Advertisement for orthosearch.org.uk
Results 1 - 20 of 37
Results per page:
Bone & Joint Research
Vol. 6, Issue 8 | Pages 522 - 529
1 Aug 2017
Ali AM Newman SDS Hooper PA Davies CM Cobb JP

Objectives. Unicompartmental knee arthroplasty (UKA) is a demanding procedure, with tibial component subsidence or pain from high tibial strain being potential causes of revision. The optimal position in terms of load transfer has not been documented for lateral UKA. Our aim was to determine the effect of tibial component position on proximal tibial strain. Methods. A total of 16 composite tibias were implanted with an Oxford Domed Lateral Partial Knee implant using cutting guides to define tibial slope and resection depth. Four implant positions were assessed: standard (5° posterior slope); 10° posterior slope; 5° reverse tibial slope; and 4 mm increased tibial resection. Using an electrodynamic axial-torsional materials testing machine (Instron 5565), a compressive load of 1.5 kN was applied at 60 N/s on a meniscal bearing via a matching femoral component. Tibial strain beneath the implant was measured using a calibrated Digital Image Correlation system. Results. A 5° increase in tibial component posterior slope resulted in a 53% increase in mean major principal strain in the posterior tibial zone adjacent to the implant (p = 0.003). The highest strains for all implant positions were recorded in the anterior cortex 2 cm to 3 cm distal to the implant. Posteriorly, strain tended to decrease with increasing distance from the implant. Lateral cortical strain showed no significant relationship with implant position. Conclusion. Relatively small changes in implant position and orientation may significantly affect tibial cortical strain. Avoidance of excessive posterior tibial slope may be advisable during lateral UKA. Cite this article: A. M. Ali, S. D. S. Newman, P. A. Hooper, C. M. Davies, J. P. Cobb. The effect of implant position on bone strain following lateral unicompartmental knee arthroplasty: A Biomechanical Model Using Digital Image Correlation. Bone Joint Res 2017;6:522–529. DOI: 10.1302/2046-3758.68.BJR-2017-0067.R1


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 96-B, Issue SUPP_11 | Pages 354 - 354
1 Jul 2014
Eraly K Stoffelen D Van Geel N Demol J Debeer P
Full Access

Summary Statement. In this study, excellent positioning of custom-made glenoid components was achieved using patient-specific guides. Achieving the preoperatively planned orientation of the component improved significantly and more screws were located inside the scapular bone compared to implantations without such guide. Introduction. Today's techniques for total or reverse shoulder arthroplasty are limited when dealing with severe glenoid defects. The available procedures, for instance the use of bone allografts in combination with available standard implants, are technically difficult and tend to give uncertain outcomes (Hill et al. 2001; Elhassan et al. 2008; Sears et al. 2012). A durable fixation between bone and implant with optimal fit and implant positioning needs to be achieved. Custom-made defect-filling glenoid components are a new treatment option for severe glenoid defects. Despite that the patient-specific implants are uniquely designed to fit the patient's bone, it can be difficult to achieve the preoperatively planned position of the component, resulting in less optimal screw fixation. We hypothesised that the use of a patient-specific guide would improve implant and screw positioning. The aim of this study was to evaluate the added value of a newly developed patient-specific guide for implant and screw positioning, by comparing glenoid implantations with and without such guide. Patients & Methods. Large glenoid defects, representative for the defects encountered in clinical practice, were created in ten cadaveric shoulders. A CT scan of each cadaver was taken to evaluate the defects and to generate three-dimensional models of the scapular bones. Based on these models, custom glenoid components were designed. Furthermore, a newly developed custom guide was designed for five randomly selected shoulders. New CT scans were taken after implantation to generate 3D models of the bone and the implanted component and screws. This enabled to compare the experimentally achieved and preoperatively planned reconstruction. The location and orientation of the glenoid component and screw positioning were determined and differences with the optimal preoperative planning were calculated. Results. An excellent component positioning (difference in location: 1.4±0, 7mm; difference in orientation: 2, 5±1, 2°) was achieved when using the guide compared to implantations without guidance (respectively 1, 7±0, 5mm; 5, 1±2, 3°). The guide improved component orientation significantly (P<0.1). After using the guide, all screws were positioned inside the scapular bone whereas 25% of the screws placed without guidance were positioned outside the scapular bone. Discussion/Conclusion. In this study, excellent positioning of custom-made glenoid components was achieved using patient-specific guides. Achieving the preoperatively planned orientation of the component improved significantly and more screws were located inside the scapular bone compared to implantations without such guide


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 96-B, Issue SUPP_11 | Pages 151 - 151
1 Jul 2014
van Leeuwen J Röhrl S Grøgaard B Snorrason F
Full Access

Summary Statement

Our data suggest that postoperative component positioning in TKA with PSPG is not consistent with pre-operative software planning. More studies are needed to rule out possible learning curve in this study.

