Abstract
Introduction: Women have gender specific shape of the distal femur. To fit these gender characteristics, gender specific femoral implants were developed for total knee arthroplasty (TKA). We aimed to compare
-
objective and subjective functional improvement;
-
patient satisfaction and preference and
-
cost-utility ratio after gender specific TKA or standard component implanted on the same women.
Materials and Methods: 30 women (60 knees) operated on successively (6 months in between) for a bilateral TKA between March 2006 and March 2008 by the same surgeon were included in this prospective study. The same surgical protocol and the same post-operative management protocol were applied for both sides. Mean age was 67±3 and mean BMI 26±4 Kg/m2. At a minimum follow-up of one year, evaluation objective and subjective functional improvement, patient satisfaction and preference and cost-utility analysis were performed double blind.
Results: Knee Society knee score and Knee Osteoarthritis Outcome Score (KOOS) improvements were comparable in both groups. However, 75% of the women preferred their gender TKA (p< 0.001). 68% of the women described less crepitus or anterior knee bothering after gender TKA (p=0.003) and 64% had faster recovery with the gender implant (p< 0.001). The cost-utility analysis was favorable for the gender knee.
Discussion: No objective or subjective superiority in terms of functional improvement was shown with gender specific implants at this short-term follow-up. However significant differences in terms of patient satisfaction and preference and a favorable cost-utility analysis were observed. These results should now be confirmed at longer-follow-up. Despite comparative functional improvement, patient satisfaction and preference were higher for the side implanted with a gender specific TKA in this prospective comparative study.
Correspondence should be addressed to: EFORT Central Office, Technoparkstrasse 1, CH – 8005 Zürich, Switzerland. Tel: +41 44 448 44 00; Email: office@efort.org
Author: Sebastien Parratte, France
E-mail: jean-noel.argenson@mail.ap-hm.fr