Injury to the syndesmosis occurs in approximately 10% of all patients with ankle fractures. Anatomic restoration of the syndesmosis is the only significant predictor of functional outcome. Several techniques of syndesmosis fixation are currently used such as cortical screws, bioabsorbable screws and more recently introduced suture-button fixation. No single technique has been shown to be superior to the others. The objective of this research project is to investigate whether treatment with a tightrope (suture-button fixation) gives superior results than the use of a cortical screw in the treatment of acute syndesmotic ankle injuries with regards to function, pain, satisfaction and return to normal activities. Research Ethics Committee approval was obtained. 40 patients with syndesmotic ankle injuries associated with diastasis were prospectively recruited, 20 in each group. Patients were randomized to one of the 2 groups. At 12 weeks, American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society (AOFAS) scores and a computerized tomography (CT) scan of both the ankles was obtained. At 1 year, AOFAS scores and satisfaction was assessed. 32 patients have been recruited so far, 20 in the tightrope group and 12 in the cortical screw group. Mean AOFAS scores at 3 months post-op were 90.67 in the Tightrope group and 84 in the screw group. The difference was not significant (p= 0.096). CT scans revealed that the quality of syndesmosis reduction was equally good with both the techniques. Metalwork prominence was common with both the devices. Both the devices achieved good reduction of the syndesmosis. Our CT scan protocol has insignificant radiation risk and allows more accurate assessment of the syndesmosis. Early clinical results do not show a significant difference in the functional outcome with the use of either device. Long-term (1 year) follow-up has been planned.Discussion and Conclusion
ECSWT has been on the medical horizon for last 30 years mainly in urology for urolithiasis and has found a parallel use in orthopaedics for various chronic soft tissue conditions like Tendoachilles tendinoses and plantar fasciitis etc. ECSWT acts a piezoelectric device releasing acoustic energy and causing micro-trauma activating cytokine mediated response stimulating local angiogenesis and tissue repair. 56 patients were recruited for the trial after ethics approval was achieved. The diagnosis was confirmed with ultrasound scan and measuring the width of the swelling and the local hypervascularity. The cohort of the patients was randomised in groups for physiotherapy [n=23] and shockwave therapy [n= 23]. The patient groups with shockwave therapy received a 3-week treatment with typical 2000 impulses per session once a week and physiotherapy group was subjected to eccentric loading exercises. Patients were assessed at 12 week with AOFAS, VISA-A scores and repeat ultrasound scan. The average age of the average age was 51 years [36- 73 years] Mean duration of symptoms prior to treatment was 25 months (range 6-60 months). AOFAS scores increased in both groups: from 64□86 in the ECSWT group and 72□79 in the physiotherapy group. VISA-A scores also increased in both groups from 39□73 in the ECSWT group and from 36□56 in the physiotherapy group. Scores were significantly higher in the ECWST group post treatment. The ultrasound scan findings suggested the tendon girth receding from 10.9 mm□9.9 mm in physiotherapy group while 9.8 mm□8.7 mm in the ECSWT group with hypervascularity decreasing from marked to mild in both groups. Statistical significance was established using SPSS 16 p < 0.001in post treatment group.Methodology
Results