Introduction

Patient specific positioning guides (PSPGs) in TKA are based on MRI or CT data. Preoperatively, knee component positions can be visualised in 3-dimensional reconstructed images. Software allows anticipation of component position. From software planning PSPGs are manufactured and those PSPGs represent intra-operative component alignment. To our knowledge, there are no studies comparing pre-operative software planning with post-operative alignment. Aim of this study is to investigate the correlation between pre-operative planning of component positioning and the post-operative achieved alignment with PSPG technique.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 103-B, Issue SUPP_13 | Pages 127 - 127
1 Nov 2021
Batailler C Lording T Naaim A Servien E Cheze L Lustig S
Full Access

Introduction and Objective. In recent studies, robotic-assisted surgical techniques for unicompartmental knee arthroplasty (UKA) have demonstrated superior implant positioning and limb alignment compared to a conventional technique. However, the impact of the robotic-assisted technique on clinical and functional outcomes is less clear. The aim of this study was to compare the gait parameters of UKA performed with conventional and image-free robotic-assisted techniques. Materials and Methods. This prospective, single center study included 66 medial UKA, randomized to a robotic-assisted (n=33) or conventional technique (n=33). Gait analysis was performed on a treadmill at 6 months to identify changes in gait characteristics (walking speed, each degree-of-freedom: flexion–extension, abduction–adduction, internal-external rotation and anterior-posterior displacement). Clinical results were assessed at 6 months using the IKS score and the Forgotten Joint Score. Implants position was assessed on post-operative radiographs. Results. Post-operatively, the whole gait cycle was not significantly different between groups. In both groups there was a significant improvement in varus deformity between the pre- and post-operative gait cycle. There was no significant difference between the two groups in clinical scores, implant position, revision and complication rates. Conclusions. No difference of gait parameters could be identified between medial UKA performed with image-free robotic-assisted technique or with conventional technique


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 106-B, Issue SUPP_1 | Pages 95 - 95
2 Jan 2024
Gjerde C
Full Access

The aim of the ongoing projects was to demonstrate the efficacy of autologous bone marrow derived stem cells (MSC) combined with biomaterial to induced new bone formation in a randomized multicenter controlled clinical trial. Patients with a need for bone reconstruction of residual edentulous ridges in both the mandible and maxilla due to bone defects with a vertical loss of alveolar bone volume and/or knife edge ridges (≤ than 4,5 mm) unable to provide adequate primary stabilization for dental implants were included in the clinical study. Autologous bone marrow MSC were expanded, loaded on BCP and used to augment the alveolar ridges. After five months bone biopsies were harvested at the implant position site and implants were installed in the regenerated bone. The implants were loaded after 8–12 weeks. Safety, efficacy, quality of life and success/survival were assessed. Five clinical centers, 4 different countries participated. Bone grafts harvested from the ramus of the mandibles were used as control in the projects


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 105-B, Issue SUPP_8 | Pages 115 - 115
11 Apr 2023
Tay M Carter M Bolam S Zeng N Young S
Full Access

Unicompartmental knee arthroplasty (UKA) has a higher risk of revision than total knee arthroplasty, particularly for low volume surgeons. The recent introduction of robotic-arm assisted systems has allowed for increased accuracy, however new systems typically have learning curves. The objective of this study was to determine the learning curve of a robotic-arm assisted system for UKA. Methods A total of 152 consecutive robotic-arm assisted primary medial UKA were performed by five surgeons between 2017 and 2021. Operative times, implant positioning, reoperations and patient-reported outcome measures (PROMS; Oxford Knee Score, EuroQol-5D, and Forgotten Joint Score) were recorded. There was a learning curve of 11 cases with the system that was associated with increased operative time (13 minutes, p<0.01) and improved insert sizing over time (p=0.03). There was no difference in implant survival (98.2%) between learning and proficiency phases (p = 0.15), and no difference in survivorship between ‘high’ and ‘low’ usage surgeons (p = 0.23) at 36 months. There were no differences in PROMS related to the learning curve. This suggested that the learning curve did not lead to early adverse effects in this patient cohort. The introduction of a robotic-arm assisted UKA system led to learning curves for operative time and implant sizing, but there was no effect on patient outcomes at early follow- up. The short learning curve was independent of UKA usage and indicated that robotic-arm assisted UKA may be particularly useful for low-usage surgeons


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 105-B, Issue SUPP_7 | Pages 60 - 60
4 Apr 2023
MacLeod A Mandalia V Mathews J Toms A Gill H
Full Access

High tibial osteotomy (HTO) is an effective surgical treatment for isolated medial compartment knee osteoarthritis; however, widespread adoption is limited due to difficulty in achieving the planned correction, and patient dissatisfaction due to soft tissue irritation. A new HTO system – Tailored Osteotomy Knee Alignment (TOKA®, 3D Metal Printing Ltd, Bath, UK) could potentially address these barriers having a custom titanium plate and titanium surgical guides featuring a unique mechanism for precise osteotomy opening as well as saw cutting and drilling guides. The aim of this study was to assess the accuracy of this novel HTO system using cadaveric specimens; a preclinical testing stage ahead of first-in-human surgery according to the ‘IDEAL-D’ framework for device innovation. Local ethics committee approval was obtained. The novel opening wedge HTO procedure was performed on eight cadaver leg specimens. Whole lower limb CT scans pre- and post-operatively provided geometrical assessment quantifying the discrepancy between pre-planned and post-operative measurements for key variables: the gap opening angle and the patient specific surgical instrumentation positioning and rotation - assessed using the implanted plate. The average discrepancy between the pre-operative plan and the post-operative osteotomy correction angle was: 0.0 ± 0.2°. The R2 value for the regression correlation was 0.95. The average error in implant positioning was −0.4 ± 4.3 mm, −2.6 ± 3.4 mm and 3.1 ± 1.7° vertically, horizontally, and rotationally respectively. This novel HTO surgery has greater accuracy and smaller variability in correction angle achieved compared to that reported for conventional or other patient specific methods with published data available. This system could potentially improve the accuracy and reliability of osteotomy correction angles achieved surgically


