Advertisement for orthosearch.org.uk
Results 1 - 20 of 58
Results per page:
Applied filters
Content I can access

Include Proceedings
Dates
Year From

Year To
Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 98-B, Issue SUPP_23 | Pages 56 - 56
1 Dec 2016
Kendrick B Grammatopoulos G Philpott A Pandit H Atkins B Bolduc M Alvand A Athanasou N McNally M McLardy-Smith P Murray D Gundle R Taylor A
Full Access

Aim

Advocates of Debridement-Antibiotics-and-Implant-Retention (DAIR) in hip peri-prosthetic joint infection (PJI) argue that a procedure not disturbing a sound prosthesis-bone interface is likely to lead to better survival and functional outcome compared to revision. However, no evidence supports this. This case-control study's aims were to compare outcome of DAIRs for infected 1° total hip arthroplasty (THA) with outcomes following 1° THA and 2-stage revisions of infected 1° THAs.

Method

We retrospectively reviewed all DAIRs, performed for confirmed infected 1° THR (DAIR-Group, n=80), in our unit between 1997–2013. Data recorded included patient demographics, medical history, type of surgery and organism identified. Outcome measures included complications, mortality, implant survivorship and functional outcome using the Oxford Hip Score (OHS). Outcome was compared with 2 control groups matched for gender and age; a cohort of 1° THA (1°-THA-Group, n=120) and a cohort of 2-stage revisions for infection (2-Stage-Revision-Group, n=66).


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 98-B, Issue SUPP_11 | Pages 49 - 49
1 Jun 2016
Spiegelberg B Kendrick B Taylor A Stubbs D McLardy-Smith P Gundle R
Full Access

Introduction

Native hip joint infection can result in hip arthrosis as a complication requiring the need for subsequent arthroplasty. There is little evidence to support single or staged THA. We present the results of patients who have undergone total hip arthroplasty (THA) following hip joint sepsis in our institution.

Methods

Patients receiving a THA following previous hip joint sepsis between 2003 and 2015 were identified from the operative records database. Further clinical information was collected from the medical records, including timing of infection and surgery, as well as culture results. Functional outcome (Oxford Hip Score, OHS) and patient satisfaction scores (PSS) were recorded.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 98-B, Issue SUPP_11 | Pages 52 - 52
1 Jun 2016
Grammatopoulos G Kendrick B Glyn-Jones S McLardy-Smith P Taylor A Gundle R
Full Access

Introduction

The value of Debridement-Antibiotics-and-Implant-Retention (DAIR) in prosthetic-joint-infection (PJI) is still a matter of debate as most studies to-date are underpowered with variable end-points. In our, tertiary referral, bone infection unit we consider DAIR to be a suitable option in all PJIs with soundly fixed prostheses, despite chronicity. The aims of this study were to define the long-term outcome following DAIR in hip PJI and identify factors that influence it.

Methods

This is a retrospective consecutive case series of DAIRs performed between 1997 and 2013. Only infected cases confirmed by established criteria were included. Data recorded included patient demographics, medical history (ASA grade, Charlson and KLICC scores), type of surgery performed (DAIR or DAIR + exchange of modular components) and organism grown. Outcome measures included complications, implant survivorship and functional outcome (Oxford Hip Score, OHS).


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 97-B, Issue SUPP_15 | Pages 72 - 72
1 Dec 2015
Grammatopoulos G Kendrick B Athanasou N Byren I Atkins B Mcnally M Mclardy-Smith P Gundle R Taylor A
Full Access

Debridement, antibiotics and implant retention (DAIR) is a surgical option in the treatment of prosthetic joint infection (PJI). It is thought to be most appropriate in the treatment of early (≤6 weeks post-op) PJI. Most studies to-date reporting on DAIRs in hip PJI have been underpowered by reporting on small cohorts (n= <45), or report on registry data with associated biases and limitations. In our, tertiary referral, bone infection unit we consider DAIR to be a suitable option in all cases of PJI with a soundly fixed prosthesis, with early or late presentation, especially in patients who are too elderly or infirm to undergo major surgery.

Aim: To define the 10-year outcome following DAIR in hip PJI and identify factors that influence it.

We retrospectively reviewed all DAIRs performed in our unit between 1997 and 2013 for hip PJI. Only infected cases confirmed by histological and microbiological criteria were included. Data recorded included patient demographics and medical history, type of surgery performed (DAIR or DAIR + exchange of modular components), organism identified and type/duration of antibiotic treatment. Outcome measures included complications, mortality rate, implant survivorship and functional outcome.

