Infection after intradiscal injections has been recognised as a distinct entity, but discitis after discography has often been attributed to an aseptic process or a chemical reaction to the contrast material. We examined the hypothesis that discitis after discography is always due to infection, and report a clinical review and an experimental study. Part I. We reviewed the case records and radiographs of 432 patients who had undergone lumbar discography. When an 18-gauge needle without a stilette had been used, discitis was diagnosed in 2.7% of 222 patients but stiletted needles and a two-needle technique at each level reduced the incidence to 0.7%. Seven patients with discitis after discography had undergone anterior discectomy and fusion; in them the histopathological findings were of a chronic inflammatory response. Bacteria were isolated from the discs of three of the four patients who had open biopsy less than six weeks from the time of discography. These findings suggest that bacteria were initiators rather than promoters of the response. Part II. Multiple level lumbar discography was carried out in mature sheep, injecting contrast material with or without various concentrations of bacteria. Radiographs were taken and the discs and end-plates were examined histologically and cultured for bacteria at intervals after injection. None of the controls showed any evidence of discitis but all sheep injected with bacteria had typical radiological and histopathological changes by six weeks, though cultures were almost all negative. However, at one and two weeks after injection, but usually not after three weeks, bacteria could be isolated. We suggest that all cases of discitis after discography are initiated by infection, and that a very strict aseptic technique should be used for all injections into intervertebral discs

Introduction Historically, lumbar discography has been one of the most controversial subjects in the management of discogenic low back pain. The diagnostic value of normal psychometric specific pain provocation by disc pressurization has emerged. The sensitivity, specificity and accuracy of discography as a diagnostic test are not in doubt. In clinical discography pain reproduction and location are essential elements. There is an accepted rate of 0–10% false positives. This rate is influenced by occupational disability and abnormal psychometric profiles. By contrast, little attention has been given to false negative results and their outcomes if surgically treated. Traditionally, whether or not the test is considered to be positive or negative is determined immediately after completion of the diagnostic procedure. This study shows that patient’s pain reproduction may occur up to 24 hours after the discogram which often initially interpreted as a true negative when it is actually a false negative result. This study verifies the existence and significance of a false negative through the patients’ treatment and outcomes. Methods In this study, 150 patients underwent discography for investigation of chronic persistent low back pain (CPLBP). All patients had a control (morphologically normal) discogram at the level above the degenerative segment. No patients with abnormal psychometric profiles or compensation were included. All patients were followed up 24 hours post discogram by the radiologist to further assess their clinical status. Ten of the patients (7.5%) were considered to have a false negative discogram, as per the Dallas Discogram Scale. The surgeon correlated the delayed response on the subsequent follow-up. These ten patients were diagnosed as having a positive response and were treated surgically for their discogenic pain. VAS-B, VAS-L, ODI, RMD were collected prospectively. Preoperative and 6 month results were reviewed. Results Seven of the 10 patients (70%) reported severe increase CPLBP and reproduction of pain within 8 hours of the discogram, while 3 patients (30%) did so in the ensuing 24 hours after the discogram. Surgical treatment was either by total disc replacement or anterior lumbar interbody fusion. All patients reported greater than 50% reduction in VAS-B and VAS-L and with improvements of greater than 50% in their ODI and RMD scores. Discussion The clinical reliability of discography hinges on the subjective assessment of pain concordance as the discriminating factor in determining false positives from false negatives. Given the limitations of discography, all information about the patient should be considered prior to diagnosis, including clinical, radiological, historical, and psychometric factors. The delayed positive discography response is an important consideration for the patient, the radiologist, and the treating surgeon to be aware of. The results of this study verify the existence of this subgroup and justify their surgical treatment

Aims. The presence of facet tropism has been correlated with an elevated susceptibility to lumbar disc pathology. Our objective was to evaluate the impact of facet tropism on chronic lumbosacral discogenic pain through the analysis of clinical data and finite element modelling (FEM). Methods. Retrospective analysis was conducted on clinical data, with a specific focus on the spinal units displaying facet tropism, utilizing FEM analysis for motion simulation. We studied 318 intervertebral levels in 156 patients who had undergone provocation discography. Significant predictors of clinical findings were identified by univariate and multivariate analyses. Loading conditions were applied in FEM simulations to mimic biomechanical effects on intervertebral discs, focusing on maximal displacement and intradiscal pressures, gauged through alterations in disc morphology and physical stress. Results. A total of 144 discs were categorized as ‘positive’ and 174 discs as ‘negative’ by the results of provocation discography. The presence of defined facet tropism (OR 3.451, 95% CI 1.944 to 6.126) and higher Adams classification (OR 2.172, 95% CI 1.523 to 3.097) were important predictive parameters for discography-‘positive’ discs. FEM simulations showcased uneven stress distribution and significant disc displacement in tropism-affected discs, where loading exacerbated stress on facets with greater angles. During varied positions, notably increased stress and displacement were observed in discs with tropism compared to those with normal facet structure. Conclusion. Our findings indicate that facet tropism can contribute to disc herniation and changes in intradiscal pressure, potentially exacerbating disc degeneration due to altered force distribution and increased mechanical stress. Cite this article: Bone Joint Res 2024;13(9):452–461

In a prospective study we attempted to define the role of lumbar discography in the investigation of patients with low back pain with or without non-dermatomal pain in the lower limb. The records of 195 patients were studied at least two years after a technically successful operation. Of 137 patients in whom discography had revealed disc disease and provoked symptoms, 89% derived significant and sustained clinical benefit from operation. Of 25 patients whose discs showed morphological abnormality but had no provocation of symptoms on discography only 52% had clinical success. These findings support the continued use of lumbar discography for the investigation of this particular group of patients

Discitis after discography is due to bacterial penetration into the intervertebral disc by a contaminated needle and has an incidence of 1% to 4%. We have examined the prophylactic role of cephazolin administered at the time of discography. An experimental study in sheep using radiographic contrast containing Staphylococcus epidermidis showed that either adding the antibiotic to the intradiscal suspension or giving it intravenously 30 minutes before intradiscal inoculation of bacteria prevented any radiographic, macroscopic or histological signs of discitis; all the intervertebral disc cultures were negative. In a prospective clinical study of 127 consecutive patients having lumbar discography, the injected contrast contained cephazolin 1 mg per ml. None of the patients developed clinical or radiographic signs of discitis. We recommend the use of a suitable broad spectrum antibiotic in a single prophylactic dose whenever the intervertebral disc is entered

We attempted to correlate the findings of MRI and discography in patients with low back pain, examining 108 lumbar intervertebral discs in 33 consecutive patients. MRI results were assessed from the intensity and shape of the signal obtained from the central part of the disc. Discography was classified according to the pattern of contrast material, the pressure accepted and the pain reproduced. All discs which were abnormal on MRI had altered patterns on discography, but 18 of the 60 discs with normal MRI had abnormal discograms. Of 39 asymptomatic discs, 33 had normal MRI signals and 24 had normal discograms. None of the 15 discs showing severe degeneration on MRI sustained high levels of intradiscal pressure, but only six of the 60 discs giving normal MRI had low pressure. With current techniques, discography is more accurate than MRI for the detection of annular pathology: a normal MRI does not exclude significant changes in the peripheral structure of the intervertebral disc which can produce low back pain

Prospective match cohort study of disc degeneration progression over ten years with and without baseline discography. To compare progression of common degenerative findings between lumbar discs injected ten years earlier with those same disc levels in matched subjects not exposed to discography. Seventy-five subjects without serious low back pain illness underwent a protocol MRI and a L3/4, L4/5 and L5 S1 discography in 1997. A match group was enrolled at the same time and underwent the same protocol MRI examination. Subjects were followed for ten years. At 7 to 10 years after baseline assessment, eligible discography in controlled subjects underwent another protocol MRI. MRI graders, blind to group designation, scored both groups for qualitative findings. Well matched cohorts, including 50 discography subjects and 52 control subjects met eligibility criteria for follow up evaluation. In all graded or measured parameters, discs that had been exposed to puncture and injection had greater progression of degenerative findings compared to control (non-injected) discs: progression of disc degeneration, 54 discs (35%) in the discography group compared to 21 (14%) in the control group (p=0.03); 55 new disc herniations in the discography group compared to 22 in the control group (p=0.0003). New disc herniations were disproportionately found on the side of the annular puncture (p=0.0006). The quantitative measures of disc height and disc signal also showed significantly greater loss of disc height (p=0.05) and signal intensity (p=0.001) in the discography disc compared to the control disc. This study demonstrates that the dimensions of the LSP change with age. Increases in LSP height occur with age. More impressive increases in LSP width occur with advancing age. This study suggests that loss of lumbar lordosis is correlated with changing LSP morphology. The increased width of the LSP with age influences access to the spinal canal, particularly if midline-preserving approaches are attempted in the ageing population. There is increased bone volume for bone grafting procedures with increasing age. The reduced distance between LSPs with age may influence design of implants that stabilize this region of the spine, and occur not only as a result of disk space narrowing, but also as a consequence of increased LSP dimensions

