There is some evidence to suggest that outcomes of THA in patients with minimal radiographic osteoarthritis may not be associated with predictable outcomes. The aim of this study was to: Assess the outcome of patients with hip pain who underwent THA with no or minimal radiographic signs of osteoarthritis, Identify patient comorbidities and multiplanar imaging findings which are predictive of outcome, Compare the outcome in these patients to the expected outcome of THA in hip OA. A retrospective review of 107 hips (102 patients, 90F:12M, median age 40.6, IQR 35.1–45.8 years, range 18–73) were included for analysis. Plain radiographs were evaluated using the Tonnis grading scale of hip OA. Outcome measures were all-cause revision; iHOT12; EQ-5D; Oxford Hip Score; UCLA Activity Scale; and whether THA had resulted in the patient's hip pain and function being Better/Same/Worse. The median Oxford Hip Score was 33.3 (IQR 13.9, range 13–48), and 36/107 (33.6%) hips achieved an OHS≥42. There was no association between primary hip diagnosis and post-operative PROMs. A total of 91 of the 102 patients (89.2%, 93 hips) reported that their hip pain and function was Better than prior to THA and would have the surgery again, 7 patients (6.8%, 10 hips) felt the Same, and 4 patients (3.9%, 4 hips) felt Worse and would not have the surgery again. Younger patients undergoing total hip arthroplasty with no or minimal radiographic osteoarthritis had lower postoperative Oxford Hip Scores than the general population; though most felt symptomatically better and knowing what they know now, would have surgery again. Those with chronic pain syndrome or hypermobility were likely to benefit less. Those with subchondral cysts or joint space narrowing on CT imaging were more likely to achieve higher functional scores and satisfaction.
The aim of this study is to evaluate whether acetabular retroversion (AR) represents a structural anatomical abnormality of the pelvis or is a functional phenomenon of pelvic positioning in the sagittal plane, and to what extent the changes that result from patient-specific functional position affect the extent of AR. A comparative radiological study of 19 patients (38 hips) with AR were compared with a control group of 30 asymptomatic patients (60 hips). CT scans were corrected for rotation in the axial and coronal planes, and the sagittal plane was then aligned to the anterior pelvic plane. External rotation of the hemipelvis was assessed using the superior iliac wing and inferior iliac wing angles as well as quadrilateral plate angles, and correlated with cranial and central acetabular version. Sagittal anatomical parameters were also measured and correlated to version measurements. In 12 AR patients (24 hips), the axial measurements were repeated after matching sagittal pelvic rotation with standing and supine anteroposterior radiographs.Aims
Methods
Acetabular retroversion (ARV) is a cause of femoroacetabular impingement leading to hip pain and reduced range of motion. We aimed to describe the radiological criteria used for diagnosing ARV in the literature and report on the outcomes of periacetabular osteotomy (PAO) and hip arthroscopy (HA) in its management. A systematic review using PRISMA guidelines was conducted on the MEDLINE, CINAHL, EMBASE, COCHRANE database in December 2022. English-language studies reporting outcomes of PAO, or open or arthroscopic interventions for ARV were included. From an initial 4203 studies, 21 non-randomised studies met the inclusion criteria. Eleven studies evaluated HA for ARV, with average follow-up ranging from 1 to 5 years, for a cumulative number of 996 patients. Only 3/11 studies identified ARV using AP standardized pelvic radiographs. The most frequent signs describing ARV identified were: Ischial Spine Sign (98% of patients), Posterior Wall Sign (PWS, 94%) and Crossover Sign (COS, 64%); with mean Acetabular Retroversion Index (ARI) ranging from 33% to 35%. 39% of HA patients had all three radiographic signs. Clinically significant outcomes were reached by 33–78% of patients. Eight studies evaluated PAO for ARV, with a follow-up ranging from 2 to 10 years, for a cumulative number of 379 patients. Five of the eight studies identified ARV using standardized radiographs. ISS, COS and PWS were positive in 54%, 97% and 81% of patients, respectively with 52% of PAO patients having all three radiographic signs. Mean ARI ranged from 36–41%. Clinically significant results were reported in 71%–78% of patients. The diagnostic criteria for ARV is poorly defined in the literature, and the quality of evidence is low. Studies on HA are more likely to have used lenient diagnostic criteria. It remains difficult to recommend which cases maybe more suitable for treatment by HA rather than PAO.