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 105-B, Issue SUPP_7 | Pages 140 - 140
4 Apr 2023
Fry M Ren W Bou-Akl T Wu B Cizmic Z Markel D
Full Access

Extensor mechanism and abductor reconstructions in total joint arthroplasty are problematic. Growing tendon into a metallic implant would have great reconstructive advantages. With the introduction of porous metal implants, it was hoped that tendons could be directly attached to implants. However, the effects of the porous metal structure on tissue growth and pore penetration is unknown. In this rat model, we investigated the effect of pore size on tendon repair fixation using printed titanium implants with differing pore sizes. There were four groups of six Sprague Dawley rats (n = 28) plus control (n=4). Implants had pore sizes of 400µm (n=8), 700µm (n=8), and 1000µm (n=8). An Achilles tendon defect was created, and the implant positioned and sutured between the cut ends. Harvest occurred at 12-weeks. Half the specimens underwent tensile load to failure testing, the other half fixed and processed for hard tissue analysis. Average load to failure was 72.6N for controls (SD 10.04), 29.95N for 400µm (SD 17.95), 55.08N for 700µm (SD 13.47), and 63.08N for 1000µm (SD 1.87). The load to failure was generally better in the larger pore sizes. Histological evaluation showed that there was fibrous tendon tissue within and around the implant material, with collagen fibers organized in bundles. This increases as the pore diameter increases. Printing titanium implants allows for precise determination of pore size and structure. Our results showed that tendon repair utilizing implants with 700µm and 1000µm pores exhibited similar load to failure as controls. Using a defined pore structure at the attachment points of tendons to implants may allow predictable tendon to implant reconstruction at the time of revision arthroplasty


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 106-B, Issue SUPP_2 | Pages 118 - 118
2 Jan 2024
Stroobant L Verstraete M Onsem S Victor J Chevalier A
Full Access

Numerous papers present in-vivo knee kinematics data following total knee arthroplasty (TKA) from fluoroscopic testing. Comparing data is challenging given the large number of factors that potentially affect the reported kinematics. This paper aims at understanding the effect of following three different factors: implant geometry, performed activity and analysis method. A total of 30 patients who underwent TKA were included in this study. This group was subdivided in three equal groups: each group receiving a different type of posterior stabilized total knee prosthesis. During single-plane fluoroscopic analysis, each patient performed three activities: open chain flexion extension, closed chain squatting and chair-rising. The 2D fluoroscopic data were subsequently converted to 3D implant positions and used to evaluate the tibiofemoral contact points and landmark-based kinematic parameters. Significantly different anteroposterior translations and internal-external rotations were observed between the considered implants. In the lateral compartment, these differences only appeared after post-cam engagement. Comparing the activities, a significant more posterior position was observed for both the medial and lateral compartment in the closed chain activities during mid-flexion. A strong and significant correlation was found between the contact-points and landmarks-based analyses method. However, large individual variations were also observed, yielding a difference of up to 25% in anteroposterior position between both methods. In conclusion, all three evaluated factors significantly affect the obtained tibiofemoral kinematics. The individual implant design significantly affects the anteroposterior tibiofemoral position, internal-external rotation and timing of post-cam engagement. Both kinematics and post-cam engagement additionally depend on the activity investigated, with a more posterior position and associated higher patella lever arm for the closed chain activities. Attention should also be paid to the considered analysis method and associated kinematics definition: analyzing the tibiofemoral contact points potentially yields significantly different results compared to a landmark-based approach


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 105-B, Issue SUPP_8 | Pages 5 - 5
11 Apr 2023
Mischler D Tenisch L Schader J Dauwe J Gueorguiev B Windolf M Varga P
Full Access

