‘Safety’ is at the centre of surgical practice with the aim of minimising the risks of complications and adverse events. Much evidence, based on either retrospective case series or prospective cohorts, concerns the frequency of adverse events. There may be a temptation to describe a procedure as ‘safe’ if no – or few – serious adverse events (the numerator) have occurred out of a number of procedures performed (the denominator). In 1983, Hanley and Lippman-Hand described a simple algorithm to calculate the 95% upper Confidence Interval for data sets in which the numerator is zero (ie series in which there no adverse events). Paediatric orthopaedics suffers from small datasets which may make its researchers especially prone to the erroneous attribution of procedures being ‘safe’. The aim of the current study was to formally assess the evidence on which paediatric orthopaedic surgical procedures are described as ‘safe’. In particular, the objective was to ascertain the proportion of studies describing a procedure as ‘safe’ which achieved a 95% upper limit Confidence Interval of risk of 5% for major adverse events. We examined all papers published by the Journal of Paediatric Orthopaedics in the previous 5 years searching for the single term ‘safe’. 84 papers were returned and 71 were considered appropriate for analysis. Of these 60 papers positively identified their intervention as ‘safe’. These papers were read in full and the number of interventions was recorded along with the rate of complication. 66 data sets were created and the 95% upper confidence interval was calculated for complication rates. Only 16 out of 66 data sets could safely predict a major complication rate of under 5%. Our work would tend to suggest that a failure to apply proper statistical tools is leading to procedures being erroneously classified as safe in the published literature.
Two randomised trials concluded cast type (above or below elbow) makes no significant difference in the re-displacement rate of paediatric forearm fractures involving the distal third of the radius. This has not, however, led to the universal use of below elbow casts. In particular we noted one trial reported significant re-displacement in 40% or more of cases, which was much higher than we would expect. To review the radiological outcomes and need for re-manipulation of paediatric distal forearm fractures treated with closed manipulation under anaesthesia in our institution, in part for subsequent comparison with published results. All forearm fractures treated at a specialist children's hospital in one year were reviewed retrospectively. Based on the methodology of one trial, we included all fractures involving the distal third of the radius, with or without an ulna fracture, which underwent closed manipulation. Outcomes were radiological alignment using existing radiographs and need for re-manipulation. Cast type was at the discretion of the treating surgeon. The radiological criteria for re-displacement were based on published methodology. 79 children underwent manipulation, 71 receiving above elbow casts and 8 below elbow casts. Radiologically 21% of injuries treated in an above elbow cast re-displaced (15/71) compared to 38% of those in below elbow plasters (3/8). In 2 cases the re-displacement was treated with re-manipulation. The preference in our institution was clearly for above elbow casts in this injury pattern. The small number of below elbow casts in our series limits any comparisons. Our rate of re-displacement using above elbow casts was half that of one of the published studies, so the existing literature is not consistent with our experience.Introduction
Neurological examination in children presenting with upper limb fractures is often poorly performed. In the peripatetic emergency department environment this may be confounded by patient distress or reduced comprehension. We aimed to assess the quality of documented neurological examination in children presenting with upper limb fractures and whether this could be improved following introduction of a simple guideline for paediatric neurological assessment. We reviewed the clinical notes of all children presenting to the emergency department with upper limb fractures over a three month period. Documentation of initial neurological assessment and clinical suspicion of any nerve injury were noted. Subsequently, we introduced a guideline for paediatric upper limb neurological examination (‘Rock, Paper, Scissors, OK’) to our hospital and performed a further 3 month review to detect resulting changes in practice. In the initial study period, 121 children presented with upper limb fractures. 10 (8%) had a nerve injury. Neurological examination was documented in 107 (88%) of patients. However, information on nerves examined was only recorded in 5 (5%) with the majority (85%) documented as ‘neurovascuarly intact’. None of the nerve injuries were detected on initial assessment. Following guideline introduction, 97 patients presented with upper limb fractures of which 8 children (8%) had a nerve injury. Documentation of neurological examination increased to 98% for patients presenting directly to our own hospital (Fisher's Exact Test, p=0.02) with details of nerves examined increasing to 69%. Within this cohort all nerve injuries with objective motor or sensory deficits were detected on initial examination. The recent British Orthopaedic Association Standards for Trauma (BOAST) guideline on peripheral nerve injuries emphasises the importance of clearly recorded neurological assessment in trauma patients. Our study shows that introduction of a simple guideline for neurological examination in children with upper limb fractures can significantly improve the quality of documented neurological assessment and detection of nerve injuries.