Introduction: The role of discography before lumbar fusion had been discussed in the literature. No study discussed its role before total lumbar disc replacement (TDR). Degenerate discs are not necessarily painful, even if they show Modic changes or HIZ. Moreover, discogenic pain might not be the predominant element in the patient’s symptoms and most of the back pain could be originating form other spinal structures. The aim of our prospective cohort study is to show whether or not provocative discography plays any significant role before TDR and to define that role. Methods: Twenty patients (11 females and 9 males) had “Prodisc” TDR. Mean age = 38.5 years (range: 20–56). All patients had mechanical low back pain with degenerative disc disease diagnosed by MRI scan. 65% (N=13) had radicular pain as well. The mean duration of back pain = 66.9 months (range: 16–240). Pre-operative provocative discography was performed in all cases. The clinical outcome was assessed by comparing the preoperative SF36-v2, ODI and VAS scores’ means to the 3, 6, 12 and 24 months post-operative ones and also comparing the last follow up SF36-v2 scores with the, age and sex adjusted, normative data for the general UK population obtained from the Oxford Healthy Lifestyle Survey III. All patients were followed up for a minimum of 2 years. Results: 90% (N=18) experienced a clinically significant improvement of their back pain (MCID for SF36-v2 scales=1SD, ODI=10 points and VAS=2 points). There has been a statistically significant improvement in the follow up outcome measures (P< 0.05) at 3, 6, 12 and 24 mths. SF 36-v2 scores of 15% of patients (N=3) reached or exceeded the normative values for the UK general population. Conclusion: Provocative discography is an important diagnostic tool before TDR. It is the only dynamic method to diagnose discogenic pain and is indispensable to exclude the painless levels in cases of multilevel disc degeneration

This prospective study was carried out to correlate findings of magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and discography. Fifty-five consecutive patients with degenerative disc disease not responding to non-operative treatment were included in the study. There were 19 men and 36 women and the mean age was 45 years. Discography was carried out on 131 disc levels. The discograms were classified using modified Adams’s classification and pain recorded into three grades. MRI scans were graded using a new classification system based on parasagittal and axial images by two independent observers blinded to discography findings. There was good intraobserver (kappa 0. 74) and interobserver (kappa 0. 70) agreement for the classification system. There was a significant correlation in the morphology of discs as determined by discograms and MRI classification (p< 0. 001). Each disc was graded on MRI scan as painful or painless on basis of defined criteria. Concordant discography pain was considered as the gold standard. The sensitivity and specificity of MRI in predicting symptomatic disc using defined criteria was 94% and 77%. The sensitivities and specificity of high intensity zones was 27% and 87% and for end plate changes was 32% and 98% respectively. In 14 patients (25%) the findings of MRI and discography did not correlate. In conclusion though MRI is an excellent investigation for assessing disc morphology it should be interpreted along with discography findings before planning fusion surgery. The proposed MRI classification is a useful aid in predicting painful degenerative disc. The utility of high intensity zones and end plate changes is limited due to low sensitivity

Two different classifications of discograms have been used in a prospective study of 279 injected discs in 100 patients. The five-stage classification of Adams, Dolan and Hutton (1986) showed increased degeneration in the lower lumbar discs and more degenerative changes in men than in women. Exact reproduction of the patient's pain on injection was more common in fissured or ruptured discs than in less degenerate discs, with 81% sensitivity and 64% specificity of the discogram for pain. The additional information obtained by comparing computerised tomography (CT) with discograms was minimal. Discography was found to be useful in the evaluation of chronic low back pain in patients whose ordinary CT scans, myelograms and flexion-extension radiographs were normal. In spondylolysis and spondylolisthesis, discography can disclose whether fusion needs to be extended above the lytic level, and it may show if the pain in patients who have had posterolateral fusion is discogenic. Thus, discography gives information which is useful in deciding whether to operate on patients with chronic low back pain

We analysed the functional outcome (Oswestry Disability Index) after technically and radiologically successful lumbar fusion in 39 non-compensation seeking patients with chronic low back pain, who had a High Intensity Zone (HIZ) – positive MRI and subsequently underwent discography. The average follow-up was 33 months. The HIZ-positive, discogrampositive group was the only one with statistically significant improvement. The HIZ-positive, discogram-negative group had the worst outcome. Relying only on the HIZ fails to identify the group of patients who would have had negative discography at the same levels. Therefore the presence of HIZ alone should not dictate treatment plan without discography confirmation

Background: Over several decades, investigators have been trying to identify the painful degenerate disc. Their work included two main methods. The first was to set criteria on the radiological investigations, mainly the MRI scan, to describe the severity of the degenerative disc disease (DDD); and the second was to perform discographies. Neither of these two methods precluded the need for the other. Purpose: Using Pfirrmann’s classification, we correlated static MRI images, for the severity of segmental disc degeneration, with dynamic lumbar discography, with the aim to improve the identification of painful ‘disco-genic’ intervertebral segments. Study design: Prospective cohort study. Inclusion criteria included patients with mechanical low back pain who exhausted the conservative measures and required surgical treatment. Patient Sample and Methods: We investigated 69 patients (45 females, 24 males). The average age was 38.9 years (range 20–56). All patients had degenerative disc disease (DDD) on lumbar MRI scans. Provocative discographies were performed in all cases as a routine investigation to identify painful levels prior to fusion or disc replacement surgery. The severity of DDD was graded using Pfirrmann’s classification. A total of 162 discographies were performed using the ‘miss the facet joint, double needle technique’. Outcome measures: During discography typical or concordant pain only was regarded as positive. Among each of the five Pfirrmann grades, the percentage of positive discographies was calculated. Significance and correlation then were investigated using the Chi-squared and Spearman’s correlation tests. Results: 24 discs were classified as Pfirrmann grade I, 33 grade II, 63 grade III, 27 grade IV and 15 grade V. The percentages of positive provocative discography for concordant pain among these groups were 0%, 9.1%, 71.4%, 100% and 100% respectively. Statistical analysis showed a high correlation between the severity of DDD on MRI scan and the result of the provocative discography (Chi2 = 32.96, P < 0.001 and correlation coefficient = 0.756). Conclusion: The higher the grade of segmental DDD, the more likely it will be painful on discography. All discs showing Pfirmann grade IV and V disease were painful on discography. We strongly recommend the Pfirrmann classification for use in grading the severity of lumbar DDD especially when assessing for its association with discogenic pain as determined by provocative discography

The lumbar spines of 22 patients were examined for disc degeneration by magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and by discography. The results from 50 intervertebral discs visualised by both techniques were independently assessed and graded on a five-point scale from normality to gross degeneration and then compared. In 44 discs the results agreed. Of the six discs which gave differing results, four discrepancies were due to observer error and two to incorrect placement of the discographic needle. MRI was shown to be more accurate than discography in the diagnosis of disc degeneration. It has several major advantages, which should make it the investigation of choice