Despite past advances of implant technologies, complication rates of fixations remain high at challenging sites such as the proximal humerus [1]. These may not only be owed to the implant itself but also to dissatisfactory surgical execution of fracture reduction and implant positioning. Therefore, the aim of this study was to quantify the instrumentation accuracy of a highly standardised and guided procedure and its influence on the biomechanical outcome and predicted failure risk. Preoperative planning of osteotomies creating an unstable 3-part fracture and fixation with a locking plate was performed based on CT scans of eight pairs of low-density proximal humerus samples from elderly female donors (85.2±5.4 years). 3D-printed subject-specific guides were used to osteotomise and instrument the samples according to the pre-OP plan. Instrumentation accuracies in terms of screw lengths and orientations were evaluated by comparing post-OP CT scans with the pre-OP plan. The fixation constructs were biomechanically tested until cyclic cut-out failure [2]. Failure risks of the planned and the post-OP configurations were predicted using a validated sample-specific finite element (FE) simulation approach [2] and correlated with the experimental outcomes. Small deviations were found for the instrumented screw trajectories compared to the planned configuration in the proximal-distal (0.3±1.3º) and anterior-posterior directions (-1.7±1.8º), and for screw tip to joint distances (-0.3±1.1 mm). Significantly higher failure risk was predicted for the post-OP compared to the planned configurations (p<0.01) via FE. When incorporating the instrumentation inaccuracies, the biomechanical results could be predicted well with FE (R. 2. =0.70). Despite the high instrumentation accuracy achieved using sophisticated subject-specific 3D-printed guides, even minor deviations from the pre-OP plan significantly increased the FE-predicted risk of failure. This underlines the importance of intraoperative guiding technology [3] in tandem with careful pre-OP planning to assist surgeons to achieve optimal outcomes. Acknowledgements. This study was performed with the assistance of the AO Foundation via the AOTRAUMA Network


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 104-B, Issue SUPP_14 | Pages 1 - 1
1 Dec 2022
Parchi P
Full Access

In the last years, 3d printing has progressively grown and it has reached a solid role in clinical practice. The main applications brought by 3d printing in orthopedic surgery are: preoperative planning, custom-made surgical guides, custom-made im- plants, surgical simulation, and bioprinting. The replica of the patient's anatomy, starting from the elaboration of medical volumetric images (CT, MRI, etc.), allows a progressive extremization of treatment personalization that could be tailored for every single patient. In complex cases, the generation of a 3d model of the patient's anatomy allows the surgeons to better understand the case — they can almost “touch the anatomy” —, to perform a more ac- curate preoperative planning and, in some cases, to perform device positioning before going to the surgical room (i.e. joint arthroplasty). 3d printing is also commonly used to produce surgical cutting guides, these guides are positioned intraoperatively on given landmarks to guide the surgeon to perform a specific surgical act (bone osteotomy, bone resection, implant position, etc.). In total knee arthroplasty, custom-made cutting guides have been developed to help the surgeon align the femoral and tibial components to the pre-arthritic condition with- out the use of the intramedullary femoral guide. 3d printed custom-made implants represent an emerging alternative to biological reconstructions especially after oncologic resection surgery or in case of complex arthroplasty revision surgery. Custom-made implants are designed to re- place the original shape and size of the patient's bone and they allow an extreme personalization of the treatment for every single patient. Patient-specific surgical simulation is a new frontier that promises great benefits for surgical training. a solid 3d model of the patient's anatomy can faithfully reproduce the surgical complexity of the patient and it allows to generate surgical simulators with increasing difficulty to adapt the difficulties of the course with the level of the trainees performing structured training paths: from the “simple” case to the “complex” case


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 106-B, Issue SUPP_1 | Pages 22 - 22
2 Jan 2024
García-Rey E Pérez-Barragans F Saldaña L
Full Access

Total hip arthroplasty (THA) outcome in patients with osteonecrosis of the femoral head ONFH) are excellent, however, there is controversy when compared with those in patients with osteoarthritis (OA). Reduced mineralization capacity of osteoblasts of the proximal femur in patients with ONFH could affect implant fixation. We asked if THA fixation in patients with ONFH is worse than in those with OA. We carried out a prospective comparative case (OA)-control (ONFH) study of patients undergoing THA at our hospital between 2017 and 2019. The minimum follow-up was 2 years. Inclusion criteria were patients with uncemented THA, younger than 70 years old, a Dorr femoral type C and idiopathic ONFH. We compared the clinical (Merlé D'Aubigné-Postel score) and radiological results related with implant positioning and fixation. Engh criteria and subsidence were assessed at the immediate postoperative, 12 weeks, 6 months, 12 months and yearly. Osteoblastic activity was determined by mineralization assay on primary cultures of osteoblasts isolated from trabecular bone samples collected from the intertrochanteric area obtained during surgery. Group 1 (ONFH) included 18 patients and group 2 (OA), 22. Average age was 55.9 years old in group 1 and 61.3 in group 2. (p=0.08). There were no differences related with sex, Dorr femoral type or femoral filling. The mean clinical outcome score was 17.1 in group 1 and 16.5 in group 2 (p=0.03). There were no cases of dislocation, infection, or revision surgery in this series. There were 5 cases (28%) of femoral stem subsidence greater than 3mm within 6 first months in group 1 and 1 case (4.5%) in group 2 (p=0.05). Although there were no significant differences related to clinical results, bone fixation was slower, and a greater subsidence was observed in patients with ONFH. Greater femoral stem subsidence was associated with a lower capacity for mineral nodule formation in cultured osteoblasts. The surgical technique could influence THA outcome in patients with reduced mineralization capacity of osteoblasts


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 105-B, Issue SUPP_16 | Pages 27 - 27
17 Nov 2023
Arafa M Kalairajah Y Zaki E Habib M
Full Access