121 DAIRs were identified with mean age of 71 years (range: 33–97). 67% followed an index procedure of 1° arthroplasty. 53% included exchange of modular components. 60% of DAIRs were for early onset PJI. Isolated staphylococcus was present in 50% of cases and 25% had polymicrobial infection. At follow-up (mean:7 years, range: 0.3 – 18), 83 patients were alive; 5- and 10- year mortality rates were 15% and 35% respectively. 45% had a complication (persistence of infection: 27%, dislocation: 10%) and 40% required further surgery. Twenty hips have been revised to-date (17%). Performing a DAIR and not exchanging the modular components was associated with an almost 3× risk (risk ratio: 2.9) of subsequent implant failure (p=0.04). 10-yr implant survivorship was 80% (95%CI: 70 – 90%). Improved 10-year implant survivorship was associated with DAIR performed for early PJI (85% Vs 68%, p=0.04). Functional outcome will be discussed.

DAIR is a particularly valuable option in the treatment of hip PJI, especially in the early post-operative period. Whenever possible, exchange of modular implants should be undertaken, however DAIRs are associated with increased morbidity even in early PJI. Factors that predict success of DAIR in late PJI need to be identified.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 97-B, Issue SUPP_12 | Pages 29 - 29
1 Nov 2015
Pollalis A Grammatopoulos G Wainwright A Theologis T McLardy-Smith P Murray D
Full Access

Introduction

Joint preserving procedures have gained popularity in an attempt to delay arthroplasty in young, dysplastic hips. Excellent results can be achieved with peri-acetabular osteotomy (PAO) in congruent non-arthritic hips. The role of salvage procedures such as the Shelf acetabuloplasty remains undefined. This study aims to determine the long-term survival and functional outcome following Shelf acetabuloplasty and to identify factors that influence outcome.

Patients/Materials & Methods

This is a retrospective, consecutive, multi-surgeon, case series from a UK referral centre. 125 Shelf procedures were performed between 1987–2013 on 117 patients for symptomatic hip dysplasia. Mean age was 33 years (15–53). Mean follow-up was 10 years (1–27). Radiographic parameters measured included pre-operative arthritis, acetabular-index, centre-edge-angle, joint congruency, subluxation and femoral sphericity. Oxford Hip and UCLA scores were collected at follow-up. Failure was defined as conversion to arthroplasty or OHS<20.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 94-B, Issue SUPP_XXXVII | Pages 247 - 247
1 Sep 2012
Grammatopoulos G Pandit H Taylor A Whitwell D Glyn-Jones S Gundle R Mclardy-Smith P Gill H Murray D
Full Access

Introduction

Since the introduction of 3rd generation Metal-on-Metal-Hip-Resurfacing-Arthroplasty (MoMHRA), thousands of such prostheses have been implanted worldwide in younger patients with end-stage hip osteoarthritis. However, no independent centre has reported their medium-to-long term outcome. The aim of this study is to report the ten year survival and outcome of the Birmingham Hip Resurfacing (BHR), the most commonly used MoMHRA worldwide.

Methods

Since 1999, 648 BHRs were implanted in 555 patients, the majority of which were male (326). The mean age at surgery was 52.1years (range: 17–82), with primary OA as most common indication (85%). Mean follow up was 7.1years (range: 1–11). The Oxford Hip Score (OHS) and UCLA questionnaires were sent to all patients. Implant survival was established, with revision as the end point. Sub-analysis was performed by gender, femoral component size (small: <45mm, standard: 46–52, large: >53mm) and age at surgery (young:<50yrs, old:>50yrs).


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 94-B, Issue SUPP_XXXVII | Pages 579 - 579
1 Sep 2012
Grammatopoulos G Pandit H Backer K Gundle R Mclardy-Smith P Desmet K Murray D Gill H
Full Access

INTRODUCTION

Femoral neck narrowing (NN) following Metal-on-Metal Hip Resurfacing Arthroplasty (MoMHRA) is a well-recognised clinical phenomenon. The incidence of resurfaced hips with NN > 10% is reported to be up to 27%. Its pathogenesis is thought to be multi-factorial secondary to stress shielding, impingement, osteolysis secondary to wear/ion particles and as a result of reduced vascularity and pressure effect on cancellous bone secondary to the presence of a soft-tissue mass around the resurfaced hip. Recognised risk factors for its development include: female gender and the presence of a pseudotumour. Serum Chromium (Cr) and Cobalt (Co) are recognised surrogate markers of in-vivo wear of MoMHRA. The aims of this study were to establish whether NN is associated with increased wear.

METHODS

A cohort of 214 patients with unilateral MoMHRA (139M: 75F) was included in this study. Primary osteoarthritis was the diagnosis leading to surgery for the majority of patients (208). The average age at surgery was 54.1 years old (13–73). Six different implants were used; BHR (116), Conserve plus (92), Recap (2), ASR (2), Adept (1) and Cormet (1). The average femoral component size was 49.2mm (range: 38–59). The average follow up was 4.3 years (range: 2–10). Patients were subdivided into 3 groups as per implant size. Small size component group had implants <45mm, average size group had components 45–51mm and large component size group had components >51mm.

