed patients among ten procedures. In the tenodesis group, 14 of 15 patients were satisfied or very satisfied. Tenodesis of the long head of the biceps can be considered as an alternative to reinsertion for the treatment of type II SLAP lesions, particularly in older athletes.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 90-B, Issue SUPP_II | Pages 258 - 258
1 Jul 2008
Neyton L PARRATTE S PELEGRI C JACQUOT N BOILEAU P
Full Access

Purpose of the study: Depending on the series, fractures of the anteroinferior glenoid labrum have been reported in 3% to 90% of patients with anterior shoulder instability. These fractures disrupt the physiological glenoid concavity and shorten the effective length of the glenoid arch. Indications for treatment depend on the size of the fragment and range from osteosynthesis to resection or suture. We hypothesized that these lesions could be treated arthroscopically (Bankart procedure with fragment suture). The purpose of this work was to analyze clinical and radiological outcome observed in nine patients with anterior instability associated with significant glenoid fracture.

Material and methods: This was a monocentric study of a continuous series of nine glenoid fractures associated with anteromedial dislocation in nine patients (three women and six men), mean age 35.5 years (range 17–75 years). Preoperatively, all of the fractures were considered to involve more than 25% of the glenoid surface. After detaching the capsulolabral lesion with the bony fragment and avivement of the anterior border, the Bankart procedure was performed with anchors and resorbable sutures. The shoulder was strapped for six weeks with passive rehabilitation (pendulum movements) initiated early.

Results: Mean follow-up was 27 months (range 12–48 months). There were no cases of recurrent instability. Seven patients were very satisfied and two were satisfied. Eight patients were able to resume their sports activities at the same level. Apprehension developed in all patients. At last follow-up, joint motion was normal for eight of the nine patients, the Duplay score was 100 for eight patients and 45 for one. All bony lesions healed in an anatomic position (six analyzed with plain x-rays and three with CT scan).

Discussion and conclusion: This short series demonstrates that glenoid fractures can be treated arthroscopically with concomitant treatment of the capsulolabroligament complex in order to reconstruct the glenoid arch, an essential element for restoring shoulder stability. It is thus necessary to identify bony lesions preoperatively to determine the most appropriate therapeutic approach. A long-term follow-up will be useful to assess the rate of recurrent instability and validate this therapeutic option.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 88-B, Issue SUPP_I | Pages 82 - 82
1 Mar 2006
Rochwerger A Parratte S Sbihi A Roge F Curvale G
Full Access

Introduction. Knee arthrodesis is a limb salvage procedure considered as an alternative to an amputation in case of severely infected total knee arthroplasties, associated with large damage of the extensor mechanism. The techniques are various and the series in the literature not always homogenous. In this study we assessed the results of knee arthrodesis performed with two monolateral external fixators in two perpendicular planes .

Material and methods . This retrospective series of 19 knee arthrodeses was done in 18 patients, which were 65 years old on average. All patients had severe damage on their extensor mechanism associated with an infection of their implant. In all cases the infection was documented and patients were treated by antibiotics during on average 9 months. The first surgical step consisted in a debridement of the knee which was provisionally fixated with the lateral external fixator. The second step consisted in the removal of the infected implant or of the spacer . The bony surfaces were freshened and the anterior external fixator was applied with a compressive effect on the fusion site . Full weight bearing was allowed 45 days after surgery.

Results. Radiological fusion was observed in 17 cases after 4,6 months on average and the external fixators were removed after 8 months on average. Two patients experienced wound healings problems that required additional plastic surgery. Two cases were revised and bone grafting was performed. One patient suffered from malunion at the last follow up ( 7 years in this study).

Discussion. This type of fixation avoids internal fixation in septic conditions. The transquadricipital pins of the anterior fixator are well tolerated. The rigidity of the combination of two monolateral fixators in two perpendicular planes allows quick reloading , which is essential in old patients, often debilitated by numerous procedures.

Conclusion. Arthrodesis is functionally an acceptable alternative to an amputation in these patients. This technique is reliable, has the advantage of avoiding an internal device in an infected knee, of stabilizing the fusion site thanks to the biplanar fixation and of allowing quick weight bearing,.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 87-B, Issue SUPP_II | Pages 130 - 130
1 Apr 2005
Gravier R Flecher X Parratte S Rapaie P Argenson J
Full Access

Purpose: Wrist fractures are often seen in elderly subjects who cannot generally tolerate aggressive fixation of unstable fractures. Percutaneous intra-focal pinning (Kapandji) is usually employed. The purpose of this study was to compare the classical treatment of unstable extra-articular fractures of the lower quarter of the radius with posterior displacement with a modified pinning technique.

Material and methods: This prospective radiological study concerned two groups of randomised patients aged 30 – 70 years who were hospitalised for surgical treatment of Pouteau-Colles fractures. In the first group, all patients were treated by the classical intra-focal technique using one or two dorsal pins and one lateral pin (group K). In the second group, all patients were treated by fixation with one or two infrafocal dorsal pins and a third pin inserted transfocally (group KM). Preoperative care, anaesthesia, and postoperative care (21 days immobilisation, pin removal at 45 days) were the same in both groups. The following anatomic measurements were made on the radiographs at day 1, 21, 45, and last follow-up: radial inclination on the lateral and AP views, bistyloid line.

Results: Group K included 49 patients, mean age 45 years. Group KM included 46 patients, mean age 54 years. There was no statistical difference between groups for age, gender, side, type of fracture. Radial inclination on the AP view was 19.2 (10–27 in group KM and 23.2 (19-30) in group. On the lateral view, radial inclination was 0 (−11 to 20) in group KM and −5.7 (−25 to 2) in group K. The proportion of bistyloid lines considered satisfactory was not different between groups.

Discussion: Infra-focal pinning can have limitations for maintaining reduction to bone healing. The Kapandji technique modified by use of a third transstyloid pin appears to provide better stabilisation of unstable fractures of the lower extremity of the radius, particularly in older subjects who cannot tolerate aggressive surgery. This preliminary study should be completed by a radio-clinical analysis in a larger number of patients to confirm these results.