Repetitive manual handling caused 31% of all work related musculoskeletal disorders in 2015, with the back being the site of injury 38% of the time. Despite its high resilience, studies have shown that intervertebral discs can be damaged during repetitive loading at physiological motions, causing cumulative damage and disc herniation. To understand the mechanism of disc injury resulting from repetitive lifting, it is important to measure disc deformations/strains accompanied by MRI imaging to identify disc tissue damage. Therefore, the aim of this study was to examine associations between the magnitude of 3D internal strains, tissue damage and macroscopic evidence of disc injury after simulated repetitive lifting on normal human lumbar discs. Sixteen cadaver lumbar functional spinal units (FSUs) were subjected to pre-test MRI. Eight FSUs (control) underwent 20,000 cycles or until failure (5 mm displacement) of loading under compression (1.7 MPa – to simulate lifting a 20 kg weight) + flexion (13°) + right axial rotation (2°) using a novel Hexapod Robot. The remaining eight FSUs (experimental) had a grid of tantalum wires inserted, and stereoradiographs were taken to track internal disc displacements at increasing cyclic intervals. Maximum shear strains (MSS) were calculated from the displacements using radiostereometric analysis at cycle 1 and 20,000 cycles (or failure). Post-test MRI was conducted to determine the extent of tissue damage and associated with regions of highest MSS. A repeated measures ANOVA was performed on MSS with a within–subjects factor of cycle number (cycle 1 and failure cycle) and a between subjects-factor of disc region and failure type (p < 0 .05). Pfirrmann grading revealed mostly normal discs [I (N=2), II (N=13), and III (N=1)]. No significant difference in MSS between control and experimental groups was found for number of cycles to failure (p=0.279). Pre and post-test MRI analysis revealed that 13 specimens were injured after repetitive lifting with either an endplate failure (N=9) or disc bulge (N=4), and two specimens did not fail. Failure strain was significantly greater than cycle 1 in all regions except posterior, left/right posterolateral (p>0.109). Largest MSS at failure was seen in the anterior (60%), and left/right posterolateral regions (64% and 70%, respectively). MSS at failure for the endplate failure group was significantly larger than the no injury group in all regions except right lateral and nucleus (p>0.707). Disc bulge group MSS was significantly larger than the no injury group in the anterior, right anterolateral, and left/right posterolateral regions (p < 0 .027). Simulated repetitive lifting led to largest shear strains in the anterior, left and right posterolateral regions that corresponded to annular tears or annular protrusion. The no injury group shear strain was less than 50% in all regions, indicating there may be a threshold that could be associated with tissue damage linked with injuries such as disc bulge and endplate failure. There was no evidence of disc herniation in normal discs, agreeing with current clinical knowledge. These results may be indicative of the effects of repetitive manual handling on normal discs of younger patients.
Repetitive loading of degenerated human intervertebral discs in combined axial compression, flexion and axial rotation, typical of manual handling lifing activities, causes: an increase in intradiscal maximum shear strains, circumferential annular tears and nuclear seperation from the endplate. Chronic low back pain (LBP) is a crippling condition that affects quality of life and is a significant burden to the health care system and the workforce. The mechanisms of LBP are poorly understood, however it is well known that loss of intervertebral disc (disc) height due to degeneration is a common cause of chronic low back and referred pain. Gross disc injury such as herniation can be caused by sudden overload or by damage accumulation via repetitive loading, which is a cause of acute LBP and an accelerant of disc degeneration. The aim of this study was to determine for the Summary Statement
Introduction
Irradiating allograft bone may compromise the mechanical stability of the prosthesis-bone construct, potentially having adverse effects on the outcome of femoral impaction grafting at revision hip replacement. This in vitro study aimed to determine the effect of irradiation of allograft bone used in femoral impaction grafting on initial prosthesis stability. Morsellised ovine femoral head bone was irradiated at 0 kGy (control), 15 kGy and 60 kGy. For each group, six ovine femurs were implanted with a cemented polished double taper stem following femoral impaction bone grafting. Dynamic hip joint loading was applied to the femoral head using a servo-hydraulic materials testing machine. The primary outcome was stem micromotion. Tri-axial micromotion of the stem relative to the bone at two sites was measured using linear variable differential transformers and non-contact laser motion transducers. Statistical analysis was performed using SPSS. Compared to the control and 15 kGy groups, specimens in the 60 kGy group demonstrated statistically significant greater micromotion in the axial, antero-posterior and medio-lateral axes. A multi-factorial post-hoc power analysis based on the overall effect of group size indicated a power of 0.7. There was no difference in micromotion between the control and 15 kGy groups. The average micromotion in the axial axes was 63μm in the control and 59μm in the 15 kGy group. The results of this study suggest that a maximum irradiation dose of 15 kGy may not affect initial prosthesis stability following femoral impaction grafting in this model and provide the basis for us to now proceed to in-vivo studies examining the effect of irradiated bone on implant stability over time.
