While pre-soaking grafts in vancomycin has demonstrated to be effective in observational studies for anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR) infection prevention, the economic benefit of the technique is uncertain. The primary aim of this study was to determine the
Purpose. The purpose of this study was to compare and evaluate the
Total knee arthroplasty is a successful procedure that reduces knee pain and improves function in most patients with knee osteoarthritis. Patient dissatisfaction however remains high, and along with implant longevity, may be affected by component positioning. Surgery in obese patients is more technically challenging with difficulty identifying appropriate landmarks for alignment and more difficult exposure of the joint. Patient specific instrumentation (PSI) has been introduced with the goal to increase accuracy of component positioning by custom fitting cutting guides to the patient using advanced imaging. A strong criticism of this new technology however, is the cost associated. The purpose of this study was to determine, using a prospective, randomized-controlled trial, the
Purpose. Patellofemoral arthroplasty (PFA) has experienced significant improvements in implant survivorship with second-generation designs. This has renewed interest in PFA as an alternative to total knee arthroplasty (TKA) for younger, active patients with isolated patellofemoral osteoarthritis (PF OA). The decision to select PFA over TKA balances the clinical benefits of sparing healthy knee compartments and ligaments against the risk of downstream conversion arthroplasty. We analyzed the
Background. The management of the patella during primary total knee arthroplasty (TKA) is controversial. Despite the majority of patients reporting excellent outcomes following TKA, a common complaint is anterior knee pain. Resurfacing of the patella at the time of initial surgery has been proposed as a means of preventing anterior knee pain, however current evidence, including four recent meta-analyses, has failed to show clear superiority of patellar resurfacing. Therefore, the purpose of this study was to estimate the
The optimal approach to arthroscopic repair of the rotator cuff is controversial, and both single row and double row fixation methods are commonly used. Which construct yields the highest efficacy is not clear. Given the current era of increasing costs in which health care delivery models are aiming for improved efficiencies and optimal outcomes, a
There is ongoing debate regarding the optimal surgical treatment of complex proximal humeral fractures in elderly patients. The aim of this study was to evaluate the
Study design. Economic evaluation alongside a prospective, randomised, controlled trial from a two-year National Health Service (NHS) perspective. Objective. To determine the
The purpose of this prospective pilot study is to examine the feasibility of a physiotherapist led rapid access shoulder screening clinic (RASC). The goal of this study is to assess for improvements in patient access to care, patient reported outcome measures, patient reported experience measures, and cost outcomes using time driven activity based costing methods. Patient recruitment began in January 2021. Consultation requests from general practitioners and emergency rooms are analyzed and triaged through a central system. One half of patients awaiting consultation were triaged to the traditional route used at our center while the other half were triaged to be assessed at the RASC. Outcome measures consisting of the Simple Shoulder Test and SF-12 were recorded at the initial consultation and at follow up appointments. Cost benefit analysis was conducted using time driven activity based costing methods (TD-ABC). From January to August of 2021, 123 new patients were triaged for RASC assessment. On average, the RASC gets 10 new referrals per month. As of September 2021, there are 65 patients still on waitlist for RASC assessment with 58 having been assessed. Of the 58, 11% were discharged through the RASC, 48% pursued private physiotherapy, 14% had injections, 19% proceeded on for surgical consultation, and 8% did not show. Over time same time period, approximately 15 new patients were seen in consultation by the surgeon's office. Thirty-five responses were obtained from RASC patients during their initial intake assessment. The average age of respondents was 54.7 with 21 females and 14 males. Median SF-12 scores in the physical dimension (PCS-12) for RASC patients were 36.82 and mental (MCS-12) 49.38927. Median Simple Shoulder Test scores measured 6. Of the patients who responded to the follow up questionnaires after completing physiotherapy at the RASC, both the SF-12 and Simple Shoulder Test scoring improved. Median PCS-12 measured 47.08, MCS-12 of 55.87, and Simple Shoulder Test measured 8. RASC assessments by PT saved $172.91 per hour for consultation and $157.97 per hour for patient follow ups. Utilization of a physiotherapy led rapid access shoulder clinic resulted in improvements in patient outcomes as measured by the SF-12 and Simple Shoulder Test as well as significant direct cost savings. Proper triage protocols to identify which patients would be suitable for RASC assessment, buy-in from physiotherapists, and timely assessment of patients for early initiation of rehabilitation for shoulder pain is paramount to the success of a RASC system at our centre. Future research direction would be geared to analyzing a larger dataset as it becomes available.