Periacetabular osteotomy (PAO) is an established treatment for developmental hip dysplasia (DDH) in young adults and can also be utilised in the management of femoroacetabular impingement (FAI) with acetabular retroversion. This study used a national registry to assess the outcomes of PAO for DDH and FAI. PAOs recorded in the UK Non-Arthroplasty Hip Registry between 2012 and November 2022 were identified along with recorded patient and surgical characteristics. Cases were grouped according to the primary pathology (DDH or FAI). Patient reported outcome measures (PROMs) captured included the International Hip Outcome Tool (iHOT)-12 (primary outcome) and the EuroQol-5 Dimensions (EQ-5D) index preoperatively and at 6 months, 1, 2, and 5 years post-operatively. 1,087 PAOs were identified; 995 for DDH (91%), 98 for FAI (9%). Most patients (91%) were female. The DDH group were significantly older (mean 31.7 years) than the FAI group (25.4 years) but had similar body mass index (mean 25.7kg/m2). Overall, significant (all p<0.0001) iHOT-12 and EQ-5D improvement (delta) vs baseline pre-operative scores were achieved at 6 months (mean iHOT-12 improvement +27.4 (95%CI 25.3 to 29.5); n=515) and maintained out to 5 years (+30.0 (21.4 to 38.6); n=44 [9.8% of those eligible for follow-up at 5 years]), at which point 71% and 55% of patients continued to demonstrate a score improvement greater than or equal to the minimum clinically important difference (≥13 points) and substantial clinical benefit (≥28 points) for iHOT-12 respectively. This study demonstrates excellent functional outcomes following PAO undertaken for DDH and FAI in the short to medium term in a large national registry.
Acetabular retroversion is a recognised cause of hip impingement. Pelvic tilt influences acetabular orientation and is known to change in different functional positions. While previously reported in patients with developmental dysplasia of the hip, positional changes in pelvic tilt have not been studied in patients with acetabular retroversion. We retrospectively analysed supine and standing AP pelvic radiographs in 22 patients with preoperative radiographs and 47 with post-operative radiographs treated for symptomatic acetabular retroversion. Measurements were made for acetabular index (AI), lateral centre-edge angle (LCEA), crossover index, ischial spine sign, and posterior wall sign. The change in pelvic tilt angle was measured both by the Sacro-Femoral-Pubic (SFP) angle and the Pubic Symphysis to Sacro-iliac (PS-SI) Index. In the supine position, the mean calculated pelvic tilt angle (by SFP) was 1.05° which changed on standing to a pelvic tilt of 8.64°. A significant increase in posterior pelvic tilt angle from supine to standing of 7.59° (SFP angle) and 5.89° (PS –SI index) was calculated (p<0.001;paired t-test). There was a good correlation in pelvic tilt change between measurements using SFP angle and PS-SI index (rho .901 in pre-op group, rho .815 in post-op group). Signs of retroversion were significantly reduced in standing x-rays compared to supine: Crossover index (0.16 vs 0.38; p<0.001) crossover sign (19/28 vs 28/28 hips; p<0.001), ischial spine sign (10/28 hips vs 26/28 hips; p<0.001) and posterior wall sign (12/28 vs 24/28 hips; p<0.001). Posterior pelvic tilt increased from supine to standing in patients with symptomatic acetabular retroversion, in keeping with previous studies of pelvic tilt change in patients with hip dysplasia. The features of acetabular retroversion were much less evident on standing radiographs. The low pelvic tilt angle in the supine position is implicated in the appearance of acetabular retroversion in the supine position. Patients presenting with symptoms of hip impingement should be assessed by supine and standing pelvic radiographs so as not to miss signs of retroversion and to assist with optimising acetabular correction at the time of surgery.
The lateral centre-edge angle (LCEA) is a plain radiological measure of superolateral cover of the femoral head. This study aims to establish the correlation between 2D radiological and 3D CT measurements of acetabular morphology, and to describe the relationship between LCEA and femoral head cover (FHC). This retrospective study included 353 periacetabular osteotomies (PAOs) performed between January 2014 and December 2017. Overall, 97 hips in 75 patients had 3D analysis by Clinical Graphics, giving measurements for LCEA, acetabular index (AI), and FHC. Roentgenographical LCEA, AI, posterior wall index (PWI), and anterior wall index (AWI) were measured from supine AP pelvis radiographs. The correlation between CT and roentgenographical measurements was calculated. Sequential multiple linear regression was performed to determine the relationship between roentgenographical measurements and CT FHC.Aims
Methods
Acetabular retroversion is a recognised cause of hip impingement. Pelvic tilt influences acetabular orientation and is known to change in different functional positions. While previously reported in patients with developmental dysplasia of the hip, positional changes in pelvic tilt have not been studied in patients with acetabular retroversion. We retrospectively analysed supine and standing AP pelvic radiographs in 22 patients with preoperative radiographs and 47 with post-operative radiographs treated for symptomatic acetabular retroversion. Measurements were made for acetabular index (AI), lateral centre-edge angle (LCEA), crossover index, ischial spine sign, and posterior wall sign. The change in pelvic tilt angle was measured both by the Sacro-Femoral-Pubic (SFP) angle and the Pubic Symphysis to Sacro-iliac (PS-SI) Index. In the supine position, the mean calculated pelvic tilt angle (by SFP) was 1.05° which changed on standing to a pelvic tilt of 8.64°. A significant increase in posterior pelvic tilt angle from supine to standing of 7.59° (SFP angle) and 5.89° (PS –SI index) was calculated (p<0.001;paired t-test). The mean pelvic tilt change of 6.51° measured on post-operative Xrays was not significantly different (p=.650). There was a good correlation in pelvic tilt change between measurements using SFP angle and PS-SI index (rho .901 in pre-op group, rho .815 in post-op group). Signs of retroversion were significantly reduced in standing x-rays compared to supine: Crossover index (0.16 vs 0.38; p<0.001) crossover sign (19/28 vs 28/28 hips; p<0.001), ischial spine sign (10/28 hips vs 26/28 hips; p<0.001) and posterior wall sign (12/28 vs 24/28 hips; p<0.001). Posterior pelvic tilt increased from supine to standing in patients with symptomatic acetabular retroversion, in keeping with previous studies of pelvic tilt change in patients with hip dysplasia. The features of acetabular retroversion were much less evident on standing radiographs. The low pelvic tilt angle in the supine position is implicated in the appearance of acetabular retroversion in the supine position. Patients presenting with symptoms of hip impingement should be assessed by supine and standing pelvic radiographs so as not to miss signs of retroversion and to assist with optimising acetabular correction at the time of surgery.
