If run-in wear is the only source of sustained metal release, then replacing the bearing with a non-MM bearing should not make a difference to metal release in patients and elevated levels should continue to persist even after such a revision. In order to verify this we studied metal release in patients who underwent revision of a MM bearing to a non-MM bearing after revision.
An earlier study (Clarke et al JBJS(Br) 2003) suggests that smaller bearings generate less wear. In that study bearings with different metallurgy and wear properties were grouped together, a potential confounding factor. The present study does not suffer from that error and our findings do not support the view that a larger bearing diameter leads to either an increase or decrease in metal ion generation.
Dislocation rates in large headed metal-on-metal resurfacings are extremely low. However, many patients are unsuitable for resurfacing and need a replacement. In such cases, it is attractive to transfer the large-headed metal-metal bearing advantage to replacement arthroplasty in order to reduce wear and dislocation rates. Does large diameter metal-metal total hip replacement really reduce the early dislocation rate?
Age at operation ranged from 37 to 83 years. Thirty patients were 55 years or under, eighty one were 56 – 65 years and ninety five were over 65 years. There were 122 females and 67 males. Posterior approach was used in all.
Old age, osteopaenia, alcohol abuse, and large cysts are risk factors for fractures. It has been suggested that performing a bilateral resurfacing puts the first side at risk of fracture from the force used in implanting the second resurfacing. Is this a true risk or a sampling error?
The low incidence of fractures (2/382, 0.5%) in this bilateral resurfacing series does not support the view that there is an increased risk of fracture from a bilateral procedure.
The extremely low failure rate in the medium term proves the suitability of resurfacing in young active patients. However, caution needs to be exercised until long term results are available.
There is sufficient evidence in this study to prove that metal ions do cross the placenta. There is therefore a continuing need for vigilance on the possible effects on the offspring born to patients with metal-metal devices.
Most friction studies are conducted in a bovine serum- carboxymethylcellulose (bs-cmc) medium. Following implantation however, the joint is bathed in blood which contains macromolecules and cells. The effect of these on friction is not fully understood. A progressive radiolucent line (fig 1) observed in some low clearance resurfacings raises the concern that increased friction may be affecting component fixation. The purpose of this investigation was to study the effect of clearance on friction for a given bearing diameter in the presence of blood as lubricant.
The results of this study suggest that reduced clearance bearings have the potential to generate higher friction when blood is the lubricant. this higher friction in the low clearance bearings may produce micromotion in the early postoperative period and hamper bony ingrowth resulting in impaired fixation with long-term implications for survival.
Bland-Altman analysis (Figure 1A) shows the limits of agreement between serum and WB are unacceptably wide (1.7 to -5.1 for chromium) suggesting poor agreement.
Hip Resurfacing has always been an attractive concept for the treatment of hip arthritis in younger patients. Introduction of modern metal-on-metal hip resurfacing in 1991 in Birmingham, UK made this concept a reality. In the early years, resurfacings were used only by a few experienced surgeons. From 1997, Birmingham Hip Resurfacings (BHRs) are being widely used in younger and more active patients. A breakdown of the ages at operation in the regional NHS hospital in Birmingham during the period April 1999 to March 2004 show that the mean age of metal-metal resurfacings is 51 years and the mean age of total hip replacements is 70 years. At a 3.7 to 10.8 year follow-up (mean follow-up 5.8 years), the cumulative survival rate of metal-metal resurfacing in young active patients with osteoarthritis is 99.8%. In the long term, none of these patients were constrained to change their occupational or leisure activities as a result of the procedure. The overall revision rate of BHRs in all ages and all diagnoses is also very low (19 out of 2167 [0.88%] with a maximum follow-up of 7.5 years). Improvements in instrumentation and a minimally invasive approach developed by the senior author have made this successful device even more attractive. Although objective evidence does not support the fact that the longer approach was any more invasive than the minimal route, patient feedback shows that it is very popular with them. While minimal approach is indeed appealing, it has a steep learning curve. In the early phase of this curve, care should be taken to avoid the potential risk of suboptimal component placement which can adversely affect long-term outcome. It is true that metal-metal bearings are associated with elevated metal ion levels. In vitro studies of BHRs show that they have a period of early run-in wear. This is not sustained in the longer term. These findings are found to hold true in vivo as well, in our studies of 24- hour cobalt output and whole blood metal ion levels. Epidemiological studies show that historic metal-metal bearings are not associated with carcinogenic effects in the long-term. Metal ion levels in patients with BHRs are in the same range as the levels found in those with historic metal-metal total hip replacements.