All patients had Prosthesis-Junction-Ratio (PJR) measured from postoperative (PJRpost) and at latest follow up (PJRfollow) radiographs. Measurements were made using the method described by Lilikakis1.

Metal ion levels (Cr/Co) were measured at last follow-up for all patients. Cr level >5.1g/ml and Co levels >4.4 g/ml were considered high2 and patients with such levels formed the high ion group.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 94-B, Issue SUPP_XXXVII | Pages 456 - 456
1 Sep 2012
Grammatopoulos G Pandit H Mellon S Glyn-Jones S Gundle R Mclardy-Smith P Murray D Gill H
Full Access

INTRODUCTION

Studies have suggested that there is a reduction in head-neck-ratio (HNR) associated with MoMHRA. A reduction in HNR at operation would decrease range of movement and increase impingement risk. Impingement could lead to 20 edge loading, increasing wear. Serum ion levels of Chromium (Cr) and Cobalt (Co) are surrogate markers of wear. Although acetabular component orientation has been shown to contribute to wear and PT development, the role of a decrease in HNR has only been highlighted in PT development. This study aimed to measure changes in HNR that occur at resurfacing and determine any gender- and component size-specific differences. In addition it aimed to determine whether changes in HNR could be associated with increased wear.

METHODS

84 patients (56M: 28F) with unilateral MoMHRA were included. The mean age at surgery was 57 years. The mean femoral component was 49mm. Components were considered small if <45mm, average if between 45–50mm and large if >50mm. Three designs were implanted; BHR, C+ and Recap. The average follow up was 4 years. All patients had Cr/Co levels measured at follow up. Patients were considered to have high ions if Cr and Co levels were 5.1ppb and 4.4ppb respectively.

Pre-operative HNR (HNRpre) and the post-operative HNR (HNRpost) were made from the respective pelvic radiographs. Assuming a 2mm thick cartilage layer, the HNR based on the diameter of the articular cartilage pre-operatively (HNRart) was calculated.

The immediate changes in HNR as a result of the operation were expressed relative to articular HNR pre-op:

HNRartpost=HNRpost–HNRart


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 94-B, Issue SUPP_XXXVII | Pages 578 - 578
1 Sep 2012
Grammatopoulos G Judge A Pandit H Mclardy-Smith P Glyn-Jones S Desmet K Murray D Gill H
Full Access

INTRODUCTION

Although simulation studies have shown superior wear properties of metal-on-metal articulations, increased concern exists regarding the excess in-vivo wear of a small number of Metal-on-Metal-Hip-Resurfacing (MoMHRA) implants. Serum ion levels of Chromium (Cr) and Cobalt (Co) are surrogate markers of wear. Risk factors associated with increased wear include female gender, small components, dysplasia, cup orientation outside safe zone and femoral head downsize during surgery with an associated decrease in Head-Neck-Ratio (HNR). However, these factors are interlinked. This study aims to identify the factors that are most important for subsequent wear of MoMHRA, by performing a multivariate analysis.

METHODS

206 patients (124M: 82F) with unilateral MoMHRA were included in this study. The average follow up was 3.3 years. All patients had Cr/Co levels measured at follow up. Inclination and anteversion of each cup were measured using EBRA. Cups were analysed as being within or outside the previously defined optimum-zone. HNR measurements were made from pre-operative (HNRpre) and post-operative (HNRpost) radiographs. The immediate changes in HNR (downsize/upsize of femoral head) as a result of the operation were expressed as:

HNRprepost=HNRpost–HNRpre

Multivariate linear regression modelling was used to explore the association between measures of ions with the following predictor variables (gender, age, diagnosis, femoral component size, orientation of the acetabular component, head/neck ratio and position of femoral stem). Analyses were carried out separately for each outcome (Cr and Co). Classification and Regression Tree (CART) models were fitted as a complimentary approach to regression modelling.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 94-B, Issue SUPP_II | Pages 13 - 13
1 Feb 2012
Steffen R Smith S Gill H Beard D McLardy-Smith P Urban J Murray D
Full Access

This study aims to investigate femoral blood flow during Metal-on-Metal Hip Resurfacing (MMHR) by monitoring oxygen concentration during the operative procedure.

Patients undergoing MMHR using the posterior approach were evaluated. Following division of fascia lata, a calibrated gas-measuring electrode was inserted into the femoral neck, aiming for the supero-lateral quadrant of the head. Baseline oxygen concentration levels were detected after electrode insertion 2-3cm below the femoral head surface and all intra-operative measures were referenced against these. Oxygen levels were continuously monitored throughout the operation. Data from ten patients are presented.

