This prospective randomised controlled trial aims to compare the clinical and radiological outcomes of ceramic on ceramic, cobalt chrome on ultra-high molecular weight polyethylene, and cobalt chrome on highly cross-linked polyethylene bearing surfaces at a minimum of five years. One hundred and two primary total hip replacements were performed in ninety one patients between February 2003 and March 2005. All patients were younger than 65 (mean 52.7, 19–64). They were randomised to receive one of the three bearing surfaces. All patients had 28mm articulations with a Reflection uncemented acetabular component and a Synergy stem (Smith & Nephew, Memphis, Tennessee). Patients were followed up periodically up to at least sixty months following surgery. Outcome measures included WOMAC and SF12 scores. Radiological assessment included implant position, evidence of osteolysis and measurement of linear wear.Purpose
Method
This prospective randomised controlled trial aims to compare the clinical and radiological outcomes of ceramic on ceramic, cobalt chrome on ultra-high molecular weight polyethylene, and cobalt chrome on highly cross-linked polyethylene bearing surfaces at a minimum of five years. One hundred and two primary total hip replacements were performed in ninety one patients between February 2003 and March 2005. All patients were younger than 65 (mean 52.7, 19–64). They were randomised to receive one of the three bearing surfaces. All patients had 28mm articulations with a Reflection uncemented acetabular component and a Synergy stem (Smith & Nephew, Memphis, Tennessee). Patients were followed up periodically up to at least sixty months following surgery. Outcome measures included WOMAC and SF12 scores. Radiological assessment included implant position, evidence of osteolysis and measurement of linear wear. Ninety seven hip replacements in eighty seven patients were available for review at a minimum of five years. Two hips were revised (one for infection and one for periprosthetic fracture), leaving a total of ninety four hips available for final review. There were no differences in age, gender, body mass index, diagnosis, level of activity, and co-morbidities between the three groups. At a minimum of five years there were no statistical differences in the clinical outcomes using the WOMAC or SF12 scores. Three patients in the ceramic group reported squeaking. Radiological evaluation revealed mean annual wear rates in the ceramic group of 0.006mm/yr, standard polyethylene of 0.151mm/yr and highly cross linked polyethylene of 0.059mm/yr. ANOVA analysis revealed these differences in wear rates to be significant (p<0.0001). In the mid term there are no differences in clinical outcome between ceramic on ceramic, cobalt chrome on ultra-high molecular weight polyethylene, and cobalt chrome on highly cross-linked polyethylene bearing surfaces in total hip arthroplasty. Ultra high molecular weight polyethylene has a significantly greater annual linear wear rate than highly cross-linked polyethylene.
To review prospectively collected data on patients undergoing primary total hip arthroplasty utilizing two different cementless acetabular components. All patients undergoing primary total hip replacement surgery at our institution are entered prospectively into a database which includes history and physical examination, radiology, WOMAC and SF-36 scores. The patients are re-examined, re-x-rayed and re-scored at 3 months, 6 months and 1 year after surgery and yearly thereafter. Using this database we are able to identify patients who have undergone total hip replacement using one of two geometric variants of the acetabular component. The first design is hemispherical and the second design has a peripheral rim expansion designed to increase initial press-fit stability.Purpose
Materials & Methods
To review prospectively collected data on patients undergoing femoral revision arthroplasty for failed cemented or cementless primary stems. All patients undergoing primary and revision joint replacement surgery at our institution are prospectively entered into a database which includes history and physical examination, radiology, WOMAC and SF-36 scores. These investigations are repeated 3 months, 6 months, 1 year and yearly thereafter at each patient visit. This database identified all patients undergoing femoral revision arthroplasty over the last 10 years. There were a total of 231 patients with 248 revision procedures performed. There were 127 female and 104 male patients and the mean age at the time of revision surgery was 69.4 years. Twenty-two of these patients had had at least one prior revision operation on the index hip. Thirty hips were treated with a cemented Echelon stem and 218 treated with a cementless Echelon stem. Of the 248 hips 14 patients were lost to follow-up (14 hips) and 9 patients (9 hips) are deceased. The average follow-up was 5.9 years. Of the 225 hips remaining in the follow-up series there was a single case of aseptic loosening confirmed radiologically. Twenty-one hips were diagnosed with infection (9.3%); 6 of those patients had had at least one prior revision procedure and 4 additional patients had a prior diagnosis of infection. Therefore, 10 of the 21 hips were either definitely or probably infected at the time of their revision operation on which we are reporting. Nine patients (4%) had multiple dislocations post-operatively. These were patients who had undergone multiple revisions or whose primary revision operation was for instability. An additional 18 patients (8%) had a single dislocation treated by closed reduction requiring no further treatment. There were 6 hips with intra-operative fracture requiring immediate re-revision plus fracture fixation and a further 12 hips (5.3%) who sustained a peri-prosthetic fracture some time after their revision procedure. Despite the number of complications the majority of patients required no further surgical treatment. Eleven hips (4.8%) required re-revision of the femoral component. Therefore the overall survival rate at 5.9 years of the Echelon revision stem was 95.2%.Materials & Methods
Results
This prospective randomised controlled trial aims to compare the clinical and radiological outcomes of ceramic on ceramic, cobalt chrome on ultra-high molecular weight polyethylene, and cobalt chrome on highly cross-linked polyethylene bearing surfaces at a minimum of five years. One hundred and two primary total hip replacements were performed in ninety one patients between February 2003 and March 2005. All patients were younger than 65 (mean 52.7, 19-64). They were randomised to receive one of the three bearing surfaces. All patients had 28mm articulations with a Reflection uncemented acetabular component and a Synergy stem (Smith & Nephew, Memphis, Tennessee). Patients were followed up periodically up to at least sixty months following surgery. Outcome measures included WOMAC and SF12 scores. Radiological assessment included implant position, evidence of osteolysis and measurement of linear wear.Aim
Methods