For phase angle (approximate magnitude 5°), no significant overall effects due to degeneration were found across any loading direction (P>
0.2). ANOVA analyses on maximum/minimum principal strains found no significant effect due to disc grade (P>
0.063). However, a small number of significant effects due to disc grade were found at particular strain gauge locations for the isolated disc in flexion, the intact FSU in extension, and the intact FSU/isolated disc in right lateral bending.
The non-significant small phase angles suggest that the disc behaves more like an elastic solid than a poroelastic material, and that dehydration associated with degeneration does not adversely affect damping. Principal strains were not significantly affected by disc degeneration overall, suggesting that the cortical shell adjacent to the disc-endplate boundary maintains a relatively homeostatic condition, with more dramatic architectural changes probably occurring within the trabecular bone. Applications of this research include providing important validation data for analytical/finite element models of the intact FSU and isolated disc segment, and a better understanding of the magnitudes of cortical strains that need to be maintained in order to avoid damaging vertebral bone stress-shielding effects after treatments for disc degeneration.
The anulus fibrosus of the human lumbar intervertebral disc has a complex, hierarchical structure comprised of collagens, proteoglycans and elastic fibres. Recent histological studies have suggested that the elastic fibre network may play an important functional role. In this study, it was hypothesised that elastic fibres enhance the mechanical integrity of the extracellular matrix transverse to the direction of the collagen fibres. Using a combination of biochemically verified enzymatic treatments and biomechanical tests, it was demonstrated that degradation of elastic fibres resulted in a significant reduction in both the initial modulus and the ultimate modulus, and a significant increase in the extensibility, of radially oriented anulus fibrosus specimens. Separate treatments and mechanical tests were used to account for any changes attributable to non-specific degradation of glycosaminoglycans. Additionally, histological assessments provided a unique perspective on structural changes in the elastic fibre network in radially oriented specimens subjected to tensile deformations. The results of this study demonstrate that elastic fibres play an important and unique role in the mechanical properties of the anulus fibrosus, and provide the basis for the development of improved material models to describe intervertebral disc mechanical behaviour.
During certain motions, the disc is at risk of annular injury. Axial compression coupled with various combinations of excessive flexion, lateral bending or axial rotation has been shown to lead to disc injury. However, similar injuries have also been caused by repetitive activity at lower, more physiological ranges of motion. The primary objectives of this study were to determine the regions of largest shear strain experienced by disc tissues in six degrees of freedom (DOF), since shear is considered a likely tissue failure criterion, and to identify the physiological motions that may place the disc at greatest risk of injury. A grid of wires was inserted into the mid-transverse plane of nine human lumbar discs that were subjected to each of six principal displacements and rotations. Stereo-radiographs were taken in each position and digitised for reconstruction of the 3D position of each grid intersection. Maximum shear strains (MSS) were calculated from relative grid-intersection displacements and normalised by the input displacement or rotation. Physiological MSS were calculated using the maximum reported physiological lumbar segmental motion for each DOF. The largest MSS were found in the posterior, posterolateral and lateral regions of the disc. For the translation motions, lateral shear and compression produced the largest MSS (approx. 9%/mm). For the rotation motions, lateral bending had significantly larger MSS than all other tests (5.8±1.6 %/°, P<
0.001). The physiological MSS was greatest for lateral bending, being significantly larger than all other motions (57.8±16.2%, P<
0.001). In addition, physiological MSS for flexion was also significantly larger than for all remaining motions (38.3±3.3%, P<
0.001). This study has identified lateral bending and flexion as the lumbar segmental motions that may place the disc at greatest risk of injury. The exact failure criterion for intervertebral disc tissue is not known, and MSS was used because it is related to maximum and minimum principal strains, and it was shown that disc tears may be initiated by large interlamellar shear strains that dominate over radial and circumferential annular fibre strains. These results provide improved understanding of disc behaviours under loading and may also be of value validating finite element models.
