Ankle fractures are common injuries presenting to trauma departments and ankle open reduction and internal fixation (ORIF) is one of the first procedures targeted in early orthopaedic training. Failure to address the fracture pattern with the appropriate surgical technique and hardware may lead to early failure resulting in revision procedures or premature degenerative change. Patients undergoing revision ORIF are known to be at much greater risk of complications, and many of these secondary procedures may be preventable. A retrospective analysis of all patients attending our unit for ankle ORIF over a two year period was undertaken. Patients were identified from our Bluespier database and a review of X rays was undertaken. All patients undergoing re-operation within eight weeks of the primary procedure were studied. The cause of primary failure was established and potential contributing patient and surgical factors were recorded.Introduction
Method
Several studies have shown that Is there a specific patient population at increased risk of Background
Study Question
Ankle intra-articular pathology after acute injury is common and often under-diagnosed. While the majority of soft tissue injuries improve with rehabilitation, up to 40% of patients experience chronic pain, stiffness or instability. MRI is increasingly used in the investigation of such patients; however interpretation of MRI findings requires specialist expertise. The aim of this study was to determine the diagnostic potential of magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) compared to ankle arthroscopy. Forty consecutive patients presenting with ankle pain of at least three months duration were included in the study. This cohort of patients underwent magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and then arthroscopy. Pre-operative MRI reported findings were compared with the arthroscopic findings. The sensitivity, specificity, positive and negative predictive value of MRI for diagnosing ankle pathology was then assessed. The 2 senior authors reviewed the MRI scans and their findings correlated. The average time between injury and presentation to our service was 2.2 years. This interval ranged from 3 months to 10 years. 51% of patients gave history of inversion and/or plantar flexion injuries. 14 % had symptoms, which persisted following an ankle fracture. At arthroscopic evaluation 23 patients had osteochondral defects and 37 had evidence of synovitis. MRI identified 50% of the osteochondral defects with sensitivity 50% and specificity 100%. Synovitis was not identified in any of the patients on preoperative MRI but 33% of the preoperative MRI did demonstrate a joint effusion. Despite the high rate of discordance between MR imaging and arthroscopy in our study MRI still remains a useful adjunct in the investigation of ankle pain. The implications for practice and further study are discussed.
Injection of the plantar fascia under general anaesthesia is a safe and effective method for the relief of conservatively unmanageable heel pain due to plantar fasciitis. A larger patient population and a greater than 1 year follow up would be helpful to determine the long term benefits &
outcomes of this treatment.
A new apparatus and technique of syndesmosis fixation is tested in a prospective clinical study. Buttons on both sides of the ankle anchor a strong suture under tension following syndesmosis reduction. This syndesmosis suture acts like a tightrope when under tension. Implantation is simple with a minimally invasive technique, as the medial side is not opened. It allows physiological micromotion whilst resisting diastasis, does not require routine removal, and allows patients to weight-bear earlier. Sixteen patients with Weber C ankle fractures with a syndesmosis diastasis underwent suture-button fixation and the results compared to 16 consecutive patients with syndesmosis screw fixation. Patients were, in effect, quasi-randomised according to surgeon preference. Mean A,O,F,A,S, ankle scores were significantly better in the suture-button group at three months post-op (91 vs 80, p=0.01, unpaired t-test) and at twelve months (93 vs 83, p=0.04, unpaired t-test). Return to work was also significantly faster (2.6 months vs 4.6 months, p=0.02, unpaired t-test). No suture-buttons required implant removal. Axial CT scanning at three months showed implants to be intact with maintenance of reduction, as compared to the uninjured contralateral side. Suture-button syndesmosis fixation is simple, safe and effective. It has shown improved outcomes and faster rehabilitation, without needing routine removal. Although the apparatus design may undergo further refinement, we believe this technique will become the treatment of choice in Weber C ankle fractures with a syndesmosis injury.
There was no significant difference between both groups for range of movement and grip strength. There was also no difference between the patient’s perception of pain and function which was assessed using the patient rated wrist evaluation (PRWE). Radiologically, the k-wire stabilisation group averaged better volar tilt compared with the ORIF group. For radial height and inclination the outcome was similar.
No correlation was found between kyphotic deformity, extent of canal compromise and clinical outcome.
In relation to the conduct of this study, one or more the authors have received, or are likely to receive direct material benefits.