The August 2012 Research Roundup360 looks at: PRP and chondrogenic differentiation; basic fibroblast growth factor; whether glucosamine works; randomised trials; ossification of the ligamentum flavum; treadmill running; inhibiting BMP antagonists; and whether NSAIDs delay union after all.
The Oxford mobile-bearing unicompartmental knee
replacement (UKR) is an effective and safe treatment for osteoarthritis
of the medial compartment. The results in the lateral compartment
have been disappointing due to a high early rate of dislocation
of the bearing. A series using a newly designed domed tibial component
is reported. The first 50 consecutive domed lateral Oxford UKRs in 50 patients
with a mean follow-up of three years (2.0 to 4.3) were included.
Clinical scores were obtained prospectively and Kaplan-Meier survival
analysis was performed for different endpoints. Radiological variables
related to the position and alignment of the components were measured. One patient died and none was lost to follow-up. The cumulative
incidence of dislocation was 6.2% (95% confidence interval (CI)
2.0 to 17.9) at three years. Survival using revision for any reason
and aseptic revision was 94% (95% CI 82 to 98) and 96% (95% CI 85
to 99) at three years, respectively. Outcome scores, visual analogue
scale for pain and maximum knee flexion showed a significant improvement
(p <
0.001). The mean Oxford knee score was 43 ( Clinical results are excellent and short-term survival has improved
when compared with earlier series. The risk of dislocation remains
higher using a mobile-bearing UKR in the lateral compartment when
compared with the medial compartment. Patients should be informed
about this complication. To avoid dislocations, care must be taken
not to elevate the lateral joint line.
We report the use of a 15° face-changing cementless
acetabular component in patients undergoing total hip replacement
for osteoarthritis secondary to developmental dysplasia of the hip.
The rationale behind its design and the surgical technique used
for its implantation are described. It is distinctly different from
a standard cementless hemispherical component as it is designed
to position the bearing surface at the optimal angle of inclination,
that is, <
45°, while maximising the cover of the component by
host bone.
Although the Western Ontario and McMaster Universities
(WOMAC) osteoarthritis index was originally developed for the assessment
of non-operative treatment, it is commonly used to evaluate patients
undergoing either total hip (THR) or total knee replacement (TKR).
We assessed the importance of the 17 WOMAC function items from the perspective
of 1198 patients who underwent either THR (n = 704) or TKR (n =
494) in order to develop joint-specific short forms. After these
patients were administered the WOMAC pre-operatively and at three,
six, 12 and 24 months’ follow-up, they were asked to nominate an
item of the function scale that was most important to them. The
items chosen were significantly different between patients undergoing
THR and those undergoing TKR (p <
0.001), and there was a shift
in the priorities after surgery in both groups. Setting a threshold
for prioritised items of ≥ 5% across all follow-up, eight items
were selected for THR and seven for TKR, of which six items were
common to both. The items comprising specific WOMAC-THR and TKR
function short forms were found to be equally responsive compared
with the original WOMAC function form. Cite this article:
The June 2012 Hip &
Pelvis Roundup360 looks at: whether metal-on-metal is really such a disaster; resurfacings with unexplained pain; large heads and high ion levels; hip arthroscopy for FAI; the inaccuracy of clinical tests for impingement; arthroscopic lengthening of iliopsoas; the OA hip; the injured hamstring – football’s most common injury; an algorithm for hip fracture surgery; and sparing piriformis at THR.
The April 2012 Wrist &
Hand Roundup360 looks at releasing the trigger finger, function in the osteoarthritic hand, complex regional pain syndrome, arthroscopic ligamentoplasty for the injured scapholunate ligament, self-concept and upper limb deformities in children, wrist arthroscopy in children, internal or external fixation for the fractured distal radius, nerve grafting, splinting the PIPJ contracture, and finding the stalk of a dorsal wrist ganglion
The Cementless Oxford Unicompartmental Knee Replacement
(OUKR) was developed to address problems related to cementation,
and has been demonstrated in a randomised study to have similar
clinical outcomes with fewer radiolucencies than observed with the
cemented device. However, before its widespread use it is necessary
to clarify contraindications and assess the complications. This
requires a larger study than any previously published. We present a prospective multicentre series of 1000 cementless
OUKRs in 881 patients at a minimum follow-up of one year. All patients
had radiological assessment aligned to the bone–implant interfaces
and clinical scores. Analysis was performed at a mean of 38.2 months
(19 to 88) following surgery. A total of 17 patients died (comprising
19 knees (1.9%)), none as a result of surgery; there were no tibial
or femoral loosenings. A total of 19 knees (1.9%) had significant
implant-related complications or required revision. Implant survival
at six years was 97.2%, and there was a partial radiolucency at
the bone–implant interface in 72 knees (8.9%), with no complete radiolucencies.