Abstract. Objective. Short-stem total hip arthroplasty (THA) aims to preserve the proximal bone stock for future revisions, so that the first revision should resemble a primary intervention rather than a revision. This study aimed to compare the clinical and radiological outcomes in revision THA after failed short stem versus after failed conventional stem THA. Methods. This study included forty-five patients with revision THA divided into three groups (15 each); group A: revision after short stem, group B: revision after conventional cementless stem and group C revision after conventional cemented stem. The studied groups were compared regarding 31 variables including demographic data, details of the primary and revision procedures, postoperative radiological subsidence, hospital stay, time for full weight bearing (FWB), preoperative and postoperative clinical scores. Results. Early stem subsidence (40%) was the main indication of revision in group A compared to peri-prosthetic femoral fractures (PFFs) (73.3%) and aseptic loosening (53.3%) in group B and C respectively (P=0.021). The mean time to revision was significantly shorter in group A (15 months) compared to 95.33 and 189.40 months in group B and C respectively. (P=0.005). Sixty % (9 patients) in group A were revised in the first year. The mean operative time, blood loss, postoperative blood transfusion and hospital stay were significantly lower in group A compared to group B and C (P<0.001, <0.001, 0.002 and 0.001 respectively). Revisions in group A were performed using either short stems (13.3%) or conventional stems (86.7%) whilst 80% of patients needed long stems and 20% of patients needed conventional stems in group B and C (P<0.001). The mean postoperative Harris Hip Score (HHS) at the latest follow up was 87.07, 87.53 and 85.47 in group A, B and C respectively. All PFFS had excellent results according to Beal's and Tower's criteria; all fractures healed and the implants were stable. Conclusion. The most common cause of failure of short stems is early stem subsidence. Short stem THA has specific indications and patient selection is very crucial. Preoperative templating for short stems and a detailed analysis of the individual patient anatomy in anteroposterior and lateral views are mandatory to predict the correct implant size more accurately. The use of intraoperative imaging can verify the sizing, implant position, and sufficient contact with the lateral cortex. Revision of short stem THA resembled the primary THA. If a standard implant can be used in a surgical revision instead of a longer revision stem, this can be considered as an advantage for the hip arthroplasty treatment concept. However, this only applies if the longevity of the first treatment with a short stem is comparable with that of a standard stem. Declaration of Interest. (b) declare that there is no conflict of interest that could be perceived as prejudicing the impartiality of the research reported:I declare that there is no conflict of interest that could be perceived as prejudicing the impartiality of the research project


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 105-B, Issue SUPP_16 | Pages 39 - 39
17 Nov 2023
FARHAN-ALANIE M Gallacher D Kozdryk J Craig P Griffin J Mason J Wall P Wilkinson M Metcalfe A Foguet P
Full Access

Abstract. Introduction. Component mal-positioning in total hip replacement (THR) and total knee replacement (TKR) can increase the risk of revision for various reasons. Compared to conventional surgery, relatively improved accuracy of implant positioning can be achieved using computer assisted technologies including navigation, patient-specific jigs, and robotic systems. However, it is not known whether application of these technologies has improved prosthesis survival in the real-world. This study aimed to compare risk of revision for all-causes following primary THR and TKR, and revision for dislocation following primary THR performed using computer assisted technologies compared to conventional technique. Methods. We performed an observational study using National Joint Registry data. All adult patients undergoing primary THR and TKR for osteoarthritis between 01/04/2003 to 31/12/2020 were eligible. Patients who received metal-on-metal bearing THR were excluded. We generated propensity score weights, using Sturmer weight trimming, based on: age, gender, ASA grade, side, operation funding, year of surgery, approach, and fixation. Specific additional variables included position and bearing for THR and patellar resurfacing for TKR. For THR, effective sample sizes and duration of follow up for conventional versus computer-guided and robotic-assisted analyses were 9,379 and 10,600 procedures, and approximately 18 and 4 years, respectively. For TKR, effective sample sizes and durations of follow up for conventional versus computer-guided, patient-specific jigs, and robotic-assisted groups were 92,579 procedures over 18 years, 11,665 procedures over 8 years, and 644 procedures over 3 years, respectively. Outcomes were assessed using Kaplan-Meier analysis and expressed using hazard ratios (HR) and 95% confidence intervals (CI). Results. For THR, analysis comparing computer-guided versus conventional technique demonstrated HR of 0.771 (95%CI 0.573–1.036) p=0.085, and 0.594 (95%CI 0.297–1.190) p=0.142, for revision for all-causes and dislocation, respectively. When comparing robotic-assisted versus conventional technique, HR for revision for all-causes was 0.480 (95%CI 0.067 –3.452) p=0.466. For TKR, compared to conventional surgery, HR for all-cause revision for procedures performed using computer guidance and patient-specific jigs were 0.967 (95% CI 0.888–1.052) p=0.430, and 0.937 (95% CI 0.708–1.241) p=0.65, respectively. HR for analysis comparing robotic-assisted versus conventional technique was 2.0940 (0.2423, 18.0995) p = 0.50. Conclusions. This is the largest study investigating this topic utilising propensity score analysis methods. We did not find a statistically significant difference in revision for all-causes and dislocation although these analyses are underpowered to detect smaller differences in effect size between groups. Additional comparison for revision for dislocation between robotic-assisted versus conventionally performed THR was not performed as this is a subset of revision for all-causes and wide confidence intervals were already observed for that analysis. It is also important to mention this NJR analysis study is of an observational study design which has inherent limitations. Nonetheless, this is the most feasible study design to answer this research question requiring use of a large data set due to revision being a rare outcome. Declaration of Interest. (b) declare that there is no conflict of interest that could be perceived as prejudicing the impartiality of the research reported:I declare that there is no conflict of interest that could be perceived as prejudicing the impartiality of the research project