Introduction: Recent cadaveric studies have identified neovascularisation and neoneuralisation as probable mechanisms in the causation of discogenic pain. Calcium pyrophosphate deposits have been observed in discs in several studies. Their significance in the causation of discogenic pain is unclear. Direct correlation between the pain site and histological features can be verified by aware state endoscopic visualisation. Aim and Objectives: The study aims to examine and correlate the presence of neovascularisation, crystalline pyrophosphate deposits in the disc, and discogenic pain by spinal probing and discography under endoscopic visualisation. Material and Methods: Tissue removed from intervertebral discs of 224 patients during surgery was examined directly, and polarised microscopy was used to identify the presence of calcium pyrophosphate and neovascularisation. Their presence was correlated to diagnostic provocative findings of spinal probing and discography and intradiscal distortion during aware state endoscopy. Results: Calcium Pyrophosphate: Twenty out of 224 patients (9%) demonstrated calcium pyrophosphate in the discs. Fourteen had pain reproduced on probing or discography. Thirteen out of 20 patients (65%) had either an annular collection or leak at the index level. 6 had an extradiscal cause of pain. One hundred percent of the patients with annular collections or leaks had pain on spinal probing or discography. Sixteen patients with pyrophosphate deposits did not have neovascularisation. Neovascularisation: Thirty seven out of 224 patients (16.5%) showed neovascularisation in the disc. Four discs had crystalline pyrophosphate deposits. Thirty three out of 37 (90%) had pain on probing and/or discography. Out of four patients who had no pain on probing or discography, two had demonstrated tears during previous discographic procedures which were treated with laser annealing. These patients had disc bulges and compressive radiculopathy. Conclusion: The presence of pyrophosphate in the disc without a tear or leak does not directly render them tender to provocation. The presence of pyrophosphate is not correlated to neovascularisation. Annular tears or leaks are not directly correlated to the presence of pyrophosphates. There is a high correlation between pain provocation and neovascularisation

Introduction. Degenerative disc disease results from mechanical alteration of the intervertebral disc. Biochemical modifications of the nucleus matrix are also incriminated. Furthermore, genetic predispositions as well as vascular factors have been advocated in the process of disc degeneration. A relationship between sciatica and Propionibacterium acnes has been described. However, it remains unclear if the hypothesis of a subclinical spondylodiscitis might play a role in the pathophysiology of degenerative disc disease. The purpose of this study was to analyze the possible presence of bacteria in lumbar discs of patients with degenerative disc disease. Methods. We prospectively analyzed the presence of bacteria in 83 patients (34 males and 49 females, average age 41 years) treated by lumbar disc replacement at L3-L4, L4-L5 or L5-S1. An intraoperative biopsy and microbiological culture were performed for each disc to determine if intradiscal bacteria were present. Great care was taken to avoid any source of contamination during the conditioning process of the biopsy. Microbiological results were compared to the magnetic resonance stages of disc degeneration according to the Pfirrmann and Modic classifications. Possible sources of previous iatrogenic disc contamination after discography or nucleotomy were analyzed. Results. The magnetic resonance stages were Pfirrmann IV or V, with Modic I signs in 32 and Modic II in 25 cases. A preoperative discography was performed in 49 patients, and 24 had previous nucleotomy. Germs were found in 40 discs, 43 cultures were steriles. The following bacteria were evidenced: Propionibacterium acnes 18, Staphylococcus coagulase negative 16, Staphylococcus aureus 3, Gram negative bacilli 3, Micrococcus 3, Corynebacterium 3, others 5. Ten biopsies presented several different germs. Bacteria were predominantly found in males (p=0.012). The mostly positive level was L4-L5 (p=0.075). Histological examination of 31 discs found inflammatory cells in 33 % of the biopsies with positive bacterial culture, versus 5 % of the sterile biopsies (p=0.038). There was no significant relationship between bacterial evidence and Modic sign. A preoperative discography or previous nucleotomies did not represent significant contamination sources. None of the patients presented clinical signs of infection. Conclusions. The finding of bacteria in 48 % of disc biopsies, presence of inflammatory cells at histological examination, the absence of responsibility of the discography as a factor of contamination, and the absence of clinical post-operative infection, defend the hypothesis of a low-grade spondylodiscitis which might play a role in the pathophysiology of degenerative disc disease. On the other hand, the presence of skin commensal bacteria, of ¼ of polymicrobial biopsies, and the fact that previous nucleotomy doesn't seem to be involved in inoculation, cannot allow to eliminate a contamination of the samples. Further studies are necessary to elucidate the responsability of intradiscal bacteria in degenerative disc disease. This could influence our treatment strategy of back pain, which could be based in the future on antibiotics

Discogenic low back pain is a common cause of disability, but its pathogenesis is poorly understood. We collected 19 specimens of lumbar intervertebral discs from 17 patients with discogenic low back pain during posterior lumbar interbody fusion, 12 from physiologically ageing discs and ten from normal control discs. We investigated the histological features and assessed the immunoreactive activity of neurofilament (NF200) and neuropeptides such as substance P (SP) and vasoactive-intestinal peptide (VIP) in the nerve fibres. The distinct histological characteristic of the painful disc was the formation of a zone of vascularised granulation tissue from the nucleus pulposus to the outer part of the annulus fibrosus along the edges of the fissures. SP-, NF- and VIP-immunoreactive nerve fibres in the painful discs were more extensive than in the control discs. Growth of nerves deep into the annulus fibrosus and nucleus pulposus was observed mainly along the zone of granulation tissue in the painful discs. This suggests that the zone of granulation tissue with extensive innervation along the tears in the posterior part of the painful disc may be responsible for causing the pain of discography and of discogenic low back pain

Objectives: To examine and correlate the presence of neovascularisation, crystalline pyrophosphate deposits and other hisotological features in the disc and discogenic pain established by spinal probing and discography under aware state endoscopic visualisation. Design: Tissue removed from intervertebral discs of 224 patients during surgery were examined by direct and polarised microscopy to identify the presence of calcium pyrophosphate and neovascularisation. Material and Methods: Histology was correlated to the diagnostic provocative findings of spinal probing and discography, discal palpation during aware state endoscopy. Results:Calcium Pyrophosphate: 20/224 (9%) patients demonstrated calcium pyrophosphate in the discs. Fourteen had pain reproduced on probing or discography; 13/20 (65%) of patients had either an annular collection or leak at the index level; 6/20 had an extradiscal cause of pain. Neovascularisation: Thirty-seven out of 224 (16.5%) patients showed neovascularisation in the disc; four discs had crystalline pyrophosphate deposits; 33/37 (90%) had pain on probing and/or discography. Conclusion: The presence of pyrophosphate in a disc without a tear or leak is not associated with annular tenderness. The presence of pyrophosphates in radial tears or leaks is associated with annular tenderness. Annular tears or leaks are not directly correlated to the presence of pyrophosphates. There is a high correlation between pain provocation and neovascularisation

Problem Chronic disabling pain in the sacrococcygeal region is regarded by clinicians with great dismay because of unpredictability of the treatment outcome. The subject is under- represented in the literature. Method Thirty eight patients with intractable coccydynia had imaging investigations for the spine other than X-rays. Six of these patients were also investigated by means of sacrococcygeal and intercoccygeal discography. The excised specimen with intact sacrococcygeral joint was sent for histological examination in 22 patients. Patients’ assessment of the benefit of coccygectomy was conducted by telephonic interview. Results After a mean post surgical follow up of 6.75 years (range 2–16 yrs), results were available for 31 out of 38 patients. 16 patients benefited greatly from the surgery and 6 benefited to some extent, giving an overall good result of 71%. 7 patients had no or little relief from surgery (29%). Moderate to severe degenerate changes in SC and IC joints on histology were found in 59% of patients. 91.6 % of these patients did well with surgery. Only 60 % of those with mild changes did well. Discography was possible in five out of six attempted cases. Two were positive and both did well from surgery. Three patients had negative discographies and two of them had a poor result and one had only some relief. Conclusions Degenerate changes in sacrococcygeal discs give rise to pain. Surgical results are better in those with a severe degree of degenerative change. It is possible to identify these with discography, though a larger study needs to be carried out