There is substantial concern about the state of musculoskeletal knowledge of junior doctors. There are also marked differences in the locomotor curricula of medical schools, raising the possibility that students may be selectively disadvantaged from gaining appropriate knowledge and/or attaining a musculoskeletal career path. The aims of this study were to assess the musculoskeletal knowledge of newly qualified doctors in the south of Scotland, and to compare this between the two medical schools (Glasgow and Edinburgh) that have different locomotor teaching programmes. All final year medical students, from Glasgow and Edinburgh Universities ( There was a significant difference (Wilcoxon two sample test; p<0.5×10−9) in the marks obtained at the two institutions, the median being 59% (IQR 50–67%) and 68% (IQR 60–76%) at Glasgow and Edinburgh respectively. The pass-rates for the two institutions (Glasgow The majority of newly qualified doctors in the south of Scotland have inadequate musculoskeletal knowledge. There is a substantial and statistically significant difference in the scores attained by students from two neighbouring medical schools (Glasgow and Edinburgh). The striking difference in the pass-rates can be best explained by differences in respective musculoskeletal courses. These explicit and comparative deficits raise substantial questions for musculoskeletal curriculum planning, teaching, assessment and quality assurance.
Neurological examination is essential in patients with upper limb injuries and should be clearly documented. We aimed to assess the quality and documentation of neurological examination performed for children presenting with upper limb fractures to the emergency department. Clinical notes of all children admitted with upper limb fractures over a three month period were reviewed. Documentation of initial neurological assessment was analysed and clinical suspicion of any nerve injury noted. In parallel, we conducted an anonymous survey of emergency doctors evaluating their upper limb neurological examination in children. The casenotes of 121 children with upper limb fractures were reviewed. 10 children (8%) had a nerve injury (median = 4, ulnar = 2, radial = 2, anterior interosseous = 2). Neurological examination was documented in 107 (88%) of patients. However, none of the nerve injuries were detected on initial examination. In patients with nerve injuries, 5 (50%) were documented as being ‘neurovascularly intact’, 2 (20%) as ‘CSM normal’, 1 (10%) as ‘moving fingers’ and 2 (20%) had no documented neurological examination. 30 emergency doctors completed the questionnaires (5 consultants, 9 registrars, 16 foundation doctors). All doctors stated that they routinely performed an upper limb neurological examination and assessed median, ulnar and radial nerves. However, 30% of doctors described incomplete examination of median nerve function, 30% inadequate ulnar nerve assessment and 50% incomplete radial nerve examination. In addition, 75% of doctors failed to identify the need for assessment of anterior interosseous nerve function. While emergency doctors recognise the importance of neurological assessment in children with upper limb injuries, it is often performed inadequately. This in part may be due to difficulties performing neurological examination in paediatric patients. As a result of this study, we have introduced local guidelines to assist neurological assessment in children.
During the cold snap in the West of Scotland 20 December 2009 to 10 January 2010 there was a cluster of uncommon lower limb injuries in children from sledging accidents. These cases are presented as a series. This retrospective descriptive study details acute orthopaedic admissions for the period of the cold snap. The case-notes for all admissions were reviewed for diagnosis, mechanism of injury. Five (ex 20 ie 1/4) trauma admissions involved sledging: (1) combined avulsion of anterior and posterior cruciate ligaments left knee (2) Lisfranc injury, (3) distal femoral fracture, (4) distal tibial plafond fracture, (5) pelvis, patella also forearm and facial fractures. These cases are analysed in more detail Sledging injuries comprise a substantial portion of workload and morbidity. In children, there is a propensity for lower limb and higher energy trauma. Tertiary referrals and non-standard trauma equipment may be required.