Defects in annulus fibrosus induced by needle puncture can compromise mechanical integrity of the disc and lead to degeneration in animal models. This study examined the immediate and short-term mechanical and biological response to annulus injury through needle puncture using small and large gauge needles in a bovine organ culture system. Bovine caudal intervertebral discs were harvested, assigned to one of two needle puncture groups (small = 25G, N=11; large = 14G, N=12) or an unpunctured control group (N=10), and cultured in organ culture for 6 days. After measuring initial heights, diameters, and wet weights, discs were placed in an organ culture chamber and incubated with constantly circulating media in standard culture conditions under a 0.2 MPa static load. Discs underwent a daily dynamic compression loading protocol for five days from 0.2 – 1 MPa at 1 Hz for one hour. Disc structure and function were assessed with measurements of dynamic modulus, creep, height loss, water content, proteoglycan loss to the culture medium, cell viability and histology. Needle insertion caused a rapid decrease in dynamic modulus and increase in creep during one hour of loading, although no changes were detected in water content, disc height, or proteoglycan lost to the media. Cell viability was maintained except for localised cell death at the needle insertion site. An increase in cell number and possible remodelling response was seen in the insertion site in the nucleus pulposus. Relatively minor disruption in the disc from needle puncture had immediate and progressive mechanical and biological consequences with important implications for the use of needle puncture in discography, and repair/regeneration techniques. Results also suggest diagnostic techniques sensitive to mechanical changes in the disc may be important for early detection of degenerative changes in response to annulus injury.
Biomechanical properties of the disc provide both flexibility and shock absorption. We hypothesised that frequency-dependent effects in shear and torsion deformations in which intrinsic viscoelasticity (solid phase) predominates would differ from compression and bending, in which fluid flow-mediated poroelasticity is also present. Disc-vertebra-disc preparations (N=8) from human lumbar spines were subjected to each of three displacements and three rotations (6 degrees of freedom - DOF) at each of four frequencies (0.001, 0.01, 0.1, and 1 Hz) after equilibration overnight under a 0.4 MPa preload in a bath of PBS at 37C with protease inhibitors. The forces and torques were recorded along with the applied translation or rotation. The stiffness (force/displacement or torque/rotation) and the phase angle (between each force and displacement) were calculated for each degree of freedom from recorded data. The stiffness significantly increased linearly with the log-frequency in most DOF (P<
0.001) apart for lateral bending and flexion/extension (P>
0.055). The increases over the four decades of frequency were 28%, 23% and 25% for antero-posterior (AP) shear, lateral shear and torsion respectively, and were 53%, 33% and 36% for compression, lateral bending and flexion. The phase angle (a measure of energy absorption) significantly decreased overall with increasing frequency in all DOF (P<
0.005) apart for lateral bending. During AP and lateral shear, significant decreases in phase angle of 10% were found between 0.001 Hz compared to 0.01 Hz and 0.1 Hz (P<
0.026) with no differences found at 1 Hz. For torsion, the phase angle at 1 Hz was significantly lower by 40% compared to all slower frequencies (P<
0.001). During compression, a large significant drop in phase angle of 25%–35% occurred between 0.001 Hz and all other frequencies (P<
0.016). No significant post-hoc differences were found for flexion-extension (P>
0.057). The dynamic effects (stiffness increase, and phase angle decrease with frequency) were consistently greater for deformation modes in which fluid flow effects are thought to be greater. Both the solid phase viscoelasticity and the fluid phase poroelasticity of the tissue appear to contribute to the disc stiffness and energy absorption, although these differences become more apparent at 1 Hz compared to the slower frequencies.
While maintaining the preload, FSUs were loaded in axial compression at 0.1 Hz through the NAB to 1 MPa in a saline bath for 5 sinusoidal cycles. Once tested, a radial tear was introduced via scalpel injury into the left postero-lateral region of the annulus and tested after one hour of re-equilibration. A final, more severe injury, in the form of removal of a 5 mm x 2 mm window of annulus at the same location was performed and tested after re-equilibration. Outcome measures were FSU stiffness, peak pressure, average pressure, contact area, and centroid of force location. Data was statistically analysed using repeated measures ANOVA or paired t-tests.
The system was used to determine pressure distributions in isolated vertebral bodies inferior to the disc, during axial compression of normal and injured discs of an ovine functional spinal unit.
The Tekscan system will be used to observe the effect of disc injury on the pressure distribution of the adjacent vertebral body. The relationship between the pressure distribution across the vertebral body and bone architecture will also be studied This study illustrated that this system is a valid tool for qualitatively and quantitatively assessing dynamic pressure distributions.
