The surgical treatment of three- and four-part fractures of the proximal humerus in osteoporotic bone is difficult and there is no consensus as to which technique leads to the best outcome in elderly patients. Between 1998 and 2004 we treated 76 patients aged over 70 years with three- or four-part fractures by percutaneous reduction and internal fixation using the Humerusblock. A displacement of the tuberosity of > 5 mm and an angulation of > 30° of the head fragment were the indications for surgery. Of the patients 50 (51 fractures) were available for follow-up after a mean of 33.8 months (5.8 to 81). The absolute, age-related and side-related Constant scores were recorded. Of the 51 fractures, 46 (90.2%) healed primarily. Re-displacement of fragments or migration of Kirschner wires was seen in five cases. Necrosis of the humeral head developed in four patients. In three patients a secondary arthroplasty had to be performed, in two because of re-displacement and in one for necrosis of the head. There was one case of deep infection which required a further operation and one of delayed healing. The mean Constant score of the patients with a three-part fracture was 61.2 points (35 to 87) which was 84.9% of the score for the non-injured arm. In four-part fractures it was 49.5 points (18 to 87) or 68.5% of the score for the non-injured arm. The Humerusblock technique can provide a comfortable and mobile shoulder in elderly patients and is a satisfactory alternative to replacement and traditional techniques of internal fixation

We used an inverted shoulder arthroplasty in 43 consecutive patients with a mean age of 78 years (65 to 97) who had sustained a three- or four-part fracture of the upper humerus. All except two were reviewed with a mean follow-up of 22 months (6 to 58). The clinical outcome was satisfactory with a mean active anterior elevation of 97° (35° to 160°) and a mean active external rotation in abduction of 30° (0° to 80°). The mean Constant and the mean modified Constant scores were respectively 44 (16 to 69) and 66% (25% to 97%). Complications included three patients with reflex sympathetic dystrophy, five with neurological complications, most of which resolved, and one with an anterior dislocation. Radiography showed peri-prosthetic calcification in 36 patients (90%), displacement of the tuberosities in 19 (53%) and a scapular notch in ten (25%). Compared with conventional hemiarthroplasty, satisfactory mobility was obtained despite frequent migration of the tuberosities. However, long-term results are required before reverse shoulder arthroplasty can be recommended as a routine procedure in complex fractures of the upper humerus in the elderly

Four-part fractures of the upper end of the humerus are uncommon injuries and there is still dispute about the best form of management. A retrospective study of 32 patients with these injuries has shown that non-operative management is frequently followed by persistent pain, stiffness and dysfunction of the shoulder. A prospective study of 49 patients with this injury presenting at the Bristol Royal Infirmary has shown that reconstruction of the upper end of the humerus with insertion of a Neer prosthesis will usually restore comfort and function. Whichever regimen is employed, disability is prolonged and dedicated physiotherapy is essential in their management

Prosthetic replacement of the humeral head for fracture remains an operative challenge to even the most experienced orthopaedic surgeon. Although most fractures of the proximal humerus are minimally displaced and treated conservatively, more complex fractures require operative intervention. In this respect, the four-part proximal humerus fracture and fracture-dislocation have been difficult to evaluate and manage. Results from conservative treatment have been consistently unsatisfactory while results from surgery have been more variable with some series reporting satisfactory results. Treatment options for four-part fractures and fracturedislocations of the proximal humerus fractures include non-operative management, open reduction internal fixation, and humeral head replacement. Because of the poor results with non-operative, resection arthroplasty, and internal fixation, Neer in 1951 introduced prosthetic arthroplasty with tuberosity reconstruction for these complex fractures. Many reports in the literature have documented the successful results of this procedure. In our series of 65 shoulders there were 82% satisfactory results, 97% pain relief, and 85% good functional results. Therefore, prosthetic replacement of acute displaced fractures is technically demanding but offers a predictive result of a pain-free shoulder and functional motion through aggressive rehabilitation. Our goals in this video are to provide stepwise, comprehensive information on the techniques and guidelines for humeral head replacement in the treatment of complex proximal humerus fractures. Careful preoperative planning, patient evaluation, imaging, meticulous operative techniques, and a closely supervised rehabilitation program are necessary to produce a successful functional shoulder after prosthetic reconstruction

