Knee arthroscopy can be used for ligamentous repair, reconstruction and to reduce burden of infection. Understanding and feeling confident with knee arthroscopy is therefore a highly important skillset for the orthopaedic surgeon. However, with limited training or experience, furthered by reduced practical education due to COVID-19, this skill can be under-developed amongst trainee surgeons. At a single institution, ten junior doctors (FY1 to CT2), were recruited as a part of a five, two-hour session, training programme utilising the Simbionix® ARTHRO Mentor knee arthroscopy simulator, supplemented alongside educational guidance with a consultant orthopaedic knee surgeon. All students had minimal to no levels of prior arthroscopic experience. Exercises completed included maintaining steadiness, image centring and orientation, probe triangulation, arthroscopic knee examination, removal of loose bodies and meniscectomy. Pre and post experience questionnaires and quantitative repeat analysis on simulation exercises were undertaken to identify levels of improvement.Introduction
Methods
Knee arthroscopy can be used for ligamentous repair, reconstruction and to reduce burden of infection. Understanding and feeling confident with knee arthroscopy is therefore a highly important skillset for the orthopaedic surgeon. However, with limited training or experience, furthered by reduced practical education due to COVID-19, this skill can be under-developed amongst trainee surgeons. At a single institution, ten junior doctors (FY1 to CT2), were recruited as a part of a five, two-hour session, training programme utilising the Simbionix® ARTHRO Mentor knee arthroscopy simulator, supplemented alongside educational guidance with a consultant orthopaedic knee surgeon. All students had minimal to no levels of prior arthroscopic experience. Exercises completed included maintaining steadiness, image centering and orientation, probe triangulation, arthroscopic knee examination, removal of loose bodies, and meniscectomy. Pre and post-experience questionnaires and quantitative repeat analysis on simulation exercises were undertaken to identify levels of improvement.Abstract
Introduction
Methods
Infections in orthopaedic surgery are costly, debilitating complications. The search for new treatments and prevention strategies has led to the use of antibiotic-filled calcium sulfate (CaS) as a bone void filler that is both safe and effective. The purpose of this study was to examine the available data on the efficacy of this technology. A literature search was performed for studies that evaluated the use of antibiotic-loaded CaS cement in orthopaedics published between inception of the databases to 2017. Selected studies included randomized controlled trials (RCTs) and observational studies published in the English language that met the following criteria: 1) patients underwent an orthopaedic procedure; 2) CaS cement with an antibiotic was used; and 3) at least one of our outcomes were mentioned. Outcomes included resolution of infection, complications related to treatment, subsequent surgeries, overall infection rate, fracture union rate, clinical outcomes, and wound complications. A total of 17 studies were included.Purpose
Methods
A meta-analysis was performed to compare rate of SSI after application of chlorhexidine vs. iodine in total joint arthroplasty. Chlorhexidine had significantly lower odds of SSI. Surgical site infections (SSI) are a significant source of morbidity and mortality. The optimal preoperative skin preparation in lower extremity total joint arthroplasty (TJA) remains debatable between chlorhexidine and iodine-containing solutions. This meta-analysis sought compare SSI rates between chlorhexidine cloth application the night before surgery plus povidone-iodine-alcohol (povidone-iodine) solution at surgery or only povidone-iodine at surgery.Summary
Introduction
Patients who have multiple sclerosis (MS) may be at increased risk of developing complications after total hip arthroplasty (THA). The purpose of this study was to compare: 1) implant survivorship; 2) functional outcomes; 3) complication rates; and 4) radiographic findings after THA between MS patients and a matched cohort. A single institutional database was reviewed for patients who had a diagnosis of MS and underwent a THA. Thirty-four patients (41 hips) were matched to a 2:1 cohort who did not have MS using based on age, sex, body mass index (BMI), and Charlson/Deyo scores. This resulted in a matching cohort of 80 patients (82 hips). The available medical records were reviewed. Functional outcomes and complications were assessed. Postoperative radiographs were evaluated. The matching cohort had higher all-cause survivorship at 4-years postoperatively (99 vs. 93%). There were 3 revisions in the MS cohort and 0 revisions in the matching cohort. The MS cohort had lower mHHS scores (66 vs.74 points, p<0.001), lower HOOS JR scores (79 vs. 88 points, p<0.01), required more physical therapy (5 vs. 3 weeks, p<0.01), and took longer to return to their baseline functional level (7 vs. 5 weeks, p<0.05). MS patients had higher rate of complications (6 vs. 1, p<0.05). Excluding revision cases, there was no additional radiographic evidence of progressive radiolucency, loosening, or subsidence. We found that MS patients had lower implant survivorship, lower functional outcome scores, and increased complication rates. These findings may help orthopaedists to have a better knowledge of how MS patients do after THA.