Oxygen concentration dropped most noticeably during the surgical approach and was reduced by 62% (Std.dev +/-26%) following dislocation and capsulectomy. Insertion of implants resulted in a further oxygenation decrease by 18% (Std.dev +/-28%). The last obtained measure before wound closure detected 22% (Std.dev +/-31%) of initial baseline oxygen levels. Variation between subjects was observed and three patients demonstrated a limited recovery of oxygen levels during implant insertion and hip relocation.

Intra-operative measurement of oxygen concentration in blood perfusing the femoral head is feasible. Results in ten patients undergoing MMHR showed a dramatic effect on the oxygenation in the femoral head during surgical approach and implant fixation. This may increase the risk of avascular necrosis and subsequent femoral neck fracture. Future experiments will determine if less invasive procedures or specific positioning of the limb can protect the blood supply to femoral neck and head.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 93-B, Issue SUPP_IV | Pages 546 - 546
1 Nov 2011
Grammatopoulos G Pandit H Taylor A Whitwell D Glyn-Jones S Gundle R McLardy-Smith P Murray D Gill H
Full Access

Introduction: Metal-on-metal-hip-resurfacing-arthroplasty (MoMHRA) has been associated with the development of inflammatory pseudotumours(IP), especially in females. IPs have been linked to wear debris, which can be related to metal-ion blood levels. Acetabular component position has been shown to influence wear. We have identified an optimum component orientation minimising IP risk around an inclination/anteversion of 40°/20°±10°. Our aim was to see if this optimal position results in lower metal ions and to identify the boundary of an optimal placement zone for low wear.

Methods: A cohort of 104 patients(60M:44F) with unilateral MoMHRA was studied. Blood tests were obtained at a mean follow up of 3.9 years and serum Co/Cr levels were measured(ICPMS). High metal ion concentrations were defined as Co> 4.1ppb and Cr> 5.2ppb. Radiographic cup inclination/anteversion were measured using EBRA. The differences in ion levels between different orientation zones were investigated. Three orientation zones were defined centered on 40°/20°: Z1-within ±5°, Z2-outside ±5°/within ±10° and Z3-within ±10°.

Results: There was a wide range of cup placements. Females had significantly (p< 0.001) smaller components(mean:51, 44–60) than males(mean: 56, 52–64). Cr levels, but not Co, were higher in females(p=0.002) and those with small femoral components(< 50mm, p =0.03). Patients with cups within Z1 (n=13) had significantly lower Co(p=0.005) and Cr(p=0.001). Males with cups within Z3(n=27) had lower ion levels in comparison to those outside, which were significantly lower for Co(p=0.049) but not Cr(p=0.084). Females had similar ion levels within and out of Z3(Cr/Co: p=0.83/0.84). Co levels were significantly lower in Z1(n=13) in comparison to Z2(n=33)(p=0.048) but Cr levels were not different (p=0.06).

Discussion: MoMHRA cups placed within ±5° of the optimum(40°/20°) had significantly lower metal ions indicating lower wear within this narrow zone. This safe zone, could extend to ±10° for males only. The narrower safe zone coupled with smaller components implanted are possible factors contributing to the increased IP incidence seen in females.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 93-B, Issue SUPP_IV | Pages 547 - 547
1 Nov 2011
Thomas G Simpson D Taylor A Whitwell D Gibbons C Gundle R Mclardy-smith P Gill H Glyn-jones S Murray D
Full Access

Introduction: The use of highly cross-linked polyethylene (HXLPE) is now commonplace for total hip arthroplasty, however there is no long-term data to support its use. Hip simulator studies suggest that the wear rate of some types of HXLPE is ten times less than conventional polyethylene (UHMWPE). The outcomes of hip simulator studies are not always reproduced in vivo and there is some evidence that HXLPE wear may increase between 5 and 7 years.

Method: A prospective double blind randomised control trial was conducted using Radiostereometric Analysis (RSA). Fifty-four subjects were randomised to receive hip replacements with either UHMWPE liners or HXLPE liners. All subjects received a cemented CPT stem and uncemented Trilogy acetabular component (Zimmer, Warsaw, IN, USA). The 3D penetration of the head into the socket was determined to a minimum of 7 years.

Results: The total liner penetration was significantly different at 7 years (p=0.005) with values of 0.33 mm (SE 0.05 mm) for the HXLPE group and 0.55 mm (SE 0.05 mm) for the UHMWPE group. The steady state wear rate from 1 year onwards was significantly lower for HXLPE (0.005 mm/yr, SE 0.007 mm/yr) than for UHMWPE (0.037 mm/yr, SE 0.009 mm/yr) (p=0.007). The direction of wear was supero-lateral.

