Ambiguities arise concerning to the anatomic position of the implants and the resulting mechanic performance. Aim of this study was the comparison of three anatomic variations of one angle stable plate system as to their mechanic stability.
A physiological load distribution (Capitulum Humeri 60%, Trochlea humeri 40%) could be guaranteed for by a therefore designed test set up. In three test series, the load to failure (static), the system rigidity (static) and the median fatigue limit (dynamic) were determined. The tests were conducted under 75° flexion and 5° extension and the relative displacements were recorded.
Great differences could be stated with the 180° (me d+lat) alternative in extension in comparison to the flexion (p<
0,05): under flexion the failure already appeared at 1077N and the stiffness reduced to 116 N ± 10 N. The highest stiffness (202 N ±19 N) under flexion load could be determined for 90° (med+post). As to stiffness, the 90° (lat+post) alt ernative lay in between. Decreases of fracture gaps due to a failure of screw bone interface and a bending of plates could be determined as failure patterns in case of static load. Under dynamic load especially fatigue fractures occurred at the implant system in terms of broken plates and screws.
The mechanic superiority of the 180° alternative (minimized gap displacement and high stiffness of the system respectively) in extension direction in comparison to a 90° alternative can be explained by the 90° position of the plates and hence reduced moment of inertia. Less stiffness under flexion direction arises from the long levers, which cause high bending moments.
To examine the mechanical performance of the Son-icPin in a realistic fracture model 12 fresh frozen tibiae were osteotomized through the medial apex of the pla-fond, simulating a horizontal fracture of the medial malleolus. The tibiae were treated with either the Son-icPin or with 4.0-millimeter partially threaded titanium screws. Mechanical testing was performed by applying a compressive load 17 degrees from the long axis of the tibia to simulate supination-adduction loading.