Radiolucencies are generally thought to be a manifestation of loosening. They are commonly seen under the tibial component of the Oxford Unicompartmental knee replacement. However, they are not associated with long term failure [1]. The aim of this study was to investigate any relationship between radiolucencies and component migration.

Eight medial Oxford Unicompartmental knee prostheses were examined post-operatively, at 12 months and at 24 months using Roentgen Stereophotogrammetric Analysis (RSA). The serial radiographs were calibrated and three dimensional CAD models were matched to the extracted component shapes. Implanted bone marker balls were then selected on all radiographs. The components were superimposed. Migration calculation was achieved by comparing relative positions of components to bone marker balls in the serial radiographs. Fluoroscopically screened X-rays were taken to determine whether there were any radiolu-cencies under the tibial component.

By 12 months, the femoral component had migrated significantly anteriorly (0.35 mm) and proximally (0.61 mm). The tibial component had migrated significantly distally (0.42 mm) and anteriorly (0.47 mm). Although on average there appeared to be a small further migration between 12 and 24 months, this was not statistically significant in any direction.

Six of the eight patients had radiolucencies at 24 months. None of the radiolucencies were was complete. The maximum radiolucency was 1 mm thick and the average was 0.57 mm. There was no correlation between radiolucency and migration.

The proximal femoral migration and distal tibial migration can be explained by the load across the knee. We cannot yet explain the anterior tibial migration. Radiolucencies almost always occur and are not related to migration.This confirms they are not associated with loosening.

The aim of the study was to measure in-vivo the 10-year linear and volumetric polyethylene wear of a fully congruent mobile bearing unicompartmental knee arthroplasty (OUKA).

We studied six OUKA’s that had all been implanted 10 years previously. Each patient was examined in even double leg stance at a range of knee flexion angles, in a calibration cage. A stereo pair of X-ray films was acquired for each patient at 0°, 15° and 30° of flexion. The films were analysed using an RSA style calibration and a CAD model silhouette-fitting technique. The position and orientation of each femoral and tibial component was found relative to each other and the bearing position inferred. Penetration of the femoral component into the original volume of the bearing was our estimate of linear wear. The volumetric wear is calculated from the measured linear wear and the known surface area of the bearing. In addition eight control patients were examined less than 3 weeks post-operation where no wear would be expected.and 30We studied seven OUKA’s that had all been implanted at least 10 years previously. A stereo pair of X-ray films was acquired for each patient at 0 Results: The control group showed no measured wear. The seven OUKA’s had an average maximum depth of linear penetration of 0.40 mm at a mean follow-up of 10.9 years. The linear wear rate was 0.033 mm/year. The volumetric material loss was 79.8 mm3. If a steady gradual material loss is assumed, 8 mm3 of UHMWPE was lost per year.

Polyethylene particulate wear debris continues to be implicated in the aetiology of component loosening and implant failure knee following arthroplasty. The OUKA employs a spherical femoral component and a fully congruous meniscal bearing to increase contact area and theoretically reduce the potential for polyethylene wear. The results from this in-vivo study confirm that the device has low 10-year linear and volumetric wear in clinical practice. This may protect the device from component loosening in the long term.

When the Oxford unicompartmental meniscal bearing arthroplasty (UCA) is used in the lateral compartment of the knee 10% of the bearings dislocate. An in-vitro cadaveric study was performed to investigate if the anatomy and joint geometry of the lateral compartment was a contributory factor in bearing dislocation. More specifically, the study investigated if the soft tissue tension of the lateral compartment, as determined by the length of the lateral collateral ligament (LCL), was related to bearing dislocation. A change in length of greater than 2 mm is sufficient to allow the bearing to dislocate.

The Vicon Motion Analysis System (Oxford Metrics, Oxford, UK) was used to assess length changes in the LCL of seven cadaveric knees. Measurements were made of the LCL length through knee flexion and of the change in LCL length when a varus force was applied at a fixed flexion angle. Measurements were made in the normal knee and with the knee implanted with the Oxford prosthesis.

In the intact knee the mean LCL change was 5.5mm (8%) over the flexion range. After implantation with the Oxford UCA the mean change in length was only 1 mm (1%). There was a significant difference in the LCL length at 90° (p=0.03) and 135° (p=0.01) of knee flexion compared to the intact knee. When a varus force was applied the LCL length change of the intact knee (5.4 mm) was significantly different (p=0.02) to that of the knee with the prosthesis implanted (2.7 mm)

This study used a new method to dynamically measure LCL length. It found that after implantation of the Oxford lateral UCA the LCL remains isometric over the flexion range and does not slacken in flexion as it in the normal knee. This would suggest that the soft tissue tension was adequate to contain the bearing within the joint.