Purpose. By systematic literature review, to quantify the association between vertebral endplate signal changes (VESC) and non-specific low back pain (NSLBP). Materials and methods. MEDLINE, EMBASE, and SveMED databases were searched for the period 1984 to June 2009. Articles were included which investigated the association between VESC and NSLBP and reported sufficient data to construct two-by-two tables. Articles on specific low back pain conditions were excluded. A standardised data collection and quality assessment were performed. To estimate the association between VESC and NSLBP, two-by-two tables were created and exact odds ratios were calculated with 95% confidence intervals (CI). Meta-analysis was performed on homogeneous studies. Results. Fourteen articles met the inclusion criteria. A statistically significant positive association between VESC and NSLBP was found in 10 of 14 studies from the general, working, and clinical populations with odds ratios ranging from 2.0 to 27.9. Two of the other four studies showed positive associations, one study a neutral association and the other a negative association but all these results were not statistically significant. Meta-analysis of the eight discography studies included in the review showed a pooled odds ratio between VESC and pain on discography of 4.50 (CI 1.96-10.32). The median prevalence of pain on discography was 88.8% in people with VESC and 41.6% in those without VESC (46.8% overall). Conclusions. The results from this systematic review show that VESC in the lumbar spine is associated with pain and therefore should be noted routinely in MRI reports

Aim: To assess the outcome of patients with chronic discogenic lumbar back pain who underwent intradiscal electro thermal therapy (IDET). Design: A prospective longitudinal study. Subjects: Patients undergoing IDET in our unit between April 2000 and October 2007 were included in the study after assessment with discography and diagnostic imaging. Discographic concordant symptoms with subsequent abolition with local anaesthetic led to inclusion in the study regardless of discogram volume. Outcome Measures: Subjects were assessed preoperatively with VAS pain scores, SF36, demographic data and pain diagrams. Then were then reassessed postoperatively with the, VAS pain scores SF36, employment status and subjective outcome at 6, and 12 months. Results: 83 patients were treated with IDET. We had a follow up rate of 75% leaving a cohort of 65 patients. Mean follow up 7.6 months. Overall there was a mean improvement in pain VAS scores of 1.9 (p=0.0875). SF36 scores showed minimal improvement in both physical and mental parameters and there was minimal improvement in subjective outcome in 55% of patients. However it was observed that a small subgroup of patients (30%) aged less than 40 with low volume positive discography and single level disease mean pain VAS scores improved by 3.78 from 7.52 to 3.74. 72% of these patients reported a subjective improvement in symptoms and SF36 scores improved significantly compared to the overall group. Further analysis also revealed that the use of pain diagrams when interpreted according to the principles of Mann et al was the predictive value. Conclusions: Patient selection seems to be crucial in determining a successful outcome using IDET. We still perform this procedure on those patients aged less than 40 with single level disease, positive low volume discography, no facet joint arthritis and an organic pre procedure pain diagram

There are many difficulties associated with the localisation of the symptomatic segment in patients presenting with cervicobrachial pain with no evidence of impaired conduction in the nerve root. Ancillary radiological investigations such as myelography, epidural phlebography, and epidural myelograms are of unreliable diagnostic value. However, discography can be of value if the technique described here is used. Infiltration of the cervical nerve root with local anaesthetic has also proved useful in the localisation of the symptomatic segment. The techniques used in cervical discography and infiltration of the nerve root are described and their reliability is assessed

We report a series of 98 patients with back pain and sciatica in whom the MRI scan was reported as normal. The patients were referred by their General Practitioners and the MRI was the first and only investigation. The patients were subsequently subjected to plain radiographs including weight-bearing spot laterals of the lumbo-sacral spine, and discography in which pain provocation and reversal were judged as indicative of a pain source. Significant degenerative change was noted in plain radiographs in 27 cases, and weight-bearing views revealed a spondylolisthesis in eight cases where the supine view and MR had appeared normal. Discography had revealed intradiscal fissuring correlating with pain reproduction and reversal in 36 cases. MRI is a scarce resource with very long waiting lists in many parts of the country and the value of the investigation may have been exaggerated both in terms of false positive and false negative results. On the basis of our study we recommend a review of radiological policy

Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) of the spine produces images which reflect the chemical composition of the intervertebral disc. We have conducted a prospective study of the serial changes in the MRI appearance of the intervertebral disc after chemonucleolysis with the enzyme chymopapain. Fourteen patients were studied after single-level chemonucleolysis and the results compared with a control group of 17 discs in six patients who had diagnostic discography without enzyme insertion. A consistent pattern of gradual loss of signal from the nucleus pulposus culminating in complete loss of nuclear signal was seen in all cases after chemonucleolysis. Chymopapain therefore produced MRI changes analogous with premature gross disc degeneration. The rate at which this occurred varied; complete loss of signal took at least six weeks. Transitory minor end-plate changes were present in five patients, probably representing a mild chemical discitis. No similar changes were seen in the discography group

Objective: To report a randomised controlled trial (RCT) of the therapeutic efficacy of intradiscal steroid injection for the treatment of discogenic back pain after two years. Introduction: Discography remains the main method to assess whether a degenerate disc is the source of back pain. The treatment of such discogenic pain is difficult. There is only one previous RCT of the use intradiscal steroids, but with a short follow-up. Patients and Methods: 120 consecutive patients with positive discography were randomised intra-operatively to receive an intradiscal injection of saline or 40mgs Depomedrone. Outcome was assessed using a back pain questionnaire at six weeks, three and six months, and at two years. Pain (using a visual analogue score), disability (the Oswestry Disability Index), and psychological status (DRAM score) were measured. The results were correlated with Modic changes and high intensity zones on MRI scan. Results: An initial improvement of back pain in the steroid group is not maintained at two years, with no statistical difference between the two groups. Correlation of the results with the MRI findings will be presented. Conclusion: This study demonstrates the need for long-term follow-up of such intradiscal therapeutic methods of treating discogenic pain

Aims: MRI changes to the symptomatic intervertebral disc following Intradiscal Electrothermal Therapy (IDET), in particular those relating to the Ç High Intensity Zone È (HIZ) in the posterior annulus, were determined in this prospective study. Methods: MRI images before the IDET procedure were compared to those taken at six months post procedure in 10 patients. The presence and absence of an HIZ, the disc height and hydration, and Modic changes, were determined from the images. Two of the patients also had discography performed post-IDET to supplement the MRI. Results: In 6 out of the 10 patients, an HIZ was present on the MRI images of the disc before the IDET procedure. In all 6 patients, a HIZ was still present six months after the procedure. In all 10 patients, there were no changes to disc height and hydration signal on T2 weighted images. Modic changes were not present in any of the patients on pre or post IDET images. Two patients had signiþ-cant changes to the shape of the posterior annulus compared to the pre-treatment MRI scans. The two patients who had discography after IDET had persistent annular tears. Conclusion: Our þndings question the clinical relevance of the Ç High Intensity Zone È. They also suggest that the main mechanism of action of IDET, may be other than that of sealing the annular tear

Introduction: We report a series of 10 cases from a cohort of 421 Dynesys procedures in which evidence of Accelerated Adjacent Disc Disease (AASDD). Spinal fusion for degenerative disc disease is known to have inconsistent outcomes. One concern is the possibility of AASDD as a result of the altered kinematics. The Dynamic Neutralisation System (Dynesys) appears to offer an advantage in that it restricts, rather than abolishes movement at the treated segment, and should thereby reduce the problem of AASDD, In the event of failure, it can in addition be removed, returning the spine to the former status quo. Various biomechanical studies confirmed flexibility of Dynesys. Method: Ten patients developed new and symptomatic disc disease within segments adjacent to Dynesys. The average age of patients was 49 year with range between 36–70 years. Average post Dynesys to secondary surgery for ASD was 24.7 months. Previous discography and MRI in all cases had shown no evidence of disc disease within these adjacent segements prior to Dynesys. All patients were evaluated preoperatively using Oswestry Disability Index, SF 36 and Visual Analogue Scores together with plain x ray imaging, MRI scanning and discography. Of this cohort Dynesys was indicated to treat single disc level in 7 and two levels in 3. Results: Incidence of AASDD associated with Dynesys was 2.1%. Further surgical intervention included:. Extension of Dynesys10. Dynesys combined with MIF2. Dynesys combined with PLIF2. There was no caudal ASD in our cohort. Discussion & Conclusions: Dyensys did not prevent the development of accelerated ASD. Evidence from Aylott cadaver studies suggests that Dynesys instrumentation alters the Kinematics of the adjacent segment and increases the excursion. It is unclear whether the small number of AASDD reported here is other than the natural progression of degenerative change. 95.7 cases did not progress

