Statement of purpose

We review the current state of development of proton therapy and the implications for beam therapy in the management of primary bone tumours

Objective

To evaluate functional and oncological outcomes following sacral resection

Objective

To evaluate functional and oncological outcomes following resection of sacral tumours and discuss the strategies for instrumentation.

To review indications, complications and outcome for revision surgery in metastatic spinal disease.

Retrospective review of casenotes and radiographs.

13 patients (9 male, 4 female) identified from a cohort of 222 patients who underwent surgery for spinal tumours between 1994- 2001.

Indication for revision, complications, survival. Further recurrence (same or different level). Further surgery, neurological grade and pain score.

Of 13 patients (4 Renal, 6 breast, 2 prostate, 1 myeloma) one is alive 101 months following revision. Two have been lost to follow up, 10 have died (mean survival 25.3 months post op). The mean time between primary and revision surgery was 10 months (range 1- 32 months)

4 disease progression (same level), 4 new level disease, 3 loss of fixation, 1 radiological collapse, 1 progressive kyphus. Approaches used: 4 anterior, 8 posterior, 1 posterior + anterior. The mean number of levels which required instrumentation on revision was 5.

Modal pain score pre op 5, modal post op 3, minimum one point improvement. Preop modal Frankel grade E, postoperatively all preserved or improved one grade. Modal Karnofsky score preop 70 (30- 90), postop 80 (40-90)- all but one at least 10 point increase. Complications: 1Dural tear, 1 bacteraemia, 1 chylothorax, 1 loss of fixation. 3 patients required further surgery (range 4 months- 18 months, mean 11 months)

Patients with metastatic disease may benefit from second procedures for recurrent disease whether locally or distant with excellent survival, low complications and good function.

To describe the development of a system of referral, initial data acquisition and subsequent database recording and outcome reporting for metastatic spinal cord compression.

Deficiencies in the literature identified by the NICE GDG for MSCC for research were compared with our original database and modifications made to ensure prospective collection of currently recognised and some proposed relevant factors.

In addition modifications were made to ensure that all NICE implementation audit data and “target “ data are recorded and can be seamlessly transferred to necessary destinations

This generates standardised reports of the presentation, management and longitudinal interval outcomes including analogue pain scales, analgesic requirement, neurological function, Karnofsky performance indices, Euroquols, and ODIs. It includes pretreatment prognostic indices (updated 2005 Tokuhashi scores) relevant to treatment selection and scale of surgical intervention. Outcomes can be subclassified by type of intervention relative to clinical status at intervention

In house live assessment has revealed some reducing minor operational flaws and initial external assessment is current.

A comprehensive information system and treatment guide for this increasing group has been developed and is evolving. Common adoption would facilitate earlier recognition and optimise treatment to diminish the high human and financial cost of MSCC. Currently networks are setting up NSSGs and for this process to be enhanced and to avoid costly duplication adoption of this system modified following peer review is suggested.

To evaluate functional and oncological outcomes following resection of primary malignant bone tumours.

Primary malignant tumours of the sacrum are rare, arising from bony or neural elements, or bone marrow in haematological malignancies.

Management of these lesions is dictated by anatomical considerations and the behaviour of tumours. The three key issues which arise are the adequacy of tumour resection, mechanical stabilisation and the need for colostomy.

A retrospective review of the surgical management of primary malignant sacral tumours from 2004 - 2009.

The study included 46 patients (34 males, 12 females) with an average age of 49 (range 7 – 82). Median duration of symptoms before presentation was 26 months.

10 patients had inoperable tumours at presentation. 6 patients had chemotherapy. 2 patients opted for palliative radiotherapy. 1 patient was unfit for surgery.

25 patients (54%) underwent surgical resection. 8 underwent instrumented stabilisations with fibula strut graft vs. 17 uninstrumented.

Colostomy was performed in 10 patients (40%). Mean follow post-operatively was 19.0 months.

Wound healing problems were present in 5/25 (20%). There was no difference in infection rates between definitive surgery with and without colostomy. Mechanical failure of stabilisation was noted in 75%. There was one peri-operative death.

Local recurrence occurred in 12%(3/25) of operated patients although follow-up period was noted to be short.

Mechanical stabilisation for extensive lesions in the sacrum are particularly challenging in tumour surgery. Despite radiological failure in 7/8 instrumented stabilisations, patients were relatively asymptomatic and only 1/8 required revision stabilisation surgery.

Ethics approval: None: Audit Interest Statement: None

Purpose

We report our surgical management of a series of primary and metastatic tumours of the lumbosacral junction, highlighting different methods of fixation, outcome and complications.