The effect of screw geometry on the pullout strength of Anterior Cruciate Ligament [ACL] reconstruction is well documented. Most research has looked at the effect of screw length and diameter, however other factors such as the degree of taper may also be important. Tapered screws should in theory be associated with increased pullout strength. This has not been demonstrated either clinically or A parallel and tapered screw were manufactured which were identical in all other respects. Sixty superficial digital flexors from the hind legs of sheep were harvested. The tendons were paired and combined to form a quadruple tendon reconstruction of approximately 7mm diameter as measured with graft sizer. An ACL reconstruction was performed on the proximal tibia of 30 bovine knees, which had been harvested in right and left knee pairs, using the quadruple tendon. Fifteen reconstructions were fixed using tapered screws and fifteen with non-tapered screws. The insertion torque of both tapered and non tapered screws were recorded using an instrumented torque screwdriver. The reconstructions were mounted in an Instron materials testing machine with an x-ray bearing system to eliminate horizontal forces, to ensure that the forces were all directed along the line of the tibial tunnel. The maximum pullout strengths were recorded in each case. Five knee pairs were subjected to bone densitometry scanning to ensure that any difference in pull out strength was not due to changes in bone density between right and left knee pairs. Results indicated that there was no difference between right and left knee pairs [p = 0.58] and that tapered screws were associated with significantly higher pull-out strengths [p=0.007] and insertion torques [p = 0.001].
We sought to identify the tensile properties of the medial patellofemoral ligament (MPFL), and determine whether its repair was sufficient as a means of restoring stability after acute lateral patella dislocation. We also sought to establish whether there was a correlation between the tensile properties of the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) and the MPFL. 16 hind limbs of Merino Wethers were obtained and stored fresh frozen. The specimens were thawed overnight, dissected out and then placed in a water bath at 37 degrees centigrade for 30 minutes prior to testing. All testing was carried out in the water bath to approximate a more physiological environment. For each specimen the ACL was first tested to failure on an Instron 8511. The MPFL was then tested to failure, then repaired and retested to failure. Finally a reconstruction was carried out, using a flexor tendon, which was again tested to failure. Results: There was no correlation between ACL and MPFL strength (p=0.677). Statistical analysis showed that the intact MPFL was significantly stronger than the repaired MPFL (P=0.001) but no different to the reconstructed MPFL (P=0.224), with no difference between repaired and reconstructed (P=0.174). A Power analysis showed that there was not adequate power to detect a significant difference between the last two pairs, and that we would have needed over 35 specimens to show a difference. This study does not support carrying out a repair of the MPFL following an acute lateral patella dislocation, as it does not restore its tensile properties. It further suggests that a reconstruction may better restore the tensile properties of this ligament.
Using the Kyle set-up, the forces required to initiate sliding were found to be lowest with the Synthes DHS (42.33±5.77N), Zimmer CHS (52.67±26.56N), and the IMHS (45.33±10.97N). These were closely followed by the Gamma nail (79.33±8.39N) and the Richards Classic hip screw (82.00±16.37N). The highest forces were for the RTN (98.00±18.52N) and the Austofix hip nail (283.00±70.62N). These results were significantly different. (p<
0.001, ANOVA)
The majority of the scientific literature is based on data obtained from elderly cadaveric material. Little is known about the biomechanical properties of the soft tissue grafts currently used prior to implantation. The correct preconditioning and intraoperative tensioning of the soft tissue grafts has also not been investigated. The initial graft biomechanical properties are important. Inadequate tension will lead to continuing instability whilst excessive tension may cause accelerated joint arthrosis. The tension in the graft may decrease by 30% if it has not been cyclically pretensioned.
This device will also allow the accurate preconditioning of the graft, providing objective data that can then be compared to the subsequent clinical progress of the patient. All testing will be accomplished during the time it takes to prepare the tunnels for insertion of the graft, and as such will not prolong unnecessarily the operative time.
This set-up will be immersed in a saline water bath maintained at body temperature during testing. The load cell will be hermetically sealed, with clamps and water bath being autoclavable. With the facilities for draping, the test area will remain sterile. The auto graft clamps will be designed to allow fixation of various graft materials (eg semitendinosus, gracilis, bone-patella tendon-bone) and adjustable for graft lengths. The water bath will house a thermocouple, heating mat and controller to maintain the saline temperature to within 1°C. The testing system will be mounted on a stainless steel trolley for mobility in the operating room with an underlying shelf to house the associated electronics and a retractable side draw for storage of the laptop computer. The autograft will be preconditioned between two known loads for 20 cycles recording load and displacement simultaneously on a laptop computer. Once preconditioned, the autograft will then be used for the ACL reconstruction in the standard way.