Objective: MRI changes to the symptomatic intervertebral disc following Intradiscal Electrothermal Therapy (IDET), in particular those relating to the “High Intensity Zone” (HIZ) in the posterior annulus, were determined in this prospective study. Material and Methods: MRI images before the IDET procedure were compared to those taken at six months post procedure in 10 patients. The presence and absence of an HIZ, the disc height and hydration, and Modic changes, were determined from the images. Two of the patients also had discography performed post-IDET to supplement the MRI. Results: In 6 out of the 10 patients, an HIZ was present on the MRI images of the disc before the IDET procedure. In all 6 patients, a HIZ was still present six months after the procedure. In all 10 patients, there were no changes to disc height and hydration signal on T. 2. weighted images. Modic changes were not present in any of the patients on pre or post IDET images. Two patients had significant changes to the shape of the posterior annulus compared to the pre-treatment MRI scans. The two patients who had discography after IDET had persistent annular tears. Conclusion: Our findings question the clinical relevance of the “High Intensity Zone”. They also suggest that the main mechanism of action of IDET, may be other than that of sealing the annular tear

Introduction The aim of the study was to determine the prevalence of different causes of neck pain in a private practice clinic by a retrospective audit of records. Methods The study included all consecutive patients attending a private spine pain clinic in the state of Washington, USA, seen between January 2003 and January 2005, in whom a diagnosis of neck pain was made. The records of all patients were examined to determine the prevalence of various diagnostic entities determined by history, examination, and invasive tests such as controlled diagnostic blocks and provocation discography. Using different denominators, the prevalence of various conditions was determined in all patients who presented with neck pain, in patients in whom investigations were undertaken, and in patients who completed investigations. Results A large proportion of patients (35%) did not pursue investigations, which diluted the crude prevalence of various conditions. A further 17% deferred completing investigations. Amongst the 48% of patients who completed investigations, the prevalence of zygapophysial joint pain was 55%, discogenic pain was 16%, and lateral atlanto-axial joint pain was 9%. A diagnosis remained elusive in only 17% of those patients who completed investigations. Discussion In a private practice setting, a patho-anatomic diagnosis for chronic neck pain can be established in over 80% of patients, provided that appropriate investigations are undertaken. The prevalence of cervical zygapophysial joint pain encountered in the present study corroborates the prevalence rates established in academic studies. The observed prevalence of discogenic pain is probably an underestimate because not all eligible patients underwent discography

Thirteen patients with symptomatic disc herniation in the cervical spine were treated with percutaneous laser disc decompression (PLDD). Patients included 10 males and 3 females with a mean age of 41.4 (range, 24–60) years old. Preoperative symptom was divided into 2 types; myelopathy in 8 and radiculopathy in 5 patients. The level of the treated disc, which was diagnosed from the provoked cervicobrachial neuralgia during discography, distributed to C4/5 in 1, C5/6 in 8, C6/7 in 4 patients. The Nd:YAG laser (1064 nm) was percutaneously irradiated to the involved disc through a needle of 1.5 mm with a mean energy of 600 joules. Clinical evaluations were assessed with modified Macnab`s criteria at a mean follow-up period of 3 years (range, 0.5–5.7 years) excluding one patient who received open surgery 3 weeks after PLDD. Six patients (46.2%) showed good to excellent results without any significant complications. Four patients of 7 with unsuccessful results received a subsequent open surgery. There was no significant difference between successful and unsuccessful group in gender, disc level, preoperative duration of symptoms, positive provocation during discography, and the total amount of irradiated energy. Patients with successful results tended to be younger with a mean age of 35.7 years compared to those with unsuccessful results with a mean of 46.3 (p=0.053). Clinical outcome in two patients with radiculopathy were judged as excellent. Although postoperative MRI revealed few morphological changes on the disc in 2–3 weeks after PLDD, MRI at the final follow-up showed remarkable decrease of signal intensity in the disc. On postoperative radiographs, the disc height and the range of motion during flexion to extension in the treated discs significantly decreased, indicating the acceleration of disc degeneration and the resultant stabilization of the segment

Study Design: Prospective cohort study. Summary of Background data: A definite link between Modic end plate changes and discogenic low back pain has yet to be established. However, current prospective data indicates that Modic changes strongly correlate with the pain provocation of lumbar discography and improved clinical outcome following instrumented posterolateral fusion. Consequently, there is recent heightened awareness using this radiological entity in the selection of patients for interbody fusion or total disc replacement. Objective: To prospectively evaluate whether Modic changes can predict improved clinical outcome following antero-posterior lumbar interbody fusion using femoral ring allograft. Methods: A cohort of chronic low back pain patients were investigated with MRI and lumbar discography. Twenty-six patients with disco-graphically-proven concordant pain reproduction were prospectively entered into the study. Clinical results were collected using the Oswestry Disability Index (ODI), Visual Analogue Scale (VAS) and Short Form 36 Health Questionnaire (SF-36) at the pre-operative and two-year follow up. The minimal clinically important difference (MCID) was taken as 10 points for ODI, 2 points for VPAS, and 7 points for the physical function and bodily pain subset of the SF-36 questionnaire. Results: MRI scans evaluated for the level fused revealed 13 patients with no end-plate changes (Type 0), whilst 2 patients had Modic Type I and 11 had Modic Type II changes. MCID in ODI were achieved in Type 0, Type 1 and Type 2, but improvement in VAS only was achieved in the Type 0 and Type 1. For SF-36, the MCID of 7 points was reached in most domains for all types of Modic change. There was no statistical difference in clinical outcome between those patients with Modic Type 0 and those with Modic type I or II. Conclusion: This prospective study shows that Modic changes do not predict improved clinical outcome following antero-posterior interbody fusion using the femoral ring allograft

Purpose: In this prospective study we present the intermediate results of our experience using the Prodisc disc replacement for lumbar degenerative disc disease. Methods and Results: A total of 29 patients underwent Prodisc disc replacement by the senior author(AAH). There were 9 males and 20 females with a mean age of 39 years(Range 28–60 years). 18 patients had a single level disc replacement (L5/S1-- 14 patients, L4/5-- 4 patients). 11 patients had double level disc replacement (L4/5& L5/S1--7 patients, L3/4& L4/5--3 patients, L2/3& L3/4--1 patient). All patients were assessed pre-operatively with clinical examination, plain films, MRI scans and discography. The indication for surgery was discogenic pain at one or two adjacent segments confirmed with discography, minimum six months of conservative treatment, 20–60 years of age and an Oswestry score > 40%. All patients also agreed to a prearranged follow up protocol. Follow up included clinical examination, plain films and subjective evaluation using the Oswestry scale, Visual Analogue Scale and SF 36 scoring system at 6 weeks, 3 months, 6 months and annually. Results- The follow up range was from 3 months to 2 years. 26 patients had excellent to very good results and 2 patients had good results. There was one complication at 3 months post operatively. This patient sustained a fractured pedicle and underwent revision surgery involving removal of the prosthesis and Anterior Lumbar Fusion. At 6 months post revision a CT scan confirmed fusion. Rapid recovery was the most noticeable aspect of this study as well as rapid return to normal activities. Conclusion: The Prodisc disc replacement is a good treatment option for lumbar degenerative disc disease provided the operative indications are strictly adhered to. The early and mid term results presented are encouraging, however close follow up of these patients is essential to ascertain the long term results

