Aims. The aim of the British Association for Surgery of the Knee (BASK) Meniscal Consensus Project was to develop an evidence-based treatment guideline for patients with meniscal lesions of the knee. Materials and Methods. A formal consensus process was undertaken applying nominal group, Delphi, and appropriateness methods. Consensus was first reached on the terminology relating to the definition, investigation, and classification of meniscal lesions. A series of simulated clinical scenarios was then created and the appropriateness of arthroscopic meniscal surgery or nonoperative treatment in each scenario was rated by the group. The process was informed throughout by the latest published, and previously unpublished, clinical and epidemiological evidence. Scenarios were then grouped together based upon the similarity of clinical features and ratings to form the guideline for treatment. Feedback on the draft guideline was sought from the entire membership of BASK before final revisions and approval by the consensus group. Results. A total of 45 simulated clinical scenarios were refined to five common clinical presentations and six corresponding treatment recommendations. The final guideline stratifies patients based upon a new, standardized classification of symptoms, signs, radiological findings, duration of symptoms, and previous treatment. Conclusion. The 2018 BASK Arthroscopic Meniscal Surgery Treatment Guidance will facilitate the consistent identification and treatment of patients with meniscal lesions. It is hoped that this guidance will be adopted nationally by surgeons and help inform healthcare commissioning guidance. Validation in clinical practice is now required and several areas of uncertainty in relation to treatment should be a priority for future high-quality prospective studies. Cite this article: Bone Joint J 2019;101-B:652–659

Aims. The aim of this study was to compare patient-reported outcomes (PROMs) following isolated anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR), with those following ACLR and concomitant meniscal resection or repair. Methods. We reviewed prospectively collected data from the UK National Ligament Registry for patients who underwent primary ACLR between January 2013 and December 2022. Patients were categorized into five groups: isolated ACLR, ACLR with medial meniscus (MM) repair, ACLR with MM resection, ACLR with lateral meniscus (LM) repair, and ACLR with LM resection. Linear regression analysis, with isolated ACLR as the reference, was performed after adjusting for confounders. Results. From 14,895 ACLR patients, 4,400 had two- or five-year Knee injury and Osteoarthritis Outcome Scores (KOOS) available. At two years postoperatively, the MM repair group demonstrated inferior scores in KOOS pain (β = −3.63, p < 0.001), symptoms (β = − 4.88, p < 0.001), ADL (β = − 2.43, p = 0.002), sport and recreation (β = − 5.23, p < 0.001), quality of life (QoL) (β = − 5.73, p < 0.001), and International Knee Documentation Committee (β = − 4.1, p < 0.001) compared with the isolated ACLR group. The LM repair group was associated with worse KOOS sports and recreation scores at two years (β = − 4.264, p < 0.001). At five years, PROMs were comparable between the groups. At five years, PROMs were comparable between the groups. Participants undergoing ACLR surgery within 12 weeks from index injury demonstrated superior PROMs at two and five years. Conclusion. Our study showed that MM repair, and to a lesser extent LM repairs in combination with ACLR, were associated with inferior patient-reported outcome measures (PROMs) compared to isolated ACLR at two years postoperatively, while meniscal resection groups exhibited comparable outcomes. However, by five years postoperation, no significant differences in PROMs were evident. Further longer-term, cross-sectional studies are warranted to investigate the outcomes of ACLR and concomitant meniscal surgery

Introduction. Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLr) is the most widely published operation in the orthopaedic literature. Over recent years there has been increased interest in the surgical technique and role of concomitant procedures performed during ACLr. The National Ligament Registry (NLR) collects robust data on ACLr performed in the UK. In this registry analysis we explore trends in ACLr surgery and how they relate to published literature and the growing industry portfolio available to surgeons. Methods. Using data from the NLR, 14,352 ACLr performed between 2013–2021 were analysed. High impact papers on ACLr were then cross referenced against this data to see if surgical practice was influenced by literature or whether surgical practice dictated publication. Common trends were also compared to key surgical industry portfolios (Arthrex, Smith and Nephew) to see how new technology influenced surgical practice. Results. The number of ACLr performed in isolation is decreasing. The number of ACL reconstructions involving meniscal surgery shows an increasing trend since 2013, with 57% of ACLr in 2021 now involving meniscus surgery. The number of ACLr with lateral extra-articular tenodesis (LET) has increased sharply since 2018, preceding the stability trial publication in 2020. Graft preference and size has remained static despite the introduction of new graft harvest and fixation devices. Additional procedures such as other ligament reconstruction and additional cartilage surgery have also remained static over time. Conclusion. In this analysis we looked at surgical trends in ACLr and their relation to literature and industry. Meniscal intervention is increasing, in keeping with the growing level of literature in this area. In the setting of LET, a high impact level 1 study appears to have significantly changed the practice of UK surgeons with a sharp increase in the number of LET procedures being performed. Industry appears to have little influence on the change in surgical trends, suggesting high quality evidence is what drives innovation in ACLr while industry supports rather than influences innovation. It will be interesting to see the impact of the stability 2 study, recent work on the medial structures of the knee and the commissioning of cartilage centres on future trends

