Introduction Correct component positioning is critical for the stability of the prosthesis in total hip arthroplasty (THA). Malpositioning of either the femoral or acetabular component may lead to impingement or dislocation. This study aims to assess the accuracy of placement of the acetabular component in THA.

Methods Forty-six total hip arthroplasties were studied. The surgeon’s estimates of intra-operative inclination and anteversion of the acetabular component were recorded. Post-operative inclination of the acetabular component was measured from routine plain antero-posterior (AP) radiographs of the pelvis. Planar anteversion of the acetabular component was determined from AP radiographs with the beam centred over the hip using the method described by Pradhan. Planar anteversion was then corrected to ‘true’ anteversion correcting for inclination. The surgeons estimate of intra-operative cup inclination and anteversion and the radiographic position were compared.

Results The mean difference between the estimated and true cup inclination was 1.5° more than planned (range of −13° to 16°, SD 6.75). The mean difference between estimated and true values of anteversion was 1.8° less than planned (range of −32° to 25°, SD 11.07). Allowing plus or minus five degrees of error, 37% of the cups were outside the estimated inclination and 35% outside the estimated anteversion. There was a poor correlation for both inclination (Spearman’s correlation coefficient equals 0.20) and anteversion (Spearman’s correlation coefficient equals 0.25) between perceived and true cup positioning. Using the ‘safe zones’ for inclination and anteversion described by Lewinnek et al for minimising dislocation, 48% of the cups were unsafely positioned in either inclination, anteversion or both.

Conclusions Our study showed that positioning of the ace-tabular component cannot be reliably performed even by experienced surgeons. Acetabular component placement is of high importance for preventing dislocation or impingement. A tool, such as a navigation device, may be beneficial in improving acetabular component placement.

In relation to the conduct of this study, one or more of the authors is in receipt of a research grant from a non-commercial source.

Introduction Component malalignment may result in failure in total knee arthroplasty (TKA). Knee navigation systems assist surgeons with intra-operative component positioning in TKA. We report on the effect of one system on the post-operative mechanical axis of the limb and coronal alignment of femoral and tibial components in TKA.

Methods In a prospective study of 47 total knee replacements we compared 24 cases using conventional techniques to 23 cases using the Stryker Knee Navigation System. Patient groups were matched for sex, weight and age. Postoperative antero-posterior radiographs of the whole leg were used to determine the mechanical axis of the limb and coronal position of the femoral and tibial components.

Results The mean post-operative mechanical axis of the limb in the navigated group was 1.3° varus (range 7° varus to 3.5° valgus, SD=2.6). In the control group the mean mechanical axis was 0.8° varus (range 9.5° varus to 10° valgus, SD=4.4). There was no significant difference in the mean mechanical axis between the groups (p=0.6). There was no significant difference in mean coronal alignment of the femoral (p=0.99) or tibial components, (p=0.98). The 95% confidence interval for the mechanical axis was narrower for the navigated group (2.4° varus to 0.2° varus) than for the control group (2.6° varus to 1.1° valgus). Using Levene’s test (not dependant on normal distribution) the variances for the mechanical axis of the limb, and the coronal alignment of the femoral and tibial components are all significantly less in the navigated than non-navigated groups (p=0.05, 0.001 and 0.004 respectively).

Conclusions This study showed no difference in the overall mean alignment of navigated versus non-navigated knees. However, a significant decrease in the variance of alignment seen with navigation means we are seeing fewer outlying results that may lead to a decrease in mechanical failure in TKA.

In relation to the conduct of this study, one or more of the authors is in receipt of a research grant from a non-commercial source.

Introduction Malposition of the acetabular component in total hip arthroplasty is associated with a number of significant complications. In this study we acertain the accuracy of an imageless computer based surgical navigation system for positioning the acetabular component, using a mechanical hip device.

Methods A mechanical hip device was constructed that allowed accurate measurement of inclination and version, leg length and lateral offset of the acetabular and femoral components. In 31 cases these parameters were varied while a blinded operator would place the cup in the predetermined position in the mechanical hip jig. The values given by the navigation system on the screen were recorded and compared to the measurements obtained directly from the mechanical hip device.

Results The mean difference between value set by an independent person and value read by the navigation system was; inclination of the cup 0.97 ± 0 and the ante-version of the cup 1.58 ± 0.83. The leg length change contributed by the cup showed a mean difference between beforehand set value and read value on the screen of 1.48 ± 1.36 mm and for lateral offset change by the cup of 1.58 ± 0 mm.

Conclusions The accuracy of the hip navigation unit demonstrated in this study is well within the limits that would be required for clinical usage as a surgical aid in total hip arthroplasty and could provide the surgeon with a tool that enables significant improvement in accuracy for acetabular positioning.

Introduction Using a new surgical technique for the first time involves a ‘learning curve’. The aim of this study is to assess the technical errors encountered in the early utilisation of a computer assistance system during total knee arthroplasty and to see if this error rate decreases with experience.