Controversy surrounds the management of displaced three- and four-part fractures of the proximal humerus. The percutaneous Resch technique of stabilisation involves minimal soft-tissue dissection and a reduced risk of stiffness and avascular necrosis. However, it requires a second operation to remove Kirschner wires and the humeral block. We describe a modification of this technique that dispenses with the need for this second operation and relies on a sequential pattern of screw placement. We report the outcome of 32 three- or four-part fractures of the proximal humerus treated in this way at a mean follow-up of 3.8 years (2 to 8)). There were 14 men and 18 women with a mean age of 56 years (28 to 83). At final follow-up the mean Oxford shoulder scores were 38 (31 to 44) and 39 (31 to 42), and the mean Constant scores were 79 (65 to 92) and 72 (70 to 80) for three- and four-part fractures, respectively. We further analysed the results in patients aged < 60 years with high-energy fractures and those aged ≥ 60 years with osteoporotic fractures. There were no cases of nonunion or avascular necrosis. The results were good and comparable to those previously reported for the Resch technique and other means of fixation for proximal humeral fractures. We would recommend this modification of the technique for the treatment of displaced three-part and four-part fractures in patients both younger and older than 60 years of age

Secure fixation of displaced proximal fractures of the humerus is a challenging problem. A total of 32 patients with acutely displaced three- or four-part proximal fractures of the humerus were treated by open reduction and internal fixation using the proximal humeral internal locking system (PHILOS) plate. There were 23 women and nine men with a mean age of 59.9 years (18 to 87). Data were collected prospectively and the outcomes were assessed using the Constant score. The mean follow-up was for 11 months (3 to 24). In 31 patients (97%) the fracture united clinically and radiologically at a mean of 10 weeks (8 to 24). The mean Constant score at final review was 66.5 (30 to 92). There was no significant difference in outcome when comparing patients aged more than 60 years (18 patients) with those aged less than 60 years (14 patients) (t-test, p = 0.8443). There was one case each of nonunion, malunion and a broken screw in the elderly population. This plate provides an alternative method of fixation for fractures of the proximal humerus. It provides a stable fixation in young patients with good-quality bone sufficient to permit early mobilisation. Failure of the screws to maintain fixation in the elderly remains a problem

Introduction and Aims: The purpose of this study was to evaluate the effect on movement under load of different techniques of reattachment of the humeral tuberosities following four-part proximal humeral fracture. Method: Biomechanical test sawbones were used. Four-part fracture was simulated and a cemented Neer3 prosthesis inserted. Three different techniques of reattachment of the tuberosities were used: 1) tuberosities attached to the shaft, and to each other through the lateral fins in the prosthesis with one cerclage suture through the anterior hole in the prosthesis; 2) as one without cerclage suture; 3) tuberosities attached to the prosthesis and to the shaft. All methods used a number five ethibond suture. Both tuberosities and the shaft had multiple markers attached. Two digital cameras formed an orthogonal photogrammetric system, allowing all segments to be tracked in a 3-D axis system. Humeri were incrementally loaded in abduction using an Instron machine, to a minimum 1200N, and sequential photographs taken. Photographic data was analysed to give 3-D linear and angular motions of all segments with respect to the anatomically relevant humeral axis, allowing intertuberosity and tuberosity-shaft displacement to be measured. Results: Techniques one and two were the most stable constructs with technique three, allowing greater separation of fragments and angular movement. True inter-tuberosity separation at the midpoint of the tuberosities was significantly greater using technique three (p< 0.05). The cerclage suture used in technique two added no further stability to the fixation. Conclusion: Our model suggests that the most effective and simplest technique of reattachment involves suturing the tuberosities to each other, as well as to the shaft of the humerus. The cerclage suture appears to add little to the fixation in abduction, although the literature would suggest it may have a role in resisting rotatory movements