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 103-B, Issue SUPP_16 | Pages 35 - 35
1 Dec 2021
Wang K Kenanidis E Miodownik M Tsiridis E Moazen M
Full Access

Abstract. Objectives. Stem malalignment in total hip arthroplasty (THA) has been associated with poor long-term outcomes and increased complications (e.g. periprosthetic femoral fractures). Our understanding of the biomechanical impact of stem alignment in cemented and uncemented THA is still limited. This study aimed to investigate the effect of stem fixation method, stem positioning, and compromised bone stock in THA. Methods. Validated FE models of cemented (C-stem – stainless steel) and uncemented (Corail – titanium) THA were developed to match corresponding experimental model datasets; concordance correlation agreement of 0.78 & 0.88 for cemented & uncemented respectively. Comparison of the aforementioned stems was carried out reflecting decisions made in the current clinical practice. FE models of the implant positioned in varus, valgus, and neutral alignment were then developed and altered to represent five different bone defects according to the Paprosky classification (Type I – Type IIIb). Strain was measured on the femur at 0mm (B1), 40mm (B2), and 80mm (B3) from the lesser trochanter. Results. Cemented constructs had lower strain on the implant neck, and higher overall stiffness and strain on bone compared to uncemented THA. Strain on the bone increased further down the shaft of the femoral diaphysis, and with progressing bone defect severity in all stem alignment cases. Highest strain on the femur was found at B2 in all stem alignment and bone defect models. Varus alignment showed higher overall femoral strain in both fixation methods. Interestingly, in uncemented models, highest strain was shown on femoral bone proximally (B1-B2) in varus alignment, but distally (B3) in neutral alignment. Conclusion. Varus stem alignment showed overall higher strain on femur compared to neutral and valgus. This highlights the crucial role of stem alignment in long term outcomes of THA. Differences between the two stem types should be taken in consideration when interpreting results from this study


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 100-B, Issue SUPP_4 | Pages 48 - 48
1 Apr 2018
Kebbach M Grawe R Geier A Winter E Kluess D Woernle C Bader R
Full Access

Introduction. Despite decades of clinical research in artificial joints and underlying failure mechanisms, systematical and reproducible identification of reasons for complications in total knee replacements (TKR) remains difficult. Due to the complex dynamic interaction of implant system and biological situs, malfunction eventually leading to failure is multifactorial and remains not fully understood. The aim of present study was to evaluate different TKR designs and positions with regard to joint kinematics and stability under dynamic conditions by using a robot-based hardware-in-the-loop (HiL) setup. Material & methods. An industrial 6-axis robot with 6-axis force-torque sensor mounted into its end-effector moved and loaded real, commercially available TKR (bicondylar, cruciate-retaining) that were in virtual interaction with a subject-specific computational multibody model representing the anatomical situs of the knee joint while performing passive seated deep knee flexion. The subject-specific musculoskeletal multibody model (MMB) included rigid bones of the lower right extremity. Bone and cartilage geometries were reconstructed from MRT/ CT data sets preserving anatomical landmarks and allowing for the calculation of inertial properties. M. quadriceps femoris was modeled as single passive tensile force elements. Knee ligaments were modelled as elastic spring elements with a nonlinear force-displacement characteristic. Providing the flexion angle, the robot moved and loaded the mounted femoral implant component with respect to the tibial component while being in continuous interaction with the MMB. Several influencing parameters like implant position (internal/external rotation, varus/valgus alignment) and design (fixed vs. mobile bearing, tibia-insert height) as well as ligament insufficiency and joint loading on joint kinematics and stability was systematically analysed. Results. Improper implant positioning caused joint instability, which was demonstrated in higher magnitudes of the relative kinematics. Negative effects by incorrect implant positioning could be partially compensated by a mobile bearing design. However, this was accompanied with an increase in tibiofemoral contact forces. High correlation of tibia-insert height on ligament and contact force was found. After releasing ligament structures, lower tibiofemoral contact forces and joint opening during deep knee flexion were observed. Conclusion. By means of HiL simulation different clinical and technical parameters of TKR were evaluated in a systematical and reproducible fashion under physiological-like boundary conditions with regard to joint kinematics and stability. The proposed HiL test setup combining robot-based testing with MMBs can contribute to deeper understanding of knee joint function and improvement of total knee implant systems. Acknowledgement. The authors would like to thank the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (grant numbers: WO WO 452/8-1, BA 3347/3-1 and KL 2327/4-1) for supporting the project


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 103-B, Issue SUPP_4 | Pages 23 - 23
1 Mar 2021
Schopper C Zderic I Menze J Muller D Rocci M Knobe M Shoda E Richards G Gueorguiev B Stoffel K
Full Access