However, when a varus force was applied the LCL did not sufficiently resist a displacing force producing an LCL length change greater than 2 mm.

The evidence provided by this study is contradictory. The “lack of change in LCL length through flexion” suggests that the ligament remains tight through range and is unlikely to allow dislocation. However, the amount of distraction possible when an adducting moment is applied is sufficient to allow bearing dislocation. The length tension properties of the lateral structures are therefore implicated in the mechanism of dislocation.

The indications for unicompartmental knee arthroplasty (UKA) can be contentious. Concerns exist about implanting a UKA in younger individuals. It has been reported that it is contra-indicated in patients under the age of 60. The suggestion is that younger patients may compromise their outcome after surgery by their increased activity levels. However, the number of publications with data on UKA in young patients is minimal and the age/activity related criteria for UKA remains unknown.

The aim of the study was 1) to confirm that younger UKA patients have higher activity levels than older patients, and 2) to test the hypothesis that younger, more active patients have inferior outcome when compared to older less active patients.

Fifty consecutive patients undergoing UKA who were under 60 years (Group Y) and 50 patients over 60 years (Group O) were recruited. Indications were anteromedial arthritis with full thickness lateral compartment cartilage, a functioning ACL and a correctible varus. All patients underwent Oxford UKA using the minimally invasive technique. This device employs an unconstrained fully congruous meniscal bearing. Outcome was evaluated using Knee Society Scores. Activity level was documented using Tegner Activity Score.

Average age of patients for group Y and O was 55 and 68 years respectively. Minimum follw-up was 2 years. pre-op. knee scores were comparable for each group. (y: 38.8, O: 35.8) and patients in both groups siginificantly improved after surgery. A significant difference in Tegner score was found between the two groups after surgery (y:4.1, O:2.6). More than 50% of younger patients regularly participated in high demand activities like skiing, tennis and manual labour. No statistically significant differences in any other post op. knee scores or complication rate were found despite adequate study power.

Younger patients have increased activity levels after UKA when compared to an older age group. There is no evidence that the outcome of UKA in younger more active patients will be inferior to those who are older and more sedentary.

Polyethylene wear can be an important cause of knee replacement failure.

Six TKRs in young, active patients with excellent Oxford Knee Scores and Knee Society Scores, mean 76 months post knee replacement and 5 control patients, 2 weeks post TKR, were selected. Each patient had weight bearing stereo radiographs of at 0, 15, 30, 45 and 60 degrees of flexion while standing in a calibration grid. These x-rays were analysed using our Radio Stereometric Analysis (RSA) system. The three-dimensional shape of the TKR (manufacturer’s computer aided design model) was matched to the TKR silhouette on the calibrated stereo radiographs for each angle of flexion. The relative positions of the femoral and tibial components in space were then determined and the linear and volumetric penetration was calculated using Matlab software.

The accuracy of the system was found to be 0.3mm (CAD model tolerance 0.25mm). The mean linear wear in the control patients was 0.02mm (range −0.19 to +0.23mm). Average linear penetration in the study group was found to be 0.6 mm at 6 years, giving an overall linear wear rate of 0.1mm/year. Average penetration volume at 76 months was 399mm3. The average volumetric wear rate was 63mm3/year.

It is possible to measure volumetric wear in vivo using RSA. Volumetric wear rate was found to be 63mm3 per year. Studies on retrieved normally functioning hip replacements have shown volumetric wear rates of 35mm3 per year. However, clinical outcomes of knee replacements are comparable to those of hip replacements, suggesting that the knee has a more effective mechanism for dealing with polyethylene wear particles.

To report a 15-year survival analysis of the Oxford Medial Unicompartmental Knee Arthroplasty (Oxford UKA) in an independent series.

We report the results of a series of 420 Oxford UKAs performed between 1983 and 2000. Indications for surgery were primary antero-medial osteoarthritis of the knee with an intact ACL, correctable varus deformity of < 15° and < 15° fixed flexion deformity. The state of the patello-femoral joint was not used as a selection criterion. Patients were contacted by a postal questionnaire or by telephone. The outcome of all 420 knees was established, with none lost to follow-up. Seventy-six knees were in patients who had died and the state of each arthroplasty was determined from hospital and GP records.