Aim: To investigate the outcome of our management of patients with giant cell tumour of the sacrum and draw lessons from this.

Method: Retrospective review of medical records and scans for all patients treated at our unit over the past 20 years with a giant cell tumour (GCT) of the sacrum.

Results: Of 517 patients treated at our unit for GCT over the past 20 years, only 9 (1.7%) had a GCT in the sacrum. 6 were female, 3 male with a mean age of 34 (range 15–52). All but two tumours involved the entire sacrum and there was only one purely distal to S3. The mean size was 10cm and the most common symptom was back or buttock pain. Five had abnormal neurology at diagnosis but only one presented with cauda equina syndrome. The first four patients were treated by curettage alone but two patients had intra-operative cardiac arrests and although both survived all subsequent curettages were preceeded by embolization of the feeding vessels. Of 7 patients who had curettage, 3 developed local recurrence but all were controlled with a combination of further embolisation, surgery or radiotherapy. One patient elected for treatment with radiotherapy and another had excision of the tumour distal to S3. All the patients are alive and only two patients have worse neurology than at presentation, one being impotent and one with stress incontinence. All are mobile and active at a follow up between 2 and 21 years.

Conclusion: GCT of the sacrum can be controlled with conservative surgery rather than sacrectomy. Embolisation and curettage are the preferred first option with radiotherapy as a possible adjunct. Spino-pelvic fusion may be needed if the sacrum collapses.

Aim: To review treatment outcomes in patients with sacral chordoma treated at our centre over the past 20 years.

Methods: Retrospective review of prospectively kept data. Previously treated patients were excluded. The surgical objective was to obtain clear margins. If sacrifice of S2,3,4 was necessary, this was usually combined with colostomy.

Results: 30 patients were treated (20 males, 10 females), median age 63.5 (28 to 94). Median duration of symptoms before presentation was 79 weeks (3–260), mean tumour size 11 cm. Most had neurological symptoms. Eight tumours involved the S2 roots, 1 the entire sacrum. Treatment was palliative in 7 patients, resection in 23. Operation time averaged 4.5 hours (1.5 to 8). Margins were wide in 7, marginal in 12, and intralesional in 4 patients. There was a high rate of postoperative complications, mostly wound problems (61% of patients). In 1 case this resulted in septicaemia and post-operative death. Average operative blood loss was 1600ml (0–3500). 65% of patients were incontinent of urine and/or faeces. Local recurrence (LR) occurred in 52% of operated patients at a median of 32 months (4–134). Incidence of LR was 60% after intralesional, 57% after marginal and 25% after wide surgery (p=0.49). LR was treated with re-excision, radiofrequency ablation, radio- and occasionally chemotherapy. Overall survival (Kaplan-Meier) of all patients was 57% at 5, and 40% at 10 years. Of operated patients this was 67% and 47%. There was a trend for better survival after wide resection margin. Metastatic disease only occurred in 3 patients.

Conclusion: Chordoma of the sacrum is frequently diagnosed late. Resection is associated with a high complication rate. Local recurrence is the most common cause of death. Early referral to a specialist centre is recommended to optimize treatment. The role of adjuvant therapy remains unclear.

Purpose: We report our surgical management of a series of primary and metastatic tumours of the lumbosacral junction, highlighting different methods of fixation, outcome and complications.

Method: Seven patients with primary and four with secondary tumours involving the lumbosacral junction underwent surgery. After tumour resection, iliolumbar fixation was performed in all but one case, using Galveston rods (4) or iliac screws (6). All constructs were attached proximally with pedicle screws. Cross links were used in all instrumented cases and autologous and allogenic bone graft applied.

Results: There were no perioperative deaths. Mean operating time was 7.3 hours (range 3–18) and there was extensive blood loss (mean transfusion requirement 7.5 units, range 0–20). We estimate a transfusion requirement of approximately one unit per hour operating time. However, we noted no complications attributable to either blood loss or transfusions.

Ambulation improved in 5, was unchanged in 5 and deteriorated in one. Neurological status deteriorated in 4 and remained static in the others. However in all but one case the neurological deficit was defined by the nature of proposed surgery. Mean survival from surgery for patients with metastatic disease was 9.5 months (3–18). At mean follow up of 10 months (1–19 months), all patients with primary tumours were still alive without evidence tumour recurrence.

Extralesional excision, and therefore potentially curative surgery, was achieved in 4 cases where this was the primary goal of surgery (osteosarcoma, osteoblastoma, chordoma, embryonic rhabdomyosarcoma). There were no cases of metalwork failure. One patient has undergone revision surgery for pseudathrosis.