Discussion: We have previously demonstrated that the penetration in the first year is creep-dominated, from one year onwards the majority of penetration is probably due to wear. This study confirms the predictions from hip simulator studies which suggest that the wear rate of this HXLPE approaches that of metal-on-metal and ceramic-on-ceramic articulations. HXLPE may have the potential to reduce the need of revision surgery, due to wear debris induced osteolysis. It may also enable surgeons to use larger couples, thus reducing the risk of impingement and dislocation.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 93-B, Issue SUPP_IV | Pages 546 - 546
1 Nov 2011
Grammatopoulos G Pandit H Taylor A Whitwell D Glyn-Jones S Gundle R McLardy-Smith P Gill H Murray D
Full Access

Introduction: Metal on metal hip resurfacing arthroplasty(MoMHRA) is an alternative option to THR in the treatment of young adults with OA. A recognised MoMHRA complication is the development of an inflammatory pseudotumour(IP). Diagnosis is made with the aid of US and/or MRI. To-date, no radiographic indication of the presence of IP has been identified. Neck thinning is a recognised phenomenon in MoMHRA hips not associated with any adverse clinical events. Its pathogenesis is considered multi-factorial. Our aim was to establish whether excessive neck narrowing is associated with the presence of a pseudotumour.

Methods: Twenty-seven hips (26 patients) with IP confirmed clinically, radiologically, intra-operatively and histologically were matched for sex, age, pre-operative diagnosis, component size and follow-up with an asymptomatic MoMHRA cohort (Control n=60). For all patients, prosthesis-neck-ratio(PNR) was measured on plain AP pelvic radiographs post-operatively and at follow-up as previously described and validated.

Results: All IP patients (4M:23F) and all (12M:48F) but two controls had a posterior approach at the time of MoMHRA. Post-operatively, there was no difference in the PNR between the two groups (p=0.19). At an average follow up of 3.5 years (range:0.7–8.3), IP patients(mean 1.26, 1.10–1.79) had a significantly higher (p< 0.0001) PNR in comparison to their controls(mean 1.14, 1.03–1.35). Greater neck narrowing occurred in both genders. IP necks had narrowed by an average of 8% (range:3–23). The degree of neck narrowing was correlated with length of survival of implant (p=0.001).

Discussion: This study shows a strong association between IP and neck narrowing. Processes such as impingement and increased wear are considered to be involved in the pathogenesis of both IP and neck narrowing. Furthermore, the presence of an IP, could lead to altered vascularity via a mass effect and further contribute to neck narrowing. Neck narrowing in symptomatic MOMHRA patients should alert surgeons of the possible presence of IP.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 93-B, Issue SUPP_III | Pages 298 - 298
1 Jul 2011
Glyn-Jones S Pandit H Doll H McLardy-Smith P Gundle R Gibbons M Athanasou N Ostlere S Whitwell D Taylor A Gill R Murray D
Full Access

Metal on metal hip resurfacing (MMHR) is a popular procedure for the treatment of osteoarthritis in young patients. Several centres have observed masses, arising from around these devices, we call these inflammatory pseudotumours. They are locally invasive and may cause massive soft tissue destruction. The aim of this study was to determine the incidence and risk factors for pseudotumours that are serious enough to require revision surgery.

In out unit, 1,419 MMHRs were performed between June 1999 and November 2008. All revisions were identified, including all cases revised for pseudotumour. Pseudotumour diagnosis was made by histological examination of samples from revision. A Kaplan-Meier survival analysis was performed, Cox regression analysis was used to estimate the independent effects of different factors.

The revision rate for pseudotumour increased with time and was 4% (95% CI: 2.2% to 5.8%) at eight years. Female gender was a strong risk factor: at eight years the revision rate for pseudotumours in men was 0.5% (95% CI 0% to 1.1%), in women over 40 it was 6% (95% CI 2.3% to 10.1%) and in women under 40 it was 25% (95% CI 7.3% to 42.9%) (p< 0.001). Other factors associated with an increase in revision rate were, small components (p=0.003) and dysplasia (p=0.019), whereas implant type was not (p=0.156).

We recommend that resurfacings are undertaken with caution in women, especially those younger than 40 years of age, but they remain a good option in men. Further work is required to understand the patho-aetiology of pseudotumours so that this severe complication can be avoided.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 93-B, Issue SUPP_II | Pages 221 - 222
1 May 2011
Kwon Y Glyn-Jones S Simpson D Kamali A Counsell L Mclardy-Smith P Beard D Gill H Murray D
Full Access

Introduction: Pseudotumours (soft-tissue masses relating to the hip joint) following metal-on-metal hip resurfacing arthroplasty (MoMHRA) have been associated with elevated serum and hip aspirate metal ion levels, suggesting that pseudotumours occur when there is increased wear. This study aimed to quantify in vivo wear of implants revised for pseudotumours and a control group of implants revised for other reasons of failure.