Pelvic re-orientation osteotomy is a well-recognised treatment of young adults with developmental dysplasia of the hip (DDH). The most commonly used technique is the periacetabular osteotomy (PAO), however, some surgeons favour a triple osteotomy. These techniques can also be utilised for acetabular retroversion leading to FAI. Despite the published literature on these techniques, the authors note a scarcity of evidence looking at patient reported outcome measures (PROMs) for these procedures. This was a retrospective analysis of prospectively collected data utilising the UK NAHR. All patients who underwent pelvic osteotomy from January 2012 to November 2019 were identified from the NAHR database. Patients who consented to data collection received EQ-5D index and iHOT-12 questionnaires, with scores being collected pre-operatively and at 6, 12 and 24 months post-operatively. Nine hundred and eleven (911) patients were identified with twenty-seven (27) undergoing a triple osteotomy, the remaining patients underwent PAO. Mean age was 30.6 (15–56) years and 90% of patients were female. Seventy-nine (79) (8.7%) of patients had the procedure for acetabular retroversion leading to FAI Statistical analysis, of all patients, showed significant improvement (p<0.001) for; iHOT-12 scores (+28 at 6-months, +33.8 at 12-months and +29.9 at 24-months) Similarly there was significant improvement (p<0.001) in EQ-5D index (+0.172 at 6-months, +0.187 at 12-months and +0.166 at 24-months) Pre-operatively, and at each follow-up time-period, raw scores were significantly better in the DDH group compared to the FAI group (p<0.05); however, the improvement in scores was similar for both groups. For both scoring measures, univariable and multivariable linear regression showed poorer pre-operative scores to be strongly significant predictors of greater post-operative improvement at 6 and 12 months (p<0.0001). This study shows that pelvic osteotomy is a successful treatment for DDH and FAI, with the majority of patients achieving significant improvement in outcome scores which are maintained up to 24 months post-operatively. The patients with FAI have significantly reduced raw scores preoperatively and, perhaps, are functionally more limited.Conclusions/Discussion
Spinopelvic parameters are associated with the development of symptomatic femoroacetabular impingement and subsequent osteoarthritis. Pelvic incidence (PI) characterizes the sagittal profile of the pelvis and is important in the regulation of both lumbar lordosis and pelvic orientation (i.e. tilt). The purpose of this imaging-based study was to test the association between PI and acetabular morphology. Measurements of the pelvis and acetabulum were performed for 96 control patients and 29 hip dysplasia patients using 3D-computed topography (3D-CT) scans. Using previously validated measurements the articular cartilage and cotyloid fossa area of the acetabulum, functional acetabular version/inclination, acetabular depth, pelvic tilt, sacral slope, and PI were calculated. Non-parametric statistical tests were used; significance was set at p<0.05.Purpose
Methods
Acetabular dysplasia (AD) can cause hip pain and early osteoarthritis. Lateral Centre Edge Angle (LCEA) and sourcil angle (AI) are plain radiographic measures of acetabular morphology, however there is little agreement as to what constitutes mild, moderate or severe dysplasia. This study aims to establish the correlation, if any, between two-dimensional (XR) and three-dimensional (CT) measurements of acetabular morphology and to establish the level of femoral head cover (CTFHC) for different levels of dysplasia. Governance board approved retrospective study. 353 PAOs performed by the senior author between January 2014 and December 2017 were included. Exclusion criteria were inadequate pre-operative CT imaging and/or plain radiographs, previous pelvic/hip surgery, acetabular retroversion, or femoral head asphericity. Of the remainder, 84 had 3D analysis by clinical graphics giving measurements for CTFHC, LCEA at 1100, 1200, 1300 and sourcil angle (AI). XRLCEA, AI, posterior wall index (PWI), and anterior wall index (AWI), were measured from supine AP pelvis radiographs. Pearson correlation coefficient, and mean CTFHC for stratified LCEAs were calculated. A linear regression model to predict CTFHC from XRLCEA was validated against these. XRLCEA correlated very strongly with total femoral head coverage (Pearson=0.917, p<0.001). Mean CTFHC with XRLCEA between 15°-19.9° was 55% (range 51–59%). At 25° −29.9° mean CTFHC was 61%. There was a linear relation of CTFHC with XR LCEA such that CTFHC = 41.5 + 0.78(XRLCEA). This linear regression model predicted CTFHC 55% (95%CI 54–56%) for XRLCEA of 17.5°, and CTFHC 63% (95%CI 62–64%) for XRLCEA 27.5°.Methods
Results
Acetabular dysplasia is typically characterised by insufficient antero-superior femoral head coverage. It is postulated (yet unproven) that patients with dysplasia compensate by reducing pelvic tilt (anterior pelvic rotation), effectively retroverting their acetabulum to improve antero-superior cover. We aimed to 1) define pelvic tilt (PT) in patients with bilateral and unilateral dysplasia, and 2) quantify PT changes following a successful periacetabular osteotomy (PAO). We retrospectively reviewed 16 patients (14 females) who underwent successful, bilateral, staged, PAOs (32 PAOs). These cases were matched for age and gender with 32 unilaterally dysplastic hips that underwent successful PAO for a similar degree of acetabular dysplasia as per pre-operative imaging. Supine and AP radiographs pre-PAO and at latest follow-up were used to measure centre-edge-angle (CEA) and Tönnis-angle (TA). PT was measured using two validated methods (Sacro-Femoral-Pubic (SFP) angle and Pubic-Symphysis to Sacro-Iliac (PS-SI) Index with excellent correlation (ρ=0.8, p<0.001).Introduction