Aims. Circular RNA (circRNA) is involved in the regulation of articular cartilage degeneration induced by inflammatory factors or oxidative stress. In a previous study, we found that the expression of circStrn3 was significantly reduced in chondrocytes of osteoarthritis (OA) patients and OA mice. Therefore, the aim of this paper was to explore the role and mechanism of circStrn3 in osteoarthritis. Methods. Minus RNA sequencing, fluorescence in situ hybridization, and quantitative real-time polymerase chain reaction (qRT-PCR) were used to detect the expression of circStrn3 in human and mouse OA cartilage tissues and chondrocytes. Chondrocytes were then stimulated to secrete exosomal miR-9-5p by cyclic tensile strain. Intra-articular injection of exosomal miR-9-5p into the model induced by destabilized medial meniscus (DMM) surgery was conducted to alleviate OA progression. Results. Tensile strain could decrease the expression of circStrn3 in chondrocytes. CircStrn3 expression was significantly decreased in human and mouse OA cartilage tissues and chondrocytes. CircStrn3 could inhibit matrix metabolism of chondrocytes through competitively ‘sponging’ miRNA-9-5p targeting Kruppel-like factor 5 (KLF5), indicating that the decrease in circStrn3 might be a protective factor in mechanical instability-induced OA. The tensile strain stimulated chondrocytes to secrete exosomal miR-9-5p. Exosomes with high miR-9-5p expression from chondrocytes could inhibit osteoblast differentiation by targeting KLF5. Intra-articular injection of exosomal miR-9-5p alleviated the progression of OA induced by destabilized medial meniscus surgery in mice. Conclusion. Taken together, these results demonstrate that reduction of circStrn3 causes an increase in miR-9-5p, which acts as a protective factor in mechanical instability-induced OA, and provides a novel mechanism of communication among joint components and a potential application for the treatment of OA. Cite this article: Bone Joint Res 2023;12(1):33–45

We examined the relationship between waiting times for ACL surgery and the need for meniscal surgery at time of reconstruction. Using the Provincial Billing Database we identified 3812 ACL reconstructions between 1999–2001. Patients waited on average four hundred and twenty-two days from initial medical visit to reconstruction. 1722 patients (45%) required meniscal surgery with the ACL procedure. The delay to surgery was: two hundred and fifty-one days (no meniscal surgery required), four hundred and thirteen days (meniscal repair) and six hundred and seventy-six days (meniscectomies). This difference was significant, p< .01, ANOVA. The rate of meniscal surgery per time period was also significantly different: 17% if < 3months, 57% if > 6months. Our present Health Care policies place patients at risk of requiring avoidable meniscal surgery and developing osteoarthritis. The purpose of this study was to examine the relationship between waiting times for ACL surgery and outcome. The outcome measure was the need for meniscal surgery at the time of ACL reconstruction. The Provincial Data Base Billing information was reviewed for ACL reconstruction between 1999–2001. The simultaneous need for a meniscal procedure was noted. Tracking back in time, all demographic, diagnostic and interventional billing data (ICD & Visit billing code) preceding their ACL surgery was recorded. Between 1999–2001, 3812 ACL reconstructions were identified. Of these, 1722 patients required a meniscal procedure (45%). On average, patients waited over four hundred and twenty-two days from injury to reconstruction. Patients who did not require any meniscal procedure waited on average two hundred and fifty-one days, meniscal repairs waited four hundred and thirteen days, while meniscectomies waited six hundred and seventy-six days. More importantly, the need for a meniscal procedure correlated with the timing of surgery: 17% of those reconstructed < three months from injury had a significant meniscal injury, compared to 57% at > six months. Almost half of which (48%) required a meniscectomy for significant meniscal injury. These differences all attained statistical significance (p< 0.01). Previous reports suggest that the ACL-deficient knee increases the risk of meniscal injury and meniscal incompetence hastens OA. Our data show a progressive increase in the rate to meniscal surgery, and meniscal injury complexity with time. These delays and rates are higher than the ones proposed in the literature. It appears that the experience in our Province simply reproduces (rather than improves upon) the natural history of the ACL injury. We postulate restricting access to specialists and to surgery place the patient at risk for requiring avoidable surgery and developing osteoarthritis