Routine use of Computed Tomography (CT) to evaluate discogram morphology is time consuming, costly and incurs additional radiation hazards. In our spinal unit, discography is routinely performed without the aid of CT. Discogram morphology for different stages of disc degeneration is evaluated using the modified Adam’s grading system on images obtained on fluoroscopy. Our aims were to assess the validity of the modified Adam’s grading system of discogram morphology, by assessing its inter- and intra-observer agreement. We reviewed the discographic images (133 intervertebral levels) of 71 patients with chronic low back pain undergoing discography as part of a preoperative assessment between 1995 and 1997. Using the modified Adam’s grading system, three independent surgeon observers of three levels of experience (Senior Fellow, Senior and Junior residents) retrospectively evaluated the morphological appearance of each disc level in a randomized and blinded manner. Each observer was supplied with descriptions and illustrations of the 5 grades1, and each level was classified accordingly. The exercise was repeated three weeks later. The respective inter- and intra-observer agreements were calculated using the kappa statistic (Fleiss 1971) and generalized kappa statistic (Landis and Koch 1977). The inter-observer agreement was excellent (kappa = 0.77; standard error = 0.054). The intra-observer agreement for each of the three observers was also excellent (kappa = 0.8, 0.8, and 0.85 with respective standard errors = 0.046, 0.049 and 0.042). Significance and conclusions: The inter- and intra-observer agreement and therefore the reliability of the modified Adam’s grading system is excellent. This classification is easy to apply and has a high degree of reproducibility amongst observers with different levels of spinal experience. In view of the high reproducibility, we recommend the Adam’s classification for the grading of discogram morphology. The routine use of computed tomography with the concomitant radiation exposure and additional cost would seem not to be justified

Introduction and Objectives: This is a retrospective study on the treatment of lumbar degenerative disk disease (LDDD) using intervertebral arthroplasty. The lack of uniformity in the treatment of LDDD, persistence of pain even with solid fusion, and the possibility of changes over the fusion site have encouraged us to seek other solutions for this condition. Total intervertebral arthroplasty has been proposed as a possible alternative for selected cases of LDDD. Materials and Methods: Between November 1999 and July 2002, 16 patients with LDDD were treated surgically using third-generation total intervertebral arthroplasty (Link SB Charité III) with a chromium-cobalt alloy and ultra-high molecular weight (UHMW) poly-ethylene. Average follow-up time was 14 months (6-36 months), and average age was 42 years (35–52). There were 11 females and 5 males. All patients underwent radi-olographic studies, CT scan, MRI, and discography (minimum 2 levels). Indications included LDDD of one to three segments, absence of root tension signs, absence of complete disc collapse, and iconography including concordant discography. LDDD was primary in 11 cases and post-discectomy in 5 cases. Surgery was indicated when at least 6 months of conservative treatment failed to yield results. Blood loss and length of hospital stay were compared to a similar group that underwent posterolateral arthrodesis. Pain, function, and degree of disability were evaluated before and after surgery using GEER (1999) instruments for the evaluation of degenerative lumbar pathology. Increase in height of the posterior intervertebral space and segmentary lordosis were also measured. Results: Preoperative VAS: 7.8; postoperative VAS: 2.3. Disability index (Oswestry) was 41.3% preoperative and 10.8% postoperative. Average increase in height of posterior intervertebral space was 2.4mm, and mean segmental lordosis was 19.5°, which remained constant through the end of the follow-up period. Average hospital stay was 4.8 days (3–15) compared with 7.5 (5–18) for a group of patients who underwent suspended arthrodesis of L4–L5 with a much smaller quantity of blood loss. No infections were found. Complications: One patient developed an epidural haematoma, which was treated conservatively. Another developed a postoperative retroperitoneal haematoma, which was also treated conservatively. In neither case was there an adverse effect on the outcome of the procedure. One patient showed malpositioning of the prosthetic components on follow-up radiographs, with poor clinical progression at one year postoperative. The patient was treated with posterolateral fusion and right L5 foraminotomy. No infections were seen. Discussion and Conclusions: Treatment of LDDD with intervertrebral arthroplasty was shown to be effective in the short term, if strict guidelines are followed. Aggressive surgical management is highly inferior to conventional arthrodesis. A longer follow-up period is needed to confirm the validity of this treatment. Technical error in malpositioning of the components in one case caused a poor result

Purpose of the study: The endoscopic transforaminal approach to the lumbar disc proposed by A.T. Yeung has achieved world-wide acceptance. The Yeung endoscopic spinal system (YESS) used with a specific instrument set enables direct magnified optical control of discectomy performed under local anesthesia and neurolepanalgesia in the outpatient setting. We began our experience in 2003 and report here the results obtained in a consecutive series of 100 patients reviewed retrospectively. Material and methods: The inclusion criteria were patients with lumbar disc herniation-related lumbosciatic or crural pain non-responsive to well conducted medical care (including epidural or periradicular injections) for at least three months. The patients also had to display a concordant clinical and radiographic picture with confirmation of the symptomatic level by discography. Exclusion criteria were: excluded herniation with a fragment which had migrated into the canal; caudia equina syndrome; lower limb paralysis with muscle force scored less than 3; advanced-stage degernerative central bony stenosis affecting the clinical expression; pregnancy. The levels treated were: L3–L4 (n=6), L4–L5 (n=72), and L5–S1 (n=22). Herniation was forminal and extraforaminal in 53 cases, posterolateral in 31, and median in 16. There was an associated constitutional central stenosis in ten cases and in thirteen others, herniation was a recurrence after conventional surgery. Results: One hundred patients were reviewed at mean 18 months (range 12–34 months) follow-up. There were no serious neurological, vascular, or infectious complications. According to the McNab criteria outcome was good for 71 cases, fair for 16 and poor for 13 with 11 requiring revision with conventional surgery. Patients with foraminal and extraforminal herniation accounted for more than half of our series and responded best to treatment (84.9% good outcome) compared with posterolateral herniation (48%) (p< 0.05). Patients with median herniation had an intermediary outcome (68% good results). The least satisfactory outcome was observed at the L5–S1 level (63% fair and poor outcome), but the difference did not reach statistical significance compared with the higher levels. In patients with recurrent herniation after conventional surgery, there were four cases of failure. Discussion: These results are less satisfactory than those found in the literature. This might be explained by the less satisfactory outcome obtained with posterolateral herniations, probably because more than halve had migrated, generally above the plane of the disc, which in our experience cannot be accessed via the transforaminal approach. In addition, comparison of our first 50 cases with the last 50 showed an improvement in outcome to a mean 82%, expressing a learning curve for this type of technique. The most frequent error early in our experience was to insert the working endoscopic canula too anteriorly compared with the disc. The point of insertion must be very lateral determined by the discography in order to enter at least 30° posterior to the posterior part of the disc. Progressive fine-tuning of patient selection also helped improve outcome. YESS improves the work of the intradiscal instruments which can be control by direct view, explaining the the better results compared with the older mechanical or automatic (blind) methods. YESS is a very effective alternative to chemonucleolysis since papaine is no longer available. Compared with other endoscopic techniques for disectomy via an interlaminar approach, YESS offers the possibility of treatment patients in an outpatient setting with a local anesthesia. In addition the quality of the visual control of the foramen is better. These methods can be used in association with intradiscal Holmium-Yag laser which can also be applied to the bony walls of the foramen for a widening foraminoplasty. This transformainal endoscopic approach also offers a way to perform an exclusively foraminoscopic spondylodesis using an intersomatic cage. Conclusion: YESS is an excellent technique for non-migrated subligament posterolateral foraminal and extraforaminal herniations where conventional access to the foramen is known to be very difficult

The management of discogenic pain continues to be controversial. The results for operative and non-operative management are variable. This study aims to look at the results of interbody fusion versus dynamic stabilisation in patients with discogenic pain. Diagnosis was made by use of MRI and provocative discography. All patients had pre-operative Visual Analogue Scores and Oswestry Disability Index scores. Patients were then assessed in the post-operative period at 6 months, 1 year and 2 years. Case matched series with 19 patients in each group with a mean follow-up of 24 months. In comparison of both techniques there were no statistically significant differences but the dynamic stabilisation group had improved outcomes with both measures. The results did raise some further issues, as several patients in each group were either worse or had no significant improvement following surgery. In conclusion this paper raises concerns regarding the use of surgery for patients with discogenic pain. If surgery is however considered, dynamic stabilisation is a valid alternative to interbody fusion