Methods: A total of 30 contemporary MoMHRA implants in two groups were investigated in this Institutional Review Board approved study:

8 MoMHRA implants revised due to pseudotumour;

22 MoMHRA implants revised due to other reasons of failure (femoral neck fracture and infection).

The linear wear of retrieved implants was measured using a Taylor-Hobson Roundness machine. The average linear wear rate was defined as the maximum linear wear depth divided by the duration of the implant in vivo.

Results: In comparison with the non-pseudotumour implant group, the pseudotumour implant group was associated with:

significantly higher median linear wear rate of the femoral component: 8.1um/year (range 2.75–25.4um/year) vs. 1.79um/year (range 0.82–4.15um/year), p=0.002; and

significantly higher median linear wear rate of the acetabular component: 7.36um/year (range1.61–24.9um/year) vs. 1.28um/year (range 0.18–3.33um/year), p=0.001.

Similarly, differences were also measured in absolute wear values. The median absolute linear wear was significantly higher in the pseudotumour implant group:

21.05um (range 2.74–164.80um) vs. 4.44um (range 1.50–8.80um) for the femoral component, p=0.005; and

14.87um (range 1.93–161.68um) vs. 2.51um (range 0.23–6.04um) for the acetabular component, p=0.008.

Wear on the acetabular cup components in the pseudotumour group always involved the edge, indicating edge-loading of the bearing. In contrast, edge-loading was observed in only one acetabular component in the non-pseudotumour group of implants. The deepest wear was observed well within the bearing surface for the rest of the non-pseudotumour group. The difference in the incidence of edge-loading between the two groups was statistically significant (Fisher’s exact test, p=0.03).

Discussion: Significantly greater linear wear rates of the MoMHRA implants revised due to pseudotumour support the in vivo elevated metal ion concentrations in patients with pseudotumours. This study provides the first direct evidence to confirm that pseudotumour is associated with increased wear at the MoM articulation. Furthermore, edge-loading with the loss of fluid film lubrication may be the dominant wear generation mechanism in patients with pseudotumour.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 93-B, Issue SUPP_II | Pages 220 - 220
1 May 2011
Thomas G Simpson D Gill H McLardy-Smith P Murray D Glyn-Jones S
Full Access

Introduction: The use of second generation highly cross-linked polyethylene (HXLPE) is now commonplace for total hip arthroplasty, however there is no long-term data to support its use. Hip simulator studies suggest that the wear rate of HXLPE is ten times less than conventional polyethylene (UHMWPE). The outcomes of hip simulator studies are not always reproducible in vivo. Long term clinical data is required, as there is emerging clinical data, which suggests that some types of second generation HXLPE may have increased wear after 5 years.

Method: A prospective double blind randomised control trial was conducted using Radiostereometric analysis (RSA). Fifty-four subjects were randomised to receive hip replacements with either UHMWPE liners or HXLPE liners. All subjects received a cemented CPT stem and uncemented Trilogy acetabular component (Zimmer, Warsaw, IN, USA). The 3D penetration of the head into the socket was determined to a minimum of 7 years.

Results: The total liner penetration was significantly different at 7 years (p=0.01) with values of 0.33mm (SD 0.17mm) for the HXLPE group and 0.51mm (SD 0.14mm) for the UHMWPE group. The steady state wear rate from 1 year onwards was significantly lower for HXLPE (0.003 mm/yr, SD 0.04 mm/yr) than for UHMWPE (0.03 mm/yr, SD 0.03 mm/yr) (p=0.01). The direction of wear was in the antero-medial direction in both groups.

Conclusion: We have previously demonstrated that the penetration in the first year is creep-dominated, from one year onwards the majority of penetration is due to wear. The wear rate of this second generation HXLPE approaches that of metal on metal bearings. Second-generation HXLPE may have the potential to reduce the risk of revision surgery, due to wear debris induced osteolysis.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 93-B, Issue SUPP_II | Pages 172 - 172
1 May 2011
Gill H Grammatopoulos G Pandit H Glyn-Jones S Whitwell D Mclardy-Smith P Taylor A Gundle R Murray D
Full Access

Introduction: Metal-on-metal hip resurfacing arthroplasty (MoMHRA) has gained popularity as an alternative to THR for younger patients with osteoarthritis. A growing concern has been the association of MoMHRA with the development of inflammatory pseudotumours (IP), especially in women. These have been linked to metal-on-metal wear, which can be related to metal ion concentrations. Elevated metal wear debris levels may result from impingement, rim contact and edge loading. Head-neck ratio (HNR) is a predetermining factor for range of movement and impingement. Neck thinning is a recognised phenomenon post-MoMHRA and we have found an association of IP with increased neck thinning based on a case control study. Our aims were to identify HNR changes a hip undergoes when resurfaced and at follow up; and whether greater neck thinning at follow-up could be associated with the presence of elevated metal ions.