Femoral neck fractures account for half of all hip fractures and are recognized as a major public health problem associated with a high socioeconomic burden. Whilst internal fixation is preferred over arthroplasty for physiologically younger patients, no consensus exists about the optimal fixation device yet. The recently introduced implant Femoral Neck System (FNS) (DePuy Synthes, Zuchwil, Switzerland) was developed for dynamic fixation of femoral neck fractures and provides angular stability in combination with a minimally invasive surgical technique. Alternatively, the Hansson Pin System (HPS) (Swemac, Linköping, Sweden) exploits the advantages of internal buttressing. However, the obligate peripheral placement of the pins, adjacent to either the inferior or posterior cortex, renders the instrumentation more challenging. The aim of this study was to evaluate the biomechanical performance of FNS versus HPS in a Pauwels II femoral neck fracture model with simulated posterior comminution. Forty-degree Pauwels II femoral neck fractures AO 31-B2.1 with 15° posterior wedge were simulated in fourteen paired fresh-frozen human cadaveric femora, followed by instrumentation with either FNS or HPS in pair-matched fashion. Implant positioning was quantified by measuring the shortest distances between implant and inferior cortex (DI) as well as posterior cortex (DP) on anteroposterior and axial X-rays, respectively. Biomechanical testing was performed in 20° adduction and 10° flexion of the specimens in a novel setup with simulated iliopsoas muscle tension. Progressively increasing cyclic loading was applied until construct failure. Interfragmentary femoral head-to-shaft movements, namely varus deformation, dorsal tilting and rotation around the neck axis were measured by means of motion tracking and compared between the two implants. In addition, varus deformation and dorsal tilting were correlated with DI and DP. Cycles to 5/10° varus deformation were significantly higher for FNS (22490±5729/23007±5496) versus HPS (16351±4469/17289±4686), P=0.043. Cycles to 5/10° femoral head dorsal tilting (FNS: 10968±3052/12765±3425; HPS: 12244±5895/13357±6104) and cycles to 5/10° rotation around the femoral neck axis (FNS: 15727±7737/24453±5073; HPS: 15682±10414/20185±11065) were comparable between the implants, P≥0.314. For HPS, the outcomes for varus deformation and dorsal tilting correlated significantly with DI and DP, respectively (P=0.025), whereas these correlations were not significant for FNS (P≥0.148). From a biomechanical perspective, by providing superior resistance against varus deformation and performing in a less sensitive way to variations in implant placement, the angular stable Femoral Neck System can be considered as a valid alternative to the Hansson Pin System for the treatment of Pauwels II femoral neck fractures


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 100-B, Issue SUPP_4 | Pages 57 - 57
1 Apr 2018
Hettwer W Petersen M
Full Access

Background. In certain clinical situations, complex local anatomy and limitations of surgical exposure can make adequate and bone tumor ablation, resection and reconstruction very challenging. We wished to review our clinical experience and accuracy achieved with entirely virtually planned single stage tumor ablation/resection and reconstructions. Methods. We report 6 cases of bone tumors in which tumor removal (by radio-frequency (RF) ablation and/or resection) and subsequent reconstruction were based entirely on pre-operative virtual analysis and planning. All interventions were accomplished with specifically designed and pre-operatively manufactured 3D-printed drill & resection guides. Immediate subsequent defect reconstruction was either performed with a precisely matching allograft (n=1) or composite metal implant (n=5) consisting of a defect specific titanium scaffold and multiple integrated fixation features to provide optimal immediate stability as well as subsequent opportunity for osseointegration. We reviewed the sequence of all procedural steps as well as the accuracy of each saw blade or drill trajectory by direct intra-operative measurement, post-operative margin status and virtual comparison of pre- and post-operative CT scans. Results. Intra-operative application/assembly of the resection guides could be accomplished with relative ease in all cases, permitting quick and efficient reproduction of the planned osteotomies as well as RF-probe trajectories with a high degree of accuracy. Histologically all resection margins were negative as planned except in one case where one pelvic resection was extended due to intraoperative concern of possible local tumor progression. All implants could be placed as planned, with post-operative imaging demonstrating satisfactory implant position. Virtual analysis of post-operative CT scans confirmeded minimal deviation of final implant position from the pre-operative plan. Conclusion. Reliable, accurate placement of tumor biopsy/ablation tracts and resection planes and their optimal alignment with respect to critical structures, tumor extent and desired preservation of unaffected bone is the most challenging and time consuming step during the analysis and planning phase. However it is also the crucial step with regard to subsequent design and production of clinically and oncologically meaningful case-specific drill/resection guides and implants. If these prerequisites are met, computer assisted virtual planning along with 3Dprinting-technology can afford high intraoperative accuracy, contribute to increased intra-operative surgeon confidence and decreased operative time


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 96-B, Issue SUPP_11 | Pages 152 - 152
1 Jul 2014
Simons M Riches P
Full Access