To assess the effectiveness of dynamic stabilisation as a treatment for discogenic pain compared to standard treatment of interbody fusion. All patients were referred for a 2 year back-pain management programme. Patients with continued pain following conservative treatment underwent discography & MRI. Patients with painful degenerate discs on the above investigations were selected. Patients underwent interbody fusion (PLIF/TLIF) or dynamic stabilisation. Mean follow-up was 24 months with a minimum follow-up of 12 months. All patients had pre-operative ODI and VAS scores. Patients were then sent further questionnaires at 6 month intervals. The mean improvement in ODI following dynamic stabilisation was 20% (-20% → 56%), the mean improvement in the pain score was 2.4 (0→8). The mean improvement in ODI following interbody fusion was 11% (-14%→48%), the mean improvement in the pain score was 2.6 (-4→9). 10 patients in the dynamic stabilisation group had a greater than 20% improvement in ODI, 7 patients in the interbody fusion group had similar results. The above results demonstrate that dynamic stabilisation is at least as effective at treating discogenic pain as interbody fusion. The results however do question the validity of either interbody fusion (PLIF/TLIF) or dynamic stabilisation in the management of discogenic pain

Objective. To assess the effectiveness of dynamic stabilisation as a treatment for discogenic pain compared to standard treatment of interbody fusion. Study Design & Subjects. All patients were referred for a 2 year back-pain management programme. Patients with continued pain following conservative treatment underwent discography & MRI. Patients with painful degenerate discs on the above investigations were selected. Patients underwent interbody fusion (PLIF/TLIF) or dynamic stabilisation. Mean follow-up was 24 months with a minimum follow-up of 12 months. Outcome Measures. All patients had pre-operative ODI and VAS scores. Patients were then sent further questionnaires at 6 month intervals. Results. The mean improvement in ODI following dynamic stabilisation was 20% (-20% → 56%), the mean improvement in the pain score was 2.4 (0→8). The mean improvement in ODI following interbody fusion was 11% (-14%→48%), the mean improvement in the pain score was 2.6 (-4→9). 10 patients in the dynamic stabilisation group had a greater than 20% improvement in ODI, 7 patients in the interbody fusion group had similar results. Conclusion. The above results demonstrate that dynamic stabilisation is at least as effective at treating discogenic pain as interbody fusion. The results however do question the validity of either interbody fusion (PLIF/TLIF) or dynamic stabilisation in the management of discogenic pain

Persistent back pain in the presence of an intact posterior fusion is commonly seen and is often regarded as being psychogenic in origin. This paper discusses five patients, all of whom were chronically disabled by such pain; all five had a confirmed posterior and/or lateral fusion. In each case lateral discography identified the disc within the fused segment as the source of symptoms and pain relief was obtained with an anterior interbody fusion. This source of pain should be considered as a possibility in similar cases of failed back surgery

Introduction: We report the outcome two years following Dynesys for the treatment of Spinal Canal Stenosis. In both the FDA trial and the European multicentre study, stenosis was invariably combined with decompression, invalidating conclusions on the results of Dynesys alone. Method: Eighteen patients had symptomatic Spinal Canal Stenosis with root claudication sufficient to justify surgical intervention. Average age of patients was 68 with a range between 44–86 years. Dynesys was applied for the treatment of a single level in 4, two levels in 8, and more than two levels in 6. Patients were evaluated preoperatively using ODI, SF36, VAS, plain x-ray, MRI scanning & discography. Questionnaires were evaluated at the first and second years. Results: 2 patients had undergone previous spinal decompression, and decompression at the time of Dynesys surgery in 7. In the remaining 9 cases, no decompression was used, relying on distraction alone as in the X stop system. In this latter group, stenotic symptoms failed to resolve. Removal of Dynesys was indicated in 3 (16.6%). Discussion & Conclusions: Dynesys alone is not recommended as a treatment for symptomatic spinal stenosis. A separate study is required to address the question of whether Dynesys adjunct improves the back pain outcome compared with decompression alone

Objectives: The purpose of this study was to assess the effect of different types of posterior stabilisation on the fusion rate of anterior lumbar interbody fusion (ALIF). Thin section CT scanning has shown a higher rate of pseudarthrosis with ALIF than previously reported with standard radiological modalities. Cadaveric studies have demonstrated that posterior stabilisation would increase stiffness of the motion segment and is likely to enhance the rate of fusion with ALIF. The results of thin section CT scanning of ALIF, with and without posterior stabilisation, has not been reported previously. Methods: Patients with discogenic back pain confirmed by discography underwent ALIF surgery as a stand alone procedure or with posterior stabilisation – using trans-laminar screws, unilateral pedicle screws or bilateral pedicle screws. Patients were followed up prospectively and thin section CT scanning was used to assess inter-body fusion. Results: The fusion rate for stand alone ALIF was 51%, for patients with supplementary stabilisation with trans-laminar screws 58%, with unilateral pedicle screws 89% and with bilateral pedicle screws 88%. When ALIF was combined with pedicle screw stabilisation a significant difference in the fusion rate was found (p< 0.01). Conclusion: The addition of pedicle screw fixation at the time of ALIF produces a significant increase in the rate of interbody fusion

Introduction: The results of the FDA trial for Dynesys stabilisation implied that the procedure was effective as a method of treatment for this condition. However, all the American cases had adjunct decompressive treatment. In this study we report the outcome of the first two years following DYNESYS for Spondylolisthesis in two groups of patients; Dynesys alone and Dynesys with fusion. Method: Fifty five patients had Dynesys for symptomatic Spondylolisthesis which was indicated for surgical treatment. Average age for group 1 was 51 years with range of 36–85 years whereas in group 2, average age was 59 years with range of 31–79 years. Patients were evaluated preoperatively using ODI, SF36, VAS, plain x-ray, MRI scanning & discography. 33 of the patients underwent Dynesys alone (group 1) while 22 underwent dynesys with fusion (group 2). Previous decompression surgery was noted in 10 in group 1 and 8 in group 2. Results: In the first year following Dynesys, both groups did show significant improvement in all the four parameters; VAS (back and leg), ODI and SF36. In group 2 slight deterioration was noted in year 2 and while group 1 continued to improve, Subsequently 3 group 1 patients underwent fusion and 12 required removal/revision of Dynesys (40%). Discussion & Conclusions: Dynesys alone in the treatment of spondylolysthesis resulted in a 45% re-operation rate, and we believe it should not be recommended as an indication

Thirty-three patients who had undergone anterior cervical fusion for degenerative disc disease were reviewed to determine the efficacy of the procedure. Only patients who were available for examination and who had undergone operation at least one year previously were included in the review. Nearly all had had arm pain and three-quarters neck pain. Diminished neck movement and neurological abnormalities in the arms had been frequent findings. Diagnosis from the clinical features and plain radiographs is described. Myelography was not used routinely and discography was not used at all. Indications for operation and surgical technique are described. Results show that pain in the neck and arm was relieved in a high proportion of cases and that the neurological abnormalities often recovered. It is concluded that this operation is safe and has a definite place in the relief of pain from cervical disc degeneration resistant to conservative treatment

Introduction. We report the outcomes of minimally invasive technique for posterior lumbar interbody fusion (PLIF) procedure using Hollow Modular Anchorage (HMA) screws supplemented by routine pedicle screw fixation (Dynesis). Patients and Methods. Seventy-nine patients, who had undergone PLIF procedure using HMA screws supplemented by pedicle screw fixation, were included. Patients deemed suitable for surgery following discography under sedation, with Marcaine instillation establishing reducibility of the listhesis and temporary relief of symptoms. Clinical outcome included visual analogue scale scores for leg pain and back pain, Oswestry Disability Index (ODI) and SF-36 questionnaires. Results. Average age was 59 (range: 27-85). Mean follow- up was 5 years (range: 1-10). All cases went into union. None were lost to follow-up. Average length of stay was 24 hours (18-72 hours). All clinical parameters improved except SF-36. Mean ODI improved from 54 (range: 44-89) preoperatively to 33 (17-55) postoperatively (statistically significant, p=0.004). Back pain relief improved in visual analogue scale from average of 68 (range: 60-100) preoperatively to 37 postoperatively (range: 8:46) (statistically significant, p= 0.022). Leg pain relief improved from 53 (range: 31-100) preoperatively to 28 postoperatively (range: 4:60) (statistically significant, p= 0.007). Although mean SF-36 score improved from 37 (range: 10-41) preoperatively to 47 (range: 53-94) postoperatively (statistically insignificant, p=0.592). Complications included: one infection required removal of implant; two temporary motor weaknesses related to L5 nerve root; four required removal of the pedicle screw due to pain or loosening. Discussion. Our results are encouraging. Interbody HMA screws are porous hollow titanium screws with favourable biomechanical characteristics. Rather than square cages, they permit accurate placement of implant. Dynesys offers the option of extension and flexible support for the adjacent segment. Conclusion. PLIF supplemented with pedicle fixation is a reliable and safe procedure for degenerative spondylolisthesis. SF-36 is less sensitive for assessing spinal surgery outcome