Complications such as implant loosening, infection, periprosthetic fracture or instability may lead to revision arthroplasty procedures. There is limited literature comparing single-stage and two-stage revision shoulder arthroplasty. This study aims to compare clinical outcomes and cost benefit between single-stage and two-stage revision procedures. Thirty-one revision procedures (mean age 72+/-7, 15 males and 16 females) performed between 2016 and 2021 were included (27 revision RSA, 2 revision TSA, 2 failed ORIFs). Two-stage procedures were carried out 4-6 weeks apart. Single-stage procedures included debridement, implant removal and washout, followed by re-prep, re-drape and reconstruction with new instrumentations. Clinical parameters including length of stay, VAS, patient satisfaction was recorded preoperatively and at mean 12-months follow up. Cost benefit analysis were performed. Seven revisions were two-stage procedures and 24 were single-stage procedures. There were 5 infections in the two-stage group vs 14 in the single-stage group. We noted two cases of unstable RSA and 8 other causes for single-stage revision. Majority of the revisions were complex procedures requiring significant glenoid and/or humeral allografts and tendon transfers to compensate for soft tissue loss. No custom implants were used in our series. Hospital stay was reduced from 41+/-29 days for 2-stage procedures to 16+/-13 days for single-stage (p<0.05). VAS improved from 9+/-1 to 2+/-4 for two-stage procedures and from 5+/-3 to 1+/-2 for single-stages. The average total cost of hospital and patient was reduced by two-thirds. Patient satisfaction in the single-stage group was 43% which was comparable to the two-stage group. All infections were successfully treated with no recurrence of infection in our cohort of 31 patients. There was no instability postoperatively. 3 patients had postoperative neural symptoms which resolved within 6 months. Single-stage procedures for revision shoulder arthroplasty significantly decrease hospital stay, improve patients’ satisfaction, and reduced surgical costs.
Purpose. Bilateral simultaneous and staged total hip arthroplasty has been issues in terms of safety and costs with development of surgical technique, postoperative medical care. The purpose of this prospective study is to compare the outcomes of simultaneous and staged bilateral operations, in terms of outcome, safety, and socioeconomic-effectiveness. Patients and Methods. All patients(470 cases) that underwent simultaneous or staged bilateral THA using modified minimally invasive two-incision technique between January 2004 and November 2009 were registered, and after exclusion divided into two groups; simultaneous bilateral THA group (Group A: 171 patients) and staged bilateral THA group (Group B: 64 patients) by patient's condition and preference. Staged operations were performed at the time when patients want to get surgery due to undurable pain. For clinical evaluations, amounts of blood loss, blood transfusion, postoperative morbidity and mortality were compared. And for socioeconomic-effectiveness, costs for hospitalization and time for returning to previous job were investigated. Results. Overall complications were not significant between two groups and perioperative morbidity rates were similar in the two groups compared. (p=0.546). Patients in group A required more blood transfusions than those in group B (3.05 vs 1.93 unit, p=0.003), although blood losses in two groups were similar. (906 vs 936 cc, p=0.605) Average interval between staged operation in group B was 18.2 months (range, 2.2 ∼ 65.0 months). Average length of hospital stay was significantly shorter in group A (average 14.6 days) than in group B (average 24.2 days) (p<0.001). Group A showed 20% higher total medical cost than group B (9,240 US vs 11,107 US dollars) (p<0.05). Conclusions. There were no differences in clinical outcome, morbidity and mortality between simultaneous and staged bilateral THA. But simultaneous operation showed a
Accurate implant alignment, prolonged operative times, array pin site infection and intra-operative fracture risk with computer assisted knee arthroplasty is well documented. This study compares the accuracy and
Primary hip and knee joint replacements in Canada have been estimated to cost over $1.4 billion dollars annually, with revision surgery costing $177 million. The most common cause of revision arthroplasty surgery in Canada is infection. Periprosthetic joint infections (PJIs) are a devastating though preventable complication following arthroplasty. Though variably used, antibiotic laden bone cement (ALBC) has been demonstrated to decrease PJIs following primary total knee arthroplasty (TKA). Unfortunately, ALBC is costlier than regular bone cement (RBC). Therefore, the aim of this study was to determine if the routine use of ALBC in primary TKA surgery is a cost-effective practice from the perspective of the Canadian healthcare system. A decision tree was constructed using a decision analysis software (TreeAge Software, Williamstown, Massachusetts) to a two-year time horizon comparing primary TKA with either ALBC or RBC from the perspective of a single-payer healthcare system. All costs were in 2020 Canadian dollars. Health utilities were in the form of quality adjusted life years (QALYs). Model inputs for cost were derived from regional and national databases. Health utilities and probability parameters were derived from the latest literature. One-way deterministic sensitivity analysis was performed on all model parameters. The primary outcome of this analysis was an incremental
Robotic and navigated TKA procedures have been introduced to improve component placement precision for the purpose of improving implant survivorship and other clinical outcomes. Although numerous studies have shown enhanced precision in placing components, adoption of technology-assistance (TA) for TKA has been relatively slow. One reason for this has been the difficulty in demonstrating the