Abstract. Introduction. The aim of this study was to determine the factors affecting return to sport (RTS) and career longevity of elite athletes after microfracture of the knee. Methods. A retrospective review of a consecutive series of elite athletes with chondral injuries in the knee treated with microfracture was undertaken. RTS was defined as competing in at least one event at professional level or national/ international level in amateur sport. Demographic, pre, intra and post operative factors affecting RTS were analysed. Results. Fifty six athletes, including 35 (62.5%) footballers and 14 (25.0 %) rugby players, with a mean age 24.8 (+/− 3.9) years, were included. 18 (32.1 %) of chondral injuries were secondary to trauma, 20 (35.7 %) post meniscectomy, 9 (16.1%) post anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction and 9 (16.1%) idiopathic. Fifty (89.3%) of athletes RTS at a mean time of 10.0 (+/−5.8) months. 43 (86.0%) athletes were still playing at 2 years. At 5 years 25 (59.5%) of the players who had RTS and had surgery more than 5 years ago were still playing professional sport. Factors associated with not playing at 5 years were cartilage lesions >1.5cm2(52.4% vs 66.7%), more than 1 lesion (35.7% vs74.1%), lateral meniscal surgery (42.1% vs 73.7%) and effusion on RTS (47.7% vs 72.2%). Conclusion. Over 89 % of elite athletes returned to professional sport after microfracture in the knee. However, the ability to continue playing is affected by several factors such as the extent of the chondral damage and recurrent effusions

Abstract. Introduction. The use of MCL “pie-crusting” (selective release of the superficial MCL) to improve arthroscopic access to the posteromedial compartment of the knee for isolated meniscal surgery has been demonstrated. However, there are concerns that MCL pie-crusting with concomitant ACL reconstruction (ACLR) might affect knee stability and outcomes postoperatively. The aim of this study was to compare the functional outcomes between patients who underwent MCL pie-crusting at ACLR with those that did not. Methods. We performed a retrospective review of prospectively collected data from on the National Ligament Registry. 55 patients (33 male and 22 female) who had MCL pie-crusting(PC group) to address a meniscal lesion at the time of ACLR were compared with 65 patients (38 male and 27 female) who underwent isolated primary ACLR. All procedures were performed by a single surgeon at a tertiary centre between October 2013 and March 2019. Results. The mean Follow up was 4.2 years(range 2- 7 years). The mean EQ 5D- VAS scores were 82 and 81 in the PC group and ACLR only group respectively. The mean IKDC scores were 81 and 85 in the PC group and ACLR only group respectively. The mean KOOS scores in the PC group and ACLR only group were: Symptoms (81,87); Pain (89,92); ADLs (94,96), sports and recreation function (81,83), QoL (75,78) respectively. The differences in the scores were not statistically significant. Conclusions. This study demonstrates that pie-crusting of the MCL at the time of ACLR does not significantly affect the functional outcomes

Anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction is a commonly performed operation. A variety of graft options are used with the most popular being bone-patellar-tendon-bone and hamstring autograft. There has been an increase in the popularity of hamstring autograft over the past decade. The aim of the study was to assess the ten year subjective knee function and activity level following four-strand semitendinosis and gracilis (STG) anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. 86 patients underwent anterior cruciate reconstruction by two knee surgeons over a 12 month period (January 1999 to December 1999). 80 patients meet the inclusion criteria of arthroscopic ACL reconstruction. The same surgical technique was used by both surgeons involving four-strand STG autograft, single femoral and tibial tunnels and aperture graft fixation with the Round headed Cannulated Interference (RCI) screw. Patient evaluation was by completion of a Lysholm Knee Score and Tegner Activity Level Scale at a minimum of ten years from reconstructive surgery. This was by initial postal questionnaire and subsequent telephone follow-up. 80 patients underwent anterior cruciate reconstruction with average age 30.9 years (15 to 58 years). There was a 77.5% (62 patients) response at ten years to the questionnaire. The median Lysholm Knee Score at ten years was 94 (52 to 100). The median activity level had decreased from 9 to 5 at ten years according to the Tegner Activity Scale. 73% of patients reported a good or excellent outcome on the Lysholm score. The group of patients was further divided into those that required meniscal surgery and those that did not. The patients that did not require meniscal surgery had a median Lysholm score of 94 and those that required meniscal surgery had a similar median Lysholm score of 92.5. However it was noted that 8 patients required medial and lateral partial menisectomies at the time of original reconstruction. This group of patients had a median Lysholm Knee Score of 83.5 and Tegner Activity Scale of 4 at ten years following reconstruction. 17 of the 62 patients (27.4%) required re-operation because of further knee symptoms, with 4 patients requiring revision of the anterior cruciate following re-rupture. In conclusion anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with four-strand STG hamstring autograft provides a reliable method of restoring knee function, with a 6% revision rate for re-rupture at ten years. Combined partial medial and lateral menisectomy at the time of the initial reconstruction is a poor prognostic indicator of function at ten years

Objectives. Meniscal injuries are often associated with an active lifestyle. The damage of meniscal tissue puts young patients at higher risk of undergoing meniscal surgery and, therefore, at higher risk of osteoarthritis. In this study, we undertook proof-of-concept research to develop a cellularized human meniscus by using 3D bioprinting technology. Methods. A 3D model of bioengineered medial meniscus tissue was created, based on MRI scans of a human volunteer. The Digital Imaging and Communications in Medicine (DICOM) data from these MRI scans were processed using dedicated software, in order to obtain an STL model of the structure. The chosen 3D Discovery printing tool was a microvalve-based inkjet printhead. Primary mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) were isolated from bone marrow and embedded in a collagen-based bio-ink before printing. LIVE/DEAD assay was performed on realized cell-laden constructs carrying MSCs in order to evaluate cell distribution and viability. Results. This study involved the realization of a human cell-laden collagen meniscus using 3D bioprinting. The meniscus prototype showed the biological potential of this technology to provide an anatomically shaped, patient-specific construct with viable cells on a biocompatible material. Conclusion. This paper reports the preliminary findings of the production of a custom-made, cell-laden, collagen-based human meniscus. The prototype described could act as the starting point for future developments of this collagen-based, tissue-engineered structure, which could aid the optimization of implants designed to replace damaged menisci. Cite this article: G. Filardo, M. Petretta, C. Cavallo, L. Roseti, S. Durante, U. Albisinni, B. Grigolo. Patient-specific meniscus prototype based on 3D bioprinting of human cell-laden scaffold. Bone Joint Res 2019;8:101–106. DOI: 10.1302/2046-3758.82.BJR-2018-0134.R1

Aims

This study examined windswept deformity (WSD) of the knee, comparing prevalence and contributing factors in healthy and osteoarthritic (OA) cohorts.

