FOUR PART PROXIMAL HUMERAL FRACTURES: DIAGNOSIS WITH THE SUNSET SIGN ON ANTEROPOSTERIOR RADIOGRAPH

Abstract

Aim: To evaluate the radiographs of proximal humeral fractures in an attempt to define a diagnostic sign as a predictor of four-part fracture.

Diagnostic sign: The normal humeral head articular surface points towards the glenoid. We describe our ‘sunset’ sign as ‘articular surface of humeral head pointing away from the glenoid and tilted upwards, in the presence of a displaced greater tuberosity fracture’. We postulate that a patient with proximal humerus fracture showing this sign has four-part fracture until proved otherwise.

Materials and Methods: Between 2002 and 2006, 80 consecutive patients underwent open reduction and internal fixation of their proximal humeral fractures in our Shoulder unit. We reviewed their preoperative radiographs and operative notes retrospectively. 79 patients were included in the study as one patient’s pre-operative radiograph was not available.

The AP radiograph was evaluated independently by three observers who were blinded to the identity of the patients and their operative diagnosis. The presence of ‘sunset’ sign was recorded. There was 90% inter-observer agreement. In the remaining 10%, a consensus review was performed as to the presence of sign for evaluation purpose. The findings were then correlated with the operative findings to confirm whether they were four-part fractures or not. With 95% confidence interval we calculated the sensitivity, specificity, and positive and negative predictive values for our diagnostic sign.

Results: 30 out of 79 patients displayed ‘sunset’sign in their preoperative radiograph. Of these 28 had confirmed four-part fractures operatively. The positive predictive value of ‘sunset’ sign in diagnosis the four-part fracture was 93%. The specificity and sensitivity were 95% and 78% respectively. The sensitivity was affected by 8 patients with four part fractures with displaced articular head fragment which had dropped either medially or posteriorly.

Conclusion: Our results suggest that in patients with proximal humeral fractures, the presence of ‘sunset’sign in the anteroposterior radiograph is a reliable indicator of four-part fracture.