Introduction: The three or four-part fracture of the proximal humerus remains a challenging fracture in the case of elderly patient. In this continuing prospective study we compared the outcome after implantation of a shoulder hemiprosthesis of the anatomical generation and a reversed prosthesis. Material and methods: 34 shoulder prosthesis were implanted in patients older than 70 between june 1996 and june 2004. All patients were evaluated by a surgeon not involved in treatment concerning activities of daily living (DASH scoring), clinical outcome (Constant-Murley Score), radiological results, and a summary of complications. Group 1: anatomical prosthesis (Tornier): At an average follow-up of 16,5 (range 6–55) months, 13/17 patients with an average age of 78,6 years (70–95), were evaluated. Group 2: reversed prosthesis (Depuy): At an average follow-up of 12,6 (range 6–18) months, 13/17 patients with an average age of 77,1 years (70–84), were evaluated. In this group functional treatment was started immediately after surgery. Results: concerning age, follow up and dash scoring there were no difference between two groups. In reversed group : the outcome was better (Constant-Murley: 79,5 (57,8–100) vs 57,1 (21–85) p=0.005), the average active elevation was better by 30° (p< 0.001) and the average active abduction was better by 53° (p< 0.001). 7/13 cases of glenoid notching stage 2 or 3 were noted. In anatomical group : the average active external rotation was better by 10° (p=0.01). Tubercle fixations failed in 6/13 cases. Discussion: No comparative study has still been published between the two sort of implant in elderly patients. Our results of shoulder arthroplasty in acute injury to the proximal humerus with reversed prosthesis are in agreement with the preliminary results reported by Sirveau. At short follow up, reversed prosthesis allow to reach early mobilisation with best functional results. Rotation remains the key point : with a significant gain in active abduction and elevation the reversed prosthesis group do not reach a better dash scoring. Attachment fixation of the posterior rotator cuff must probably be discussed in reversed prosthesis in acute fracture

Introduction: The three or four-part fracture of the proximal humerus remains a challenging fracture in the case of elderly patient. In this continuing prospective study we compared the outcome after implantation of a shoulder hemiprosthesis of the anatomical generation and a reversed prosthesis. Material and Methods: 34 shoulder prosthesis were implanted in patients older than 70 between june 1996 and june 2004. All patients were evaluated by a surgeon not involved in treatment concerning activities of daily living (DASH scoring), clinical outcome (Constant-Murley Score), radiological results, and a summary of complications. Group 1: anatomical prosthesis (Tornier): At an average follow-up of 16,5 (range 6–55) months, 13/17 patients with an average age of 78,6 years (70–95), were evaluated. Group 2: reversed prosthesis (Depuy): At an average follow-up of 12,6 (range 6–18) months, 13/17 patients with an average age of 77,1 years (70–84), were evaluated. In this group functional treatment was started immediately after surgery. Results: concerning age, follow up and dash scoring there were no difference between two groups. In reversed group: the outcome was better (Constant-Murley: 79,5 (57,8–100) vs 57,1 (21–85) p=0.005), the average active elevation was better by 30° (p< 0.001) and the average active abduction was better by 53° (p< 0.001). 7/13 cases of glenoid notching stage 2 or 3 were noted. In anatomical group: the average active external rotation was better by 10° (p=0.01). Tubercle fixation’s failed in 6/13 cases. Discussion: No comparative study has still been published between the two sort of implant in elderly patients. Our results of shoulder arthroplasty in acute injury to the proximal humerus with reversed prosthesis are in agreement with the preliminary results reported by Sirveau. At short follow up, reversed prosthesis allow to reach early mobilisation with best functional results. Rotation remains the key point: with a significant gain in active abduction and elevation the reversed prosthesis group do not reach a better dash scoring. Attachment fixation of the posterior rotator cuff must probably be discussed in reversed prosthesis in acute fracture