Introduction. Partial meniscectomy, a surgical treatment for meniscal lesions, allows athletes to return to sporting activities within two weeks. However, this increases knee joint shear stress, which is reported to cause osteoarthritis. The volumes and locations of partial meniscectomy that would result in a substantial increase in knee joint stress is not known. This information could inform surgeons when a meniscus reconstruction is required. Aim. Our aim was to use a previously validated knee finite element (FE) model to predict the effects of different volumes and locations of partial meniscectomy on cartilage shear stress. The functional point of interest was at the end of weight acceptance in walking and running, when the knee is subjected to maximum loading. Method. An FE model of the knee joint was used to simulate walking and running, two of the most common functional activities. Forces and moments, obtained from the gait cycle of a 76.4 kg male subject, were applied at the tibia. Different sizes (0%, 10%, 30%, 60%) and locations (anterior, medial and posterior) of partial meniscectomies were simulated (Figure 1). Maximum cartilage shear stress was determined for the different meniscectomies. Graphs were plotted of the cumulative tibial cartilage volume subjected to stress values above specific thresholds. Results and analysis. Maximum shear stress values for the intact knee during walking were 2.00 MPa medially and 1.71 MPa laterally. During running these magnitudes rose to 3.48 MPa medially and 4.70 MPa laterally. For a 30% anterior, central and posterior meniscectomy during walking shear stress increased by 25.9%, 44.9% and 32.5% medially, and 12.4%, 25.7% and 17.8% laterally. During running shear stress increased by 9.6%, 8.3% and 7.1%, medially and 31.6%, 37.5% and 43.6% laterally. For a 60% meniscectomy, during walking shear stress increased by 47.2% medially and 31.8%, laterally. During running shear stress increased by 10.0%, medially and 51.8%, laterally. The percentage of cartilage volume exposed to shear stress levels above a specified threshold is illustrated in Figure 2 for different volumes and locations of partial meniscectomy. Discussion and conclusions. This is first study that has estimated the volume of cartilage exposed to specific stress thresholds in walking and running as a function of the amount and location of meniscectomy. Maximum shear stress was 100% higher at the end of weight acceptance in running compared to walking. Stress was higher in the lateral compartment during running while higher in the medial compartment during walking. This is because a valgus moment acts at the knee at the end of weight acceptance in running while a varus moment acts at the joint in walking. Clinical significance. The model developed from this research has potential for applications in planning meniscal surgeries and developing rehabilitation strategies for athletes. It could inform surgeons about the safe volume and location of partial meniscectomy that can be performed before meniscus reconstruction becomes necessary. Results of this study also highlight the importance of considering the effect of post-surgical outcomes following different common functional activities

AIM. Failure of a primary anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction is associated with poor functional outcomes even after revision surgery. The aim of this study is to identify early predictors for failure, so that it may aid in recognition of at-risk patients. METHOD. An observational study was conducted of 623 patients undergoing primary ACL reconstruction by a single surgeon over a 72 month period. Patient and procedure related parameters including age, gender, BMI, time to surgery, graft size, fixation methods, meniscal and chondral injuries, meniscal surgery, radiological parameters and post-operative IKDC scores. Logistic regression modeling was employed to identify those factors which were statistically significant for failure. RESULTS. We identified 14 patients who experienced failure of their ACL graft. The causes for failure included trauma (9), infection (2), arthrofibrosis (1), biological (1) and recurrent instability (1). Univariate analysis established a significant relationship between age at time of injury (p<0.001), BMI (p=0.001), time to index procedure (p<0.001), screw length (p=0.04) and early post-operative IKDC score (p<0.001). Multivariate analysis demonstrated all factors stated except screw length to be important for predicting failure for ACL reconstruction. CONCLUSIONS. The rate of graft failure is lower than has been those quoted in the literature. We have identified those patients who are at high risk of rupturing a reconstructed primary ACL graft. Careful monitoring and functional modification of high-risk patients may be indicated to prevent failure. This study identifies predictive factors of failed ACL reconstruction. Age at time of injury, BMI, time to surgery, post-operative IKDC scores were found to be associated with failure

Aim: The purpose of this study was to evaluate the results of transphyseal ACL reconstruction technique in skeletally immature patients. Material & Methods: Between 2002 and 2008, twenty knees in twenty skeletally immature patients with a mean chronological age of 13.2 years (range, 7 to 16.2 years) underwent transphyseal reconstruction of the anterior cruciate ligament with use of an autogenous quadrupled hamstrings-tendon graft with metaphyseal fixation. Ten knees had additional meniscal surgery. The functional outcome, graft survival, radiographic outcome, and any growth disturbance were evaluated at a mean of 2.2 years (range, 1.0 to 5.9 years) after the surgery. Results: No patient underwent revision anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. The mean International Knee Documentation Committee subjective knee score (SD) was 90.5 (10.0) points and the mean Lysholm knee score was 92.2 (10.0) points. The result of the Lachman examination was normal in 18 knees and nearly normal in two; it was not abnormal or severely abnormal in any knee. The mean increase in total height was 7.2 cm (range, 1.2 to 20.4 cm) from the time of surgery to the time of final follow-up. No angular deformities of the lower extremity were measured radiographically, and no lower-extremity length discrepancies were measured clinically. Complications included one case of knee stiffness requiring physiotherapy, one case of persistent pain leading to medial menisectomy for tear and one case of re-injury five months post ACL reconstruction requiring medial meniscus repair. Conclusion: Excellent functional outcome was noted in skeletally immature patients after transphyseal reconstruction of the anterior cruciate ligament with use of an autogenous quadrupled hamstrings-tendon graft with metaphyseal fixation. There were very few complications and no growth disturbance