There was no significant increase in complication rate compared
with cemented fixation (p = 0.87), and no specific contraindications
to cementless fixation were identified. Cementless OUKR appears to be safe and reproducible in patients
with end-stage anteromedial osteoarthritis of the knee, with radiological
evidence of improved fixation compared with previous reports using
cemented fixation. Cite this article:
We reviewed the long-term radiological outcome,
complications and revision operations in 19 children with quadriplegic
cerebral palsy and hip dysplasia who underwent combined peri-iliac
osteotomy and femoral varus derotation osteotomy. They had a mean
age of 7.5 years (1.6 to 10.9) and comprised 22 hip dislocations
and subluxations. We also studied the outcome for the contralateral
hip. At a mean follow-up of 11.7 years (10 to 15.1) the Melbourne
cerebral palsy (CP) hip classification was grade 2 in 16 hips, grade
3 in five, and grade 5 in one. There were five complications seen
in four hips (21%, four patients), including one dislocation, one
subluxation, one coxa vara with adduction deformity, one subtrochanteric
fracture and one infection. A recurrent soft-tissue contracture occurred
in five hips and ten required revision surgery. In pre-adolescent children with quadriplegic cerebral palsy good
long-term outcomes can be achieved after reconstruction of the hip;
regular follow-up is required.
Cite this article:
The August 2012 Knee Roundup360 looks at: meniscal defects and a polyurethane scaffold; which is best between a single or double bundle; OA of the knee; how to resolve anterior knee pain; whether yoga can be bad for your menisci; metal ions in the serum; whether ACI is any good; the ACL; whether hyaluronic acid delays collagen degradation; and hyaluronan and patellar tendinopathy.
The aim of this study was to determine the accuracy
of registration and the precision of the resection volume in navigated
hip arthroscopy for cam-type femoroacetabular impingement, using
imageless and image-based registration. A virtual cam lesion was
defined in 12 paired cadaver hips and randomly assigned to either
imageless or image-based (three-dimensional (3D) fluoroscopy) navigated
arthroscopic head–neck osteochondroplasty. The accuracy of patient–image
registration for both protocols was evaluated and post-operative
imaging was performed to evaluate the accuracy of the surgical resection.
We found that the estimated accuracy of imageless registration in the
arthroscopic setting was poor, with a mean error of 5.6 mm (standard
deviation ( In conclusion, given the limited femoral surface that can be
reached and digitised during arthroscopy of the hip, imageless registration
is inaccurate and does not allow for reliable surgical navigation.
However, image-based registration does acceptably allow for guided
femoral osteochondroplasty in the arthroscopic management of femoroacetabular
impingement.
The number of surgical procedures performed each year to treat
femoroacetabular impingement (FAI) continues to rise. Although there
is evidence that surgery can improve symptoms in the short-term,
there is no evidence that it slows the development of osteoarthritis
(OA). We performed a feasibility study to determine whether patient
and surgeon opinion was permissive for a Randomised Controlled Trial
(RCT) comparing operative with non-operative treatment for FAI. Surgeon opinion was obtained using validated questionnaires at
a Specialist Hip Meeting (n = 61, 30 of whom stated that they routinely
performed FAI surgery) and patient opinion was obtained from clinical
patients with a new diagnosis of FAI (n = 31).Objectives
Methods
We investigated the extent to which improved
balance relative to pain relief correlates with the success of total knee
replacement (TKR). A total of 81 patients were recruited to the
study: 16 men (19.8%) and 65 women (80.2%). Of these, 62 patients
(10 men, 52 women) with a mean age of 73 (57 to 83) underwent static
and dynamic assessment of balance pre-operatively and one year post-operatively.
The parameters of balance were quantified using commercially available
and validated equipment. Motor function and self-reported outcome
were also assessed. There was a significant improvement in dynamic balance (p <
0.001) one year after TKR, and better balance correlated with improved
mobility, functional balance and increased health-related quality
of life. As it seems that balance, and not only pain relief, influences
the success of TKR, balance skills should be better addressed during
the post-operative rehabilitation of patients who undergo TKR.