Patients/Materials and Methods
The periacetabular osteotomy (PAO) improves hip joint mechanics in patients with symptomatic dysplasia. As a consequence of the multi-planar acetabular re-orientation, the course of the iliopsoas tendon over the hip may be affected, potentially resulting in iliopsoas tendon-related pain. At present, little information regarding the incidence of iliopsoas-related pathology following PAO exists. We aimed to identify the incidence of iliopsoas-related pain following PAO. Secondarily, we aimed to identify any risk factors associated with this pathology. We retrospectively reviewed the PAO's performed from 2014–2017, for symptomatic dysplasia in our unit (single-surgeon, minimum 1-year follow-up). All patients with adequate pelvic radiographs were included. Radiographic parameters of dysplasia were measured from pre- and post-operative AP pelvic radiographs using a validated software (Introduction
Methods
Peri-acetabular-osteotomy (PAO) was initially described for the correction of acetabular dysplasia. Anteverting PAO is an established treatment for acetabular retroversion. By reviewing a large cohort, we aimed to (1) Test whether PAO outcome is equivalent in different types of deformity (classic dysplasia vs. retroversion) and (2) Determine whether outcome in acetabular retroversion is different between impinging-only hip and hips with combined pathology (impingement & dysplasia). A single-centre, retrospective cohort study was performed on a group of patients (n=183) with acetabular retroversion (n=90) or lateral-under-coverage dysplasia (n=93) treated with PAO. Acetabular deformity was defined on pelvic radiographs and 3-D CTs using a number of parameters. Hips with retroversion, were sub-divided into combined pathology - retroversion with dysplasia (lateral centre-edge [LCEA] < 25°), or retroversion-only (LCEA≥25°). The mean age at time of the procedure was 29+/−7 years and most hips were in females (n=171). Complication (as per Dindo-Clavien)-, re-operation-, hip preservation rates and patient-reported-outcome measures were measured using the Non-Arthroplasty-Hip-Score (NAHS).Introduction
Methods
Acetabular retroversion (AR) can cause pain and early osteoarthritis. The sagittal pelvic position or pelvic tilt (PT)has a direct relationship with acetabular orientation. As the pelvis tilts anteriorly, PT reduces and AR increases. Therefore, AR may be a deformity secondary to abnormal PT (functional retroversion) or an anatomical deformity of the acetabulum and/or pelvic ring. This study aims to:
Define PT at presentation is in AR patients and whether this is different to controls (volunteers without pain). Assess whether the PT changes following a anteverting periacetabular osteotomy (PAO). PT was measured for 51 patients who underwent a successful PAO. Mean age at PAO was 29±6 years and 48 were females. PT, pelvic incidence (PI), anterior pelvic plane (APP), and sacral slope (SS) were measured from CT data in 23 patients and compared to 44 (32±7 years old, 4 females) asymptomatic volunteers. Change in pelvic tilt in all 51 patients was measured using the Sacro-Femoral-Pubic angle (SFP), a validated method, from pre- and post-operative radiographs at a mean interval of 2.5(±2) years.Introduction
Methods
The purpose of this study was to determine the complications after Bernese periacetabular osteomy (PAO) performed by one experienced surgeon using a minimally invasive modified Smith-Petersen approach. Between May 2012 and December 2015, 224 periacetabular osteotomies (PAO) in 201 patients were performed. The perioperative complications were retrospectively reviewed after reviewing clinical notes and radiographs. The mean age was 28.8 years with 179 females and 22 males. The most common diagnosis was acetabular dysplasia with some cases of retroversion. The average lateral centre edge (LCE) angle was 16.5°(−18–45) and mean acetabular index (AI) 16.79° (−3–50). Postoperatively the mean LCE angle was 33.1°(20–51.3) and mean AI 3.0° (−13.5–16.6). There were no deep infections, no major nerve or vascular injuries and only one allogenic blood transfusion. Nine superficial wound infections required oral antibiotics and two wounds needed a surgical debridement. There was one pulmonary embolus and one deep vein thrombosis. Nine (4%) cases underwent a subsequent hip arthroscopy and three (1.3%) PAO's were converted to a total hip arthroplasty after a mean follow-up of 22 months (3–50). Lateral femoral cutaneous nerve dysaesthesia was noted in 64 (28.6%) PAO's. In 55 (24.5%) an iliopsoas injection of local anaesthetic and steroid for persistent iliopsoas irritation during the recovery phase was given. The minimally invasive modified Smith-Petersen approach is suitable to perform a Bernese periacetabular osteotomy with a low perioperative complication rate. Persistent pain related to iliopsoas is a not uncommon finding and perhaps under-reported in the literature.