Background: Unfortunately ACL injuries are not uncommon in the young: the majority however occurring after skeletal maturity. Aim: To perform an internal audit of the demand, methods and results of ACL reconstruction in young patients at a tertiary referral centre. Methods: Patients were identified through electronic patient records, and all operation notes and follow up records were scrutinised. Results: 84 cases under 20 years of age (range 14–19) were reviewed from 2000–2004 with a minimum follow-up of 6 months. Over 10% had undergone previous surgery or had documented articular injury. 42 cases required further meniscal surgery at the time of reconstruction: 12% repairs (20/168 menisci), 18% partial menisectomy (30/168). The median time to reconstruction from injury was 9 months (range 1–72). No case was delayed for growth plate maturation. Reconstruction methods were partly surgeon dependent, following adult themes. Occasionally tibial fixation was away from the growth plate with low profile screws and washers. We are only aware of 1 failure during this short follow-up. Conclusion: We believe that the use of techniques similar to those used on adults is appropriate for adolescents. However the high comorbidity is of some concern, demonstrating that this age range is as challenging as their older counterparts

Purpose: To report the 2–5 year results of ACL reconstruction with doubled Tibialis anterior allograft. Method: Seventy-three patients who underwent primary ACL reconstruction with doubled tibialis anterior allografts with minimum 2 year follow-up were included in the study. Patients were assessed via telephone interview using the Lysholm knee score, Tegner activity score, and the subjective International Knee Documentation Committee rating. In addition, they were asked if they had failure of the ACL requiring revision or any other procedures such as repeat arthroscopy for meniscal surgery/articular cartilage. Statistical analysis using levene’s test and the T-test was used to assess outcomes of patients according to age and sex. Results: Sixty-four (88%) patients were available for follow-up. The mean age was 28.94 years (16–55). There were 33 males (51.6%) and 31 females (48.4%). The mean follow-up was 41.6 months (range 24–55 months). There were 2 (3%) complications, 1 patient suffered a DVT with subsequent PE, and 1 patient suffered a hardware problem. Four patients (6.3%) had failure of their graft and 6 patients (9%) required repeat arthroscopy. The mean Lysholm score was 91.75 (SD+/− 8.2), and the mean Tegner activity score was 5.4 (range 1–10). The mean IDKC was 88.94 (SD+/− 8.33). According to the IDKC score 58% of patients were rated as excellent, 27% as good, and 13% as fair and 2% as poor. There was no difference in outcome in patients under 30 compared to over 30 years. Males performed statistically better on the Lysholm and the IKDC scores (p 0.005 and 0.038 respectively) when compared to women. Conclusion: ACL reconstruction with Allograft Tibialis anterior tendon provided good functional results with a low failure rate at 2–5 years. There was no statistical difference in outcome between Patients under 30 years and those above 30 years. Males performed better on the Lysholm and the IDKC questionnaires

Aim: To determine the influence of concomitant partial meniscal resection on the medium-term clinical results after anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction. Method: Four hundred and sixty patients fulfilled the criteria for inclusion in this multi-center study. Four hundred and twelve of the 460 (90%) patients were re-examined by independent observers after a median 41 months (range: 24 months to 60 months). At the initial operation resection of a minimum of one third of the medial or lateral menisci was performed in 137 patients. The remaining 275 patients had stable, intact menisci. Patients who had undergone previous or subsequent meniscal surgery, a re-rupture of the ACL graft, or had an abnormal contralateral limb were excluded from the study. Results: The patients who underwent concomitant meniscal resection at the ACL reconstruction had significantly more pain (p=0.012), a greater incidence of loss of motion (p=0.0006), increased laxity (p=0.001) and lower IKDC (p< 0.0001) and Lysholm (p< 0.0001) evaluation scores than patients who had intact menisci. Conclusion: At the medium-term clinical follow-up the patients who underwent partial meniscal resection in conjunction with the ACL reconstruction revealed significantly worse subjective and objective measurements than the patients who had intact menisci. These findings demonstrated the effect of meniscectomy on the surgical outcome of ACL reconstruction and emphasised the importance of intact menisci for the function of the knee joint