Bone defects are occasionally encountered during
primary total knee replacement (TKR) and cause difficulty in establishing
a stable well-aligned bone-implant interface. Between March 1999
and November 2005, 59 knees in 43 patients underwent primary TKR
with a metal block augmentation for tibial bone deficiency. In all,
six patients (eight knees) died less than four years post-operatively,
and four patients (five knees) were lost to follow-up leaving 46 knees
in 33 patients available for review at a mean of 78.6 months (62
to 129). The clinical results obtained, including range of movement,
American Knee Society and Oxford knee scores, and the Western Ontario
and McMaster Universities osteoarthritis index, were good to excellent,
with no failures. Radiolucent lines at the block-cement-bone interface
were noted in five knees (11%) during the first post-operative year,
but these did not progress. Modular rectangular metal augmentation for tibial bone deficiency
is a useful option. No deterioration of the block-prosthesis or
block-cement-bone interface was seen at minimum of five years follow-up.
Advanced MRI cartilage imaging such as T1-rho
(T1ρ) for the diagnosis of early cartilage degradation prior to morpholgic
radiological changes may provide prognostic information in the management
of joint disease. This study aimed first to determine the normal
T1ρ profile of cartilage within the hip, and secondly to identify
any differences in T1ρ profile between the normal and symptomatic
femoroacetabular impingement (FAI) hip. Ten patients with cam-type
FAI (seven male and three female, mean age 35.9 years (28 to 48))
and ten control patients (four male and six female, mean age 30.6
years (22 to 35)) underwent 1.5T T1ρ MRI of a single hip. Mean T1ρ relaxation
times for full thickness and each of the three equal cartilage thickness
layers were calculated and compared between the groups. The mean
T1ρ relaxation times for full cartilage thickness of control and
FAI hips were similar (37.17 ms ( These results suggest that 1.5T T1ρ MRI can detect acetabular
hyaline cartilage changes in patients with FAI.
We investigated 60 patients (89 feet) with a
mean age of 64 years (61 to 67) treated for congenital clubfoot deformity,
using standardised weight-bearing radiographs of both feet and ankles
together with a functional evaluation. Talocalcaneal and talonavicular
relationships were measured and the degree of osteo-arthritic change
in the ankle and talonavicular joints was assessed. The functional
results were evaluated using a modified Laaveg-Ponseti score. The
talocalcaneal (TC) angles in the clubfeet were significantly lower
in both anteroposterior (AP) and lateral projections than in the
unaffected feet (p <
0.001 for both views). There was significant
medial subluxation of the navicular in the clubfeet compared with
the unaffected feet (p <
0.001). Severe osteoarthritis in the
ankle joint was seen in seven feet (8%) and in the talonavicular
joint in 11 feet (12%). The functional result was excellent or good
(≥ 80 points) in 29 patients (48%), and fair or poor (<
80 points)
in 31 patients (52%). Patients who had undergone few (0 to 1) surgical
procedures had better functional outcomes than those who had undergone
two or more procedures (p <
0.001). There was a significant correlation
between the functional result and the degree of medial subluxation
of the navicular (p <
0.001, r2 = 0.164), the talocalcaneal
angle on AP projection (p <
0.02, r2 = 0.025) and extent of osteoarthritis
in the ankle joint (p <
0.001). We conclude that poor functional outcome in patients with congenital
clubfoot occurs more frequently in those with medial displacement
of the navicular, osteoarthritis of the talonavicular and ankle
joints, and a low talocalcaneal angle on the AP projection, and
in patients who have undergone two or more surgical procedures. However,
the ankle joint in these patients appeared relatively resistant
to the development of osteoarthritis.