Methods: A cohort of 91 patients (57M:34F) with unilateral MoMHRAs were included in this study. Blood tests were obtained at a mean follow up of 3.9 years (range 1.7–7 years) and serum (Co:Cr) ion levels were measured (ICPMS). High metal ion concentrations were defined as Co> 4.1ppb and Cr> 5.2ppb. For all patients, head-neck ratio (HNR) was measured on plain anterio-posterior pelvic radiographs pre-operatively, immediately post-operatively and at follow-up.

Results: Female patients had significantly bigger HNR pre-op (mean=1.35, range:1.22–1.64) compared to males(mean=1.22, range:1.05–1.38) (p< 0.01). Immediately post-op, female HNRs (mean: 1.26, range: 1.14–1.34) were not different to male patients(mean=1.24, range=1.11–1.38) (p=0.11). At follow-up HNR was once again significantly bigger (p< 0.01) in females (mean=1.35, range: 1.21–1.49), compare to males (mean=1.27, range:1.11–1.38). HNR alterations with operation (p=0.00) and at follow-up (p< 0.01) were significantly bigger in female patients. Furthermore, there was a significant correlation between high ion levels and HNR change at follow-up for both Co (p=0.02) and Cr (p< 0.01).

Conclusion: This study identified gender-specific changes in HNR that resurfaced hips undergo, not previously documented. Female hips have greater HNR pre-operatively, compared to male hips, and appear to be biomechanically disadvantaged when resurfaced. A decrease in HNR with resurfacing could result in impingement and lead to processes, known to be more prevalent in females, such as neck thinning, increased wear and IP development. In addition, we highlight a correlation between high ion levels and greater neck thinning at follow-up. Increased neck thinning in symptomatic MoMHRA hips could be secondary to increased wear and should be investigated further radiologically for the presence of IP.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 93-B, Issue SUPP_II | Pages 174 - 174
1 May 2011
Grammatopoulos G Kwon Y Langton D Pandit H Gundle R Whitwell D Mclardy-Smith P Murray D Gill H
Full Access

Introduction: Metal-on-metal hip resurfacing arthroplasty (MoMHRA) has gained popularity as an alternative to THR for younger patients with osteoarthritis. A growing concern has been the association of MoMHRA with the development of inflammatory pseudotumours (IP), especially in women. These have been linked to metal-on-metal wear, which can be related to metal ion concentrations. Although cup orientation has been shown to influence wear, the optimum cup position has not been clearly defined. We have identified an optimal cup orientation to minimise IP risk, based on a case controlled study, for inclination/anteversion within ±10° of 40°/20°. Our aim was to see if this optimal position results in lower metal ions, and to identify the boundary of an optimal placement zone for low wear.

Methods: A cohort of 104 patients (60M: 44F) with unilateral MoMHRA was included in this study. Blood tests were obtained at a mean follow up of 3.9 years (range 1.7–7 years) and serum Co and Cr ion levels were measured (ICPMS). High metal ion concentrations were defined as Co> 4.1ppb and Cr> 5.2ppb. Radiographic cup inclination and anteversion were measured using EBRA. The differences in ion levels between different cup orientation zones were investigated. Three orientation zones were defined centered on the target orientation of 40°/20°: Z1 within ±5°, Z2 outside ±5°/within ±10° and Z3: within ±10°.

Results: There was a wide range of cup placements; mean inclination/anteversion were 46.3°(21.5°–64.6°)/15°(2.7°–35.6°). Cr levels, but not Co, were higher in female patients (p=0.002) and those with small femoral components (< 50mm, p =0.03).

For the whole cohort, there was no significant difference in ion levels (Cr: p=0.092. Co=0.075) between cups positioned within Z3 (n=58) versus those outside (n=46 mean). Male patients with cups within Z3 (n=27) had lower ion levels in comparison to those outside Z3, which were significantly lower for Co (p=0.049) but not Cr (p=0.084). Female patients had similar levels within and out of Z3 for both ions (Cr: p=0.83, Co: p=0.84). However, patients with cups within Z1 (n=13) had significantly lower Co (p=0.005) and Cr (p=0.001) than those outside Z1 (n=95). Interestingly, Co levels were significantly lower in Z1 (n=13) in comparison to Z2 (n=33) (p=0.048) but Cr levels were not different (p=0.06).