Clinical graphics allows creation of three dimensional simulation based on CT or MRI that allows pre-operative planning. The software reports several hip morphological parameters routinely. Our aim was to validate the measurements of acetabular morphological parameters using CT based clinical graphics in patients presenting with symptomatic hip pain. We reviewed standardised plain radiographs, CT scans and 3D clinical graphics outputs of 42 consecutive hips in 40 patients presenting with symptomatic hip pain. Acetabular index (AI), lateral centre edge angle (LCE), acetabular and femoral version measurements were analysed for the 3D clinical graphics with radiographs and CT as gold standard. Significant differences were noted in measurements of AI, LCE, acetabular version and femoral version using the 3D motion analysis versus conventional measures, with only acetabular version showing comparable measurements. Correlation between 3D clinical graphics and conventional measures of acetabular morphology (AI, LCE) showed only slight agreement (ICC <0.4); while substantial agreement was noted for acetabular and femoral version (IC > 0.5). Acetabular morphological parameters measured by 3D clinical graphics are not reliable or validated. While clinicians may pursue the use of 3D clinical graphics for preoperative non-invasive planning, caution should be exercised when interpreting the reports of hip morphological parameters such as AI and LCE.
Periacetabular osteotomy has been described as an effective way of treating symptomatic hip dysplasia. We describe a new minimally invasive technique using a modification of the Smith Peterson approach. 189 consecutive patients operated on between March 2010 and March 2013 were included in the study. Patients who had undergone previous pelvic surgery for DDH were excluded. There were 174 females and 15 males. The mean age was 31 years (15–56) and the mean duration of follow-up was 29 months (14 – 53 months). 90% of cases were Tonnis grade 0 or 1. Twenty-three patients were operated on for primary acetabular retroversion. Functional outcomes were assessed using the NAHS, UCLA and Tegner activity scores. The surgical procedure is performed through an 8–10 cm skin crease incision; a soft tissue sleeve is elevated from the anterior superior iliac spine. The interval medial to the rectus femoris is developed. The hip joint is not opened and fixation of the osteotomy was with three 4.5mm cortical screws. A cell saver was routinely used.Introduction
Patients/Materials & Methods
The cam-type deformity in femoroacetabular impingement
is a 3D deformity. Single measurements using radiographs, CT or
MRI may not provide a true estimate of the magnitude of the deformity.
We performed an analysis of the size and location of measurements
of the alpha angle (α°) using a CT technique which could be applied
to the 3D reconstructions of the hip. Analysis was undertaken in
42 patients (57 hips; 24 men and 18 women; mean age 38 years (16
to 58)) who had symptoms of femoroacetabular impingement related
to a cam-type abnormality. An α° of >
50° was considered a significant
indicator of cam-type impingement. Measurements of the α° were made
at different points around the femoral head/neck junction at intervals
of 30°: starting at the nine o’clock (posterior), ten, eleven and
twelve o’clock (superior), one, two and ending at three o’clock
(anterior) position. The mean maximum increased α° was 64.6° (50.8° to 86°). The two
o’clock position was the most common point to find an increased α°
(53 hips; 93%), followed by one o’clock (48 hips; 84%). The largest α°
for each hip was found most frequently at the two o’clock position
(46%), followed by the one o’clock position (39%). Generally, raised α angles
extend over three segments of the clock face. Single measurements of the α°, whether pre- or post-operative,
should be viewed with caution as they may not be representative
of the true size of the deformity and not define whether adequate
correction has been achieved following surgery. Cite this article:
The position of the pelvis has been shown to influence acetabular orientation. However there have been no studies quantifying that effect on the native acetabulum. Our aims were to investigate whether it is possible to quantify the relationship between pelvic tilt and acetabular orientation in native hips, and whether pelvic tilt affects acetabular cover of the femoral head. Computerized tomography scans of 93 hips (36 normal, 31 dysplastic and 26 with acetabular retroversion) were analyzed. We used a CT technique that allows standardised three-dimensional (3D) analysis of acetabular inclination and anteversion and calculation of femoral head cover in relation to the anterior pelvic plane and at different degrees of forward and backward tilt. Acetabular anteversion, inclination and cover of the femoral head were measured at pelvic tilt angles ranging from −20° to 20° in relation to the anterior pelvic plane using 5° increments. The effect of pelvic tilt on version was similar in the normal, dysplastic and retroverted groups, with a drop in anteversion ranging from 2.5° to 5° for every 5° of forward tilt. The effect on inclination was less marked and varied among the three groups. Pelvic tilt increased femoral head cover in both normal and dysplastic hips. The effect was less marked, and tended to be negligible at higher positive tilt angles, in the retroverted group. This study has provided benchmark data on how pelvic tilt affects various acetabular parameters which in turn may be helpful in promoting greater understanding of acetabular abnormalities and how pelvic tilt affects the interpretation of pelvic radiographs.