Purpose of the study: For symptomatic discoid meniscus, the treatment of choice in children is arthroscopic meniscoplasty. The treatment of associated meniscal lesions remains a subject of debate. The purpose of our work was to evaluate our results with arthroscopic meniscoplasty associated with meniscal repair as needed and the findings of the systematic postoperative MRI. Material and methods: This was a retrospective series of patients treated by one operator. There were 23 discoid menisci (21 patients) treated from 2004 to 2007 with arthroscopic meniscoplasty followed by a complementary procedure depending on the residual meniscus: abstention if there was no associated lesion, suture or reinsertion for reparable lesions, partial meniscectomy for non-reparable lesions. The Lysholm and Tegner scores, plain x-rays, and MRI were obtained systematically. Results: Mean age at surgery was 9.8 years. The Watanabe classification was I:9, II:9, III:5. Arthroscopy revealed 15 lesions, including 11 longitudinal tears. Meniscoplasty was performed in 9 cases alone, associated with partial meniscectomy in 6 and with repair in 8 (5 cases of disinsertion and 3 tears). Mean follow-up was 37.1 months. The mean postoperative Lysholm was 87.9, the Tegner 5.9. Outcome was considered satisfactory or very satisfactory by 90% of patients. MRI failed to reveal any signs of chondral degeneration or meniscal tear. There were however four cases of high intensity intra-meniscal signals and one meniscal cyst. Mean measurements of the residual meniscus were: anterior segment 8.6 mm thickness and 2.6 mm height; middle segment 5.5 and 2.3 mm; posterior segment 5.8 and 3.0 mm. One case of osteochondritis of the lateral condyle was noted postoperatively. Discussion: To our knowledge, there is no other study evaluating the outcome of discoid meniscus surgery with postoperative MRI. There have been few reports concerning meniscoplasty then repair. This approach spares meniscal tissue, essential for children. We obtained good clinical results and patient satisfaction. At the MRI, the residual meniscus had a morphology close to normal. There were no signs of tears. The high intensity signals occurred in patients with good outcome. Conclusion: Arthroscopic meniscoplasty associated with repair or partial meniscectomy as needed appears to be a good therapeutic solution for discoid meniscus in children

Introduction: Meniscus repairs with sutures have become more common as the importance of preserving the meniscus has been established. Studies have shown a high rate of repeat surgery, but it is unclear what factors contribute to failure. The purpose of this study was to determine what factors lead to failure of suture meniscus repair. Failure was operationally defined as repeat surgery on the meniscus within 2 years of the repair. Methods: Two hundred eighty-three (283) meniscus suture repairs were performed by a single surgeon. The average patient age was 31 years (range, 18 to 71). There were 177 males and 106 females. All repairs were completed with an inside-out suture technique. One hundred thirty-seven (137) had an ACL reconstruction and meniscus repair (93 concurrent reconstructions and 44 two-staged ACL reconstructions). One hundred eighty-one (181) medial menisci and 102 lateral menisci were repaired. Of the medial repairs, 80% were in the posterior third of the meniscus, 11% in the middle third, 1% in the anterior third, and 8% extended to all areas of the meniscus. Of the lateral meniscus repairs, 49% were in the posterior third, 26% in the middle third, 22% in the anterior third, and 3% extended to all areas. Results: Twenty-eight (28) patients (10%) had required repeat surgery on the repaired meniscus within the first 2 years and were considered failures. The average time to repeat meniscus surgery was 12 months (range, 2.5 to 24 months). There were no differences based on age, gender or location. Thirteen percent (13%) of medial repairs and 4% of lateral repairs failed (p=0.012). Medial meniscus repairs failed significantly earlier (5.6 months) than lateral meniscus repairs (12.9 months) (p=0.001). For patients who had ACL reconstruction and meniscus repair, factors associated with failure included age (failed age=22; non-failure age=29; p=0.013), and concurrent ACL reconstruction (two-staged repair failures=2%; concurrent repair failures=11%; p=0.04). Conclusion: Failure of suture repair of the meniscus within the first two years following index repair is more likely to occur in medial meniscus repairs and in young patients who had a repair and concurrent ACL reconstruction