In Norway total joint replacement after hip dysplasia
is reported more commonly than in neighbouring countries, implying
a higher prevalence of the condition. We report on the prevalence
of radiological features associated with hip dysplasia in a population
of
2081 19-year-old Norwegians. The radiological measurements used
to define hip dysplasia were Wiberg’s centre-edge (CE) angle at
thresholds of <
20° and <
25°, femoral head extrusion index
<
75%, Sharp’s angle >
45°, an acetabular depth to width ratio
<
250 and the sourcil shape assessed subjectively. The whole
cohort underwent clinical examination of their range of hip movement,
body mass index (BMI), and Beighton hypermobility score, and were
asked to complete the EuroQol (EQ-5D) and Western Ontario and McMaster
Universities Osteoarthritis Index (WOMAC). The prevalence of hip
dysplasia in the cohort varied from 1.7% to 20% depending on the
radiological marker used. A Wiberg’s CE angle <
20° was seen
in 3.3% of the cohort: 4.3% in women and 2.4% in men. We found no
association between subjects with multiple radiological signs indicative
of dysplasia and BMI, Beighton score, EQ-5D or WOMAC. Although there
appears to be a high prevalence of hip dysplasia among 19-year-old
Norwegians, this is dependent on the radiological parameters applied. Cite this article:
Patients with skeletal dysplasia are prone to
developing advanced osteoarthritis of the knee requiring total knee replacement
(TKR) at a younger age than the general population. TKR in this
unique group of patients is a technically demanding procedure owing
to the deformity, flexion contracture, generalised hypotonia and ligamentous
laxity. We retrospectively reviewed the outcome of 11 TKRs performed
in eight patients with skeletal dysplasia at our institution using
the Stanmore Modular Individualised Lower Extremity System (SMILES)
custom-made rotating-hinge TKR. There were three men and five women
with mean age of 57 years (41 to 79). Patients were followed clinically
and radiologically for a mean of seven years (3 to 11.5). The mean
Knee Society clinical and function scores improved from 24 (14 to
36) and 20 (5 to 40) pre-operatively, respectively, to 68 (28 to
80) and 50 (22 to 74), respectively, at final follow-up. Four complications
were recorded, including a patellar fracture following a fall, a
tibial peri-prosthetic fracture, persistent anterior knee pain,
and aseptic loosening of a femoral component requiring revision.
Our results demonstrate that custom primary rotating-hinge TKR in
patients with skeletal dysplasia is effective at relieving pain,
with a satisfactory range of movement and improved function. It compensates
for bony deformity and ligament deficiency and reduces the likelihood
of corrective osteotomy. Patellofemoral joint complications are
frequent and functional outcome is worse than with primary TKR in
the general population.
Despite excellent results, the use of cemented
total hip replacement (THR) is declining. This retrospective cohort study
records survival time to revision following primary cemented THR
using the most common combination of components that accounted for
almost a quarter of all cemented THRs, exploring risk factors independently associated
with failure. All patients with osteoarthritis who had an Exeter
V40/Contemporary THR (Stryker) implanted before 31 December 2010
and recorded in the National Joint Registry for England and Wales
were included in the analysis. Cox’s proportional hazard models
were used to analyse the extent to which risk of revision was related
to patient, surgeon and implant covariates, with a significance
threshold of p <
0.01. A total of 34 721 THRs were included in
the study. The overall seven-year rate of revision for any reason
was 1.70% (99% confidence interval (CI) 1.28 to 2.12). In the final
adjusted model the risk of revision was significantly higher in
THRs with the Contemporary hooded component (hazard ratio (HR) 1.88,
p <
0.001) than with the flanged version, and in smaller head
sizes (<
28 mm) compared with 28 mm diameter heads (HR 1.50,
p = 0.005). The seven-year revision rate was 1.16% (99% CI 0.69
to 1.63) with a 28 mm diameter head and flanged component. The overall
risk of revision was independent of age, gender, American Society
of Anesthesiologists grade, body mass index, surgeon volume, surgical
approach, brand of cement/presence of antibiotic, femoral head material
(stainless steel/alumina) and stem taper size/offset. However, the
risk of revision for dislocation was significantly higher with a
‘plus’ offset head (HR 2.05, p = 0.003) and a hooded acetabular component
(HR 2.34, p <
0.001). In summary, we found that there were significant differences
in failure between different designs of acetabular component and
sizes of femoral head after adjustment for a range of covariates.
The purpose of this study was to assess N-acetyl aspartate changes
in the thalamus in patients with osteoarthritis of the hip using
proton magnetic resonance spectroscopy. Nine patients with osteoarthritis of the hip (symptomatic group,
nine women; mean age 61.4 years (48 to 78)) and nine healthy volunteers
(control group, six men, three women; mean age 30.0 years (26 to
38)) underwent proton magnetic resonance spectroscopy to assess
the changes of N-acetyl aspartate in the thalamus. Objectives
Methods
Osteoarthritis is extremely common and many different causes for it have been described. One such cause is abnormal morphology of the affected joint, the hip being a good example of this. For those joints with femoroacetabular impingement (FAI) or developmental dysplasia of the hip (DDH), a link with subsequent osteoarthritis seems clear. However, far from being abnormal, these variants may be explained by evolution, certainly so for FAI, and may actually be normal rather than representing deformity or disease. The animal equivalent of FAI is coxa recta, commonly found in species that run and jump. It is rarely found in animals that climb and swim. In contrast are the animals with coxa rotunda, a perfectly spherical femoral head, and more in keeping with the coxa profunda of mankind. This article describes the evolutionary process of the human hip and its link to FAI and DDH. Do we need to worry after all?