Seventeen patients (4%) had required revision. Indications for revision were lateral compartment arthrosis (7), component loosening (4), bearing dislocation (4) and infection (2). There were no failures for polyethylene wear. Cumulative survival at 15 years was 94.3% [95% CI 3.8%]. The worst case scenario was 94.3% as none were lost to follow-up.

The results from an independent series are important, as they avoid bias. The 15-year results of this independent series are better than any other reported series of unicompartmental device at 15 years and as good as the published independent 15 year survival results for total knee arthroplasty. The data illustrates that excellent long-term survival can be achieved with the Oxford UKA, allowing patients to benefit from the advantages that unicompartmental arthroplasty offers. We believe that provided patients are selected appropriately, this device provides the treatment of choice for anteromedial osteoarthritis of the knee.

Introduction: The indications for unicompartmental knee arthroplasty (UKA) can be contentious. Concerns exist about implanting a UKA in younger individuals and it has been reported that the procedure is contra-indicated in patients under the age of 60. The suggestion is that younger patients may compromise their outcome after surgery by their increased activity levels. However, the number of publications with data on UKA in young patients is minimal and the age/activity related criteria for UKA remains unknown.

Aim: The aim is twofold: 1) to confirm that younger UKA patients have higher activity levels than older patients, and 2) to test the hypothesis that younger, more active patients have inferior outcome when compared to older less active patients.

Materials and methods: Fifty consecutive patients undergoing UKA who were under 60 years old at the time of surgery (Group Y) and 50 patients over 60 years (Group O) were recruited. Indications were anteromedial arthritis with full thickness lateral compartment cartilage, a functioning ACL and a correctible varus deformity. All patients underwent Oxford UKA using the minimally invasive technique. This device employs an unconstrained fully congruous meniscal bearing. Outcome was evaluated using the American Knee Society Score (AKSS). Activity level was documented using the established Tegner Activity Score.

Results: The average age of patients for group Y and O was 55 years and 68 years respectively. Minimum follow up for both groups was 2 years. Pre-operative AKSS scores were comparable for each group (Group Y = 38.8, Group O = 35.8) and patients in both groups significantly improved after surgery. A significant difference in Tegner score was found between groups after surgery (Group Y = 3.9, Group O = 2.6). It was found that 40% of younger patients regularly participate in high demand activities like skiing, tennis, hard manual labour and swimming. No statistically significant difference in any other post operative knee scores or complication rate were found despite adequate study power.

Conclusions: Younger patients have increased activity levels after UKA when compared to an older age group. There is no evidence that the outcome of UKA in younger more active patients will be inferior to those who are older and more sedentary.

Introduction: Polyethylene wear can be an important cause of knee replacement failure.

Method: Six TKRs in young, active patients with excellent Oxford Knee Scores and Knee Society Scores, mean 76 months post knee replacement and 5 control patients, 2 weeks post TKR, were selected. Each patient had weight bearing stereo radiographs of at 0, 15, 30, 45 and 60 degrees of flexion while standing in a calibration grid. These x-rays were analysed using our Radio Stereometric Analysis (RSA) system. The three-dimensional shape of the TKR (manufacturer’s computer aided design model) was matched to the TKR silhouette on the calibrated stereo radiographs for each angle of flexion. The relative positions of the femoral and tibial components in space were then determined and the linear and volumetric penetration was calculated using Matlab software.

Results: The accuracy of the system was found to be 0.3mm (CAD model tolerance 0.25mm). The mean linear wear in the control patients was 0.02mm (range −0.19 to +0.23mm). Average linear penetration in the study group was found to be 0.6 mm at 6 years, giving an overall linear wear rate of 0.1mm/year. Average penetration volume at 76 months was 399mm³. The average volumetric wear rate was 63mm³/year.

Conclusion: It is possible to measure volumetric wear in vivo using RSA. Volumetric wear rate was found to be 63mm³ per year. Studies on retrieved normally functioning hip replacements have shown volumetric wear rates of 35mm³ per year. However, clinical outcomes of knee replacements are comparable to those of hip replacements, suggesting that the knee has a more effective mechanism for dealing with polyethylene wear particles.

*Oxford Hip and Knee Group: P McLardy-Smith, C Dodd, D Murray & R Gundle