The position of the pelvis influences acetabular orientation. In particular, pelvic tilt in the sagittal plane may lead to inaccurate interpretation of plain pelvic radiographs. We therefore quantified the relationship between this pelvic tilt and acetabular orientation in native hips, and determined whether pelvic tilt affects femoral head cover. We analysed computed tomography scans of 93 hips (36 normal, 31 dysplastic, 26 with acetabular retroversion) and measured acetabular anteversion, inclination, and femoral head cover at pelvic tilt angles ranging from −20° to 20° in relation to the anterior pelvic plane using 5° increments. The effect of pelvic tilt on version was similar in the normal, dysplastic, and retroverted groups, with a drop in anteversion ranging from 2.5° to 5° for every 5° of forward tilt. There was a tendency for the inclination angle to decrease when the pelvis was tilted forward from a position of extension, and in normal hips, this produced a reduction in inclination of about 4° for every 8° of pelvic tilt; but once neutral pelvic tilt was reached, further forward rotation of the acetabulum had rather a small effect on the inclination angle. In normal and dysplastic hips pelvic tilt increased apparent femoral head cover; in the retroverted group the effect was less marked and tended to be negligible at higher tilt angles. Anterior cover increased with increasing forward tilt in all three groups of hips. Posterior cover, on the other hand, decreased by just 2% for the dysplastic hips, 3.5% for the normal hips, and 6% for the retroverted hips over the whole range of tilt from −20° to 20°. A greater understanding of the influence of pelvic tilt may allow improvements in the radiological diagnosis and surgical treatment of acetabular abnormalities, particularly in relation to acetabular reorientation procedures and femoroacetabular impingement.
A new conservative hip stem has been designed to address the complex problem of total hip arthroplasty in the younger population. To assess the stability and strain distribution of a new conservative hip stem.Introduction
Objectives
In recent years, there has been a significant advancement in our understanding of femoro-acetabular impingement and associated labral and chondral pathology. Surgeons worldwide have demonstrated the successful treatment of these lesions via arthroscopic and open techniques. The aim of this study is to validate a simple and reproducible classification system for acetabular chondral lesions. In our classification system, the acetabulum is first divided into 6 zones as described by Ilizalithurri VM et al [Arthroscopy 24(5) 534-539]. The cartilage is then graded as 0 to 4 as follows: Grade 0 – normal articular cartilage lesions; Grade 1 softening or wave sign; Grade 2 - cleavage lesion; Grade 3 - delamination and Grade 4 –exposed bone. The site of the lesion is further typed as A, B or C based on whether the lesion is 1/3 distance from acetabular rim to cotyloid fossa, 1/3 to 2/3 distance from acetabular rim to cotyloid fossa and > 2/3 distance from acetabular rim to cotyloid fossa. For validating the classification system, six surgeons reviewed 14 hip arthroscopy video clips. All surgeons were provided with written explanation of our classification system. Each surgeon then individually graded the cartilage lesion. A single observer then compared results for observer variability using kappa statistics.Introduction
Methods
For validating the classification system, six surgeons reviewed 14 hip arthroscopy video clips. All surgeons were provided with written explanation of our classification system. Each surgeon then individually graded the cartilage lesion. A single observer then compared results for observer variability using kappa statistics.
There have been considerable recent advances in the understanding and management of femoroacetabular impingement and associated labral and chondral pathology. We have developed a classification system for acetabular chondral lesions. In our system, we use the six acetabular zones previously described by Ilizaliturri et al. The cartilage is then graded on a scale of 0 to 4 as follows: grade 0, normal articular cartilage lesions; grade 1, softening or wave sign; grade 2, cleavage lesion; grade 3, delamination; and grade 4, exposed bone. The site of the lesion is further classed as A, B or C based on whether the lesion is less than one-third of the distance from the acetabular rim to the cotyloid fossa, one-third to two-thirds of the same distance and greater than two-thirds of the distance, respectively. In order to validate the classification system, six surgeons graded ten video recordings of hip arthroscopy. Our findings showed a high intra-observer reliability of the classification system with an intraclass correlation coefficient of 0.81 and a high interobserver reliability with an intraclass correlation coefficient of 0.88. We have developed a simple reproducible classification system for lesions of the acetabular cartilage, which it is hoped will allow standardised documentation to be made of damage to the articular cartilage, particularly that associated with femoroacetabular impingement.