Abstract

This study evaluated the effect on movement under load of three different techniques for re-attachment of the tuberosities of the humerus using test sawbones. In the first, the tuberosities were attached both to the shaft and to each other, with one cerclage suture through the anterior hole in the prosthesis. The second technique was identical except for omission of the cerclage suture and in the third the tuberosities were attached to the prosthesis and to the shaft. An orthogonal photogrammetric system allowed all segments to be tracked in a 3D axis system. The humeri were incrementally-loaded in abduction, and the 3D linear and angular movements of all segments were calculated. Displacement between the tuberosities and the shaft was measured.

The first and second techniques were the most stable constructs, with the third allowing greater separation of fragments and angular movement. Separation at the midpoint of the tuberosities was significantly greater using the latter technique (p < 0.05). The cerclage suture added no further stability to the fixation.

The results of proximal humeral replacement following trauma are substantially worse than for osteoarthritis or rheumatoid arthritis. The stable reattachment of the lesser and greater tuberosity fragments to the rotator cuff and the restoration of shoulder biomechanics are difficult. In 1992 we developed a prosthesis designed to improve fixation of the tuberosity fragments in comminuted fractures of the proximal humerus. The implant enables fixation of the fragments to the shaft of the prosthesis and the diaphyseal fragment using screws, washers and a special toothed plate. Between 1992 and 2003 we used this technique in 50 of 76 patients referred to our institution for shoulder reconstruction after trauma. In the remaining 26, reconstruction with a prosthesis and nonabsorbable sutures was performed, as the tuberosity fragments were too small and too severely damaged to allow the use of screws and the toothed plate.

The Constant score two years post-operatively was a mean of 12 points better in the acute trauma group and 11 points better in the late post-traumatic group than in the classical suture group.

We recommend this technique in patients where the tuberosity fragments are large enough to allow fixation with screws, washers and a toothed plate.

Age is the most accurate surrogate for bone density and poor bone density is the reason for many fracture repairs to fail. Hemiarthroplasty has demonstrated consistently inconsistent results in terms for restoration of function. Most recently, with the evolution of reverse prostheses, prospective studies which are, in many cases, randomised and Level 2, have clearly shown reverse prostheses to be the most consistently reliable treatment in the patient noted above. It is with a high degree of certainty that we can inform such a patient that their function will be restored and their pain minimal with such treatment.

Management of 4-part fractures of the proximal humerus continues to challenge orthopaedic surgeons, shoulder surgeons, and trauma surgeons. Truly displaced 4-part fractures typically require surgery if the patient is medically able to undergo a surgical procedure. However, outcomes following surgery are not always as predictable as we would like. Results following hemiarthroplasty have led to more predictable pain relief than predictable functional recovery relying exclusively on the fate of tuberosity healing. Tuberosity healing failure leads to nearly universal catastrophic results with pain, dysfunction, and pseudoparalysis. Furthermore, conversion of failed hemiarthroplasty to reverse total shoulder arthroplasty leads to the highest incidence of complications and poorest outcomes of all groups of patients undergoing reverse total shoulder replacement. This is countered by the knowledge that if tuberosity healing occurs the outcome can be reliable with regard to pain relief and functional restoration.

Reverse total shoulder arthroplasty, on the other hand, has emerged as a preferred surgical option for many surgeons due to the issues following hemiarthroplasty. The increased prevalence of RTSA for the management of 4-part fractures has come without overwhelming evidence that outcomes are superior especially in light of the increased cost, life-time weight bearing restrictions, and uncertain long-term durability. Long-term follow-up of patients treated with RTSA for 4-part fracture has shown concerning degradation of function and outcomes and remains a valid concern about the long-term durability. We must remain diligent therefore in continuing to better understand which fractures should be treated non-operatively and those that may be amenable to anatomic hemiarthroplasty and finally those which may be better served by using a reverse total shoulder replacement.