Methods Thirty-two total knee replacement procedures performed by a single surgeon using the Stryker Knee Navigation system for the first time, were monitored. All technical difficulties were documented. We compared the complications encountered in the first five cases against the following 27 cases.

Results Technical difficulties related to the navigation equipment were noted in four of the 32 cases (12.5%). These included (one case each); errors in tibial pin placement, concern over initial navigation readings, pin loosening, and dropping the navigation shim plate. There was a significant decrease in technical difficulties encountered in the later cases (7%) compared to the first five cases (40 percent, p= 0.041). Additionally, in three of the 32 cases (9%) the surgeon used their clinical judgement to override the navigation readings and recut the bone, to take ligament balancing into account.

Conclusions A steep learning curve is involved when first utilising the Stryker Knee Navigation system. It is recommended that adequate training is undertaken prior to utilising knee navigation. The computer readings should be considered carefully and clinical judgement should not be overridden.

In relation to the conduct of this study, one or more of the authors is in receipt of a research grant from a non-commercial source.

Introduction Concentric interference screw placement has been proposed as having potentially better biological graft integration than eccentric interference screw placement during soft tissue ACL reconstruction. The purpose of this study was to determine whether a wedge shaped concentric screw was at least equivalent to an eccentric screw in stiffness, yield load, ultimate load and mode of failure.

Methods Seven matched pairs of human cadaveric tendon in porcine tibia with titanium wedge shaped screws were randomly allocated to either the eccentric or concentric groups. Bone tunnels were drilled 45° to the long axis of the tibia, akin to standard ACL reconstruction. Tendon diameter was matched to tunnel diameter and a screw one millimetre larger than tunnel diameter was inserted. An Instrom machine was used to pull in the line of the tendon. Tendons were inspected after construct disassembly.

Results The concentric screw configuration showed significantly higher stiffness (p< 0.0085), yield load (p< 0.0135) and ultimate load (p< 0.0075). The mode of failure in the eccentric screw position was slippage at the screw tendon interface in all cases. In the concentric group 88% of cases had a breakage in the tendon and 13% of cases had slippage at the tendon bone interface. However, it was observed during construct disassembly that there was more macroscopic damage to the tendon substance in the concentric group. Failure was mostly by tendon breakage, which reflects the strongest fixation possible with the tendon being the weakest link in the system.

Conclusions Concentric interference screw fixation of soft tissue graft offers superior fixation in single pullout mode when compared to eccentric interference screw fixation.

Introduction The reduced WOMAC function scale has been developed and initial validity performed. However, further validation and recommendations for the treatment of missing values is required. The aim of this study is to further assess the validity of the reduced function scale of the WOMAC and recommend a protocol for the treatment of missing values.

Method Further validation of the reduced scale was performed via a cross-over study of 100 pre-operative total joint replacement patients, each being randomised to receive either the full or reduced scale along with the pain scale, and then the alternate version upon admission. Data utilised in the development of the reduced scale was used to develop a missing value protocol, where the number of valid responses for several protocols was examined, as well as comparison of the means and standard deviations. Of the consenting 100 patients, 66 continued onto admission. The median time between administrations of the questionnaires was 14 days (range zero to 72 days).

Results There was no significant difference between pain scores for each questionnaire using the paired t-test (p=0.56). Similarly, there was no significant difference between the full and reduced function scales (p=0.65). The standard protocol for the full scale is that if there are four or more missing items, the patient’s response is invalid. But when there are one to three items missing, the average value for the sub-scale is substituted in lieu of these missing values. Examining the frequencies of valid responses, means and standard deviations when using different missing value protocols (none missing, zero or one, up to two and up to three missing), indicated that there was no substantial benefit between the ‘up to two’ missing and ‘up to three’ missing response protocols. However, for this small gain, the supposition that the completed items are representative of the missing ones rises from 29% (two of seven items) to 43% (three of seven items) should be considered unacceptable.

Conclusions The reduced WOMAC function scale has been further validated. It is proposed that where three or more responses are missing, the patients response is regarded as invalid. Where there are one or two items missing, the average value for the sub-scale is substituted in lieu of these missing values.

Introduction: The aim of this study was to compare the serum cobalt and chromium levels in patients with Oxford Universal hips and Cenator hips. Both systems are composed of cobalt chromium alloy and have modular cobalt chromium heads, however only the Oxford hip has a sliding mechanism.

Material: The serum levels of chromium and cobalt were measured in 20 patients with Oxford Universal Hip replacement (Group 1). This was compared to the serum levels of chromium and cobalt in 17 patients with Cenator Hip replacement (Group 2) and 20 patients with no implants (Group 3). Patients in Group 1 and 2 were assessed clinically and with plain radiographs. Patients were excluded if there was evidence of loosening, if they had other joint implants or any other known cobalt or chromium implant and if they had impaired renal function. All hip replacements were performed as primary procedures. Specimens were analysed by electrothermal atomization atomic absorption spectrometry.

