Many case reports and small studies have suggested that cobalt
ions are a potential cause of cardiac complications, specifically
cardiomyopathy, after metal-on-metal (MoM) total hip arthroplasty
(THA). The impact of metal ions on the incidence of cardiac disease
after MoM THA has not been evaluated in large studies. The aim of
this study was to compare the rate of onset of new cardiac symptoms
in patients who have undergone MoM THA with those who have undergone
metal-on-polyethylene (MoP) THA. Data were extracted from the Standard Analytics Files database
for patients who underwent MoM THA between 2005 and 2012. Bearing
surface was selected using International Classification of Diseases
ninth revision codes. Patients with a minimum five-year follow-up
were selected. An age and gender-matched cohort of patients who underwent
MoP THA served as a comparison group. New diagnoses of cardiac disease
were collected during the follow-up period. Comorbidities and demographics
were identified and routine descriptive statistics were used.Aims
Patients and Methods
We have encountered patients who developed large joint fluid collections with massive elevations in chromium (Cr) and cobalt (Co) concentrations following metal-on-metal (MoM) hip arthroplasties. In some cases, retrieval analysis determined that these ion concentrations could not be explained simply by the wear rates of the components. We hypothesized that these effects may be associated with aseptic lymphocyte-dominated vasculitis-associated lesion (ALVAL). We examined the influence of the ALVAL grade on synovial fluid Co and Cr concentrations following adjustment for patient and device variables, including volumetric wear rates. Initially restricting the analysis to include only patients with one MoM hip resurfacing device, we performed multiple regression analyses of prospectively collected data. We then repeated the same statistical approach using results from a larger cohort with different MoM designs, including total hip arthroplasties.Objectives
Patients and Methods
The aims of this study were to examine the rate at which the
positioning of the acetabular component, leg length discrepancy
and femoral offset are outside an acceptable range in total hip
arthroplasties (THAs) which either do or do not involve the use
of intra-operative digital imaging. A retrospective case-control study was undertaken with 50 patients
before and 50 patients after the integration of an intra-operative
digital imaging system in THA. The demographics of the two groups
were comparable for body mass index, age, laterality and the indication
for surgery. The digital imaging group had more men than the group without.
Surgical data and radiographic parameters, including the inclination
and anteversion of the acetabular component, leg length discrepancy,
and the difference in femoral offset compared with the contralateral
hip were collected and compared, as well as the incidence of altering
the position of a component based on the intra-operative image.Aims
Patients and Methods
The aims of this piece of work were to: 1) record the background
concentrations of blood chromium (Cr) and cobalt (Co) concentrations
in a large group of subjects; 2) to compare blood/serum Cr and Co
concentrations with retrieved metal-on-metal (MoM) hip resurfacings;
3) to examine the distribution of Co and Cr in the serum and whole
blood of patients with MoM hip arthroplasties; and 4) to further
understand the partitioning of metal ions between the serum and
whole blood fractions. A total of 3042 blood samples donated to the local transfusion
centre were analysed to record Co and Cr concentrations. Also, 91
hip resurfacing devices from patients who had given pre-revision
blood/serum samples for metal ion analysis underwent volumetric
wear assessment using a coordinate measuring machine. Linear regression analysis
was carried out and receiver operating characteristic curves were
constructed to assess the reliability of metal ions to identify
abnormally wearing implants. The relationship between serum and
whole blood concentrations of Cr and Co in 1048 patients was analysed
using Bland-Altman charts. This relationship was further investigated
in an Objectives
Methods
Lately, concerns have arisen following the use of large metal-on-metal bearings in hip replacements owing to reports of catastrophic soft-tissue reactions resulting in implant failure and associated complications. This review examines the literature and contemporary presentations on current clinical dilemmas in metal-on-metal hip replacement.
Hip replacement is a very successful operation and the outcome is usually excellent. There are recognised complications that seem increasingly to give rise to litigation. This paper briefly examines some common scenarios where litigation may be pursued against hip surgeons. With appropriate record keeping, consenting and surgical care, the claim can be successfully defended if not avoided. We hope this short summary will help to highlight some common pitfalls. There is extensive literature available for detailed study.