Abstract. Reverse shoulder arthroplasty (RSA) is being increasingly used for complex, displaced fractures of the proximal humerus. The main goal of the current study was to evaluate the functional and radiographic results after primary RSA of three or four-part fractures of the proximal humerus in elderly patients. Between 2012 and 2020, 70 consecutive patients with a recent three- or four-part fracture of the proximal humerus were treated with an RSA. There were 41 women and 29 men, with a mean age of 76 years. The dominant arm was involved in 42 patients (60%). All surgeries were carried out within 21 days. Displaced three-part fracture sustained in 16 patients, 24 had fracture dislocation and 30 sustained a four-part fracture of the proximal humerus. Patients were followed up for a mean of 26 months. The mean postoperative OSS at the end of the follow-up period was 32.4. The mean DASH score was 44.3. Tuberosity non-union occurred in 18 patients (12.6%), malunion in 7 patients (4.9%), heterotopic ossification in 4 patients (2.8%) and scapular notching in one patient. Anatomical reconstruction was achieved in 25 patients (17.5%), the influence of greater tuberosity healing on shoulder function could not be demonstrated. Heterotopic ossification seems to affect OSS and QDASH, we found statistically significant relation between HO and clinical outcomes. Patients with heterotopic ossification had significantly lower postoperative scores on DASH and OSS (P = .0527). Despite expecting good functional outcome with low complication rate after RSA, the functional outcome was irrespective of healing of the tuberosities

Aim: To evaluate the radiographs of proximal humeral fractures in an attempt to define a diagnostic sign as a predictor of four-part fracture. Diagnostic sign: The normal humeral head articular surface points towards the glenoid. We describe our ‘sunset’ sign as ‘articular surface of humeral head pointing away from the glenoid and tilted upwards, in the presence of a displaced greater tuberosity fracture’. We postulate that a patient with proximal humerus fracture showing this sign has four-part fracture until proved otherwise. Materials and Methods: Between 2002 and 2006, 80 consecutive patients underwent open reduction and internal fixation of their proximal humeral fractures in our Shoulder unit. We reviewed their preoperative radiographs and operative notes retrospectively. 79 patients were included in the study as one patient’s pre-operative radiograph was not available. The AP radiograph was evaluated independently by three observers who were blinded to the identity of the patients and their operative diagnosis. The presence of ‘sunset’ sign was recorded. There was 90% inter-observer agreement. In the remaining 10%, a consensus review was performed as to the presence of sign for evaluation purpose. The findings were then correlated with the operative findings to confirm whether they were four-part fractures or not. With 95% confidence interval we calculated the sensitivity, specificity, and positive and negative predictive values for our diagnostic sign. Results: 30 out of 79 patients displayed ‘sunset’sign in their preoperative radiograph. Of these 28 had confirmed four-part fractures operatively. The positive predictive value of ‘sunset’ sign in diagnosis the four-part fracture was 93%. The specificity and sensitivity were 95% and 78% respectively. The sensitivity was affected by 8 patients with four part fractures with displaced articular head fragment which had dropped either medially or posteriorly. Conclusion: Our results suggest that in patients with proximal humeral fractures, the presence of ‘sunset’sign in the anteroposterior radiograph is a reliable indicator of four-part fracture

Introduction. There is considerable uncertainty about the optimal treatment of displaced four-part fractures of the proximal humerus. Within the last decade locking plate technology has been considered a breakthrough in the treatment of these complex injuries. Methods. We systematically identified and reviewed clinical studies of the benefits and harms after osteosynthesis with locking plates in displaced four-part fractures. Results. We included fourteen studies with 374 four-part fractures. There were no randomised trials, one prospective observational comparative study, three retrospective observational comparative studies, and ten case series. Small studies with a high risk of bias precluded reliable estimates of functional outcome. Unexpected high rates of complications (range 16% to 64%) and re-operations (range 11% to 27%) were reported. Conclusion. The empirical foundation for the clinical value of locking plates in displaced four-part fractures of the proximal humerus is very sketchy. We emphasise the need for well conducted randomised trials and observational studies

