Introduction

It is widely accepted that intra-articular graft reconstruction with correct placement stands the greatest chance of abolishing symptomatic instability secondary to anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) deficiency. It is estimated that at least 100,000 ACL reconstructions are performed a year in the USA, where approximately 30% of the population are currently clinically obese.

In the UK obesity is a growing problem and as participation in exercise is seen as an important part of the strategy in improving the health of the nation, it is likely that there will be an increasing number of ligament injured patients from this sub group.

Does obesity prejudice outcome? There is very little published work on this association of obesity and ligament reconstruction. It has been reported that subjects with a BMI greater than 30 have 0.35 times the odds of success as subjects with a normal BMI.

Hamstring tendons are commonly used for Anterior Cruciate Ligament (ACL) reconstruction. In our series of 100 consecutive Hamstring ACL reconstructions, a four-strand graft was less than 7.0 mm in 5 patients. The aim of this study was to develop a screening test to assess the size of the hamstring tendon and so aid in the pre operative planning and patient counselling especially if hamstring size was deemed to be inadequate. A retrospective study of 100 consecutive hamstring ACL reconstructions analysed the correlation of the tendon size to height, weight and body mass index. A prospective double blind study was also set up involving independent observations by a musculoskeletal radiologist and the lead Orthopaedic surgeon.

The purpose of the study was to establish if there is a consensus amongst knee surgeons in U.K. related to rehabilitation protocols following microfracture/drilling procedure performed for treatment of full thickness chondral lesions of the knee. Successful rehabilitation is accepted to be essential for achievement of best results.

A questionnaire was produced including questions about use of a CPM machine, use of a brace, weight-bearing status, use of an exercise bike, time allowed for patient to resume running, time allowed for patient to return to contact sports and surgeon’s expectancy of when symptoms will plateau. A simple scenario was put at the beginning of the questionnaire: “ A 23 year-old rugby player sustained a full thickness 1.5 x 1.5 cm chondral fracture on

the medial femoral condyle and

The lesion is treated using microfracture or a standard debridement method – post-operatively how is the patient managed?”. Questions were asked with regard to each site. The questionnaire was sent to BASK members. One hundred and twenty surgeons replied.

Analysis of responses showed an unexpected variability regarding the rehabilitation for patients having treatment for a full thickness chondral lesion, with no common agreement (less than 50%) even about such aspects as the use of CPM, allowed range of motion, weight bearing status or return to sport.

There is a marked disparity amongst knee surgeons in UK regarding the protocol of rehabilitation after treatment for full thickness chondral lesions of the knee. The majority of patients suitable for microfracture are young and active and a successful rehabilitation program is crucial to optimize the results of surgery. There is a need for development of accepted practice guidelines, to standardise the outcome for these patients.

We aim to identify any changes in the demographics of ACL injured patients over the last decade. Over a twelve month period, the demographic data from 117 consecutive new patients with ACL injuries attending one consultant’s clinic in 1994 was prospectively recorded. This was then compared with data from a similar cohort of 103 consecutive new ACL injured patients attending the same clinic some twelve years later.

Since 1994, the proportion of women seen with ACL injury doubled from 12% to 25%. The proportion of skiing related injuries trebled from 9% to 28%. The average age at presentation rose by 6.5 years from 26.5 to 33. In 2006, the average age of the skiers was 40 and 72.4% of them were female compared to only 8% of non-skiers.

The population of patients with new ACL injuries has changed significantly over the last twelve years. The average age, proportion of women and number of skiing related injuries have all increased significantly. We speculate that the most likely cause of these changes is the skiing population, which has enlarged and, due to retention of participants, has aged over the period of this study (1). Most skiing injuries are sustained abroad and the vast majority of skiers buy holiday insurance to cover themselves against injury. Yet it is the NHS that ends up footing the bill for any reconstructive surgery and rehabilitation. We propose that if the insurance companies maintained responsibility for their clients’ injuries until a full recovery had been made, the NHS would save millions of pounds.

Post traumatic myositisossificans is a benign condition of heterotropic ossification of unknown aetiology which typically is related to trauma from a single blow or repeated episodes of microtrauma. We describe an unusual case of myositis ossificans which developed as a complication at the donor site for hamstring autologous graft used in open anterior and posterior cruciate repair and posterolateral corner reconstruction in a 15 year old girl.

Case report: A 15 year old girl sustained a closed traumatic dislocation of her left knee when she fell from a trampoline. She underwent emergency manipulation under anaesthetic and closed reduction followed by MRI scan which showed a complete disruption of the lateral collateral ligament complex, posterolateral corner injury, complete tears of the anterior and posterior cruciate ligaments and a partial tear of the medial collateral ligament.

13 days later she had an open reconstruction of her anterior and posterior cruciate ligaments with allograft and a repair of popliteus and lateral structures with Larson reinforcement with controlateral hamstring autologous graft.

Eight months following open reconstruction the patient represented to her primary care practitioner with a painful lump in the postero-medial controlateral right thigh. MRI study showed that there was a lobulated hypervascular appearance with a thin enhancing rim of low signal on all sequences indicating calcification. An xray revealed a calcified mass consistent with the diagnosis of myositis ossificans.

Discussion and conclusion: To date we have found no reported cases of myositis ossificans occurring as a result of surgery to harvest hamstring autograft in the setting of ligament reconstruction about the knee. We believe that this is an unusual complication of the donor site which needs awareness amongst clinicians involved in primary and revision cruciate ligament reconstruction. We suggest that a management strategy of surveillance for this lesion is appropriate and excision biopsy should be reserved for specific indications such as malignant features on imaging or mass effect.