Conclusion: Sacral resection and iliolumbar reconstruction is a feasible treatment option in selected patients, offering potential cure. The fixation methods used by the authors restored lumbosacral stability, sufficient for pain relief and preserving ambulation and usually the predicted level of neurological function.

Introduction and Aims: To confirm whether bacteria were present in disc material harvested at the time of discectomy; and to determine whether the presence of bacteria correlated with elevation of Anti Lipid S antibody levels; and to compare these results with antibody levels and disc specimens from patients undergoing surgery for indications other than radiculitis.

We have previously demonstrated significantly elevated IgG titres (ELISA) to a glycolipid antigen found in the cell wall of most gram-positive bacteria in patients with discogenic sciatica. This raised the possibility that the inflammation associated with disc protrusion might be initiated or accelerated by bacteria.

Method: A prospective study was performed using disc material harvested with stringent aseptic precautions from 207 microdiscectomy and 27 trauma, tumor or scoliosis patients (controls). Serology was obtained for all patients.

Results: In the Microdiscectomy group 76/207 (37%) had positive cultures after seven days incubation, of which 26 (34%) had positive serology. Forty-nine patients had Propionibacteria, 11 Coagulase-negative-Staphylococci (CNS), eight Propionibacteria and CNS, four other organisms and four mixed growth.

One hundred and thirty one (63%) patients had negative cultures of whom 15% had positive serology. There was a significant difference between patients with positive serology and culture, compared with those with negative serology and culture (Fischer exact test P< 0.01). In some patients, organisms were visible on microscopy prior to culture. Two of the patients undergoing surgery for other indications had positive cultures (P.acnes) of whom one had positive serology. Of those with negative cultures, six had positive serology.

There was a significant difference between positive cultures in those with sciatica and controls (P< .001).

Conclusion: A significant proportion of patients with discogenic radiculitis have positive cultures with low-virulence Gram-positive organisms (predominantly Propionibacteria ) and in proportion, a corresponding appropriate antibody response.

Aims: The validation of two previously published prognostic scoring systems in relation to survival following surgery for metastatic disease of the spine. Methods: 169 patients operated upon for metastatic disease of the spine were retrospectively reviewed and prognostic scores calculated according to the systems of Tokuhashi and Tomita. Surgical approach and strategy, complications and reoperations were also recorded. Patient survival was compared by prognostic group and surgical strategy within and between the two systems. Results: 126 patients were conþrmed dead at a mean of 8.3 months and 43 alive at a mean 31.2 months. Patients with Tokuhashi scores of 9–12 had 50% survivial of 23 months compared to 5 months and 2 months for scores of 5–8 and 1–4 respectively (p< 0.05). Tomita scoring showed a similar trend with 50% survivals of 15 and 5 months for predicted long and medium term groups (p< 0.05). Each prognostic parameter was signiþcantly related to survival for both systems. There was no difference in survival within the better prognostic groups in relation to surgical stratergy. Tomitañs system was less sensitive to early mortality. Conclusions: Both systems are potentially useful in deciding the suitability for surgery in patients with metastatic spinal disease. There use in the emergency, unstaged patient has not been validated here. They may help in comparing patient status in future studies allowing more meaningful analysis of data.

Introduction: Percutaneous or semi-open needle biopsy is recommended to obtain histological or bacteriological diagnosis prior to definitive treatment of destructive vertebral lesions. The clinical efficacy of repeating biopsies when initial samples have been inconclusive has not been established. We have examined the accuracy of repeat biopsy in these cases.

Materials and Methods: 103 patients with destructive vertebral lesions underwent percutaneous trans-pedicular or open vertebral biopsy. Eighty-two were available for analysis, and in 33 (39%) the initial biopsy failed to establish a histological or microbiological diagnosis. Thirteen patients underwent a repeat biopsy. The remaining 20 patients underwent a definitive surgical procedure or were treated empirically.

Results: Repeat biopsy was inconclusive in six patients, two were confirmed as infection (one TB and one Staph Aureus) and five malignancy (four lymphoma and one chordoma).

There was no significant association between the type of biopsy (open or percutaneous), the vertebral level of the lesion or the use of adjuvant therapy in the malignant cases. As has already been shown from this unit, the commencement of ‘blind’ antibiotic therapy reduces the success of bacteriological culture but does not affect the histological appearance.

Conclusion: Repeat vertebral biopsy is indicated if the initial biopsy is inconclusive, especially if antibiotics have not been commenced or a diagnosis of lymphoma is suspected. It should be performed promptly so as not to compromise the definitive treatment.

Introduction: We have previously demonstrated significantly elevated IgG titres (ELISA) to a glycolipid antigen found in the cell wall of most gram positive bacteria in patients with discogenic radiculitis (sciatica).