Stiffness after total knee arthroplasty is a common occurrence. Despite its prevalence, little is known as to which patients are at risk for poor range of motion after total knee arthroplasty. The purpose of this study was to determine the risk factors for manipulation under anesthesia (MUA) after total knee arthroplasty (TKA). Using a single institution registry, 160 patients who underwent a manipulation under anesthesia after total knee arthroplasty between 2007 and 2013 were retrospectively evaluated. Each patient was 1:1 matched by age, gender and laterality to a control group of 160 patients who did not require MUA after TKA. Risk factors for MUA were assessed, and included medical co-morbidities, BMI, prior operations, and preoperative range of motion.Introduction
Methods
The aim of this study was to compare the short-term and mid-term outcome of lateral UKRs using a single prosthesis, the AMC Uniglide knee implant. Between 2003 and 2010, seventy lateral unicompartmental knee replacements (mean patient age 63.6±12.7 years) were performed at our unit for isolated lateral compartmental disease. Range of knee motion and functional outcome measures including the American Knee Society (AKSS), Oxford (OKS) and WOMAC scores were recorded from 19 knees at five years' post-operatively and compared to 35 knees at two-years and 53 knees at one-year post-op.Purpose
Methods
Kneeling ability is better in unicompartmental than total knee arthroplasty. There is also an impression that mobile bearing knees achieve better functional outcome than their fixed bearing cousins in unicompartmental and to a lesser extent total joint arthroplasty. In the UK, the market leading unicompartmental replacement is mobile bearing. To analyse kneeling ability after total and unicompartmental knee replacement using mobile and fixed bearing inserts.Introduction
Aim
Trochlear dysplasia (TD) is still poorly recognised, generally considered uncommon and to present purely as persistent patella dislocation. 87 patients diagnosed as having TD by a true lateral X-ray, MRI scan or at surgery were sent a questionnaire about their initial symptoms. 60% had suffered adolescent anterior knee pain. Lack of trust, wobbling, stair problems, giving way and catching were also common symptoms. Only 66% had ever suffered a dislocation, their troubles had started at 12 years of age. Most had undergone unsuccessful realignment procedures and many had developed premature lateral patello-femoral arthritis.Introduction
Diagnosis
Between 1989 and 1992 102 knees adjudged suitable for Unicompartmental replacement (UKR) were randomised to receive either a St Georg Sled UKR or a Kinematic modular total knee replacement (TKR). The early results demonstrated that the UKR group had less complications, and more rapid rehabilitation. At 5 years there were equal failures but the UKR group had more excellent results and a greater range of movement. Despite this doubt persisted about whether these advantages would be maintained these cases have been followed regularly by a research nurse at 8, 10, 12 years. We now report the final outcome at 15 years. 43 patients (45 knees) have died with all their knees intact. Throughout the review period the Bristol Knee Scores (BKS) of the UKR group have been better and at 15 years 77% and 53% of the surviving UKRs and TKRs achieve an excellent score. 6 TKRs and 4 UKRs have failed during the 15 years of the review. The better early results with UKR are maintained at 15 years with no greater failure rate. The median BKS scores of the UKR group was 91.1 at five years and 92 at 15 years suggesting little functional deterioration in either the prosthesis or remainder of the joint. These results would seem to justify the increased use of UKR.Conclusion
Unicompartmental knee replacements (UKR) converted to total knee replacements (TKR) have often been viewed with scepticism because of the perceived difficulty of the revision and because revision procedures generally do less well than primaries. This is a prospective review of TKRs converted from a UKR between 1982 and 2000. We present the survivorship of a 77 patient cohort and the clinical results of 35 patients. All information was recorded at the time of surgery onto a database and patients have been regularly reviewed since.Background
Methods
The Bristol Knee Group has prospectively followed the results of over 500 isolated patellofemoral arthroplasties. Initial experience with the Lubinus prosthesis was disappointing. The main causes of failure were mal-tracking and instability leading to excessive polythene button wear and disease progression in the tibio femoral joint. This experience resulted in the design of a new prosthesis to correct the tracking problems and improve the wear. We have now performed over 425 Avon arthroplasties with a maximum follow-up of 9 years. Survivorship at 5 years and the functional outcome have been reported with 95.8% survivorship, and improved function with Oxford score from 18 to 39 points out of 48. There have been 14 cases with mal-tracking (3%). Several of these cases have required proximal or distal realignment with the Elmslie or Insall procedures. Two knees with patella alta required distalisation of the tibial tubercle. Symptomatic progression of the arthritic disease in the medial or lateral tibio-femoral compartments has occurred in 28 cases (7%) causing recurrent joint pain. Radiographic follow-up has shown a higher rate of disease progression emphasising the importance of careful assessment of patients prior to operation. We have investigated 8 cases of persistent unexplained pain. Analysis of these cases suggests 3 possible causes. An extended anterior cut leading to overstuffing, insufficient external rotation and over sizing of the femoral component leading to medial or lateral retinacular impingement. Six of these cases have been successfully treated by revision of the femoral component leading to dramatic resolution of the symptoms.Introduction
Results
Although good long term results for fixed bearing uni-compartmental knee replacements (UKRs) have been reported mobile bearings predominate in some parts of the world. Three prospective studies have been undertaken comparing the short and medium term outcomes of fixed and mobile UKRs.