Juvenile idiopathic arthritis (JIA) affecting the hip can cause debilitating pain and walking disability in children. Total hip replacement offers the potential of a pain free joint and a significant improvement in function. There remains the concern regarding the high rates of aseptic loosening of cemented total hip replacements in this group of patients, and there is evidence that younger patients have higher failure rates. The aim of this study was to look at the results of uncemented total hip replacement in children with Juvenile Idiopathic Arthritis and in particular to assess any problems associated with performing this surgery in the presence of open growth plates in the acetabular and trochanteric regions. Between 1995 and 2005, 56 uncemented total hip replacements were carried out in 37 children with JIA with a mean follow up of 7.5 years (range 3 to 12.5). 25 of the hips had ceramic on ceramic bearings. The mean age at surgery was 13.9 years (range 11–16). 19 patients underwent bilateral procedures. All patients showed a significant improvement in their HSS Hip scores (p<
0.01). Two CAD CAM femoral stems were revised for gross subsidence and three acetabular components were revised for loosening. Four polyethylene liners were exchanged due to wear. 51 of 53 (96%) femoral stems and 50 (94%) acetabular components remain well fixed at latest follow up with no signs of loosening. There were no dislocations or infections. Uncemented fixation appears to work well in this challenging group of patients even in the presence of open growth plates. Implant choice is important to avoid problems of subsidence and loosening. Ceramic bearings available for small implant sizes give promise of improved performance compared to polyethylene over the long term.
Hip arthroscopic debridement of FAI lesions offers similar results to open procedures allowing for full inspection of the joint and the treatment of any chondral lesion but with a quicker recovery time. It nonetheless has a very long learning curve and even in the most experienced hands the treatment of impingement lesions is complicated and technically challenging. The purpose of this cadaveric study was to assess the degree of exposure obtained using two different limited anterior approaches to the hip which would allow effective surgical treatment of cam and pincer FAI.
In summary cam and pincer impingement of the hip can be treated by either the direct anterior or Heuter approach. The choice of approach would be dictated after careful consideration as to which portion of the anterior acetabular rim required surgery, with more lateral acetabular lesions being favoured by the Heuter approach and more medial impingement sites by the anterior approach we have described.
This study examined the relationship between the cross-over sign and the true three-dimensional anatomical version of the acetabulum. We also investigated whether in true retroversion there is excessive femoral head cover anteriorly. Radiographs of 64 hips in patients being investigated for symptoms of femoro-acetabular impingement were analysed and the presence of a cross-over sign was documented. CT scans of the same hips were analysed to determine anatomical version and femoral head cover in relation to the anterior pelvic plane after correcting for pelvic tilt. The sensitivity and specificity of the cross-over sign were 92% and 55%, respectively for identifying true acetabular retroversion. There was no significant difference in total cover between normal and retroverted cases. Anterior and posterior cover were, however, significantly different (p <
0.001 and 0.002). The cross-over sign was found to be sensitive but not specific. The results for femoral head cover suggest that retroversion is characterised by posterior deficiency but increased cover anteriorly.
We present a new CT-based method which measures cover of the femoral head in both normal and dysplastic hips and allows assessment of acetabular inclination and anteversion. A clear topographical image of the head with its covered area is generated. We studied 36 normal and 39 dysplastic hips. In the normal hips the mean cover was 73% (66% to 81%), whereas in the dysplastic group it was 51% (38% to 64%). The significant advantage of this technique is that it allows the measurements to be standardised with reference to a specific anatomical plane. When this is applied to assessing cover in surgery for dysplasia of the hip it gives a clearer understanding of where the corrected hip stands in relation to normal and allows accurate assessment of inclination and anteversion.
This project assessed the long-term stability of this design at different orientations, by measuring the change in surface strain distribution following its insertion.
Image analysis results demonstrated an average bone attachment of 30.94% to the implant surface (fig 2). Greatest bone attachment occurred at the end of the pins (78.99%) contributing 22% of overall attachment to the implant. Least attachment occurred beneath the prosthetic cup (13.82%) and in the medial aspect adjacent to the central pin. Greater total bone area was measured in control hips and no significant correlation between bone attachment to the ‘pegs’ and bone area beneath the prosthetic cup was identified.
Pelvic and acetabular surgery may be associated with significant blood loss because of the vascularity and anatomy of the pelvis. Concerns continue in relation to blood transfusion because of the potential for disease transmission and because of the increasing cost of providing safe blood products. The purpose of this study was to examine in a retrospective fashion the blood transfusion requirements in a consecutive series of patients undergoing peri-acetabular osteotomy for hip dysplasia. Surgery was performed under general anaesthesia with an epidural in place in the majority of cases. A cell saver was not used and no pre operative autologous blood donation was performed. In seven cases one unit of blood was drawn off immediately prior to the operation in the anaesthetic room and re-infused towards the end of the operation. This practice was discontinued when one of these units clotted and could not be re-infused. A post-operative transfusion policy was adopted where an haemoglobin (Hb) concentration of <
7.5 g/dl was an indication for transfusion. There were 19 females and 2 males. The average age was 26.6 (range 14 – 40). The average duration of surgery was 233mins (range 180 – 285min). Pre-operatively the average Hb concentration was 13.68 g/dl (range 12.3 – 16.2 g/dl). Overall 16 patients did not require any cross-matched transfusion. Two patients received one unit of blood and three received two units. If the transfusion policy had been correctly followed, 4 of these patients would not have received cross-matched blood. The average post-op Hb in those not receiving transfusion was 8.6 g/dl (range 7.3 – 9.9 g/dl). This study shows that it is possible to safely perform peri-acetabular osteotomies in most cases without blood transfusion which is important in this group of patients who are generally young and female.