Introduction. Accurate diagnosis of peri-prosthetic joint infection is critical to allow adequate treatment. Currently, the criteria of the Musculo-Skeletal Infection Society (MSIS) serve as a validated reference tool. More recently, these criteria have been modified for better accuracy. The goal of this study was to compare retrospectively the diagnostic accuracy of these two different tools in cases of known peri-prosthetic hip or knee infection or in aseptic cases and to analyze one additional criterion: presence of an early loosening (prior to 2 years after implantation). Material – Methods. All cases of hip or knee prosthesis exchange operated on at our department during the year 2017 have been selected. There were 130 cases in 127 patients: 67 men and 60 women, with a mean age of 69 years − 69 total hip (THA) and 61 total knee (TKA) arthroplasties. 74 cases were septic and 53 cases were aseptic. All criteria included in both classifications were collected: presence of a fistula, results of bacteriological samples, ESR and CRP levels, analysis of the joint fluid, histological analysis. Additionally, the presence of an early loosening was recorded. The diagnosis accuracy of the classical MSIS classification and of the 2018 modification were assessed and compared with a Chi-square test at a 0.05 level of significance. Results. The conventional MSIS classification correctly discriminated between infected and non-infected cases in 128/130 cases (98%). There were two failures by infected cases: one case was considered infected with no major criteria and only three minor criteria; one case was considered infected with no major criteria and only two minor criteria. There was no failure by non-infected cases. The new MSIS classification correctly discriminated between infected and non-infected cases in 129/130 cases (99%). There was one single failure by infected cases: one case was considered infected despite a score of 4 points. There was no significant difference between the diagnostic accuracy of both classifications. The presence of an early loosening had a high specificity (85%) but a low sensitivity (22%). Discussion. The conventional MSIS classification had a high diagnostic accuracy. The new MSIS classification offered only minor, non significant increase of this accuracy. As the new classification involves several additional biological assays, these results might question the
Introduction. Postoperative dislocation remains a vexing problem for patients and surgeons following total hip arthroplasty (THA). It is the commonest reason for revision THA in the US. Dual mobility (DM) THA implants markedly decrease the risk of THA instability. However, DM implants are more expensive than those used for conventional THA. The purpose of this study was to perform a
Despite the vast quantities of published artificial intelligence (AI) algorithms that target trauma and orthopaedic applications, very few progress to inform clinical practice. One key reason for this is the lack of a clear pathway from development to deployment. In order to assist with this process, we have developed the Clinical Practice Integration of Artificial Intelligence (CPI-AI) framework – a five-stage approach to the clinical practice adoption of AI in the setting of trauma and orthopaedics, based on the IDEAL principles ( Cite this article:
Ankle ligament injury is a common cause of injury to military recruits, and frequently implicated in failure to complete Royal Marines (RM) recruit training. A minority of patients at Commando Training Centre Royal Marines (CTCRM) with ankle ligament injury undergo arthroscopic ankle stabilisation surgery (Bostrum or Evans procedures). The decision to undertake surgery involves an assessment of functional benefit to the patient, medical and surgical risks, and
Frozen section is a recognised technique to assist in the diagnosis of infection and there are standards for reporting. Our aim of this review was to assess the value of frozen section in the diagnosis of infection, as well as other variables. We performed a retrospective review of all frozen sections for suspected infection in 2016. Patient demographics, histological and microbiological investigations, laboratory and bedside tests were recorded and analysed using statistical software. 46 patients had 55 frozen sections; the majority were for lower limb arthroplasty. No sections were reported as polymorphonuclear neutrophils per high-power field. Three sections showed signs of infection and one without evidence had positive cultures. One uncertain section did not grow organisms. 10 patients had two-stage procedures, four of these were intended to be determined by frozen section but only two had evidence of infection on analysis. Evidence of infection on frozen section does correlate with microbiological growth but does not relate to intention to stage procedures in half of patients. The effect of new tests such as Synovasure is highlighted by this review. Frozen section analysis is reported subjectively but is a good predictor of infection. Clinical assessment is accurate in diagnosing infection. Histological, microbiological and additional investigations should be considered in relation to their
Purpose. Arthritis is the most common chronic illness in the United States. TKR provides reliable pain relief and improved function for patients with advanced knee arthritis. Total joint replacement now represents the greatest expense in the national healthcare budget. Surgical costs are driven by two key components: fixed and variable costs. Patient Specific Instruments™ (PSI, Zimmer, Warsaw, IN, USA) has the potential to reduce both fixed and variable costs by shortening operative time and reducing surgical instrumentation. However, PSI requires the added costs of pre-operative MRI scanning and fabrication of custom pin guides. Previous studies have shown reduction in operating room times and required instrumentation, but question the