Discussion: MoMHRA cups placed with ±5° of the ideal position of 40°/20°gave rise to significantly lower metal ions indicating lower wear within this narrow zone, in both sexes. This safe zone, could be extended to ±10° for male patients only. Gender specific factors, such as pelvic anatomy and joint flexibility, could be responsible for the narrower ‘safe’ zone seen in females. The narrower safe zone coupled with smaller components implanted are factors contributing to higher ion levels and hence the increased incidence of IP seen in females.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 93-B, Issue SUPP_II | Pages 223 - 223
1 May 2011
Grammatopoulos G Langton D Kwon Y Pandit H Gundle R Mclardy-Smith P Whitwell D Murray D Gill H
Full Access

Introduction: The development of Inflammatory Pseudotumour (IP) is a recognised complication following Metal on Metal Hip Resurfacing Arthroplasty (MoMHRA), thought to occur secondary to wear and elevated ion levels. Studies have shown that acetabular component orientation influences the wear of metal-on-metal hip replacement bearings. The aims of this study were to investigate the significance of cup orientation in the development of IP, and to identify a ‘safe-zone’ for cup placement with lower-risk for IP development.

Methods: Twenty six patients (n=27 hips) with IP confirmed radiologically, intra-operatively and histologically were matched for sex, age, pre-operative diagnosis, component size and follow-up with a cohort of asymptomatic MoMHRA patients (Control n=58). Radiographic acetabular anteversion and inclination were measured using EBRA. We calculated the distance in degree space of each acetabular component from the optimum position of 40° inclination and 20° anteversion, recommended by the designers, and thus compared acetabular component position between the two groups. Three different zones were tested as possibly optimum for acetabular placement. These were Lewinneck’s Zone (LZ) (inclination/anteversion; 30–50°/5–25°), and two zones defined by ±5° (Zone 1) or ± 10° (Zone 2) about the suggested target of 40°/20°. An optimal placement zone was determined based on a significant difference in IP incidence between components in the zone versus those outside.

Results: There was a wide range in cup orientations; mean inclination and anteversion were similar in the two groups: IP 47.5° (10.1°–80.6°)/14.1° (4.1°–33.6°) Vs Control 46.1° (28.8°–59.8°)/15.6° (4.3°–32.9°). Acetabular components in the IP group were significantly further away from the optimum position of 40°/20° in comparison to the controls (p=0.023). There was no difference in IP incidence between cups positioned within (IP:13/27, Control:35/58) or out of LZ (p=0.09) and within (IP: 2/27, Control: 10/58) or out of Zone 1 (p=0.156). Cups placed in Zone 2 (IP:6/27, Control:27/58) had significantly lower IP incidence versus those outside this zone (p=0.01). The odd’s ratio of developing IP when the cup is positioned out-of Zone 2 was 3.7.

Discussion: This study highlights the importance of ace-tabular component orientation in IP development. On the whole, patients with pseudotumour had acetabular components that were further away from the optimum position in comparison to the controls. However, a small number of IP patients had well-placed components implying that additional factors, possibly patient and/or gender specific, are involved in the development of pseudotumour. Furthermore, we defined an optimum, ‘safe-zone’ of ±10° around the cup position of 40°/20°. Patients with acetabular components outside this safe zone have an increased risk of IP development.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 93-B, Issue SUPP_I | Pages 26 - 26
1 Jan 2011
Gulati A Glyn-Jones S Simpson D Palan J Beard D Gill H McLardy-Smith P Gundle R Murray D
Full Access

Roentgen Stereophotogrammetric Analysis (RSA) can predict long-term outcome of prostheses by measuring migration over time. The Exeter femoral stem is a double-tapered highly polished implant and has been shown to subside within the cement mantle in 2 year RSA studies. It has a proven track record in terms of long-term survivorship and low revision rates. Several studies have demonstrated excellent clinical outcomes following its implantation but this is the first study to assess stem migration at 10 years, using RSA.

This is a single-centre study involving 20 patients (mean age: 63 years, SD=7) undergoing primary total hip replacement for degenerative osteoarthritis using the lateral (Hardinge) approach. RSA radiographs were taken with the patient bearing full weight post-operatively, at 3, 6, 12 months and at 2, 5 and 10 years follow-up. The three-dimensional migration of the Exeter femoral stem was determined.

The mean Oxford Hip Score at 10 years was 43.4 (SD=4.6) and there were no revisions. The stems subsided and rotated internally during a 10-year period. The mean migrations of the head and tip of the femoral stem in all three anatomic directions (antero-posterior, medio-lateral & supero-distal) were 0.69 mm posterior, 0.04 mm lateral and 1.67 mm distal for the head and 0.20 mm anterior, 0.02 mm lateral and 1.23 mm distal for the tip. The total migration at 10 years was 1.81 mm for the head and 1.25 mm for the tip.

The Exeter femoral stem exhibits migration which is a complex combination of translation and rotation in three dimensions. Comparing our 10 year with our previous 2 year migration results, the Exeter stems show continued, but slow distal migration and internal rotation. The subsidence continues to compress the cement and bone-cement interface which maintains secure fixation in the long term.