We sought to determine whether cobalt-chromium alloy (CoCr) femoral
stem tapers (trunnions) wear more than titanium (Ti) alloy stem
tapers (trunnions) when used in a large diameter (LD) metal-on-metal
(MoM) hip arthroplasty system. We performed explant analysis using validated methodology to
determine the volumetric material loss at the taper surfaces of
explanted LD CoCr MoM hip arthroplasties used with either a Ti alloy
(n = 28) or CoCr femoral stem (n = 21). Only 12/14 taper constructs
with a rough male taper surface and a nominal included angle close
to 5.666° were included. Multiple regression modelling was undertaken
using taper angle, taper roughness, bearing diameter (horizontal
lever arm) as independent variables. Material loss was mapped using
a coordinate measuring machine, profilometry and scanning electron
microscopy.Aims
Patients and Methods
The use of ceramic femoral heads in total hip arthroplasty (THA) has increased due to their proven low bearing wear characteristics. Ceramic femoral heads are also thought to reduce wear and corrosion at the head-stem junction with titanium (Ti) stems when compared with metal heads. We sought to evaluate taper damage of ceramic compared with metal heads when paired with cobalt chromium (CoCr) alloy stems in a single stem design. This retrieval study involved 48 total hip arthroplasties (THAs) with CoCr V40 trunnions paired with either CoCr (n = 21) or ceramic (n = 27) heads. The taper junction of all hips was evaluated for fretting/corrosion damage and volumetric material loss using a roundness-measuring machine. We used linear regression analysis to investigate taper damage differences after adjusting for potential confounding variables.Objectives
Methods
This study aimed to characterise and qualitatively grade the severity of the corrosion particles released into the hip joint following taper corrosion. The 26 cases examined were CoC/ABG Modular (n = 13) and ASR/SROM (n = 13). Blood serum metal ion levels were collected before and after revision surgery. The haematoxylin and eosin tissue sections were graded on the presence of fibrin exudates, necrosis, inflammatory cells and corrosion products. The corrosion products were identified based on visible observation and graded on abundance. Two independent observers blinded to the clinical patient findings scored all cases. Elemental analysis was performed on corrosion products within tissue sections. X-Ray diffraction was used to identify crystalline structures present in taper debris.Objectives
Methods
We retrospectively analysed concentrations of chromium and cobalt ions in samples of synovial fluid and whole blood taken from a group of 92 patients with failed current-generation metal-on-metal hip replacements. We applied acid oxidative digestion to our trace metal analysis protocol, which found significantly higher levels of metal ion concentrations in blood and synovial fluid than a non-digestive method. Patients were subcategorised by mode of failure as either ‘unexplained pain’ or ‘defined causes’. Using this classification, chromium and cobalt ion levels were present over a wider range in synovial fluid and not as strongly correlated with blood ion levels as previously reported. There was no significant difference between metal ion concentrations and manufacturer of the implant, nor femoral head size below or above 50 mm. There was a moderately positive correlation between metal ion levels and acetabular component inclination angle as measured on three-dimensional CT imaging. Our results suggest that acid digestion of samples of synovial fluid samples is necessary to determine metal ion concentrations accurately so that meaningful comparisons can be made between studies.
We wished to investigate the influence of metal debris exposure
on the subsequent immune response and resulting soft-tissue injury
following metal-on-metal (MoM) hip arthroplasty. Some reports have
suggested that debris generated from the head-neck taper junction
is more destructive than equivalent doses from metal bearing surfaces. We investigated the influence of the source and volume of metal
debris on chromium (Cr) and cobalt (Co) concentrations in corresponding
blood and hip synovial fluid samples and the observed agglomerated
particle sizes in excised tissues using multiple regression analysis
of prospectively collected data. A total of 199 explanted MoM hips
(177 patients; 132 hips female) were analysed to determine rates
of volumetric wear at the bearing surfaces and taper junctions. Aims
Patients and Methods
We compared the incidence of pseudotumours after
large head metal-on-metal (MoM) total hip arthroplasty (THA) with
that after conventional metal-on-polyethylene (MoP) THA and assessed
the predisposing factors to pseudotumour formation. From a previous randomised controlled trial which compared large
head (38 mm to 60 mm) cementless MoM THA with conventional head
(28 mm) cementless MoP THA, 93 patients (96 THAs: 41 MoM (21 males,
20 females, mean age of 64 years, standard deviation ( The incidence of pseudotumours, measured using a standardised
CT protocol was 22 (53.7%) after MoM THA and 12 (21.8%) after MoP
THA. Women with a MoM THA were more likely to develop a pseudotumour
than those with a MoP THA (15 Contrary to popular belief, pseudotumours occur frequently around
MoP THAs. Women with a MoM THA and an elevated cobalt level are
at greatest risk. In this study, pseudotumours had no effect on
the functional outcome after either large head MoM or conventional
MoP THA. Cite this article:
Metal-on-metal (MoM) hip resurfacing was developed in the 1990s by surgeons in Birmingham, UK, as a surgical solution to the problem of osteoarthritis in younger, more active patients. Early results were promising and the procedure gained in popularity. However, adverse reports of soft-tissue reaction and failure started to appear from 2008 onwards. Surgeons may be asked to write medico-legal reports on the surgical aspects of an individual case for claimant lawyers or in defence for the NHSLA or indemnity insurers. The purpose of this article is to cover some of the aspects of the operation that may be considered in such medico-legal reports.