A 5 year comparative cohort study of 47 Oxford mobile bearing and 57 St Georg Sled fixed bearing UKRs. A 2 year study of 50 fixed and 50 mobile bearing AMC Uniglide UKRs.(The implant system allows implantation of either a fixed or mobile tibial component with the same femoral component.) The 1 year results of a randomised controlled trial of 38 fixed and 33 mobile AMC Uniglide UKRs in patients under 70. In all groups the preoperative sex mix, average age and knee scores were extremely similar. All patients were assessed both pre and postoperatively by a research nurse and radiographs were taken; the results were entered on the Bristol Knee database.
Multiple problems were encountered, perhaps because of the introduction of MIS, but at 5 years 11 Oxford and 4 Sleds had failed. The major problem with the mobile bearing implant was instability though tibial fractures were also seen. Both groups had three cases of arthritic progression and loose cement was seen twice in the fixed bearing group. – Amongst the remaining patients the median scores for the Sled were better. Bristol Knee Score (Max 100) 95:90; Oxford (Max 48) 39:37; and reduced WOMAC (Best score 12) 18:24. 2 bearing exchanges and 3 revisions were needed in the mobile group with none in the fixed group. Again all scores were better for the fixed group. American Knee Score (AKS) (Max 200) 195:185; Oxford (Max48) 39:37; and reduced WOMAC (Max 12) 19:20. One fixed bearing implant had been revised but none in the mobile group, however 3 randomised to receive a mobile bearing had a fixed bearing inserted because the surgeon was unhappy about bearing stability; all three are doing well. All knee scores at one year show the fixed bearing implant to be performing better. AKS (Max 200) 194:173; Oxford (Max48) 39:33; and WOMAC(Max) 12 18:22.
99 knees were followed for 15 years, 21 knees for 20 years and four for 25 or more years. The average Bristol knee score of the surviving knees fell from 86 to 79 during the second decade, largely as a result of aging. A previous study of the St Georg. Fixed bearing UKR showed an 89% 10 year survivorship and this is now extended to 82% at 15 years and 76.5% at 20 years.
Since 1996 over 400 isolated patellofemoral replacements using the Avon prosthesis have been undertaken in Bristol. As a result of the usually gratifying outcomes seen in patients over 55 years old, the indications for this surgery were soon extended to include the many younger patients who have severely disabling patellofemoral disease. We present results from a prospective cohort study of patients under 55 years of age at the time of surgery. 110 knees in 86 patients (median age 47 years, range 24–54) have been treated with Avon patellofemoral replacement (88 in females and 22 in males). Diagnoses included lateral facet OA (59 knees), patella dislocation (25 knees), trochlear dysplasia (41 knees) and post patellectomy instability (7 knees). 79 knees had undergone previous surgery. 17 knees required additional intra-operative procedures including 11 lateral releases and 2 patella realignments. All patients were assessed pre-operatively and at regular intervals using the Oxford, Bristol and WOMAC scores. All knees were scored preoperative and only one knee has been lost to follow-up due to the patient’s death, which was unrelated to surgery. Post-operative Oxford knee scores have been obtained for 106 knees with follow-up between 8 months and 8 years (mean follow-up 24 months). The mean Oxford score improved from 18 preoperatively to 31 at latest review. Bristol and WOMAC scores showed similar improvements. 16 knees required post-operative additional procedures including 6 lateral releases, 3 patella realignments and 11 revisions. Of the revisions 5 were for progression of tibiofemoral OA but none of these were knees with trochlear dysplasia. Equally good mean scores were seen when comparing patients with the 3 main underlying pathologies (trochlear dysplasia, patellar dislocation and lateral facet OA). At least 37% of the patients studied had pre-existing trochlear dysplasia and the majority of these patients report onset of symptoms, often patellar dislocation, in the first three decades of life. More than 90% of patients were overweight or obese according to their BMI at the time of surgery. Many of this type of patient, with disabling symptoms, wish to “live now”. The short-term improvements are frequently dramatic. As yet there is no suggestion of prosthetic failure. Revision presents little difficulty since minimal bone is resected in the primary proceedure. Radiological deterioration of the tibio femoral joint is seen in some cases of primary OA but not with trochlear dysplasia.
611 patients were involved with a mean age of 68 years. Residual pain following surgery was assessed with either the Oxford Knee Score (OKS) or the WOMAC score. The patients were followed up at one and two years postoperatively by a Research nurse and the findings recorded prospectively on the Bristol Knee database.