This paper investigates whether cortical comminution
and intra-articular involvement can predict displacement in distal
radius fractures by using a classification that includes volar comminution
as a separate parameter. A prospective multicentre study involving non-operative treatment
of distal radius fractures in 387 patients aged between 15 and 74
years (398 fractures) was conducted. The presence of cortical comminution
and intra-articular involvement according to the Buttazzoni classification
is described. Minimally displaced fractures were treated with immobilisation
in a cast while displaced fractures underwent closed reduction with
subsequent immobilisation. Radiographs were obtained after reduction,
at 10 to 14 days and after union. The outcome measure was re-displacement
or union. In fractures with volar comminution (Buttazzoni type 4), 96%
(53 of 55) displaced. In intra-articular fractures without volar
comminution (Buttazzoni 3), 72% (84 of 117) displaced. In extra-articular
fractures with isolated dorsal comminution (Buttazzoni 2), 73% (106
of 145) displaced while in non-comminuted fractures (Buttazzoni
1), 16 % (13 of 81 ) displaced. A total of 32% (53 of 165) of initially minimally displaced fractures
later displaced. All of the initially displaced volarly comminuted
fractures re-displaced. Displacement occurred in 31% (63 of 205)
of fractures that were still in good alignment after 10 to 14 days. Regression analysis showed that volar and dorsal comminution
predicted later displacement, while intra-articular involvement
did not predict displacement. Volar comminution was the strongest
predictor of displacement. Cite this article:
To investigate the differences of open reduction and internal
fixation (ORIF) of complex AO Type C distal radius fractures between
two different models of a single implant type. A total of 136 patients who received either a 2.4 mm (n = 61)
or 3.5 mm (n = 75) distal radius locking compression plate (LCP
DR) using a volar approach were followed over two years. The main
outcome measurements included motion, grip strength, pain, and the
scores of Gartland and Werley, the Short-Form 36 (SF-36) and the
Disabilities of the Arm, Shoulder, and Hand (DASH). Differences
between the treatment groups were evaluated using regression analysis
and the likelihood ratio test with significance based on the Bonferroni
corrected p-value of <
0.003.Objectives
Methods
We identified 11 women with a mean age of 74 years (65 to 81) who sustained comminuted distal radial and ulnar fractures and were treated by volar plating and slight shortening of the radius combined with a primary Sauvé-Kapandji procedure. At a mean of 46 months (16 to 58), union of distal radial fractures and arthrodesis of the distal radioulnar joint was seen in all patients. The mean shortening of the radius was 12 mm (5 to 18) compared to the contralateral side. Flexion and extension of the wrist was a mean of 54° and 50°, respectively, and the mean pronation and supination of the forearm was 82° and 86°, respectively. The final mean disabilities of the arm, shoulder and hand score was 26 points. According to the Green and O’Brien rating system, eight patients had an excellent, two a good and one a fair result. The good clinical and radiological results, and the minor complications without the need for further operations related to late ulnar-sided wrist pain, justify this procedure in the elderly patient.
Fractures of the distal radius occurring in young adults are treated increasingly by open surgical techniques, partly because of concern that failure to restore the alignment of the fracture accurately may cause symptomatic post-traumatic osteoarthritis in future years. We reviewed 106 adults who had sustained a fracture of the distal radius between 1960 and 1968 and who were below the age of 40 years at the time of injury. We carried out a clinical and radiological assessment at a mean follow-up of 38 years (33 to 42). No patient had required a salvage procedure. While there was radiological evidence of post-traumatic osteoarthritis after an intra-articular fracture in 68% of patients (27 of 40), the disabilities of the arm, shoulder and hand (DASH) scores were not different from population norms, and function, as assessed by the Patient Evaluation Measure, was impaired by less than 10%. Ordinal logistic regression analysis showed a significant relationship between narrowing of the joint space and extra-articular malunion (dorsal angulation and radial shortening) as well as intra-articular injury. Multivariate analysis revealed that grip strength had fallen to 89% of that of the uninjured side in the presence of dorsal malunion, but no measure of extra-articular malunion was significantly related to either the Patient Evaluation Measure or DASH scores. While anatomical reduction is the principal aim of treatment, imperfect reduction of these fractures may not result in symptomatic arthritis in the long term, and this should be considered when counselling patients on the risks and benefits of the many treatment options available.