Purposes of Study: To establish what happens, over time, to an ACL graft which is implanted in the skeletally immature knee.

Methods/Results: 5 cases of hamstring ACL reconstruction in prepubertal patients were available from the practices of 2 surgeons in which there were X-ray/MRI images taken over a period of an average of approximately 3 years from the operation. The changes in graft dimensions were measured from these images. No case of growth arrest was seen, nor of soft tissue contracture such as fixed flexion. All patients recovered to their same pre-injury level of activity, including elite level sport in 3 cases. Clinical laxity tests were always satisfactory but the senior authors have noticed that they tighten in time.

The growth of the patients was an average 17cm. The graft diameters did not change despite large changes in graft length (average 145%). Most of the length gain was in the femur.

Conclusion: Much has been written regarding potential harm to the growth plate in these patients but we are not aware of literature on the subject of the fate of the graft itself. Considerable length changes in the grafts were evident. The biological phenomena taking place in the graft are unknown. We have clearly shown an increase in the size of graft tissue due to lengthening but no change in girth. Either the graft stretches or tissue neogenesis occurs, or both. If it simply stretched then the graft would be expected to become narrower, at least in places- it did not. Nevertheless the ‘tightening’ phenomenon reported anecdotally could be due to the graft having to stretch but failing to keep up with growth. As the volume of graft increases so much then at least some neogenesis is highly likely.

Anterior Cruciate Ligament (ACL) reconstruction is performed widely across the United Kingdom by orthopaedic surgeons many of whom are members of the British Association for Surgery to the Knee (BASK), The choice of graft and fixation devices varies, based on surgeon’s preference, experience and patient needs. No data has been published with regards to choice of graft material or fixation devices in primary ACL reconstruction within the United Kingdom (UK).

To find out what current practice is, we undertook a postal questionnaire of BASK members. 62% responded. Of these, 55% of surgeons have been undertaking ACL reconstruction for more than 10 years. Only 39% are performing over 50 ACL reconstructions per year. 71% of surgeons have read the Good Practice for ACL reconstruction booklet published by the British Orthopaedic Association (BOA).

For the femur, the most popular devices used were metal screws (49%), rigidfix (17%), endobutton (14%), transfix (8%) and bioscrews (6%). For the tibia it was metal screws (57%), bioscrews (25%) and intrafix (14%)

16% use bone patellar tendon bone graft (BPTB), 18% use hamstrings, while 66% use either. Overall the most popular method seems to be the use of hamstrings or BPTB secured at both ends with metal interference screws without the use of a tensioner.

Whether the variation alters clinical result is difficult to prove. With no national registry, comparison of outcomes becomes impossible. Our survey should serve as a baseline for any future research in this area.

The potential harm to the growth plate following reconstruction of the anterior cruciate ligament in skeletally-immature patients is well documented, but we are not aware of literature on the subject of the fate of the graft itself. We have reviewed five adolescent males who underwent reconstruction of the ligament with four-strand hamstring grafts using MR images taken at a mean of 34.6 months (18 to 58) from the time of operation. The changes in dimension of the graft were measured and compared with those taken at the original operation. No growth arrest was seen on radiological or clinical measurement of leg-length discrepancy, nor was there any soft-tissue contracture. All the patients regained their pre-injury level of activity, including elite-level sport in three. The patients grew by a mean of 17.3 cm (14 to 24). The diameter of the grafts did not change despite large increases in length (mean 42%; 33% to 57%). Most of the gain in length was on the femoral side. Large changes in the length of the grafts were seen.

There is a considerable increase in the size of the graft, so some neogenesis must occur; the graft must grow.

Antero-inferior reattachment of a femoral peel off type injury of the Anterior Cruciate Ligament (ACL) occurs fairly commonly when an injury involves a valgus strain in addition to the more common external rotation strain of the knee.

This produces a recognisable and consistent pattern of clinical signs with an increased Lachman but with a solid end stop, an increased anterior drawer with no end stop and a pivot glide or 1+ pivot shift. This pattern of signs can be explained on a biomechanical basis.

From a functional point of view the reattachment often provides enough stability to allow a patient to return to a reasonable level of sporting activity.

Problems arise however when functional instability does occur and an inability to interpret the clinical signs, an MRI that is often interpreted as normal, and an arthroscopy when, to the inexperienced, the ACL may look relatively normal, leads to an error in decision making with regard to ACL reconstruction.

This variety of ACL injury has not been previously reported.

This study set out to determine the incidence of avulsion of the posterior horn of the lateral meniscus in isolated Anterior cruciate ligament injuries.

Anterior cruciate injuries are often associated with meniscal injuries and a number of different patterns of injuries are described. Although avulsion of the posterior horn of the lateral meniscus has been reported in combined ACL/MCL injuries this has not been reported in isolated ACL injuries. We examined 25 consecutive patients who had ACL ruptures and recorded the presence or absence of an avulsed posterior horn of the lateral meniscus. The mechanism of injury was also recorded. We found 6 patients (24%) with avulsion of the posterior horn of the lateral meniscus from its tibial attachment. All these patients had an external rotation injury rather than a valgus type injury.

Avulsion of the posterior horn of the lateral meniscus is a relatively common finding in ACL injury. If this injury occurs the normal load sharing function of the meniscus may not be present and this may be part of the explanation for the development of degenerative change in the ACL injured knee.