Results: There was no statistically significant difference in serum cobalt and chromium levels between groups 1 and 2. Patients in groups 1 and 2 had statistically significant higher serum levels of chromium and cobalt than group 3 patients.

Discussion: This study demonstrates that serum levels of chromium and cobalt are elevated in patients with stable hip implants composed of this alloy but not in a normal population. Although it is not known what the long-term effects of chronic low-grade exposure to these ions are, these levels are many order of magnitude below the toxic range. Furthermore, our results show that the Oxford Universal Hip releases no more metal ions into the circulation than an implant without a sliding mechanism.

Purpose: The purpose of the study is to compare the disease severity at the time of surgical intervention between patients undergoing primary joint replacement under the National Health Service and Private Health-care Systems.

Materials: 166 patients were included in the study – 101 NHS and 65 Private. Inclusion criteria were: 1) hip or knee osteoarthritis, 2) primary joint replacement, and 3) informed consent of the patient. Patients with arthropathy of inflammatory, infectious or neoplastic aetiology were excluded. Physician evaluation included medical history, calculation of Charleson Comorbidity Scores, and Knee Society rating. Patients were given self-assessment health questionnaires including WOMAC, SF-36, and Nottingham Health Profile.

Results: Mean age was 69.4 years and did not vary significantly between NHS and Private groups. Charleson Comorbidity Scores were significantly worse in the NHS group than in the private. Health assessment questionnaire scores were all adjusted for age, sex, and comorbidity. In NHS patients undergoing TKR, we demonstrate significantly worse pre-operative comorbidity than in private group for indices of function and pain. Patients undergoing THR showed little difference in pre-operative comorbidity.

Conclusion: NHS patients undergoing primary TKR have significantly more advanced disease than their counterparts who are privately insured. Access to TKR surgery is determined by the healthcare delivery system rather then a threshold level of disease severity. Further follow-up of the outcomes of TKR in these two groups needs to be carried out to determine the long-term effects of accessing surgical care at a more advanced stage of disease.

Temporary immobilisation of joints can lead to permanent ankylosis or fusion. The aim of this study is to demonstrate that treatment of vertebral fractures by single level fusion and 2 level fixation preserves movement in the unfused lower motion segment after removal of metalwork.

12 consecutive thoracolumbar fractures were treated by posterior fixation over two motion segments with fusion of the upper injured segment. Average age 39 years (27–50yrs.) and 6 were male. L2 was most frequently affected (6) then T12 (3), L1(2) and L3(1). Using the Denis classification 9 were Burst type B, 1 was Burst type A and 2 were Compression type B. No patients had abnormal neurology or any other vertebral injury. All operations were performed by one surgeon (RC) within 7 days of injury. Metalwork bridging the injured vertebra was removed at mean 11 months (8–13 * one patient 27 months) and average follow up in this study was 12 months (2–40) after removal of metalwork. A simple pain questionnaire and flexion-extension radiographs were obtained. The average movement in the motion segment previously bridged by metalwork was 5 degrees (0–12). For comparison, the level below moved an average of 7 degrees (2–17). Kyphus angle was 11 degrees (1–18) on presentation corrected to 0 degrees at operation (−6 - +12) returning 1 year after removal of metalwork to 5 degrees (1–16). Pain scores (0–10) were measured retrospectively, prior to the accident mean 0(0–1) and at review 2.6 (0–6).

Only one patient failed to return to previous employment. She had the highest pain score at 6, showed no movement at the bridged motion segment where removal of metalwork was delayed to 27 months.

Introduction: Octacol F15 is a fibrin sealant, derived from human cryoprecipitate, which can be delivered as a spray that seals on contact. Pre-clinical studies have established its safety. The aim of this study was to determine the impact of Octacol F15 on blood loss in patients undergoing THR

Materials and Methods: The effect of Octacol F15 on 81 patients undergoing THR was studied in a randomised, prospective, multi-centres study. 38 patients received Octacol F15 delivered to the soft tissues around the hip at 3 predetermined times throughout the operation. 43 patients received a routine THR. Surgeons were constrained to use their predetermined approach, fixation method, and DVT prophylaxis. Blood loss was measured and transfusion needs recorded along with all adverse events.

Results: Mean blood loss in treatment patients was 699ml v 837ml in controls. Log transformed means adjusted for weight, surgeon and pre-operative haemoglobin showed a significant reduction in blood loss of 197ml or 23.5% (95% CI 5.4% to 38.1%) as an effect of treatment (p=0.014). Intra-operative blood loss was not significantly less in the treatment group (p=0.13) but post-operative blood loss was significantly reduced (p=0.0005). 11 treatment patients received blood transfusions (29%) against 18 controls (42%). This difference in transfusion needs was not significant (p=0.11). There was only one minor complication ‘possibly’ related to the use of Octacol F15.

Conclusion: Octacol F15 significantly reduces blood loss in THR without any increase in the complication rate. Its use in THR, particularly in procedures in which increased bleeding may be encountered, offers important clinical benefits.