Summary

We report the first use of synchrotron xray spectroscopy to characterize and compare the chemical form and distribution of metals found in tissues surrounding patients with metal-on-metal hip replacements that failed with (Ultima hips) or without (current generation, large diameter hips) corrosion.

Metal-on-metal (MOM) hip resurfacings release chromium and cobalt wear debris into the surrounding joint. The hip tissue taken from failed MOM hips shows specific histological features including a subsurface band-like infiltrate of macrophages with particulate inclusions, perivascular lymphocytic infiltrate and fibrin exudation. This tissue response has been called Aseptic Lymphocytic Vasculitis Associated Lesion (ALVAL).

There is a recognised carcinogenic potential associated with hexavalent chromium and epidemiological data from first generation MOM arthroplasties may suggest an increased incidence of haematological malignancy. The ALVAL type reaction includes a marked proliferation of lymphocytes in the perivascular space and thorough investigation of this lymphocytic response is warranted.

This study aims to further characterise the lymphocytic infiltrate using immunohistochemistry and to test clonality using polymerase chain reaction (PCR).

Tissues from revised all cause failed MOM hip arthroplasties (n=77) were collected and analysed initially using routine H&E staining. Those that met the diagnostic criteria of ALVAL described above (n=34) were further stained with a panel of immunohistochemical markers (CD3, CD4, CD8 (T-cell markers) and CD20 (B-cell marker)). 10 representative ALVAL cases were selected and sent for gene rearrangement studies using PCR to determine whether the lymphocytes were polyclonal or monoclonal in nature.

The analysis of the lymphocytic aggregates in ALVAL, showed a mixed population of B and T cells. Within the aggregates, there was a predominance of B cells (CD20) over T cells (CD3). Of the 10 cases which were analysed by PCR, 7 were suitable for interpretation. None of these cases showed evidence of monoclonal lymphocyte proliferation.

The carcinogenic potential of wear debris from MOM hips, particularly affecting the haematopoietic system should be investigated. This study has shown a predominantly B-lymphocyte response in tissues surrounding MOM hips which is polyclonal. Although the numbers are small, the study suggests an immune mediated response in MOM hip tissue and excludes a neoplastic proliferation.

However, long term follow up of patients with MOM hips may be prudent.

Introduction: Local problems of metal on metal (MOM) hip arthroplasty such as pseudotumours, neck thinning and osteolysis maybe related to concentrations of cobalt and chromium ions in the synovial fluid. There is little reported on these values. Our aim was to determine the range of metal ion levels in synovial fluid, and to investigate the relationship between these samples and simultaneous blood samples.

Methods: Synovial fluid and whole blood samples were taken from 30 consecutive patients at the time of revision surgery for a painful MOM hip. Aspirated fluid was not visibly contaminated with blood. Impants were in situ for a mean period of 31 months. All had normal renal function. Samples were analysed using ICP mass spectrometry and compared with 10 samples from patients without implants.

Results: The mean (and range) of synovial fluid metal ion levels were 1965 ug/l (30 to 13618) and 6265 ug/l (11 to 81630) for Cobalt and Chromium respectively. There was a good correlation between synovial and blood levels for both cobalt (R=0.65, p = 0.0001) and chromium (R = 0.59, p = 0.006).

Discussion and Conclusion: Metal ions in synovial fluid from MOM hips are generated from wear of the bearing surfaces, the correlation with blood metal ion levels, shown in this study, suggest that blood levels may be used as surrogate marker for hip wear rate. Our range of synovial fluid metal ion levels may be useful for those conducting in vitro studies on the biocompatibility of MOM hips.