To assess the performance and success of joint sparing limb salvage surgery in high grade malignancy, in terms of function, complications, recurrence and survival, as compared to joint resection. We report a ten-year experience of twenty patients with high grade malignancies of bone which did not cross the epiphyseal plate. They underwent not only limb salvage surgery but also joint preservation. The aim of this is to preserve function in the joint and to prevent the inevitable wear of prosthetic joints requiring revision surgery. The age range was 4 - 25 years (mean 13. 5). The Diagnoses were 14 Osteosarcomas and 6 Ewings sarcomas. Mean follow up was 49 months. There were 13 femoral &
7 tibial malignancies. 12 underwent complex biological fixation with a combination of reimplanted autoclaved or irradiated bone; vascularised fibular graft; femoral or humeral allograft. In 8 cases custom made hydroxyapatite coated prostheses were used to replace the resected bone. This surgery must clearly be evaluated in the context of recurrence, particularly as this is associated with an increased risk of metastases and death. Analysis of our results to date has not shown a greater rate of complications. We experienced one recurrence, and one death. The custom prostheses group had fewer complications and operations. Functionally these patients report near normal limbs and joints and do not report any limitation of activities. Joint sparing limb salvage surgery is extremely worthwhile as it produces a significantly better functioning limb and lower morbidity, with less likelihood of revision surgery. We have not found a higher risk of post-operative complications, recurrence or death. Furthermore massive prosthetic replacement is quicker, osseointegrates reliably and is associated with a lower complication and further operation rate.
To assess the clinical features, development of metastases, and survival rate of patients with local recurrence after the resection of osteosarcoma in a large series. Five hundred and thirty (530) patients with high-grade osteosarcoma were treated between 1989 and 1998. Fifty-four patients (10%) developed local recurrence after resection and adjuvant chemotherapy. There were 38 men and 16 women with a mean age of 19 years (range 6–50). The mean follow up was 39 months (range 7–120 months). Forty-three patients (79%) had clear resection margins microscopically, while in 8 patients (15%) microscopic tumour was found at the resection margin, and contaminated excision was performed in 3 patients. Histological response was category 1 in 24% of the patients, and category 2 in 76%. Clinical features, treatment, and prognosis were analyzed. Survival rates were examined using Kaplan-Meier Analysis. The average interval between the first resection and local recurrence was 15 months (range 2–109 months). Forty-one patients (76%) had local recurrence in deep soft tissue, 7 in bone, and 6 in subcutaneous tissue. Twenty-six patients (49%) had lung metastasis at the time of local recurrence, while 21 patients (38%) developed it later. Thirty patients (57%) were treated with resection of the recurrent lesion and 18 (32%) were treated with amputation. 1-, 3-, and 5-year survival rates after local recurrence were 0.57, 0.38, and 0.22 respectively.
87% of patients with local recurrence developed metastases either concurrently or at a later date. Immediate amputation did achieve local tumor control. However, the survival rate was not statistically higher. 87% of the local recurrence arose in soft tissue. Therefore, careful attention should be paid to secure the wide margin around biopsy tract, muscle insertion to the affected bone, and neurovascular bundle at the time of initial resection.
We report the results of anterior soft-tissue release of the hip for fixed flexion deformity in 17 patients (31 hips) with juvenile chronic arthritis. The mean age at operation was 8 years 6 months. All the patients were reviewed at one and three years and 11 (21 hips) were available for review at five years. The results were good as regards early pain relief and improved mobility. At one year, the average fixed flexion deformity was reduced from 35 degrees to 9.5 degrees, and at three years it was 18 degrees. This degree of improvement was maintained in the hips followed for five years. At 5 to 12 years' follow-up (mean 6.7) seven patients (14 hips) have required no further surgery and have maintained an acceptable range of motion. We discuss the influence of surgery on radiographic changes and on femoral neck anteversion.
We review the results of 96 primary total hip replacements in 54 patients with juvenile chronic arthritis at five years or longer after surgery. The mean age at operation was 16.7 years (range 11.25 to 26.6); the follow-up period averaged 11.5 years. The clinical results in terms of pain, range of movement, mobility and function are presented. A revision procedure was required in 24 hips (25%) in 18 patients at an average of 9.5 years after the primary operation. A further 17 hips had radiographic signs of loosening. The factors thought to contribute to this relatively high failure rate in patients with juvenile chronic arthritis are discussed.
Thirteen total hip replacements with titanium alloy femoral components required revision for loosening at an average of two years after implantation. At revision the soft tissues around the implant were darkly stained and a proliferative membrane had invaded the cement-bone interface. The femoral components showed polishing of parts of their shot-blasted surfaces. Histology showed a fibroblastic reaction with abundant titanium lying free and within histiocytes, and a scanty foreign-body giant-cell reaction. Surface analysis of the removed femoral components and chemical analysis of the excised tissues is described. Tissue reaction in response to the metal-wear debris may have contributed to the early failure of these implants.