Purpose of study: The diagnosis of meniscal tears is usually based on the patient’s history and on specific physical tests. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and arthroscopy is often necessary for diagnosis. Theofilos Karachalios et al. described the new ‘Thessaly test’ and concluded that it could be safely used as a first line screening test for the selection of patients who need arthroscopic meniscal surgery (Ref: J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2005 May; 87(5):955–62). Our objective was to study the role of physical diagnostic tests in screening for meniscal tears and to validate the diagnostic accuracy of the Thessaly test. Methods & Results: We examined 109 patients [(80 male, 29 female), average age 39.11 years, range (16–66)] who presented with a history suggestive of a meniscal tear. Joint line tenderness,. McMurray’s test and the Thessaly test were assessed by an independent investigator blinded to any imaging data in all patients. MRI and subsequent arthroscopy results were then collated. Our study showed a much lower diagnostic accuracy for the Thessaly test (61.25 % for medial meniscus and 80 % for lateral meniscus) It is comparable to McMurray’s test (57.14 % for medial meniscus and 77.38 % for lateral meniscus). The Joint line tenderness test has a far superior diagnostic accuracy (80.95 %for medial meniscus and 90.48 % for lateral meniscus). Combining the joint line tenderness test with McMurrays test or the Thessaly test further increased the diagnostic accuracy. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) detected 96% of meniscal tears. Arthroscopy was diagnostic and therapeutic in all cases. Conclusion: Physical tests may not always be diagnostic of meniscal tears. MRI and arthroscopy may be essential in dubious clinical presentations. In our study the Thessaly test in isolation did not have the highest diagnostic accuracy for the detection of meniscal tears but helps increase diagnostic certainty when combined with standard tests

Objective: Lysholm and Tegner scores have been validated to assess outcomes of meniscus surgery. We prospectively determined Lysholm scores for function and calculated Tegner index to determine percentage of pre-injury activity level regained by patients six years after partial meniscectomy alone versus placement of collagen meniscus implants (CMI, MenaflexTM). We hypothesized that in this prospective randomized multicenter clinical trial, patients who received collagen meniscus implant would have better function and would have regained more of their lost activity than patients with meniscectomy alone. Methods: Patients 18 to 60 years old who had undergone 1 to 3 prior partial medial meniscectomies (thus deemed “chronic”) and remained symptomatic randomly received either a CMI (n=76) or another partial medial meniscectomy (control) (n=69). Lysholm and Tegner data were collected prospectively. Tegner index was calculated by subtracting preoperative Tegner scores from the longest follow-up scores and then dividing that difference by the difference of pre-injury less preoperative scores. The quotient multiplied by 100 yields a percentage that represents amount of lost activity regained as a result of therapeutic intervention. The findings were then compared to earlier analyses of the same patients. Results: Average follow-up for both groups was 72 months (range for CMI, 24 to 88; for controls, 24 to 92). For both groups, Lysholm scores improved significantly (p=0.0001) from preoperative to 6 years postoperative, but there was no difference between treatments. Average Tegner index for CMI patients was 0.47; thus, 6 years after receiving CMI they had regained 47% of activity lost due to the inciting injury. Average Tegner index for controls was 0.22; thus, they regained 22% of lost activity. This difference was clinically and statistically significant (p=0.028). The Lysholm scores for both groups were unchanged from 2-year findings; however, Tegner index for CMI patients improved from 0.42 to 0.47, but Tegner index decreased for controls from 0.29 earlier to 0.22 at 6 years. Conclusion: CMI (Menaflex) and partial meniscectomy both allowed chronic patients to regain function equally 6 years after index surgery. However, patients treated with CMI had significantly higher Tegner index at 6 years compared to controls, thus chronic CMI patients regained more of the activity they had lost as a result of their inciting injury. Noteworthy, CMI patients continued to gain activity from 2 to 6 years while meniscectomy only controls lost activity. These findings suggest that control patients reduced their activity levels in an attempt to maintain their function