Summary Statement. Uptake of robotically-assisted orthopaedic surgery may be limited by a perceived steep learning curve. We quantified the technological learning curve and 5 surgeries were found to bring operating times to appropriate levels. Implant positioning was as planned from the outset. Introduction. Compared to total knee replacement, unicondylar knee replacement (UKR) has been found to reduce recovery time as well as increase patient satisfaction and improve range of motion. However, contradictory evidence together with revision rates concern may have limited the adoption of UKR surgery. Semi-active robotically-assisted orthopaedic tools have been developed to increase the accuracy of implant position and subsequent mechanical femorotibial angle to reduce revision rates. However, the perceived learning curve associated with such systems may cause apprehension among orthopaedic surgeons and reduce the uptake of such technology. To inform this debate, we aimed to quantify the learning curve associated with the technological aspects of the NavioPFS™ (Blue Belt Technologies Inc., Pittsburgh, USA) with regards to both operation time and implant accuracy. Methods. Five junior orthopaedic trainees volunteered for the study following ethical permission. All trainees attended the same initial training session and subsequently each trainee performed 5 UKR surgeries on left-sided synthetic femurs and tibiae (model 1146–2, Sawbones-Pacific Research Laboratories Inc, Vashon, WA, USA). A few days lapsed between surgeries, which were all completed in a two week window. Replica Tornier HLS Uni Evolution femoral and tibial implants (Tornier, France) were implanted without cementation. Each surgery was videoed and timings taken for key operation phases, as well as the overall operative time. A ball point probe with four reflective spherical markers attached was used to record the position of manufactured divots on the implant, which allowed the 3D position of the implant to be compared to the planned position. Absolute translational and rotational deviations from the planned position were analysed. Results. Total surgical time decreased significantly with surgery number (p < 0.001) from an initial average of 85 minutes to 48 minutes after 5 surgeries. All stages, except the cutting tool set up, demonstrated a significant difference in operative time with increasing number of surgeries performed (all p < 0.05) with the cutting phase decreasing from 41 to 23 minutes (p < 0.001). The translational and rotational accuracy of the implants did not significantly vary with surgery number. Discussion and Conclusion. The accuracy in implant position obtained by trainee surgeons on synthetic bones were similar to published data for experienced orthopaedic surgeons on other systems on cadavers. Whilst cadaver operations increase the complexity of operation, this should not theoretically affect the robotic system in preventing innaccurate implantation. Moreover, the fact that this accuracy was obtainable on the first surgery clearly demonstrates the system's ability in ensuring accurate implantation. Five surgeries dramatically reduced the total operative time, and moreover, the trend suggests that more surgeries would further decrease the total operation time. It was not the intention of the study to compare absolute trainee times on synthetic bones to surgeons with cadavers, but the learning curve of the protocol and technology suggests a halving of the operation time after 5 sessions would not be unrealistic


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 99-B, Issue SUPP_2 | Pages 53 - 53
1 Jan 2017
Devivier C Roques A Taylor A Heller M Browne M
Full Access

There is a critical need for safe innovation in total joint replacements to address the demands of an ageing yet increasingly active population. The development of robust implant designs requires consideration of uncertainties including patient related factors such as bone morphology but also activity related loads and the variability in the surgical procedure itself. Here we present an integrated framework considering these sources of variability and its application to assess the performance of the femoral component of a total hip replacement (THR). The framework offers four key features. To consider variability in bone properties, an automated workflow for establishing statistical shape and intensity models (SSIM) was developed. Here, the inherent relationship between shape and bone density is captured and new meshes of the target bone structures are generated with specific morphology and density distributions. The second key feature is a virtual implantation capability including implant positioning, and bone resection. Implant positioning is performed using automatically identified bone features and flexibly defined rules reflecting surgical variability. Bone resection is performed according to manufacturer guidelines. Virtual implantation then occurs through Boolean operations to remove bone elements contained within the implant's volume. The third feature is the automatic application of loads at muscle attachment points or on the joint contact surfaces defined on the SSIM. The magnitude and orientation of the forces are derived from models of similar morphology for a range of activities from a database of musculoskeletal (MS) loads. The connection to this MS loading model allows the intricate link between morphology and muscle forces to be captured. Importantly, this model of the internal forces provides access to the spectrum of loading conditions across a patient population rather than just typical or average values. The final feature is an environment that allows finite element simulations to be run to assess the mechanics of the bone-implant construct and extract results for e.g. bone strains, interface mechanics and implant stresses. Results are automatically processed and mapped in an anatomically consistent manner and can be further exploited to establish surrogate models for efficient subsequent design optimization. To demonstrate the capability of the framework, it has been applied to the femoral component of a THR. An SSIM was created from 102 segmented femurs capturing the heterogeneous bone density distributions. Cementless femoral stems were positioned such that for the optimal implantation the proximal shaft axis of the femurs coincided with the distal stem axis and the position of the native femoral head centre was restored. Here, the resection did not affect the greater trochanter and the implantations were clinically acceptable for 10000 virtual implantations performed to simulate variability in patient morphology and surgical variation. The MS database was established from musculoskeletal analyses run for a cohort of 17 THR subjects obtaining over 100,000 individual samples of 3D muscle and joint forces. An initial analysis of the mechanical performance in 7 bone-implant constructs showed levels of bone strains and implant stresses in general agreement with the literature