Aim: To evaluate the radiographs of proximal humeral fractures in an attempt to define a diagnostic sign as a predictor of four-part fracture. Diagnostic sign The normal humeral head articular surface points towards the glenoid. We describe our ‘sunset’ sign as ‘articular surface of humeral head pointing away from the glenoid and tilted upwards, in the presence of a displaced greater tuberosity fracture’. We postulate that a patient with proximal humerus fracture showing this sign has four-part fracture until proved otherwise. Materials and Methods: Between 2002 and 2006, 80 consecutive patients underwent open reduction and internal fixation of their proximal humeral fractures in our Shoulder unit. We reviewed their preoperative radiographs and operative notes retrospectively. The AP radiograph was evaluated independently by three observers who were blinded to the operative diagnosis. The presence of ‘sunset’ sign was recorded. A consensus review was performed for evaluation purpose. The findings were then correlated with the operative findings. With 95% confidence interval we calculated the sensitivity, specificity, and positive and negative predictive values for our diagnostic sign. Results: Thirty patients displayed ‘sunset’sign in their radiograph. Of these 28 had confirmed four-part fractures operatively. The positive predictive value of ‘sunset’ sign in diagnosis of four-part fracture was 93%. The specificity and sensitivity were 95% and 78% respectively. The sensitivity was affected by 8 patients with four part fractures with displaced articular head fragment which had dropped either medially or posteriorly. There were substantial interobserver and intraobserver agreement as measured by kappa coefficient (0.62 and 0.70). Conclusion: Our results suggest that in patients with proximal humeral fractures, the presence of ‘sunset’sign in the anteroposterior radiograph is a reliable indicator of four-part fracture

Objectives. The objective of this study was to perform a meta-analysis of all randomised controlled trials (RCTs) comparing surgical and non-surgical management of fractures of the proximal humerus, and to determine whether further analyses based on complexity of fracture, or the type of surgical intervention, produced disparate findings on patient outcomes. Methods. A systematic review of the literature was performed identifying all RCTs that compared surgical and non-surgical management of fractures of the proximal humerus. Meta-analysis of clinical outcomes was performed where possible. Subgroup analysis based on the type of fracture, and a sensitivity analysis based on the type of surgical intervention, were also performed. Results. Seven studies including 528 patients were included. The overall meta-analysis found that there was no difference in clinical outcomes. However, subgroup and sensitivity analyses found improved patient outcomes for more complex fractures managed surgically. Four-part fractures that underwent surgery had improved long-term health utility scores (mean difference, MD 95% CI 0.04 to 0.28; p = 0.007). They were also less likely to result in osteoarthritis, osteonecrosis and non/malunion (OR 7.38, 95% CI 1.97 to 27.60; p = 0.003). Another significant subgroup finding was that secondary surgery was more common for patients that underwent internal fixation compared with conservative management within the studies with predominantly three-part fractures (OR 0.15, 95% CI 0.04 to 0.63; p = 0.009). Conclusion. This meta-analysis has demonstrated that differences in the type of fracture and surgical treatment result in outcomes that are distinct from those generated from analysis of all types of fracture and surgical treatments grouped together. This has important implications for clinical decision making and should highlight the need for future trials to adopt more specific inclusion criteria. Cite this article: S. Sabharwal, N. K. Patel, D. Griffiths, T. Athanasiou, C. M. Gupte, P. Reilly. Trials based on specific fracture configuration and surgical procedures likely to be more relevant for decision making in the management of fractures of the proximal humerus: Findings of a meta-analysisBone Joint Res 2016;5:470–480. DOI: 10.1302/2046-3758.510.2000638