Ponseti first advocated his treatment for idiopathic clubfoot in the early 1950's. The method has only gained popularity and widespread use since the 1990's. Despite publications showing favourable results, there is little published data scrutinising the change in modes of talipes treatment. This study sought to define the trends in treatment for Idiopathic Clubfoot in Scotland over a twelve-year period (1997 – 2008). (i) A review was performed to identify the number of publications referencing the Ponseti method over the past 40 years. (ii) A structured questionnaire was sent to all Paediatric Orthopaedic practitioners in Scotland to ascertain the treatment methods used and over the time period. (iii) Data from the National Census for number of live births were combined with that obtained from the Scottish Morbidity Record (SMR01) for number of peritalar clubfoot surgeries performed over the study period. (iv) Similar data was also obtained for non-Talipes related peritalar surgeries, and data colleceted for the number of Tibialis Anterior transfer operations for this period. Clubfoot incidence data was measured indirectly by means of sample from the database of a tertiary referral Paediatric Orthopaedic Unit. Regression analysis was used to evaluate the trends over time. Review of the literature referencing the Ponseti method over the past 40 years showed an exponential increase from the late 1990's. The survey of Clubfoot management of Paediatric Orthopaedic Surgeons in Scotland showed a marked increase in use of the method over with this period. Over this period, the number of operations for clubfoot dropped substantially, from 55 releases in 1997 to 1 release in 2008. The linear equation estimated a decrease of approximately 5 surgical releases per year (R²= 0.87, p<0.05). In Scotland, most Tibialis Anterior transfers are performed at age 3years, the frequency of the procedure has increased in the latter half of the study period. In Scotland between 1997 and 2008, the number of peritalar (posterior, medial, posteromedial release) operations used in the primary treatment of idiopathic clubfoot has dropped substantially. This correlates with a marked increase in reference to the method within the literature and increased usage of the Ponseti technique by Paediatric Orthopaedic Consultants.
Pyomyositis is a primary pyogenic infection in skeletal muscle, often progressing to abscess formation. It is rare in temperate climates and generally deep-seated within the pelvis with non-specific clinical features, making diagnosis difficult. Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) is highly sensitive for muscle inflammation and fluid collection and with its increasing availability is now the investigation of choice. Treatment of pyomyositis abscess has traditionally been with incision and drainage or guided aspiration followed by a prolonged course of antibiotics, although there are sporadic reports of cases treated successfully with antibiotics alone. From our 20 year database of over 16000 paediatric orthopaedic admissions we identified only 3 cases with MRI-confirmed pyomyositis abscess. These were all in boys (aged 2-12) and affected the gluteal, piriformis and adductor muscles. Despite the organisms not being identified, each patient was treated successfully with a short (4-7 day) course of intravenous antibiotics followed by 2-6 weeks of oral therapy. There were no recurrences or complications and all made a full recovery. We propose that uncomplicated pyomyositis abscess in children may usually be managed conservatively without the need for open or percutaneous drainage.
Forearm fractures are a common paediatric injury. This study was aimed to describe the epidemiological of paediatric forearm fractures in the urban population of Glasgow. We reviewed of all the forearm fracture treated by the orthopaedic service in Yorkhill Children's Hospital in 2008. Datum gathered from case notes and radiographs using the prospective orthopaedic database to identify patients with forearm fractures. The age, sex, side and type of fracture, the timing and mechanism of the injury and treatment were documented for the 436 fractures. Census data were used to derive absolute age-specific incidences. Distinction was made between torus and other types of fractures. Torus fractures require no specific orthopaedic treatment and were segregated out. For the remaining 314 fractures, the age and sex distribution, seasonal variation of fractures and treatments for each type of fracture were examined. The incidence of forearm fractures in our population is 411 fractures per 100,000 population per year. An increased number of fractures occurred during the months of May and August. A fall from less than one metre was the commonest mechanism of injury, sporting injuries were the second commonest with football the most common sport associated. This study identifies some features which are in good agreement with studies from elsewhere in Britain, such as incidence and seasonality. However, there are also interesting differences – such as the Glasgow peak incidence for forearm fractures being at age 8, with a marked decline by 12 years. Furthermore, our findings have been extended to consideration of type of intervention, and likelihood of successful treatment.