Background: Spinal fusion for degenerative disc disease remains a controversial issue due to adjacent segment disease. Several alternatives have been evaluated; including Dynamic Neutralisation System for Spine and artificial disc arthroplasty. In our cohort study, we are highlighting advantages of DYNESYS over TDA and fusion as being a simple and reversible procedure if removal of implants is necessary. Materials and Methods: Prospective cohort study on 415 patients underwent DYNESYS. The implant has to be removed in 43 patients. Patients were evaluated preoperatively using Oswestry Disability Index, SF 36 and Visual Analogue Scores together with plain imaging and MRI scanning. Preoperative discography was performed in 81% of patients. Questionnaires were evaluated on subsequent follow up at 3 & 6 months, 1 year then at annual intervals. Results: Average treatment period was 26 months with a range from 3/12 to 60/12. The main reason for DYNE-SYS removal was screws’ failure or loosening followed by infections. The implant was used to treat single disc space in 20.9%, two spaces in 67.4% and three disc spaces in 9.3%. 81% of the screws were not Hydroxy-appetite coated. No loosening was detected among HA coated screws. Outcome assessment revealed significant improvement in SF36 even after removal of stabilising system while no worsening of ODI or VAS in comparison with preoperative status. Conclusions: DYNESYS can maintain disc height and restricts movements exceeding physiological limits. HA coated screws have superior biomechanical characteristics in preventing screw loosening and subsequent spinal spasms. If necessary, removal of implants is a simple procedure

Background: Spinal fusion for degenerative disc disease remains a controversial issue due to adjacent segment disease. Several alternatives have been evaluated; including Dynamic Neutralisation System for Spine and artificial disc arthroplasty. In our cohort study, we are highlighting advantages of DYNESYS over TDA and fusion as being a simple and reversible procedure if removal of implants is necessary. Material & Methods: Prospective cohort study on 415 patients underwent DYNESYS. The implant has to be removed in 43 patients. Patients were evaluated preoperatively using Oswestry Disability Index, SF 36 and Visual Analogue Scores together with plain imaging and MRI scanning. Preoperative discography was performed in 81% of patients. Questionnaires were evaluated on subsequent follow up at 3/12, 6/12 then at annual intervals. Results: Average treatment period was 26 months with a range from 3/12 to 60/12. The main reason for DYNE-SYS removal was screws’ failure or loosening followed by infections. The implant was used to treat single disc space in 20.9%, two spaces in 67.4% and three disc spaces in 9.3%. 81% of the screws were not Hydroxy Appetite coated. No loosening was detected among HA coated screws. Outcome assessment revealed significant improvement in SF36 even after removal of stabilising system while no worsening of ODI or VAS in comparison with preoperative status. Conclusions: DYNESYS can maintain disc height and restricts movements exceeding physiological limits. HA coated screws have superior biomechanical characteristics in preventing screw loosening and subsequent spinal spasms. If necessary, removal of implants is a simple procedure

Anterior lumbar interbody fusion (ALIF) is an accepted surgical treatment for disabling discogenic pain. Additional posterior fixation has been advocated. This is a prospective clinic al study evaluating a stand-alone anterior fusion cage with an integrated titanium plate and four divergent locking screws. Patients who had failed conservative management for lumbar discogenic pain were recruited into the study. All underwent diagnostic discography. Surgery was performed through an anterior retro-peritoneal approach. The fusion cage was packed with autogenous bone graft. Outcome measures included: Visual Analogue Scores (VAS), Oswestry Disability Index (ODI) and SF-36 data. Fine-cut CT was performed at one and two years post-operatively. Fusion was defined as continuous bony trabeculae joining the vertebral bodies. Fifty levels were operated on in 39 patients with a mean age of 40.8 years (22–55). The mean operative time was less than 120 minutes, and mean blood loss less than 100 mls. Radiographic fusion at one year was 78% and 100% at two years. Two year mean VAS sc ores for back pain improved from 7.0 to 3.7 (p< 0.01) and for leg pain from 6.1 to 3.1 (p< 0.01). The mean ODI scores decreased from 50.7 to 31.7 (p< 0.01), and SF-36 (PCS) scores increased from 28.4 to 37.5 (p< 0.01). There were no major complications and no patients have required supplementary posterior fixation. This technique is safe and is as effective as 360° fusion in achieving fusion in the management of discogenic back pain over one and two levels. This technique has the advantage of avoiding the morbidity associated with additional posterior fixation

Purpose And Background: In patients with chronic low back pain (LBP), selective injection procedures (provocative discography, medial branch, facet and sacroiliac joint blocks) have shown the pain source to be the intervertebral disc in 40%, the sacroiliac joint in 13–19% and the facet joints in 15–40%. No individual features in the history or examination are of consistent discriminatory value in diagnosis. This study aimed to assess whether patients with different pain sources could be differentiated using the Oswestry Disability Index (ODI) (a validated patient questionnaire scoring ten different aspects of pain and function in patients with LBP; higher scores correlating with greater disability). Methods And Results: ODI scores were recorded from 67 patients (46 female, age 17–82) whose source of LBP was subsequently confirmed by selective injection. The scores for each section of the ODI were compared between patients grouped according to pain origin; disc (n=11), sacroiliac (n=31) or facet (n=25). Patients with disc pain had significantly greater overall disability and scored higher for sitting, sleeping and social activity than those with facet or sacroiliac pain as judged by the 95% confidence limits of the median (p< 0.05). Patients with facet pain scored higher for walking and standing compared to those with sacroiliac pain. For disc pain scores were higher for sitting and standing than for walking, and for facet pain scores were higher for standing than for sitting or walking. Conclusion: Although the ODI is not a diagnostic tool, analysis of its components reveals characteristic pain and disability patterns in patients sub-grouped according to pain source

Aim: To investigate the use of the Graf Dynamic Stabilisation System for the treatment of multi-level discogenic pain associated with symptoms of ‘instability’. Introduction: Indications for the use of the Graf Ligament system remain controversial. There is a small group of patients who present with severely disabling pain with failed conservative treatment, of discogenic origin at more than one level, and associated with symptoms of so-called ‘instability’ (acute pain related to position and movement), for whom treatment is extremely difficult. Methods: Twenty-two consecutive adult patients of working age with this clinical picture, with discogenic pain at two or three levels confirmed by discography, were treated with the Graf Ligament System. They were prospectively studied, and reviewed by an independent assessor. Results: At an average of three year follow up, 50% had good or excellent results including return to work, 18% fair, and 32% were no better. None were worse. Correlation with pre-operative MRI findings and complications will be discussed. Conclusions: Whilst such dynamic systems may have a role in the treatment of discogenic pain, the success rate in this series does not justify its continued use for this indication without further research into the theoretical basis of the action of such dynamic stabilisation systems and the entry of all cases into prospective controlled trials

Primary disc space infections are thought to occur in children because of the abundant vascularity of the disc prior to skeletal maturity, and while they generally resolve with treatment, little is known about the long-term consequences on the spine. An ovine model of discitis was used to investigate the effects of discitis on spinal development in the growing sheep. Six-week-old lambs underwent lumbar discography at multiple spinal levels using either radiographic contrast inoculated with Staphylococcus epidermidis (inoculated group) or radiographic contrast only (control group). Plain x-rays of the spines were taken at intervals up to 18 months before the animals were killed and the spines removed for histologic and morphometric analysis. Discs from animals in the control group were radiologically and histologically normal at all time points, and as expected there was a steady increase in vertebral body and disc dimensions. Although not all inoculated animals showed histologic evidence of discitis, disc abnormalities were evident from an early stage. In particular disc height was significantly reduced from 2 weeks after inoculation and vertebral body dimensions were significantly reduced from one year. Infection of discs at a young age, whether or not it progresses to discitis, has a significant effect on spinal development