This raised the possibility that the inflammation associated with disc protrusion might be initiated or accelerated by the presence of bacteria.

Aim of the study: To confirm whether bacteria were present in the disc material harvested at the time of discectomy. To determine whether the presence of bacteria correlated with elevation of Anti Lipid S antibody levels. To compare these results with Antibody levels and disc specimens from patients undergoing surgery for indications other than radiculitis.

Methods: This was a prospective study. Recognising the frequency of contamination in clean wound culture stringent aseptic precautions were taken. Disc material was harvested from 108 microdiscectomy patients with sciatica.

Disc material was also obtained from 11 patients undergoing discectomy for other indications (trauma, tumour scoliosis). Serology was obtained for all these patients.

Results: In the microdiscectomy group 50/112 (45%) had positive cultures after seven days incubation, of which 15 (30%) had positive serology. Thirty-one patients had Propionibacteria, nine Coagulase negative Staphylococci (CNS), six Propionibacteria and CNS, one Corynebacterium and three mixed growth.

Sixty-two (55%) patients had negative cultures and all except one had negative serology. There was a significant difference between patients with positive serology and culture compared with those with negative serology and culture (Fischer exact test P< 0.01). In some patients organisms were visible on microscopy prior to culture.

Thirteen of those with postive cultures and 25 of those with negative cultures had had one or more epidural injections prior to surgery. Epidural injection was not found to be significantly associated with postive culture.

None of the patients undergoing surgery for other indications had positive serology or positive cultures.

Conclusion: A significant proportion of patients with discogenic radiculitis have positive cultures with low virulence Gram positive organisms (predominantly Propionibacteria) and in a proportion a corresponding appropriate antibody response.

Introduction: We have previously demonstrated significantly elevated IgG titres (ELISA) to a glycolipid antigen found in the cell wall of most gram positive bacteria in patients with discogenic radiculitis (sciatica).

This raised the possibility that the inflammation associated with disc protrusion might be initiated or accelerated by the presence of bacteria.

Aim of the Study: To confirm whether bacteria were present in disc material harvested at the time of discectomy. To determine whether the presence of bacteria correlated with elevation of Anti Lipid S antibody levels. To compare these results with Antibody levels and disc specimens from patients undergoing surgery for indications other than radiculitis.

Methods: This was a prospective study. Recognising the frequency of contamination in clean wound culture, stringent aseptic precautions were taken. Disc material was harvested from 62 microdiscectomy patients with sciatica. Disc material was also obtained from three patients undergoing decompression but without radiculitis and from three patients undergoing anterior correction of scoliosis. Serology was obtained for all these patients.

Results: In the Microdiscectomy group, 27/62 (43%) had positive cultures after seven days incubation, of which nine (33%) had positive serology. 22 patients had Propionibacteria, three Coagulase negative Staphylococci, one Corynebacterium and one mixed growth. Thirty five (56.4%) patients had negative cultures and all except one had negative serology. There was a significant difference between patients with positive serology and culture compared with those with negative serology and culture (Fischer exact test P< 0.001). In some patients organisms were visible on microscopy prior to culture.

Ten of those with positive cultures and fourteen of those with negative cultures had had one or more epidural injections prior to surgery. Epidural injection was not found to be significantly associated with positive culture.

None of the patients undergoing surgery for other indications had positive serology or positive cultures.

Conclusion: A significant proportion of patients with discogenic radiculitis have positive cultures with low virulence Gram positive organisms (predominantly Propionibacteria) and in a proportion, a corresponding appropriate antibody response.

Sixteen consecutive patients with tibial plateau fractures were investigated by standard radiography, biplanar tomography and computerised axial tomograms (CT scans). It was found that CT scanning proved most helpful for classifying the type of fracture, for evaluating the degree of comminution, and for measuring displacement. Moreover, because a single position was maintained throughout the investigation, the patients felt less discomfort than during other assessment procedures. For these reasons CT scanning is recommended for evaluating this type of fracture.

Acute compartment syndromes often develop insidiously and are often recognised too late to prevent permanent disability. Management is difficult as the compartment involved is seldom clinically apparent. By continuously monitoring the intracompartmental pressure these problems can be avoided: transient compartment syndromes can be differentiated from established ones and the correct compartment can be surgically decompressed. Pressure monitoring techniques were used in 28 patients; three developed a compartment syndrome requiring surgical intervention, seven had a temporary increase of pressure and in 18 the pressure remained unaltered. Of the three with compartment syndromes, one was unusual in that it affected the thigh and another, unique in our experience, affected both the thigh and the calf. Intracompartmental pressure monitoring significantly altered the management of two cases giving successful results with minimal intervention.