Patients from a randomised trial on resurfacing
hip arthroplasty (RHA) (n = 36, 19 males; median age 57 years, 24
to 65) comparing a conventional 28 mm metal-on-metal total hip arthroplasty
(MoM THA) (n = 28, 17 males; median age 59 years, 37 to 65) and
a matched control group of asymptomatic patients with a 32 mm ceramic-on-polyethylene
(CoP) THA (n = 33, 18 males; median age 63 years, 38 to 71) were
cross-sectionally screened with metal artefact reducing sequence-MRI
(MARS-MRI) for pseudotumour formation at a median of 55 months (23
to 72) post-operatively. MRIs were scored by consensus according
to three different classification systems for pseudotumour formation. Clinical scores were available for all patients and metal ion
levels for MoM bearing patients. Periprosthetic lesions with a median volume of 16 mL (1.5 to
35.9) were diagnosed in six patients in the RHA group (17%), one
in the MoM THA group (4%) and six in the CoP group (18%). The classification
systems revealed no clear differences between the groups. Solid
lesions (n = 3) were exclusively encountered in the RHA group. Two patients
in the RHA group and one in the MoM THA group underwent a revision
for pseudotumour formation. There was no statistically significant
relationship between clinical scoring, metal ion levels and periprosthetic
lesions in any of the groups. Periprosthetic fluid collections are seen on MARS-MRI after conventional
CoP THA and RHA and may reflect a soft-tissue collection or effusion. Currently available MRI classification systems seem to score
these collections as pseudotumours, causing an-overestimatation
of the incidence of pseudotumours. Cite this article:
Metal artefact reduction (MAR) MRI is now widely
considered to be the standard for imaging metal-on-metal (MoM) hip
implants. The Medicines and Healthcare Products Regulatory Agency
(MHRA) has recommended cross-sectional imaging for all patients
with symptomatic MoM bearings. This paper describes the natural
history of MoM disease in a 28 mm MoM total hip replacement (THR)
using MAR MRI. Inclusion criteria were patients with MoM THRs who had
not been revised and had at least two serial MAR MRI scans. All
examinations were reported by an experienced observer and classified
as A (normal), B (infection) or C1–C3 (mild, moderate, severe MoM-related
abnormalities). Between 2002 and 2011 a total of 239 MRIs were performed
on 80 patients (two to four scans per THR); 63 initial MRIs (61%)
were normal. On subsequent MRIs, six initially normal scans (9.5%)
showed progression to a disease state; 15 (15%) of 103 THRs with
sequential scans demonstrated worsening disease on subsequent imaging. Most patients with a MoM THR who do not undergo early revision
have normal MRI scans. Late progression (from normal to abnormal,
or from mild to more severe MoM disease) is not common and takes
place over several years. Cite this article:
We report a 12- to 15-year implant survival assessment
of a prospective single-surgeon series of Birmingham Hip Resurfacings
(BHRs). The earliest 1000 consecutive BHRs including 288 women (335
hips) and 598 men (665 hips) of all ages and diagnoses with no exclusions
were prospectively followed-up with postal questionnaires, of whom
the first 402 BHRs (350 patients) also had clinical and radiological
review. Mean follow-up was 13.7 years (12.3 to 15.3). In total, 59 patients
(68 hips) died 0.7 to 12.6 years following surgery from unrelated
causes. There were 38 revisions, 0.1 to 13.9 years (median 8.7)
following operation, including 17 femoral failures (1.7%) and seven
each of infections, soft-tissue reactions and other causes. With
revision for any reason as the end-point Kaplan–Meier survival analysis
showed 97.4% (95% confidence interval (CI) 96.9 to 97.9) and 95.8%
(95% CI 95.1 to 96.5) survival at ten and 15 years, respectively.
Radiological assessment showed 11 (3.5%) femoral and 13 (4.1%) acetabular
radiolucencies which were not deemed failures and one radiological
femoral failure (0.3%). Our study shows that the performance of the BHR continues to
be good at 12- to 15-year follow-up. Men have better implant survival
(98.0%; 95% CI 97.4 to 98.6) at 15 years than women (91.5%; 95%
CI 89.8 to 93.2), and women <
60 years (90.5%; 95% CI 88.3 to
92.7) fare worse than others. Hip dysplasia and osteonecrosis are
risk factors for failure. Patients under 50 years with osteoarthritis
fare best (99.4%; 95% CI 98.8 to 100 survival at 15 years), with
no failures in men in this group. Cite this article:
