Arthrodesis of the 1st metatarso-phalangeal joint (MTPJ) is a common procedure in forefoot surgery for hallux rigidus and severe hallux valgus. Debate persists on two issues - the best preparation method for the articular surfaces, and the optimal technique for operative stabilisation of the joint. We performed 1st MTPJ arthrodesis in 100 patients randomized into two equal groups. In the first group, the articular surfaces were prepared using cup-and-cone reamers, whilst in the second group, ‘flat cut’ osteotomies were performed with an oscillating saw. In all other respects, their treatment was identical. Fixation was secured using a plantar double compression Fixos™ screw and dorsal Anchorage™ plate. Full weight-bearing was allowed on the first post-operative day. Patients completed self-administered satisfaction questionnaires, including an AOFAS and SF-36 score pre-operatively and at two and six months post-operatively. Clinical examination and radiographs were compared at zero, two and six months. Statistical analysis was performed using Instat.Introduction
Methods
An enlarged debridment of the first MTP joint was mandatory before any reconstructive procedure. The collateral lateral ligament reconstruction has been achieved with a synthetic suture (LigaproÒ or LigasticÒ of 1.5 mm diameter) according to flexible joint with no arthritis (regimen 1 (25 cases), youngpopulation (44 years) with an average varus of −12°). The first MTP joint arthrodesis was performed for osteoarthritis combined with stiffness. (regimen 2 (40 cases), older (64 years) with an average varus of −16°.
In series 1 (ligament reconstruction),24/25 patients were totally painless with an artificial device well tolerated. The joint motion, the gait and the shoe-wearing were normal in 24/25 of cases. The medium post-operative valgus was of 12°. In series 2 (MTP arthrodesis), arthrodesis healed in 39 cases with an average time of 60 days. Valgus positionning was always restaured.Degenerative changings occured in the IP joint in 4 cases without any complain. Shoe- wearing was classical in all the cases.
Among the procedures for the first MTP joint preservation, enabled to restore valgus strength, the synthetic reconstruction of the collateral lateral ligament is a reliable and reproducible technique, without any damages for the active tendons nor for the joint function.