In relation to the conduct of this study, one or more of the authors is in receipt of a research grant from a non-commercial source.
All patients over 65 yrs with an ISS greater than 15 attending Edinburgh Royal Infirmary between 1997 and 2000 were prospectively entered into the study. Patients were followed until death or discharge home. The patients were divided into, group 1 [patients who survived], and group 2 [those who died.] A total of 72 patients were included in the study, 42 males and 31 females. 42 patients survived, and 31 died. Group 1 consisted of 29 males and 15 females with an average age of 75.23yrs. Group 2 consisted of 13 males and 18 females with an average age of 78.05yrs. All incidents involved blunt trauma. The three main mechanisms of injury were RTA, Fall less than 2 meters, and Fall greater than 2 meters. Five patients required intubation in group 1 and 12 patients in group 2.The average GCS was lower in group 1 compared to the group 2. All Injuries with AIS of greater than 3 were analysed. The total number of injuries was greater in the group 2. Group 1 required 214 days in HDU/ITU and a total of 943 in-patient days. Group 2 in comparison needed 62 HDU/ITU days and 169 in-patient days. The major cause of death was head and spinal injury 11 (35%), and Multiple injuries 9 (29%). A total number of 1952 days were spent in rehabilitation prior to discharge, with an average of 46.48 days. Post trauma the level of independence was significantly reduced. The injuries are exclusively blunt and in the majority of cases secondary to motor vehicle accidents. Predictors of mortality appear to include, intubation, head and neck injuries, GCS, and chest injuries. Current outcome scores correlate inaccurately. These patients require long hospital stays with a large amount of intensive care input. After discharge rehabilitation is universally required. These patients place a large demand on the NHS and social services; the total cost of their care was approximately £2,500,000.
Humeral hemi arthroplasty has become widely used as a form of surgical management for severe fractures. However there is still no consensus as to the role for prosthetic replacement in displaced proximal humeral fractures. The aim was to assess shoulder hemi arthroplasty for un-reconstructable three and four part proximal humeral fractures at a minimum of twelve months and identify factors that guide to prognosis. Criteria for inclusion were patients with a fracture that went onto shoulder hemi arthroplasty with Constant scoring at a minimum follow up of one year. Patients were treated using a Neer or Osteonics prosthesis, with the decision for hemi arthroplasty being made at the time of surgery. Post-operative management was standardised. An independent functional assessment, record review establishing a physiological index according to comorbidities, and a radiological analysis were carried out. A survival analysis was performed for the one and five year results and data was analysed by linear regression to identify prognostic factors. Of 163 patients there were 138 fitting the criteria, 42 males and 96 females with an average age of 68.5 (range30–90) years and average follow up of 6.3 (range1–15) years. The fracture pattern was three or four part in 133 cases and 5 head split fractures; 58 were associated with a dislocation. Survival was 96.4% at 1 year and 93.6% at 5 years, with no significant difference between prostheses. There were 8 revisions, (1 deep infection, 4 dislocations and 3 peri-prosthetic fractures), most within 12 months. The average Constant score was 67.1 at one year. Prognostic factors on presentation were the age of the patient and their physiological index. Factors at 3 months were any complication, the position of the implant, tuberosity union and persistent neurological deficit. Overall optimum outcome was gained by patients aged 55–60, with minimal comorbidities and an uncomplicated recovery.
We reviewed the results of the treatment of 30 tibial fractures with minor to severe bone loss in 29 patients by early soft-tissue and bony debridement followed by primary locked intramedullary nailing. Subsequent definitive closure was obtained within the first 48 hours usually with a soft-tissue flap, and followed by bone-grafting procedures which were delayed for six to eight weeks after the primary surgery. The time to fracture union and the eventual functional outcome were related to the severity and extent of bone loss. Twenty-nine fractures were soundly united at a mean of 53.4 weeks, with delayed amputation in only one patient. Poor functional outcome and the occurrence of complications were usually due to a departure from the standard protocol for primary management. We conclude that the protocol produces satisfactory results in the management of these difficult fractures, and that intramedullary nailing offers considerable practical advantages over other methods of primary bone stabilisation.
We reviewed 63 patients with fractures of the distal tibial metaphysis, with or without minimally displaced extension into the ankle joint. The fractures had been caused by two distinct mechanisms, either a direct bending force or a twisting injury. This influenced the pattern of the fracture and its time to union. All fractures were managed by statically locked intramedullary nailing, with some modifications of the procedure used for diaphyseal fractures. There were few intra-operative complications. At a mean of 46 months, all but five patients had a satisfactory functional outcome. The poor outcomes were associated with either technical error or the presence of other injuries. We conclude that closed intramedullary nailing is a safe and effective method of managing these fractures.
We describe a new technique for open reduction, bone grafting and fixation with a single Kirschner wire of unstable fractures of the distal radius. Of the 83 patients treated by this technique, most had regained volar tilt when seen at an average of 13 months after injury. Malunion was seen in 18 patients due either to poor placement of the graft and Kirschner wire or because of both volar and dorsal comminution. Assessment of hand and wrist function showed an average recovery of 63% of mass grip strength with an excellent return of specialised grip strength and range of movement. The advantages of this technique over closed methods include the ability to regain the volar tilt of the distal radius and to achieve reduction at any time before union of the fracture.
We performed an epidemiological analysis of 523 fractures treated in the Edinburgh Orthopaedic Trauma Unit over a three-year period using modern descriptive criteria. The fractures were defined in terms of their AO morphology and their degree of comminution, location and cause. Closed fractures were classified using the Tscherne grading system and open fractures according to the Gustilo classification. Further analysis of fractures caused by road-traffic accidents and football was carried out. The use of the AO classification allowed the common fracture patterns to be defined. Correlation of the classification systems showed an association between the AO morphological system and the Tscherne and Gustilo classifications. The relative rarity of severe tibial fractures is indicated and it is suggested that in smaller orthopaedic units the infrequency of these fractures has implications for training and the development of treatment protocols.
Exchange nailing for failure of union after primary intramedullary nailing of the tibia is widely used but the indications and effectiveness have not been reported in detail. We have reviewed 33 cases of uninfected nonunion of the tibia treated by exchange nailing. This technique was successful without open bone grafting in all closed fractures and in open fractures of Gustilo types I, II and IIIa. The requirement for open bone grafting was reduced in type-IIIb fractures, but exchange nailing failed in type-IIIb fractures with significant bone loss. For these we recommend early open bone grafting. The most common complication was wound infection, seen more often than after primary nailing. We discuss our protocol for the use and timing of exchange nailing of all grades and types of tibial fracture.
We report the results of a three-year study of bifocal fractures of the tibia and fibula, excluding segmental shaft fractures. In our whole series, these formed 4.7% of all tibial diaphyseal fractures. We describe three groups: bifocal fractures of both the proximal and the distal joint surfaces, fractures of the shaft and tibial plateau, and fractures of the shaft and ankle. These groups of fractures had different characteristics and prognoses. We discuss treatment protocols for each of these three groups.
We reviewed a series of 79 distal radial fractures with volar displacement which had been fixed internally using a buttress plate. The fractures were classified using the Frykman and AO systems; 59% were intraarticular. Complications occurred in 40.5% of cases; malunion was most frequent (28%). Functional recovery in patients with malunion was significantly worse than in those with good anatomical restoration (p <
0.001). The AO and Frykman classifications and the degree of restoration of volar tilt were predictive of outcome.